Tizanidine-induced depression of polysynaptic cutaneous reflexes in nonanesthetized monkeys is mediated by an alpha 2-adrenergic mechanism

Potent suppression of stretch reflex activity after systemic or spinal delivery of tizanidine in rats with spinal ischemia-induced chronic spastic paraplegia

BACKGROUND

Spasticity and rigidity are serious complications associated with spinal traumatic or ischemic injury. Clinical studies show that tizanidine (Tiz) is an effective antispasticity agent; however, the mechanism of this effect is still not clear. Tiz binds not only to α2-adrenoreceptors (AR) but also to imidazoline (I) receptors. Both receptor systems (AR+I) are present in the spinal cord interneurons and α-motoneurons. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the therapeutic potency of systematically or spinally (intrathecally [IT]) delivered Tiz on stretch reflex activity (SRA) in animals with ischemic spasticity, and to delineate supraspinal or spinal sites of Tiz action.

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES

Animals were exposed to 10 min of spinal ischemia to induce an increase in SRA. Increase in SRA was identified by simultaneous increase in recorded electromyography (EMG) activity and ankle resistance measured during computer-controlled ankle dorsiflexion (40°/3 s) in fully awake animals. Animals with increased SRA were divided into several experimental subgroups and treated as follows: (i) Tiz administered systemically at the dose of 1 mg kg(-1), or IT at 10 μg or 50 μg delivered as a single dose; (ii) treatment with systemic Tiz was followed by the systemic injection of vehicle, or by nonselective AR antagonist without affinity for I receptors; yohimbine (Yoh), α2A AR antagonist; BRL44408 (BRL), α2B AR antagonist; ARC239 (ARC), nonselective AR and I(1) receptor antagonist; efaroxan (Efa), or nonselective AR and I(2) receptor antagonist; idazoxan (Ida); (iii) treatment with IT Tiz was followed by the IT injection of selective α2A AR antagonist; atipamezole (Ati). In a separate group of spastic animals the effect of systemic Tiz treatment (1 mg/kg) or isoflurane anesthesia on H-reflex activity was also studied.

RESULTS

Systemic and/or IT treatment with Tiz significantly suppressed SRA. This Tiz-mediated anti-SRA effect was reversed by BRL (5 mg kg(-1)), Efa (1 mg kg(-1)), and Ida (1 mg kg(-1)). No reversal was seen after Yoh (3 mg kg(-1)) or ARC (5 mg kg(-1)) treatment. Anti-SRA induced by IT Tiz (50 μg) was reversed by IT injection of Ati (50 μg). Significant suppression of H-reflex was measured after systemic Tiz treatment (1 mg/kg) or isoflurane (2%) anesthesia, respectively. Immunofluorescence staining of spinal cord sections taken from animals with spasticity showed upregulation of α2A receptor in activated astrocytes.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that α2A AR and I receptors, but not α2B AR, primarily mediate the Tiz-induced antispasticity effect. This effect involves spinal and potentially supraspinal sites and likely targets α2A receptor present on spinal neurons, primary afferents, and activated astrocytes. Further studies using highly selective antagonists are needed to elucidate the involvement of specific subtypes of the AR and I receptors in the antispasticity effect seen after Tiz treatment.

Comparison of the effect of intrathecal administration of clonidine and yohimbine on the locomotion of intact and spinal cats

Several studies have shown that noradrenergic mechanisms are important for locomotion. For instance, L-dihydroxyphenylalanine (L-DOPA) can initiate "fictive" locomotion in immobilized acutely spinalized cats and alpha(2)-noradrenergic agonists, such as 2,6,-dichloro-N-2-imidazolidinylid-enebenzenamine (clonidine), can induce treadmill locomotion soon after spinalization. However, the activation of noradrenergic receptors may be not essential for the basic locomotor rhythmicity because chronic spinal cats can walk with the hindlimbs on a treadmill in the absence of noradrenergic stimulation because the descending pathways are completely severed. This suggests that locomotion, in intact and spinal conditions, is probably expressed and controlled through different neurotransmitter mechanisms. To test this hypothesis, we compared the effect of the alpha(2) agonist, clonidine, and the antagonist (16 alpha, 17 alpha)-17-hydroxy yohimbine-16-carboxylic acid methyl ester hydrochloride (yohimbine), injected intrathecally at L(3)--L(4) before and after spinalization in the same cats chronically implanted with electrodes to record electromyograms (EMGs). In intact cats, clonidine (50-150 microg/100 microl) modulated the locomotor pattern slightly causing a decrease in duration of the step cycle accompanied with some variation of EMG burst amplitude and duration. In the spinal state, clonidine could trigger robust and sustained hind limb locomotion in the first week after the spinalization at a time when the cats were paraplegic. Later, after the spontaneous recovery of a stable locomotor pattern, clonidine prolonged the cycle duration, increased the amplitude and duration of flexor and extensor bursts, and augmented the foot drag at the onset of swing. In intact cats, yohimbine at high doses (800--1600 microg/100 microl) caused major walking difficulties characterized by asymmetric stepping, stumbling with poor lateral stability, and, at smaller doses (400 microg/100 microl), only had slight effects such as abduction of one of the hindlimbs and the turning of the hindquarters to one side. After spinalization, yohimbine had no effect even at the largest doses. These results indicate that, in the intact state, noradrenergic mechanisms probably play an important role in the control of locomotion since blocking the receptors results in a marked disruption of walking. In the spinal state, although the receptors are still present and functional since they can be activated by clonidine, they are seemingly not critical for the spontaneous expression of spinal locomotion since their blockade by yohimbine does not impair spinal locomotion. It is postulated therefore that the expression of spinal locomotion must depend on the activation of other types of receptors, probably related to excitatory amino acids.

