Long-term survival after bronchial sleeve resection: univariate and multivariate analyses

Completion pneumonectomy: Indications and outcomes in non-small cell lung cancer

Background

This retrospective single-center study aims to review the indications and outcomes of completion pneumonectomy after primary resection due to non-small cell lung cancer.

Methods

Of a total of 452 patients who underwent pneumonectomy between January 2004 and August 2017 for non-small cell lung cancer, 29 (24 males, 5 females; mean age 59.9±7.1 years; range, 45 to 72 years) were performed completion pneumonectomy. Patients" indications, factors affecting early and late-term outcomes, operative mortality and survival rates were analyzed.

Results

Operative mortality rate was 24.1%, including two intraoperative and five postoperative deaths. Complication rate was 44.8% and the most frequent complication was bronchopleural fistula with 24.1%. Study population was divided into two groups. While elective completion pneumonectomy group (n=19) consisted of recurrent malignant tumor patients, rescue completion pneumonectomy group (n=10) consisted of patients performed urgent pneumonectomy due to a bronchopulmonary complication developing after an anatomic lung resection. The morbidity and mortality rates for elective completion pneumonectomy and rescue completion pneumonectomy were 26.3% and 21.1%; and 70% and 30%, respectively. The morbidity for rescue completion pneumonectomy was significantly higher than elective completion pneumonectomy (p=0.016). Advanced age and presence of any preoperative risk (comorbidity and neoadjuvant treatment) were related to higher operative mortality (p=0.019 and p=0.049, respectively). The median survival after completion pneumonectomy was 19.5 months (95% confidence interval 17.2 to 21.9 months).

Conclusion

The morbidity and mortality rates of completion pneumonectomy are higher than standard pneumonectomy. Rescue completion pneumonectomy is related to higher postoperative risk, but has better survival. The most significant complication after completion pneumonectomy is bronchopleural fistula. Advanced age and presence of any preoperative risk are related to statistically significantly higher mortality in completion pneumonectomy. Nevertheless, completion pneumonectomy is still a significant treatment option in selected patients.

Management of stage I and II nonsmall cell lung cancer

The incidence of stage I and II nonsmall cell lung cancer is likely to increase with the ageing population and introduction of screening for high-risk individuals. Optimal management requires multidisciplinary collaboration. Local treatments include surgery and radiotherapy and these are currently combined with (neo)adjuvant chemotherapy in specific cases to improve long-term outcome. Targeted therapies and immunotherapy may also become important therapeutic modalities in this patient group. For resectable disease in patients with low cardiopulmonary risk, complete surgical resection with lobectomy remains the gold standard. Minimally invasive techniques, conservative and sublobar resections are suitable for a subset of patients. Data are emerging that radiotherapy, especially stereotactic body radiation therapy, is a valid alternative in compromised patients who are high-risk candidates for surgery. Whether this is also true for good surgical candidates remains to be evaluated in randomised trials. In specific subgroups adjuvant chemotherapy has been shown to prolong survival; however, patient selection remains important. Neoadjuvant chemotherapy may yield similar results as adjuvant chemotherapy. The role of targeted therapies and immunotherapy in early stage nonsmall cell lung cancer has not yet been determined and results of randomised trials are awaited.

Surgical treatment of early-stage non-small-cell lung cancer

Surgical resection remains the standard of care for functionally operable early-stage non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and resectable stage IIIA disease. The role of invasive staging and restaging techniques is currently being debated, but they provide the largest biopsy samples which allow for precise mediastinal staging. Different types of operative procedures are currently available to the thoracic surgeon, and some of these interventions can be performed by video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) with the same oncological results as those by open thoracotomy. The principal aim of surgical treatment for NSCLC is to obtain a complete resection which has been precisely defined by a working group of the International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer (IASLC). Intraoperative staging of lung cancer is of utmost importance to decide on the extent of resection according to the intraoperative tumour (T) and nodal (N) status. Systematic nodal dissection is generally advocated to evaluate the hilar and mediastinal lymph nodes which are subdivided into seven zones according to the most recent 7th tumour-node-metastasis (TNM) classification. Lymph-node involvement not only determines prognosis but also the administration of adjuvant therapy.

In 2011, a new multidisciplinary adenocarcinoma classification was published introducing the concepts of adenocarcinoma in situ and minimally invasive adenocarcinoma. This classification has profound surgical implications. The role of limited or sublobar resection, comprising anatomical segmentectomy and wide wedge resection, is reconsidered for early-stage lesions which are more frequently encountered with the recently introduced large screening programmes. Numerous retrospective non-randomised studies suggest that sublobar resection may be an acceptable surgical treatment for early lung cancers, also when performed by VATS.

More tailored, personalised therapy has recently been introduced. Quality-of-life parameters and surgical quality indicators become increasingly important to determine the short-term and long-term impact of a surgical procedure. International databases currently collect extensive surgical data, allowing more precise calculation of mortality and morbidity according to predefined risk factors. Centralisation of care has been shown to improve results. Evidence-based guidelines should be further developed to provide optimal staging and therapeutic algorithms.

