Over-expression and refolding of beta-subunit from the chloroplast ATP synthase

Ralstonia solanacearum type III effector RipAA targets chloroplastic AtpB to modulate an incompatible interaction on Nicotiana benthamiana

Introduction

The type III effector RipAA of Ralstonia solanacearum GMI1000 plays a critical role in the incompatible interaction on Nicotiana benthamiana.

Methods

The RipAA was transiently expressed in N. benthamiana by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Chemical staining with trypan blue and DAB were conducted to examine the cell death and the accumulation of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂), respectively. The expression of the marker genes for salicylic acid (SA) and jasmonic acid (JA) signaling was evaluated by quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR). The proteins interacted with RipAA was identified from N. benthamiana by yeast two-hybrid and pull-down assays. A TRV-mediated gene silencing was used to assess the role of host gene in response to RipAA expression and R. solanacearum infection.

Results and discussion

RipAA induced the accumulation of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) and genome DNA degradation in N. benthamiana, which were accompanied by a hypersensitive reaction. Simultaneously, the marker genes for salicylic acid (SA) signaling were induced and those for jasmonic acid (JA) signaling were reduced. N. benthamiana chloroplastic AtpB, the ATPase β subunit, was identified as an interactor with RipAA. The silencing of atpB in N. benthamiana resulted in the inability of RipAA to induce a hypersensitive response, a compatible interaction with GMI1000, and an enhanced sensitivity to bacterial wilt. Our data support the concept that RipAA determines host-range specificity by targeting the host chloroplastic AtpB.

Molecular Evolution of the Substrate Specificity of Chloroplastic Aldolases/Rubisco Lysine Methyltransferases in Plants

Rubisco and fructose-1,6-bisphosphate aldolases (FBAs) are involved in CO2 fixation in chloroplasts. Both enzymes are trimethylated at a specific lysine residue by the chloroplastic protein methyltransferase LSMT. Genes coding LSMT are present in all plant genomes but the methylation status of the substrates varies in a species-specific manner. For example, chloroplastic FBAs are naturally trimethylated in both Pisum sativum and Arabidopsis thaliana, whereas the Rubisco large subunit is trimethylated only in the former species. The in vivo methylation status of aldolases and Rubisco matches the catalytic properties of AtLSMT and PsLSMT, which are able to trimethylate FBAs or FBAs and Rubisco, respectively. Here, we created chimera and site-directed mutants of monofunctional AtLSMT and bifunctional PsLSMT to identify the molecular determinants responsible for substrate specificity. Our results indicate that the His-Ala/Pro-Trp triad located in the central part of LSMT enzymes is the key motif to confer the capacity to trimethylate Rubisco. Two of the critical residues are located on a surface loop outside the methyltransferase catalytic site. We observed a strict correlation between the presence of the triad motif and the in vivo methylation status of Rubisco. The distribution of the motif into a phylogenetic tree further suggests that the ancestral function of LSMT was FBA trimethylation. In a recent event during higher plant evolution, this function evolved in ancestors of Fabaceae, Cucurbitaceae, and Rosaceae to include Rubisco as an additional substrate to the archetypal enzyme. Our study provides insight into mechanisms by which SET-domain protein methyltransferases evolve new substrate specificity.

Uncovering the protein lysine and arginine methylation network in Arabidopsis chloroplasts

Post-translational modification of proteins by the addition of methyl groups to the side chains of Lys and Arg residues is proposed to play important roles in many cellular processes. In plants, identification of non-histone methylproteins at a cellular or subcellular scale is still missing. To gain insights into the extent of this modification in chloroplasts we used a bioinformatics approach to identify protein methyltransferases targeted to plastids and set up a workflow to specifically identify Lys and Arg methylated proteins from proteomic data used to produce the Arabidopsis chloroplast proteome. With this approach we could identify 31 high-confidence Lys and Arg methylation sites from 23 chloroplastic proteins, of which only two were previously known to be methylated. These methylproteins are split between the stroma, thylakoids and envelope sub-compartments. They belong to essential metabolic processes, including photosynthesis, and to the chloroplast biogenesis and maintenance machinery (translation, protein import, division). Also, the in silico identification of nine protein methyltransferases that are known or predicted to be targeted to plastids provided a foundation to build the enzymes/substrates relationships that govern methylation in chloroplasts. Thereby, using in vitro methylation assays with chloroplast stroma as a source of methyltransferases we confirmed the methylation sites of two targets, plastid ribosomal protein L11 and the β-subunit of ATP synthase. Furthermore, a biochemical screening of recombinant chloroplastic protein Lys methyltransferases allowed us to identify the enzymes involved in the modification of these substrates. The present study provides a useful resource to build the methyltransferases/methylproteins network and to elucidate the role of protein methylation in chloroplast biology.

