Thermodynamic and kinetic studies on the association of melittin with a phospholipid bilayer

Applications and evolution of melittin, the quintessential membrane active peptide

Melittin, the main venom component of the European Honeybee, is a cationic linear peptide-amide of 26 amino acid residues with the sequence: GIGAVLKVLTTGLPALISWIKRKRQQ-NH₂. Melittin binds to lipid bilayer membranes, folds into amphipathic α-helical secondary structure and disrupts the permeability barrier. Since melittin was first described, a remarkable array of activities and potential applications in biology and medicine have been described. Melittin is also a favorite model system for biophysicists to study the structure, folding and function of peptides and proteins in membranes. Melittin has also been used as a template for the evolution of new activities in membranes. Here we overview the rich history of scientific research into the many activities of melittin and outline exciting future applications.

Exchange of Gramicidin between Lipid Bilayers: Implications for the Mechanism of Channel Formation

The canonical mechanism of gramicidin (gA) channel formation is transmembrane dimerization of nonconducting subunits that reside in opposite bilayer leaflets. The channels do not open and close; they appear and disappear due to subunit association and dissociation. Many different types of experiments support this monomer ↔ dimer mechanism. Recently, however, this mechanism was challenged, based on experiments with lipid vesicle-incorporated gA under conditions where vesicle fusion could be controlled. In these experiments, sustained channel activity was observed long after fusion had been terminated, which led to the proposal that gA single-channel current transitions result from closed-open transitions in long-lived bilayer-spanning dimers. This proposal is at odds with 40 years of experiments, but involves the key assumption that gA monomers do not exchange between bilayers. We tested the possibility of peptide exchange between bilayers using three different types of experiments. First, we demonstrated the exchange of gA between 1,2-dierucoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DC_22:1PC) or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DC_18:1PC) lipid vesicles using a fluorescence assay for gA channel activity. Second, we added gA-free DC_22:1PC vesicles to both sides of planar DC_18:1PC bilayers preincubated with gA, which reduced channel activity up to 10-fold. Third, we added gA-containing DC_22:1PC vesicles to one or both sides of DC_18:1PC planar bilayers, which produced much higher channel activity when the gA-containing vesicles were added to both sides of the bilayer, as compared to one side only. All three types of experiments show that gA subunits can exchange between lipid bilayers. The exchange of subunits between bilayers thus is firmly established, which becomes a crucial consideration with respect to the mechanism of channel formation.

Transmembrane oligomeric intermediates of pore forming toxin Cytolysin A determine leakage kinetics

Leakage kinetics of Cytolysin A, an α pore forming toxin, occurs through stochastic insertion of oligomeric intermediates or ‘arcs’.

Simultaneous Analysis of Secondary Structure and Light Scattering from Circular Dichroism Titrations: Application to Vectofusin-1

Circular Dichroism data are often decomposed into their constituent spectra to quantify the secondary structure of peptides or proteins but the estimation of the secondary structure content fails when light scattering leads to spectral distortion. If peptide-induced liposome self-association occurs, subtracting control curves cannot correct for this. We show that if the cause of the light scattering is independent from the peptide structural changes, the CD spectra can be corrected using principal component analysis (PCA). The light scattering itself is analysed and found to be in good agreement with backscattering experiments. This method therefore allows to simultaneously follow structural changes related to peptide-liposome binding as well as peptide induced liposome self-association. We apply this method to study the structural changes and liposome binding of vectofusin-1, a transduction enhancing peptide used in lentivirus based gene therapy. Vectofusin-1 binds to POPC/POPS liposomes, causing a reversal of the negative liposome charge at high peptide concentrations. When the peptide charges exactly neutralise the lipid charges on both leaflets reversible liposome self-association occurs. These results are in good agreement with biological observations and provide further insight into the conditions required for efficent transduction enhancement.

Ionizable Nitroxides for Studying Local Electrostatic Properties of Lipid Bilayers and Protein Systems by EPR

Electrostatic interactions are known to play a major role in the myriad of biochemical and biophysical processes. Here, we describe biophysical methods to probe local electrostatic potentials of proteins and lipid bilayer systems that are based on an observation of reversible protonation of nitroxides by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR). Two types of probes are described: (1) methanethiosulfonate derivatives of protonatable nitroxides for highly specific covalent modification of the cysteine's sulfhydryl groups and (2) spin-labeled phospholipids with a protonatable nitroxide tethered to the polar head group. The probes of both types report on their ionization state through changes in magnetic parameters and degree of rotational averaging, thus, allowing the electrostatic contribution to the interfacial pKa of the nitroxide, and, therefore, the local electrostatic potential to be determined. Due to their small molecular volume, these probes cause a minimal perturbation to the protein or lipid system. Covalent attachment secures the position of the reporter nitroxides. Experimental procedures to characterize and calibrate these probes by EPR, and also the methods to analyze the EPR spectra by simulations are outlined. The ionizable nitroxide labels and the nitroxide-labeled phospholipids described so far cover an exceptionally wide range of ca. 2.5-7.0 pH units, making them suitable to study a broad range of biophysical phenomena, especially at the negatively charged lipid bilayer surfaces. The rationale for selecting proper electrostatically neutral interface for probe calibration, and examples of lipid bilayer surface potential studies, are also described.

Direct observation of nanometer-scale pores of melittin in supported lipid monolayers

Melittin is the most studied membrane-active peptide and archetype within a large and diverse group of pore formers. However, the molecular characteristics of melittin pores remain largely unknown. Herein, we show by atomic force microscopy (AFM) that lipid monolayers in the presence of melittin are decorated with numerous regularly shaped circular pores that can be distinguished from nonspecific monolayer defects. The specificity of these pores is reinforced through a statistical evaluation of depressions found in Langmuir-Blodgett monolayers in the presence and absence of melittin, which eventually allows characterization of the melittin-induced pores at a quantitative low-resolution level. We observed that the large majority of pores exhibit near-circular symmetry and a Gaussian distribution in size, with a mean diameter of ∼8.7 nm. A distinctive feature is a ring of material found around the pores, made by, on average, three positive peaks, with a height over the level of the lipidic background of ∼0.23 nm. This protruding rim is most likely due to the presence of melittin near the pore border. Although the current resolution of the AFM images in the {x, y} plane does not allow distinction of the specific organization of the peptide molecules, these results provide an unprecedented view of melittin pores formed in lipidic interfaces and open new perspectives for future structural investigations of these and other pore-forming peptides and proteins using supported monolayers.

