Differential inhibition of acetylcholinesterase molecular forms in normal and Alzheimer disease brain

A review of butyrylcholinesterase as a therapeutic target in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease

OBJECTIVE

To examine the role of butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) in cholinergic signaling and neurologic conditions, such as Alzheimer's disease (AD). The rationale for inhibiting cholinesterases in the management of AD, including clinical evidence supporting use of the dual acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and BuChE inhibitor rivastigmine, is discussed.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed searches were performed using butyrylcholinesterase as a keyword. English-language articles referenced in PubMed as of September 2011 were included. Study Selection and Data Synthesis: English-language articles related to BuChE considered to be of clinical relevance to physicians were included. English-language articles specifically related to AChE were not included, as the role of AChE in cholinergic signaling and the underlying pathology of AD is well documented. Reference lists of included publications were used to supplement the search.

RESULTS

AChE and BuChE play a role in cholinergic signaling; BuChE can hydrolyze acetylcholine and compensate for AChE when levels are depleted. In the AD brain, AChE levels decrease, while BuChE levels are reportedly increased or unchanged, with changes becoming more pronounced during the disease course. Furthermore, BuChE genotype may influence AD risk and rate of disease progression. Strategies that increase acetylcholine levels (eg, cholinesterase inhibitors) demonstrate symptomatic efficacy in AD. Rivastigmine has proven cognitive efficacy in clinical trials, and data suggest that its action is mediated, in part, by inhibition of BuChE. Retrospective analyses of clinical trials provide evidence that BuChE genotype may also influence treatment response.

CONCLUSIONS

AChE-selective inhibitors and a dual AChE and BuChE inhibitor demonstrate symptomatic efficacy in AD. Mounting preclinical and clinical evidence for a role of BuChE in maintaining normal cholinergic function and the pathology of AD provides a rationale for further studies investigating use of rivastigmine in AD and the influence of BuChE genotype on observed efficacy.

Association between acetylcholinesterase and beta-amyloid peptide in Alzheimer's cerebrospinal fluid

The altered expression of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) in the brains of patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) has raised much interest of late. Despite an overall decrease in the AD brain, the activity of AChE increases around beta-amyloid plaques and indeed, the beta-amyloid peptide (Abeta) can influence AChE levels. Such evidence stimulated our interest in the possibility that the levels of AChE and amyloid might vary together in AD. We previously found that the different AChE forms present in both the brain and in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of AD patients varied in conjunction with abnormal glycosylation. Thus, the alterations in glycosylation are correlated with the accumulation of a minor subspecies of AChE monomers. We also recently analysed whether long-term exposure to the cholinesterase inhibitor (ChE-I) donepezil influences the AChE species found in AD CSF. The marked increase in CSF-AChE activity in AD patients following long-term treatment with donepezil was not paralleled by a rise in this subset of light variants. Hence, the correlation with the levels of CSF-Abeta is unique to these AChE species in patients receiving such treatment. The aim of this report is to review the links between AChE and beta-amyloid, and to discuss the significance of the responses of the distinct AChE species to ChE-I during the treatment of AD.

Cerebrospinal fluid acetylcholinesterase changes after treatment with donepezil in patients with Alzheimer's disease

We analyzed whether donepezil differently influences acetylcholinesterase (AChE) variants from cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) after long-term treatment. Overall CSF-AChE activity in AD patients before treatment was not different from controls, but the ratio between the major tetrameric form, G(4), and the smaller G(1) and G(2) species was significantly lower. AChE levels at study outset were found to correlate positively with beta-amyloid (1-42) (Abeta42). When patients were re-examined after 12 months treatment with donepezil, there was a remarkable increase in both the G(4) and the lighter species of CSF AChE. As compared with placebo, donepezil caused decreases in the percentage of AChE that failed to bind to the lectin concanavalin A and the antibody AE1. These non-binding species comprised primarily a small subset of G(1) and G(2) forms. In treated patients, these light variants were the only subset of CSF AChE that correlated with CSF-Abeta42 levels. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis showed that a 77-kDa band, attributed in part to inactive AChE, was lower in AD patients than in controls. Unlike enzyme activity, the intensity of this band did not increase after donepezil treatment. The varying responses of different AChE species to ChE-I treatment suggest different modes of regulation, which may have therapeutic implications.

