Prognostic significance of silent myocardial ischemia detected by early treadmill exercise after coronary angioplasty

Impact of routine angiographic follow-up after angioplasty

BACKGROUND

There is an ongoing controversy as to whether repeat coronary angiography should be routinely performed after successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA).

METHODS

We examined the 10-year outcome in 400 patients who had or had not undergone an angiographic control 6 months after successful PTCA and a subsequent event-free 6-month period. Our comparison was based on data gathered by questionnaire and telephone interview in 315 patients with (group A) and 85 patients without (group B) a routine 6-month angiographic control. Multivariate analysis (Cox model) was performed to identify predictors of adverse events.

RESULTS

During the 10-year follow-up period, 22 (7%) of the 315 patients in group A died, compared with 16 (19%) patients in group B (P= .003). In groups A and B, respectively, acute myocardial infarction occurred in 28 (9%) and 10 (12%) patients (not significant [NS]); coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) was performed in 42 (13%) and 14 (16%) patients (NS); repeat PTCA was performed in 89 (28%) and 11 (13%) patients (P= .012); and serious adverse events (death, myocardial infarction, CABG) occurred in 76 (24%) and 32 (38%) patients (P= .02). Absence of a 6-month angiographic follow-up was identified as an independent predictor of death associated with a 2.7 times higher mortality rate during the 10-year follow-up period. Previous myocardial infarction increased the risk of death 2.5 times. Any increase of residual diameter stenosis by 10% was combined with a 1.4 times higher mortality rate. The chance of bypass surgery was higher in patients with multivessel disease (2.9 times), in patients with unstable angina (2.1 times), and in case of an increase of residual diameter stenosis by 10% (1.3 times). No predictor for the risk of myocardial infarction was found. Angiographic follow-up increased the likelihood of PTCA 2.5 times.

CONCLUSIONS

A routinely performed angiographic control 6 months after successful PTCA is associated with a significantly higher rate of repeat PTCA but, most important, is correlated with a significantly lower mortality rate during the 10-year follow-up period.

Asymptomatic Cardiac Ischemia Pilot (ACIP) study: impact of anti-ischemia therapy on 12-week rest electrocardiogram and exercise test outcomes. The ACIP Investigators

OBJECTIVES

This report from the Asymptomatic Cardiac Ischemia Pilot (ACIP) study examines differences in the magnitude of reduction of myocardial ischemia as determined by exercise treadmill testing in patients randomized to three different treatment strategies: angina-guided medical therapy, ischemia-guided medical therapy and coronary revascularization.

BACKGROUND

No prospective randomized clinical trials in patients with exercise electrocardiographic (ECG) abnormalities and asymptomatic cardiac ischemia on ambulatory ECG monitoring have compared the impact of different treatment strategies, including coronary revascularization, in terms of reducing myocardial ischemia.

METHODS

The ACIP exercise protocol was used. Exercise variables measured included final exercise stage; presence of exercise-induced angina or ischemia; time to angina; time to 1-mm ST segment depression; number of exercise ECG leads with abnormalities; maximal depth of ST segment depression in any lead; sum of ST segment depression; ST/HR index; and rate-pressure product at time to angina, at time to 1-mm ST segment depression and at peak exertion.

RESULTS

Peak exercise time was increased by 0.5, 0.7 and 1.6 min in patients assigned to the angina-guided, ischemia-guided and coronary revascularization strategies, respectively, from the qualifying visit to the 12-week visit (p < 0.001). At the qualifying visit, the sum of exercise-induced ST segment depression was 9.4 +/- 5.0 (mean +/- SD), 9.6 +/- 4.7 and 9.9 +/- 5.5 mm (p = NS) in the three treatment strategies, respectively. At the 12-week visit, the sum of exercise-induced ST segment depression was 7.4 +/- 5.7, 6.8 +/- 5.3 and 5.6 +/- 5.6 mm (p = 0.02) in the three treatment strategies, respectively. Each treatment strategy resulted in a significant reduction in all exercise-induced variables of myocardial ischemia measured at 12 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Coronary revascularization significantly reduced the extent and frequency of exercise-induced myocardial ischemia compared with either medical strategy. The prognostic impact of these observations should be evaluated in a large-scale multicenter clinical trial.

