Effects of strobe light on adaptation of vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) to vision reversal

Plasticity and repair of the vestibulo-ocular reflex

It is self-evident, once one thinks about it, that the vestibulo-ocular reflex must have caretaker systems that keep it operating correctly over the span of a lifetime. When a movement is not correct (e.g., in position, speed, direction) it is said to be dysmetric. For the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR), if eye velocity is not equal and opposite to head velocity within reasonable limits, one has vestibulo-ocular dysmetria. Consequently, the function of the caretaker systems is to eliminate vestibulo-ocular dysmetria. These systems are first required to act just after birth when the gain of the reflex is usually not normal, and must be initially calibrated; and then maintained as the animal grows older; and then in adult life an important function of the caretaker systems is the compensation required after damage. The mechanisms of this caretaker system and ensuring motor learning is the focus of this chapter.

Saccade and vestibular ocular motor adaptation

PURPOSE

This paper focuses on motor learning within the saccadic and vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) oculomotor systems, vital for our understanding how the brain keeps these subsystems calibrated in the presence of disease, trauma, and the changes that invariably accompany normal development and aging. We will concentrate on new information related to multiple time scales of saccade motor learning, adaptation of the VOR during high-velocity impulses, and the role of saccades in VOR adaptation. The role of the cerebellum in both systems is considered.

METHODS

Review of data involving saccade and VOR motor learning.

RESULTS

Data supports learning within the saccadic and VOR oculomotor systems is influenced by 1). Multiple time scales, with different rates of both learning and forgetting (seconds, minutes, hours, days, and months). In the case of forgetting, relearning on a similar task may be faster. 2). Pattern of training, learning and forgetting are not similarly achieved. Different contexts require different motor behaviors and rest periods between training sessions can be important for memory consolidation.

CONCLUSIONS

The central nervous system has the difficult task of determining where blame resides when motor performance is impaired (the credit assignment problem). Saccade and VOR motor learning takes place at multiple levels within the nervous system, from alterations in ion channel and membrane properties on single neurons, to more complex changes in neural circuit behavior and higher-level cognitive processes including prediction.

Influence of eye motion on adaptive modifications of the vestibulo-ocular reflex in the rat

While sustained retinal slip is assumed to be the basic conditioning stimulus in adaptive modifications of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) gain, several observations suggest that eye motion-related signals might also be involved. We oscillated pigmented rats over periods of 20 min around the vertical axis, at 0.3 Hz and 20 degrees/s peak velocity, in different retinal slip and/or eye motion conditions in order to modify their VOR gain. The positions of both eyes were recorded by means of a phase-detection coil system with the head restrained. The main findings came from the comparison of two basic conditions--including their respective controls--in which one or both eyes were reversibly immobilised by threads sutured to the eyes. In the first condition the animals were rotated in the light with one eye immobilised and the other eye free to move but covered. Rotation in the light in this open-loop condition immediately elicited high-gain compensatory eye movements of the non-impeded, covered eye. At the end of this training procedure, the VOR gain increased by 43.2%. In the second condition, both eyes were immobilised and one eye was covered. The result was an increase in the VOR gain of 26.3%. These two conditions were similar as to the visuo-vestibular drive during the exposure, but different as to the resulting--and allowed--eye motion, showing that the condition where the larger eye movements occurred yielded the larger VOR gain change. Our data support the idea proposed by Collewijn and Grootendorst (1979, p. 779) and Collewijn (1981, p. 146) that "[retinal] slip and eye movements seem to be relevant signals for the adaptation of the rabbit's visuo-vestibular oculomotor reflexes".(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Short-term vestibulo-ocular reflex adaptation in humans. II. Error signals

We oscillated humans sinusoidally at 0.2 Hz for 1 h, using various combinations of rotations of the head and visual surround to elicit short-term adaptation of the gain of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR). Before and after each period of training, the gain of the VOR was measured in darkness, in response to a position step of head rotation. A small foveal target served as well as a full-field stimulus at driving VOR adaptation. Oscillation of the visual surround alone produced a substantial increase in the VOR gain. When the visual scene was rotated in phase with the head but with a larger amplitude to produce a reversal of the VOR, the VOR gain increased if the movement of the visual scene was much greater than that of the head, otherwise the gain decreased. We interpreted these results with a model of VOR adaptation that uses as its "error signal" the combination of motion of images on the retina (retinal slip) and any additional slow-phase eye velocity, beyond that generated by the VOR through the vestibular nuclei, necessary to prevent such retinal slip during head rotation. The slow phase velocity generated by the VOR is derived from "inferred head rotation", a signal based on the discharge of neurons in the vestibular nuclei that receive both labyrinthine and visual (optokinetic) inputs. The amplitude and sign of the ratio of the "error signal" to "inferred head velocity" determined the amplitude and the direction (increase or decrease) of VOR gain adaptation.

The relationship between vestibulo-ocular reflex plasticity and changes in apparent concomitant motion

The vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) and the apparent motion of a spot stimulus fixated during head movement (apparent concomitant motion, ACM) were measured before and after an adaptation period during which subjects attempted fixation of a stimulus which moved either in the same or opposite direction as head oscillations. Movements of the head were voluntary and paced by a metronome at either 0.5 or 2.0 Hz during the 4 min adaptation period. Pre- and post-adaptation measures of VOR and ACM were obtained for both frequencies of head oscillation. VOR and ACM were altered similarly by the period of exposure to correlated head and stimulus motion. Viewing a stimulus moving in the same direction as head motion resulted in decreased VOR gain and increased ACM in the opposite direction as head motion. Viewing a stimulus moving opposite head motion resulted in increased VOR gain and increased ACM in the same direction as head movement. Differences between pre- and post-measures tended to be maximal at the adaptation frequency, but transferred to a lesser degree to the other frequency. The results indicate that changes in motor and perceptual systems are related, and are consistent with the proposal that VOR gain is a determinant of ACM.

