Cornigerine, a potent antimitotic Colchicum alkaloid of unusual structure. Interactions with tubulin

Colchicine Alkaloids and Synthetic Analogues: Current Progress and Perspectives

Colchicine, the main alkaloid of Colchicum autumnale, is one of the most famous natural molecules. Although colchicine belongs to the oldest drugs (in use since 1500 BC), its pharmacological potential as a lead structure is not yet fully exploited. This review is devoted to the synthesis and structure-activity relationships (SAR) of colchicine alkaloids and their analogues with modified A, B, and C rings, as well as hybrid compounds derived from colchicinoids including prodrugs, conjugates, and delivery systems. The systematization of a vast amount of information presented to date will create a paradigm for future studies of colchicinoids for neoplastic and various other diseases.

Structural Modification of the 3,4,5-Trimethoxyphenyl Moiety in the Tubulin Inhibitor VERU-111 Leads to Improved Antiproliferative Activities

Colchicine binding site inhibitors (CBSIs) hold great potential in developing new generations of antimitotic drugs. Unlike existing tubulin inhibitors such as paclitaxel, they are generally much less susceptible to resistance caused by the overexpression of drug efflux pumps. The 3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl (TMP) moiety is a critical component present in many CBSIs, playing an important role in maintaining suitable molecular conformations of CBSIs and contributing to their high binding affinities to tubulin. Previously reported modifications to the TMP moiety in a variety of scaffolds of CBSIs have usually resulted in reduced antiproliferative potency. We previously reported a potent CBSI, VERU-111, that also contains the TMP moiety. Herein, we report the discovery of a VERU-111 analogue 13f that is significantly more potent than VERU-111. The X-ray crystal structure of 13f in complex with tubulin confirms its direct binding to the colchicine site. In addition, 13f exhibited a strong inhibitory effect on tumor growth in vivo.

Natural antitubulin agents: importance of 3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl fragment

Microtubules are polar cytoskeletal filaments assembled from head-to-tail and comprised of lateral associations of α/β-tubulin heterodimers that play key role in various cellular processes. Because of their vital role in mitosis and various other cellular processes, microtubules have been attractive targets for several disease conditions and especially for cancer. Antitubulin is the most successful class of antimitotic agents in cancer chemotherapeutics. The target recognition of antimitotic agents as a ligand is not much explored so far. However, 3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl fragment has been much highlighted and discussed in such type of interactions. In this review, some of the most important naturally occurring antimitotic agents and their interactions with microtubules are discussed with a special emphasis on the role of 3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl unit. At last, some emerging naturally occurring antimitotic agents have also been tabulated.

Anti-mitotic activity of colchicine and the structural basis for its interaction with tubulin

In this review, an attempt has been made to throw light on the mechanism of action of colchicine and its different analogs as anti-cancer agents. Colchicine interacts with tubulin and perturbs the assembly dynamics of microtubules. Though its use has been limited because of its toxicity, colchicine can still be used as a lead compound for the generation of potent anti-cancer drugs. Colchicine binds to tubulin in a poorly reversible manner with high activation energy. The binding interaction is favored entropically. In contrast, binding of its simple analogs AC or DAAC is enthalpically favored and commences with comparatively low activation energy. Colchicine-tubulin interaction, which is normally pH dependent, has been found to be independent of pH in the presence of microtubule-associated proteins, salts or upon cleavage of carboxy termini of tubulin. Biphasic kinetics of colchicines-tubulin interaction has been explained in light of the variation in the residues around the drug-binding site on beta-tubulin. Using the crystal structure of the tubulin-DAMAcolchicine complex, a detailed discussion on the pharmacophore concept that explains the variation of affinity for different colchicine site inhibitors (CSI) has been discussed.

Phytochemical study and cytotoxicity evaluation of Colchicum stevenii Kunth (Colchicaceae): A Jordanian meadow saffron

Isolation, characterization, and biological evaluation of active components of Colchicum stevenii Kunth (Colchicaceae) are described. Colchicum stevenii is an unexplored Jordanian specie with toxic reputation. Directed by brine shrimp lethality test (BST), methanolic extraction, liquid-liquid partition, preparative TLC, and semi-preparative HPLC, it resulted in the isolation of six cytotoxic compounds. The compounds, reported for the first time from this specie, are: (-)-colchicine (1), 2-demethyl-(-)-colchicine (2), (-)-cornigerine (3), beta-lumicolchicine (4), (-)-isoandrocymbine (5) and (-)-O-methylandrocymbine (6). A new, in-house developed, acidic-based reverse-phase gradient semi-preparative HPLC method for the separation of colchisides is presented here. Structural elucidation was based on spectroscopic techniques principally; 1H-NMR and low resolution EIMS. Based on BST results, reported as LC50 values in microg mL(-1) (ppm) with 95% confidence intervals, (-)-colchicine (2.5 ppm) and (-)-cornigerine (2.7 ppm) were the most potent.