Daily life cardiac ischaemia. Should it be treated?

Daily life cardiac ischaemia is defined as reversible myocardial cellular hypoxia that occurs during activities of daily living, without artificial provocation. Most of these daily life ischaemic episodes are not associated with symptoms. However, it is not practical to distinguish silent versus symptomatic daily life ischaemia as both are associated with haemodynamic abnormalities and future adverse outcomes. Daily life cardiac ischaemia is best detected using ambulatory electrocardiogram (ECG) monitoring; however, there are other diagnostic tools (e.g. exercise treadmill) that can be used. Once detected, the optimal therapy for daily life myocardial ischaemia has yet to be identified. However, it does appear that usual antianginal medications including nitrates, beta-blockers, calcium antagonists and antiplatelet drugs are effective in reducing the incidence and severity of daily life myocardial ischaemia. Medical therapy and revascularisation should be utilised to obliterate all episodes of daily life cardiac ischaemia to prevent future cardiac events. Moreover, the efficacy of the chosen therapeutic regimen for each patient should be documented with follow-up objective testing. The diagnosis and management of daily life myocardial ischaemia is continually evolving. Future research as well as economic considerations will shape future management strategies.

Silent myocardial ischemia in diabetics with normal autonomic function

Twenty male diabetic patients (age range, 40-60 years) with normal autonomic function were studied to determine the prevalence of silent myocardial ischemia on exercise as well as ambulatory electrocardiography. The presence and extent of silent myocardial ischemia was also correlated with the severity of atherosclerotic coronary artery disease as determined by coronary angiography. A cohort of 20 matched non-diabetic patients were also included in the study. Silent myocardial ischemia was detected in 50% of the diabetic patients on exercise electrocardiography and in 35% on ambulatory electrocardiography compared with 10% and 5% in non-diabetics by the two methods, respectively (P < 0.01 and P < 0.05, respectively). On exercise testing in diabetic patients, silent myocardial ischemia was detected in 64% of the patients with three-vessel disease, 50% of the patients with two-vessel disease and 20% of the patients with one-vessel disease whereas in non-diabetic patients silent myocardial ischemia was detected in only 18% of the patients with three-vessel disease (P < 0.05) and in none of the patients with two- or one-vessel disease. On ambulatory electrocardiography, only patients (both diabetic and non-diabetic) with three-vessel disease manifested silent myocardial ischemia. Total ischemic burden was similar in both the diabetic and non-diabetic patients. We conclude that silent myocardial ischemia occurs in diabetic patients with coronary artery disease more frequently even in the absence of autonomic dysfunction and the prevalence of silent myocardial ischemia is higher in patients with severe degree of coronary artery disease.

Truly silent ischemia and the relationship of chest pain and ST segment changes to the amount of ischemic myocardium: evaluation by supine bicycle stress echocardiography

OBJECTIVES

The objectives of this study were 1) to determine the relationship between the amount of exercise-induced ischemic myocardium and the presence or absence of chest pain and ST segment depression, and 2) to define the incidence and characteristics of "truly silent ischemia," that is, ischemia that is not manifested by symptoms or electrocardiographic (ECG) findings.

BACKGROUND

There are no prior data relating ischemia to chest pain and ST depression. Thallium-201 imaging studies have evaluated perfusion but not ischemia. In contrast, supine bicycle stress echocardiography demonstrates exercise-induced ischemic dysfunction.

METHODS

Supine bicycle stress echocardiography and arteriography were performed in 130 patients and the severity and geographic extent of ischemic myocardium were compared in three groups. On exercise, Group I patients had both chest pain and ST segment depression (symptomatic ischemia), Group II patients ST depression without chest pain (asymptomatic ischemia) and Group III patients had neither chest pain nor ST depression (truly silent ischemia).

