Cross-reactivity patterns of murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Antiviral cytotoxic T cells cross-reactively recognize disparate peptide determinants from related viruses but ignore more similar self- and foreign determinants

We have investigated the reactivities of cytotoxic T (Tc) cells against the two immunodominant, H-2K(k)-restricted determinants from the FLAVIVIRUS: Murray Valley encephalitis virus (MVE), MVE(1785) (REHSGNEI) and MVE(1971) (DEGEGRVI). The respective Tc cell populations cross-reactively lysed target cells pulsed with determinants from the MVE(1785)- and MVE(1971)-corresponding positions of six other flaviviruses, despite low sequence homology in some cases. Notably, anti-MVE(1785) Tc cells recognized a determinant (TDGEERVI) that shares with the determinant used for stimulation only the carboxyl-terminal amino acid residue, one of two H-2K(k) anchor residues. These reactivity patterns were also observed in peptide-dependent IFN-gamma production and the requirements for in vitro restimulation of memory Tc cells. However, the broad cross-reactivity appeared to be limited to flavivirus-derived determinants, as none of a range of determinants from endogenous mouse-derived sequences, similar to the MVE-determinants, were recognized. Neither were cells infected with a number of unrelated viruses recognized. These results raise the paradox that virus-immune Tc cell responses, which are mostly directed against only a few "immunodominant" viral determinants, are remarkably peptide cross-reactive.

High peptide affinity for MHC class I does not correlate with immunodominance

Cytotoxic T (Tc)-cell responses against influenza virus infection in BALB/c (H-2d) mice are dominated by Tc clones reactive to the viral nucleoprotein (NP). Here, we report investigations using recombinant vaccinia viruses (VV) encoding major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I H-2Kd molecules differing by a single amino acid from glutamine (wild-type, Kdw) to histidine (mutant, Kdm) at position 114 located in the floor of the peptide-binding groove. Influenza-infected target cells expressing Kdw were strongly lysed by Kd-restricted Tc cells against A/WSN influenza virus or the immunodominant peptide of viral NP (NPP147-155), whereas infected Kdm-expressing targets gave little or no lysis, respectively, thus showing the immunodominance of NPP147-155. Kdm-expressing target cells saturated with synthetic NPP147-155 (10-5 M) were lysed similarly to Kdw-expressing targets by NPP147-155-specific Tc cells. Thus the defect in influenza-infected Kdm-expressing targets was quantitative; insufficient Kdm-peptide complexes were expressed. Tc-cell responses against four other viruses or alloantigens showed no effect of Kdm. When peptide transport-defective cells were infected with VV-Kdw or VV-Kdm and co-infected with a recombinant VV encoding an endoplasmic reticulum-targeted viral peptide, two influenza haemaglutinin peptides caused higher expression of Kdw than NPP147-155 indicating their higher affinity for Kdw. These results are inconsistent with the hypothesis that immunodominance in the anti-influenza response reflects high affinity of the immunodominant peptide, but are consistent with skewing of the Tc-cell receptor repertoire.

Spontaneous mutation at position 114 in H-2Kd affects cytotoxic T cell responses to influenza virus infection

Vaccinia virus (VV)-encoded MHC class I Kd molecules which differ by a single amino acid change from glutamine (Kdw, wild type) to histidine (Kdm, mutant) at position 114 located in the floor of the peptide binding groove were compared in terms of peptide binding and cytotoxic T (Tc) cell recognition. Most anti-viral Tc cells were not affected or only marginally affected. However, the Kdm molecule did not detectably present the immunodominant peptide (NPP147-155) of influenza virus nucleoprotein (NP), encoded by the full-length NP gene either in influenza A virus or recombinant VV. This defect could be overcome by using exogenous synthetic NPP147-155 or translation from a minigene encoding NPP147-155 in VV. Kdw presented NPP147-155 encoded by the full-length NP gene, but Kdw-NPP147-155 complexes were at least 100-fold less abundant than after translation from a minigene.

