Insulin antibodies in patients receiving penicillamine

Comparison of patient characteristics between East Asian and non-East Asian patients with insulin autoimmune syndrome

OBJECTIVE

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is the third most common cause of spontaneous hypoglycaemia in Japan but very rare in the rest of the world. We aimed to identify factors, which are associated with the occurrence of IAS and which may differ between East Asian and non-East Asian patients.

DESIGN

A PubMed search using the search terms 'insulin autoimmune syndrome' and 'Hirata disease' revealed a total of 287 reports of IAS cases, including one previously unpublished own case.

RESULTS

Mean age (±standard deviation) was 52 ± 19 years in East Asian and 54 ± 21 years in non-East Asian patients (p > .05). In both groups, there were more females. Mean body mass index was lower in East Asian than in non-East Asian patients (23.0 ± 4.3 vs. 27.1 ± 5.6 kg/m² , p < .0001). Postprandial hypoglycaemia was more common in non-East Asian patients (p < .05). East Asian patients took more frequently antithyroid medications and non-East Asian patients angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors (both p < .0001). Graves' disease and other autoimmune diseases were more frequently observed in East Asian patients (both p < .01). Parameters of glucose metabolism were comparable in both groups, independent of diabetes diagnosis (p > .05), except for insulin that was higher in East Asian compared to non-East Asian metabolically healthy patients (p < .01). Human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DRB1*0406 was the most frequent HLA-type in East Asian patients (p < .0001), whereas DRB1*0403 and *0404 were more frequent in non-East Asian patients (both p < .05). Non-East Asian patients received more secondary treatments, including plasmapheresis and rituximab, whereas medication discontinuation was more common in East Asian patients (all p < .05). Outcome was similar in both groups (p > .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Factors associated with IAS markedly differ between East Asian and non-East Asian patients, with autoimmune disorders, particularly Graves' disease, antithyroid medications, and HLA-DRB1*0406 more prevalent in East Asian patients and cardiovascular and plasma cell diseases, ACE inhibitors and HLA-DRB1*0403 more prevalent in non-East Asian patients.

Hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia associated with insulin antibodies caused by exogenous insulin analog

Insulin antibodies (IA) associated with exogenous insulin administration seldom caused hypoglycemia and had different characteristics from insulin autoantibodies (IAA) found in insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS), which was first described by Dr Hirata in 1970. The characteristic of IAS is the presence of insulin-binding autoantibodies and related fasting or late postprandial hypoglycemia. Here, we report a patient with type 1 diabetes mellitus under insulin glargine and insulin aspart treatment who developed recurrent spontaneous post-absorptive hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia with the cause probably being insulin antibodies induced by exogenous injected insulin. Examinations of serial sera disclosed a high titre of insulin antibodies (33%, normal <5%), high insulin concentration (111.9 IU/mL) and undetectable C-peptide when hypoglycemia occurred. An oral glucose tolerance test revealed persistent high serum levels of total insulin and undetectable C-peptide. Image studies of the pancreas were unremarkable, which excluded the diagnosis of insulinoma. The patient does not take any of the medications containing sulfhydryl compounds, which had been reported to cause IAS. After administering oral prednisolone for 3 weeks, hypoglycemic episodes markedly improved, and he was discharged smoothly.

LEARNING POINTS

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) or IAS-like situation should be one of the differential diagnosis in patients with hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.Although less reported, insulin antibodies (IA) caused by exogenous insulin analog should be considered as the cause of hypoglycemia.Patients with suspected insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) should be screened for drugs related to autoimmunity to endogenous insulin.

Inferring new drug indications using the complementarity between clinical disease signatures and drug effects

BACKGROUND

Drug repositioning is the process of finding new indications for existing drugs. Its importance has been dramatically increasing recently due to the enormous increase in new drug discovery cost. However, most of the previous molecular-centered drug repositioning work is not able to reflect the end-point physiological activities of drugs because of the inherent complexity of human physiological systems.

METHODS

Here, we suggest a novel computational framework to make inferences for alternative indications of marketed drugs by using electronic clinical information which reflects the end-point physiological results of drug's effects on the biological activities of humans. In this work, we use the concept of complementarity between clinical disease signatures and clinical drug effects. With this framework, we establish disease-related clinical variable vectors (clinical disease signature vectors) and drug-related clinical variable vectors (clinical drug effect vectors) by applying two methodologies (i.e., statistical analysis and literature mining). Finally, we assign a repositioning possibility score to each disease-drug pair by the calculation of complementarity (anti-correlation) and association between clinical states ("up" or "down") of disease signatures and clinical effects ("up", "down" or "association") of drugs. A total of 717 clinical variables in the electronic clinical dataset (NHANES), are considered in this study.

