The economic burden of unrecognized vasodepressor syncope

Convulsive Syncope as a Complication of Outpatient Procedures: A Case Series and Review of the Literature

ABSTRACT

Sports medicine providers often perform various outpatient procedures to manage musculoskeletal and neuropathic conditions. Vasovagal syncope is a rare but a possible complication. Convulsive syncope is one subtype that involves brief extensor stiffening and nonsustained myoclonus and can be easily mistaken for seizures. We present a case series of convulsive syncope as a complication of common sports medicine outpatient procedures. We aim to describe how to identify this condition, and offer risk stratification and management strategies to mitigate the risks of this complication. Sports medicine providers who routinely practice outpatient procedures should be aware of this complication. Simple changes in approaching the procedure may mitigate these risks. High- and intermediate-risk features of the syncopal episode should prompt physicians to seek further evaluation by a specialist to rule out more serious conditions. In all instances, appropriate on-site support and equipment for emergent resuscitation and management should be prepared.

Fludrocortisone in Pediatric Vasovagal Syncope: A Retrospective, Single-Center Observational Study

Background and Purpose

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of fludrocortisone in patients with pediatric vasovagal syncope (VVS).

Methods

This retrospective observational single-tertiary-center study based on chart reviews included 74 patients who were newly diagnosed with VVS in the head-up tilt-table test (HUTT). Some of the patients had been treated with fludrocortisone. All patients were assessed using a brain and cardiac workup before treatment to rule out the syncope being due to other causes, which resulted in seven of them being excluded: two for epilepsy and five for brain pathologies. The remaining 67 patients were analyzed. The effect of fludrocortisone was evaluated based on the results of a follow-up HUTT, with a response to the treatment considered to be present if there was a negative change at the follow-up HUTT. Univariate logistic regression were used for statistical analyses, with the criterion for significance being p<0.05.

Results

There were no significant differences in the characteristic of the patients between the no-medication (n=39) and fludrocortisone (n=28) groups, including age, sex, and duration of treatment. The recurrence rate of syncopal or presyncopal events was significantly lower in the fludrocortisone group (39.3%, 11 of 28) than in the no-medication group (64.1%, 25 of 39) (p=0.044), as was the rate of negative change at the follow-up HUTT: 57.1% (16 of 28) and 28.2% (11 of 39), respectively (p=0.017).

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that fludrocortisone is more effective than no medication in pediatric patients with VVS.

Diagnostic Yield of Echocardiography in Syncope Patients with Normal ECG

Aim. This study aimed to assess the role of echocardiography as a diagnostic tool in evaluating syncope patients with normal versus abnormal electrocardiogram. Methods. We conducted a retrospective study of 468 patients who were admitted with syncope in 2011 at St. Joseph's Regional Medical Center, Paterson, NJ. Hospital records and patient charts, including initial emergency room history and physical, were carefully reviewed. Patients were separated into normal versus abnormal electrocardiogram groups and then further divided as normal versus abnormal echocardiogram groups. Causes of syncope were extrapolated after reviewing all test results and records of consultations. Results. Three hundred twelve of the total patients (68.6%) had normal ECG. Two-thirds of those patients had echocardiograms; 11 patients (5.7%) had abnormal echo results. Of the aforementioned patients, three patients had previous documented history of severe aortic stenosis on prior echocardiograms. The remaining eight had abnormal but nondiagnostic echocardiographic findings. Echocardiography was done in 93 of 147 patients with abnormal ECG (63.2%). Echo was abnormal in 27 patients (29%), and the findings were diagnostic in 6.5% patients. Conclusions. This study demonstrates that echocardiogram was not helpful in establishing a diagnosis of syncope in patients with normal ECG and normal physical examination.

The Role of the Syncope Management Unit

Syncope is a common symptom, experienced by 15% of persons less than 18 years old and up to 23% of elderly nursing home residents, so it is important to consider optimizing strategies for the management of these patients. The strategy selected will inevitably differ from place to place. However, an organized structure offers more cost-effective care. This article discusses possible health care delivery models for syncope management and reviews the current status of the organization of syncope care, to show the value of a multidisciplinary approach to the organized management of patients with syncope.

The effect of late adoption of Canadian innovations: a case for implantable cardiac monitors

Syncope is a sudden and generally momentary loss of consciousness, which can have serious adverse events. The outcomes of the syncope episode can vary from a fall to fatal accidents. Syncope has a major negative effect on the patient's health-related quality of life. The economic burden of syncope on healthcare systems is considerable. There are no clear diagnostic pathways for identifying the cause of syncope; patients can be admitted to hospital and undergo expensive and often repeated and inconclusive diagnostic tests. Implantable cardiac monitors have been available for more than a decade to help early diagnosis of syncope in unexplained cases. However, despite being a Canadian invention, the use of the implantable cardiac monitors has been suboptimal in the Canadian healthcare system. This study provides an overview of syncope, its management, and presents the estimated potential cost savings per diagnosis of systematic use of implantable cardiac monitors in Ontario.