Structural and thermodynamic properties of water-membrane interphases: significance for peptide/membrane interactions

Water appears as a common intermediary in the mechanisms of interaction of proteins and polypeptides with membranes of different lipid composition. In this review, how water modulates the interaction of peptides and proteins with lipid membranes is discussed by correlating the thermodynamic response and the structural changes of water at the membrane interphases. The thermodynamic properties of the lipid-protein interaction are governed by changes in the water activity of monolayers of different lipid composition according to the lateral surface pressure. In this context, different water populations can be characterized below and above the phase transition temperature in relation to the CH₂ conformers' states in the acyl chains. According to water species present at the interphase, lipid membrane acts as a water state regulator, which determines the interfacial water domains in the surface. It is proposed that those domains are formed by the contact between lipids themselves and between lipids and the water phase, which are needed to trigger adsorption-insertion processes. The water domains are essential to maintain functional dynamical properties and are formed by water beyond the hydration shell of the lipid head groups. These confined water domains probably carries information in local units in relation to the lipid composition thus accounting for the link between lipidomics and aquaomics. The analysis of these results contributes to a new insight of the lipid bilayer as a non-autonomous, responsive (reactive) structure that correlates with the dynamical properties of a living system.

The electrical response of bilayers to the bee venom toxin melittin: evidence for transient bilayer permeabilization

Melittin is a 26-residue bee venom peptide that folds into amphipathic α-helix and causes membrane permeabilization via a mechanism that is still disputed. While an equilibrium transmembrane pore model has been a central part of the mechanistic dialogue for decades, there is growing evidence that a transmembrane pore is not required for melittin's activity. In part, the controversy is due to limited experimental tools to probe the bilayer's response to melittin. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a technique that can reveal details of molecular mechanism of peptide activity, as it yields direct, real-time measurements of membrane resistance and capacitance of supported bilayers. In this work, EIS was used in conjunction with vesicle leakage studies to characterize the response of bilayers of different lipid compositions to melittin. Experiments were carried out at low peptide to lipid ratios between 1:5000 and 1:100. The results directly demonstrate that the response of the bilayer to melittin at these concentrations cannot be explained by an equilibrium transmembrane pore model.

Surface electrostatics of lipid bilayers by EPR of a pH-sensitive spin-labeled lipid

Many biophysical processes such as insertion of proteins into membranes and membrane fusion are governed by bilayer electrostatic potential. At the time of this writing, the arsenal of biophysical methods for such measurements is limited to a few techniques. Here we describe a, to our knowledge, new spin-probe electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) approach for assessing the electrostatic surface potential of lipid bilayers that is based on a recently synthesized EPR probe (IMTSL-PTE) containing a reversibly ionizable nitroxide tag attached to the lipids' polar headgroup. EPR spectra of the probe directly report on its ionization state and, therefore, on electrostatic potential through changes in nitroxide magnetic parameters and the degree of rotational averaging. Further, the lipid nature of the probe provides its full integration into lipid bilayers. Tethering the nitroxide moiety directly to the lipid polar headgroup defines the location of the measured potential with respect to the lipid bilayer interface. Electrostatic surface potentials measured by EPR of IMTSL-PTE show a remarkable (within ±2%) agreement with the Gouy-Chapman theory for anionic DMPG bilayers in fluid (48°C) phase at low electrolyte concentration (50 mM) and in gel (17°C) phase at 150-mM electrolyte concentration. This agreement begins to diminish for DMPG vesicles in gel phase (17°C) upon varying electrolyte concentration and fluid phase bilayers formed from DMPG/DMPC and POPG/POPC mixtures. Possible reasons for such deviations, as well as the proper choice of an electrostatically neutral reference interface, have been discussed. Described EPR method is expected to be fully applicable to more-complex models of cellular membranes.

A synthetic S6 segment derived from KvAP channel self-assembles, permeabilizes lipid vesicles, and exhibits ion channel activity in bilayer lipid membrane

KvAP is a voltage-gated tetrameric K(+) channel with six transmembrane (S1-S6) segments in each monomer from the archaeon Aeropyrum pernix. The objective of the present investigation was to understand the plausible role of the S6 segment, which has been proposed to form the inner lining of the pore, in the membrane assembly and functional properties of KvAP channel. For this purpose, a 22-residue peptide, corresponding to the S6 transmembrane segment of KvAP (amino acids 218-239), and a scrambled peptide (S6-SCR) with rearrangement of only hydrophobic amino acids but without changing its composition were synthesized and characterized structurally and functionally. Although both peptides bound to the negatively charged phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylglycerol model membrane with comparable affinity, significant differences were observed between these peptides in their localization, self-assembly, and aggregation properties onto this membrane. S6-SCR also exhibited reduced helical structures in SDS micelles and phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylglycerol lipid vesicles as compared with the S6 peptide. Furthermore, the S6 peptide showed significant membrane-permeabilizing capability as evidenced by the release of calcein from the calcein-entrapped lipid vesicles, whereas S6-SCR showed much weaker efficacy. Interestingly, although the S6 peptide showed ion channel activity in the bilayer lipid membrane, despite having the same amino acid composition, S6-SCR was significantly inactive. The results demonstrated sequence-specific structural and functional properties of the S6 wild type peptide. The selected S6 segment is probably an important structural element that could play an important role in the membrane interaction, membrane assembly, and functional property of the KvAP channel.