RESULTS

The statistical significance of our prediction results is supported through two benchmark datasets (Comparative Toxicogenomics Database and Clinical Trials). We discovered not only lots of known relationships between diseases and drugs, but also many hidden disease-drug relationships. For example, glutathione and edetic-acid may be investigated as candidate drugs for asthma treatment. We examined prediction results by using statistical experiments (enrichment verification, hyper-geometric and permutation test P<0.009 in Comparative Toxicogenomics Database and Clinical Trials) and presented evidences for those with already published literature.

CONCLUSION

The results show that electronic clinical information is a feasible data resource and utilizing the complementarity (anti-correlated relationships) between clinical signatures of disease and clinical effects of drugs is a potentially predictive concept in drug repositioning research. It makes the proposed approach useful to identity novel relationships between diseases and drugs that have a high probability of being biologically valid.

Approach to the patient with spontaneous hypoglycemia

Hypoglycemia is common in daily clinical practice and often occurs during the treatment of diabetes mellitus. However, a small minority of hypoglycemia encountered in clinical practice is spontaneous and thus not induced by glycemic lowering agents. These spontaneous hypoglycemic events confront the clinician with a diagnostic enigma. Although the trained clinician can recognize the autonomic and neuroglycopenic symptoms of hypoglycemia even in a patient not on insulin, it remains challenging to decipher the etiology of a spontaneous hypoglycemic event. A logical and stepwise approach to the spontaneous hypoglycemic event allows for a conclusive diagnosis. This diagnostic process consists of adequately diagnosing hypoglycemia by fulfilling Whipple's triad, stratifying patients according to their clinical status and analyzing a full hypoglycemic blood panel. A complete hypoglycemic blood panel should include the analysis of glucose, insulin, C-peptide, pro-insulin, insulin antibodies and the presence of oral hypoglycemic agents. For patients with episodes of hypoglycemia induced by excessive endogenous insulin, additional imaging is often required to detect the presence of an underlying insulinoma. By diagnosing the underlying cause of the spontaneous hypoglycemia, the physician also diagnosis the mechanism by which the hypoglycemic event occurs. Allowing for a problem orientated therapeutic approach.

METHODOLOGY

The present review is based upon a comprehensive PubMed search between 1985 and 2013. This uses search terms of spontaneous hypoglycemia, insulinoma, nesidioblastosis, insulin auto-immunity, noninsulinoma pancreatogenous hypoglycemia syndrome, hormone deficiency, pro-IGF II, and pro-insulin growth factor II, and cross reference searching of pivotal articles in the subject.

Recurrent hypoglycemia from insulin autoimmune syndrome

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is an uncommon cause of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia characterized by autoantibodies to endogenous insulin in individuals without previous exposure to exogenous insulin. IAS is the third leading cause of spontaneous hypoglycemia in Japan, and is increasingly being recognized worldwide in non-Asian populations. We report a case of IAS in a Caucasian woman with recurrent complaints of hypoglycemia, with laboratory findings of serum glucose 2.5 mmol/L (45 mg/dL), insulin 54,930 pmol/L (7,909 μIU/mL), connecting peptide (C-peptide) 4,104 pmol/L (12.4 ng/mL), and a corresponding insulin to C-peptide molar ratio of 13.4 during a spontaneous hypoglycemic event. Autoantibodies to insulin were markedly elevated at > 50 kU/L (> 50 U/mL). IAS should be considered in the differential diagnosis of hypoglycemia in non-diabetic individuals. Distinction from insulinoma is especially crucial to prevent unwarranted invasive procedures and surgical interventions in hypoglycemic patients.

Late postprandial hypoglycemia due to bioactive insulin dissociation from autoantibody leading to unconsciousness in a patient with insulin autoimmune syndrome

We report here the case of an 83-year-old man who was treated for unconsciousness and hypoglycemia (39 mg/dL) accompanied by marked elevation of serum immunoreactive insulin (IRI) (4,760 µIU/mL). We diagnosed his condition as insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS, Hirata disease) because of a high insulin autoantibody (IAA) titer (>90%: bound/total) and no history of exogenous insulin administration. Reactive hypoglycemia occurred due to immediate association followed by dissociation between insulin and insulin autoantibodies after glucose or food intake. An α-glucosidase inhibitor in combination with frequent small meals reduced the postprandial hyperglycemia (glucose spike) and ameliorated the reactive hypoglycemia.