Near-infrared diffuse optical monitoring of cerebral blood flow and oxygenation for the prediction of vasovagal syncope

Significant drops in arterial blood pressure and cerebral hemodynamics have been previously observed during vasovagal syncope (VVS). Continuous and simultaneous monitoring of these physiological variables during VVS is rare, but critical for determining which variable is the most sensitive parameter to predict VVS. The present study used a novel custom-designed diffuse correlation spectroscopy flow-oximeter and a finger plethysmograph to simultaneously monitor relative changes of cerebral blood flow (rCBF), cerebral oxygenation (i.e., oxygenated/deoxygenated/total hemoglobin concentration: r[HbO2]/r[Hb]/rTHC), and mean arterial pressure (rMAP) during 70 deg head-up tilt (HUT) in 14 healthy adults. Six subjects developed presyncope during HUT. Two-stage physiological responses during HUT were observed in the presyncopal group: slow and small changes in measured variables (i.e., Stage I), followed by rapid and dramatic decreases in rMAP, rCBF, r[HbO2], and rTHC (i.e., Stage II). Compared to other physiological variables, rCBF reached its breakpoint between the two stages earliest and had the largest decrease (76±8%) during presyncope. Our results suggest that rCBF has the best sensitivity for the assessment of VVS. Most importantly, a threshold of ∼50% rCBF decline completely separated the subjects from those without presyncope, suggesting its potential for predicting VVS.

Use of implantable loop recorders to unravel the cause of unexplained syncope

Syncope is a symptom of many underlying disease states, which range from the relatively benign to the life threatening. There are numerous investigations done for patients with recurrent unexplained syncope which may have very low yield when it comes to making a definitive diagnosis. Recently, the implantable loop recorder (ILR) for continuous monitoring of the cardiac rhythm has been launched in India. This review will briefly discuss these current available strategies and focus on the usefulness of an ILR in the definitive diagnosis and treatment of patients with a recurrent unexplained syncope.

Syncope in adults: systematic review and proposal of a diagnostic and therapeutic algorithm

This review aims to provide a practical and up-to-date description on the relevance and classification of syncope in adults as well as a guidance on the optimal evaluation, management and treatment of this very common clinical and socioeconomic medical problem. We have summarized recent active research and emphasized the value for physicians to adhere current guidelines. A modern management of syncope should take into account 1) use of risk stratification algorithms and implementation of syncope management units to increase the diagnostic yield and reduce costs; 2) early implantable loop recorders rather than late in the evaluation of unexplained syncope; and 3) isometric physical counter-pressure maneuvers as first-line treatment for patients with neurally-mediated reflex syncope and prodromal symptoms.

Management of syncope in adults: an update

Syncope is a clinical syndrome characterized by transient loss of consciousness and postural tone that is most often due to temporary and spontaneously self-terminating global cerebral hypoperfusion. A common presenting problem to health care systems, the management of syncope imposes a considerable socioeconomic burden. Clinical guidelines, such as the European Society of Cardiology Guidelines on Management of Syncope, have helped to streamline its management. In recent years, we have witnessed intensive efforts on many fronts to improve the evaluation process and to explore therapeutic options. For this update, we summarized recent active research in the following areas: the role of the syncope management unit and risk prediction rules in providing high-quality and cost-effective evaluation in the emergency department, the implementation of structured history taking and standardized guideline-based evaluation to improve diagnostic yield, the evolving role of the implantable loop recorder as a diagnostic test for unexplained syncope and for guiding management of neurally mediated syncope, and the shift toward nonpharmacological therapies as mainstay treatment for patients with neurally mediated syncope. Syncope is a multidisciplinary problem; future efforts to address critical issues, including the publication of clinical guidelines, should adopt a multidisciplinary approach.

Syncope: experience at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi, Pakistan

Introduction

Our aim was to determine the characteristics of patients presenting with syncope at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi, Pakistan.

Methods

A review of medical records was conducted retrospectively at the Department of Medicine, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi. Patients aged 16 and above, admitted from January 2000 to December 2005 with the diagnosis of syncope made by the attending physician were included.

Results

A total of 269 patients were included (75% males, mean age: 57.4 years). Neurogenic (vasovagal) syncope was the most common cause (47%), followed by cardiogenic syncope (18%) and orthostatic syncope (9%). A total of 24% were discharged undiagnosed. Twenty patients (7.4%) did not have any prodrome. Common prodromal symptoms included dizziness (61%), sweating (25%), palpitations (19%), nausea/vomiting (19%) and visual symptoms (17%). The distribution of symptoms according to cause of syncope revealed only breathlessness to be significantly associated with cardiogenic syncope (p = 0.002). Most patients with cardiogenic syncope were aged above 40 (98%, p < 0.001), had coronary artery disease (72%, p < 0.001) and abnormal electrocardiogram at presentation (92%, p < 0.001).

Conclusion

Despite differences in burden of diseases, our findings were similar to those of published syncope literature. Further studies are needed to develop a protocol to expedite the evaluation and limit the work-up and admission in low-risk patients.

