Functional properties of area 19 as compared to area 17 of the cat

Silencing "Top-Down" Cortical Signals Affects Spike-Responses of Neurons in Cat's "Intermediate" Visual Cortex

We examined the effects of reversible inactivation of a higher-order, pattern/form-processing, postero-temporal visual (PTV) cortex on the background activities and spike-responses of single neurons in the ipsilateral cytoarchitectonic area 19 (putative area V3) of anesthetized domestic cats. Very occasionally (2/28), silencing recurrent “feedback” signals from PTV, resulted in significant and reversible reduction in background activity of area 19 neurons. By contrast, in large proportions of area 19 neurons, PTV inactivation resulted in: (i) significant reversible changes in the peak magnitude of their responses to visual stimuli (35.5%; 10/28); (ii) substantial reversible changes in direction selectivity indices (DSIs; 43%; 12/28); and (iii) reversible, upward shifts in preferred stimulus velocities (37%; 7/19). Substantial (≥20°) shifts in preferred orientation and/or substantial (≥20°) changes in width of orientation-tuning curves of area 19 neurons were however less common (26.5%; 4/15). In a series of experiments conducted earlier, inactivation of PTV also induced upward shifts in the preferred velocities of the ipsilateral cytoarchitectonic area 17 (V1) neurons responding optimally at low velocities. These upward shifts in preferred velocities of areas 19 and 17 neurons were often accompanied by substantial increases in DSIs. Thus, in both the primary visual cortex and the “intermediate” visual cortex (area 19), feedback from PTV plays a modulatory role in relation to stimulus velocity preferences and/or direction selectivity, that is, the properties which are usually believed to be determined by the inputs from the dorsal thalamus and/or feedforward inputs from the primary visual cortices. The apparent specialization of area 19 for processing information about stationary/slowly moving visual stimuli is at least partially determined, by the feedback from the higher-order pattern-processing visual area. Overall, the recurrent signals from the higher-order, pattern/form-processing visual cortex appear to play an important role in determining the magnitude of spike-responses and some “motion-related” receptive field properties of a substantial proportion of neurons in the intermediate form-processing visual area—area 19.

Graded classes of cortical connections: quantitative analyses of laminar projections to motion areas of cat extrastriate cortex

Current hierarchical models of the cerebral cortex are mainly based on qualitative connection studies. From wheatgerm-agglutinin-horseradish peroxidase injections, we examined the laminar patterns of projections to and between the three major subdivisions of the motion-processing lateral suprasylvian (LS) complex [areas posteromedial lateral suprasylvian area (PMLS), anteromedial lateral suprasylvian (AMLS), posterolateral lateral suprasylvian area (PLLS)] of cat extrastriate cortex and of an adjoining form-processing area, 21a. We counted approximately 145,000 labelled projection cells in 20 cortical areas in 11 cats, and applied various analyses to the data, expressed as the percent supragranular layer (%SG) origin of each connection. We report two main results. (i) A wide range of %SG values was obtained, both from each individual cat and across the 163 projections examined. Nonetheless, both hierarchical and non-parametric cluster analyses of the pooled connection origins suggested the presence of three distinct laminar projection classes, constrained by graded %SG values of 0-33%, 39-69% and 76-97%. These conformed, respectively, to feedback, lateral and feedforward laminar patterns seen qualitatively in our material. (ii) Hierarchical connectivity analyses suggested that PMLS, AMLS and PLLS are ordered in a hierarchical sequence. Macaque motion areas V5/MT, MST and FST are arranged in a similar sequence, and areas at equivalent levels of the two motion hierarchies have some analogous functional specializations. Our findings provide the first objective support for the three laminar projection classes that underpin existing theoretical models of hierarchical cortical organization, and they suggest that the implementation of higher-order motion processing evolved along similar lines in the cat and monkey visual cortex.

CLARIFYING HOMOLOGIES IN THE MAMMALIAN CEREBRAL CORTEX: THE CASE OF THE THIRD VISUAL AREA (V3)

1. Experiments in mammalian models are the main source of information on the neural architecture underlying human visual perception, establishing scientific boundaries for the interpretation of experiments using non-invasive techniques in humans and for the realistic modelling of visual processes. Thus, it is important to define the homology between visual areas in different species. 2. To date, relatively few visual areas can be defined with certainty across mammalian Orders. Here, we review the evidence pointing to the fact that the third visual area (V3; or area 19) is a crucial node of a system involved in shape recognition that exists in most, if not all, eutherian mammals. 3. The size and shape of area V3 are variable, even between species that belong to the same Order. Although some features of the visuotopic organization of V3 are constant (including the relative location of the representations of the upper and lower quadrant and correspondence between the anterior border and the representation of the vertical meridian of the visual field), others are variable between species and even individuals. A complex pattern of representation, involving topological discontinuities, can exist. 4. In addition to its location in relation to the first (V1) and second (V2) visual areas, the identification of V3 homologues can be aided by certain other features, including low myelination, weak cytochrome oxidase reactivity, response properties that are indicative in the processing of stimulus shape, relationship to clusters of neurons forming interhemispheric connections and projections from the koniocellular (W-cell-like) components of the lateral geniculate nucleus. 5. Recent research in primates has clarified the organization of the V3 homologue in members of this Order. Regions of cortex that were formerly thought to belong to V3 (including a densely myelinated region near the dorsal midline) are better considered as part of a separate dorsomedial area, involved in motion analysis and visuomotor integration. The redefined V3, which includes the 'ventral posterior area' and parts of the dorsolateral complex proposed by earlier studies, is very similar to V3 (area 19) of other species in terms of structure and function.