Novel benzopyridothiadiazepines as potential active antitumor agents

The synthesis of novel thiadiazepine derivatives, that could be considered as constraint analogues of E-7010, are reported. These molecules were evaluated for their antiproliferative activity toward the murine L1210 leukemia cell line. Flow cytometric studies performed on L1210 cells with the most cytotoxic compounds showed an accumulation of the cells in the G2/M phases of the cell cycle with a significant percentage of tetraploid cells (8N DNA content). Submicromolar cytotoxicities were observed with compounds 2b, 4b, 4e, 4g, and 4i. Two of them, compounds 2b and 4b, were found to be potent inhibitors of tubulin polymerization with IC50 of respectively 3.8 and 2.4 microM compared to 2.4 microM for desoxypodophyllotoxin. A 4-methoxyphenylethyl substitution on the pyridinyl nitrogen of the benzopyridothiadiazepine was found to be essential for the antiproliferative activity. The in vitro activities of compounds 2b and 4b make benzopyridothiadiazepine dioxides a promising new class of tubulin binders which warrant further in vivo evaluation.

An analysis of cytotoxic botanical formulations used in the traditional medicine of ancient Persia as abortifacients

We report here an analysis of plants used by traditional healers of ancient Persia to induce abortions. Six herbal formulations that contain 39 different species from 21 plant families with their vernacular names, English names, amounts used, and their methods of preparation are reported. Our initial objective of this ethnobotanical analysis was to evaluate the validity and the efficacy of the plants used by (1) comparing other reported uses of these plants in traditional medicine, (2) investigating the medical and pharmacological literature on the medicinal properties of the plant species used, and (3) investigating the reported cytotoxic effects of compounds prevalent in these plants. Previous phytochemical analyses have shown that a number of plant species are rich in coumarin compounds that have potential antineoplastic or cytotoxic activities. Our results indicate a correlation between the reported use of these plants as abortifacients and their cytotoxic (antineoplastic) effects. In addition, we discuss the process in which this ethnobotanical investigation led to the discovery of dicoumarol (a coumarin anticoagulant) as a potential chemotherapeutic agent.

RPR112378 and RPR115781: two representatives of a new family of microtubule assembly inhibitors

A screening program aimed at the discovery of new antimicrotubule agents yielded RPR112378 and RPR115781, two natural compounds extracted from the Indian plant Ottelia alismoides. We report their isolation, structural determination, and mechanisms of action. RPR112378 is an efficient inhibitor of tubulin polymerization (IC(50) = 1.2 microM) and is able to disassemble preformed microtubules. Regarding tubulin activity, RPR115781 is 5-fold less active than RPR112378. Tubulin-RPR112378 complexes, when isolated by gel filtration, were able to block further tubulin addition to growing microtubules, a mechanism that accounts for the substoichiometric effect of the drug. RPR112378 was found to prevent colchicine binding but not vinblastine binding to tubulin. Although colchicine binding is known to induce an increase of tubulin GTPase activity, no such increase was observed with RPR112378. We show that RPR112378 is a highly cytotoxic compound and that RPR115781 is 10, 000-fold less active as an inhibitor of KB cell growth. Part of the cytotoxicity of RPR112378 is probably caused by a reaction of addition with sulfhydryl groups, an observation that has not been made with RPR115781. In conclusion, these molecules represent a new class of inhibitors of microtubule assembly with potential therapeutic value.