Using the net benefit regression framework to construct cost-effectiveness acceptability curves: an example using data from a trial of external loop recorders versus Holter monitoring for ambulatory monitoring of "community acquired" syncope

Background

Cost-effectiveness acceptability curves (CEACs) describe the probability that a new treatment or intervention is cost-effective. The net benefit regression framework (NBRF) allows cost-effectiveness analysis to be done in a simple regression framework. The objective of the paper is to illustrate how net benefit regression can be used to construct a CEAC.

Methods

One hundred patients referred for ambulatory monitoring with syncope or presyncope were randomized to a one-month external loop recorder (n = 49) or 48-hour Holter monitor (n = 51). The primary endpoint was symptom-rhythm correlation during monitoring. Direct costs were calculated based on the 2003 Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) fee schedule combined with hospital case costing of labour, materials, service and overhead costs for diagnostic testing and related equipment.

Results

In the loop recorder group, 63.27% of patients (31/49) had symptom recurrence and successful activation, compared to 23.53% in the Holter group (12/51). The cost in US dollars for loop recording was $648.50 and $212.92 for Holter monitoring. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of the loop recorder was $1,096 per extra successful diagnosis. The probability that the loop recorder was cost-effective compared to the Holter monitor was estimated using net benefit regression and plotted on a CEAC. In a sensitivity analysis, bootstrapping was used to examine the effect of distributional assumptions.

Conclusion

The NBRF is straightforward to use and interpret. The resulting uncertainty surrounding the regression coefficient relates to the CEAC. When the link from the regression's p-value to the probability of cost-effectiveness is tentative, bootstrapping may be used.

Is ambulatory monitoring for "community-acquired" syncope economically attractive? A cost-effectiveness analysis of a randomized trial of external loop recorders versus Holter monitoring

BACKGROUND

Out patient ambulatory monitoring is often performed in patients with syncope that present in the primary care setting to include or exclude an arrhythmia. The cost-effectiveness of 2 monitoring strategies was assessed in a prospective randomized trial.

METHODS

One hundred patients referred for ambulatory monitoring with syncope or presyncope were randomized to a 1-month external loop recorder (n = 49) or 48-hour Holter monitor (n = 51). Patients were offered crossover if there was failed activation or no symptom recurrence. The primary end point was symptom-rhythm correlation during monitoring. Direct costs were calculated based on the 2003 Ontario Health Insurance Plan fee schedule, combined with calculation of labor, materials, service, and overhead for diagnostic testing and related equipment.

RESULTS

Before enrollment, the cost of all previous health care resource use was USD 472 +/- USD 397 (range USD 21-USD 1965). In the loop recorder group, 63% of patients had symptom recurrence and successful activation, compared with 24% in the Holter group (P < .0001). The cost per Holter was USD 177.64, and per loop recorder, USD 533.56, with a similar cost per diagnosis with the 2 techniques. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of the loop recorder was USD 901.74 per extra successful diagnosis. A strategy of Holter followed by offered loop recorder trended toward lower cost than initial loop recorder followed by Holter (USD 481 +/- USD 267 vs USD 551 +/- USD 83, P = .08), but was associated with a lower overall diagnostic yield (49% vs 63%) and a resultant higher cost per diagnosis (USD 982 vs USD 871, P = .08). Bootstrapping suggested that 90% of incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were less than USD 1250.

CONCLUSION

Despite the increased upfront cost of external loop recorders, the marked improvement in diagnostic yield offsets the cost. External loop recorders are an economically attractive alternative. First-line use of external loop recorders in patients with "community-acquired" syncope and presyncope should be considered to optimize diagnostic yield given its value.

Diagnostic criteria for vasovagal syncope based on a quantitative history

AIMS

Our goal was to develop historical criteria for the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We administered a 118-item historical questionnaire to 418 patients with syncope and no apparent structural heart disease. The prevalence of each item was compared between patients with positive tilt tests and those with syncope of other, known causes. The contributions of symptoms to diagnoses were estimated with logistic regression, point scores were developed, and the scores were tested using receiver operator characteristic analysis. The accuracy of the decision rule was assessed with bootstrapping. Data sets were complete for all subjects. The causes of syncope were known in 323 patients and included tilt-positive vasovagal syncope (235 patients) and other diagnoses such as complete heart block and supraventricular tachycardias (88 patients). The point score correctly classified 90% of patients, diagnosing vasovagal syncope with 89% sensitivity and 91% specificity. The decision rule suggested that 68% of an additional 95 patients with syncope of unknown cause and a negative tilt test have vasovagal syncope.

CONCLUSION

A simple point score of historical features distinguishes vasovagal syncope from syncope of other causes with very high sensitivity and specificity.

