The apparent non-linearity of the relationship between the rate of respiration and the protonmotive force of mitochondria can be explained by heterogeneity of mitochondrial preparations

Safranine O as a fluorescent probe for mitochondrial membrane potential studied on the single particle level and in suspension

The permeant cationic dye safranine O is often used to measure mitochondrial membrane potential due to the dependence of both its absorption and fluorescence on mitochondrial energization, which causes its oligomerization inside mitochondria. In the present study we have used fluorescent correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to record the fluorescence changes on a micro level, i.e. under conditions permitting resolution of contributions from single particles (molecules of the dye and stained mitochondria). We have shown that the decrease in fluorescence signal from a suspension of energized mitochondria stained with a high safranine concentration (10 microM) is explained by the decrease in dye concentration in the medium in parallel with the accumulation of the dye inside the mitochondria, which results in fluorescence quenching. With 1 microM safranine O, the fluorescence rise after energization is caused by the accumulation of the dye up to a level not sufficient for full fluorescence quenching and also by the higher intensity of mitochondrial fluorescence on immersion of the dye in the hydrophobic milieu. Besides the estimation of the inner mitochondrial membrane potential, this approach also assesses the concentration of fluorescent particles. The non-monotonic dependence of the FCS parameter 1/G(tau-->0) on the concentration of mitochondrial protein suggests heterogeneity of the system with respect to fluorescence of particles. An important advantage of the described method is its high sensitivity, which allows measurements with low concentrations and quantities of mitochondrial protein in samples (less than 10 microg).

Cyclosporin A-induced oxidative stress is not the consequence of an increase in mitochondrial membrane potential

Cyclosporin A induces closure of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore. We aimed to investigate whether this closure results in concomitant increases in mitochondrial membrane potential (DeltaPsim) and the production of reactive oxygen species. Fluorescent probes were used to assess DeltaPsim (JC-1, 5,5',6,6'-tetrachloro-1,1',3,3'-tetraethyl-benzimidazolyl-carbocyanine iodide), reactive oxygen species [DCF, 5- (and 6)-chloromethyl-2',7'-dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate, acetyl ester] and [Ca2+][Fluo-3, glycine N-[4-[6-[(acetyloxy)methoxy]-2,7-dichloro-3-oxo-3H-xanthen-9-yl]-2-[2-[2-[bis[2-[(acetyloxy)methoxy]-2-oxyethyl]amino]-5-methylphenoxy]ethoxy]phenyl]-N-[2-[(acetyloxy)methoxy]-2-oxyethyl]-(acetyloxy)methyl ester] in human kidney cells (HK-2 cells) and in a line of human small cell carcinoma cells (GLC4 cells), because these do not express cyclosporin A-sensitive P-glycoprotein. We used transfected GLC4 cells expressing P-glycoprotein as control for GLC4 cells. NIM811 (N-methyl-4-isoleucine-cyclosporin) and PSC833 (SDZ-PSC833) were applied as selective mitochondrial permeability transition pore and P-glycoprotein blockers, respectively. To study the effect of cyclosporin A on mitochondrial function, we isolated mitochondria from fresh pig livers. Cyclosporin A and PSC833 induced a more than two-fold increase in JC-1 fluorescence in HK-2 cells, whereas NIM811 had no effect. None of the three substances induced a significant increase in JC-1 fluorescence in GLC4 cells. Despite this, cyclosporin A, NIM811 and PSC833 induced a 1.5-fold increase in DCF fluorescence (P<0.05) and a two-fold increase in Fluo-3 fluorescence (P<0.05). Studies in isolated mitochondria showed that blockage of mitochondrial permeability transition pores by cyclosporin A affected neither DeltaPsim, ATP synthesis, nor respiration rate. The mitochondrial permeability transition pore blockers cyclosporin A and NIM811, but also the non-mitochondrial permeability transition pore blocker PSC833, induced comparable degrees of reactive oxygen species production and cytosolic [Ca2+]. Neither mitochondria, effects on P-glycoprotein nor inhibition of calcineurin therefore play a role in cyclosporin A-induced oxidative stress and disturbed Ca2+ homeostasis.