Bronchoscopic debulking followed by bronchoplastic procedure helps in limiting lung resection in a bronchial carcinoid: a case report

Bronchoplasty is a conservative procedure in lung surgeries used in the past for patients with poor functional status but recently these procedures have been performed in low grade malignant tumors of lung avoiding extensive morbid procedure like pneumonectomy without compromising the oncologic outcome. We describe a case of bronchial carcinoid treated by bronchoscopic intervention followed by wedge bronchoplasty. The importance of bronchoscopic debulking of the tumor for accurate assessment of its extent has been highlighted. A parenchyma preserving pulmonary resection can then be performed with bronchoplastic technique, thus avoiding pneumonectomy.

Sleeve lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer with N1 nodal disease does not compromise survival

BACKGROUND

We evaluated if sleeve lobectomy had worse survival compared with pneumonectomy for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with N1 disease, which may be a risk factor for locoregional recurrence.

METHODS

Patients who underwent pneumonectomy or sleeve lobectomy without induction treatment for T2-3 N1 M0 NSCLC at a single institution from 1999 to 2011 were reviewed. Survival distribution was estimated with the Kaplan-Meier method, and multivariable Cox proportional hazards regression was used to evaluate the effect of resection extent on survival.

RESULTS

During the study period, 87 patients underwent pneumonectomy (52 [60%]) or sleeve lobectomy (35 [40%]) for T2-3 N1 M0 NSCLC. Pneumonectomy and sleeve lobectomy patients had similar mean ages (60.9 ± 10.7 vs 63.5 ± 12.7 years, p = 0.30), gender distribution (69.2% [36 of 52] vs 60.0% [21 of 35] male, p = 0.37), mean forced expiratory volume in 1 second (66.3 ± 15.9 vs 63.5 ± 17.6, p = 0.47), stage (61.5% [32 of 52] vs 62.9% [22 of 35] stage II, p = 0.90), and tumor grade (51.9% [27 of 52] vs 31.4% [11 of 35] well/moderately differentiated, p = 0.17). Postoperative mortality (3.8% [2 of 52] vs 5.7% [2 of 35], p = 0.68) and median (interquartile range) length of stay (5 [4 to 7] vs 5 [4 to 7] days, p = 0.68) were similar between the two groups. The 3-year survival after pneumonectomy (46.8% [95% CI, 31.8% to 60.4%]) and sleeve lobectomy (65.2% [95% CI, 45.5% to 79.3%]) was not significantly different (p = 0.23). In multivariable survival analysis that included resection extent, age, stage, and grade, only increasing age predicted worse survival (hazard ratio, 1.03/year; p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Performing sleeve lobectomy instead of pneumonectomy for NSCLC with N1 nodal disease does not compromise long-term survival.

Extensive resections: pancoast tumors, chest wall resections, en bloc vascular resections

Infiltration by lung tumor of adjacent anatomic structures including major vessels, main bronchi, and chest wall not only influences the oncologic severity of the disease but also increases the technical complexity of surgery, requiring extended resections and demanding reconstructive procedures. Completeness of resection represents in every case one of the main factors influencing the long-term outcome of patients. Technical and oncologic aspects of extended operations, including resection of Pancoast tumors and chest wall, bronchovascular sleeve resections, and en bloc resections of major thoracic vessels, are reported in this article.

[Isolated bronchial resection for tumor]

Tumors that are confined to specific areas of the airway (e.g. left main stem bronchus or the bronchus intermedius) can be removed with resections of the bronchus only and preservation of the parenchyma. During the period of January 2004 to February 2009 five patients underwent isolated bronchial resection for lung tumor with curative intent. In this study we analyzed the data of five men with a median age of 47.6 years (range 29–68 years). In four cases resection of the intermediate bronchus was performed, and in one case left main bronchus was removed. Intraoperative frozen section revealed negative bronchial resection margins in all cases. Four patients had carcinoid tumors, while one was diagnosed with chemodectoma. Minor postoperative complications were observed in two patients only. Isolated bronchial resection for lung tumor is associated with low morbidity and mortality. Lung sparing procedures are preferable in the above cases but sufficient experience and conditions are mandatory to achieve adequate results.

Sleeve resections for squamous cell carcinoma of the lung

BACKGROUND

Sleeve resection is an advanced technique that was developed as an alternative to pneumonectomy. This study evaluated our cases of sleeve resection for squamous cell carcinoma of the lung and compared the outcomes with the literature reports.

METHODS

In total, 26 bronchial, 5 bronchovascular, and 3 vascular sleeve lobectomies were performed between January 2000 and July 2005 in our clinic. Age, gender, operations, postoperative diagnosis and staging, and postoperative morbidity and mortality were evaluated.

RESULTS

Sleeve resections were performed in 34 patients. All patients were male, with a mean age of 59.4 years. The operations consisted of 16 right upper, 14 left upper, and 1 left lower sleeve lobectomies and 3 superior sleeve bilobectomies. The most common postoperative pathological staging group was stage IIb (32.3%). Operative mortality was 5.9% (n=2). Postoperative morbidity was 20.5% (n=7), including 4 prolonged air leaks plus empyema, 1 prolonged air leak, 1 postoperative bleeding needing revision, and 1 severe bronchostenosis; of these, 6 had persistent atelectasis. The local tumour recurrence rate was 11.7% (n=4). The median survival time and 5-year survival were 36 months and 42%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Sleeve resection proved to be good therapy for lung cancer and has a lower morbidity and mortality than standard pneumonectomies and results in better lung function and quality of life. The anastomosis-related complications are experience-related technical complications and training thoracic surgeons to perform SRs at experienced centres will reduce the morbidity associated with SRs.