Antitumor agents. 199. Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship study of the colchicine binding site ligands using comparative molecular field analysis

Inhibitors of tubulin polymerization interacting at the colchicine binding site are potential anticancer agents. We have been involved in the synthesis of a number of colchicine site agents, such as thiocolchicinoids and allocolchicinoids, which are colchicine analogues, and 2-phenyl-quinolones and 2-aryl-naphthyridinones, which are the amino analogues of cytotoxic antimitotic flavonoids. The most cytotoxic of the latter compounds strongly inhibit binding of radiolabeled colchicine to tubulin, and these agents therefore probably bind in the colchicine site of tubulin. We have applied conventional CoMFA and q(2)-GRS CoMFA to identify the essential structural requirements for increasing the ability of these compounds to form tubulin complexes. The CoMFA model for the training set of 51 compounds yielded cross-validated R(2) (q(2)) values of 0.637 for conventional CoMFA and 0.692 for q(2)-GRS CoMFA. The predictive power of this model was confirmed by successful activity prediction for a test set of 53 compounds with known potencies as inhibitors of tubulin polymerization. The activities of 88% of the compounds were predicted with absolute value of residuals of less than 0.5. The predictive q(2) values were 0.546 for conventional CoMFA and 0.426 for q(2)-GRS CoMFA. The conventional CoMFA model with the highest predictive q(2) (0.546) was analyzed in detail in terms of underlying structure-activity relationships.

Antitumor agents. 196. Substituted 2-thienyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-ones: their synthesis, cytotoxicity, and inhibition of tubulin polymerization

As part of our continuing search for potential anticancer drug candidates in the 2-aryl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-one series, we have synthesized a series of substituted 2-thienyl-1, 8-naphthyridin-4-ones. Most compounds showed significant cytotoxic effects (log GI(50) < -4.0; log molar drug concentration required to cause 50% growth inhibition) against a variety of human tumor cell lines in the National Cancer Institute's in vitro screen, including cells derived from solid tumors such as non-small-cell lung, colon, central nervous system, melanoma, ovarian, prostate, and breast cancers. The most active compounds (31-33,40) demonstrated strong cytotoxic effects with ED(50) values in the micromolar or submicromolar range in most of the tumor cell lines. The most cytotoxic compounds inhibited tubulin polymerization at concentrations substoichiometric to the tubulin concentration. The most potent inhibitors of polymerization (40,42,43) had effects comparable to those of the potent antimitotic natural products podophyllotoxin and combretastatin A-4 and to that of NSC 664171, a particularly potent, structurally related analogue. Only compound 40 was a potent inhibitor of the binding of radiolabeled colchicine to tubulin, and it was both the most cytotoxic agent and the most effective inhibitor of polymerization among the newly synthesized compounds.

Tubulin as a target for anticancer drugs: agents which interact with the mitotic spindle

Tubulin is the biochemical target for several clinically used anticancer drugs, including paclitaxel and the vinca alkaloids vincristine and vinblastine. This review describes both the natural and synthetic agents which are known to interact with tubulin. Syntheses of the more complex agents are referenced and the potential clinical use of the compounds is discussed. This review describes the biochemistry of tubulin, microtubules, and the mitotic spindle. The agents are discussed in relation to the type of binding site on the protein with which they interact. These are the colchicine, vinca alkaloid, rhizoxin/maytansine, and tubulin sulfhydryl binding sites. Also included are the agents which either bind at other sites or unknown sites on tubulin. The literature is reviewed up to October 1997.

Antitumor agents. 181. Synthesis and biological evaluation of 6,7,2',3',4'-substituted-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-2-phenyl-4-quinolones as a new class of antimitotic antitumor agents

A novel series of 6,7,2',3',4'-substituted-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-2-phenyl- 4-quinolones were synthesized and evaluated for interactions with tubulin and for cytotoxic activity against a panel of human tumor cell lines, including ileocecal carcinoma (HCT-8), breast cancer (MCF-7), lung carcinoma (A-549), epidermoid carcinoma of the nasopharynx (KB), renal cancer (CAKI-1), and melanoma cancer (SKMEL-2). Most compounds (18, 20, 22-27) showed potent cytotoxic and antitubulin effects. The most active compounds (23, 26, 27) demonstrated strong cytotoxic effects with ED50 values in the nanomolar or subnanomolar range in almost all tumor cell lines. Three active racemates (20, 22, 25) were separated into the enantiomers, and generally, the optically pure (-)-isomers (20a, 22a, 25a) exhibited greater biological activity than the racemates or (+)-isomers. Cytotoxicity and antitubulin activity were closely correlated, with the most active compounds (23, 26, 27) having effects comparable to those of colchicine, podophyllotoxin, and combretastatin A-4.