Phase-disparity coding in extrastriate area 19 of the cat

Binocular interactions were investigated in area 19 of the anaesthetized cat using dichoptically presented phase-shifted static spatial frequency gratings that flickered at a fixed temporal rate. More than two-thirds of the binocular cells showed phase specificity to static phase disparities leading to either summation or facilitation interactions. This proportion of spatial disparity selectivity was higher than that shown for the same area (one-third of the units) when drifting light bars or drifting spatial frequencies were used to create disparities. The range of phase disparities encoded by binocular cells in area 19 is inversely related to the optimal spatial frequency of the dominant eye. Thus, cells in this area are tuned to coarse spatial disparities which, as supported by behavioural studies, could reflect its involvement in the analysis of stereoscopic pattern having gross disparities but devoid of motion cues. Because of the nature of its interconnections with numerous visual cortical areas, area 19 could serve as a way station where stereoscopic information could be first analysed and sent to other higher order areas for a complete representation of three-dimensional objects.

Modulations of the processing of line discontinuities under selective attention conditions?

We examined whether the processing of discontinuities involved in figure-ground segmentation, like line ends, can be modulated under selective attention conditions. Subjects decided whether a gap in collinear or parallel lines was located to the right or left. Two stimuli were displayed in immediate succession. When the gaps were on the same side, reaction times (RTs) for the second stimulus increased when collinear lines followed parallel lines, or the reverse, but only when the two stimuli shared the same orientation and location. The effect did not depend on the global form of the stimuli or on the relative orientation of the gaps. A frame drawn around collinear elements affected the results, suggesting a crucial role of the "amodal" orthogonal lines produced when line ends are aligned. Including several gaps in the first stimulus also eliminated RT variations. By contrast, RT variations remained stable across several experimental blocks and were significant for interstimulus intervals from 50 to 600 msec between the two stimuli. These results are interpreted in terms of a modulation of the processing of line ends or the production of amodal lines, arising when attention is selectively drawn to a gap.

Cellular response to texture and form defined by motion in area 19 of the cat

The present study examined the neuronal sensitivity in area 19 of the cat to a motion-defined bar and to texture. Sensitivity was tested in normal, lesioned (areas 17-18) and split-chiasm cats using a kinematogram, as well as a textured bar drifting on a uniform light background and a light bar drifting on a stationary textured background. Texture density was varied. The results indicate that almost all cells of area 19 recorded in the three groups of cats responded to a motion-defined bar or to its edges. Texture density influenced the responses in that the discharge rate increased as density decreased. However, the majority of cells were sensitive to the highest texture density kinematogram. Moreover, the neural responses of all cats were either independent of the density of the textured bar or background, or were modulated by it. These results show that cells in area 19 can signal the presence of a kinetic bar and that the density of either the textured bar, the background or both can influence figure-ground detection. The results are interpreted with respect to how various inputs influence the function of area 19.

Effects of a benzodiazepine, lorazepam, on motion integration and segmentation: an effect on the processing of line-ends?

Previous studies have shown that the perceptual integration of component motions distributed across space is inhibited whenever segmentation cues, such as line-ends, are salient. Herein, we investigate to what extent enhanced inhibition induced by lorazepam, a benzodiazepine facilitating the fixation of GABA on GABAA receptors, modifies the balance between motion integration and motion segmentation at the behavioural level. Motion integration was tested in 16 healthy volunteers taking a single and oral dose of either placebo or lorazepam (0.038 mg kg-1). The stimulus consisted of an outlined diamond presented behind four, otherwise invisible, apertures and translating along a circular trajectory (Lorenceau & Shiffrar (1992). Vision Research, 32, 263-273). Under these conditions, recovering the global diamond direction requires the integration of the component motions available within each aperture. The observers were asked to discriminate the global, clockwise or counter-clockwise, diamond direction under difficult--at high luminance contrasts--or easy--at low luminance contrasts--conditions. Overall, reaction times and error rates increased in the lorazepam group as compared to the placebo group, suggesting strong non-specific effects. However, the changes in performance in the lorazepam group are not homogeneous across conditions, suggesting that lorazepam also induces specific effects that modulate the integration/segmentation balance. Additional experiments performed with visible apertures or visible diamond vertices indicate that the effects of lorazepam are unlikely to reflect a deficit of motion processing or motion integration mechanisms since performance is only slightly impaired in the lorazepam as compared to the placebo group under these conditions. These results suggest that lorazepam might specifically modulate the saliency of line-ends, presumably because processing these features involves inhibitory mechanisms using GABA as a neuromediator, and in turn modify the balance between motion integration and segmentation.

