Monoterpene biosynthesis: mechanistic evaluation of the geranyl pyrophosphate:(-)-endo-fenchol cyclase from fennel (Foeniculum vulgare)

Chemical diversity in angiosperms - monoterpene synthases control complex reactions that provide the precursors for ecologically and commercially important monoterpenoids

Monoterpene synthases (MTSs) catalyze the first committed step in the biosynthesis of monoterpenoids, a class of specialized metabolites with particularly high chemical diversity in angiosperms. In addition to accomplishing a rate enhancement, these enzymes manage the formation and turnover of highly reactive carbocation intermediates formed from a prenyl diphosphate substrate. At each step along the reaction path, a cationic intermediate can be subject to cyclization, migration of a proton, hydride, or alkyl group, or quenching to terminate the sequence. However, enzymatic control of ligand folding, stabilization of specific intermediates, and defined quenching chemistry can maintain the specificity for forming a signature product. This review article will discuss our current understanding of how angiosperm MTSs control the reaction environment. Such knowledge allows inferences about the origin and regulation of chemical diversity, which is pertinent for appreciating the role of monoterpenoids in plant ecology but also for aiding commercial efforts that harness the accumulation of these specialized metabolites for the food, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical industries.

Experiment and Simulation Reveal How Mutations in Functional Plasticity Regions Guide Plant Monoterpene Synthase Product Outcome

Monoterpenes (C10 isoprenoids) are a structurally diverse group of natural compounds that are attractive to industry as flavours and fragrances. Monoterpenes are produced from a single linear substrate, geranyl diphosphate, by a group of enzymes called the monoterpene cyclases/synthases (mTC/Ss) that catalyse high-energy cyclisation reactions involving unstable carbocation intermediates. Efforts towards producing monoterpenes via biocatalysis or metabolic engineering often result in the formation of multiple products due to the nature of the highly branched reaction mechanism of mTC/Ss. Rational engineering of mTC/Ss is hampered by the lack of correlation between the active site sequence and cyclisation type. We used available mutagenesis data to show that amino acids involved in product outcome are clustered and spatially conserved within the mTC/S family. Consensus sequences for three such plasticity regions were introduced in different mTC/S with increasingly complex cyclisation cascades, including the model enzyme limonene synthase (LimS). In all three mTC/S studied, mutations in the first two regions mostly give rise to products that result from premature quenching of the linalyl or α-terpinyl cations, suggesting that both plasticity regions are involved in the formation and stabilisation of cations early in the reaction cascade. A LimS variant with mutations in the second region (S454G, C457V, M458I), produced mainly more complex bicyclic products. QM/MM MD simulations reveal that the second cyclisation is not due to compression of the C2-C7 distance in the α-terpinyl cation, but is the result of an increased distance between C8 of the α-terpinyl cation and two putative bases (W324, H579) located on the other side of the active site, preventing early termination by deprotonation. Such insights into the impact of mutations can only be obtained using integrated experimental and computational approaches, and will aid the design of altered mTC/S activities towards clean monoterpenoid products.

Monoterpenoid accumulation in Melaleuca alternifolia seedlings

Individual leaves of the commercial terpinen-4-ol type of Melaleuca alternifolia were examined both quantitatively and qualitatively for volatile constituents from the emergence of the first true leaves, through to 6-week-old tenth leaf set material. A GC internal standard addition method was used to measure changes in oil composition and the accumulation of volatile constituents expressed on a dry weight, unit leaf area and whole leaf basis. In the early stages of seedling growth, leaves contained higher concentrations of terpinolene, alpha-pinene and beta-pinene and lower concentrations of terpinen-4-ol, sabinene and cis-sabinene hydrate than mature leaf. Concentrations of the former constituents fell and the latter rose by the time leaf set 10 was 6 weeks old. Key constituent, 1,8-cineole remained in similar concentration throughout ontogeny. The variation in concentration of other key constituents during early stages of seedling development suggests that caution is required in extrapolating seedling leaf data to mature tree oil quality.