Potencies and selectivities of inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase and its molecular forms in normal and Alzheimer's disease brain

Eight inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (AChE), tacrine, bis-tacrine, donepezil, rivastigmine, galantamine, heptyl-physostigmine, TAK-147 and metrifonate, were compared with regard to their effects on AChE and butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) in normal human brain cortex. Additionally, the IC50 values of different molecular forms of AChE (monomeric, G1, and tetrameric, G4) were determined in the cerebral cortex in both normal and Alzheimer's human brains. The most selective AChE inhibitors, in decreasing sequence, were in order: TAK-147, donepezil and galantamine. For BuChE, the most specific was rivastigmine. However, none of these inhibitors was absolutely specific for AChE or BuChE. Among these inhibitors, tacrine, bis-tacrine, TAK-147, metrifonate and galantamine inhibited both the G1 and G4 AChE forms equally well. Interestingly, the AChE molecular forms in Alzheimer samples were more sensitive to some of the inhibitors as compared with the normal samples. Only one inhibitor, rivastigmine, displayed preferential inhibition for the G1 form of AChE. We conclude that a molecular form-specific inhibitor may have therapeutic applications in inhibiting the G1 form, which is relatively unchanged in Alzheimer's brain.

Effects of huperzine A on acetylcholinesterase isoforms in vitro: comparison with tacrine, donepezil, rivastigmine and physostigmine

Five inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase, huperzine A, donepezil, tacrine, rivastigmine and physostigmine, were compared with regard to their effects on different molecular forms of acetylcholinesterase in cerebral cortex, hippocampus, and striatum from the rat brain. In general, huperzine A preferentially inhibited tetrameric acetylcholinesterase (G4 form), while tacrine and rivastigmine preferentially inhibited monomeric acetylcholinesterase (G1 form). Donepezil showed pronounced selectivity for G1 acetylcholinesterase in striatum and hippocampus, but not in cortex. Physostigmine showed no form-selectivity in any brain region. In cortex, the most potent inhibitors of G4 acetylcholinesterase were huperzine A (K(i) 7 x 10(-9) M) and donepezil (K(i) 4 x 10(-9) M). The potent inhibitors of cortical G1 acetylcholinesterase were donepezil (K(i) 3.5 x 10(-9) M) and tacrine (K(i) 2.3 x 10(-8) M). In hippocampus, huperzine A and physostigmine were the most potent inhibitors of G4 acetylcholinesterase, while donepezil and tacrine were most potent against G1 acetylcholinesterase. In striatum, huperzine A and donepezil were the most potent against G4 acetylcholinesterase, while again donepezil was the most potent against G1. Although the inhibition constants (K(i)) of these acetylcholinesterase inhibitors differed significantly from region to region, the nature of the inhibition did not vary. These results suggest that the use of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors in treatment of Alzheimer's disease must consider both form-specific and region-specific characteristics of acetylcholinesterase inhibition.

Selective inhibitors of butyrylcholinesterase: a valid alternative for therapy of Alzheimer's disease?

The brain of mammals contains two major forms of cholinesterases (ChEs): acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE). The two forms differ genetically, structurally and in their kinetics. Butyrylcholine is not a physiological substrate in mammalian brains which makes the function of BuChE difficult to interpret. In human brains, BuChE is found in neurons and glial cells as well as in neuritic plaques and tangles in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD). While AChE activity decreases progressively in the brain of patients with AD, BuChE activity shows some increase. In order to study the function of BuChE, we perfused intracortically the rat brain with a selective BuChE inhibitor. We found that extracellular acetylcholine levels increased 15-fold from 5 nmol/L to 75 nmol/L concentrations, with little cholinergic adverse effect in the animal. Based on these data, we postulated that two pools of ChEs may be present in the brain: one mainly neuronal and AChE dependent; and one mainly glial and BuChE dependent. The two pools show different kinetic properties with regard to regulation of acetylcholine concentration in the brain and can be separated with selective inhibitors. The recent development of highly selective BuChE inhibitors will allow us to test these new agents in patients with AD in order to find out whether or not they represent an advantage for the treatment of patients with AD as compared with selective (donepezil) or relatively non-selective (rivastigmine, galantamine) ChE inhibitors presently in use. The association between a BuChE-K variant and AD has not been confirmed in several studies. In conclusion, additional experimental and clinical work is necessary in order to elucidate the role of BuChE in normal brain function and in the brains of patients with AD. In the future, it may be possible that selective BuChE inhibitors will have a role in treatment of patients with advanced AD.