Pulse wave analysis during supine rest may identify subjects with recurrent vasovagal syncope

In the present study, we studied whether analysis of the FAP (finger arterial pressure) waveform during supine rest discriminates subjects with recurrent VVS (vasovagal syncope) from healthy controls. Signal-averaged FAP waveforms (Finapres) were obtained in 32 head-up tilt-test-positive subjects with recurrent VVS (35±13 years) and in 32 sex- and age-matched healthy controls. The DT (time delay) between the systolic and diastolic peaks of the FAP waveform was measured and large artery SI (stiffness index) was calculated as a ratio of body height and DT. VVS patients had significantly shorter DT compared with controls (303±31 compared with 329±18 ms; P<0.001) and higher SI (5.79±0.70 compared with 5.20±0.36 m/s; P<0.001). The differences were independent of heart rate and blood pressure. SI >5.45 m/s identified subjects with syncope with a sensitivity of 72% and a specificity of 84%. Age-corrected DT (cDT=DT+age−350) identified subjects with syncope with a sensitivity of 75% and a specificity of 84%. Combined use of cDT <0 ms and SI >5.45 m/s increased sensitivity and specificity to 81% and 96% respectively. The discriminative power of FAP descriptors improved further when younger subjects were excluded. In subjects aged >30 years (median age), the combination of cDT and SI identified subjects with syncope with a sensitivity of 93% and a specificity of 100%. These results suggest that FAP descriptors during supine rest might be useful in the diagnosis of VVS in middle-aged subjects.

Unconscious confusion--a literature search for definitions of syncope and related disorders

BACKGROUND

Imprecise definitions of syncope and related conditions appear common in the medical literature. To investigate the scope of the problem we systematically searched for definitions in high-ranking medical journals.

METHODS

Literature review of articles on 'syncope', 'neurocardiogenic syncope', 'neurally mediated syncope', 'orthostatic intolerance', and 'orthostatic hypotension' with these keywords in the title, mainly published in the ten journals with the highest impact in the fields of cardiology, internal medicine, and neurology.

RESULTS

Syncope, neurocardiogenic syncope, neurally mediated syncope, orthostatic intolerance, and orthostatic hypotension were defined in only 41%, 34%, 26%, 38%, and 48% of papers respectively. Definitions, when given, differed considerably among papers. Orthostatic hypotension was most frequently defined, with an increase in number and consistency of definitions after publication of a consensus in 1996.

CONCLUSIONS

Syncope and related conditions proved to be infrequently and inconsistently defined in current medical literature. The lack of consistent terminology is likely to harm medical education, research, and patient care. There is a strong need for a systematic terminology for syncope and related conditions.

Syncope in children: diagnostic tests have a high cost and low yield

OBJECTIVES

To assess the use, yield, and cost-effectiveness of diagnostic tests used in the evaluation of syncope in children.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective review of 169 pediatric patients presenting to a tertiary care center with new onset syncope was undertaken. Test results were considered diagnostic when an abnormal result correlated with the clinical diagnosis or a normal result was obtained during a syncopal episode. Costs were based on the hospital cost of testing for fiscal year 1999, using a relative value unit-based costing methodology and did not include professional fees or costs of hospitalization.

RESULTS

A total of 663 tests were performed at a cost of 180,128 dollars. Only 26 tests (3.9%) were diagnostic in 24 patients (14.2%). The average cost per patient was 1055 dollars, and the cost per diagnostic result was 6928 dollars. Echocardiograms, chest radiographs, cardiac catheterizations, electrophysiology studies, and serum evaluations were not diagnostic.

CONCLUSIONS

The evaluation of pediatric syncope remains expensive, and testing has a low diagnostic yield. An approach that focuses on the use of testing to verify findings from the history and physical examination or exclude life-threatening causes is justified.

Distinguishing benign syncope from life-threatening cardiac causes of syncope

Syncope, defined as the temporary loss of consiousness and postural tone resulting from an abrupt transient decrease in cerebral blood flow, is a common usually benign self-limiting event. However, rarely, it may be the first warning sign of a serious condition including arrhythmias, structural heart disease, or non-cardiac disease. This article presents a differential diagnosis of syncope in children with an emphasis on neurocardiogenic syncope, details important positives and negatives in the history and physical exam that would suggest cardiac syncope and gives recommendations on when to refer a child for syncope to a pediatric cardiologist.

Role of autonomic evaluation in the diagnosis and management of syncope

There are many causes of syncope that include neurological (autonomic and non-autonomic), cardiac and psychiatric causes, amongst others. Disorders of the autonomic nervous system, either intermittent or fixed, are increasingly recognised as contributing to a large proportion of syncope. However, the majority of guidelines focus on cardiological and neurological evaluation in these disorders. In this overview we focus specifically on the role of autonomic evaluation. This has dual purposes; to aid the diagnosis and cause of syncope, and furthermore to provide information to understand the pathophysiological basis of syncope and thus improve management of such disorders.

Defining and classifying syncope

There is no widely adopted definition or classification of syncope and related disorders. This lack of uniformity harms patient care, research, and medical education. In this article, syncope is defined as a form of transient loss of consciousness (TLOC) due to cerebral hypoperfusion. Differences between syncope and other causes of TLOC such as epilepsy, and disorders mimicking TLOC are described. A pathophysiological classification of syncope is proposed.

Diagnostic Value of Nitrate Stimulated Tilt Testing Without Preceding Passive Tilt in Patients with Suspected Vasovagal Syncope and a Healthy Control Group

BACKGROUND

The contribution of the passive tilt phase, in a combined nitrate stimulated tilt protocol may be low yielding. In order to develop a shortened, and thus easier to perform test, we investigated the optimal duration of a nitrate tilt protocol without a preceding passive phase.