Flow-force relationships in lettuce thylakoids. 1. Strict control of electron flow by internal pH

The regulation by the proton gradient of the electron flow from water to ferricyanide was investigated in thylakoids extracted from lettuce leaves. When the transmembrane proton current was varied by an uncoupler or by the ATP synthase activity, a unique relationship was found between the rate of ferricyanide reduction and the proton gradient, restricted here to its delta pH component. This behavior was conserved in CF1-depleted thylakoids where the passive proton flow was varied by the concentration of an Fo inhibitor or by the concentration of an uncoupler after 100% inhibition of Fo. This shows that under our experimental conditions no direct proton transfer exists in steady state between the site of regulation of the redox chain and the ATPase. Studies at two different pH's indicate that the internal pH, and not the transmembrane pH difference, controls the electron transfer between PS2 and PS1. Modeling the data suggests that a single deprotonation step is kinetically limiting.

Respiration in non-phosphorylating yeast mitochondria. Roles of non-ohmic proton conductance and intrinsic uncoupling

Respiratory rate, protonmotive force and charge/O ratio were measured under two different kinds of steady state in non-phosphorylating yeast mitochondria: (i) when the electron flux was modulated by a variable limitation in electron supply or (ii) when oxygen consumption was decreased by respiratory chain inhibitor titration. We showed that the relationships between either delta p or charge/O ratio and respiratory rate are different under the two kinds of steady state, indicating different degrees of intrinsic uncoupling in respiratory chain. Moreover, we observed a non-ohmic dependence between H(+)-conductance and delta p. We concluded that the high rate of static-head respiration in yeast mitochondria was determined both by the non-ohmic proton conductance of the inner membrane and the saturation of the redox proton pump slipping.

Effect of protonmotive force on the relative proton stoichiometries of the mitochondrial proton pumps

The rate of phosphorylation of ADP by isolated mitochondria respiring on succinate was set by addition of ATP, ADP or ADP plus malonate. We measured the rates of phosphorylation and respiration and the protonmotive force under each of these conditions. We measured the oxygen consumption required to drive the proton leak at the protonmotive force reached under each condition and subtracted it from the respiration rate during phosphorylation to determine the oxygen consumption driving phosphorylation. By dividing the rate of phosphorylation by the rate of respiration driving phosphorylation we calculated the mechanistic P/O ratio (number of molecules of ADP phosphorylated per oxygen atom reduced). This ratio was the same at high, intermediate and low values of protonmotive force, indicating that the relative stoichiometries of the mitochondrial protonmotive-force-producing and protonmotive-force-consuming pumps (i.e. H+/O:H+/ATP) are independent of the protonmotive force. This greatly weakens the case for a decrease in stoichiometry, or 'slip', in the mitochondrial proton pumps at high protonmotive force.

Evolution of energy metabolism. Proton permeability of the inner membrane of liver mitochondria is greater in a mammal than in a reptile

Standard metabolic rate is 7-fold greater in the rat (a typical mammal) than in the bearded dragon, Amphibolurus vitticeps (a reptile with the same body mass and temperature). Rat hepatocytes respire 4-fold faster than do hepatocytes from the lizard. The inner membrane of isolated rat liver mitochondrial has a proton permeability that is 4-5-fold greater than the proton permeability of the lizard liver mitochondrial membrane per mg of mitochondrial protein. The greater permeability of rat mitochondria is not caused by differences in the surface area of the mitochondrial inner membrane, but differences in the fatty acid composition of the mitochondrial phospholipids may be involved in the permeability differences. Greater proton permeability of the mitochondrial inner membrane may contribute to the greater standard metabolic rate of mammals.