Eptastigmine: ten years of pharmacology, toxicology, pharmacokinetic, and clinical studies

Eptastigmine (heptyl-physostigmine tartrate) is a carbamate derivative of physostigmine in which the carbamoylmethyl group in position 5 of the side chain has been substituted with a carbamoylheptyl group. In vitro and ex vivo results suggest that eptastigmine has a long-lasting reversible brain cholinesterase (i.e., acetylcholinesterase and butyryl-cholinesterase) inhibitory effect. When administered in vivo to rodents by various routes, eptastigmine inhibits cerebral acetylcholinesterases (AChE) and increases acetylcholine (Ach) brain levels by 2500-3000%, depending on the dose. This effect leads to an improvement in the cerebral blood flow in the ischemic brain, excitatory and inhibitory effects on the gastrointestinal tract and to a protection from acute soman and diisopropylfluorophosphate intoxication. Eptastigmine, by either acute or chronic administration, has been found to have memory enhancing effects in different species of normal, aged and lesioned animals. It also restored to normal the age-related increase of EEG power without affecting spontaneous motor activity. Clinical investigations on more than 1500 patients with Alzheimer's disease demonstrated that eptastigmine significantly improved cognitive performance (as assessed by the cognitive subscale of the Alzheimer's Disease Assessment Scale) as compared with placebo. This improvement was most evident in patients with more severe cognitive impairment at the baseline. The relationship between patient performance and average steady-state AChE inhibition was described by an inverted U-shaped dose-response curve. Pharmacokinetic studies have revealed that after oral administration eptastigmine is rapidly distributed to the tissues and readily enters the CNS, where it can be expected to inhibit AChE for a prolonged period. Eptastigmine is generally well tolerated and the majority of adverse events (cholinergic) were mild to moderate in intensity. However, the adverse hematologic (granulocytopenia) effects reported in two studies have resulted in the suspension of further clinical trials.

Inhibition of cholinesterase-associated aryl acylamidase activity by anticholinesterase agents: focus on drugs potentially effective in Alzheimer's disease

The potency of a series of anticholinesterase (anti-ChE) agents and serotonin-related amines as inhibitors of the aryl acylamidase (AAA) activity associated with electric eel acetylcholinesterase (AChE) (EC 3.1.1.7) and horse serum butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) (EC 3.1.1.8) was examined and compared with the potency of the same compounds as ChE inhibitors. Neostigmine, physostigmine, BW 284C51, (+/-)-huperzine A, E2020, tacrine, edrophonium and heptyl-physostigmine were, in that order, the most potent in inhibiting eel AChE-associated AAA activity, their inhibitor constant (Ki) values being in the range 0.02-0.37 microM. The rank order of the same compounds as AChE inhibitors basically paralleled that of AAA, although they were in general stronger on AChE (Ki = 0.001-0.05). The peripheral anionic site inhibitors propidium and gallamine were inactive on AChE-associated AAA. Serotonin and its derivatives were slightly stronger on AAA (Ki = 7.5-30 microM) than on AChE (Ki = 20-140 microM). Tacrine (IC50 = 0.03 microM), diisopropylfluorophosphate (IC50 = 0.04 microM), heptyl-physostigmine (IC50 = 0.11 microM), physostigmine (IC50 = 0.15 microM) and tetra-iso-propylpyrophosphoramide (iso-OMPA) (IC50 = 0.75 microM) were the most potent in inhibiting horse serum BuChE-associated AAA activity. Serotonin and related amines were very weak on BuChE-associated AAA activity. These results indicate that the inhibitory potencies of the active site anti-ChE agents on the AAA activity associated with eel AChE and horse serum BuChE are closely correlated with their action on the respective ChE. In addition, the efficacy of tacrine, E2020, heptyl-physostigmine and (+/-)-huperzine A in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease is unlikely to be related to the action of these drugs on ChE-associated AAA.

Is there a rationale for the use of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors in the therapy of Alzheimer's disease?

Since the 1980s, the cholinergic hypothesis of the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease has proven to be a strong stimulus to pharmacological strategies aimed at correcting the cognitive deficit by manipulating cholinergic neurotransmission. Among these strategies, the one based on acetylcholinesterase inhibition is currently the most extensively developed for the therapy of Alzheimer's disease. The inhibitors' mechanisms of action are complex, including changes in the release of acetylcholine, and modulation of acetylcholine receptors. Various clinical trials of various inhibitors have shown that, on the whole, their effects were modest and, in the case of some drugs, were associated with frequent adverse reactions. Among the conceivable reasons for the limited efficacy of these drugs, those related to the pharmacological target deserve particular attention. This review, therefore, focuses on the complex nature of the acetylcholine system, the alterations of acetylcholinesterase and muscarinic receptor signal transduction in Alzheimer's disease, and the involvement of other neurotransmitters.