Prospects for the bioengineering of isoprenoid biosynthesis

Over the last decade, our understanding of isoprenoid biosynthesis has progressed to the stage where specific strategies for the bioengineering of essential oil production can be considered. This review provides a current overview of the enzymology and regulation of essential oil isoprenoid biosynthesis. The reaction mechanisms of the synthases which produce many of the basic isoprenoid skeletons are described in detail. Coverage is also provided of the regulation of isoprenoid biosynthesis, including the roles played by tissue and subcellular compartmentation, and by partitioning of intermediates between different branches of isoprenoid metabolism. This provides necessary context for rationally targeting specific enzymes of metabolic pathways for bioengineering essential oil production. Wherever possible, emphasis is placed on research specific to essential oil isoprenoid biosynthesis, although relevant work related to other isoprenoids is also considered when it can provide useful insights. Finally, building upon this understanding of essential oil isoprenoid biosynthesis, several approaches to the bioengineering of isoprenoid metabolism are considered.

Monoterpene synthases from gymnosperms and angiosperms: stereospecificity and inactivation by cysteinyl- and arginyl-directed modifying reagents

To further define specific structural and mechanistic differences among monoterpene synthases from divergent plant sources, the stereospecificity of the enzyme-catalyzed isomerization of geranyl pyrophosphate to linalyl pyrophosphate and the subsequent cyclization to monoterpene olefins (which have been well established for monoterpene synthases from herbaceous angiosperms) were examined for monoterpene synthases from a conifer, lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta). The chiral monoterpenes isolated from lodgepole pine oleoresin and the major chiral products from cell-free assays of each of the four lodgepole pine monoterpene synthases belonged to the stereochemical family related by the biosynthetic intermediacy of 3S-linalyl pyrophosphate. Furthermore, both the putative intermediate, 3S-linalyl pyrophosphate, and the natural substrate, geranyl pyrophosphate, were enzymatically converted to the same monoterpene enantiomers. Thus, like monoterpene synthases from herbaceous angiosperms, monoterpene synthases from lodgepole pine appear to catalyze both the stereospecific isomerization of geranyl pyrophosphate to linalyl pyrophosphate and the subsequent cyclization of this enzyme-bound intermediate to multiple, stereochemically related monoterpene olefin isomers. The susceptibility of monoterpene synthases to inactivation by cysteinyl- and arginyl-directed chemical modification reagents was also examined to identify specific structural differences between enzymes from conifers and angiosperms. Like monoterpene synthases from peppermint (Mentha x piperita) and culinary sage (Salvia officinalis), monoterpene synthases from lodgepole pine were inactivated by thiol-directed reagents; however, unlike monoterpene synthases from these herbaceous angiosperms, monoterpene synthases from lodgepole pine were not protected against inactivation by coincubation with substrate and metal ion cofactor. Lodgepole pine monoterpene synthases were also inactivated by the arginyl-directed reagent phenylglyoxal, and coincubation with substrate and cofactor, to effect active-site protection, reduced the rate of inactivation 10-fold. (+)-Pinene synthase and (-)-pinene synthase from sage were also inactivated by phenylglyoxal, but no protection was afforded by coincubation with substrate and cofactor. Thus, monoterpene synthases of conifers appear to have catalytically important arginyl residues specifically located at or near the active site and have at least some catalytically important thiol residues at a non-substrate-protectable region of the enzyme, in contrast to monoterpene synthases from angiosperms which appear to have catalytically important cysteinyl residues at the active site and have catalytically important arginyl residues located at a non-substrate-protectable region of the enzyme.

Biosynthesis of monoterpenes: inhibition of (+)-pinene and (-)-pinene cyclases by thia and aza analogs of the 4R- and 4S-alpha-terpinyl carbocation

