Unequal cleavage and the differentiation of echinoid primary mesenchyme

Lessons from a transcription factor: Alx1 provides insights into gene regulatory networks, cellular reprogramming, and cell type evolution

The skeleton-forming cells of sea urchins and other echinoderms have been studied by developmental biologists as models of cell specification and morphogenesis for many decades. The gene regulatory network (GRN) deployed in the embryonic skeletogenic cells of euechinoid sea urchins is one of the best understood in any developing animal. Recent comparative studies have leveraged the information contained in this GRN, bringing renewed attention to the diverse patterns of skeletogenesis within the phylum and the evolutionary basis for this diversity. The homeodomain-containing transcription factor, Alx1, was originally shown to be a core component of the skeletogenic GRN of the sea urchin embryo. Alx1 has since been found to be key regulator of skeletal cell identity throughout the phylum. As such, Alx1 is currently serving as a lens through which multiple developmental processes are being investigated. These include not only GRN organization and evolution, but also cell reprogramming, cell type evolution, and the gene regulatory control of morphogenesis. This review summarizes our current state of knowledge concerning Alx1 and highlights the insights it is yielding into these important developmental and evolutionary processes.

The gene regulatory control of sea urchin gastrulation

The cell behaviors associated with gastrulation in sea urchins have been well described. More recently, considerable progress has been made in elucidating gene regulatory networks (GRNs) that underlie the specification of early embryonic territories in this experimental model. This review integrates information from these two avenues of work. I discuss the principal cell movements that take place during sea urchin gastrulation, with an emphasis on molecular effectors of the movements, and summarize our current understanding of the gene regulatory circuitry upstream of those effectors. A case is made that GRN biology can provide a causal explanation of gastrulation, although additional analysis is needed at several levels of biological organization in order to provide a deeper understanding of this complex morphogenetic process.

Equalization of Cleavage Is Not Causally Responsible for Specification of Cell Lineage

An unequal cleavage gives rise to a dedicated population of larval skeletogenic cells in sea urchins. The timing of this unequal cleavage, associated localization of key lineage markers, and loss of this lineage when embryos are treated with cleavage-equalizing reagents have all suggested that the asymmetry of the daughter cells is causal to the specification of this cell lineage. However, the mechanism by which asymmetric cleavage specifies this cell type remains unidentified. I found that applying a classical cleavage-equalizing reagent (sodium dodecyl sulfate) to embryos of an equally cleaving urchin eliminates its larval skeleton. This result suggests that equalization of cleavage itself is not causally responsible for specification of this cell lineage but coincident.

From genome to anatomy: The architecture and evolution of the skeletogenic gene regulatory network of sea urchins and other echinoderms

The skeletogenic gene regulatory network (GRN) of sea urchins and other echinoderms is one of the most intensively studied transcriptional networks in any developing organism. As such, it serves as a preeminent model of GRN architecture and evolution. This review summarizes our current understanding of this developmental network. We describe in detail the most comprehensive model of the skeletogenic GRN, one developed for the euechinoid sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, including its initial deployment by maternal inputs, its elaboration and stabilization through regulatory gene interactions, and its control of downstream effector genes that directly drive skeletal morphogenesis. We highlight recent comparative studies that have leveraged the euechinoid GRN model to examine the evolution of skeletogenic programs in diverse echinoderms, studies that have revealed both conserved and divergent features of skeletogenesis within the phylum. Last, we summarize the major insights that have emerged from analysis of the structure and evolution of the echinoderm skeletogenic GRN and identify key, unresolved questions as a guide for future work.

Autonomy in specification of primordial germ cells and their passive translocation in the sea urchin

The process of germ line determination involves many conserved genes, yet is highly variable. Echinoderms are positioned at the base of Deuterostomia and are crucial to understanding these evolutionary transitions, yet the mechanism of germ line specification is not known in any member of the phyla. Here we demonstrate that small micromeres (SMics), which are formed at the fifth cell division of the sea urchin embryo, illustrate many typical features of primordial germ cell (PGC) specification. SMics autonomously express germ line genes in isolated culture, including selective Vasa protein accumulation and transcriptional activation of nanos; their descendants are passively displaced towards the animal pole by secondary mesenchyme cells and the elongating archenteron during gastrulation; Cadherin (G form) has an important role in their development and clustering phenotype; and a left/right integration into the future adult anlagen appears to be controlled by a late developmental mechanism. These results suggest that sea urchin SMics share many more characteristics typical of PGCs than previously thought, and imply a more widely conserved system of germ line development among metazoans.