Fluctuations and the rate-limiting step of peptide-induced membrane leakage

Peptide-induced vesicle leakage is a common experimental test for the membrane-perturbing activity of antimicrobial peptides. The leakage kinetics is usually very slow, requiring minutes to hours for complete release of vesicle contents, and exhibits a biphasic behavior. We report here that, in the case of the peptaibol trichogin GA IV, all processes involved in peptide-membrane interaction, such as peptide-membrane association, peptide aggregation, and peptide translocation, take place on a timescale much shorter than the leakage kinetics. On the basis of these findings, we propose a stochastic model in which the leakage kinetics is determined by the discrete nature of a vesicle suspension: peptides are continuously exchanging among vesicles, producing significant fluctuations over time in the number of peptide molecules bound to each vesicle, and in the formation of pores. According to this model, the fast initial leakage is caused by vesicles that contain at least one pore after the peptides are randomly distributed among the liposomes, whereas the slower release is associated with the time needed to occasionally reach in an intact vesicle the critical number of bound peptides necessary for pore formation. Fluctuations due to peptide exchange among vesicles therefore represent the rate-limiting step of such a slow mechanism.

Membrane partitioning: "classical" and "nonclassical" hydrophobic effects

The free energy of transfer of nonpolar solutes from water to lipid bilayers is often dominated by a large negative enthalpy rather than the large positive entropy expected from the hydrophobic effect. This common observation has led to the idea that membrane partitioning is driven by the “nonclassical” hydrophobic effect. We examined this phenomenon by characterizing the partitioning of the well-studied peptide melittin using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and circular dichroism (CD). We studied the temperature dependence of the entropic (−TΔS) and enthalpic (ΔH) components of free energy (ΔG) of partitioning of melittin into lipid membranes made of various mixtures of zwitterionic and anionic lipids. We found significant variations of the entropic and enthalpic components with temperature, lipid composition and vesicle size but only small changes in ΔG (entropy–enthalpy compensation). The heat capacity associated with partitioning had a large negative value of about −0.5 kcal mol⁻¹ K⁻¹. This hallmark of the hydrophobic effect was found to be independent of lipid composition. The measured heat capacity values were used to calculate the hydrophobic-effect free energy ΔG_hΦ, which we found to dominate melittin partitioning regardless of lipid composition. In the case of anionic membranes, additional free energy comes from coulombic attraction, which is characterized by a small effective peptide charge due to the lack of additivity of hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions in membrane interfaces [Ladokhin and White J Mol Biol 309:543–552, 2001]. Our results suggest that there is no need for a special effect—the nonclassical hydrophobic effect—to describe partitioning into lipid bilayers.

Aggregation state of melittin in lipid vesicle membranes

We have performed time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer measurements using melittin as donor and a modified melittin as acceptor. The melittin molecules were bound to fluid vesicle membranes of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine. Analysis of the temporal decay of the energy transfer and of its variation with the donor and acceptor concentrations led to the conclusion that melittin in fluid membranes is usually monomeric. Only at the high melittin/lipid molar ratio of 1/200 and high ionic strength evidence for aggregation was obtained, the percentage of aggregated melittin molecules being of the order of 10%. The shortcomings of previous steady-state measurements of fluorescence energy transfer between melittin molecules are discussed.

Thermodynamics of melittin binding to lipid bilayers. Aggregation and pore formation

Lipid membranes act as catalysts for protein folding. Both alpha-helical and beta-sheet structures can be induced by the interaction of peptides or proteins with lipid surfaces. Melittin, the main component of bee venom, is a particularly well-studied example for the membrane-induced random coil-to-alpha-helix transition. Melittin in water adopts essentially a random coil conformation. The cationic amphipathic molecule has a high affinity for neutral and anionic lipid membranes and exhibits approximately 50-65% alpha-helix conformation in the membrane-bound state. At higher melittin concentrations, the peptide forms aggregates or pores in the membrane. In spite of the long-standing interest in melittin-lipid interactions, no systematic thermodynamic study is available. This is probably caused by the complexity of the binding process. Melittin binding to lipid vesicles is fast and occurs within milliseconds, but the binding process involves at least four steps, namely, (i) the electrostatic attraction of the cationic peptide to an anionic membrane surface, (ii) the hydrophobic insertion into the lipid membrane, (iii) the conformational change from random coil to alpha-helix, and (iv) peptide aggregation in the lipid phase. We have combined microelectrophoresis (measurement of the zeta potential), isothermal titration calorimetry, and circular dichroism spectroscopy to provide a thermodynamic analysis of the individual binding steps. We have compared melittin with a synthetic analogue, [D]-V(5,8),I(17),K(21)-melittin, for which alpha-helix formation is suppressed and replaced by beta-structure formation. The comparison reveals that the thermodynamic parameters for the membrane-induced alpha-helix formation of melittin are identical to those observed earlier for other peptides with an enthalpy h(helix) of -0.7 kcal/mol and a free energy g(helix) of -0.2 kcal/mol per peptide residue. These thermodynamic parameters hence appear to be of general validity for lipid-induced membrane folding. As g(helix) is negative, it further follows that helix formation leads to an enhanced membrane binding for the peptides or proteins involved. In this study, melittin binds by approximately 2 orders of magnitude better to the lipid membrane than [D]-V(5,8),I(17),K(21)-melittin which cannot form an alpha-helix. We also found conditions under which the isothermal titration experiment reports only the aggregation process. Melittin aggregation is an entropy-driven process with an endothermic heat of reaction (DeltaH(agg)) of approximately 2 kcal/mol and an aggregation constant of 20-40 M(-1).

On the mechanism of pore formation by melittin

The mechanism of pore formation of lytic peptides, such as melittin from bee venom, is thought to involve binding to the membrane surface, followed by insertion at threshold levels of bound peptide. We show that in membranes composed of zwitterionic lipids, i.e. phosphatidylcholine, melittin not only forms pores but also inhibits pore formation. We propose that these two modes of action are the result of two competing reactions: direct insertion into the membrane and binding parallel to the membrane surface. The direct insertion of melittin leads to pore formation, whereas the parallel conformation is inactive and prevents other melittin molecules from inserting, hence preventing pore formation.