(+)-Pinene cyclase (synthase) from Salvia officinalis leaf catalyzes the cyclization of geranyl pyrophosphate, via (3R)-linalyl pyrophosphate and the (4R)-alpha-terpinyl cation, to (+)-alpha-pinene and to lesser quantities of stereochemically related monoterpene olefins, whereas (-)-pinene cyclase converts the same achiral precursor, via (3S)-linalyl pyrophosphate and the (4S)-alpha-terpinyl cation, to (-)-alpha-pinene and (-)-beta-pinene and to lesser amounts of related olefins. Racemic thia analogs of the linalyl and alpha-terpinyl carbocation intermediates of the reaction sequence were previously shown to be good uncompetitive inhibitors of monoterpene cyclases, and inhibition was synergized by the presence of inorganic pyrophosphate. These results suggested that the normal reaction proceeds through a series of carbocation:pyrophosphate anion paired intermediates. Both the (4R)- and the (4S)-thia and -aza analogs of the alpha-terpinyl cation were prepared and tested as inhibitors with the antipodal pinene cyclases, both in the absence and in the presence of inorganic pyrophosphate. Although the inhibition kinetics were complex, cooperative binding of the analogs and inorganic pyrophosphate was demonstrated, consistent with ion pairing of intermediates in the course of the normal reaction. Based on the antipodal reactions catalyzed by the pinene cyclases, stereochemical differentiation between the (4R)- and the (4S)-analogs was anticipated; however, neither enzyme effectively distinguished between enantiomers of the thia and aza analogs of the alpha-terpinyl carbocation. Enantioselectivity in the enzymatic conversion of (RS)-alpha-terpinyl pyrophosphate to limonene by the pinene cyclases was also examined. Consistent with the results obtained with the thia and aza analogs, the pinene cyclases were unable to discriminate between enantiomers of alpha-terpinyl pyrophosphate in this unusual reaction. Either the alpha-terpinyl antipodes are too similar to allow differentiation by the pinene cyclases, or these enzymes lack an inherent requirement to distinguish the (4R)- and (4S)-forms because they encounter only one enantiomer in the course of the normal reaction from geranyl pyrophosphate.

Evidence for an essential histidine residue in 4S-limonene synthase and other terpene cyclases

(4S)-Limonene synthase, isolated from glandular trichome secretory cell preparations of Mentha x piperita (peppermint) leaves, catalyzes the metal ion-dependent cyclization of geranyl pyrophosphate, via 3S-linalyl pyrophosphate, to (-)-(4S)-limonene as the principal product. Treatment of this terpene cyclase with the histidine-directed reagent diethyl pyrocarbonate at a concentration of 0.25 mM resulted in 50% loss of enzyme activity, and this activity could be completely restored by treatment of the preparation with 5 mM hydroxylamine. Inhibition with diethyl pyrocarbonate was distinguished from inhibition with thiol-directed reagents by protection studies with histidine and cysteine carried out at varying pH. Inactivation of the cyclase by dye-sensitized photooxidation in the presence of rose bengal gave further indication of the presence of a readily modified histidine residue. Protection of the enzyme against inhibition with diethyl pyrocarbonate was afforded by the substrate geranyl pyrophosphate in the presence of Mn2+, and by the sulfonium ion analog of the linalyl carbocation intermediate of the reaction in the presence of inorganic pyrophosphate plus Mn2+, suggesting that an essential histidine residue is located at or near the active site. Similar studies on the inhibition of other monoterpene and sesquiterpene cyclases with diethyl pyrocarbonate suggest that a histidine residue (or residues) may play an important role in catalysis by this class of enzymes.

Characterization and mechanism of (4S)-limonene synthase, a monoterpene cyclase from the glandular trichomes of peppermint (Mentha x piperita)

(4S)-Limonene synthase, a monoterpene cyclase isolated from the secretory cells of the glandular trichomes of Mentha x piperita (peppermint), catalyzes the cyclization of geranyl pyrophosphate to (4S)-limonene, a key intermediate in the biosynthesis of p-menthane monoterpenes in Mentha species. The enzyme synthesizes principally (-)-(4S)-limonene (greater than 94% of the total products), plus several other monoterpene olefins. The general properties of (4S)-limonene synthase resemble those of other monoterpene cyclases. The enzyme shows a pH optimum near 6.7, an isoelectric point of 4.35, and requires a divalent metal ion for catalysis, either Mg2+ or Mn2+, with Mn2+ preferred. The Km value measured for geranyl pyrophosphate was 1.8 microM. The activity of (4S)-limonene synthase was inhibited by sodium phosphate, sodium pyrophosphate, and reagents directed against the amino acids cysteine, methionine, and histidine. In the presence of Mn2+, geranyl pyrophosphate protected against cysteine-directed inhibition, suggesting that at least one cysteine residue is located at or near the active site. Experiments with alternate substrates and substrate analogs confirmed many elements of the proposed reaction mechanism, including the binding of geranyl pyrophosphate in the form of a complex with the divalent metal ion, the preliminary isomerization of geranyl pyrophosphate to linalyl pyrophosphate (a bound intermediate capable of cyclization), and the participation of a series of carbocation:pyrophosphate anion pairs in the reaction sequence.