Involvement of the noradrenergic system in modulating the blink reflex in humans

Several researches have shown that the spinal reflex transmission in animals, as well as humans, was inhibited by alpha(2)-agonists, due to a disfacilitation of tonic noradrenergic control on motoneuronal output. To understand better the mechanisms regulating certain aspects of motor activity, here we reinvestigated the possible role of noradrenergic systems in modulating reflex activity of the brainstem in humans. To this aim, blink reflex responses (R1 and R2) evoked by electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve were electromyographically recorded in healthy volunteers. Both R1 and R2 areas were measured at 10-min intervals before and after i.v. injection of alpha(2)-agonist clonidine (0.5 microg/kg). The substance induced consistent depression of R1, which reached its maximum 40 min after drug administration (-43% of the control values). Ipsilateral R2 area resulted little affected by clonidine (-15% at 50 min), whereas no effects were observed in contralateral R2. Blood pressure values were never altered by drug injections. These results, taken together with previous observations, support the hypothesis that alpha(2)-agonist substances may cause a transient inactivation of noradrenergic neurons, thus releasing neurons involved in the circuitry of the blink reflex from a facilitatory drive. Since clonidine differentially modulated blink reflex responses, it is likely to assume that such a disfacilitation concerns mostly pontine units mediating the R1. However, the complexity of clonidine's effects at multiple pre- and postsynaptic sites does not allow us to exclude that other systems are involved in the alpha(2)-mediated control of facial motoneurons.

Scopolamine-induced convulsions in food given fasted mice: effects of clonidine and tizanidine

We recently reported that scopolamine pretreated mice fasted for 48 h developed clonic convulsions soon after they were allowed to eat ad libidum. Pretreatment with MK-801, the non-competitive NMDA antagonist, decreased the incidence of these convulsions. We suggested that a possible scopolamine-induced glutamatergic hyperactivity could account for these convulsions. Using alpha2-agonists, clonidine, which has been shown to inhibit glutamate release, and tizanidine, the present study was performed to find some additional data for the role of glutamate in the underlying mechanism of scopolamine-induced convulsions in food given fasted mice. Animals fasted for 48 h and pretreated (i.p.) with saline, clonidine (0.05, 0.10, 1 mg/kg) or tizanidine (0.10, 0.15, 0.30, 0.45 mg/kg) were treated (i.p.) with either saline or scopolamine (3 mg/kg). Then 20 min later, they were allowed to eat ad libidum and were observed for 30 min for the incidence and onset of clonic convulsions. All doses of clonidine pretreatment completely suppressed (0%) scopolamine-induced clonic convulsions (75%). On the other hand, only 0.15 mg/kg tizanidine pretreatment significantly decreased (15%) the incidence of convulsions; however as well as 0.15 mg/kg, both 0.30 and 0.45 mg/kg tizanidine pretreatments significantly increased latency to the onset of convulsions.

Effects of intrathecal alpha1- and alpha2-noradrenergic agonists and norepinephrine on locomotion in chronic spinal cats