Melittin-lipid bilayer interactions and the role of cholesterol

The membrane-destabilizing effect of the peptide melittin on phosphatidylcholine membranes is modulated by the presence of cholesterol. This investigation shows that inclusion of 40 mol % cholesterol in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine liposomes reduces melittin's affinity for the membrane. It is significant that the presence of cholesterol does not increase the amount of membrane-associated melittin needed to cause maximum leakage from, or major structural rearrangements of, the liposomes. Furthermore, comparison of microscopy and leakage data suggests that melittin-induced leakage occurs via different mechanisms in the cholesterol-free and cholesterol-supplemented systems. In the absence of cholesterol, leakage of carboxyfluorescein takes place from intact liposomes in a manner compatible with the presence of small melittin-induced pores. In the presence of cholesterol, on the other hand, adsorption of the peptide causes complete membrane disruption and the formation of long-lived open-bilayer structures. Moreover, in the case of cholesterol-supplemented systems, melittin induces pronounced liposome aggregation. Cryotransmission electron microscopy was used, together with ellipsometry, circular dichroism, turbidity, and leakage measurements, to investigate the effects of melittin on phosphatidylcholine membranes in the absence and presence of cholesterol. The melittin partitioning behavior in the membrane systems was estimated by means of steady-state fluorescence spectroscopy measurements.

Melittin: a membrane-active peptide with diverse functions

Melittin is the principal toxic component in the venom of the European honey bee Apis mellifera and is a cationic, hemolytic peptide. It is a small linear peptide composed of 26 amino acid residues in which the amino-terminal region is predominantly hydrophobic whereas the carboxy-terminal region is hydrophilic due to the presence of a stretch of positively charged amino acids. This amphiphilic property of melittin has resulted in melittin being used as a suitable model peptide for monitoring lipid-protein interactions in membranes. In this review, the solution and membrane properties of melittin are highlighted, with an emphasis on melittin-membrane interaction using biophysical approaches. The recent applications of melittin in various cellular processes are discussed.

Effect of lipid headgroup composition on the interaction between melittin and lipid bilayers

The effect of the lipid polar headgroup on melittin-phospholipid interaction was investigated by cryo-TEM, fluorescence spectroscopy, ellipsometry, circular dichroism, electrophoresis and photon correlation spectroscopy. In particular, focus was placed on the effect of the lipid polar headgroup on peptide adsorption to, and penetration into, the lipid bilayer, as well as on resulting colloidal stability effects for large unilamellar liposomes. The effect of phospholipid headgroup properties on melittin-bilayer interaction was addressed by comparing liposomes containing phosphatidylcholine, -acid, and -inositol at varying ionic strength. Increasing the bilayer negative charge leads to an increased liposome tolerance toward melittin which is due to an electrostatic arrest of melittin at the membrane interface. Balancing the electrostatic attraction between the melittin positive charges and the phospholipid negative charges through a hydration repulsion, caused by inositol, reduced this surface arrest and increased liposome susceptibility to the disruptive actions of melittin. Furthermore, melittin was demonstrated to induce liposome structural destabilization on a colloidal scale which coincided with leakage induction for both anionic and zwitterionic systems. The latter findings thus clearly show that coalescence, aggregation, and fragmentation contribute to melittin-induced liposome leakage, and that detailed molecular analyses of melittin pore formation are incomplete without considering also these colloidal aspects.

Fluorescence study of protein–lipid complexes with a new symmetric squarylium probe

The novel symmetric squarylium derivative SQ-1 has been synthesized and tested for its sensitivity to the formation of protein-lipid complexes. SQ-1 binding to the model membranes composed of zwitterionic lipid phosphatidylcholine (PC) and its mixtures with anionic lipid cardiolipin (CL) in different molar ratios was found to be controlled mainly by hydrophobic interactions. Lysozyme (Lz) and ribonuclease A (RNase) exerted an influence on the probe association with lipid vesicles resulting presumably from the competition between SQ-1 and the proteins for bilayer free volume and modification of its properties. The magnitude of this effect was much higher for lysozyme which may stem from the amphipathy of protein alpha-helix involved in the membrane binding. Varying membrane composition provides evidence for the dye sensitivity to both hydrophobic and electrostatic protein-lipid interactions. Fluorescence anisotropy studies uncovered the restriction of SQ-1 rotational mobility in lipid environment in the presence of Lz and RNase being indicative of the incorporation of the proteins into bilayer interior. The results of binding, fluorescence quenching and kinetic experiments suggested lysozyme-induced local lipid demixing upon protein association with negatively charged membranes with threshold concentration of CL for the lipid demixing being 10 mol%.

Model-free analysis of binding at lipid membranes employing micro-calorimetric measurements

Based on universal thermodynamic principles (Schwarz in Biophys Chem 86:119-129, 2000) it is shown how measured enthalpy changes can be utilized to determine the relevant binding isotherm as well as the variation of the molar enthalpy change. This is carried out in a novel way involving multiple titration experiments whose evaluation requires no beforehand assumptions or models whatever. An appropriate specific model mechanism may be discussed afterwards and developed in view of the given experimental results. The pertinent procedure is demonstrated using micro-calorimetric data obtained in the case of the local anesthetic dibucaine as it associates with POPC liposomes. Mutual interactions of the bound ligand molecules could be described in terms of repulsive enthalpic and entropic activity coefficients. Apparently these are induced by electrostatic forces and by the finite size of binding sites, respectively.