Spatial and temporal matching of receptive field properties of binocular cells in area 19 of the cat

The spatial and temporal properties of single neurons were investigated in area 19 of the cat. We evaluated the matching of binocular receptive field properties with regard to the respective strength of the ipsilateral and contralateral inputs. Results indicate that most cells in area 19 are well tuned to spatial and temporal frequencies and exhibit relatively low contrast threshold (mean=6.8%) when assessed using optimal parameters and tested through the dominant eye. Spatial resolution (mean=0.75 c/degree), optimal spatial frequencies (mean=0.16 c/degree) were relatively low and spatial bandwidths (mean=2.1 octaves) were broader as compared to those of cells in area 17 but comparable to those of cells in other extrastriate areas. On the other hand temporal resolution (mean=10.7 Hz), optimal temporal frequency (mean=4.5 Hz) and temporal bandwidths (mean=2.9 octaves) were higher and broader than in primary visual cortex. A significant relationship exists between most of the cell's properties assessed through either eye. For some parameters, such as spatial and temporal resolution, ocular dominance was shown to be significantly related to the extent of matching between the two eyes. For these parameters, binocular cells that exhibited a balanced ocular dominance were generally well matched with regard to the receptive field properties of each eye whereas the largest mismatches were found in cells that were more strongly dominated by one eye. These results suggest that visual input contributes to the activation of cells in area 19 in a redundant manner, possibly attesting to the multiplicity of parallel pathways to this area in the cat.

A metabolic mapping study of orientation discrimination and detection tasks in the cat

Increasing evidence suggests that a large number of distinct cortical areas and associated subcortical structures participate in the processing of visual information and that different aspects of visual scenes are evaluated in different areas. This necessitates identification of cortical and subcortical regions cooperating in particular visual tasks. Using the 2-deoxyglucose technique, we monitored the differential activation of areas in the cat visual cortex participating in an orientation discrimination and a detection task. Concordant with previous lesion studies, we found increased activity levels in area 17 in the discrimination condition relative to the detection condition. In addition, the 2-deoxyglucose technique revealed discrimination-related increased activations in the claustrum, the putamen and in parts of the anteromedial, anterolateral and posterolateral lateral suprasylvian visual areas. Regions activated differentially with the detection task comprised subdivisions of areas 17, 18, 19 and 21, posterior area 7 (7p), several areas of the posterior part of the middle and posterior suprasylvian sulcus, the pulvinar complex and the superior colliculus. These results show that the 2-deoxyglucose technique is useful to investigate cognitive brain functions, and that different sets of cortical and subcortical regions are activated during two visual tasks with similar visual stimulation.

Spatial and temporal frequency selectivity of cells in area 21a of the cat

1. The spatial and temporal response properties of single cells in area 21a of the anaesthetized cat were assessed using drifting sinusoidal gratings presented at the optimum orientation for each cell. 2. Responses to sinusoidal gratings were dominated by an elevation of the mean discharge, with a relatively small modulated component at the temporal frequency of grating drift. The relative modulation ratio for the majority of cells was less than 1, similar to complex cells in the striate cortex. 3. Of those cells responsive to stimulation with sinusoidal gratings, 94% displayed spatial bandpass characteristics. Values derived from spatial frequency tuning curves were: mean optimum spatial frequency, 0.26 cycles deg-1; mean spatial resolution, 0.86 cycles deg-1; mean spatial bandwidth, 1.8 octaves; and mean normalized bandwidth, 1.3. Two cells (6%) displayed spatial low-pass characteristics. 4. Approximately half our sample of cells (44%) displayed temporal low-pass tuning, while 35% displayed temporal bandpass characteristics. The mean optimum temporal frequency of bandpass cells was 3.3 Hz and the mean temporal bandwidth 1.9 octaves. The remaining cells were classified as temporal broadband (17%) and temporal high-pass (4%). 5. We conclude that the dominant functional input to cells with relatively high spatial frequency selectivity and/or temporal low-pass response properties most probably arises from area 17. The responses of the remaining cells may be explained by input from area 17 or 18.

Binocular interaction and disparity coding in area 19 of visual cortex in normal and split-chiasm cats

Binocular disparity, resulting from the projection of a three-dimensional object on the two spatially separated retinae, constitutes one of the principal cues for stereoscopic perception. The binocularity of cells in one hemisphere stems from two sources: (1) the ganglion cells in the homonymous temporal and nasal hemiretinae and (2) the contralateral hemisphere via the corpus callosum (CC). The objectives of this study were, on one hand, to determine whether disparity-sensitive cells are present in a "higher order" area, namely area 19 of the visual cortex, of the cat and, on the other hand, to ascertain whether the CC contributes to the formation of these cells. As in areas 17-18, two types of disparity-sensitive neurons were found: one type, showing maximal interactive effects around zero disparity, responded with strong excitation or inhibition when the stimuli presented independently to the two eyes were in register. These neurons are presumed to signal stimuli situated about the fixation plane. The other type, also made up of two subtypes of opposed valencies, gave maximum responses at one set of disparities and inhibitory responses to the other set. These are presumed to signal stimuli situated in front of or behind the fixation plane. Unlike areas 17-18, however, disparity-sensitive cells in area 19 of the normal cat were less finely tuned and their proportion was lower. In the split-chiasm animal, very few cells were sensitive to disparity. These results, when coupled with behavioral data obtained with destriate animals, indicate that (1) area 19 is probably less involved in the analysis of disparity information than area 17, (2) the disparity-sensitive neurons that are sensitive to disparity are not involved in the resolution of very fine three-dimensional spatial detail, and (3) the CC only determines a limited number of these cells in the absence of normal binocular input.