The echinoid mitotic gradient: effect of cell size on the micromere cleavage cycle

Like other euechinoids, the fertilized eggs of the sand dollar Dendraster excentricus proceed through cleavages that produce a pattern of macromeres, mesomeres, and micromeres at the 4th division. The 8 cells of the macro-mesomere lineage proceed through 6 additional cleavages before hatching. At the fifth overall division, the 4 micromeres produce a lineage of large micromeres that will divide 3 additional times, and a lineage of small micromeres that will divide once more before hatching. Irrespective of lineage, the length of the cell cycles is closely related to the size of the blastomere; cells of the same size have the same cell cycle time. A consequence is that at the fourth cleavage, there is a gradient of mitotic activity from the fastest dividers at the animal pole and the slowest cleaving micromeres at the vegetal pole. By the time of hatching, which is the 10th division of meso-macromeres, all cells are the same small size, the metachronic pattern of division gives way to asynchrony, and the mitotic gradient along the polar axis is lost. Experimental pre-exposure to sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), however, blocks the appearance of the gradients in cell size, the mitotic gradient, and the differential in cell cycle times. It is proposed that the mitotic gradients, cell cycle times, and attainment of a state of asynchrony are functions of cell size. Developmental consequences of the transition are large, and include coordinated activation of transcriptions, synthesis of new patterns of proteins, alterations of metabolism, and onset of morphogenesis.

Activation of the skeletogenic gene regulatory network in the early sea urchin embryo

The gene regulatory network (GRN) that underlies the development of the embryonic skeleton in sea urchins is an important model for understanding the architecture and evolution of developmental GRNs. The initial deployment of the network is thought to be regulated by a derepression mechanism, which is mediated by the products of the pmar1 and hesC genes. Here, we show that the activation of the skeletogenic network occurs by a mechanism that is distinct from the transcriptional repression of hesC. By means of quantitative, fluorescent whole-mount in situ hybridization, we find that two pivotal early genes in the network, alx1 and delta, are activated in prospective skeletogenic cells prior to the downregulation of hesC expression. An analysis of the upstream regulation of alx1 shows that this gene is regulated by MAPK signaling and by the transcription factor Ets1; however, these inputs influence only the maintenance of alx1 expression and not its activation, which occurs by a distinct mechanism. By altering normal cleavage patterns, we show that the zygotic activation of alx1 and delta, but not that of pmar1, is dependent upon the unequal division of vegetal blastomeres. Based on these findings, we conclude that the widely accepted double-repression model is insufficient to account for the localized activation of the skeletogenic GRN. We postulate the existence of additional, unidentified repressors that are controlled by pmar1, and propose that the ability of pmar1 to derepress alx1 and delta is regulated by the unequal division of vegetal blastomeres.

Lessons from a gene regulatory network: echinoderm skeletogenesis provides insights into evolution, plasticity and morphogenesis

Significant new insights have emerged from the analysis of a gene regulatory network (GRN) that underlies the development of the endoskeleton of the sea urchin embryo. Comparative studies have revealed ways in which this GRN has been modified (and conserved) during echinoderm evolution, and point to mechanisms associated with the evolution of a new cell lineage. The skeletogenic GRN has also recently been used to study the long-standing problem of developmental plasticity. Other recent findings have linked this transcriptional GRN to morphoregulatory proteins that control skeletal anatomy. These new studies highlight powerful new ways in which GRNs can be used to dissect development and the evolution of morphogenesis.

Gene regulatory networks and developmental plasticity in the early sea urchin embryo: alternative deployment of the skeletogenic gene regulatory network

Cell fates in the sea urchin embryo are remarkably labile, despite the fact that maternal polarity and zygotic programs of differential gene expression pattern the embryo from the earliest stages. Recent work has focused on transcriptional gene regulatory networks (GRNs) deployed in specific embryonic territories during early development. The micromere-primary mesenchyme cell(PMC) GRN drives the development of the embryonic skeleton. Although normally deployed only by presumptive PMCs, every lineage of the early embryo has the potential to activate this pathway. Here, we focus on one striking example of regulative activation of the skeletogenic GRN; the transfating of non-skeletogenic mesoderm (NSM) cells to a PMC fate during gastrulation. We show that transfating is accompanied by the de novo expression of terminal,biomineralization-related genes in the PMC GRN, as well as genes encoding two upstream transcription factors, Lvalx1 and Lvtbr. We report that Lvalx1, a key component of the skeletogenic GRN in the PMC lineage, plays an essential role in the regulative pathway both in NSM cells and in animal blastomeres. MAPK signaling is required for the expression of Lvalx1 and downstream skeletogenic genes in NSM cells, mirroring its role in the PMC lineage. We also demonstrate that Lvalx1 regulates the signal from PMCs that normally suppresses NSM transfating. Significantly,misexpression of Lvalx1 in macromeres (the progenitors of NSM cells)is sufficient to activate the skeletogenic GRN. We suggest that NSM cells normally deploy a basal mesodermal pathway and require only an Lvalx1-mediated sub-program to express a PMC fate. Finally, we provide evidence that, in contrast to the normal pathway, activation of the skeletogenic GRN in NSM cells is independent of Lvpmar1. Our studies reveal that, although most features of the micromere-PMC GRN are recapitulated in transfating NSM cells, different inputs activate this GRN during normal and regulative development.