Autoimmune forms of hypoglycemia

Autoimmune syndromes are a rare cause of hypoglycemia characterized by elevated levels of insulin in the presence of either anti-insulin antibodies (insulin autoimmune syndrome) or anti-insulin receptor antibodies (type B insulin resistance). Insulin autoimmune syndrome is the third leading cause of hypoglycemia in Japan, but has rarely been described in the non-Asian population.In the current study, we report the clinical and biochemical characteristics and clinical course of 2 white patients with insulin autoimmune syndrome, and present a literature review of non-Asian patients reported with insulin autoimmune syndrome. Also, we describe the clinical and biochemical characteristics of patients reported in the literature with type B insulin resistance who manifested hypoglycemia. We compare the clinical and laboratory features of insulin autoimmune syndrome and type B insulin resistance with each other and with other forms of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.Autoimmune forms of hypoglycemia are uncommon. However, they should be considered in any patient with hypoglycemia in the setting of unsuppressed insulin levels associated with anti-insulin or anti-insulin receptor antibodies. Making the correct diagnosis may spare a hypoglycemic patient from an unnecessary pancreatic surgical procedure.

Spontaneous hypoglycaemia in the presence of both anti-insulin antibody and anti-insulin receptor antibody

Beside insulinoma, alternative causes of hyperinsulinaemic hypoglycaemia include the rare autoimmune syndrome related to spontaneous autoantibodies either to insulin or to insulin receptor. We describe a case of hypoglycaemia with high insulinemia in which insulinoma could not be evidenced. Surprisingly, we found in the patient's serum both insulin autoantibodies and insulin receptor autoantibodies. Available data eventually supported the predominant role of insulin autoantibodies rather than insulin receptor autoantibodies in the mechanism of hypoglycaemia of this patient. Insulin antibodies were present in high titre. Most of the insulin in serum was bound to the insulin antibodies and free insulin was slightly increased. HLA typing displayed DR4 haplotype, known to be strongly linked to the insulin autoimmune syndrome. The patient's serum was able to inhibit insulin binding to its receptor in a cultured cell line overexpressing insulin receptors both in experiments with native serum and with serum depleted from insulin antibodies. However, we could not demonstrate that the insulin receptor antibodies had insulin mimicking effect. We have no obvious explanation for the presence of these two antibodies in the same patient. Possible hypotheses might involve an idiotype-anti-idiotype mechanism or a poly-autoimmune disease.

Insulin Autoimmunity and Hypoglycemia in Seven White Patients

OBJECTIVE

To report the clinical, biochemical, and immunologic characteristics of 7 white patients with the rare disorder of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia in association with spontaneously generated high titers of antibodies to human insulin.

METHODS

We reviewed the clinical data, history, and symptoms of the 7 study patients and summarized the biochemical findings during a spontaneous episode of hypoglycemia. Insulin antibody binding was measured in all patients, and antibody affinity, capacity, and clonality were analyzed in 4. A mixed meal study was conducted in 2 patients. A potential mechanism for postprandial hypoglycemia is presented.

RESULTS

In all 7 patients (6 women and 1 man), symptoms were neuroglycopenic, occurring primarily postprandially but during fasting in some patients. During hypoglycemia, concentrations of insulin, proinsulin, and, in most patients, C peptide considerably exceeded those observed in patients with insulinoma. These concentrations were spuriously elevated as a result of interference by the autoantibodies in the immunoassays. No patient had evidence of an insulinoma on various radiologic localization procedures directed at the pancreas. Insulin antibodies showed a high percentage of binding to human insulin--50 to 90%. Heterogeneity of antibodies regarding clonality and antibody binding sites was noted; some patients had polyclonal and some had monoclonal IgG class antibodies. Most patients had two categories of binding sites: high affinity/low capacity and low capacity/high affinity. Although the mechanism for postprandial hypoglycemia remains conjectural, prolonged elevations of postprandial concentrations of total and free insulin are consistent with the putative mechanism of a buffering effect of insulin antibodies.

CONCLUSION

Insulin autoimmune hypoglycemia, although rare in any racial group and especially in white subjects, can be readily detected by high titers of insulin antibodies. Such a determination should be done in all patients undergoing evaluation for hypoglycemia.