The generation of memory antigen-specific cytotoxic T cell responses by CD28/CD80 interactions in the absence of antigen

The interaction of co-stimulatory molecules CD80/CD86 on antigen-presenting cells with CD28 on naive CD8+ cytotoxic T (Tc) cells is understood to be critical in the induction of Tc effectors. CD80 is capable of providing signal 2 for the activation of Tc cells, but has no effect if encountered in the absence of specific peptide/MHC complexes (signal 1). We have found that CD80 presented in vitro to resting memory viral-immune or alloimmune Tc cells can provide sufficient stimulus for the generation of effector Tc cells in the absence of specific antigen, the peptide/MHC class I complex. Effector Tc cells generated in vitro from influenza- or class I alloantigen-primed mice by co-stimulation in the absence of antigen require exogenous interleukin (IL)-2 signaling via the cell surface-expressed IL-2 receptor or, under conditions of IL-2 blockade, exogenous IL-7. Activation of memory Tc cells by signal 1 and 2 is independent of IL-2 and IL-7. Although memory influenza-immune Tc cells did respond to CD80 in the absence of antigen, the presence of antigen +CD80 enabled an earlier induction of these Tc cells and they retained their lytic activity in vitro over a longer time period. The capacity of memory Tc cells to be activated by signal 2 alone provides one explanation for the observed heterogeneity of phenotype of memory T cells in vivo and a possible mechanism for the maintenence of memory in the absence of persisting antigen.

Flavivirus-induced up-regulation of MHC class I antigens; implications for the induction of CD8+ T-cell-mediated autoimmunity

Infection of a wide variety of cells of human, mouse and other species' origin by flaviviruses such as WNV, YF, Den, MVE, KUN and JE, increases the cell-surface expression of MHC class I. This MHC class I up-regulation is not due to increased MHC class I synthesis per se, but the result of increased peptide availability in the ER for MHC class I assembly. This is most likely due to the interaction of the viral polyprotein with the ER membrane during viral replication. Flavivirus infection can overcome peptide deficiency in TAP-deficient or non-permissive cell lines such as RMA-S and Syrian hamster cells, BHK and NIL-2. The consequence of this increased MHC class I expression manifests itself in reduced susceptibility to NK cells and augmented lysis by Tc cells. In mice, long-term flavivirus-immune Tc cell memory formation is impaired, following the appearance of strong anti-self Tc cell reactivity observed in in vitro cultures from splenocytes of flavivirus-primed animals. We hypothesize that flavivirus-induced MHC class I up-regulation leads to transient T-cell autoimmunity, followed by down-regulation of both autoimmunity and virus-specific Tc cell memory. Furthermore, we speculate that flavivirus infections of humans in the tropics may be responsible for the observed lower incidence of overt autoimmunity in these geographic regions than in temperate climates where flaviviruses are not endemic.

Class I major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-transformed B lymphoblastoid cell lines against which they were raised

We have raised CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from three Epstein-Barr virus-seropositive donors by incubating peripheral blood lymphocytes with irradiated autologous B95.8-strain EBV-transformed B lymphoblastoid cells (LCL). However, to detect lysis in a standard 51Cr release assay of the LCL against which these CTL were raised, superinfection with recombinant vaccinia expressing the appropriate EBV protein or incubation with the peptide epitope was necessary. The untreated LCL were not lysed, even though Western blotting demonstrated that they expressed the EBV antigens containing the CTL epitopes. We have found CTL of this phenotype that are restricted by human leukocyte antigen-A2, -A3, -B7, or -B39, and which recognize the EBV latent proteins, EBV nuclear antigen (EBNA)-3A, EBNA-3C, or terminal protein. During these experiments, we identified a new human leukocyte antigen-A3-restricted EBNA-3A epitope, residues 603-611, RLRAEAGVK. We raised a spontaneous LCL, transformed by endogenous EBV, from one donor, but this was also not lysed. For at least one of the epitopes, CTL from another donor lysed the LCL without superinfection or addition of peptides. We conclude that the CTL were unable to achieve a high enough avidity of interaction with untreated LCL to trigger effector function, although the LCL were able to stimulate them to grow in vitro for up to 4 mo. To assess whether a small percentage of the LCL might possess a higher antigen density, we used an assay of tumor necrosis factor release from a CTL clone, which was able to detect antigen-bearing cells representing only 1% of a stimulating LCL population. Nevertheless, the untreated autologous LCL line failed to stimulate tumor necrosis factor release.