METHODS

Thirty-eight consecutive patients (18F/20M; mean age 46 +/- 16) with clinically suspected vasovagal syncope and 31 control subjects (15F/16M; mean age 40 +/- 18) were tested. The subjects were tilted to 70 degrees for a maximum period of 30 minutes, and sublingual nitroglycerin 0.4 mg spray was administrated directly after attaining erect posture. Receiver operator characteristics (ROC) analysis was done to determine the optimal test duration.

RESULTS

In the patient group 31 (82%) and in controls 5 (16%) had a positive test. Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy at test end were 82, 84, and 83%, respectively. ROC analysis revealed that a maximum accuracy of 83% was attained at 14 minutes, with a sensitivity and specificity of 79 and 87%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Nitrate stimulated tilt testing, without a preceding passive tilt phase, and limited to a test duration of 15 minutes, provides an accurate, sensitive, and specific method to provoke vasovagal reactions in subjects with clinically suspected vasovagal syncope.

Syncope Evaluation in the Emergency Department Study (SEEDS): a multidisciplinary approach to syncope management

BACKGROUND

The primary aim and central hypothesis of the study are that a designated syncope unit in the emergency department improves diagnostic yield and reduces hospital admission for patients with syncope who are at intermediate risk for an adverse cardiovascular outcome.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In this prospective, randomized, single-center study, patients were randomly allocated to 2 treatment arms: syncope unit evaluation and standard care. The 2 groups were compared with chi2 test for independence of categorical variables. Wilcoxon rank sum test was used for continuous variables. Survival was estimated with the Kaplan-Meier method. One hundred three consecutive patients (53 women; mean age 64+/-17 years) entered the study. Fifty-one patients were randomized to the syncope unit. For the syncope unit and standard care patients, the presumptive diagnosis was established in 34 (67%) and 5 (10%) patients (P<0.001), respectively, hospital admission was required for 22 (43%) and 51 (98%) patients (P<0.001), and total patient-hospital days were reduced from 140 to 64. Actuarial survival was 97% and 90% (P=0.30), and survival free from recurrent syncope was 88% and 89% (P=0.72) at 2 years for the syncope unit and standard care groups, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The novel syncope unit designed for this study significantly improved diagnostic yield in the emergency department and reduced hospital admission and total length of hospital stay without affecting recurrent syncope and all-cause mortality among intermediate-risk patients. Observations from the present study provide benchmark data for improving patient care and effectively utilizing healthcare resources.

Do patients with a negative Emergency Department evaluation for syncope require hospital admission?

Is hospitalization needed for patients in whom an underlying cause of syncope is not detected in the Emergency Department (ED)? To answer this question, we conducted a prospective, short-term outcomes study of consecutive patients > or = 50 years old presenting to our ED after a syncopal episode. All subjects received a structured ED evaluation. Forty-five patients met inclusion criteria, 67% were hospitalized. None of the patients experienced a life-threatening event or required significant therapeutic interventions during the hospitalization. No patient had a new diagnosis relevant to syncope. Follow-up interviews 1 month later revealed no repeat ED visits, hospitalizations, or deaths (95% upper CI, 6.5%). One patient reported a recurrent syncope (recurrence 2.2% [95% upper CI, 10%]). This pilot study suggests that a negative structured ED evaluation may identify patients > or = 50 years of age who may be safely discharged from the ED. Further validation is required before this observation is applied to clinical practice.

Cost implications of testing strategy in patients with syncope: randomized assessment of syncope trial

OBJECTIVES

We sought to assess the cost implications of two investigation strategies in patients with unexplained syncope.

BACKGROUND

Establishing a diagnosis in patients with unexplained syncope is complicated by infrequent and unpredictable events. The cost-effectiveness of immediate, prolonged monitoring as an alternative to conventional diagnostic strategies has not been studied.

METHODS

Sixty patients (age 66 +/- 14 years; 33 males) with unexplained syncope and LV ejection fraction >35% were randomized to conventional testing with an external loop recorder, tilt and electrophysiologic (EP) testing, or prolonged monitoring with an implantable loop recorder with one-year monitoring. If patients remained undiagnosed after their assigned strategy, they were offered a crossover to the alternate strategy. Cost analysis of the two testing strategies was performed.