Alx1, a member of the Cart1/Alx3/Alx4 subfamily of Paired-class homeodomain proteins, is an essential component of the gene network controlling skeletogenic fate specification in the sea urchin embryo

In the sea urchin embryo, the large micromeres and their progeny function as a critical signaling center and execute a complex morphogenetic program. We have identified a new and essential component of the gene network that controls large micromere specification, the homeodomain protein Alx1. Alx1 is expressed exclusively by cells of the large micromere lineage beginning in the first interphase after the large micromeres are born. Morpholino studies demonstrate that Alx1 is essential at an early stage of specification and controls downstream genes required for epithelial-mesenchymal transition and biomineralization. Expression of Alx1 is cell autonomous and regulated maternally through beta-catenin and its downstream effector, Pmar1. Alx1 expression can be activated in other cell lineages at much later stages of development, however, through a regulative pathway of skeletogenesis that is responsive to cell signaling. The Alx1 protein is highly conserved among euechinoid sea urchins and is closely related to the Cart1/Alx3/Alx4 family of vertebrate homeodomain proteins. In vertebrates, these proteins regulate the formation of skeletal elements of the limbs, face and neck. Our findings suggest that the ancestral deuterostome had a population of biomineral-forming mesenchyme cells that expressed an Alx1-like protein.

The role of micromere signaling in Notch activation and mesoderm specification during sea urchin embryogenesis

In the sea urchin embryo, the micromeres act as a vegetal signaling center. These cells have been shown to induce endoderm; however, their role in mesoderm development has been less clear. We demonstrate that the micromeres play an important role in the induction of secondary mesenchyme cells (SMCs), possibly by activating the Notch signaling pathway. After removing the micromeres, we observed a significant delay in the formation of all mesodermal cell types examined. In addition, there was a marked reduction in the numbers of pigment cells, blastocoelar cells and cells expressing the SMC1 antigen, a marker for prospective SMCs. The development of skeletogenic cells and muscle cells, however, was not severely affected. Transplantation of micromeres to animal cells resulted in the induction of SMC1-positive cells, pigment cells, blastocoelar cells and muscle cells. The numbers of these cell types were less than those found in sham transplantation control embryos, suggesting that animal cells are less responsive to the micromere-derived signal than vegetal cells. Previous studies have demonstrated a role for Notch signaling in the development of SMCs. We show that the micromere-derived signal is necessary for the downregulation of the Notch protein, which is correlated with its activation, in prospective SMCs. We propose that the micromeres induce adjacent cells to form SMCs, possibly by presenting a ligand for the Notch receptor.

The centrosome-attracting body, microtubule system, and posterior egg cytoplasm are involved in positioning of cleavage planes in the ascidian embryo

Many kinds of animal embryos exhibit stereotyped cleavage patterns during early embryogenesis. In the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi, cleavage patterns are invariant but they are complicated by successive unequal cleavages that occur in the posterior region. Here we report the essential roles of a novel structure, called the centrosome-attracting body (CAB), which exists in the posterior pole cortex of cleaving embryos, in generating unequal cleavages. By removing and transplanting posterior egg cytoplasm and by treatment with sodium dodecyl sulfate, we demonstrated that loss of the CAB resulted in abolishment of unequal cleavage, while ectopic formation of the CAB caused ectopic unequal cleavages to occur. Experiments with a microtubule inhibitor demonstrated that the centrosome and nucleus were attracted toward the posterior cortex, where the CAB is located, by shortening of microtubule bundles formed between the centrosome and the CAB. Consequently, the mitotic apparatus was positioned asymmetrically, resulting in unequal cleavage. Immunohistochemistry provided evidence that a microtubule motor protein, a kinesin or kinesin-like molecule, may be associated with the CAB. Formation of the CAB during the early cleavage stage was resistant to treatment with the microtubule inhibitor. In contrast, the integrity of the CAB was lost upon treatment with a microfilament inhibitor. We propose that the CAB plays key roles in the orientation and positioning of cleavage planes during unequal cell division.