The effects of strobe rate of head-fixed visual targets on suppression of vestibular nystagmus

The effects of degrading retinal image velocity information on suppression of the vestibulo-ocular reflex have been assessed through tachistoscopic presentation of target sources in man. Subjects were required to fixate a head-fixed display during exposure to a 0.5 Hz sinusoidal angular oscillation of the head at +/- 60 degrees/s. In the first experiment it was found that the degree of suppression was progressively degraded as the interval between successive target presentations was increased from 10 to 3,000 ms. In the second experiment no effect of changing the duration of the target pulse was observed over a range from 20 to 1,000 microseconds. The results appear consistent with a model of visual motion sensitivity in which relative velocity information is obtained by the temporal integration of responses from spatially separated retinal cells.

Oculomotor response to rapid head oscillation (0.5-5.0 Hz) after prolonged adaptation to vision-reversal. "Simple" and "complex" effects

This study examined long-term (up to 27 days) effects of maintained vision reversal on (i) smooth visual tracking with head still, (ii) oculomotor response to actively, generated head oscillation and (iii) "spontaneous" saccades. Dove prism goggles produced horizontal, but not vertical (sagittal plane), vision reversal. Eye movements were recorded by EOG; head movements by an electro-magnetic search coil. Both visual tracking and saccade dynamics remained unchanged throughout. In contrast, both the ocular response to active head oscillations (goggles off and subject looking at a stationary target) and associated retinal image blur showed substantial and retained adaptive changes, akin to those previously found in the vestibulo-ocular reflex as tested in darkness at 0.17 Hz. However, several addition unexpected results emerged. First, in the fully adapted state smooth eye movements tended to be of reversed phase in the range 0.5-1.0 Hz (in spite of normal vision during tests), but of normal phase from about 2 Hz and above (in spite of negligible visual tracking in this upper range). Second, after permanent removal of the inverting goggles, this peculiar frequency response of the fully adapted state quickly (36 h) reverted to a dynamically simpler condition manifest as retained (2-3 weeks) attenuation of gain (eye vel./head vel.) which, as in control conditions, was monotonically related to frequency. From these two findings it is inferred that the fully adapted state may have comprised two separate components: (i) A "simple element of monotonic and long-lasting gain attenuation and (ii) a "complex", frequency labile, element which could be quickly rejected. Dynamic characteristics of the putative "complex" element were estimated by vectorial subtraction of the "simple" one from that of the fully adapted condition. The outcome suggests that the inferred "complex" condition might represent a predictive element. Two further findings are reported: (i) Substantially different vectors of the adapted response were obtained with normal and reversed vision at 3.0 Hz head oscillation, indicating a novel visual tracking. (ii) During head oscillation in the vesicle sagittal plane (in which vision was not reversed) there was never any image blur, indicating high geometric specificity in the adaptive process.

Differential visual adaptation of vertical canal-dependent vestibulo-ocular reflexes

Reversing vision in the horizontal (left-right) plane in humans induces adaptive mechanisms and even reversal of the horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex (HVOR). The present experiments were aimed at investigating if such adaptive modifications could be observed in the frontal plane by reversal of the torsional visual world movements. Torsional vestibulo-ocular reflex (TVOR) was measured in one subject who wore Dove prisms for 19 days. The gain of TVOR was tested in the dark with the head leaned backward and rotating around an earth vertical axis with sinusoidal rotation (1/6 HZ). The gain decreased from 0.27 to 0.13 at 70 degrees peak-to-peak amplitude, and from 0.3 to 0.11 at 45 degrees peak-to-peak amplitude after 19 days of prism-wearing. Full gain recovery was observed 10 days after prism removal. The results are compared with the observation that in the same situation the vertical VOR (up-down) is not reversed (Dove prisms do not reverse visual images in this plane). As the same four (vertical) canals produce both reflexes, it is suggested that central neuronal mechanisms allow the recognition of the geometrical pattern of visual reversals and selectively adapt the reflex in the relevant planes.

Adaptability of the vestibulo-ocular reflex to vision reversal in strobe reared cats

Optical reversal of vision brings about adaptive changes in the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) tending to reduce retinal image slip during head movement. The present experiments investigated this form of adaptation in cats whose complement of direction sensitive central visual cells had been substantially reduced by rearing in 8 Hz stroboscopic light. Horizontal vision reversal was produced by dove prisms carried in a skull-mounted mask. A scleral eye coil was used to measure horizontal eye movements. VOR gain and phase were measured in the dark during sinusoidal rotation using test stimuli of 1/8 Hz and 5- or 20 degrees/sec velocity amplitude. Initially, strobe reared cats produced virtually normal VOR in the dark, except for slight but significant exaggeration of the normal phase advancement to be expected at 1/8 Hz. Addition of their familiar strobe illumination produced almost perfect oculomotor compensation. Maintained vision reversal in both strobe and normal illumination produced similar patterns of adaptive change in normal and strobe reared subjects, i.e. all animals exhibited an initial fast, and subsequent much slower, stage of gain attenuation, with similar changes in phase. Thus, strobe rearing did not prevent the development of an essentially normal VOR, nor did it interfere significantly with the ability to adapt in response to vision reversal. Since strobe rearing depletes direction selective visual movement detectors in the cortex and superior colliculi, it is inferred that signals responsible for activating the adaptive process are probably carried mainly in the accessory optic, rather than cortical and collicular, visual system.