Influence of the lipid composition on the kinetics of concerted insertion and folding of melittin in bilayers

We have examined the kinetics of the adsorption of melittin, a secondary amphipathic peptide extracted from bee venom, on lipid membranes using three independent and complementary approaches. We probed (i) the change in the polarity of the 19Trp of the peptide upon binding, (ii) the insertion of this residue in the apolar core of the membrane, measuring the 19Trp-fluorescence quenching by bromine atoms attached on lipid acyl chains, and (iii) the folding of the peptide, by circular dichroism (CD). We report a tight coupling of the insertion of the peptide with its folding as an alpha-helix. For all the investigated membrane systems (cholesterol-containing, phosphoglycerol-containing, and pure phosphocholine bilayers), the decrease in the polarity of 19Trp was found to be significantly faster than the increase in the helical content of melittin. Therefore, from a kinetics point of view, the formation of the alpha-helix is a consequence of the insertion of melittin. The rate of melittin folding was found to be influenced by the lipid composition of the bilayer and we propose that this was achieved by the modulation of the kinetics of insertion. The study reports a clear example of the coupling existing between protein penetration and folding, an interconnection that must be considered in the general scheme of membrane protein folding.

The membrane-binding properties of a class A amphipathic peptide

The membrane-binding properties of a class A amphipathic peptide (18D) were investigated using two different immobilized model membrane systems. The first system involved the use of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to study the binding of 18D to dimyristylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and dimyristylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG), which allowed peptide binding to be monitored in real time. The SPR experiments indicated stronger binding of 18D to DMPG than DMPC, which kinetic analysis revealed was due to a faster on-rate. The second model membrane system involved immobilized membrane chromatography in which the binding of 18D to either DMPC or DMPG monolayers covalently linked to silica particles was analysed by elution chromatography. Stronger binding affinity of 18D was also obtained with the negatively charged phosphatidylglycerol (PG) monolayer compared to the phosphatidylcholine (PC) monolayer, which was consistent with the SPR results. Non-linear binding behaviour of 18D to the immobilized lipid monolayers was also observed, which suggests that the peptide undergoes conformational and orientational changes upon binding to the immobilized PC and PG ligands. Significant band broadening was also observed on both monolayers, with larger bandwidths obtained on the PC surface, indicating slower binding and orientation kinetics with the zwitterionic surface. The dependence of logk' on the percentage of methanol also demonstrated a bimodal interaction whereby hydrophobic forces predominated at higher temperatures and methanol concentrations, while at lower temperatures, electrostatic and other polar forces also made a contribution to the affinity of the peptides for the lipid monolayer particularly. Overall, these results demonstrate the complementary use of these two lipid biosensors which allows the role of hydrophobic and electrostatic forces in peptide-membrane interactions to be studied and insight gained into the kinetic factors associated with these interactions.

Charge-dependent translocation of the Trojan peptide penetratin across lipid membranes

We studied the interaction of the cell-penetrating peptide penetratin with mixed dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dioleoylphoshatidylglycerol (DOPC/DOPG) unilamellar vesicles as a function of the molar fraction of anionic lipid, X(PG), by means of isothermal titration calorimetry. The work was aimed at getting a better understanding of factors that affect the peptide binding to lipid membranes and its permeation through the bilayer. The binding was well described by a surface partitioning equilibrium using an effective charge of the peptide of z(P) approximately 5.1 +/- 0.5. The peptide first binds to the outer surface of the vesicles, the effective binding capacity of which increases with X(PG). At X(PG) approximately 0.5 and a molar ratio of bound peptide-to-lipid of approximately 1/20 the membranes become permeable and penetratin binds also to the inner monolayer after internalization. The results were rationalized in terms of an "electroporation-like" mechanism, according to which the asymmetrical distribution of the peptide between the outer and inner surfaces of the charged bilayer causes a transmembrane electrical field, which alters the lateral and the curvature stress acting within the membrane. At a threshold value these effects induce internalization of penetratin presumably via inversely curved transient structures.

Quantifying molecular partition into model systems of biomembranes: an emphasis on optical spectroscopic methods

Optical spectroscopies have been intensively used to determine partition coefficients by a plethora of methodologies. The present review is intended to give detailed and useful information for the determination of partition coefficients and addresses several relevant aspects, namely: (i) definition and calculation of the partition coefficient between aqueous and lipidic phases; (ii) partition coefficients vs. "binding" formalisms; (iii) advantages of spectroscopic methodologies over separation techniques; (iv) formalisms for various experimental approaches based on UV-Vis absorption or fluorescence parameters (fluorescence intensity, lifetime, anisotropy and quenching); (v) experimental hints, artifacts and model limitations; and (vi) a brief survey of nonoptical techniques.

Interaction of quinine with model lipid membranes of different compositions

The binding of a drug such as Quinine with neutral and negatively charged small unilamellar lipid vesicles at pH 7 and 37 degrees C was investigated. Changes in the fluorescence properties of the drug after association with the liposomes were used to obtain binding isotherms over a range of phospholipid compositions at different ionic strengths. Under such conditions, the association was strongly enhanced by the negative net charge of the bilayer but diminished by the increasing presence of electrolytes in the aqueous media. Binding data were analyzed in terms of a surface partition equilibrium without and after correcting for electrostatic effects by means of the Gouy-Chapman theory. The intrinsic (hydrophobic) constant, obtained after charge correction, was smaller than the apparent binding constant determined without taking into account such an effect. A new analysis considering the two components not fully dissociated and affected by an identical screening factor has been introduced. It yielded rather similar hydrophobic partition coefficients for all conditions, independent of both the surface charge density of the lipid vesicles and the ionic strength, with an average value estimated to be (3 +/- 1) x 10(3) M(-1). All the findings suggested that the association of Quinine to liposomes is controlled primarily through electrostatic attractions, and, in a lesser extent, by hydrophobic forces. Because electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions play a crucial role in both the drug-membrane affinity and the location of the drug, their quantitative evaluation can shed light on the mechanism for a next therapeutic "action."