Synthesis and activity studies of N-[omega-N'-(adamant-1'-yl)aminoalkyl]- 2-(4'-dimethylaminophenyl)acetamides: in the search of selective inhibitors for the different molecular forms of acetylcholinesterase

A series of N-[omega-N'-(adamant-1'-yl)aminoalkyl]-2-(4'- dimethylaminophenyl)acetamides were synthesized and tested as acetylcholinesterase inhibitors. A significant selectivity toward acetylcholinesterases from various natural sources, mainly differing in their quaternary structure and solubility, was pointed out. The interest of this kind of molecules as potential therapeutic agents for Alzheimer's disease is discussed.

Differential recovery of acetylcholinesterase in guinea pig muscle and brain regions after soman treatment

1. In brain areas of untreated guinea-pigs the highest activity of acetylcholinesterase was seen in the striatum and cerebellum, followed by the midbrain, medulla-pons and cortex, and the lowest in the hippocampus. The activity in diaphragm was seven-fold lower than in the hippocampus. 2. At 1 h after soman (27 micrograms/kg) administration the activity of the enzyme was dramatically reduced in all tissues studied. In muscle the three major molecular forms (A12, G4 and G1) showed a similar degree of inhibition and a similar rate of recovery and the activity had returned to normal by 7 days. 3. In the brain soman inhibited the G4 form more than the G1 form. The hippocampus, cortex and midbrain showed the greatest reductions in enzyme activity. At 7 days the activity in the cortex, medulla pons and striatum had recovered but in the hippocampus, midbrain and cerebellum it was still inhibited. 4. Thus the effects of soman administration varied in severity and time course in the different tissues studied. However the enzyme activity was still reduced in all tissues at 24 h when the overt signs of poisoning had disappeared.

The cholinergic system in Alzheimer's disease

The past decade has witnessed an enormous increase in our knowledge of the variety and complexity of neuropathological and neurochemical changes in Alzheimer's disease. Although the disease is characterized by multiple deficits of neurotransmitters in the brain, this overview emphasizes the structural and neurochemical localization of the elements of the acetylcholine system (choline acetyltransferase, acetylcholinesterase, and muscarinic and nicotinic acetylcholine receptors) in the non-demented brain and in Alzheimer's disease brain samples. The results demonstrate a great variation in the distribution of acetylcholinesterase, choline acetyltransferase, and the nicotinic and muscarinic acetylcholine receptors in the different brain areas, nuclei and subnuclei. When stratification is present in certain brain regions (olfactory bulb, cortex, hippocampus, etc.), differences can be detected as regards the laminar distribution of the elements of the acetylcholine system. Alzheimer's disease involves a substantial loss of the elements of the cholinergic system. There is evidence that the most affected areas include the cortex, the entorhinal area, the hippocampus, the ventral striatum and the basal part of the forebrain. Other brain areas are less affected. The fact that the acetylcholine system, which plays a significant role in the memory function, is seriously impaired in Alzheimer's disease has accelerated work on the development of new drugs for treatment of the disease of the 20th century.

Determination of acetylcholine by on-line microdialysis coupled with pre- and post-microbore column enzyme reactors with electrochemical detection

A sensitive procedure consisting of a pre- and post-microbore column reactor sequence of a LC-electrochemical detection system coupled with on-line microdialysis system is described in the present study to measure endogenous acetylcholine concentration in freely moving rats. The pre-column packed, with immobilized choline oxidase and catalase, was used to remove choline, whereas the post-column, packed with immobilized acetylcholine oxidase and choline oxidase, was used to measure acetylcholine selectively. The detection limit of acetylcholine oxidase and choline oxidase, was used to measure acetylcholine selectively. The detection limit of acetylcholine was found to be 5 fmol/microliter (50 fmol/10 microliters). The usefulness of the described methodology was evaluated by examining the change in the striatal acetylcholine concentration of freely moving rats after physostigmine (0.5 mg/kg, s.c.) administration.