Structural Analysis of the Regulatory Dithiol-containing Domain of the Chloroplast ATP Synthase γ Subunit

The gamma subunit of the F1 portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase contains a critically placed dithiol that provides a redox switch converting the enzyme from a latent to an active ATPase. The switch prevents depletion of intracellular ATP pools in the dark when photophosphorylation is inactive. The dithiol is located in a special regulatory segment of about 40 amino acids that is absent from the gamma subunits of the eubacterial and mitochondrial enzymes. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to probe the relationship between the structure of the gamma regulatory segment and its function in ATPase regulation via its interaction with the inhibitory epsilon subunit. Mutations were designed using a homology model of the chloroplast gamma subunit based on the analogous structures of the bacterial and mitochondrial homologues. The mutations included (a) substituting both of the disulfide-forming cysteines (Cys199 and Cys205) for alanines, (b) deleting nine residues containing the dithiol, (c) deleting the region distal to the dithiol (residues 224-240), and (d) deleting the entire segment between residues 196 and 241 with the exception of a small spacer element, and (e) deleting pieces from a small loop segment predicted by the model to interact with the dithiol domain. Deletions within the dithiol domain and within parts of the loop segment resulted in loss of redox control of the ATPase activity of the F1 enzyme. Deleting the distal segment, the whole regulatory domain, or parts of the loop segment had the additional effect of reducing the maximum extent of inhibition obtained upon adding the epsilon subunit but did not abolish epsilon binding. The results suggest a mechanism by which the gamma and epsilon subunits interact with each other to induce the latent state of the enzyme.

Structural restoration of inactive recombinant fish growth hormones by chemical chaperonin and solvent restraint approaches

Recombinant proteins may undergo conformational distortion, leading to aggregation and loss of function, when they are expressed in heterologous systems. The structural and functional restoration of such inactive proteins is highly desirable. We have over-expressed recombinant growth hormones from the fish ayu (Plecoglossus altivelis) and yellow grouper (Epinephelus awoara) by a pET expression system. Both recombinant proteins accumulate as insoluble form in Escherichia coli. We refolded these inactive proteins into the active form using a stepwise refolding process with a dilute denaturing agent as a steric blocker and chemical chaperonin. Optical characterization showed that stable folding intermediates with a helical conformation can be detected in the molten globule state. Moreover, the function of restored recombinant growth hormones was demonstrated by its ability to stimulate proliferation in zebrafish liver cells.

Role of the ATP synthase alpha-subunit in conferring sensitivity to tentoxin

Tentoxin, produced by phytopathogenic fungi, selectively affects the function of the ATP synthase enzymes of certain sensitive plant species. Binding of tentoxin to a high affinity (K(i) approximately 10 nM) site on the chloroplast F(1) (CF(1)) strongly inhibits catalytic function, whereas binding to a second, lower affinity site (K(d) > 10 microM) leads to restoration and even stimulation of catalytic activity. Sensitivity to tentoxin has been shown to be due, in part, to the nature of the amino acid residue at position 83 on the catalytic beta subunit of CF(1). An aspartate in this position is required, but is not sufficient, for tentoxin inhibition. By comparison with the solved structure of mitochondrial F(1) [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628], Asp83 is probably located at an interface between alpha and beta subunits on CF(1) where residues on the alpha subunit could also participate in tentoxin binding. A hybrid core F(1) enzyme assembled with beta and gamma subunits of the tentoxin-sensitive spinach CF(1), and an alpha subunit of the tentoxin-insensitive photosynthetic bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum F(1) (RrF(1)), was stimulated but not inhibited by tentoxin [Tucker, W. C., Du, Z., Gromet-Elhanan, Z. and Richter, M. L. (2001) Eur. J. Biochem. 268, 2179-2186]. In this study, chimeric alpha subunits were prepared by introducing short segments of the spinach CF(1) alpha subunit from a poorly conserved region which is immediately adjacent to beta-Asp83 in the crystal structure, into equivalent positions in the RrF(1) alpha subunit using oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Hybrid enzymes containing these chimeric alpha subunits had both the high affinity inhibitory tentoxin binding site and the lower affinity stimulatory site. Changing beta-Asp83 to leucine resulted in loss of both inhibition and stimulation by tentoxin in the chimeras. The results indicate that tentoxin inhibition requires additional alpha residues that are not present on the RrF(1) alpha subunit. A structural model of a putative inhibitory tentoxin binding pocket is presented.