RESULTS

Fourteen of 30 patients who were being monitored were diagnosed at a cost of 2,731 Canadian dollars +/- 285 Canadian dollars per patient and 5,852 Canadian dollars +/- 610 Canadian dollars per diagnosis. In contrast, only six of 30 conventional patients were diagnosed (20% vs. 47%, p = 0.029), at a cost of 1,683 Canadian dollars +/- 505 Canadian dollars per patient (p < 0.0001) and 8,414 Canadian dollars +/- 2,527 Canadian dollars per diagnosis (p < 0.0001). After crossover, a diagnosis was obtained in 1 of 5 patients undergoing conventional testing, compared with 8 of 21 patients who completed monitoring (20% vs. 38%, p = 0.44). Overall, a strategy of monitoring followed by tilt and EP testing was associated with a diagnostic yield of 50%, at a cost of 2,937 Canadian dollars +/- 579 Canadian dollars per patient and 5,875 Canadian dollars +/- 1,159 Canadian dollars per diagnosis. Conventional testing followed by monitoring was associated with a diagnostic yield of 47%, at a greater cost of 3,683 Canadian dollars +/- 1,490 Canadian dollars per patient (p = 0.013) and a greater cost per diagnosis (7,891 Canadian dollars +/- 3,193 Canadian dollars, p = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

A strategy of primary monitoring is more cost-effective than conventional testing in establishing a diagnosis in recurrent unexplained syncope.

Discovering the cause of syncope. A guide to the focused evaluation

Syncope has many causes. Although the most common ones are generally benign and do not require extensive evaluation, cardiac syncope has high rates of recurrence and death. In this article, Dr Hauer describes how physical examination and electrocardiographic findings can guide further evaluation to provide the largest diagnostic yield at the lowest cost.

Role of echocardiography in the evaluation of syncope: a prospective study

OBJECTIVE

To study the role of echocardiography in the stepwise evaluation of syncope.

DESIGN

A prospective observational study with an 18 month follow up.

SETTING

University teaching hospital providing primary and tertiary care.

SUBJECTS

650 consecutive patients with syncope and clinical suspicion of an obstructive valvar lesion, or with syncope not explained by history, physical examination, or a 12 lead ECG, who underwent bidimensional Doppler transthoracic echocardiography.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The causes of syncope were assigned using published diagnostic criteria. Echocardiography was considered diagnostic when confirming a suspected diagnosis, or when revealing occult cardiac disease explaining the syncope.

RESULTS

A systolic murmur was identified in 61 of the 650 patients (9%). Severe aortic stenosis was suspected in 20 of these and was confirmed by echocardiography in eight. Follow up excluded further cases of aortic stenosis. In patients with unexplained syncope (n = 155), routine echocardiography showed no abnormalities that established the cause of the syncope. Echocardiography was normal or non-relevant in all patients with a negative cardiac history and a normal ECG (n = 67). In patients with a positive cardiac history or an abnormal ECG (n = 88), echocardiography showed systolic dysfunction (left ventricular ejection fraction < or = 40%) in 24 (27%) and minor non-relevant findings in the remaining 64. Arrhythmias were diagnosed in 12 of the 24 patients with systolic dysfunction (50%), and in 12 of the 64 remaining patients (19%) (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Echocardiography was most useful for assessing the severity of the underlying cardiac disease and for risk stratification in patients with unexplained syncope but with a positive cardiac history or an abnormal ECG.

Historical criteria that distinguish syncope from seizures

OBJECTIVES

We prospectively sought evidence-based criteria that distinguished between seizures and syncope.

BACKGROUND

Loss of consciousness is usually due to either seizures or syncope. There are no evidence-based historical diagnostic criteria that distinguish them.

METHODS

A total of 671 patients with loss of consciousness completed a 118-item historical questionnaire. Data sets were complete for all subjects. The data set was randomly divided into two equal groups. The contributions of symptoms to diagnoses in one group were estimated with logistic regression and point scores were developed. The accuracy of the decision rule was then assessed using split-half analysis. Analyses were performed with and without inclusion of measures of symptom burden, which were the number of losses of consciousness and the duration of the history. The scores were tested using receiver-operator characteristic analysis.

RESULTS

The causes of loss of consciousness were known satisfactorily in 539 patients and included seizures (n = 102; complex partial epilepsy [50 patients] and primary generalized epilepsy [52 patients]) and syncope (n = 437; tilt-positive vasovagal syncope [267 patients], ventricular tachycardia [90 patients] and other diagnoses such as complete heart block and supraventricular tachycardias [80 patients]). The point score based on symptoms alone correctly classified 94% of patients, diagnosing seizures with 94% sensitivity and 94% specificity. Including symptom burden did not significantly improve accuracy, indicating that the symptoms surrounding the loss of consciousness accurately discriminate between seizures and syncope.

CONCLUSIONS

A simple point score of historical features distinguishes syncope from seizures with very high sensitivity and specificity.

When is intracardiac electrophysiologic evaluation indicated in the older or very elderly patient? Complications rates and data

The use of invasive EPS and catheter ablation is well established for many cardiac rhythm disorders. Because of the high prevalence of arrhythmias, which often are tolerated poorly in the elderly, and the increased frequency of adverse effects of pharmacologic therapy in this population, the potential for benefit from invasive EPS and catheter ablation is great. The notion that elderly patients are at increased risk of complications from invasive EPS is not borne out by available data. Therefore, the suitability of this form of diagnostic and therapeutic approach should be based on the assessment of the individual patient and the clinical context, while taking into consideration patient-specific risks, goals, and expectations in adopting an invasive strategy.

Cerebral blood flow velocity declines before arterial pressure in patients with orthostatic vasovagal presyncope

OBJECTIVES

We studied hemodynamic changes leading to orthostatic vasovagal presyncope to determine whether changes of cerebral artery blood flow velocity precede or follow reductions of arterial pressure.