Long-term outcome of hybrid surgical approach of video-assisted minithoracotomy sleeve lobectomy for non-small-cell lung cancer

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to evaluate the technical feasibility and safety of a hybrid surgical approach of video-assisted minithoracotomy (hybrid VATS) sleeve lobectomy for non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC), using success rate as the primary end point.

METHODS

Between February 1996 and December 2006, patients with bronchogenic tumors were prospectively registered to undergo hybrid VATS sleeve resection in a single institution. Hybrid VATS involved performing the main procedures via rib spreading and minithoracotomy using a monitor and direct vision. A successful procedure was defined as a patient who had a sleeve lobectomy via hybrid VATS without conversion to thoracotomy and without significant perioperative morbidity or mortality.

RESULTS

A total of 148 patients (108 men and 40 women; median age = 58 years) who underwent hybrid VATS sleeve lobectomy for NSCLC were identified in our database. The median duration of the successfully completed procedures was 190 min (range = 145-305 min). The median length of time of chest tube in place was 3 days (range = 1-12 days). Hybrid VATS sleeve lobectomy was performed successfully in 134 of 148 patients for a success rate of 90.5%. The median follow-up period was 65.1 months (range = 34.5-154.8 months). The overall 5-year disease-free survival and overall survival of all patients were 36.7% (95% CI = 27.9-45.5%) and 54.2% (95% CI = 44.8-63.6%), respectively.

CONCLUSION

Hybrid VATS sleeve lobectomy is feasible for selected patients with NSCLC in specialized centers.

Tracheal carinal reconstruction and bronchovasculoplasty in central type bronchogenic carcinoma

Background and objective

Because radical resection for lung cancer invading the initial borderline of different lobes and carina is difficult, we tried to analyse the variables of successful tracheal carinoplasty and bronchovasculoplasty to discover a proper approach for appropriate early and long term results.

Methods

Of 1 399 lung resections for primary lung cancer performed in our hospital from April 1985 to December 2006, 133 underwent bronchoplastic surgeries, including 15 carinoplasty cases and 118 sleeve lobectomy (SL) cases, and 118 pneumoectomy (PN) cases were compared at the same time.

Results

Complications occurred in 18 cases, with no operative related mortality. For all patients, the 1 year, 3 year, and 5 year survival rates were 79.8%, 56.7% and 31.2%, respectively. The 5 year survival rate by cancer stage was 69.2% for Ⅰb, 40.6% for Ⅱb, 19.6% for Ⅲa, and 16.6% for Ⅲa (N2).

Long-term results of sleeve lobectomy in the management of non-small cell lung carcinoma and low-grade neoplasms

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to evaluate the operative mortality, morbidity, and long-term survival of sleeve lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer and low-grade neoplasms. We evaluated the effects of neoadjuvant therapy on the bronchial anastomotic complication rate and determined whether sleeve lobectomy performed in patients with N1 disease resulted in decreased overall survival.

METHODS

This study is a retrospective review of 196 patients who underwent sleeve lobectomy. One hundred twenty-five patients had non-small cell lung cancer. There were 117 men (59.7%) and 79 women (40.3%) with a mean age of 54 years. Sixteen patients (13%) received neoadjuvant therapy. Fifty-six patients with N1 disease underwent sleeve lobectomy.

RESULTS

There were 4 (2.0%) postoperative deaths. The postoperative morbidity rate was 36.7%. Four patients (2.0%) experienced bronchopleural fistulas. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that age older than 70 years (p = 0.02) and the diagnosis of non-small cell lung cancer (p = 0.0002) were risk factors for postoperative complications. Multivariate analysis also demonstrated that neoadjuvant therapy predicted anastomotic complications (p = 0.01). For non-small cell lung cancer patients, the 5-year survival rate was 44%. The 5-year survival rates for patients with pathologic N0 disease and N1 disease were 52.6% versus 39.3%, respectively (p = 0.205).

CONCLUSIONS

Sleeve lobectomy can be performed with minimal bronchial anastomotic complications and low postoperative mortality. In our study, neoadjuvant therapy for non-small cell lung cancer adversely influenced the rate of anastomotic complications. Performing sleeve lobectomy for patients with N1 disease was not associated with decreased overall survival rates.

Preserving middle lobe to improve lung function in non-small-cell lung cancer

When a lung tumor arises in segment 6, the close anatomical relationship to the middle lobe bronchus may make a lower bilobectomy necessary. Sleeve lobectomy may be an alternative. These procedures were compared retrospectively in 36 patients operated on between January 2005 and December 2006 with non-small-cell lung cancer (stage I-IIIB) of the right lower lobe. Sleeve lobectomy was performed in 21 patients and bilobectomy in 15 (41%). Preoperative lung function was comparable in both groups. Radical resection was achieved in 34/36 patients. Operation time was 121 min for sleeve lobectomy and 144 min for bilobectomy. Chest tubes were removed after 5 days in both groups. Postoperative lung function was better after sleeve lobectomy than bilobectomy (forced expiratory volume in 1st sec: 78% vs. 69%). Preservation of the middle lobe by sleeve lobectomy is feasible. There was no evidence that this resection was less radical, and complication rates were similar in both groups.