RESULTS

There were no differences among groups in arteriographic characteristics. The incidence of "truly silent ischemia" was 43%. The number of abnormally contracting ischemic segments, average score per segment and sum of scores were virtually identical in Groups I and II and significantly greater than in Group III for the patients (p < 0.01 to < 0.0001), for the vessels as a group (p < 0.01 to < 0.0001) and for the left anterior descending (p < 0.01 to < 0.0001) and right (p < 0.05) coronary arteries. By multivariate analysis, positive findings on the stress ECG was the single most significant variable in relation to the amount of ischemia (p < 0.001); exercise chest pain had no significant relationship.

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise-induced ST segment depression is the single most significant variable in relation to the amount of ischemic myocardium; exercise-induced chest pain is not related to the amount of ischemia. Patients with "truly silent ischemia" constitute almost 50% of patients with coronary artery disease and have less ischemia than do patients with ECG indications of ischemia, with or without chest pain.

Silent myocardial ischemia

The documentation of abnormalities related to myocardial ischemia, whether symptomatic or silent, is of central importance. Whenever this information is available, it should be used in the overall assessment of the patient at risk for adverse outcome. The level of concern for treatment of CAD should be based on the risk implications associated with the ischemia-related abnormalities detected during objective testing rather than on the presence or absence of pain. The exercise stress test is still the single most useful test to begin the evaluation of a patient with an analyzable ST segment. In persons suspected of having CAD, the detection of ischemic-type ST-segment depression, at a low workload (e.g., < 120 beats/min or < 6.5 METS) of > 2 mm magnitude or persisting for more than 6 min implies high risk for adverse outcome. Asymptomatic ischemia during everyday activities, detected by Holter monitoring, in the high-risk patient, most probably adds additional risk beyond the risk of an abnormal stress test alone. Left ventricular imaging by two-dimensional echocardiography, RNA, angiogram, vest, etc, showing an ejection fraction > or = 40%, reversible wall motion abnormalities in multiple regions and redistribution defects or a failure to increase ejection fraction during exercise even if the patient remains asymptomatic, also imply high risk. The presence of any of these abnormal findings, regardless of symptoms, should therefore prompt as high a degree of concern as with ischemia-related signals associated with pain. Thus any therapy chosen should be directed toward elimination of transient ischemia, not just relief of symptoms that may or may not be ischemia related. If this course is chosen, the efficacy of the therapeutic regimen and possible progression of CAD should be assessed with follow-up testing for ischemia. We believe that risk factor modification and aspirin should be considered for most, if not all, patients in whom ischemia, silent or symptomatic, is suspected or detected. If symptoms or ischemia suggesting low risk is present, anti-ischemic medical therapy may be considered, but follow-up is advised. If a high-risk ischemic signal, even without symptoms, is detected, medical therapy should be used to attempt to modify the signal. If the ischemic signal suggesting high risk persists despite medical therapy, revascularization should be considered. Until additional data from large clinical trials are available, this approach appears to have the greatest likelihood of modifying the adverse outcome of CAD.

Safety and clinical use of exercise testing one to three days after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

To evaluate both the safety and clinical use of predischarge symptom-limited exercise testing after successful uncomplicated percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), 100 patients were randomized to undergo exercise testing (n = 50) or no exercise testing (n = 50). There were no differences in clinical or angiographic characteristics between the groups. Exercise testing was performed 38 +/- 14 hours after PTCA. Patients who exercised achieved 71 +/- 12% of predicted maximal heart rate, with 38% reaching greater than or equal to stage III of the Bruce protocol. No patient in either group developed cardiac complications during 48-hour follow-up. Of the 11 patients with a positive test result, 92% had angiographically incomplete revascularization. Attending physicians (n = 16) were questioned both before and after exercise testing about when, after discharge, they would allow their patient to perform each of 11 specific activities of daily living. Questionnaires were administered to physicians at similar time frames for patients in the no-exercise group. Comparison of the responses between initial and repeat questionnaires showed that patients in the exercise group (with a test result negative for ischemia) were allowed to perform 7 of 11 activities, including return to work, earlier (p less than 0.05) than the no-exercise patients. These data indicate that in this well-defined group of patients, symptom-limited exercise testing early after PTCA appears to be safe, and alters physician management in allowing patients with a negative test result to return to various activities at an earlier date. Such testing may be useful in counseling patients after PTCA.