Thermodynamic Study of Small Hydrophobic Ions at the Water–Lipid Interface

The thermodynamics of binding of two small hydrophobic ions such as norharman and tryptophan to neutral and negatively charged small unilamellar vesicles was investigated at pH 7.4 using fluorescence spectroscopy. Vesicles were formed at room temperature from dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) or DMPC/dimyristoylphosphatidic acid and DMPC/dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol. The changes in fluorescence properties were used to obtain association isotherms at variable membrane surface negative charge and at different ionic strengths. The binding of both ions was found to be quantitatively enhanced as the percentage of negative phospholipid increases in the membrane. Also, a decrease in ion binding was found to occur as the concentration of monovalent salt was increased (0.045-0.345 M). If electrostatic effects were ignored, the experimental data showed biphasic behavior in Scatchard plots. When electrostatic effects were taken into account by means of the Gouy-Chapman theory, the same data yielded linear Scatchard plots that were described by a simple partition equilibrium of the hydrophobic ion into the lipid-water interface. We demonstrate that the effective interfacial charge, nu, of the ion is a determinant factor to obtain a unique value of the intrinsic (hydrophobic) binding constant independently of the surface charge density of the lipid membrane.

General aspects of peptide selectivity towards lipid bilayers and cell membranes studied by variation of the structural parameters of amphipathic helical model peptides

Model compounds of modified hydrophobicity (Eta), hydrophobic moment (mu) and angle subtended by charged residues (Phi) were synthesized to define the general roles of structural motifs of cationic helical peptides for membrane activity and selectivity. The peptide sets were based on a highly hydrophobic, non-selective KLA model peptide with high antimicrobial and hemolytic activity. Variation of the investigated parameters was found to be a suitable method for modifying peptide selectivity towards either neutral or highly negatively charged lipid bilayers. Eta and mu influenced selectivity preferentially via modification of activity on 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) bilayers, while the size of the polar/hydrophobic angle affected the activity against 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidyl-DL-glycerol (POPG). The influence of the parameters on the activity determining step was modest in both lipid systems and the activity profiles were the result of the parameters' influence on the second less pronounced permeabilization step. Thus, the activity towards POPC vesicles was determined by the high permeabilizing efficiency, however, changes in the structural parameters preferentially influenced the relatively moderate affinity. In contrast, intensive peptide accumulation via electrostatic interactions was sufficient for the destabilization of highly negatively charged POPG lipid membranes, but changes in the activity profile, as revealed by the modification of Phi, seem to be preferentially caused by variation of the low permeabilizing efficiency. The parameters proved very effective also in modifying antimicrobial and hemolytic activity. However, their influence on cell selectivity was limited. A threshold value of hydrophobicity seems to exist which restricted the activity modifying potential of mu and Phi on both lipid bilayers and cell membranes.

Measurement of the affinity of melittin for zwitterionic and anionic membranes using immobilized lipid biosensors

The binding of melittin to zwitterionic dimyristyphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and anionic dimyristylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG) was analysed using two different immobilized model membrane systems. The first system used surface plasmon resonance (SPR), which monitors the real-time binding of peptides to an immobilized hybrid bilayer. SPR experiments reflected a stronger binding of melittin for DMPG than for DMPC, while kinetic analysis suggested the existence of at least two distinct binding steps. The second lipid biosensor system involved an immobilized phospholipid monolayer covalently attached to a microporous silica surface. The binding of melittin to the immobilized monolayer was then monitored using dynamic elution chromatography with varied methanol concentrations to analyse the binding of melittin to DMPC and DMPG. The nonlinear binding behaviour observed for melittin with the phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylglycerol (PG) monolayers compared with the linear retention plots and Gaussian peak shapes observed for the control molecule demonstrated that melittin undergoes significant conformational and orientational changes upon binding to the immobilized PC and PG ligands. The dependence of log k' on per cent methanol also demonstrated a bimodal interaction whereby hydrophobic forces predominated at higher temperatures and methanol concentrations, while other forces, presumably electrostatic in nature, also made a contribution to the affinity of the peptides for the lipid monolayer, particularly at lower temperatures. The complementary use of these two lipid biosensors thus allows the role of hydrophobic and electrostatic forces in peptide-membrane interactions to be studied.

Optimization of the antimicrobial activity of magainin peptides by modification of charge

Investigation of magainin II amide analogs with cationic charges ranging between +3 and +7 showed that enhancement of the peptide charge up to a threshold value of +5 and conservation of appropriate hydrophobic properties optimized the antimicrobial activity and selectivity. High selectivity was the result of both enhanced antimicrobial and reduced hemolytic activity. Charge increase beyond +5 with retention of other structural motifs led to a dramatic increase of hemolytic activity and loss of antimicrobial selectivity. Selectivity could be restored by reduction of the hydrophobicity of the hydrophobic helix surface (H(hd)), a structural parameter not previously considered to modulate activity. Dye release experiments with lipid vesicles revealed that the potential of peptide charge to modulate membrane activity is limited: on highly negatively charged 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidyl-DL-glycerol bilayers, reinforcement of electrostatic interactions had an activity-reducing effect. On neutral 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers, the high activity was determined by H(hd). H(hd) values above a certain threshold led to effective permeabilization of all lipid systems and even compensated for the activity-reducing effect of charge increase on highly negatively charged membranes.

Negative cooperativity and aggregation in biphasic binding of mastoparan X peptide to membranes with acidic lipids

The change of Trp fluorescence intensity when large vesicles with 10% acidic lipid are added to mastoparan X solutions reflects a fast and a slow binding process. By means of a novel procedure of data analysis that takes advantage of so-called mass conservation plots we have separated association isotherms related to: (i) the apparent fast pre-equilibrium; and (ii) the final equilibrium, respectively. This approach also reveals that the intrinsic fluorescence signal of the slow binding is considerably raised against that of the fast binding, presumably indicating a penetration of bound peptide from the lipid/water interface into the apolar lipid core. The shape of either binding curve discloses a pronounced tendency of aggregation. Furthermore, it turns out that in the slow process the final binding ratio decreases markedly compared with the initial fast binding ratio. Accordingly the occupation of final binding sites must exert a substantial effect of negative cooperativity on the affinity of the interfacial binding states.