Different motion sensitive units are involved in recovering the direction of moving lines

We studied direction discrimination for lines moving obliquely relative to their orientation. Manipulating contrast, length and duration of motion, we found systematic errors in direction discrimination at low contrast, long length and/or short durations. These errors can be accounted for by a competition between ambiguous velocity signals originating from contour motion processing units and signals from line terminator processing units. The dynamic of this competition can be described by a simple model involving two different classes of processing units with different contrast thresholds, different integration time constants and different levels of response saturation.

A comparison of magnification functions in area 19 and the lateral suprasylvian visual area in the cat

A retinotopic map can be described by a magnification function that relates magnification factor to visual field eccentricity. Magnification factor for primary visual cortex (V1) in both the cat and the macaque monkey is directly proportional to retinal ganglion cell density. However, among those extrastriate areas for which a magnification function has been described, this is often not the case. Deviations from the pattern established in V1 are of considerable interest because they may provide insight into an extrastriate area's role in visual processing. The present study explored the magnification function for the lateral suprasylvian area (LS) in the cat. Because of its complex retinotopic organization, magnification was calculated indirectly using the known magnification function for area 19. Small tracer injections were made in area 17, and the extent of anterograde label in LS and in area 19 was measured. Using the ratio of cortical area labeled in LS to that in area 19, and the known magnification factor for area 19 at the corresponding retinotopic location, we were able to calculate magnification factor for LS. We found that the magnification function for LS differed substantially from that for area 19: central visual field was expanded, and peripheral field compressed in LS compared with area 19. Additionally, we found that the lower vertical meridian's representation was compressed relative to that of the horizontal meridian. We also examined receptive field size in areas 17, 19, and LS and found that, for all three areas, receptive field size was inversely proportional to magnification factor.

Processing of form and motion in area 21a of cat visual cortex

Extracellular recordings from single neurons have been made from presumed area 21a of the cerebral cortex of the cat, anesthetized with N2O/O2/sodium pentobarbitone mixture. Area 21a contains mainly a representation of a central horizontal strip of contralateral visual field about 5 deg above and below the horizontal meridian. Excitatory discharge fields of area 21a neurons were substantially (or slightly but significantly) larger than those of neurons at corresponding eccentricities in areas 17, 19, or 18, respectively. About 95% of area 21a neurons could be activated through either eye and the input from the ipsilateral eye was commonly dominant. Over 90% and less than 10% of neurons had, respectively, C-type and S-type receptive-field organization. Virtually all neurons were orientation-selective and the mean width at half-height of the orientation tuning curves at 52.9 deg was not significantly different from that of neurons in areas 17 and 18. About 30% of area 21a neurons had preferred orientations within 15 deg of the vertical. The mean direction-selectivity index (32.8%) of area 21a neurons was substantially lower than the indices for neurons in areas 17 or 18. Only a few neurons exhibited moderately strong end-zone inhibition. Area 21a neurons responded poorly to fast-moving stimuli and the mean preferred velocity at about 12.5 deg/s was not significantly different from that for area 17 neurons. Selective pressure block of Y fibers in contralateral optic nerve resulted in a small but significant reduction in the preferred velocities of neurons activated via the Y-blocked eye. By contrast, removal of the Y input did not produce significant changes in the spatial organization of receptive fields (S or C type), the size of the discharge fields, the width of orientation tuning curves, or direction-selectivity indices. Our results are consistent with the idea that area 21a receives its principal excitatory input from area 17 and is involved mainly in form rather than motion analysis.

Visuotopic organization of corticocortical connections in the visual system of the cat

It has recently been demonstrated that, in contrast with the retinogeniculocortical projection, the corticocortical connections in the cat present a high degree of convergence and divergence. This suggests that some corticocortical connections link nonvisuotopically corresponding regions. Using fine-grain electrophysiological mapping and anatomical tracing, we have set out to test this possibility by placing a small injection of retrograde tracer in area 17 and by comparing the extent of visual field encoded in the region of area 18 containing labeled cells and that represented in the uptake zone. The results demonstrate that the size of the labeled region on the surface of area 18 is independent of eccentricity and that, despite its anisotrophy, this region of labeling encodes a broadly circular region of visual field that is larger than that encoded in the uptake zone of the tracer in area 17. For example, in the representation of lower visual field, a virtual point in area 17 that encodes a visual field region 4 degrees in diameter receives afferents from a region of area 18 encoding a region 11 degrees wide. Examination of the density of labeled cells in the labeled zone in area 18 reveals that the highest density is observed in a region in visuotopic correspondence with the injection site. However, high labeling density is also occasionally found in patches that do not represent the same visual field region as the injection site. Many receptive fields of neurons recorded in the labeled zone in area 18 only partially overlap or fail to overlap the visual field region encoded by the injection site. The results also demonstrate that the extent of visual field encoded in the labeled zone in area 18 is the same as that represented in the region of intrinsic labeling in area 17. It is suggested that cortical afferents coming from several cortical areas and converging on a column of cells in area 17 cover the same extent of visual field and that this cortical network constitutes the structural basis for the modulatory regions of the receptive field as well as the synchronization of neurons in different cortical areas.