BACKGROUND

Some evidence suggests that disordered cerebral autoregulation contributes to the occurrence of orthostatic vasovagal syncope. We studied cerebral hemodynamics with transcranial Doppler recordings, and we closely examined the temporal sequence of changes of cerebral artery blood flow velocity and systemic arterial pressure in 15 patients who did or did not faint during passive 70 degrees head-up tilt.

METHODS

We recorded photoplethysmographic arterial pressure, RR intervals (electrocardiogram) and middle cerebral artery blood flow velocities (mean, total, mean/RR interval; Gosling's pulsatility index; and cerebrovascular resistance [mean cerebral velocity/mean arterial pressure, MAP]).

RESULTS

Eight men developed presyncope, and six men and one woman did not. Presyncopal patients reported light-headedness, diaphoresis, or a sensation of fatigue 155 s (range: 25 to 414 s) before any cerebral or systemic hemodynamic change. Average cerebral blood flow velocity (CBFV) changes (defined by an iterative linear regression algorithm) began 67 s (range: 9 to 198 s) before reductions of MAP. Cerebral and systemic hemodynamic measurements remained constant in nonsyncopal patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Presyncopal symptoms and CBFV changes precede arterial pressure reductions in patients with orthostatic vasovagal syncope. Therefore, changes of cerebrovascular regulation may contribute to the occurrence of vasovagal reactions.

Costs and utility of tests in the evaluation of the pediatric patients with syncope

New diagnostic tests have markedly improved the ability to establish a cause of syncope in pediatric patients, but at a substantial cost. The goal of syncope evaluation should be to diagnose treatable causes and identify patients at high risk for sudden death. The diagnostic utility of commonly used tests is reviewed. Although there are limited data on the application of specific diagnostic tests in the child with syncope, most tests have a low yield in unselected patients. A more directed approach to testing, based on the results of history, physical examination and the electrocardiogram is likely to result in significant cost reduction while still identifying patients with life threatening disorders. Validation of such an approach awaits prospective evaluation.

[Usefulness of the implantable subcutaneous recorder in the diagnosis of recurrent syncope of unknown etiology in patients without structural heart disease and negative tilt test and electrophysiological study]

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

In up to 38% of the cases, the etiology of syncope difficult to determine. The main obstacle for diagnosis of the causes of syncope lies in the unpredictable frequency of episodes. Development of implantable loop recorders allows long term electrocardiographic monitoring. The aim of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of the implantable loop recorder for the diagnosis of recurrent syncope of unknown origin.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From May 1991 to April 1999, a cohort of 176 patients with recurrent syncope was prospectively assessed. Investigations, including Holter monitoring, Tilt Test and electrophysiological study, allowed the determination of the etiology in 161 patients. The remaining 15 patients, without structural cardiac disease were selected for continuous electrocardiographic monitoring using an implantable loop recorder.

RESULTS

During follow up after implant, 15 +/- 2 months (X- +/- SEM), 9 patients showed recurrence of symptoms concordant with prior episodes (time: 105 +/- 30 days). In 7 cases records during symptoms were diagnostic (0.47; CI 95%: 0.21-0.73), in 3 cases a diagnosis with documented arrhythmia was achieved, and in 4 other cases a presumptive clinical diagnosis of non-arrhythmic cause was made. In 8 patients, 6 with no recurrences, diagnosis was not possible. There were no complications related to the use of the device.

CONCLUSIONS

The strategy of long term monitoring with the implantable loop recorder is safe and effective in patients with recurrent syncope of unknown etiology.

Observations on recurrent syncope and presyncope in 641 patients

BACKGROUND

Syncope is a common disorder that is potentially disabling and affects both young and old. Once neurological, cardiological, and metabolic causes have been excluded, there remains a group in which diagnosis is unclear; some may have an autonomic basis. We therefore did a retrospective study on consecutive patients referred to our tertiary referral autonomic centres between 1992 and 1998 with recurrent syncope and presyncope, in whom non-autonomic causes, before referral, had been sought and excluded. The object was to find out whether autonomic investigation helped diagnosis.

METHODS

Data from case notes and from the autonomic database on 641 patients were analysed. Syncopal patients with a known or provisional diagnosis of autonomic failure were excluded from analysis. The role of screening tests in establishing or excluding an autonomic cause was assessed. Response to additional autonomic tests (such as head-up tilt with or without venepuncture, and food challenge and exercise) was documented. Some patients underwent further testing if non-autonomic neurological, psychiatric, and other disorders were considered.

FINDINGS

Screening autonomic function tests indicated orthostatic hypotension and confirmed chronic autonomic failure in 31 (4.8%) patients. Neurally mediated syncope was diagnosed in 279 (43.5%) on the basis of clinical features and autonomic testing. Most had vasovagal syncope (227 [35%]); other causes included carotid sinus hypersensitivity (37 [5.8%]), and a group of 15 (2.3%) were associated with rarer causes such as micturition and swallowing. Miscellaneous cardiovascular causes (systemic hypotension, arrhythmias), or drugs, contributed to syncope in 53 (8.3%). Non-autonomic neurological causes included vestibular dysfunction (32 [5%]) and epilepsy (11 [1.7%]). In 56 (8.7%) a psychiatric cause was thought to be contributory. In 179 (27.9%), syncope was of unknown cause.