The neurochemistry of Alzheimer type, vascular type and mixed type dementias compared

We present the results of a meta-analysis of neurochemical changes in human post mortem brains of Alzheimer type (AD), vascular type (VD) and mixed type (MF) dementias, and matched controls based on 275 articles published between January 1980 and February 1994. Severity of degeneration between the different neurochemical systems is as follows, although ranking is difficult with regard to limited numbers of investigations in some neurochemical systems: Cholinergic system > serotonergic system > excitatory amino acids > GABAergic system > energy metabolism > NA > oxidative stress parameters > neuropeptides > DA. But, within a neurochemical system, degeneration is not evenly distributed. Spared parameters, e.g. muscarinic receptors and MAO-B, allow to make some suggestions for future therapeutic strategies.

Differential inhibition of soluble and membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase forms from mouse brain by choline esters with an acyl moiety of an intermediate size

Differential inhibitions of soluble and membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase forms purified from mouse brain were examined by the comparison of kinetic constants such as a Km value, a Kss value (substrate inhibition constant), and IC50 values of active site-selective ligands including choline esters. Membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase form (solubilized only in the presence of detergent) showed lower Km and Kss values than soluble acetylcholinesterase form (easily solubilized without detergent). Edrophonium expressed a slightly but significantly (p < 0.01) higher inhibition of detergent-soluble acetylcholinesterase form than aqueous-soluble acetylcholinesterase form, while physostigmine inhibited both forms with a similar potency. A remarkable difference in inhibition was observed using choline esters; although choline esters with acyl chain of a short size (acetyl- to butyrylcholine) or a long size (heptanoyl- to decanoylcholine) showed a similar inhibitory potency for two forms of acetylcholinesterase, pentanoylcholine and hexanoylcholine inhibited more strongly aqueous-soluble acetylcholinesterase than detergent-soluble acetylcholinesterase. Thus, it is suggested that the two forms of AChE may be distinguished kinetically by pentanoyl- or hexanoylcholine.

Cholinesterases colocalize with sites of neurofibrillary degeneration in aged and Alzheimer's brains

Acetylcholinesterase and butyrylcholinesterase have been associated with structures undergoing neurofibrillary degeneration, as well as with all types of senile plaques, in non-demented aged and Alzheimer's brains. At the electron microscope level, the reaction product of both enzymes, appeared to decorate paired helical filaments, straight filaments and beta A4 amyloid fibrils. Recent studies showed that cholinesterases were associated with amyloid at early stages, e.g., in diffuse plaques. In the present study, the interrelationship of cholinesterases to structures undergoing neurofibrillary degeneration was analyzed further. Tau immunoreactivity was compared to the staining pattern observed with the two esterases. Double protocols consecutively performed on the same sections, and counterstaining with thioflavin-S, confirmed the presence of cholinesterases in all structures with neurofibrillary degeneration. The conclusion that cholinesterases consistently colocalize with both neurofibrillary bundles and beta A4 amyloid fibrils at all stages of their accumulation, allows us to speculate on the possible role that these enzymes may play in either the formation or the consolidation of fibrillary aggregates.

Amphiphilic and hydrophilic forms of acetyl- and butyrylcholinesterase in human brain

Human brain acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) were sequentially extracted, first with a Tris-saline buffer (S1) and then with 1% (w/v) Triton X-100 (S2). About 20 and 30% of the AChE and BuChE activities were recovered in S1 and most of the remaining enzymes in S2. Main molecular forms of about 10.5 S and 12.0 S, G4 forms of AChE and BuChE, and smaller amounts of 4.5 S and 5.5 S forms, G1 species of AChE and BuChE, were measured in S1. Application of Triton X-114 phase partitioning and affinity chromatography on phenyl-agarose to S1 revealed that 25% of the AChE and none of the BuChE molecules displayed amphiphilic properties. Analysis of the enzyme activity retained by the phenyl-agarose showed that G1 AChE constituted the bulk of the amphiphilic molecules released without detergent. Main G4 forms of AChE and BuChE were found in the S2 extract. Eighty and 45% of the AChE and BuChE activities in S2 were measured in the detergent-rich phase by Triton X-114 phase partitioning. Thus, most of the AChE and about half of the BuChE molecules in S2 displayed amphiphilic properties. The main peak of BuChE, a 12.0 S form in gradients made with Triton X-100, splits into two peaks of 9.5 S and 12.5 S in Brij 96-containing gradients. This suggests that hydrophilic G4 BuChE forms are predominant in S1 and that hydrophilic and amphiphilic isoforms coexist in S2.