Orientation discrimination in the cat: its cortical locus. I. Areas 17 and 18

An elementary unit of visual pattern and form perception is thought to be the orientation of edges; this element has been studied extensively by neurophysiologists using oriented line segments or bars. These same stimuli have been used in the present study to measure threshold discriminations in cats before and after cortical lesions of areas 17 and/or 18. Control experiments showed that the discriminations were made by using a single cue, orientation, and that other stimulus parameters, width, length and contrast of the bar, were optimized. The extent of the lesions was evaluated anatomically from cell and fiber stained sections through cortex and thalamus, matched to retinotopic maps of Tusa et al. (Cortical Sensory Organization, Vol. 2, Humana Press, pp. 1-31, '81) and Sanderson (Journal of Comparative Neurology 143:101-118, '71), and physiologically from visual field position of receptive fields of cells recorded in areas neighboring the lesions. Lesions involving area 17 and large parts of area 18 produced a marked deficit in orientation discrimination which included a loss in retention, and after retraining a substantial increase in thresholds for up to 3 years when tested with long bars. There was no recovery of discrimination when the animals were tested with short bars. Lesions which involved area 17 plus small parts of 18, or lesions of areas 18 and 19, produced no retention deficit and resulted in an increase in thresholds only at low contrast and narrow width. These experiments revealed an excellent correlation between lesion locus and size and behavioral deficit. They indicate that the cortical representation of bar orientation used for discrimination is distributed within and across areas 17 and 18. The spread of the distribution depends on other stimulus parameters such as bar width and length. Furthermore the experiments show that neither the most narrowly tuned cells nor the X-cell system is required for fine orientation discrimination of a long bar.

Contribution of area 19 to the foreground-background-interaction of the cat: an analysis based on single cell recordings and behavioural experiments

The contribution of area 19 to pattern discrimination in the cat was studied by single cell recordings in this area and by behavioural experiments before and after bilateral lesions. In order to make quantitative comparisons between behavioural performance and that of cell systems, we introduced a new parameter that characterizes visual neurons by their signal-to-noise (S/N) thresholds. A structured visual background made up of Gaussian visual broadband noise which could be moved was superimposed on the signal (moving bars or outline patterns) and the S/N characteristics of the response were determined by varying the signal intensity. The detection performance of cats after bilateral lesion of area 19 showed no deficits. Only for slowly (11 deg/s) or quickly (110 deg/s) moving patterns, or when the background was moved relative to stationary patterns, did we find slight, but significant deficits in the low S/N range. However, when the S/N ratios were higher than 5, all cats achieved their full preoperative performances and no deficits remained. The S/N thresholds of neurons in area 19 were much higher than those found for neurons in areas 17 and 18. The lowest thresholds were found with a stationary background. Introduction of relative velocity between background and bar resulted in intermediate thresholds and the highest thresholds were observed for stimulus configurations lacking relative velocity. These effects correspond to the performance of the intact animal, in which introduction of relative motion increases the performance. The S/N thresholds did not correlate with levels of spike rate recorded at high S/N ratios, direction selectivity or speed preference, indicating that S/N threshold measurements provide a significant additional description of visual neurons. A limited number of area 19 cells recorded in area 17/18 lesioned animals showed very similar thresholds suggesting that this property may be independent of the intactness of areas 17 and 18. The residual performance by 17/18 lesioned cats in detecting small patterns corresponds well to the characteristics of the single cells of area 19. This suggests that area 19 might be able to make a considerable contribution to this task when areas 17/18 are eliminated, though by itself it seems not to be able to sustain the level of performance mediated by them. The contribution of area 19 is restricted to performances at high S/N ratios only.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Orientation discrimination in the cat: a distributed function

Cats were trained to make fine orientation discriminations with stimuli similar to those used in physiological experiments--narrow, light bars 12 degrees long--before and after various combinations of lesions of areas 17 and 18. Discrimination thresholds were measured at different contrast levels and different bar widths, both pre- and postoperatively, for up to 1.5 years after the lesion. For high contrast stimuli, lesions restricted to area 17 or area 18 had little effect, but those lesions involving area 17 and a substantial part of area 18 raised thresholds. In the latter case there was a relationship between the amount of area 18 spared and the bar width at which discrimination was impaired. At low contrast deficits were seen only for narrow widths. These results lead to the following conclusions. (i) Orientation discrimination is a function distributed within and across areas 17 and 18. (ii) How this function is distributed in this cortex depends on stimulus width. (iii) The X system does not carry the signal necessary for orientation discrimination. (iv) Cells most narrowly tuned for orientation, which reside in the part of area 17 subserving central vision, do not determine the orientation discrimination threshold.