INTERPRETATION

In recurrent syncope and presyncope, when cardiac, neurological, and metabolic causes have been excluded, autonomic investigation can aid management by making, confirming, or excluding various factors or diagnoses.

Syncope

Syncope is a common clinical presentation. Although most commonly benign, it may herald a pathology with a poor prognosis. The work-up of syncope includes a careful history, physical examination, electrocardiogram, risk stratification, and appropriately directed testing. The key factor in the investigation of syncope is the presence (or absence) of structural heart disease or an abnormal electrocardiogram. The most useful investigation in unexplained syncope with a normal heart is the tilt table test for evaluating predisposition to neurocardiogenic (vasovagal) syncope. In the setting of structural heart disease or an abnormal electrocardiogram, electrophysiologic studies play a more important role. The utility of noninvasive cardiac monitoring for symptom-rhythm correlation may be limited by infrequent symptoms. The availability of external and implantable loop recorders allows prolonged periods of monitoring to increase diagnostic yield. The management of patients with syncope may be complex. Early referral to a cardiac electrophysiologist is warranted in patients who are at high risk.

Intravenous nitrates for pharmacological stimulation during head-up tilt testing in patients with suspected vasovagal syncope and healthy controls

Nitrates may be used for pharmacological stimulation during tilt testing for the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope. In this study we assessed the diagnostic value of intravenous nitrates during tilt testing in patients with a typical history of vasovagal syncope. Twenty patients and 23 controls were tilted at 700 for a maximum duration of 30 minutes. After a 10-minute baseline supine phase, the test started with a continuous nitrate infusion at 1 microg/kg/min and increased every 5 minutes by 1 microg/kg/min, to a maximum of 6 microg/kg/min at the end of the test. The test was ended if the subjects developed a positive response (syncope or presyncope). Nineteen patients (95%) and 17 (74%) of the controls had a positive response. At test end sensitivity was 95%, but specificity was 26% and accuracy was 58%. Receiver operator characteristics (ROC) analysis revealed a maximum accuracy of 79% at 18 minutes, with a sensitivity of 80% and a specificity of 78%. Intravenous nitrates during tilt testing in patients with typical clinical criteria of vasovagal syncope is highly effective in provoking vasovagal syncope. Based on the ROC analysis, a maximum accuracy of 79% was attained at 18 minutes (at a dose of 4 microg/kg/min), suggesting a good diagnostic performance when tilt duration is limited to this point. A positive result requiring more than 18 minutes of stimulated tilting should be interpreted with caution, due to the accompanying considerable decrease of specificity.

Management of vasovagal syncope

Vasovagal syncope is a common disorder of autonomic cardiovascular regulation that can be very disabling and result in a significant level of psychosocial and physical limitations. The optimal approach to treatment of patients with vasovagal syncope remains uncertain. Although many different types of treatment have been proposed and appear effective based largely on small nonrandomized studies and clinical series, there is a remarkable absence of data from large prospective clinical trials. However, based on currently available data, the pharmacologic agents most likely to be effective in the treatment of patients with vasovagal syncope include beta blockers, fludrocortisone, and alpha-adrenergic agonists. In this article, we provide a summary of the various therapeutic options that have been proposed for vasovagal syncope and review the clinical studies that form the basis of present therapy for this relatively common entity.

Evaluation of syncope in the emergency department

Although most cases of syncope are benign, an adequate evaluation, which begins in the emergency department, is required to exclude life-threatening disorders. In addition, life-threatening disorders such as QT prolongation as well as confounding alternative diagnoses (e.g., seizure disorder) are also discussed.

Head-upright tilt table testing. A safe and easy way to assess neurocardiogenic syncope

Head-upright tilt table testing has emerged as an exciting technique for evaluating episodes of autonomically mediated syncope. It may be performed using gravity alone as the provocative stimulus or with the addition of isoproterenol. The classic neurocardiogenic response to the test is a sudden drop in blood pressure followed by a decrease in heart rate, but other abnormal response patterns have also been reported. Continuing investigations will improve understanding of autonomic disturbances that cause orthostatic intolerance and will help elaborate the role of tilt table testing in their evaluation and management.

Syncope: current diagnosis and treatment

The patient with syncope often poses a formidable diagnostic challenge. A large number of underlying causes must be considered, ranging in severity from benign to life-threatening. A careful, systematic clinical evaluation beginning with a history, physical examination, and ECG will establish the diagnosis in most patients, and the judicious use of specialized testing will confirm or uncover the cause in many of the remaining cases. Further basic and clinical research into the pathogenesis and treatment of neurocardiogenic syncope, the role of HUT testing in neurally mediated syncope, and the optimal use of EPS in patients with cardiac disease will markedly improve our management of these patients in the future.