Severe hypoglycemic coma due to insulin autoimmune syndrome

Insulin autoimmune syndrome, characterized by the presence of insulin-binding autoantibodies and fasting or late postprandial hypoglycemia, is a rare cause of hypoglycemia. We report a patient with pulmonary tuberculosis who developed recurrent spontaneously post-absorptive hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia after treatment with anti-tuberculous drugs. Imaging studies of the pancreas were unremarkable, and selective intra-arterial calcium stimulation with hepatic venous sampling for insulin failed to show a gradient, thus almost completely excluding the possibility of occult insulinoma or nesidioblastosis. Examinations of sera, however, disclosed a high titer of polyclonal insulin-binding autoantibodies containing at least 2 classes of binding sites, 1 with high affinity but low capacity, and the other with low affinity but high capacity. An oral glucose tolerance test revealed high serum levels of total insulin associated with relatively low levels of free insulin, but not of C-peptide, suggesting binding of the released insulin to autoantibodies. Regretfully, shortly after the withdrawal of isoniazid, the patient died of respiratory failure unrelated to hypoglycemia, and whether these antibodies were induced by isoniazid remains unknown. We recommend that insulin autoimmune syndrome be one of the differential diagnoses in patients with hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.

D-penicillamine-induced pancreatic islet autoantibody production is independent of the immunogenetic background: a lesson from patients with Wilson's disease

D-penicillamine (d-PA) was reported to induce various immunological abnormalities including production of autoantibodies to insulin. These abnormalities were mainly described in patients with primary immunological disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis. In order to clarify whether d-PA-induced immune disorders are restricted to patients genetically prone to develop autoimmune diseases or to a direct drug effect, we tested for the presence of various autoantibodies and for molecular HLA typing in 17 patients with Wilson's disease treated with this drug. In 2/17 patients, low-titer (10 JDFU) circulating islet cell autoantibodies (ICA) were detected, while another patient was positive for the presence of insulin autoantibodies. None of the sera tested showed reactivity for glutamic acid decarboxylase or ICA512. Five of twelve patients were positive for anti-single-stranded DNA autoantibody. Molecular HLA typing of the autoantibody-positive subjects showed that they carry HLA haplotypes not associated with insulin-dependent diabetes. The insulin response to intravenous glucose tolerance test in two patients with autoantibodies was found to be normal. A second blood testing of the autoantibody-positive patients 5 months following initial evaluation revealed conversion to negativity in all three. Our results suggest that d-PA-induced autoantibodies in patients with Wilson's disease are independent of the immunogenetic background characteristics of diabetes.

Insulin autoimmune syndrome as a cause of spontaneous hypoglycemia in alcoholic cirrhosis

Hypoglycemia in fulminant hepatic failure and hyperinsulinemia in cirrhosis are well-described phenomena. A patient with alcoholic cirrhosis who developed fasting hypoglycemia with an extremely high immunoreactive insulin level and a mildly elevated C-peptide level is reported. An insulinoma was excluded by detailed radiological imaging of the pancreas and by endoscopic ultrasonography. Detection of very high levels of insulin autoantibodies with no prior exposure to exogenous insulin confirmed the diagnosis of insulin autoimmune syndrome. During his hospital course, the patient developed another rare syndrome, acquired inhibitors to factor V, which led to the fatal coagulopathy that resulted in his death. Insulin autoimmune syndrome is the third leading cause of spontaneous hypoglycemia in Japan, where it has been associated with a variety of diseases and drugs. Outside of Japan, only approximately 20 cases have been reported and usually have been found in the context of an underlying autoimmune disorder or prior exposure to sulfhydryl drugs. It is believed that this is the first case reported outside Japan occurring in association with alcoholic liver disease, and the first in the world with coexisting acquired inhibitors to factor V.

Correlates of insulin autoantibodies with beta cell function at the time of diagnosis of diabetes mellitus

In this article, the author discusses the prevalence of insulin autoantibodies (IAA) and endogenous insulin secretion in Saudi patients at the onset of diabetes. A positive result, defined as a value greater than 3 SD above the mean binding of normal, was found in 8 (7.6%) of 105 of the patients with diabetes and in 3 (5.7%) of 53 of the healthy control subjects. The relation between the presence of IAA and the pancreatic beta cell secretory activity was studied by determining the levels of insulin and C-peptide in the fasting state and 6 minutes after intravenous injection of 1 mg glucagon. All the IAA positive subjects had a response to glucagon stimulation test. A positive correlation was found between basal and after stimulation for both insulin and C-peptide (r = 0.79, P < 0.001; r = 0.85, P < 0.001 for insulin and r = 0.76, P < 0.001; r = 0.81, P < 0.001 for C-peptide, respectively). Therefore, the current finding indicates that there is no direct effect of IAA on the pancreatic beta cell potential activity in Saudi patients with diabetes at the time of diagnosis, suggesting further that these patients have no insulin deficiency or have mild insulin dependency.