Sleeve and wedge parenchyma-sparing bronchial resections in low-grade neoplasms of the bronchial airway

OBJECTIVE

Sleeve and wedge bronchial resections without parenchymal resection may represent a surgical option in selected cases of low-grade neoplasms of the airway. We reviewed our experience analyzing the indications, the operative technique, and the results of such operations.

METHODS

From 1980 to 2006, we performed 248 bronchoplastic procedures, and 26 of those were bronchoplastic procedures without parenchymal resection for low-grade neoplasms of the airway. There were 17 men and 9 women with a mean age of 49.4 years (range 19-74 years). All patients underwent a preoperative bronchoscopic study, which gave indication for such a procedure, and an intraoperative bronchoscopic examination confirming the feasibility and the good quality of the bronchial suture. The bronchial resection involved the trachea and the carina (n = 5), the main bronchi (n = 7), the intermediate bronchus (n = 2), the bronchial corner (n = 6), and the lobar bronchus (n = 6).

RESULTS

The resection margins were always tumor free. There was no operative mortality. The mean hospital stay was 6.7 days (range 4-16 days). One minimal dehiscence and no stenosis of the anastomosis were observed. In 1 case we experienced a granulation that required an endoscopic treatment. The histologic type was carcinoid (n = 18), mucoepidermoid (n = 2), adenoid cystic (n = 1), chondroma (n = 2), hamartoma (n = 1), melanoma endobronchial metastasis (n = 1), and glomic tumor (n = 1). The mean follow-up was 134 months and no local relapse occurred.

CONCLUSION

Bronchoplastic procedures without resection of the lung parenchyma are a suitable and fascinating technique for selected cases of low-grade endobronchial neoplasms.

Comparison of operative mortality and complications between bronchoplastic lobectomy and pneumonectomy in lung cancer patients

Bronchoplastic lobectomy is a lung-saving procedure indicated for central tumors, for which the alternative is pneumonectomy. We compared operative mortality and complications between bronchoplastic lobectomy and pneumonectomy in lung cancer patients. From March 1993 through December 2005, 1,461 patients were surgically resected for non-small cell lung cancer, including 73 who underwent bronchoplastic lobectomy and 258 who underwent pneumonectomy. Bronchoplastic lobectomy was performed on any lesion that could be completely resected by this technique, whereas pneumonectomy was only performed on lesions that could not be removed by bronchoplastic lobectomy. Operative deaths occurred in 1 of 73 (1.4%) bronchoplastic lobectomy and 26 of 258 (10.1%) pneumonectomy patients (p=0.014). Major complications occurred in 16 of 73 (21.9%) bronchoplastic lobectomy and 58 of 258 (22.5%) pneumonectomy patients (p=1.0). Bronchoplastic lobectomy has a lower risk of operative mortality than pneumonectomy. Although the complication rates were similar, bronchoplastic lobectomy was associated with improved postoperative cardiopulmonary status and a low prevalence of fatal complications after bronchial anastomosis. These findings indicate that bronchoplastic lobectomy is a valuable alternative to pneumonectomy for anatomically appropriate patients, regardless of underlying cardiopulmonary function.

Comparison of Morbidity, 30-Day Mortality, and Long-Term Survival After Pneumonectomy and Sleeve Lobectomy For Non–Small Cell Lung Carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The advantage of sleeve lobectomy as an alternative to pneumonectomy for preserving lung function is obvious and among other arguments allows operating on patients with lung cancer who would not tolerate pneumonectomy. The purpose of this retrospective, nonrandomized study is to compare the early (30-day mortality) and late (5-year survival) outcomes of both procedures.

METHODS

The charts of 310 patients who underwent either pneumonectomy or sleeve lobectomy for lung cancer stages I to IIIA from 1987 to 1997 were reviewed. One hundred ninety-four patients underwent pneumonectomy, and 116 patients underwent sleeve lobectomy. Specific operative complications, i.e., anastomotic leakage versus stump dehiscence, perioperative complications, 30-day or in-hospital mortality, and 5-year survival were registered for comparison of the immediate risk of the respective procedures.

RESULTS

In the bronchial sleeve lobectomy group, the incidence of anastomotic leakage was 6.9% (8 of 116 patients) and the operative mortality was 4.3%. The incidence of bronchial stump fistulas after pneumonectomy was 3.6% (7 of 194 patients), and early mortality was 4.6%. All but 6 patients (98%) had a complete resection. Overall 5-year survival after sleeve lobectomy was 39% and after pneumonectomy, 27%. The distribution of 5-year survival stage by stage in either group is presented. Sleeve lobectomy, age younger than 65 years, pN0, and stage I are positive prognostic factors for long-term survival. In the multivariate analysis, pneumonectomy is a negative prognostic factor.

CONCLUSIONS

The indication for pneumonectomy versus sleeve lobectomy depends on the localization of the primary tumor on the one hand, and on cardiorespiratory function, which might be more often distinctly impaired in the sleeve group, on the other hand. This could explain why the mortality in the sleeve lobectomy group was identical with that in the pneumonectomy group. However, both techniques are appropriate treatment modalities of advanced lung cancer or patients with critical functional reserve. Therefore, whenever possible, sleeve lobectomy should be performed.

