Conformation of proline residues in bacteriorhodopsin

The role of proline residues in the dynamics of transmembrane helices: the case of bacteriorhodopsin

Proline residues in transmembrane helices have been found to have important roles in the functioning of membrane proteins. Moreover, Pro residues occur with high frequency in transmembrane alpha-helices, as compared to alpha-helices for soluble proteins. Here, we report several properties of the bacteriorhodopsin mutants P50A (helix B), P91A (helix C) and P186A (helix F). Compared to wild type, strongly perturbed behaviour has been found for these mutants. In the resting state, increased hydroxylamine accessibility and altered Asp-85 pKa and light-dark adaptation were observed. On light activation, hydroxylamine accessibility was increased and proton transport activity, M formation kinetics and FTIR difference spectra of M and N intermediates showed clear distortions. On the basis of these alterations and the near identity of the crystalline structures of mutants with that of wild type, we conclude that the transmembrane proline residues of bacteriorhodopsin fulfil a dynamic role in both the resting and the light-activated states. Our results are consistent with the notion that mutation of Pro to Ala allows the helix to increase its flexibility towards the direction originally hindered by the steric clash between the ring Cgamma and the carbonyl O of the i-4 residue, at the same time decreasing the mobility towards the opposite direction. Due to their properties, transmembrane Pro residues may serve as transmission elements of conformational changes during the transport process. We propose that these concepts can be extended to other transmembrane proteins.

Nucleation of beta-hairpin structures with cis amide bonds in E-vinylogous proline-containing peptides

Synthesis and conformational studies of peptides containing the E-vinylogous prolines 1 (VPro1) and 2 (VPro2), Boc-Ala-Val-VPro1-Xaa-Leu-OMe (3, Xaa = Gly; 4, Xaa = Phe), Boc-Ala-Val-VPro2-Xaa-Leu-OMe (5, Xaa = Gly; 6, Xaa = Phe), Boc-Leu-Ile-Val-VPro1-Xaa-Leu-OMe (7, Xaa = Gly; 8, Xaa = Phe), and Boc-Leu-Ile-Val-VPro2-Xaa-Leu-OMe (9, Xaa = Gly; 10, Xaa = Phe), were carried out. It has been shown that both VPro1 and VPro2 lead to the formation of 12-membered intramolecularly hydrogen bonded structures very similar to type VI beta-turns with a cis Xaa-VPro amide bond in the major conformers in all the peptides 3-10, resulting in the nucleation of beta-hairpin type structures in these molecules in CDCl(3).

Solid-state NMR investigation of the buried X-proline peptide bonds of bacteriorhodopsin

The role of proline residues in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is addressed using solid-state NMR. (13)C and (15)N chemical shifts from X-Pro peptide bonds in bR are assigned from REDOR difference spectra of pairwise labeled samples, and correlations of chemical shifts with structure are explored in a series of X-Pro model compounds. Results for the three membrane-embedded X-Pro bonds of bR indicate only slight changes in the transition from the resting state of the protein to either the early or late M state of the protonmotive photocycle. These results suggest that the buried prolines serve a principally structural role in bR.

Magnetic resonance studies of the bacteriorhodopsin pump cycle

Active transport requires the alternation of substrate uptake and release with a switch in the access of the substrate binding site to the two sides of the membrane. Both the transfer and switch aspects of the photocycle have been subjects of magnetic resonance studies in bacteriorhodopsin. The results for ion transfer indicate that the Schiff base of the chromophore is hydrogen bonded before, during, and after its deprotonation. This suggests that the initial complex counterion of the Schiff base decomposes in such a way that the Schiff base carries its immediate hydrogen-bonding partner with it as it rotates during the first half of the photocycle. If so, bacteriorhodopsin acts as an inward-directed hydroxide pump rather than as an outward-directed proton pump. The studies of the access switch explore both protein-based and chromophore-based mechanisms. Combined with evidence from functional studies of mutants and other forms of spectroscopy, the results suggest that maintaining access to the extracellular side of the protein after photoisomerization involves twisting of the chromophore and that the decisive switch in access to the cytoplasmic side results from relaxation of the chromophore when the constraints on the Schiff base are released by decomposition of the complex counterion.

Thr90 is a key residue of the bacteriorhodopsin proton pumping mechanism

Mutation of Thr90 to Ala has a profound effect on bacteriorhodopsin properties. T90A shows about 20% of the proton pumping efficiency of wild type, once reconstituted into liposomes. Mutation of Thr90 influences greatly the Schiff base/Asp85 environment, as demonstrated by altered lambda(max) of 555 nm and pK(a) of Asp85 (about 1.3 pH units higher than wild type). Hydroxylamine accessibility is increased in both dark and light and differential scanning calorimetry and visible spectrophotometry show decreased thermal stability. These results suggest that Thr90 has an important structural role in both the unphotolysed bacteriorhodopsin and in the proton pumping mechanism.