Formation and properties of hybrid photosynthetic F1-ATPases. Demonstration of different structural requirements for stimulation and inhibition by tentoxin

A hybrid ATPase composed of cloned chloroplast ATP synthase beta and gamma subunits (betaC and gammaC) and the cloned alpha subunit from the Rhodospirillum rubrum ATP synthase (alphaR) was assembled using solubilized inclusion bodies and a simple single-step folding procedure. The catalytic properties of the assembled alpha3Rbeta3CgammaC were compared to those of the core alpha3Cbeta3CgammaC complex of the native chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1) and to another recently described hybrid enzyme containing R. rubrum alpha and beta subunits and the CF1 gamma subunit (alpha3Rbeta3RgammaC). All three enzymes were similarly stimulated by dithiothreitol and inhibited by copper chloride in response to reduction and oxidation, respectively, of the disulfide bond in the chloroplast gamma subunit. In addition, all three enzymes exhibited the same concentration dependence for inhibition by the CF1 epsilon subunit. Thus the CF1 gamma subunit conferred full redox regulation and normal epsilon binding to the two hybrid enzymes. Only the native CF1 alpha3Cbeta3CgammaC complex was inhibited by tentoxin, confirming the requirement for both CF1 alpha and beta subunits for tentoxin inhibition. However, the alpha3Rbeta3CgammaC complex, like the alpha3Cbeta3CgammaC complex, was stimulated by tentoxin at concentrations in excess of 10 microm. In addition, replacement of the aspartate at position 83 in betaC with leucine resulted in the loss of stimulation in the alpha3Rbeta3CgammaC hybrid. The results indicate that both inhibition and stimulation by tentoxin require a similar structural contribution from the beta subunit, but differ in their requirements for alpha subunit structure.

Hybrid Rhodospirillum rubrum F(0)F(1) ATP synthases containing spinach chloroplast F(1) beta or alpha and beta subunits reveal the essential role of the alpha subunit in ATP synthesis and tentoxin sensitivity

Trace amounts ( approximately 5%) of the chloroplast alpha subunit were found to be absolutely required for effective restoration of catalytic function to LiCl-treated chromatophores of Rhodospirillum rubrum with the chloroplast beta subunit (Avital, S., and Gromet-Elhanan, Z. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 7067-7072). To clarify the role of the alpha subunit in the rebinding of beta, restoration of catalytic function, and conferral of sensitivity to the chloroplast-specific inhibitor tentoxin, LiCl-treated chromatophores were analyzed by immunoblotting before and after reconstitution with mixtures of R. rubrum and chloroplast alpha and beta subunits. The treated chromatophores were found to have lost, in addition to most of their beta subunits, approximately a third of the alpha subunits, and restoration of catalytic activity required rebinding of both subunits. The hybrid reconstituted with the R. rubrum alpha and chloroplast beta subunits was active in ATP synthesis as well as hydrolysis, and both activities were completely resistant to tentoxin. In contrast, a hybrid reconstituted with both chloroplast alpha and beta subunits restored only a MgATPase activity, which was fully inhibited by tentoxin. These results indicate that all three copies of the R. rubrum alpha subunit are required for proton-coupled ATP synthesis, whereas for conferral of tentoxin sensitivity at least one copy of the chloroplast alpha subunit is required together with the chloroplast beta subunit. The hybrid system was further used to examine the effects of amino acid substitution at position 83 of the beta subunit on sensitivity to tentoxin.

Refolding of recombinant alpha and beta subunits of the Rhodospirillum rubrum F(0)F(1) ATP synthase into functional monomers that reconstitute an active alpha(1)beta(1)-dimer

The alpha subunit from the Rhodospirillum rubrum F(0)F(1) ATP synthase (RrF(1)alpha) was over-expressed in unc operon-deleted Escherichia coli strains under various growth conditions only in insoluble inclusion bodies. The functional refolding of urea-solubilized RrF(1)alpha was followed by measuring its ability to stimulate the restoration of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis in beta-less R. rubrum chromatophores reconstituted with pure native or recombinant RrF(1)beta [Nathanson, L. & Gromet-Elhanan, Z. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 10933-10938]. The refolding efficiency was found to increase with decreasing RrF(1)alpha concentrations and required high concentrations of MgATP, saturating approximately 60% when 50 microgram protein.mL(-1) were refolded in presence of 50 mM MgATP. Size-exclusion HPLC of such refolded RrF(1)alpha revealed a 50-60% decrease in its aggregated form and a parallel appearance of its monomeric peak. RrF(1)beta refolded under identical conditions appeared almost exclusively as a monomer. This procedure enabled the isolation of large amounts of a stable RrF(1)alpha monomer, which stimulated the restoration of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis much more efficiently than the refolded alpha mixture, and bound ATP and ADP in a Mg-dependent manner. Incubation of both RrF(1)alpha and beta monomers, which by themselves had no ATPase activity, resulted in a parallel appearance of activity and assembled alpha(1)beta(1)-dimers, but showed no formation of alpha(3)beta(3)-hexamers. The RrF(1)-alpha(1)beta(1)-ATPase activity was, however, very similar to the activity observed in isolated native chloroplast CF(1)-alpha(3)beta(3), indicating that these dimers contain only the catalytic nucleotide-binding site at their alpha/beta interface. Their inability to associate into an alpha(3)beta(3)-hexamer seems therefore to reflect a much lower stability of the noncatalytic RrF(1) alpha/beta interface.