Sleeve resection after induction therapy

Preoperative chemoradiotherapy seems to improve the overall survival in locally advanced lung cancer but may also expose patients to an increased risk of postoperative complications. In particular, extended procedures, such as pneumonectomy, and especially right pneumonectomy, are associated with increased morbidity and mortality. Therefore, the extent of the procedure should be carefully weighed against the oncologic completeness of the resection. Among the potential sources of complications, special concern is given to bronchial healing, because of the impairment in bronchial blood flow caused by chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Accordingly, bronchial sleeve lobectomy after induction therapy was not widely accepted as an alternative to pneumonectomy, until the current authors showed that even complex bronchial and vascular procedures can be done safely and effectively in this setting. Many controversial issues still exist, and this article provides an updated summary of the different views and experiences.

Sleeve lobectomy versus pneumonectomy for lung cancer: a comparative analysis of survival and sites or recurrences

BACKGROUND

Sleeve lobectomy (SL) in a lung-saving procedure indicated for central tumors for which the alternative is pneumonectomy (PN). Although it has been suggested that it may provide as good if not better survival results than pneumonectomy in the treatment of lung cancer, there are very few reports of clinical series comparing operative mortality, survival, and sites of recurrences between these procedures.

METHODS

Survival and sites of recurrences were analyzed and compared in 1,230 consecutive patients who underwent PN (n = 1,046) or SL (n = 184) in a single institution. Sleeve lobectomy was always done when technically possible. Thus PN was reserved for lesions that could not be removed by a bronchoplastic procedure. Pathologic staging was accomplished by nodal sampling except for N2 and selected N1 patients who underwent mediastinal lymphadenectomy. Ultimately, all patients were staged according to the 1997 TNM nomenclature.

RESULTS

There were 3 operative deaths of the 184 SL patients (operative mortality of 1.6%) and 55 operative deaths of the 1,046 PN patients (operative mortality of 5.3%, p = 0.036). Follow-up was complete for all 1,230 patients. For the entire group, survival at 5 years was 52% after SL and 31% after PN (p < 0.0001). These rates for patients with complete resection were 58% for SL and 33% for PN (p = 0.021). There was also a significant difference in survival favoring SL for patients with pathologic stage I (p = 0.018) and stage II (p = 0.005) disease. When recurrences occurred (n = 577), the site of first recurrence was local in 22% of patients with SL and in 35% of patients with PN.

CONCLUSIONS

Sleeve lobectomy can be done with a much lower risk of operative mortality than PN. Although it is recognized that stage for stage, PN patients likely have more advanced disease, long-term survival and local control are significantly better when complete resection can be achieved by SL.

The natural history of recurrence after bronchoplastic procedures for non-small cell lung cancer

BACKGROUND

The natural course of recurrence after bronchoplastic procedures for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has not been described.

METHODS

Sex, age, tnm-stage, histology, neoadjuvant chemotherapy, disease-free interval (months), exact localisation of tumour recurrence, time between first and second recurrence (months), survival after first and second recurrence (months), causes of death were retrospectively recorded in 83 patients operated between December 1993 and July 2001.

RESULTS

One patient was lost to follow-up, five resections were nonradical. Survivors' follow-up lasted 5 to 100.7 months (mean 43.3). Fourteen patients (14.4%) died tumor free. Eleven (13.2%) distant recurrences were diagnosed 1 to 42 months (mean 10.6) postoperatively, eight (9.6%) died 0 to 17 months (mean 7.55) after diagnosis. Nine local recurrences (10.8%)-5 unifocal, 4 multifocal-occurred 2 to 35 months (mean 17.3) postoperatively, eight died 0 to 8 months (mean 2.13) after diagnosis. Nine mixed recurrences (10.8%)-1 synchronous, 8 metachronous-were found (14.8%) 2 to 21 months postoperatively (mean 8.3). All died 4 to 41 months (mean 17.83) after diagnosis. Fourteen mediastinal lymph node recurrences occurred, ten as a primary recurrence and four as secondary. Lymph nodes were involved in all multifocal recurrences. Intrabronchial recurrence was observed in five patients and was always a result of progressive regional lymph node recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

The pattern and natural history of recurrence cannot be sufficiently explained by stage and surgical radicality and suggest different genetic characteristics of the primary tumor. In case of reoperation due to intrabronchial recurrence adjuvant mediastinal irradiation should be considered.

Personal experience in lung cancer sleeve lobectomy and sleeve pneumonectomy

BACKGROUND

Sleeve lobectomy (SL) and tracheal sleeve pneumonectomy (TSP) represent valuable alternative techniques to standard resections in the treatment of benign and malignant conditions of the airway and allow preservation of lung parenchyma.

METHODS

Eighty-three sleeve lobectomies and 27 tracheal sleeve pneumonectomies have been performed for nonsmall cell lung cancer in the thoracic department of the University of Milan from 1979 to 1999. There were 46 upper right lobectomies, 11 upper and middle lobectomies, 18 upper left lobectomies, 8 lower left lobectomies, and 27 right pneumonectomies.