Guidelines for membrane protein engineering derived from de novo designed model peptides

Notwithstanding great advances in the engineering and structural analysis of globular proteins, relatively limited success has been achieved with membrane proteins--due largely to their intrinsic high insolubility and the concomitant difficulty in obtaining crystals. Progress with de novo synthesis of model membrane-interactive peptides presents an opportunity to construct simpler peptides with definable structures, and permits one to approach an understanding of the properties of the membrane proteins themselves. In the present article, we review how our laboratory and others have used peptide approaches to assess the detailed interactions of peptides with membranes, and primary folding at membrane surfaces and in membranes. Structural studies of model peptides identified the existence of a "threshold hydrophobicity," which controls spontaneous peptide insertion into membranes. Related studies of the relative helicity of peptides in organic media such as n-butanol indicate that the helical propensity of individual residues--not simply their hydrophobicity--may dictate the conformations of peptides in membranes. The overall experimental results provide fundamental guidelines for membrane protein engineering.

Internal packing of helical membrane proteins

Helix packing is important in the folding, stability, and association of membrane proteins. Packing analysis of the helical portions of 7 integral membrane proteins and 37 soluble proteins show that the helices in membrane proteins have higher packing values (0.431) than in soluble proteins (0.405). The highest packing values in integral membrane proteins originate from small hydrophobic (G and A) and small hydroxyl-containing (S and T) amino acids, whereas in soluble proteins large hydrophobic and aromatic residues have the highest packing values. The highest packing values for membrane proteins are found in the transmembrane helix-helix interfaces. Glycine and alanine have the highest occurrence among the buried amino acids in membrane proteins, whereas leucine and alanine are the most common buried residue in soluble proteins. These observations are consistent with a shorter axial separation between helices in membrane proteins. The tight helix packing revealed in this analysis contributes to membrane protein stability and likely compensates for the lack of the hydrophobic effect as a driving force for helix-helix association in membranes.

Molecular dynamics of individual alpha-helices of bacteriorhodopsin in dimyristol phosphatidylocholine. I. Structure and dynamics

Understanding the role of the lipid bilayer in membrane protein structure and dynamics is needed for tertiary structure determination methods. However, the molecular details are not well understood. Molecular dynamics computer calculations can provide insight into these molecular details of protein:lipid interactions. This paper reports on 10 simulations of individual alpha-helices in explicit lipid bilayers. The 10 helices were selected from the bacteriorhodopsin structure as representative alpha-helical membrane folding components. The bilayer is constructed of dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine molecules. The only major difference between simulations is the primary sequence of the alpha-helix. The results show dramatic differences in motional behavior between alpha-helices. For example, helix A has much smaller root-mean-squared deviations than does helix D. This can be understood in terms of the presence of aromatic residues at the interface for helix A that are not present in helix D. Additional motions are possible for the helices that contain proline side chains relative to other amino acids. The results thus provide insight into the types of motion and the average structures possible for helices within the bilayer setting and demonstrate the strength of molecular simulations in providing molecular details that are not directly visualized in experiments.

Solid-state 13C-NMR of [(3-13C)Pro]bacteriorhodopsin and [(4-13C)Pro]bacteriorhodopsin: evidence for a flexible segment of the C-terminal tail

The configuration of an Xaa-Pro bond can be determined by solid-state magic-angle-sample-spinning (MASS)-13C-NMR spectroscopy since the chemical shifts of C beta and Cgamma of the proline ring are sensitive to the isomerization state of the preceding peptide bond. (3-13C)Pro and (4-13C)Pro have been chemically synthesized; the former by means of an asymmetric synthesis. The 13C-labeled Pro residues were biosynthetically incorporated into bacteriorhodopsin with a yield of 80%. The solid-state-MASS-13C-NMR spectra of [(3-13C)Pro]bacteriorhodopsin and [(4-13C)Pro]bacteriorhodopsin revealed isotropic chemical shifts at 29.8 ppm and 25.5 ppm, respectively. From the chemical-shift values we conclude that all Xaa Pro peptide bonds are in the trans configuration confirming previous results from solution-NMR studies on solubilized bacteriorhodopsin in organic solvents [Deber, M.C., Sorrell, B.J. & Xu, G.Y. (1990) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 172, 862-869]. Inversion-recovery experiments could differentiate between three classes of Pro residues distinguished by their relaxation time t1. Tentatively, these three distinct groups of Pro residues could be assigned to the helical, the loop, and the C-terminal parts of the protein. The resonances of the two C-terminal Pro could be identified by removing the C-terminus by proteolysis. Although they are separated by only one Glu they occupy different chemical environments and possess different flexibilities. These results indicate that the first part of the C-terminal tail is constrained. Pro238 marks the position where the tail becomes freely mobile. It is proposed that the C-terminus is fixed to the membrane via salt bridges between divalent cations and negative charges of the C-terminus as well as interhelical loops.