Difference between antigen-binding receptor repertoires in effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes and their secondary precursors (memory cells) specific to H-2Kb

The fine specificity of antigen-binding receptors was compared in pCTL-2 and secondary effector CTL (cytotoxic T lymphocytes) induced in vivo with the H-2Kb alloantigen in recombinant inbred mice. The lymphocyte preparations were enriched by elution from macrophage monolayers of various origins, including the donor (B6 strain), the H-2Kb mutant bm1, the H-2Kk allele B10.A(4R) and the recipient strain B10.D2(R101) as a control. Anti-Kb pCTL-2 eluted from third-party bm1 or B10.A(4R) monolayers gave rise to CTL progeny that lysed, equally well, both donor TC and those third-party TC from whose monolayer the pCTL-2 had been eluted, but which were unable to lyse irrelevant third-party TC. The lytic activities of secondary CTL whose precursors had been eluted from bm1 or B10.A(4R) monolayers were 6 and 12 times lower, respectively, than pCTL-2 eluted from the donor monolayer. Opposite results were shown for receptors of enriched secondary anti-Kb effector CTL. Irrespective of their elution source, whether donor, mutant or allele variant, the eluted effector CTL were able to lyse the donor TC to a similar degree and much more than the given third-party TC; moreover, they retained cross-reactivity in all cases. It is suggested that CTL receptors are homogeneous in specificity for a whole composite immunodominant epitope and differ from each other only in the affinity/lability of the combining site. In contrast, pCTL-2 can be separated into fractions: receptors of each fraction are strictly specific (with high affinity) to a particular portion of the same composite CTL epitope. It seems likely that the pCTL-2 receptor antigen-binding site is modified during pCTL-2 in vivo differentiation into effector CTL.

Quantitative considerations of T-cell activation and self tolerance

We have reviewed evidence for the hypothesis that T-cell activation by antigen is an all or none process which is triggered when signal strength exceeds a certain threshold. Signal is generated by multivalent interaction between T-cell antigen receptors (TCR) and antigenic epitopes on the surface of antigen-presenting cells (APC) or target cells. Therefore total signal strength (Stot) will depend upon the concentration of TCR (and other accessory molecules that bind to cell surface ligands, e.g. CD4 and CD8) on T cells, the concentration of antigen on APC or targets and the affinity of interaction between receptors (a broad term incorporating TCR plus CD4 and CD8) and antigen. This hypothesis means that T-cell self tolerance is quantitatively determined by self-antigen concentrations on cell surfaces. Implications for a variety of immunological phenomenona are reviewed.

Hyperthermia and the generation and activity of murine influenza-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro

The rate of generation of murine secondary influenza virus-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro is enhanced under limiting dilution conditions at hyperthermal temperatures (39 versus 37 degrees C). Increased mean values of cytotoxic activity were observed in the presence as well as absence of exogenous helper factors. Elevated cytotoxic activity at 39 degrees C was observed after day 3 to day 5 of culture. The number of autoreactive cytotoxic cells observed was not greater at 39 degrees C than at 37 degrees C. Elevated temperature did not influence target cell lysis or release of isotopes from killed target cells. The results are discussed with a view to the role of fever in augmenting the cellular immune response responsible for the host defense against primary viral infection.

Dk-restricted antiinfluenza cytotoxic T-cell clone loses one of its two alloreactivities

K6, an influenza-specific cytotoxic T (Tc)-cell clone derived from C3H/He mice, was Dk-restricted. Further analysis showed that K6 also recognized Dd and Dq as allotargets. The clonal nature of the three recognition specificities was confirmed by cold-target cell inhibition. After extensive in vitro selection, K6 lost the ability to lyse Dd cells while retaining both other specificities. The role of the Lyt-2 molecule in antigen-specific self-H-2-restricted vs allospecific recognition was investigated by inhibition with the Lyt-2-specific monoclonal antibody 53-6.7. Both activities were proportionately inhibited, indicating that the Lyt-2 molecule is equally important for both recognition specificities of this Tc-cell clone.

Alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes lyse syngeneic influenza-infected tumour cell targets

Spleen cells from C57BL/10(H-2b) mice, when stimulated in vitro to Kk alloantigens, lysed syngeneic influenza A virus-infected tumour cell targets but not uninfected or vaccinia- or Sendai virus-infected targets. Peritoneal macrophage targets infected with influenza virus were not lysed. Lysis of H-2k targets and EL4-A influenza virus-infected targets was abrogated by treatment of effectors with anti-Thy 1.2 plus C and anti-Lyt 2 plus C but not by anti-Lyt 1 plus C or anti-GM-1, a natural killer cell-specific, monoclonal antibody plus C. Cold target inhibition experiments indicated that one and the same population of Tc cells see H-2Kk and H-2b plus influenza virus. Sensitization of C57BL/10 mice to Kk in vivo did not potentiate virus clearance from lungs. The data are discussed in relation to observed Ir gene effects and variation and modulation of H-2 antigens on tumour cells.