Unequal divisions at the third cleavage increase the number of primary mesenchyme cells in sea urchin embryos

To clarify the distribution and behavior of the maternal factors that direct the differentiation of primary mesenchyme cells (PMC) in sea urchin embryos, unequal division was induced at the third cleavage with the treatment of dinitro-phenol (DNP), and the numbers of differentiated PMC were examined. The most surprising finding was that the number of PMC was considerably increased in some of the DNP-treated embryos. This increase n the number of PMC was suggested to be closely related to the size of the precocious micromeres formed at the 8-cell stage. By measuring both the size of the precocious micromeres and the number of PMC in individual embryos, it was suggested that almost all the descendants of the precocious micromeres differentiated into PMC, if the volume was less than 26 pL (about three times the volume of normal micromeres). Cell tracing experiments ascertained that precocious micromeres with small volumes behave just like micromeres formed at the fourth cleavage in normal embryos. The obtained results indicated that the maternal factors present in sea urchin embryos can direct, at least, more than three times the number of PMC, and that the number of cell divisions of the PMC lineage is not strictly regulated.

Mesodermal cell interactions in the sea urchin embryo: properties of skeletogenic secondary mesenchyme cells

An interaction between the two principal populations of mesodermal cells in the sea urchin embryo, primary and secondary mesenchyme cells (PMCs and SMCs, respectively), regulates SMC fates and the process of skeletogenesis. In the undisturbed embryo, skeletal elements are produced exclusively by PMCs. Certain SMCs also have the ability to express a skeletogenic phenotype; however, signals transmitted by the PMCs direct these cells into alternative developmental pathways. In this study, a combination of fluorescent cell-labeling methods, embryo microsurgery and cell-specific molecular markers have been used to study the lineage, numbers, normal fate(s) and developmental potential of the skeletogenic SMCs. Previous fate-mapping studies have shown that SMCs are derived from the veg2 layer of blastomeres of the 64-cell-stage embryo and from the small micromeres. By specifically labeling the small micromeres with 5-bromodeoxyuridine, we demonstrate that descendants of these cells do not participate in skeletogenesis in PMC-depleted larvae, even though they are the closest lineal relatives of PMCs. Skeletogenic SMCs are therefore derived exclusively from the veg2 blastomeres. Because the SMCs are a heterogeneous population of cells, we have sought to gain information concerning the normal fate(s) of skeletogenic SMCs by determining whether specific cell types are reduced or absent in PMC(−) larvae. Of the four known SMC derivatives: pigment cells, blastocoelar (basal) cells, muscle cells and coelomic pouch cells, only pigment cells show a major reduction (> 50%) in number following SMC skeletogenesis. We therefore propose that the PMC-derived signal regulates a developmental switch, directing SMCs to adopt a pigment cell phenotype instead of a default (skeletogenic) fate. Ablation of SMCs at the late gastrula stage does not result in the recruitment of any additional skeletogenic cells, demonstrating that, by this stage, the number of SMCs with skeletogenic potential is restricted to 60–70 cells. Previous studies showed that during their switch to a skeletogenic fate, SMCs alter their migratory behavior and cell surface properties. In this study, we demonstrate that during conversion, SMCs become insensitive to the PMC-derived signal, while at the same time they acquire PMC-specific signaling properties.

Secondary mesenchyme of the sea urchin embryo: ontogeny of blastocoelar cells

Secondary mesenchyme in sea urchin embryos is released into the blastocoel after primary mesenchyme, and although these cells have been recognized for some time, we lack knowledge about many fundamental aspects of their origin and fate. Here we documented the ontogeny of one of the principal, and least well-known, types of cells derived from secondary mesenchyme. The blastocoelar cells arise from mesenchyme released from the tip of the archenteron following the initial phase of gastrulation. The cells migrate with their cell bodies suspended in the blastocoel, rather than being apposed to the basal lamina like primary mesenchyme. The cells extend numerous fine filopodia to form a network of cytoplasmic processes around the gut, along the skeletal rods, and within the larval arms. Once the network is formed, the cells maintain their positions, although they actively translocate vesicles and cytoplasm along their filopodia. Cell counts indicate there is an initial recruitment of cells during gastrulation, followed by a more gradual increase in cell number after the larva begins to feed. Lineage studies in which 16-cell-stage macromeres were injected with horseradish peroxidase indicate that almost all of the macromere-derived mesenchyme forms pigment cells and blastocoelar cells. We propose that blastocoelar cells are a distinct subset of secondary mesenchyme that forms fibroblast-like cells in the blastocoel of sea urchin embryos.