1H-15N-NMR studies of bacteriorhodopsin Halobacterium halobium. Conformational dynamics of the four-helical bundle

Series of uniformly and selectively 15N-labeled bacteriorhodopsins of Halobacterium halobium (strain ET 1001) were obtained and a 1H-15N-NMR study was performed in methanol/chloroform (1:1) and 0.1 M NH4CHOO, medium which mimics that in the membrane in vivo. Less than half of the cross-peaks expected from the amino acid sequence of uniformly 15N-labeled bacteriorhodopsin were observed, using heteronuclear 1H-15N coherence spectroscopy. In order to assign the observed cross-peaks, a selective 15N-labeling of amino acid residues (Tyr, Phe, Trp, Lys, Gly, Leu, Val or Ile) was carried out and 1H-15N-NMR spectra of bacteriorhodopsin and its fragments C1 (residues (72-231), C2 (residues 1-71), B1 (residues 1-155) and BP2 (residues 163-231) were investigated. By this procedure, all observed 1H-15N cross-peaks of the entire bacteriorhodopsin were found to belong to the transmembrane segments A, B and G. The cross-peaks from four (C, D, E and F) helical bundles (79-189 residues) were missed. These results clearly indicate that dynamic processes occur in the four helice bundle. The significance of this, in respect to bacteriorhodopsin functioning, is discussed.

Multiple peak formation from reversed-phase liquid chromatography of recombinant human platelet-derived growth factor

Reversed-phase liquid chromatography of recombinant platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) results in the appearance of at least four distinguishable peaks. The relative areas of these peaks are, in part, dependent upon the gradient time and the temperature. Isolation and reinjection of each peak gave chromatographic profiles comparable to that obtained from unfractionated PDGF. Increasing the temperature above 60 degrees C resulted in a single peak that, when isolated and reinjected at ambient temperature, produced a chromatogram comparable to PDGF which had not been exposed to elevated temperature. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that all four peaks had the same molecular mass as PDGF and were active as determined by a PDGF mitogenic bioassay. These results indicate that multiple conformations of PDGF are present and we postulate that their appearance may be a result of isomeric structures arising from the presence of Pro-Pro bonds within the primary structure of the protein.

Minimum energy conformations of proline-containing helices

Proline occurs frequently in transmembrane alpha-helices of transport and receptor proteins even though statistical surveys demonstrate the overwhelming preference of this residue for a non-alpha-helical, hydrophilic environment. As a result, membrane-buried proline has been proposed to be functionally important, with function arising from structural discontinuity or destabilization of the helix. Destabilization may occur by Pro-mediated conformational transitions between discrete states, and may be manifested in membrane protein systems through reversible processes such as channel opening and closing or signal transduction. In this study, computer modeling of a model transmembrane alpha-helix, (Ala)8-Leu-Pro-Phe-(Ala)8, in a medium of low polarity (dielectric = 2), is used to examine the occurrence and energetic accessibility of Pro-mediated conformational interconversions. Leu psi and chi 1, Pro psi, and Phe phi and chi 1 torsion angles were assigned random values so that a data base of 200 conformations for each of the cis and trans states was generated. The conformations were minimized and low-energy structures organized into families. This analysis demonstrated that the most populated lowest energy family is the Trans-I conformation, corresponding to proline in a kinked alpha-helix. Two additional trans structures, Trans-II and Trans-III, as well as a cis conformation, Cis-I, are also energetically competitive. Interconversions between the trans states could thus be mediated by changes at a single torsion angle, accompanied by minor local hydrogen-bonding rearrangements. This work substantiates that membrane-buried proline can provide the basis for conformational transitions between discrete alpha-helix-based structures in a nonpolar environment.

NMR studies of retinal proteins

A review is given of the use of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to study bacteriorhodopsin and bovine rhodopsin. Solution and solid-state approaches are included. The studies of the bacterial proton pump examine the chromophore, the peptide backbone, and the protein side chains. The studies of the bovine visual pigment are limited to the chromophore. Various forms of each pigment are considered. Both structural and dynamic features are addressed.