An improved colorimetric assay for T cell cytotoxicity in vitro

An improved colorimetric assay for estimation of cytotoxic T (Tc) cells is described. The method involves staining thioglycollate-induced macrophage targets with the dye neutral red prior to addition of cytotoxic T cells and estimating macrophage survival at the end of the assay by measuring dye remaining in viable targets. The method using macrophage targets is more sensitive than the 51Cr release assay employing macrophages or a variety of other targets. It may be used to detect alloreactive and H-2 restricted Tc cells in both short-term (4 h) and long-term (24 h) assays and overcomes some variability encountered with a previously described colorimetric procedure. Furthermore, the method is cheap, fast, reliable and avoids the use of radioactivity.

Neonatal tolerance of major histocompatibility complex antigens alters Ir gene control of the cytotoxic T cell response to vaccinia virus

The K region of H-2 controls the Tc cell response to vaccinia-Db. The Kb, Kd, and Kq alleles allow good Tc cell responses against vaccinia-Db. In contrast, the presence of Kk in H-2 recombinants 2R (Kk,Db) and 4R (Kk,Db) or in F1 hybrids greatly reduces the anti-vaccinia-Db response. The defect does not lie in antigen presentation, as infected 4R cells can stimulate anti-vaccinia-Db Tc cells in vitro. Furthermore, nonresponder animals possess Tc cell precursors for vaccinia-Db, as transfer of F1 nonresponder spleen cells into infected, lethally irradiated responder recipients allowed generation of anti-vaccinia-Db effector Tc cells. Secondary responses to vaccinia-Db can also be obtained in vitro from T cells of 4R animals. Feedback inhibition was excluded in experiments with mixed chimeras in which Kk and Db were expressed on separate cell populations. Neonatal tolerance of B10 animals to Kk suppressed the anti-vaccinia-Db response but did not affect anti-vaccinia-Kb, anti-lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus, or anti-H-2d responses. In cold target competition experiments, H-2k competitors inhibited vaccinia-Db-specific target cell lysis by Tc cells, which suggests that anti-vaccinia-Db and anti-H-2Kk Tc cells may cross-react. Therefore, we propose that the suppressive influence of Kk on anti-vaccinia-Db Tc cell responses is a consequence of self-tolerance and that suppression of anti-Kk Tc cells results in cross-reactive suppression of anti-vaccinia-Db Tc cells.

Automated colorimetric assay for T cell cytotoxicity

A colorimetric method has been developed for detecting the lysis of target cells by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (Tc). The method entails incubating Tc cells with thioglycollate-induced macrophage targets and estimating macrophage survival at the end of the assay by staining viable macrophages with the dye neutral red. The method is substantially more sensitive than the 51Cr release assay and can be used to detect alloreactive Tc cells and H-2-restricted Tc cells against viruses, haptens and minor-H antigens. Furthermore, the assay is applicable to limit dilution analysis of Tc cell precursors. The method is cheap, avoids radioactive materials and by measuring optical densities with automated spectrophotometers developed for microELISA systems, results can be obtained 50-100 times faster than with the radioactive procedure.

Mutations in H-2Kb influence the specificity of alloreactive effector cells included in the repertoire of H-2Db-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes against Moloney leukemia virus

Moloney leukemia virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), generated by secondary in vitro stimulation of spleen cells with syngeneic virus-infected cells, frequently lysed not only syngeneic virus-infected cells, but also noninfected allogeneic target cells. This phenomenon was studied with B6(H-2b) responder cells and a series of H-2Kb-mutant responder cells. Thus, B6 Moloney-specific CTL lysed noninfected Kb-mutant cells, but not B6 cells, whereas Kb-mutant Moloney-specific CTL lysed noninfected B6 cells and not noninfected cells of the same mutant. Cold-target-inhibition studies showed that the CTL reactions against different allogeneic cells were mediated by different subpopulations of virus-specific CTL: lysis of allogeneic target cells was fully inhibited only by the same allogeneic and by syngeneic virus-infected cells, but not by another allogeneic cell, also lysed by the same effector-cell population. Lysis of syngeneic virus-infected cells could not be inhibited by allogeneic target cells. These data imply that a minority of virus-specific CTL shows cross-reactivity with a given allogeneic target cell. It is concluded that limited amino acid substitutions in the Kb molecule alter the repertoire of Moloney virus-specific CTL, as reflected in alloreactive CTL populations, even though the virus-specific CTL response of B6 and all Kb mutants is mainly Db-restricted. Thus, the development of tolerance to self class-I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules affects the repertoire of self-restricted cytotoxic T cells.