Characterization of insulin autoantibodies in a patient with autoimmune hypoglycemia

A 60-year-old man referred because of hypoglycemic bouts was found to have insulin autoantibodies. Total plasma insulin was as high as 1.44 nmol/l. Both plasma free insulin and C-peptide were in the normal range. The indirect immunofluorescence technique showed positivity for antinuclear antibodies. The T-lymphocyte populations in the peripheral blood were normal. When serum binding capacity for pork insulin was measured, antibodies binding pork insulin were not detected. The patient's serum bound 125I-insulin. The binding protein was identified to be an immunoglobulin G. The kinetics of dissociation, studied by the Scatchard analysis of the autoantibody, showed a curvilinear plot, which was analyzed in two components. Cold human insulin was able to compete with 125I-insulin for the antibody binding site (I.C.50 = 1.35 nmol/ml). These antibodies were apparently not associated with antibodies directed against the insulin receptor.

Solid versus liquid phase assays in detection of insulin antibodies. Influence of iodination site on labelled insulin binding

On type 1 newly diagnosed and on insulin treated diabetic patients, anti-insulin autoantibodies (IAA) and antibodies (IA) having the same specificity are respectively induced. Such immune response may be evaluated either by radiobinding assay (RBA) or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Both methodologies have been compared at previous International Workshops, which pointed out discrepancies in results. In this work, IAA/IA prevalence was assessed by displacement RBA and ELISA, in normal subjects, type 2 (treated with hypoglycaemic agents), insulin treated and newly diagnosed type 1 diabetic patients. Results showed a lack of RBA-ELISA agreement. An attempt was then made to determine whether such results were, at least in part, attributable to iodination site in Tyr-A14. For this purpose parallel RBA assays were carried out by using radiolabelled insulin at A14 and A19 Tyr residues. Control sera and samples from insulin treated and type 1 newly diagnosed diabetic patients were tested. Our results suggest that labelling position is not involved in artifactual binding of tracers, at least as a systematic phenomenon. In the majority of cases the variability in RBA-ELISA signal ratios are best explained in terms of differences in the basic principles operating in both methods instead of artifacts due to tracer preparation.

Insulin autoantibodies in patients with autoimmune diseases

Insulin antibodies (IAA) can be detected in the serum of the majority of newly diagnosed IDDM patients prior to insulin therapy. In first degree relatives of IDDM patients, IAA are associated with an increased risk of development of IDDM. However, the disease specificity of IAA, detected by radiobinding assays, has not been addressed. We thus tested sera from patients with autoimmune disease for IAA. One of 29 (3%) patients with Graves' disease and five of 27 (19%) patients with SLE had IAA levels exceeding the range for normal controls. IAA were not detected in sera from 29 patients with Addison's disease, 15 patients with pernicious anaemia or 10 patients with increased gamma globulins. Non-specific binding of 125I-labelled insulin was increased in serum from 14 (21%) samples from patients with Graves' disease, 10 (37%) patients with SLE, one (3.2%) of 29 patients with Addison's disease and two (13%) of 15 patients with pernicious anaemia. The increased non-specific binding most likely relates to immunoglobulin binding as it was also found in eight of 10 patients with oligoclonal or polyclonal increase in gamma globulins. Our findings suggest that moderate elevations of IAA are not uncommon in patients with SLE, in whom increased non-specific binding of insulin is also common. This observation is of importance in preclinical diabetes screening studies.

Increased specificity and sensitivity of insulin antibody measurements in autoimmune thyroid disease and type I diabetes