Visual response properties of cortical inputs to an extrastriate cortical area in the cat

The existence of multiple areas of extrastriate visual cortex raises the question of how the response properties of each area are derived from its visual input. This question was investigated for one such area in the cat, referred to here as the Clare-Bishop area (Hubel & Wiesel, 1969); it is the region of lateral suprasylvian cortex that receives input from area 17. A novel approach was used, in which kainic acid was injected locally into the Clare-Bishop area, making it possible to record directly from afferent inputs. The response properties of the great majority of a sample of 424 presumed afferents resembled cells in areas 17 and 18. Thus, a systematic comparison was made with cells from area 17's upper layers, the source of its projection to the Clare-Bishop area (Gilbert & Kelly, 1975), to see whether these afferents had distinctive properties that might distinguish them from cells projecting to areas 18 or 19. Some differences did emerge: (1) The smallest receptive fields typical of area 17 were relatively scarce among afferents. (2) Direction-selective afferents were more abundant than were such cells in area 17. (3) End-stopped afferents were extremely rare, although end-stopped cells were common in area 17's upper layers. Despite these differences, afferents were far more similar in their properties to cells in areas 17 and 18 than to cells in the Clare-Bishop area. Compared to the latter, afferents showed major discrepancies in receptive-field size, in direction selectivity, in end-stopping, and in ocular dominance distribution. These differences seem most likely to stem from circuitry intrinsic to the Clare-Bishop area.

Physiological studies on the feedback connection to the striate cortex from cortical areas 18 and 19 of the cat

The functional characteristics of the feedback connections from areas 18 and 19 to area 17 in the cat have been examined with electrophysiological techniques. The experiments involved single unit recording in laminae 2 and 3 of area 17 while stimulating electrically a small region of area 18 or 19. It was found that a precise retinotopic correspondence between the sites of recording and stimulation was necessary before neurons of area 17 could be activated by electrical stimulation in extrastriate areas. Latencies were long compared to those obtained after stimulation of the optic radiation. The mean latency for orthodromic drive from area 19 was 10.4 ms and 6.1 ms from area 18, suggesting that the conduction velocities in these pathways are of the order of 1 m/s. The jitter of the latency after repeated orthodromic stimulation was often shorter than 0.3 ms, indicating that a large number of the sampled neurons received a direct drive from area 18 or from area 19. The functional properties of neurons driven from area 19 were different from those of cells driven from area 18. Thus, most striate neurons orthodromically driven from area 19 were of the SH and S type whereas the cells activated by area 18 stimulation belonged to the C and B categories.

Parallel processing of binocular disparity in the cat's retinogeniculocortical pathways

In the cat, parallel streams of information processing have been traced from X-, Y- and W-type retinal ganglion cells to visual cortical areas 17 (X-, Y- and W-type), 18 (Y-type) and 19 (W-type). In the present study we have examined, in the anaesthetized and paralysed adult cat, the role played by X-, Y- and W-subsystems, projecting to areas 17 and 19, in the processing of binocular retinal disparity. The tapetal reflection technique was used to monitor residual eye movements and to provide a map, for each eye, of the retinal blood vessels which could later be compared with retinal wholemounts stained with cresyl violet to reveal the area centralis. The receptive-field disparities of cells recorded from areas 17 and 19 were compared with each other and with reference to the visual axes defined by the area centralis of each eye. Cells of area 19 (receiving W-type input) had horizontal receptive-field disparities that were significantly more divergent than those of the cells in area 17 and 17-18 'border region'. Referred to the area centralis, the mean horizontal receptive-field disparity in area 19 was -0.5 degrees (+/- 0.8 degrees). The mean horizontal receptive-field disparity of area 17 (receiving X-, Y- and W-type input) was convergent with respect to the visual axis at +2 degrees (+/- 0.5 degrees). Finally, the mean horizontal receptive-field disparity of the cells in the 17-18 border region (which receive mainly Y-type input) was even more convergent (2.6 degrees +/- 1.5 degrees) than that of area 17. Binocular interactions of cortical neurons were tested with the Risley biprism technique. Area 19 cells had maximal responses to binocular stimulation when the receptive-field disparities were either close to zero or slightly divergent. In contrast, area 17 cells tended to respond optimally to disparities that were either slightly or strongly convergent. At the level of the lateral geniculate nucleus there were significant differences between the receptive-field disparities inferred from the comparison of receptive-field positions of adjacent neurons recorded on either side of the border between the A and A1 geniculate laminae and those inferred from a similar comparison at the C1-C2 border. The mean horizontal disparities inferred from the interlaminar comparison at the A-A1 border were +2.1 degrees (+/- 0.3 degrees); those inferred from the interlaminar comparison at the C1-C2 border -0.2 (+/- 0.2 degrees) were more divergent.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Patterns of cytochrome oxidase activity in areas 17, 18 and 19 of the visual cortex of cats and kittens