Non-H-2 and H-2-linked immune response genes control the cytotoxic T-cell response to H-Y

The immunoregulation of cytotoxic T-cell responses to the male-specific antigen H-Y in mice has been found to be genetically controlled by genes of the major histocompatibility complex (H-2). Responsiveness was mainly confined to H-2b strains, but it has also been found in recombinant strains, F1 hybrids, and chimeras that carry at least part of the H-2b haplotype. By using a different immunization procedure it has been shown recently that an H-2k mouse strain (CBA) is also able to mount an equivalent H-Y-specific response. We investigate here, by applying this immunization technique, the responsiveness of other H-2k strains and of strains of other independent H-2 haplotypes. Both responders and nonresponders are found in three haplotypes: k, s, and d. The strain distribution pattern of responsiveness shows a combined influence of non-H-2 and H-2 genes. In certain strains there is a high variability in responsiveness between genetically identical individual animals. We discuss a model of immune response (Ir) gene function which could account for these observations.

Neonatal tolerance to alloantigens alters major histocompatibility complex-restricted response patterns

Male-specific transplantation antigen (H-Y)-immune cytotoxic T cells of some individual CBA/H mice exhibit lytic activity on male and female allogeneic targets (e.g., H-2b). Neonatal tolerance to H-2b abrogates the ability of CBA mice to generate secondary H-Y-immune cytotoxic T cells, but such cell activity to third-party alloantigens and to Bebaru and influenza virus is not impaired. The results are discussed in relationship to dominant major histocompatibility complex-coded immune response gene effects on cytotoxic T-cell responses.

Idiotypes on major histocompatibility complex-restricted virus-immune cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Specificity-associated determinants could be demonstrated on major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted virus-immune cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) using antisera raised in syngeneic mice. This result indicates that the number of clonotypes sufficiently small to allow the detection of such idiotypic determinants. The functional properties of three anti-idiotypic antisera were tested in blocking studies and by idiotypic antisera plus complement. Whereas the former test did not reveal any results obtained from binding studies, i.e., all three anti-idiotypic antisera specifically reacted with CTL of the type used for immunization and had no effect on syngeneic influenza-immune CTL, syngeneic alloreactive CTL, or NDV-immune CTL of an H-2-disparate strain. These results are discussed in terms of current models for MHC-restricted CTL responses.

Clonal analysis of cytolytic T lymphocyte specificity. I. Phenotypically distinct sets of clones as the cellular basis of cross-reactivity to alloantigens

The cellular basis of the cytolytic cross-reactivity observed in primary allogeneic (C56BL/6 anti-DBA/2 and C57BL/6 anti-C3H/He) mixed-leukocyte cultures (MLC) was investigated by analysis of the specificity of clonal progeny derived from individual cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursor cells (CTL-P) contained within these populations. A sensitive mixed-leukocyte microculture (micro-MLC) technique was used with limiting dilution analysis by Poisson statistics to determine the frequency of CTL-P reactive against both specific and third-party (P815 and AKRA) target cells, to calculate the probability that each micro-MLC was a clone derived from a single CTL-P, and to examine the specificity of each micro-MLC assayed separately against both target cells. A total of 287 phenotypically specific, heteroclitic, and cross-reactive micro-MLC from the 2 different strain combinations were observed with a relative frequency of 81, 11, and 8%, respectively, and were calculated to have mean clone probability of 90 and 99% when based, respectively, upon the frequencies of CTL-P reactive against the specific and third-party target cells. These clones were estimated to have an approximate size of 6 X 10(4) cells, which corresponded to roughly 16 cell doublings during the 7 d of culture. 22 clones were successfully subcloned and in virtually every case, the subclones retained the specificity phenotype of the original clone from which they were derived. These results provide direct evidence for three phenotypically distinct sets of CTL as the cellular basis of cross-reactivity in MLC populations assayed against two different target cells.

Cross-reactive cytotoxic T cells to alphavirus infection

Secondary Tc cells immune to alphaviruses (BEB, SIN and SFV) cross-react between serologically defined subgroups at the level of target lysis and at the level of induction of response. Despite this apparently complete Tc cell cross-reactivity between BEB, SIN and SFV, antisera raised against BEB and SIN showed virus specificity in their ability to block Tc cell-mediated lysis of alphavirus-infected targets. This result suggests that Tc cells recognize the same viral antigen molecule as antibodies, but with less specificity. Other possible interpretations are discussed.