Cell interactions in the sea urchin embryo studied by fluorescence photoablation

In many organisms, interactions between cells play a critical role in the specification of cell fates. In the sea urchin embryo, primary mesenchyme cells (PMCs) regulate the developmental program of a subpopulation of secondary mesenchyme cells (SMCs). The timing of this cell interaction was analyzed by means of a fluorescence photoablation technique, which was used to specifically ablate PMCs at various stages of development. In addition, the PMCs were microinjected into PMC-depleted recipient embryos at different developmental stages and their effect on SMC fate was examined. The critical interaction between PMCs and SMCs was brief and took place late in gastrulation. Before that time, SMCs were insensitive to the suppressive signals transmitted by the PMCs.

Effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate on polar lobe formation and function in Ilyanassa obsoleta embryos

Polar lobes, anucleate vegetal pole protrusions formed by Ilyanassa obsoleta embryos, serve as a mechanism for shunting morphogenetic determinants to one cell during the first two cleavages. Polar lobe material becomes segregated in the CD cell during first cleavage and in the D cell during second cleavage, resulting in a very unequal four-cell stage. Larval structures including external shell, foot, operculum, statocysts, and eyes develop only when polar lobe material is present. Treatment with the anionic detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) before and during the first cleavage inhibited polar lobe formation and equalized cleavage, as the lobe material was distributed to two cells. No polar lobes formed during second clevage in SDS-equalized embryos, and the four-cell stage consisted of four equal cells with reduced cell contacts. SDS inrreversibly inhibited polar lobe formation without affecting cytokinesis. Although 27% of the larvae from SDS-equalized embryos had one or more lobe-dependent structures duplicated, morphogenesis was impaired: more than 40% of such larvae failed to form shell and/or statocysts. When cells were separated after equalized first cleavage and raised as pairs, the pairs of resulting larvae duplicated lobe-dependent structures with the same frequency as whole equalized embryos. Possible explanations for impaired morphogenesis in SDS-treated embryos are discussed.

Ontogeny and characterization of mesenchyme antigens of the sea urchin embryo

A monoclonal antibody, Sp12, binds to cortical granules, the hyaline layer, and skeletogenic, chromogenic, and blastocoelar mesenchyme of sea urchin eggs and embryos. Adult urchins also express Sp12 antigens in the dermal layer of the test and spines. Antigen is expressed on the surface of primary mesenchyme cells after they have entered the blastocoel, and by two secondary mesenchyme derivatives--the blastocoelar cells after they have been released from the tip of the archenteron, and the pigment cells in prism stage embryos. Immunogold localizations show antigen on the surfaces of mesenchyme, within membrane bounded vesicles, and associated with the Golgi apparatus. Western blots of antigens immunoprecipitated from seven developmental stages reveal twelve antigens ranging in Mr from 35 k to 240 k. Most of these antigens appear, disappear or change Mr over the first five days of development. Characterizations of this complex array of antigens show that the epitope recognized by Sp12 is eliminated by proteolytic enzymes and endoglycosidase F, while immunoreactivity is only reduced by periodate oxidation. As well, calcium magnesium free seawater extracts a subset of antigens different from that retained by crude membrane preparations. It is proposed that the mesenchyme of sea urchin embryos produces a family of developmentally regulated cell surface and extracellular matrix glycoproteins which all exhibit a carbohydrate epitope recognized by Sp12.

Evans blue treatment promotes blastomere separation and twinning in Lytechinus pictus embryos

Demembraned Lytechinus pictus embryos briefly treated with the dye Evans Blue during the first cleavage division subsequently showed frequent blastomere disengagement leading to development of twinned embryos. Further development of twinned embryos was observed in hanging drops and in batch cultures. The timing of micromere production was disturbed in some twinned embryos, but this disturbance was not correlated with subsequent developmental problems. Many twinned embryos resulting from blastomere separation following Evans Blue treatment developed into small but normal-appearing plutei.

Constraint, flexibility, and phylogenetic history in the evolution of direct development in sea urchins

Development in sea urchins typically involves the production of an elaborate feeding larva, the pluteus, within which the juvenile sea urchin grows. However, a significant fraction of sea urchins have completely or partially eliminated the pluteus, and instead undergo direct development from a large egg. Direct development is achieved primarily by heterochrony, that is, by the abbreviation or elimination of larval developmental processes and the acceleration of processes involved in development of adult features. Direct development has evolved independently several times, and in several ways. These radically altered ontogenies offer remarkable opportunities for the study of the mechanisms by which early development undergoes evolutionary modification. The recent availability of monoclonal antibody and cDNA probes that recognize homologous cells in embryos of closely related typical and direct developing species makes possible an experimental analysis of the cellular and molecular bases for heterochronic changes in development.