RESULTS

Mortality rate was 3.6% in SL and 7.4% in TSP. Complications were 10.8% of all SLs and 15% of all TSPs. The overall 5-year survival rate was 43% for SL and 20% for TSP; the 10-year survival rate was 34% and 14%, respectively. There was a highly significant difference in survival between patients with N0 and N1-N2 disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Sleeve lobectomy is an appropriate surgical procedure and an alternative to pneumonectomy in patients with limited respiratory reserve whenever the situation permits. Trachael sleeve pneumonectomy is associated with more complications and poor survival.

Parenchymal sparing operations for bronchogenic carcinoma

By the end of the 1950s, the principles of tracheobronchial and pulmonary artery (PA) reconstruction had been established, and their successful clinical application had taken place. It was not until very recently, however, that these techniques aroused widespread interest among thoracic surgeons as a means to achieve complete cancer resection while preserving functioning lung parenchyma. At the present time, sleeve resection of the bronchus and/or PA has a definite role in the surgical management of lung cancer. Growing interest in this field is evidenced by an increasing number of technical variations intended to adapt the basic technique to the different anatomical settings. Also pitfalls, complications, and their prevention and treatment are being extensively described. Last but not least, functional and oncological long-term results, comparing favorably with those of more extended resections, are being reported by many groups. This demonstrates that sleeve lobectomy is no longer reserved only for particularly skillful surgeons. Sleeve lobectomy has achieved its rightful position among the techniques commonly used in thoracic surgery after 40 years of improving understanding and alternating enthusiasm and legitimate doubts.

Can pneumonectomy for non-small cell lung cancer be avoided? An audit of parenchymal sparing lung surgery

BACKGROUND

Lung cancer resection rates are suboptimal in the UK. Pneumonectomy has a higher perioperative mortality risk than lobectomy. To increase resection rates and improve outcomes we have implemented a policy of parenchymal sparing surgery for tumours involving a main stem bronchus.

METHODS

In a prospective 4 year study of 119 consecutive patients operated upon by a single surgeon the perioperative course, pathology and survival were compared for 81 patients undergoing pneumonectomy and 38 patients in whom pneumonectomy was avoided by bronchoplastic+/-angioplastic procedures.

RESULTS

The rate of pneumonectomy decreased significantly with increasing experience with parenchymal sparing surgery (R(2)=0.98, P<0.001) with 21 of the last 30 patients (70%) avoiding pneumonectomy. There were no significant inter-group differences in patient characteristics, perioperative course or outcome. One-year survival was 64% after pneumonectomy and 73% after sleeve lobectomy. However the perioperative loss of respiratory function was significantly lower in the patients in whom pneumonectomy was avoided (P=0.0003).

CONCLUSIONS

Pneumonectomy can be avoided in a large proportion of patients with non-small cell lung cancer of a main stem bronchus without adversely affecting outcome but with preservation of lung function

Surgery for non-small cell lung cancer--new trends

New trends in lung cancer surgery focus on new approaches to the management of the primary tumour, combined modality approaches to both local and distant control of the tumour, new approaches to ensure resectability by staging and techniques to expand the limits of operability. With new screening methods for NSCLC there is a trend toward sublobar, segmental resections of smaller tumours including an expanding use of video assisted thoracoscopy. Improvements in surgical and anaesthetic procedures have stimulated a renewed interest in the resection of locally advanced tumours. The understanding that local control alone may not give the best chance of long term survival has stimulated new trends in the use of neoadjuvant and adjuvant chemotherapy. There is a trend towards more detailed preoperative and intraoperative nodal staging in NSCLC, including video assisted techniques, and the identification of sentinel lymph node involvement to direct lymph node dissection. Increased understanding of the physiological benefits of surgery in emphysema have resulted in a re-evaluation of the selection of patients for lung cancer surgery. This together with a greater application of bronchoplastic and angioplastic techniques is leading to greater resection rates.

Bronchoplastic procedures in malignant and nonmalignant disease: multivariable analysis of 144 cases

OBJECTIVES

We sought to analyze the experience with bronchoplastic procedures over a 7-year period and to determine putative prognostic factors for survival.

METHODS

From 1991 to 1997, 144 bronchoplastic procedures were performed for non-small cell lung cancer (n = 123), small cell lung cancer (n = 5), carcinoid tumor (n = 10), and metastases of extrathoracic malignant tumors (n = 6). There were 111 sleeve lobectomies, 17 bilobectomies, 4 lobectomies with carinal resection, 8 sleeve pneumonectomies, and 4 bronchotomies without parenchymal resection. Multivariable analysis included risk factors, such as age, sex, type of bronchoplastic procedure (bronchotomy, lobectomy, bilobectomy, or pneumonectomy), additional angioplasty, TNM staging, histology, radicality of resection, respiratory risk (forced expiratory volume in 1 second, percent predicted < 60), cardiovascular risk, and adjuvant therapy.

RESULTS

Overall 1- and 3-year survival was 72% and 52%, respectively. The overall 30-day mortality was 8.3% (5.4% for single sleeve lobectomies). Multivariable analysis demonstrated 4 risk factors for survival. High tumor stage, type of bronchoplastic procedure, impaired lung function, and presence of cardiovascular risk were associated with a poor outcome. Univariate analysis showed reduced survival in patients with sleeve pneumonectomies (1-year survival, 25%).