The proton leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane

The proton conductance of the mitochondrial inner membrane increases at high protonmotive force in isolated mitochondria and in mitochondria in situ in rat hepatocytes. Quantitative analysis of its importance shows that about 20-30% of the oxygen consumption by resting hepatocytes is used to drive a heat-producing cycle of proton pumping by the respiratory chain and proton leak back to the matrix. The flux control coefficient of the proton leak pathway over respiration rate varies between 0.9 and zero in mitochondria depending on the rate of respiration, and has a value of about 0.2 in hepatocytes. Changes in the proton leak pathway in situ will therefore change respiration rate. Mitochondria isolated from hypothyroid animals have decreased proton leak pathway, causing slower state 4 respiration rates. Hepatocytes from hypothyroid rats also have decreased proton leak pathway, and this accounts for about 30% of the decrease in hepatocyte respiration rate. Mitochondrial proton leak may be a significant contributor to standard metabolic rate in vivo.

Regulation of mitochondrial resting state respiration: slip, leak, heterogeneity?

The contribution of molecular slippage of proton pumps, of proton leak and of coupling heterogeneity of mitochondrial population to the well-known non-linear interrelationship between resting state respiration and the protonmotive force is discussed in view of the following experimental findings. (1) After blocking mitochondrial respiration with cyanide, the rate of dissipation of the membrane potential is non-linearly dependent on the actual membrane potential, similarly to the resting state respiration in mitochondria titrated with small amounts of an inhibitor. In contrast, delta pH dissipates proportionally to its actual value. (2) The rate of electron flow from succinate to ferricyanide depends upon the protonmotive force, similarly to the flow from succinate to oxygen. This strongly suggests that the H+/e- stoichiometry in complexes III and IV of the respiratory chain is constant. (3) Mitochondria 'in situ', in permeabilized Ehrlich ascites cells, exhibit the same non-linear flux/force relationship as isolated mitochondria. These results strongly suggest that the non-ohmic characteristics of the inner mitochondrial membrane, with respect to protons driven by the membrane potential but not by the concentration gradient, is the main factor responsible for the nonlinear flux/force relationship in resting state mitochondria.

Energetics of Ehrlich ascites mitochondria: membrane potential of isolated mitochondria and mitochondria within digitonin-permeabilized cells

Ehrlich ascites tumour cells were treated with digitonin so that they became permeable for low-molecular-weight compounds but, at certain concentrations of digitonin, retained most of their cytoplasmic proteins. Respiration of mitochondria with exogenous substrates and their membrane potential could thus be measured in situ by means of oxygen electrode and tetraphenylphosphonium-sensitive electrode, respectively. The results were compared with data from similar measurements on mitochondria isolated from such digitonin-permeabilized cells. Isolated mitochondria and mitochondria in situ oxidized succinate at similar rates and developed membrane potential of comparable magnitude. Both preparations also exhibited an identical nonlinear relationship between resting state respiration (titrated with a respiratory inhibitor) and the membrane potential. In the cells permeabilized with low concentrations of digitonin (i.e., retaining most of cytoplasmic proteins) and suspended in medium containing NaCl and other major anions and cations at concentrations close to those in mammalian plasma, anaerobiosis did not produce a decrease in the mitochondrial membrane potential, which was collapsed only after a subsequent addition of oligomycin. In this medium, glucose had little effect on either respiration or the membrane potential.

Resting state respiration of mitochondria: reappraisal of the role of passive ion fluxes

Rat liver mitochondria respiring under resting state conditions in the presence of oligomycin were rapidly blocked with cyanide and the dissipation of the membrane potential, measured with a tetraphenylphosphonium-sensitive electrode, was followed over time. The plot of the rate of membrane potential dissipation versus the actual value of the membrane potential was nonlinear and identical to the plot of resting state respiration (titrated with small amounts of a respiratory inhibitor) versus the membrane potential. The relationship between the respiratory chain activity and the proton-motive force in mitochondria oxidizing succinate with either oxygen or ferricyanide as electron acceptors was also found to be identical. These results are interpreted as an indication that the passive permeability of the inner mitochondrial membrane toward ions is far more significant in maintaining resting state respiration than is the molecular slippage of the pumps in the respiratory chain. These results also confirm the non-ohmic characteristics of the inner mitochondrial membrane.

Slip and leak in mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation

During oxidative phosphorylation by mammalian mitochondria part of the free energy stored in reduced substrates is dissipated and energy is released as heat. Here I review the mechanisms and the physiological significance of this phenomenon.