Insulin autoantibodies (IAA), a marker for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), have been reported in other diseases such as thyroid disease and after treatment with sulfhydryl containing medications. Reported prevalences of IAA in non-diabetics vary widely, probably due in part to methodological differences between laboratories. In addition, certain sera may have a high non-specific binding to insulin. We compared a radioimmunoassay (RIA) for IAA which included non-specific binding with an RIA that incorporated a competitive displacement with cold insulin to remove non-specific binding. Using the RIA which measured specific plus non-specific binding, IAA positivity was found in 22/92 (23.9%) of sera from thyroid disease patients, 16/124 (12.9%) of random masked sera from a hospital laboratory, 27/335 (8.1%) of first degree relatives of IDDM patients, 63/178 (35.4%) of subjects with newly diagnosed IDDM, and 0/92 (0%) of normal controls. Insulin antibodies (IA) were found in 80/99 (80.8%) of insulin-treated diabetic subjects. In contrast, using the displacement assay which allowed measurement of specific binding, the frequency of IAA positivity was lower for subjects with thyroid disease (7/92 (7.6%)), random hospital sera (12/124 (9.8%)), and for first degree relatives of IDDM patients (8/335 (2.4%)), while higher for subjects with newly diagnosed IDDM (71/178 (39.9%)). Subjects with insulin-treated diabetes (78/99 (78.8%)) and normal subjects (1/92 (1.1%)) showed little change. Strikingly, three of the eight (37.5%) relatives of IDDM patients that were positive in the RIA measuring specific binding were detected only because cold displacement was utilized. We conclude: (1) subjects with thyroid disease and first degree relatives of IDDM patients frequently have high non-specific binding for IAA in an RIA not employing a cold displacement step, (2) in some newly diagnosed IDDM patients and first degree relatives of IDDM patients, IAA may be missed by an assay not optimized to measure specific binding, and (3) displacement with cold insulin increases both the specificity and sensitivity of RIAs measuring insulin autoantibodies.

Reactive hypoglycemic coma due to insulin autoimmune syndrome: case report and literature review

Recurrent episodes of postprandial hypoglycemic symptoms culminated in hypoglycemic coma in a hypertensive but otherwise healthy man while he was taking hydralazine. The patient was found to have an extreme elevation in the immunoreactive insulin level, leading to the discovery of insulin antibodies in the absence of prior exposure to exogenous insulin. Negative results of an anatomic study of the pancreas and an inability to reproduce hypoglycemia during a prolonged fast helped to exclude insulinoma. In contrast, symptomatic hypoglycemia developed in response to oral glucose loading and was associated with an elevation in total and free insulin as well as C-peptide levels. The patient was diagnosed with insulin autoimmune syndrome, which, although a common source of hypoglycemia in Japan, has been well documented in only 15 cases from other countries. HLA typing revealed the patient to be positive for groups Cw4 and DR4, a combination that has been preliminarily associated with insulin autoimmune syndrome in Japan. Unlike the majority of cases previously reported, this patient had no clinical or serologic evidence of an underlying autoimmune disorder and had not been exposed to drugs containing sulfhydryl groups. This case adds to the world literature on insulin autoimmune syndrome, lends support to a postulated HLA association, and documents the presence of insulin autoantibodies in the absence of another underlying autoimmune disorder.

Polymorphism of insulin antibodies in six patients with insulin-immune hypoglycaemic syndrome

Insulin antibodies in six patients with immune hypoglycaemic syndrome were studied. The antibodies displayed a higher affinity for bovine insulin in two patients, were specific for human insulin in one patient and non-species specific in the other three patients. The predominant IgG subclass of the insulin antibodies was IgG4 in two patients, IgG3 in two and IgG1 in two. In one of these, the other three subclasses were also detectable. Insulin autoantibodies of four patients were homogeneous with regard to light chains (kappa), and those of the other two contained both kappa and gamma light chains. Analysis of insulin immune complex size by fast protein liquid chromatography was possible in three patients and demonstrated immune complexes with elution profile close to that of IgG, although not exactly superimposable to the one obtained with a mouse monoclonal insulin antibody. In two patients, avidity was too low to permit chromatography of the immune complexes, and, moreover, in these two cases insulin antibodies were of the IgG3 isotype and spontaneously formed aggregates independently of insulin binding. We conclude that insulin antibodies of the insulin immune syndrome are polymorphic but different from those generated by insulin therapy.

