Antigen modulation of the immune response. VI. Rate of large memory cell appearance in lymph nodes and thoracic duct lymph

Lymphokine-induction of memory B-cell differentiation: differential stimulation of large virgin and memory B-cell differentiation

In order to compare and contrast the requirements of virgin and memory B cells for B-cell differentiation factors, a model system was developed in which low-density rat B cells isolated from 4-week primed antigen-draining lymph nodes were cultured in vitro. This large low-density cell population contained B cells which were 90% surface IgM positive and 60% IgD positive and showed moderately elevated Ia staining. When the cell population was stimulated with antigen plus lymphokines or lymphokines alone, antigen-specific IgG antibody was secreted; this was used as a measure of memory cell differentiation. When the cell population was stimulated with mitogen (lipopolysaccharide plus dextran sulfate) plus lymphokines, polyclonal IgG and IgM secretion was seen and was used as a measure of virgin B-cell differentiation. Using this system, we found that lymphokines contained in a Con A-induced rat spleen cell supernatant (CSN) were sufficient to drive both memory and virgin B-cell differentiation. In contrast, lymphokines contained in the supernatant from the murine T-cell hybridoma B151K12 (B151CFS) were able to induce large amounts of polyclonal IgM and IgG secretion but did not support memory B-cell differentiation. When recombinant human IL-2 was added to these cultures, it acted synergistically to augment virgin B-cell differentiation, but this combination of lymphokines was still not able to support memory B-cell differentiation. Furthermore, recombinant rat interferon-gamma and a commercial source of human BCGF, with or without IL-2, were unable to promote significant virgin or memory B-cell differentiation. These data support the hypothesis that memory B cells and virgin B cells differ in their lymphokine requirements for differentiation into antibody-secreting cells.

Polyclonal activation of primed rat B cells

In recent years, murine and human virgin B lymphocytes have been used to examine the steps necessary for polyclonal activation. In these models mitogens are used in conjunction with lymphokines to determine which signals are responsible for regulating B-cell triggering, proliferation, and differentiation. While progress has been made in understanding these events as they occur in virgin B cells, very little evidence exists to suggest whether these models of activation also apply to the memory B-cell population. In this report we have described an antigen-specific, secondary in vitro immune response using cells isolated from lymph nodes draining the site of antigen injection. Unfractionated cells, B cells, and size-fractionated cells from dinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH)-primed rats were challenged in vitro with DNP-KLH, lipopolysaccharide plus dextran sulfate (LPS/DxS), and T-cell factors. We have consistently found, under all these conditions, that antigen challenge of primed cells results in the production of DNP-specific IgG antibody while stimulation with LPS/DxS plus T-cell factors results only in the polyclonal activation of virgin B cells; no antigen-specific IgG secretion is seen. This suggests that acquisition of memory status is associated with a loss in responsiveness to LPS/DxS-induced differentiation.

Functional anatomy of germinal centers

This year we celebrate the first centennial of the discovery of germinal centers by Flemming in 1884. The present paper reviews and adds new data to the functional anatomy of a germinal center. Emphasizing its reactive nature, we first describe a germinal center reaction and then deal with its infrastructural aspects and constituent cell populations, both lymphoid and nonlymphoid. Elements involved in the de novo formation of a germinal center, like antigen, T cells, and the mysterious germinal-center-precursor cell, are discussed. Next, attention is paid to the requirements for lymphoid cells to migrate into germinal centers, and novel features of germinal-center-seeking cells are presented. Subsequently, we discuss kinetic aspects of the high proliferative activity in a germinal center; and finally a description of the functional capacities of germinal-center-derived cells, such as B memory cells and IgM-antibody-forming cell precursors, completes this picture of present-day knowledge of the germinal center, a structure which has yet to reveal its last secrets.

The correlation between the activation state of B cells and their capacity for in vitro propagation of immunologic memory

The B-cell population responsible for in vitro antigen-mediated proliferation and expansion of the memory B-cell population is a large activated blast. Such cells predominate early after antigen priming and can be regenerated by adjuvant (Bordetella pertussis) stimulation in vivo. Although these cells are proliferating in vivo, additional stimuli are needed for expansion of the memory population in vitro. These triggering requirements include specific antigen (DNP-OVA) and the assistance of adherent accessory cells. Although T cells are present in the culture, their role in the propagation of memory is not completely clear. Using the unrelated antigen, sheep erythrocytes, we have shown that "bystander" T-cell help can mediate differentiation of these memory B-cell blasts to AFC, but it cannot induce expansion of the memory-cell population. However, the fact that the TI-2 antigen DNP-Ficoll is a relatively ineffective inducer of memory-cell propagation (inducing an expanded response which is less than 10% of that induced by the T-cell-dependent antigen, DNP-OVA) suggests that T cells may be involved, possibly via production of B-cell growth factor. Thus, the minimal requirements for triggering the propagation of B-cell memory include (i) a blastogenic signal which can be mediated by adjuvant, (ii) specific antigen, and (iii) adherent accessory-cell help.

A mathematical model of B lymphocyte differentiation: control by antigen

A mathematical model of B lymphocyte differentiation, based on experimental results, has been developed. The model focuses on the role of antigen in initiating and regulating B cell differentiation while other mechanisms, acting in concert with antigen but the functioning of which can be circumvented under appropriate conditions, are not considered. The importance of presence of antigen at individual stages of B cell differentiation was studied in experiments with an easily metabolizable antigen. Immunocompetent cells (ICC), arising by antigen-independent differentiation of stem cells, are activated by antigen (they become immunologically activated cells--IAC). Excess of antigen drives IAC into the terminal stage (antibody-forming cells--AFC) thereby restricting proliferation. Exhaustive terminal differentiation results in tolerance. A low primary dose permits IAC to escape antigen; IAC proliferate and later give rise to resting memory cells (MC) which are amenable to reactivation. MC have higher avidity for antigen (due to higher affinity, number and density of receptors) and the effect of different doses of antigen on MC is diverse. A very low secondary dose induces tolerance, a medium dose secondary response, and the administration of a high dose of antigen also brings about tolerance. The model suggests that the fate of memory cells is controlled by the ratio R:Ag, of the number of immunoglobulin receptors on B cells (R) to the number of available antigenic molecules (Ag), low values R:Ag favouring stimulation to differentiation while high values of R:Ag favouring inactivation. A nonlinear system of ordinary differential equations, describing the development of the populations involved in antigen-driven B cell differentiation, was used to simulate experiments and good qualitative agreement was achieved.