Antitumor agents. 174. 2',3',4',5,6,7-Substituted 2-phenyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-ones: their synthesis, cytotoxicity, and inhibition of tubulin polymerization

Two series of 2',3',4',5,6,7-substituted 2-phenyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-ones and 2-phenylpyrido[1,2-alpha]pyrimidin-4-ones have been synthesized and evaluated as cytotoxic compounds and as inhibitors of tubulin polymerization. Most 2-phenyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-ones showed potent cytotoxic and antitubulin activities, whereas 2-phenylpyrido[1,2-alpha]pyrimidin-4-ones showed no activity in either assay. In general, a good correlation was found between cytotoxicity and inhibition of tubulin polymerization in the 2-phenyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-one series. The 2-phenyl-1,8-naphthyridin-4-ones (44-49) with a methoxy group at the 3'-position showed potent cytotoxicity against most tumor cell lines with GI50 values in the low micromolar to nanomolar concentration range in the National Cancer Institute's 60 human tumor cell line in vitro screen. Introduction of substituents (e.g. F, Cl, CH3, and OCH3) at the 4'-position led to compounds with reduced or little activity and substitution at the 2'-position resulted in inactive compounds. The effects of various A-ring substitutions on activity depend on the substitution in ring C. Compounds 44-50 were potent inhibitors of tubulin polymerization, with activity nearly comparable to that of the potent antimitotic natural products colchicine, podophyllotoxin, and combretastatin A-4. Compounds 44-49 also inhibited the binding of radiolabeled colchicine to tubulin, but the inhibition was less potent than that obtained with the natural products. Further investigation is underway to determine if substitution at the 3'-position and multisubstitutions in ring C will result in compounds with increased activity.

Computational and molecular modeling evaluation of the structural basis for tubulin polymerization inhibition by colchicine site agents

The computer-automated structure evaluation programs MultiCASE and CASE were used to perform a quantitative structure-activity relationship study on tubulin polymerization inhibitors. A learning set of 536 chemicals (202 active. 27 marginal, and 307 inactive), built using IC50 values for inhibition of tubulin polymerization or mitosis from this and previous studies, was used for artificial intelligence self-teaching. The algorithms successfully predicted the activity of agents in the learning set with > 90% accuracy. Seventeen MultiCASE and twelve CASE (mostly included in the MultiCASE set) biophores (substructures significantly correlated with activity) were identified with a probability > 0.95. Here we present the biophores of podophyllotoxins, colchicinoids, and certain combretastatins, each examined for structure-activity relationships. For the podophyllotoxins and colchicinoids in the learning set, the correlations between observed and predicted potencies were > 0.85. The algorithms recognized the importance of several known site, electronic, and steric effects in the two classes. A predictive QSAR (R2 = 0.98) was developed for combretastain A-2 and dihydrocombretastatin analogues. The MultiCASE/CASE analyzes were used in combination with molecular models to study relative orientations of colchicine, podophyllotoxin, combretastatin A-4, and steganacin at the colchicine site. This resulted in a new hypothesis, consistent with extensive published experimental data, in which the C-ring and part of the B-ring of colchicine overlap with the A- and B-rings of podophyllotoxin. Consequently, the trimethoxyphenyl rings of colchicine and podophyllotoxin occupied different regions of space, each pointing out from a hydrophobic 'core' occupied by the overlapping biophores. The molecular model of the highly potent combretastatin A-4 could fit into the model binding site in at least three different ways. The developed QSARs were used to identify the potent microtubule stabilizer discodermolide. Its identification, in concert with recently reported findings, suggest potential overlap in the colchicine and paclitaxel binding sites on tubulin.

Antitumor activity of combretastatin-A4 phosphate, a natural product tubulin inhibitor

The tubulin-binding natural product combretastatin A-4 (CA-4) was tested for antitumor activity against fresh human tumors in vitro and 2 mouse tumors, both in vitro and in vivo. In colony forming assays using 10% fetal bovine serum, CA-4 was inhibitory in 27/40 human ovary cancers with a mean IC50 of 3.18 micrograms/mL for a 1-hour exposure (n = 35 specimens) and 0.27 microgramf1p4for a continuous exposure to CA-4 for 11-14 days (n = 5 specimens). Murine B-16 melanoma and P-388 leukemia were also highly sensitive to CA-4 in vitro with an identical IC50 value of 0.0007 micrograms/mL for continuous drug exposure for 8 days. Comparable in vitro cell culture studies performed in serum concentrations higher than 10%, revealed a significant loss of cytotoxic potency. Using the same reversed-phase HPLC technique as developed for paclitaxel, CA-4 was shown to bind to serum proteins (> or = 30,000 mw) > 99% and to albumin approximately 70%. CA-4 was only marginally active (25% increased lifespan) in DBA/2 mice bearing P-388 leukemia who were given doses of 100 mg/kg IP on either days, 1, 5 and 9 (p = 0.075 by Wilcoxon analysis) or on consecutive days 1-9 (p = 0.19 compared to control). A higher IP dose of 150 mg/kg on days 1, 5 and 9 did not delay subcutaneous B-16 melanoma tumor growth in C57/B1 mice. These findings demonstrate a substantial loss of antitumor efficacy for CA-4 in physiologic serum concentrations in vitro. No consistent antitumor activity was observed in two murine tumor models in vivo.