The laminar pattern of cytochrome oxidase activity was studied in visual cortical areas 17, 18 and 19 in adult cats and kittens, following electrophysiological determination of the boundaries of these areas in all but the youngest animals. The patterns of cytochrome oxidase staining and the cytoarchitectonic appearances of areas 17, 18 and 19 were compared. At all ages activity was especially high in the region of layers IV and VI in areas 17 and 18, and was low in all laminae in area 19. The results suggest that the degree of cytochrome oxidase activity in these regions of the visual cortex may be related to the strength and type of projection that they receive from the lateral geniculate nucleus. The cytochrome oxidase technique is a useful means of defining the 18/19 border, and may help locate the boundary between areas 17 and 18, in both adult cats and kittens.

Colliding targets: evidence for spatial localization within the motion system

The ability to judge the relative location of moving targets is seriously degraded if the targets move in different directions. The vernier acuity for a target in which the two components move in the same direction is not impaired until target velocity exceeds about 4 deg/sec. If the components are moving along trajectories which differ in direction by more than 15 deg, vernier thresholds rise significantly at target speeds greater than 1 deg/sec. The conditions which affect stationary vernier acuity, i.e. separation of target components, duration, and orientation, do not account for the loss in acuity. Our results suggest that localization for moving targets depends on directionally-selective motion detectors.

Lack of binocular activation of cells in area 19 of the Siamese cat

Single cells were recorded in area 19 of 8 Siamese cats. Receptive fields (RFs) were typical for this area in terms of size, directional specificity and type. However, 69 out of the 70 units found were monocularly driven through the contralateral eye. Moreover, the amount of excursion of RFs into the ipsilateral visual field was more limited than that generally demonstrated for areas 17 and 18, extending to a maximum of 5 degrees with very few cells having RFs situated completely within the ipsilateral hemifield.

Performance in the cat's visual system: a behavioural and neurophysiological analysis

Behavioural research, neurophysiological experiments and computer simulations are used in an attempt to analyze pattern recognition in the cat's visual system. The methods were chosen in such a way that the measurable performance data resulting from behavioural and neurophysiological experiments can be combined simply. It is shown that, with minor modifications, the methods can be adapted to every estimation and detection problem like pattern discrimination, movement detection and to the assessment of lesion effects, so that they are widely applicable. The system analysis permits the correct prediction of behavioural experiments and an approximate assignment of functions to the areas 17, 18 and 19 for the task set.

Relationship between preferred orientation and receptive field position of neurons in extrastriate cortex (area 19) in the cat

Orientation sensitivity is a characteristic of most retinal ganglion cells (Levick and Thibos, '82), most relay cells in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (Vidyasagar and Urbas, '82), and most neurons in the visual cortex (Hubel and Wiesel, '62) in the cat. In the retina there is a systematic relationship between receptive field position (polar angle) and preferred orientation. Outside of the area centralis most retinal ganglion cells respond best to stimuli oriented radially, i.e., oriented parallel to the line connecting their receptive fields to the area centralis (Levick and Thibos, '82). This relationship is strongest along the horizontal meridian (the visual streak) and appears to reflect the innate, radial orientation of retinal ganglion cell dendritic fields (Leventhal and Schall, '83). A relationship between preferred orientation and polar angle also exists in cat striate cortex; outside of the area centralis representation most cells respond best to lines oriented radially. This relationship is strongest for S-type cells, the most orientation-selective cells, and cells in regions representing the horizontal meridian (Leventhal, '83). To determine if similar relationships exist in cat extrastriate cortex, the preferred orientations and receptive field positions of 226 neurons in area 19 were studied. We find that, as in area 17, most area 19 cells outside of the representation of the area centralis respond best to lines oriented radially; this relationship is strongest for the cells having the narrowest receptive fields and in regions subserving the horizontal meridian. Unlike in striate cortex, in area 19 the relationship between preferred orientation and polar angle is not dependent upon cell type (S or C) or to the degree of orientation sensitivity exhibited. Also, in area 19, but not in area 17, the relationship between preferred orientation and polar angle fails for the cells having the widest receptive fields.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Meridional variations in the line orientation discrimination of the cat

Cat's differential orientation thresholds were measured with single lines presented in succession. Differential orientation thresholds measured at horizontal or vertical orientations were smaller (median 2.9 degrees) than those measured at oblique orientation (median 4.7 degrees). Replications of the experiments showed that the oblique effect was stable over a period of 2 years. Using the same behavioral methods grating acuity was measured and did not show an oblique effect. These behavioral observations are compared with the physiological data on orientation specificity of area 17 cells. This comparison suggests that the most likely explanation of the meridional variation in orientation discrimination is the meridional variation in orientation preference of area 17 S cells.