CONCLUSIONS

Bronchoplastic procedures for central tumors and sleeve pneumonectomies are associated with poor survival. Careful selection of these patients, as well as of patients with impaired lung function and cardiovascular risk factors, is mandatory.

Long-term results of sleeve lobectomy for lung cancer

OBJECTIVE

Sleeve lobectomy is a lung saving procedure indicated for central tumors for which the alternative is a pneumonectomy. Current controversies relate to the safety of the procedure and adequacy as a cancer operation. The aim of the study is to analyze long-term survival after sleeve lobectomy, particularly in relation with nodal status and histological type. The incidence and patterns of recurrences were reviewed.

METHODS

From 1972 to 1998, 184 patients (male 152, female 32) underwent sleeve resection for lung cancer. The mean age was 60+/-10 years (11-78 years), and the indications for operation were a central tumor (79%), peripheral tumor with nodal involvement (13%) and compromised pulmonary function (8%). The histological type was predominantly squamous (n=125, 68%), followed by non-squamous (n=50, 27%) and carcinoid tumors (n=9, 5%). Resection was complete in 161 patients (87%).

RESULTS

The operative mortality was 1.6% (n=3). Follow-up was complete for the remaining 181 patients (mean, 5.7 years; range, 1 month-26 years). The survival at 5 and 10 years of all patients was 52 and 33%, respectively. Theses rates for patients with N0 status (n=97) were 63 and 48%, and 48 and 27% for those with N1 status (n=68; N0 vs. N1, P<0.05). An 8% survival rate was observed with N2 status (n=19) at 5 years, with no survivors after 7 years of follow-up. The 5 and 10 year survival was 56 and 34% for squamous carcinoma vs. 33 and 22% for non-squamous carcinoma (P<0.05). These rates were 58 and 38% for complete resection vs. 11 and 6% for incomplete resection at 5 and 10 years, respectively (P<0.05). Local recurrences occurred in 22% of cases, and the prevalence was statistically different between patients with N0 disease (14%) and N1 disease (23%; P=0.03), but not between N1 and N2 disease (42%; P=0.2). When local and distant recurrence were pooled together, the differences were highly significant between N0 (22%) and N1 (41%) disease (P=0.007), and between N0 and N2 (63%) disease (P=0.0002), but not between N1 and N2 disease (P=0.09).

CONCLUSION

Sleeve lobectomy is a safe and effective therapy for patients with resectable lung cancer. The presence of N1 and N2 disease, or of non-squamous carcinoma significantly worsen the prognosis.

Survival related to lymph node involvement in lung cancer after sleeve lobectomy compared with pneumonectomy

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to compare the outcomes after sleeve lobectomy and pneumonectomy for patients with non-small cell lung cancer distributed according to their nodal involvement status.

METHODS

Of 1172 patients in whom primary non-small cell lung carcinoma, including mediastinal lymph nodes, was completely excised, 151 patients underwent sleeve lobectomy and 60 underwent pneumonectomy. For bias reduction in comparison with a nonrandomized control group, we paired 60 patients undergoing sleeve lobectomy with 60 patients undergoing pneumonectomy by using the nearest available matching method.

RESULTS

The 30-day postoperative mortality was 2% (1/60) in the pneumonectomy group and 0% in the sleeve lobectomy group. Postoperative complications occurred in 13% of patients in the sleeve lobectomy group and in 22% of those in the pneumonectomy group. Local recurrences occurred in 8% of patients in the sleeve lobectomy group and in 10% of those in the pneumonectomy group. The overall 5- and 10-year survivals for the sleeve lobectomy group were 48% and 36%, respectively, whereas those for the pneumonectomy group were 28% and 19%, respectively (P =.005). Multivariable analysis showed that the operative procedure, T factor, and N factor were significant independent prognostic factors and revealed that survival after sleeve lobectomy was significantly longer than that after pneumonectomy (P =.03).

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that sleeve lobectomy should be performed instead of pneumonectomy in patients with non-small cell lung cancer regardless of their nodal status whenever complete resection can be achieved because this is a lung-saving procedure with lower postoperative risks and is as curative as pneumonectomy.

Lung conservation techniques: bronchial sleeve resection and reconstruction of the pulmonary artery

Bronchial and vascular reconstructive procedures are a technically feasible alternative to pneumonectomy and have the advantage of sparing functioning lung parenchyma. Between 1989 and 1999, we performed bronchovascular sleeve resection and reconstruction in 145 patients (109 men, 36 women; age range, 26 to 76 years, mean, 56 years) with non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLCL). Forty-one patients had induction chemotherapy and 3 had pre-operative radiotherapy. Immediate and long-term postoperative evaluation included bronchoscopy, spirometry, electrocardiogram, Doppler echocardiography, and perfusion lung scans, computed tomography and, only recently, angio-magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Follow-up ranged between 3 months and 10 years (mean, 3.7 years) and is complete for all patients. We report the results of this series and conclude that morbidity, mortality, and functional data indicate that bronchovascular reconstructions are equal to standard lobectomy in terms of pulmonary function. Long-term survival is comparable with that reported for standard resection (lobectomy-pneumonectomy). These findings suggest that even complex lung-sparing operations can be proposed as adequate procedures in the treatment of lung cancer as long as a complete anatomical resection is obtained.