Noradrenergic drugs, acting on alpha adrenoceptors, have been found to play an important role in the initiation and modulation of locomotor pattern in adult cats after spinal cord transection. There are at least two subtypes of alpha adrenoceptors, alpha1 and alpha2 adrenoceptors. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of selective alpha1 and alpha2 agonists in the initiation and modulation of locomotion in adult chronic cats in the early and late stages after complete transection at T13. Five cats, chronically implanted with an intrathecal cannula and electromyographic (EMG) electrodes were used in this study. Noradrenergic drugs including alpha2 agonists (clonidine, tizanidine, and oxymetazoline) and an antagonist, yohimbine, one alpha1 agonist (methoxamine), and a blocker, prazosin, as well as norepinephrine were injected intrathecally. EMG activity synchronized to video images of the hindlimbs were recorded before and after each drug injection. The results show differential effects of alpha1 and alpha2 agonists in the initiation of locomotion in early spinal cats (i.e., in the first week or so when there is no spontaneous locomotion) and in the modulation of locomotion and cutaneous reflexes in the late-spinal cats (i.e., when cats have recovered spontaneous locomotion). In early spinal cats, all three alpha2 agonists were found to initiate locomotion, although their action had a different time course. The alpha1 agonist methoxamine induced bouts of nice locomotor activity in three spinal cats some hours after injection but only induced sustained locomotion in one cat in which the effects were blocked by the alpha1 antagonist prazosin. In late spinal cats, although alpha2 agonists markedly increased the cycle duration and flexor muscle burst duration and decreased the weight support or extensor activity (effects blocked by an alpha2 antagonist, yohimbine), alpha1 agonist increased the weight support and primarily the extensor activity of the hindlimbs without markedly changing the timing of the step cycle. Although alpha2 agonists, especially clonidine, markedly reduced the cutaneous excitability and augmented the foot drag, the alpha1 agonist was found to increase the cutaneous reflex excitability. This is in line with previously reported differential effects of activation of the two receptors on motoneuron excitability and reflex transmission. Noradrenaline, the neurotransmitter itself, increased the cycle duration and at the same time retained the cutaneous excitability, thus exerting both alpha1 and alpha2 effects. This work therefore suggests that different subclasses of noradrenergic drugs could be used to more specifically target aspects of locomotor deficits in patients after spinal injury or diseases.

Effects of tizanidine administration on precipitated opioid withdrawal signs in rats

An opioid withdrawal syndrome was precipitated by naloxone administration in rats treated with morphine. The withdrawal caused alteration of several physiological signs. The aim of the study was to investigate whether the altered physiological profiles were modified by utilising tizanidine, an alpha 2 adrenergic receptor agonist which is capable of affecting faecal and urinary excretion, rectal temperature, pain threshold levels and salivation. To induce an opioid withdrawal syndrome, morphine was administered in three daily intraperitoneal injections for four days at doses of 9, 16 and 25 mg/kg (1st day), 25, 25 and 50 mg/kg (2nd day), 50, 50 and 50 mg/kg (3rd day) and 50, 50 and 100 mg/kg (4th day): naloxone was injected (30 mg/kg) i.p. 180 min after the last morphine injection. Tizanidine was administered orally at 0.17, 0.35 and 0.7 mg/kg, 60 min after the last morphine injection. Signs such as faecal and urine excretion, rectal temperature and latency times to thermal stimulus, salivation, jumping and wet dog shakes were affected in different ways by morphine, naloxone, tizanidine and by the combination of these agents. Notably, the administration of tizanidine in rats receiving morphine and naloxone decreased the intensity of certain withdrawal symptoms, including altered excretion of faeces and urine, salivation and wet dog shake behavior. Body temperature levels and nociceptive threshold values were also modified. The effects caused by tizanidine administration may be due to its alpha 2 receptor agonist activity interfering with a mechanism involved in the regulation of these previously mentioned withdrawal symptoms. Thus, the use of this drug may be indicated as a possible control of the acute phase of opioid withdrawal in heroin addicts.

Tizanidine. A review of its pharmacology, clinical efficacy and tolerability in the management of spasticity associated with cerebral and spinal disorders

The central alpha 2 adrenoceptor agonist tizanidine is a myotonolytic agent used in the treatment of spasticity in patients with cerebral or spinal injury. Wide interpatient variability in the effective plasma concentrations of tizanidine means that the optimal dosage must be titrated over 2 to 4 weeks for each patient (dosages of 2 to 36 mg/day have been used in clinical trials). Maximum effects occur within 2 hours of administration. Antispastic efficacy has been demonstrated for tizanidine in placebo-controlled trials, with reduction in mean muscle tone scores of 21 to 37% versus 4 to 9% for patients receiving placebo. Improvement in muscle tone occurred in 60 to 82% of tizanidine recipients, compared with 60 to 65% of baclofen and 60 to 83% of diazepam recipients. Spasm frequency and clonus are also reduced by tizanidine. The most common adverse effects associated with tizanidine are dry mouth and somnolence/drowsiness. Muscle strength, as assessed by objective means, appears not to be adversely affected by tizanidine and subjective muscle weakness is reported less often by tizanidine recipients than by those receiving baclofen or diazepam. Global tolerability was assessed as good to excellent in 44 to 100% of patients receiving tizanidine, compared with 38 to 90% of baclofen and 20 to 54% of diazepam recipients. In conclusion, tizanidine is an antispastic agent with similar efficacy to that of baclofen and a more favourable tolerability profile. While drowsiness is a frequently reported adverse effect with both agents, subjective muscle weakness appears to be less of a problem with tizanidine than with baclofen. Tizanidine, therefore, appears to be an attractive therapeutic alternative for patients with spasticity associated with cerebral or spinal damage.