Influence of affinity of antibodies upon their detection by liquid phase radiobinding assay and solid phase enzyme linked immunosorbent assay. Demonstration using monoclonal antibodies raised against rDNA human proinsulin

Hybridomas producing proinsulin antibodies were cloned by limiting dilution of cell cultures obtained by fusion of splenocytes of immunized mice with immortal myeloma cells. Some proinsulin monoclonal antibodies crossreacted with labelled insulin but none did with labelled C-peptide indicating that the involved epitopes were at one of the insulin/C-peptide junctions or included in the insulin moiety. Hybridoma supernatants were assayed for IgG concentration by a solid phase assay and for ligand binding by a radiobinding assay and an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay. The half-life of immune complexes formed with radioligand was measured and, as expected, correlated with affinity as measured by the method of Scatchard. Antibody titres determined by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay did not correlate to those measured by radiobinding assay. IgG concentration correlated to enzyme linked immunosorbent assay titres but not to radiobinding assay titres. Finally, a significant correlation was found between radiobinding assay titre and the product of enzyme linked immunosorbent assay titre by the period of immune complexes. It is concluded that, except for very low affinity antibodies, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay is a capacity assay whereas radiobinding assay is influenced by both antibody concentration and affinity. The former assay is thus best suited to detecting low affinity antibodies whereas the latter is more efficient in the presence of low levels of high affinity antibodies.

Insulin autoantibodies in Graves' disease--before and after carbimazole therapy

Insulin autoantibodies (IAA) are well documented in patients with insulin-dependent diabetes (IDDM) prior to the administration of insulin and in patients with reactive hypoglycaemia--the insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS). It has been suggested that IAA can be induced by the administration of drugs containing sulphydryl groups, such as carbimazole, and they have been frequently described in Graves' disease. An alternative explanation is the clustering of autoantibodies in autoimmune disease. We studied 39 patients (37 females, two males, age range 14 to 61 years; mean 33.8 years) with proven Graves' disease and no previous treatment with carbimazole. Fifteen of the 39 patients had a family history of other autoimmune diseases. IAA and thyroid autoantibodies were assayed at diagnosis and monthly thereafter while on treatment with carbimazole, for up to 6 months. IAA were measured using a direct-binding solid-phase ELISA and specificity was confirmed by absorption studies using insulin covalently coupled to Sepharose beads. At diagnosis 33 of the 39 patients (85%) were positive for thyroid microsomal antibodies, 13 (33%) were positive for thyroglobulin antibodies, and 4 (10%) were positive for IAA. All IAA-positive patients had microsomal antibodies at diagnosis, and two had thyroglobulin antibodies in addition. After 4 months on carbimazole, the frequency of thyroid microsomal autoantibodies was unchanged (83%), while that of anti-thyroglobulin antibodies had fallen (8.6%). All four IAA-positive patients remained positive, and studies of binding to human, porcine and bovine insulin demonstrated that one serum, initially human insulin specific, later became cross-reactive with all three. We conclude that low titres of IAA are found in Graves' disease, and are associated with the presence of autoimmunity rather than the carbimazole. Symptomatic hypoglycaemia, however, is rare in Caucasian patients.

Antibody markers for type 1 diabetes: the issues

The detection of islet-cell-specific autoantibodies before clinical onset may mean that diabetes mellitus can be predicted, with important implications for targeting those to whom preventive treatment might be given. A large number of such markers have been proposed, but only high-titer islet cell antibodies have so far demonstrated the specificity and sensitivity to be of potential clinical value.

Autoimmune insulin syndrome

Initially described in Japan, the autoimmune insulin syndrome is caused by the presence of anti-insulin antibodies in patients who have never received insulin. This syndrome accounts for spontaneous or reactive hypoglycaemia with very high levels of total immuno-reactive insulin. Discordance between the levels of immunoreactive insulin and C peptide indicate the possible presence of anti-insulin antibodies; this can avoid an incorrect diagnosis of insulinoma. These autoimmune hypoglycaemias often present a difficult diagnostic problem in distinguishing them from factitious hypoglycaemia. The course of the autoimmune insulin syndrome is usually favourable, with a spontaneous rapid diminution of the levels of anti-insulin antibodies. The reasons for the appearance of anti-insulin antibodies and the exact mechanisms of the hypoglycaemia remain uncertain. However, the frequent association of the autoimmune insulin syndrome with certain autoimmune diseases suggest a common immune dysfunction. Drugs containing a sulphydryl group have been implicated in the aetiology of this syndrome.