Structure, location, and lipid perturbations of melittin at the membrane interface

Melittin is arguably the most widely studied amphipathic, membrane-lytic alpha-helical peptide. Although several lines of evidence suggest an interfacial membrane location at low concentrations, melittin's exact position and depth of penetration into the hydrocarbon core are unknown. Furthermore, the structural basis for its lytic action remains largely a matter of conjecture. Using a novel x-ray absolute-scale refinement method, we have now determined the location, orientation, and likely conformation of monomeric melittin in oriented phosphocholine lipid multilayers. Its helical axis is aligned parallel to the bilayer plane at the depth of the glycerol groups, but its average conformation differs from the crystallographic structure. As observed earlier for another amphipathic alpha-helical peptide, the lipid perturbations induced by melittin are remarkably modest. Small bilayer perturbations thus appear to be a general feature of amphipathic helices at low concentrations. In contrast, a dimeric form of melittin causes larger structural perturbations under otherwise identical conditions. These results provide direct structural evidence that self-association of amphipathic helices may be the crucial initial step toward membrane lysis.

How to measure and analyze tryptophan fluorescence in membranes properly, and why bother?

Tryptophan fluorescence is a powerful tool for studying protein structure and function, especially membrane-active proteins and peptides. It is arguably the most frequently used tool for examining the interactions of proteins and peptides with vesicular unilamellar model membranes. However, high light scattering associated with vesicular membrane systems presents special challenges. Because of their reduced light scattering compared to large unilamellar vesicles (LUV), small unilamellar vesicles (SUV) produced by sonication are widely used membrane models. Unfortunately, SUV, unlike LUV, are metastable and consequently unsuitable for equilibrium thermodynamic measurements. We present simple and easily implemented experimental procedures for the accurate determination of tryptophan (Trp) fluorescence in either LUV or SUV. Specifically, we show that Trp spectra can be obtained in the presence of up to 6 mM LUV that are virtually identical to spectra obtained in buffer alone, which obviates the use of SUV. We show how the widths and peak positions of such spectra can be used to evaluate the heterogeneity of the membrane conformation and penetration of peptides. Finally, we show how to use a reference fluorophore for the correction of intensity measurements so that the energetics of peptide partitioning into membranes can be accurately determined.

A universal thermodynamic approach to analyze biomolecular binding experiments

Binding processes of any kind can be characterized as an association of a given ligand with some binding factor. This includes macromolecules as well as supramolecular aggregates such as micelles or membranes. The underlying molecular binding mechanism may be more or less complicated due to various intermediate steps (involving for instance conformational changes, aggregation, cooperativity, etc.). A sensible discussion of possible binding models naturally calls for a model-independent access to basic thermodynamic properties. The present contribution will demonstrate how this can quite generally be accomplished by a pertinent processing of properly selected experimental data. The method requires a series of titration measurements comprising the use of variable amounts of both the ligand and the binding factor. It leads to a linear mass conservation plot (i.e. amount of the ligand vs. a matching amount of the binding factor) whose slope and ordinate intercept are equal to the binding ratio (i.e. bound ligand per binding factor) and the free ligand concentration, respectively. This establishes the specific binding isotherm. The approach also reveals latent structurally determined features of the applied physical measuring signal. A number of examples including specific binding, unspecific adsorption and insertion in two-dimensional molecular films will illustrate the methodology.

A Pro --> Ala substitution in melittin affects self-association, membrane binding and pore-formation kinetics due to changes in structural and electrostatic properties

Melittin, the main component of bee venom of Apis mellifera, contains a proline at position 14, which is highly conserved in related peptides of various bee venoms. To investigate the structural and functional role of Pro14 a melittin analogue was studied where proline is substituted by an alanine residue (P14A). The investigations were focussed on: (i) the secondary structure in aqueous solution and membranes; (ii) the self-association in solution; (iii) the binding to POPC membranes; and (iv) the P14A-induced leakage and pore formation in membrane vesicles. Circular dichroism and gel filtration experiments showed that P14A exists at concentrations < 12 microM in monomeric form with an alpha-helicity of 28 +/- 7%. A further increase in peptide concentration leads to the formation of large aggregates consisting of 9 +/- 1 monomers. While binding studies with POPC vesicles revealed for P14A a stronger binding affinity towards membranes than for melittin, the peptide-induced leakage of fluorescent markers from vesicles was less efficient for P14A than for melittin. Furthermore, an unexpected efflux behaviour at high values of bound P14A was observed which indicated that the pore formation kinetics for P14A is more complex than it was reported for melittin. The different features of P14A in aggregation, binding and efflux compared to melittin are mainly ascribable directly to structural changes caused by the proline --> alanine substitution. Furthermore, the results indicate an improved screening of the positively charged residues of P14A by counterions which contributes additionally to the observed differences in peptide activities. It is suggested that the presence of proline in melittin is not only of structural importance but also influences indirectly the electrostatic properties of the native peptide.

Binding of a fluorescent dansylcadaverine-substance P analogue to negatively charged phospholipid membranes

We have investigated the binding of a new dansylcadaverine derivative of substance P (DNC-SP) with negatively charged small unilamellar vesicles composed of a mixture of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and either phosphatidylglycerol (PG) or phosphatidylserine (PS) using fluorescence spectroscopic techniques. The changes in fluorescence properties were used to obtain association isotherms at variable membrane negative charges and at different ionic strengths. The experimental association isotherms were analyzed using two binding approaches: (i) the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the partition equilibrium model, that neglect the activity coefficients; and (ii) the partition equilibrium model combined with the Gouy-Chapman formalism that considers electrostatic effects. A consistent quantitative analysis of each DNC-SP binding curve at different lipid composition was achieved by means of the Gouy-Chapman approach using a peptide effective interfacial charge (v) value of (0.95 +/- 0.02), which is lower than the physical charge of the peptide. For PC/PG membranes, the partition equilibrium constant were 7.8 x 10(3) M(-1) (9/1, mol/mol) and 6.9 x 10(3) M(-1) (7/3, mol/mol), whereas for PC/PS membranes an average value of 6.8 x 10(3) M(-1) was estimated. These partition equilibrium constants were similar to those obtained for the interaction of DNC-SP with neutral PC membranes (4.9 x 10(3) M(-1)), as theoretically expected. We demonstrate that the v parameter is a determinant factor to obtain a unique value of the binding constant independently of the surface charge density of the vesicles. Also, the potential of fluorescent dansylated SP analogue in studies involving interactions with cell membranes is discussed.