Can we really justify the treatment of silent ischemia in 1992? No!

Since the advent of ambulatory ST-segment monitoring, it has been established that silent ischemia is common in patients with various coronary artery disease syndromes, and such silent episodes represent up to 80% of all ischemic episodes. It appears to be associated with an adverse prognosis when compared with similarly characterized patients without silent ischemia during daily life. Silent ischemia does not, however, bother the patients, by virtue of the fact that it is silent, and therefore treatment of such ischemia must be justified by an improved outlook for the patient, rather than symptom relief. There is no direct evidence to date that silent ischemia is associated with acute myocardial infarction or sudden cardiac death in a cause-and-effect relationship, or that reduction or eradication of silent ischemia will lead to an improved prognosis for the patient; indeed, we have been unable to demonstrate any significant improvement in outlook when using the various antianginal/antiischemic agents at our disposal. Until we can demonstrate a benefit to the patient by detecting and treating silent ischemia, we should not waste large resources attempting to eradicate something whose significance we do not understand.

Circadian variation of ischemic threshold in patients with chronic stable angina

Circadian variation of ischemic threshold in chronic stable exertional angina was determined in 51 patients with documented coronary artery disease from the Holter monitor results. The peak favored time zones of ischemic attacks were 8 a.m. and 9 a.m. There was no difference in frequency of ischemic attacks, magnitude of ST-segment depression, or duration of ST-segment depression between the two time zones for ischemic attacks, 6-9 a.m. and 0-3 p.m., but the ischemic threshold was lower in the morning than in the afternoon. These observations suggest that the pathogenesis of ischemic attacks differs from one time zone to the other and is considered helpful in planning therapeutic strategies for myocardial ischemia.

Effects of coronary artery bypass surgery and angioplasty on the total ischemic burden: a study of exercise testing and ambulatory ST segment monitoring

To assess the effects of standard therapeutic interventions on the total ischemic burden, 86 patients with stable angina underwent 48 hours of ambulatory ST segment monitoring and treadmill exercise testing before and at a mean of 10 weeks after coronary artery bypass surgery (CABG) (group 1, N = 46) or percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) (group 2, N = 40). There were 72 male and 14 female patients with a mean age of 56.4 years. All patients had documented coronary artery disease (24, single-vessel; 28, two-vessel; 34, three-vessel disease). Both groups were characteristically similar apart from more severe coronary artery disease (p less than 0.001) and more previous myocardial infarctions (p less than 0.05) in group 1. Groups with CABG and PTCA had significant prolongation of exercise time after intervention (group 1: 7.6 to 9.8 minutes, p less than 0.0001; group 2: 8.1 to 10.0 minutes, p less than 0.001), and both interventions led to a significant reduction in ischemic responses (group 1: 33 to 4, p less than 0.001; group 2: 20 to 13, p less than 0.05) to exercise. During a total of 7643 hours of ST segment monitoring, 253 episodes of ischemia were recorded in 3768 hours before and 44 ischemic episodes in 3875 hours after intervention (group 1, 113 episodes in 24 patients and 21 episodes in 10 patients; group 2, 140 episodes in 13 patients and 23 episodes in six patients). Both interventions reduced the mean frequency of ischemia per 24 hours (group 1: 1.24 to 0.22 episodes per 24 hours; p less than 0.01; group 2: 1.9 to 0.3 episodes per 24 hours; p less than 0.05). Almost 28% (N = 24) of resting electrocardiographic findings were altered as a result of intervention.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)