Effects of clonidine on a C-fibre reflex in the rat

A C-fibre reflex elicited by electrical stimulation within the territory of the sural nerve, was recorded from the ipsilateral biceps femoris muscle in anaesthetized rats. The temporal evolution of the response was studied using a constant stimulus intensity (3 x threshold) and recruitment curves were built by varying stimulus intensity from 0 to 7 x threshold. The intravenous administration of 0.02-0.2 mg/kg clonidine resulted in a dose-dependent depression of the C-fibre reflex. The alpha 2-adrenoceptor antagonist idazoxan completely prevented this depressive effect of clonidine. The effects of clonidine on the C-fibre reflex elicited by a wide range of stimulus intensities were investigated using recruitment curves: following 0.16 mg/kg clonidine, a dramatic shift of the recruitment curve to the right was seen with both an increase in the threshold and a decrease in the slope. Clonidine also produced a dose-dependent increase in blood pressure, but this was not correlated with the depression of the nociceptive reflex.

Selective depression of medium-latency leg and foot muscle responses to stretch by an alpha 2-agonist in humans

1. In standing humans, toe-up rotation of a platform induces a short-latency (SLR) and a medium-latency response (MLR) in both soleus (Sol) and flexor digitorum brevis (FDB) muscles. Toe-down rotation evokes a MLR in the tibialis anterior (TA). The SLR is the counterpart of the monosynaptic stretch reflex, but the origin of the MLR is still debated. By means of tizanidine (an alpha 2-adrenergic receptor agonist) we tested the hypothesis that the MLR is relayed by group II afferent fibres, since animal data indicate that tizanidine or stimulation of monoaminergic brainstem centres decrease the excitability of spinal interneurones supplied by those fibres. In addition, we compared the effect of the drug on these responses with that induced by stabilization of posture. 2. Eight subjects received tizanidine (150 micrograms kg-1 orally) or placebo, in a single-blind design. Platform rotations were delivered prior to administration and for 3 h afterwards. Both TA- and FDB-MLRs decreased in size, starting from about 1 h after tizanidine administration. Sol-SLR was unaffected. Response latencies were unchanged. Placebo induced no changes in any response. In each subject, the extent of TA-MLR depression induced by holding onto a frame and by tizanidine was superimposable. 3. The selective effect of tizanidine on MLR supports the notion that it is relayed through group II afferent fibres. The similar effects of holding and tizanidine on the response suggests that it is modulated by monoaminergic centres.

A comparison of intrathecally administered narcotic and nonnarcotic analgesics for experimental chronic neuropathic pain

The antinociceptive actions of morphine and tizanidine (an alpha 2-adrenergic agonist) administered intrathecally in a rat model of mononeuropathic pain were investigated. Tizanidine increased to normal levels the intensity of a noxious pressure stimulus required to induce paw withdrawal (p < 0.01) and decreased the duration of limb withdrawal from both normal-temperature and cooled floors in a dose-dependent manner (p < 0.01). Tizanidine had virtually no effect on the latency of paw withdrawal from a noxious heat stimulus. In comparison, morphine significantly decreased, in a dose-dependent manner, limb withdrawal from the normal-temperature and cooled floors and increased to cutoff values the withdrawal latencies of both noxious heat and pressure stimuli (p < 0.01). The effect of tizanidine was limited to the hyperalgesic limb and served to normalize reactive latencies, whereas morphine affected both hindlimbs and increased latencies to supranormal cutoff values. These data suggest that intrathecal tizanidine may be more specific than morphine in reversing the allodynia and hyperpathia associated with neuropathic pain states and may be of value in the management of patients with these clinical syndromes.

Development of a simple spasticity quantification method: effects of tizanidine on spasticity in patients with sequelae of cerebrovascular disease

A simple method that can be performed at the bedside using a spring balance was developed in order to quantify spasticity. The effects of tizanidine on spasticity were evaluated in 30 patients with sequelae of cerebrovascular disease using this method. Treatment with tizanidine was effective in 60% of the patients; there were high correlations between spasticity before and after tizanidine administration and the severity of symptoms and also between the degree of improvement in spasticity and in that of the symptoms. Atonic seizures, due to overdose of tizanidine, were observed in only one patient. The simple spasticity quantification method developed was useful for monitoring tizanidine administration in order to prevent drug overdose. The method appears to be very useful for evaluating the degree of spasticity at the bedside and in measuring the effects of antispastic drugs.