Uncompetitive inhibition of monoterpene cyclases by an analog of the substrate geranyl pyrophosphate and inhibition of monoterpene biosynthesis in vivo by an analog of geraniol

Monoterpene cyclases catalyze the divalent metal ion-dependent conversion of the acyclic precursor geranyl pyrophosphate to a variety of monocyclic and bicyclic monoterpene skeletons. Examination of the kinetics of inhibition of cyclization by the pyrophosphate ester of (E)-4-[2-diazo-3-trifluoropropionyloxy]-3-methyl-2-buten-1-o l, a photolabile structural analog of the substrate, using a partially purified preparation of geranyl pyrophosphate:(+)-pinene cyclase and geranyl pyrophosphate:(+)-bornyl pyrophosphate cyclase from common sage (Salvia officinalis) evidenced (under dark conditions) strictly uncompetitive inhibition with K'i values of 3.2 and 4.7 microM, respectively. These values are close to the corresponding Km values for the substrate with these two enzymes. This novel property of the substrate analog was also examined in the presence of two other inhibitors which bind to different domains of the cyclase active site (inorganic pyrophosphate and a sulfonium ion analog of a cyclic carbocationic intermediate of the reaction sequence (dimethyl-(4-methylcyclohex-3-en-1-yl)sulfonium iodide)) in order to address the mechanistic origins of the uncompetitive inhibition of cyclization. It was not possible, however, to rule out either an induced-fit mechanism or a sequential binding mechanism since the substrate is recognized by at least two binding domains and because direct examination of the effects of binding on cyclase conformation is currently not feasible. The substrate analog, although photoactive, did not give rise to light-dependent enzyme inactivation of greater magnitude than that obtained from ultraviolet light alone. The unusual behavior of the analog was attributed to intramolecular interaction of the electron-rich carbonyl group of the diazoester with the required divalent metal ion that is chelated by the pyrophosphate group. A photostable analog of geraniol that resembled the photoactive substrate analog in bearing a carbonyl function at C6 (6-oxo-3,7-dimethyloct-2(trans)en-1-ol) was prepared. Following foliar application to rapidly growing sage plants, this analog was seemingly activated to the corresponding pyrophosphate ester in vivo and selectively inhibited the activity of several cyclases in this tissue as evidenced by diminished production of the corresponding monoterpene end products.

Biosynthesis of monoterpenes: stereochemistry of the coupled isomerization and cyclization of geranyl pyrophosphate to camphane and isocamphane monoterpenes

The conversion of geranyl pyrophosphate to (+)-bornyl pyrophosphate and (+)-camphene is considered to proceed by the initial isomerization of the substrate to (-)-(3R)-linalyl pyrophosphate and the subsequent cyclization of this bound intermediate. In the case of (-)-bornyl pyrophosphate and (-)-camphene, isomerization of the substrate to the (+)-(3S)-linalyl intermediate precedes cyclization. The geranyl and linalyl precursors were shown to be mutually competitive substrates (inhibitors) of the relevant cyclization enzymes isolated from Salvia officinalis (sage) and Tanacetum vulgare (tansy) by the mixed substrate analysis method, demonstrating that isomerization and cyclization take place at the same active site. Incubation of partially purified enzyme preparations with (3R)-[1Z-3H]linalyl pyrophosphate plus [1-14C]geranyl pyrophosphate gave rise to double-labeled (+)-bornyl pyrophosphate and (+)-camphene, whereas incubation of enzyme preparations catalyzing the antipodal cyclizations with (3S)-[1Z-3H]-linalyl pyrophosphate plus [1-14C]geranyl pyrophosphate yielded double-labeled (-)-bornyl pyrophosphate and (-)-camphene. Each product was then transformed to the corresponding (+)- or (-)-camphor without change in the 3H:14C isotope ratio, and the location of the tritium label was deduced in each case by stereoselective, base-catalyzed exchange of the exo-alpha-hydrogen of the derived ketone. The finding that the 1Z-3H of the linalyl precursor was positioned at the endo-alpha-hydrogen of the corresponding camphor in all cases, coupled to the previously demonstrated retention of configuration at C1 of the geranyl substrate in these transformations, confirmed the syn-isomerization of geranyl pyrophosphate to linalyl pyrophosphate and the cyclization of the latter via the anti,endo- conformer. These relative stereochemical elements, in combination with the observed enantiospecificities of the enzymes for the linalyl intermediates, allows definition of the overall absolute stereochemistry of the coupled isomerization and cyclization of geranyl pyrophosphate to the antipodal camphane (bornane) and isocamphane monoterpenoids.