The 20 C-terminal amino acid residues of the chloroplast ATP synthase gamma subunit are not essential for activity

It has been suggested that the last seven to nine amino acid residues at the C terminus of the gamma subunit of the ATP synthase act as a spindle for rotation of the gamma subunit with respect to the alpha beta subunits during catalysis (Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628). To test this hypothesis we selectively deleted C-terminal residues from the chloroplast gamma subunit, two at a time starting at the sixth residue from the end and finishing at the 20th residue from the end. The mutant gamma genes were overexpressed in Escherichia coli and assembled with a native alpha3beta3 complex. All the mutant forms of gamma assembled as effectively as the wild-type gamma. Deletion of the terminal 6 residues of gamma resulted in a significant increase (>50%) in the Ca-dependent ATPase activity when compared with the wild-type assembly. The increased activity persisted even after deletion of the C-terminal 14 residues, well beyond the seven residues proposed to form the spindle. Further deletions resulted in a decreased activity to approximately 19% of that of the wild-type enzyme after deleting all 20 C-terminal residues. The results indicate that the tip of the gammaC terminus is not essential for catalysis and raise questions about the role of the C terminus as a spindle for rotation.

A subunit interaction in chloroplast ATP synthase determined by genetic complementation between chloroplast and bacterial ATP synthase genes

F1F0-ATP synthases utilize protein conformational changes induced by a transmembrane proton gradient to synthesize ATP. The allosteric cooperativity of these multisubunit enzymes presumably requires numerous protein-protein interactions within the enzyme complex. To correlate known in vitro changes in subunit structure with in vivo allosteric interactions, we introduced the beta subunit of spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1 ATP into a bacterial F1 ATP synthase. A cloned atpB gene, encoding the complete chloroplast beta subunit, complemented a chromosomal deletion of the cognate uncD gene in Escherichia coli and was incorporated into a functional hybrid F1 ATP synthase. The cysteine residue at position 63 in chloroplast beta is known to be located at the interface between alpha and beta subunits and to be conformationally coupled, in vitro, to the nucleotide binding site > 40 A away. Enlarging the side chain of chloroplast coupling factor 1 beta residue 63 from Cys to Trp blocked ATP synthesis in vivo without significantly impairing ATPase activity or ADP binding in vitro. The in vivo coupling of nucleotide binding at catalytic sites to transmembrane proton movement may thus involve an interaction, via conformational changes, between the amino-terminal domains of the alpha and beta subunits.

In vitro assembly of the core catalytic complex of the chloroplast ATP synthase

The regulatory gamma subunit and an alpha beta complex were isolated from the catalytic F1 portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase. The isolated gamma subunit was devoid of catalytic activity, whereas the alpha beta complex exhibited a very low ATPase activity (approximately 200 nmol/min/mg of protein). The alpha beta complex migrated as a hexameric alpha 3 beta 3 complex during ultracentrifugation and gel filtration but reversibly dissociated into alpha and beta monomers after freezing and thawing in the presence of ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid and in the absence of nucleotides. Conditions are described in which the gamma and alpha beta preparations were combined to rapidly and efficiently reconstitute a fully functional catalytic core enzyme complex. The reconstituted enzyme exhibited normal tight binding and sensitivity to the inhibitory epsilon subunit and to the allosteric inhibitor tentoxin. However, neither the alpha beta complex nor the isolated gamma subunit alone could bind the epsilon subunit or tentoxin with high affinity. Similarly, high affinity binding sites for ATP and ADP, which are characteristic of the core alpha 3 beta 3 gamma enzyme, were absent from the alpha beta complex. The results indicate that when the gamma subunit binds to the alpha beta complex, it induces a three-dimensional conformation in the enzyme, which is necessary for tight binding of the inhibitors and for high-affinity, asymmetric nucleotide binding.

Reassembly of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 F1-ATPase from its over-expressed subunits

Subunits alpha, beta, and gamma of the F1-part of cyanobacterial F0F1-ATPase have been cloned into expression vectors. Over-expressed subunit beta was found soluble in the cytoplasmic fraction of Escherichia coli cells under appropriate culture and induction conditions and was purified from cell extracts. Recombinant alpha and gamma subunits precipitated into inclusion bodies and had to be solubilized, purified and refolded. The correct folding and functional integrity of the alpha and beta subunits was monitored by their ability to bind nucleotides. Active cyanobacterial F1-ATPase was assembled from its purified subunits alpha, beta, gamma, delta and epsilon. The reassembled enzyme reconstituted ATP synthesis in F1-depleted thylakoid membranes of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 and hydrolyzed ATP.