Factors affecting the insulin autoantibody ELISA

IgG antibodies to insulin are present in insulin-treated patients and are detected in the prodrome of untreated type I diabetes. Sporadic reports of autoantibodies to insulin suggest that they are also present in other disorders. To establish the incidence of insulin autoantibodies in other endocrine and autoimmune diseases an ELISA was used to examine sera from 529 subjects with no prior insulin therapy. These untreated patients included: normal controls (adults and children), newly-diagnosed type I diabetes, first-degree relatives of diabetics, type II diabetes, Graves' hyperthyroidism, and systemic lupus erythematosus. As a positive control group, 280 insulin-treated patients were studied. Measurement of IgG antibodies by direct binding to insulin coated plates was complicated by differences between adult and pediatric populations and by overlap of binding between treated and untreated subjects. Competitive inhibition with excess soluble human insulin overcame these problems and permitted identification of insulin specific binding. Using this approach insulin antibodies were most frequent in insulin-treated diabetics (98%) and in type I diabetics (37%) prior to treatment. The absolute numbers of subjects with insulin autoantibody in the other groups differed depending upon whether a cut-off for binding (mean + 2SD of controls) or for insulin inhibition of binding (45%) was used. Regardless of the criteria used there were subjects (2-24%) in all groups tested with circulating insulin-specific IgG autoantibody detected by ELISA. These low level antibodies detected in solid phase assays may be part of the normal immune repertoire.

Immunological aspects of diabetes mellitus: prospects for pharmacological modification

It is now well known that insulin-dependent diabetes is a chronic progressive autoimmune disease. The prolonged prediabetic phase of progressive beta-cell dysfunction is associated with immunological abnormalities. A prediabetic period is suggested by the appearance of islet cell antibodies, anti-insulin antibodies, and anti-insulin receptor antibodies. The existence of activated T lymphocytes and abnormal T cell subsets are also other markers. There is still no concensus about the use of the immunosuppression superimposed upon conventional insulin therapy in early diagnosed IDDM and the follow-up of the relatives of IDDM patients who share the genetic predisposition and serological markers for the risk of future onset of IDDM. Treatment in the prodromal period cannot be justified because a link between the disease and early markers such as ICA has not been established with certainty (Diabetes Research Program NIH, 1983). Many immunopharmacological manipulations were reported to be effective in animal models. However, most of them are not readily applied to human subjects. Moreover, IDDM patients are now believed to be heterogeneous, with a complex genetic background. HLA-DR, and more recently DQ, are closely related to the genetic predisposition to IDDM but those genes are not themselves diabetogenic. The contribution of autoimmunity does not appear to be uniform, and in some cases, the contribution of virus is considered more important. There is a lack of a marker for the future onset of IDDM. ICA and ICSA were found after mumps infection, but the existence of those autoantibodies and even the co-existence of HLA-DR3 do not always indicate the future trend to insulin dependency. More precise markers will be disclosed through the biochemical analysis of the target antigens on pancreatic beta-cell for islet antibodies and effector T cells. Much safer and more effective immunopharmacological treatment will be developed through animal experimentation using rat and mouse models. The recent development and interest in this field will further facilitate the attainment of the goal for the complete prevention of IDDM.

The determination of detection limits for insulin antibody assays

In order to define the detection limit of a radioimmunoassay for insulin-antibody a correction was made for binding in the presence of an excess of unlabelled insulin and assay precision was calculated. One hundred forty control sera were assessed; all were islet cell antibody negative. For each sample, binding of 125-I human insulin was determined both with and without excess unlabelled insulin, subtraction of the latter acting as a correction. The distribution of uncorrected binding was skewed while corrected binding was normally distributed, (mean (SD) = 0.149 (0.298%)) Precision, defined as the mean of the standard deviations of replicates, was 0.263%. Detection limits calculated from the estimate of precision (0.263%) or from the standard deviation of the corrected binding (0.298%) were similar. Two hundred thirty sera from insulin-treated patients were studied. Precision was plotted as a 'precision profile' and the detection limit calculated from the precision for binding of less than 1% [0.261%]; 88% of the sera were positive [cut-off 1.3%, p less than 0.01]. We conclude that corrected binding is normally distributed in antibody-negative sera and that an estimate of assay precision can be used to define the detection limit of the assay.

Autoimmunity induced by chemicals

Immunotoxicologic studies have demonstrated that autoimmune responses and/or autoimmune diseases are induced in humans and experimental animals by chronic exposure to various chemicals. The present review is focused on seven groups of chemically induced human disorders, i.e. systemic lupus erythematosus, autoimmune hemolytic anemia, myasthenia gravis, pemphigus, glomerulonephritis, thyroiditis and hepatitis. Results obtained from studies of the available experimental counterparts of these diseases, i.e. those models obtained from the exposure of laboratory animals to various chemicals, are then analyzed. Finally, we present the lessons that can be derived from immunotoxicologic investigations regarding mechanisms of induction, heterogeneity of chemicals involved, humoral vs. cellular immune responses and genetic predisposition to chemically induced autoimmunity.