Analysis of mechanisms of free-energy coupling and uncoupling by inhibitor titrations: theory, computer modeling and experiments

The rates of ATP synthesis and of ATP-driven NAD reduction have been measured in bovine heart submitochondrial particles as a function of the fraction of inhibited redox pumps (in titrations with either antimycin or rotenone) and of the fraction of inhibited ATPases (in titrations with DCCD). The flux control coefficients of the redox and ATPase proton pumps on the rates of ATP synthesis and of ATP-driven NAD reduction have been derived and found to be equal to 1 for both pumps; i.e., both pumps appear to be 'completely rate limiting'. A theoretical analysis of the inhibitor titration approach based on kinetic models of chemiosmotic coupling and on the theory of metabolic control is presented. This analysis (i) shows that the results of the single inhibitor titrations are incompatible with a delocalized chemiosmotic mechanism of energy coupling if the proton conductance of the membrane is sufficiently low with respect to the conductances of the pumps; and (ii) suggests an experimental approach based on the determination of the P/O and the respiratory control ratios at different degrees of inhibition of the proton pumps to establish the origin of the 'loose coupling' of submitochondrial particle preparations. Three independent types of observation show that the 'loose coupling' of the particle preparation is not mainly due to an increased membrane proton conductance. The same and other independent observations are consistent with the view that the loose coupling of submitochondrial particle preparation is due mainly to inhomogeneity, i.e. to the presence of a subpopulation of highly leaky non-phosphorylating vesicles respiring at maximal rate. The results as a whole together with the simulations and analysis presented lead to the conclusion that the mechanism of free-energy coupling in submitochondrial particles is not completely delocalized.

Redox-linked proton translocation in cytochrome oxidase: the importance of gating electron flow. The effects of slip in a model transducer

In at least one component of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, cytochrome c oxidase, exothermic electron transfer reactions are used to drive vectorial proton transport against an electrochemical hydrogen ion gradient across the mitochondrial inner membrane. The role of the gating of electrons (the regulation of the rates of electron transfer into and out of the proton transport site) in this coupling between electron transfer and proton pumping has been explored. The approach involves the solution of the steady-state rate equations pertinent to proton pump models which include, to various degrees, the uncoupled (i.e., not linked to proton pumping) electron transfer processes which are likely to occur in any real electron transfer-driven proton pump. This analysis furnishes a quantitative framework for examining the effects of variations in proton binding site pKas and metal center reduction potentials, the relationship between energy conservation efficiency and turnover rate, the conditions for maximum power output or minimum heat production, and required efficiency of the gating of electrons. Some novel conclusions emerge from the analysis, including: An efficient electron transfer-driven proton pump need not exhibit a pH-dependent reduction potential; Very efficient gating of electrons is required for efficient electron transfer driven proton pumping, especially when a reasonable correlation of electron transfer rate and electron transfer exoergonicity is assumed; and A consideration of the importance and possible mechanisms of the gating of electrons suggests that efficient proton pumping by CuA in cytochrome oxidase could, in principle, take place with structural changes confined to the immediate vicinity of the copper ion, while proton pumping by Fea would probably require conformational coupling between the iron and more remote structures in the enzyme. The conclusions are discussed with reference to proton pumping by cytochrome c oxidase, and some possible implications for oxidative phosphorylation are noted.

Changes in permeability to protons and other cations at high proton motive force in rat liver mitochondria

We have confirmed that the respiration rate of rat liver mitochondria can be substantially inhibited with only a small drop in proton motive force. We have directly measured the passive proton permeability as a function of delta psi by using K+ diffusion potentials and have shown that there is a large increase in proton permeability at high delta psi. This can quantitatively account for the inhibitor titrations of respiration. delta psi and delta pH were shown to have roughly equal effects on the relatively high respiration rate in static head. The permeabilities to K+, tetramethylammonium+ and choline+ were shown to increase greatly at high delta psi, in a similar way to proton permeability, indicating a similar mechanism of entry.