[14C]2-deoxyglucose demonstration of the organization of ocular dominance in areas 17 and 18 of the normal cat

The purpose of this study was to demonstrate the spatial organization of ocular dominance in the visual cortex of the cat. We administered [14C]2-deoxyglucose ([14C]2-DG) to 4 alert, monocularly stimulated cats; one eye had previously been removed from 3 of these cats, and the other cat had received a uniocular injection of tetrodotoxin (TTX). In areas 17 and 18, but not in area 19, we observed alternating regions of heavy and light label, which were clearest in layer IV. Near the representation of the area centralis, especially in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the stimulated eye, the labeled regions formed columns that extended from the pial surface to the white matter. In the representation of peripheral retina, especially in the hemisphere contralateral to the stimulated eye, the pattern was often (but not always) restricted to the middle layers. We conclude that this pattern of label reflects the organization of ocular dominance because: (1) we never observed this pattern in control cats in which both eyes were stimulated or neither eye was stimulated; (2) many characteristics of the pattern are consistent with physiological studies of ocular dominance, and (3) the width and spacing of the alternating label was consistent with the size of the patches of geniculocortical afferents representing the left and right eyes in layer IV of areas 17 and 18.

Effects of visual deprivation upon the geniculocortical W-cell pathway in the cat: area 19 and its afferent input

We studied the receptive field properties of 206 single units in area 19 of normal cats and 228 single units in area 19 of cats deprived of vision for 9-14 months by monocular lid suture. The ocular dominance of a sample of cells in area 17 of normal cats was studied for comparison. In some of these monocularly deprived animals, we also studied the sizes of relay cells in the parvocellular C laminae of the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus labeled by electrophoretic injections of horseradish peroxidase into area 19. In area 19 of normal cats, the large majority of cells, regardless of their laminar location and the retinal eccentricity of their receptive fields, were binocular. Most responded equally well to the two eyes. In area 17, (see also Leventhal and Hirsch, '78, '80) but not in area 19, the cells which had the narrowest receptive fields tended to be activated unequally by the two eyes. In area 19 of monocularly deprived cats, virtually all cells (97%), regardless of their laminar location and receptive field eccentricity, responded only to stimulation of the normal eye. Thus, the effects of monocular deprivation upon area 19 are apparently more severe than those reported for area 17. In area 17 significant numbers of neurons in layer 4 can be activated by the deprived eye (Shatz and Stryker, '78). Within the limits of our technique, measurements of relay cells in the parvocellular C laminae labeled by injections into area 19 of deprived cats indicated that cell size in the deprived C laminae was unaffected by the deprivation. In contrast, cells in the deprived A laminae of these cats were severely shrunken. These findings suggest that the types of relay found in the parvocellular C laminae (referred to collectively as W-cells) are not affected by visual deprivation as severely as are the X- and Y-cells in the A laminae. Since laminar location and receptive field width are related to binocularity in area 17 but not in area 19 and the sizes of relay cells in the parvocellular C laminae (see also Hickey, '80) are not seriously affected by monocular deprivation, it is suggested that binocular interactions in area 19 are mainly determined by connections among cortical cells.

Lack of binocularity in cells of area 19 of cat visual cortex following monocular deprivation

We have studied the visual receptive field properties of neurons in cortical area 19 of monocularly deprived cats. Almost all visually responsive units responded to stimulation of the non-deprived eye only. Receptive field properties assessed through the non-deprived eye were found to be normal. Monocular deprivation appears thus to have sharply reduced the normal binocularity of neurons in area 19. Since the W-cell component of the visual pathways provide the predominant input to area 19, our results suggest that W-cells are vulnerable to environmental manipulation.

Receptive field structure of area 19 as compared to area 17 of the cat

A total of 139 cells from area 19 along with a comparison sample of 172 cells from area 17 were classified using a system proposed by Orban and Kennedy, following Henry and consisting of 4 basic cell 'families', namely S, C, A and B, each having an end-stopped member: HS, HC, HA and HB. The two basic parameters separating the 4 families are firstly spatial overlap of ON and OFF subregions and secondly receptive field (RF) width. Spatial overlap was studied quantitatively in a number of these cells using multiple presentations of stationary slits or moving light and dark edges. RF width was determined quantitatively using bars moving at different velocities across the RF. It was found that cells with spatially nonoverlapping and overlapping subregions are present in both areas. S and HS cells, which show similarities with simple cells, were encountered in area 19 but they constituted only 18% of the population as opposed to 55% in area 17. C and HC cells, reminiscent of complex cells, were about as common in area 19 as in area 17. In both areas C cells were the only group which consistently discharged equally well or better in response to diffuse light turned on and off than when presented with light bars. A and B families formed a minority in both areas. Area 19 contained a larger proportion of nonoriented and undriveable units, as well as a special category of cells preferring stimuli with a width larger than the length ('rectangle cells'). RF width was generally larger in area 19 than in area 17 and its distribution in area 19 showed distinct peaks. In the part of area 19 subserving central vision these peaks appeared with a periodicity of 0.8 degrees, suggesting that cells in this zone are supplied by one or more rows of a uniform set of afferents having a RF center diameter of about 0.8 degrees. The identification of this population as W-relay cells is supported by the long latencies found in cells from this part of area 19. It is concluded that basic principles underlying the structure of the RF are similar in both areas 19 and 17.