Stability of a melittin pore in a lipid bilayer: a molecular dynamics study

We have investigated the configuration and the stability of a single membrane pore bound by four melittin molecules and embedded in a fully hydrated bilayer lipid membrane. We used molecular dynamics simulations up to 5.8 ns. It is found that the initial tetrameric configuration decays with increasing time into a stable trimer and one monomer. This continuous transformation is accompanied by a lateral expansion of the aqueous pore exhibiting a final size comparable to experimental findings. The expansion-induced formation of an interface between the pore-lining acyl chains of the lipids and the pore water ("hydrophobic pore") is transformed into an energetically more favorable toroidal pore structure where some lipid heads are translocated from the rim to the central part of the interface ("hydrophilic pore"). The expansion of the pore is supported by the electrostatic repulsion among the alpha-helices. It is hypothesized that pore growth, and hence cell lysis, is induced by a melittin-mediated line tension of the pore.

Membrane partitioning of the cleavage peptide in flock house virus

Membrane translocation of the ssRNA genome of nodaviruses has been proposed to be mediated by direct lipid-protein interactions between a postassembly autocatalytic cleavage product from the capsomere and the target membrane. We have recently shown that the 21-residue Met-->Nle variant of the N-terminal helical domain (denoted gamma(1)) of the cleavage peptide in flock house nodavirus increases membrane permeability to hydrophilic solutes and can alter both membrane structure and function, suggesting the possibility of peptide-triggered disruption of the endosomal membrane as a prelude to viral uncoating in the host cytoplasm. Elucidation of partitioning energetics would allow an assessment of the likelihood of this mechanism. We report herein complete thermodynamic characterization of the partitioning of gamma(1) to phospholipids by lipid-peptide titrations following changes in ellipticity, fluorescence signature, or calorimetric response. These experiments revealed a partitioning energy comparable to natural membrane-active peptide toxins, suggesting that the proposed mechanism may be possible. Additionally, a novel switch in the balance of partitioning forces was found: when the lipid headgroup was changed from zwitterionic to negatively charged, membrane association of the peptide became completely entropy-driven.

Ideally amphipathic beta-sheeted peptides at interfaces: structure, orientation, affinities for lipids and hemolytic activity of (KL)(m)K peptides

Designed to model ideally amphipathic beta-sheets, the minimalist linear (KL)(m)K peptides (m=4-7) were synthesized and proved to form stable films at the air/water interface, they insert into compressed dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine monolayers and interact with egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles. Whatever the interface or the lateral pressure applied to the films, FT-IR and polarization-modulated IRRAS spectroscopy developed in situ on the films indicated that all the peptides totally fold into intermolecular antiparallel beta-sheets. Calculated spectra of the amide region allowed us to define the orientation of the beta-strands compared to the interface. It is concluded that such beta-sheets remain flat-oriented without deep perturbation of zwitterionic phospholipids. Dansyl labelling at the N-terminus indicates that all the peptides are monomeric at a low concentration in aqueous buffer and bind to lipids with similar Dns burying. The affinities for zwitterionic lecithin mono- and bilayers, quantitatively estimated from buffer to lipid partition constants, monotonically increased with peptide length, indicating that hydrophobicity is a limiting parameter for lipid and membrane affinities. Peptides induced permeability increases on zwitterionic liposomes, they are strongly hemolytic towards human erythrocytes and their activity increases concurrently with length. Taking into account the lipid affinity, a hemolytic efficiency can be defined: at the same amount of peptide bound, this efficiency strongly increases with the peptide length. It is proposed that the first determinant step of membrane disturbance is the invasion of the outer membrane leaflet by these ideally amphipathic beta-sheeted structures lying flat at the interface, like large rafts depending on the number of beta-strands.

The monolayer technique: a potent tool for studying the interfacial properties of antimicrobial and membrane-lytic peptides and their interactions with lipid membranes

Erudites of the antiquity already knew the calming effect of oil films on the sea waves. But one had to wait until 1774 to read the first scientific report on oil films from B. Franklin and again 1878 to learn the thermodynamic analysis on adsorption developed by J. Gibbs. Then, in 1891, Agnes Pockels described a technique to manipulate oil films by using barriers. Finally, in 1917, I. Langmuir introduced the experimental and theoretical modern concepts on insoluble monolayers. Since that time, and because it has been found to provide invaluable information at the molecular scale, the monolayer technique has been more and more extensively used, and, during the past decade, an explosive increase in the number of publications has occurred. Over the same period, considerable and ever-increasing interest in the antimicrobial peptides of various plants, bacteria, insects, amphibians and mammals has grown. Because many of these antimicrobial peptides act at the cell membrane level, the monolayer technique is entirely suitable for studying their physicochemical and biological properties. This review describes monolayer experiments performed with some of these antimicrobial peptides, especially gramicidin A, melittin, cardiotoxins and defensin A. After giving a few basic notions of surface chemistry, the surface-active properties of these peptides and their behavior when they are arranged in monomolecular films are reported and discussed in relation to their tridimensional structure and their amphipathic character. The penetration of these antimicrobial peptides into phospholipid monolayer model membranes, as well as their interactions with lipids in mixed films, are also emphasized.