Sleeve resection and prosthetic reconstruction of the pulmonary artery for lung cancer

BACKGROUND

Lobectomy associated with reconstruction of the pulmonary artery (PA) is a technically feasible alternative to pneumonectomy in patients with lung cancer. However, concern about postoperative complications and long-term survival limited its acceptance so far.

METHODS

Between 1989 and 1996, we performed a PA reconstruction in 52 patients (41 men, 11 women; age range 35 to 75 years, mean 60 years) with lung cancer. Eleven patients had induction chemotherapy. We performed 15 PA sleeve resections, 34 PA reconstructions by a pericardial patch, and three PA reconstructions by a pericardial conduit, associated with a bronchial sleeve lobectomy or bilobectomy (33), or with standard lobectomy (19). Immediate and long-term postoperative evaluation included spirometry, echocardiography, perfusion lung scans, computed tomography, and PA angiography. The follow-up ranged between 27 and 96 months and is complete for all patients.

RESULTS

We had one specific postoperative complication (PA thrombosis) and no mortality. Perfusion scans and PA angiography were normal in all but the 1 patient having thrombosis. Mean forced expiratory volume (FEV) in 1 s and forced vital capacity (FVC) were, respectively, 72% and 80% preoperatively, 65% and 76% 1 month after surgery, and then they plateaued at 70% and 78% after 6 months. Echocardiography showed patterns in the normal range and normal estimates of PA pressures in all but 2 patients. Five-year survival was 38.3% for the entire group, 18.6% for stages IIIA and B, and 64.4% for stages I and II.

CONCLUSIONS

Morbidity, mortality, and functional data do not differ from what is currently reported for standard lobectomy. Long-term survival is in line with that reported for standard resection. These data support PA reconstruction as a viable option in the treatment of lung cancer.

Survival and prognostic factors in patients undergoing parenchymal saving bronchoplastic operation for primary lung cancer: a series of 110 consecutive cases

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to report our experience concerning bronchial sleeve lobectomy for treating bronchogenic cancer.

METHOD

From 1980 to 1994, 110 patients underwent bronchial sleeve lobectomy for bronchogenic cancer. In 45 patients, preoperative investigations contraindicated pneumonectomy, whereas in 65 other patients, sleeve resection was performed without functional necessity. The most common procedures were sleeve lobectomy of the right upper lobe (64%), and of the left upper lobe (21%). Sixteen patients (15%) underwent additional arterial vascular resection. Seven patients had microscopic invasion of the bronchial margin without the possibility of further resection in six with regard to their limited respiratory function. Tumors were staged as follow: 32 stage IB (all T2 N0), 57 stage IIB (57T2 N1), and 17 stage IIIA (eight, T3N1; nine, T2N2), whereas four patients had an in situ cancer (four stage 0).

RESULTS

Operative mortality was 2.75%. The 5- and 10-year actuarial survival rates were, respectively, 39 and 22% for the entire group. The 5-year actuarial survival rates were, 60% in stage IB, 30% in stage IIB, and 27% in stage IIIA. Four factors significantly influenced survival (P<0.05): nodal stage, arterial resection, invasion of the bronchial stump and poor functional respiratory status contraindicating pneumonectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

In our experience, sleeve resection for stage I provides comparable survival to that of standard resection at equal stage. However, in patients with pathologically N1 disease, who can tolerate a pneumonectomy, a randomized study is mandatory to confirm that sleeve lobectomy can be performed without the risk of decreasing long-term survival. In our study, patients who required an associated vascular resection demonstrated a poor survival.

Surgical results of 40 patients with malignant tracheobronchial lesions

The objective of this study was to evaluate the results of tracheobronchoplastyperformed on a variety of malignant diseases which involved the tracheobronchus. Between July 1988 and March 1996 tracheobronchial surgery was performed on 40 patients who had a variety of malignant diseases. The primary diseases were bronchogenic carcinoma (n=26), tracheobronchial tumour (n=5), thyroid cancer (n=6), and oesophageal cancer (n=3). Operative procedures that were performed on the tracheobronchus were sleeve lobectomy (n=22) or bilobectomies (n=5), sleeve pneumonectomy (n=3), sleeve resection of trachea (n=7) and bronchus (n=3). There was one postoperative death with a mortality rate of 2.5%. However, there were no significant postoperative complications apart from the one postoperative death; one patient developed a bronchopleural fistula and empyema. In lung cancer patients, the 2 year survival rate was 47.3%, and one (3.8%) local tumour recurrence. Four of five patients who had tracheobronchial tumours were alive and free from disease during 2-6 year follow-up period. One patient who had malignant fibrous histiocytoma died of brain metastasis 6 months after the operation. Among six patients whose thyroid cancer involved the trachea, one patient survived for 7 years, the other five patients were still alive and free from disease 2-5 years after the operation. Of the three patients whose oesophageal carcinoma involved the tracheobronchus, there was one operative death and the others died of tumour recurrence 1 and 2 years, respectively. We suggest that tracheobronchoplasty is a safe procedure with low morbidity and mortality rates in carefully selected patients with malignant diseases.