Podophyllotoxin, steganacin and combretastatin: natural products that bind at the colchicine site of tubulin

A large number of antimicrotubule agents are known that bind to tubulin in vitro and disrupt microtubule assembly in vitro and in vivo. Many of these agents bind to the same site on the tubulin molecule, as does colchicine. Of these, the natural products podophyllotoxin, steganacin and combretastatin are the subjects of this review. For each of these, the chemistry and biochemistry are described. Particular attention is given to stereochemical considerations. Biosynthetic pathways for podophyllotoxin and congeners are surveyed. The binding to tubulin and the effects on microtubule assembly and disassembly are described and compared. In addition, structural features important to binding are examined using available analogs. Several features significant for tubulin interaction are common to these compounds and to colchicine. These are described and the implications for tubulin structure are discussed. The manifold results of applying these agents to biological systems are reviewed. These actions include effects that are clearly microtubule mediated and others in which the microtubule role is less obvious. Activity of some of these compounds due to inhibition of DNA topoisomerase is discussed. The range of species in which these compounds occur is examined and in the case of podophyllotoxin is found to be quite broad. In addition, the range of species that are sensitive to the effects of these compounds is discussed.

Interactions of colchicine with tubulin

Colchicine exerts its biological effects through binding to the soluble tubulin heterodimer, the major component of the microtubule. The colchicine-binding abilities of tubulins from a variety of sources are summarized, and the mechanism of colchicine binding to brain tubulin is explored in depth. The relationship between colchicinoid structure and tubulin binding activity provides insight into the structural features of colchicine responsible for high affinity binding to tubulin and is reviewed for analogs in the colchicine series. The thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of the association are described and evaluated in terms of the binding mechanism. Colchicine binding to tubulin results in unusual alterations in the low energy electronic spectra of colchicine. The spectroscopic features of colchicine bound to tubulin are discussed in terms of the nature of the colchicine-tubulin complex. Attempts to locate the high affinity colchicine binding site on tubulin are presented.

Antimitotic natural products combretastatin A-4 and combretastatin A-2: studies on the mechanism of their inhibition of the binding of colchicine to tubulin

Combretastatin A-4 (CS-A4), 3,4,5-trimethoxy-3'-hydroxy-4'-methoxy-(Z)-stilbene, and combretastatin A-2 (CS-A2), 3,4-(methylenedioxy)-5-methoxy-3'-hydroxy-4'-methoxy-(Z)-stilbene, are structurally simple natural products isolated from the South African tree Combretum caffrum. They inhibit mitosis and microtubule assembly and are competitive inhibitors of the binding of colchicine to tubulin [Lin et al. (1988) Mol. Pharmacol. 34, 200-208]. In contrast to colchicine, drug effects on tubulin were not enhanced by preincubating CS-A4 or CS-A2 with the protein. The mechanism of their binding to tubulin was examined indirectly by evaluating their effects on the binding of radiolabeled colchicine to the protein. These studies demonstrated rapid binding of both compounds to tubulin even at 0 degrees C (binding was complete at the earliest times examined), in contrast to the relatively slow and temperature-dependent binding of colchicine. Although the binding of the C. caffrum compounds to tubulin was quite tight, permitting ready isolation of near-stoichiometric amounts of drug-tubulin complex even in the absence of free drug, both CS-A4 and CS-A2 dissociated rapidly from tubulin in the presence of high concentrations of radiolabeled colchicine. Apparent rate constants for drug dissociation from tubulin at 37 degrees C were 3.2 x 10(-3) s-1 for CS-A4, 4.8 x 10(-3) s-1 for CS-A2, and 2.9 x 10(-5) s-1 for colchicine (half-lives of 3.6, 2.4, and 405 min, respectively). Thus, the effectiveness of the C. caffrum compounds as antimitotic agents appears to derive primarily from the rapidity of their binding to tubulin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)