Properties of N-terminus truncated and C-terminus mutated muscle acylphosphatases

Structural and thermodynamic investigations on the aggregation and folding of acylphosphatase by molecular dynamics simulations and solvation free energy analysis

Protein engineering method to study the mutation effects on muscle acylphosphatase (AcP) has been actively applied to describe kinetics and thermodynamics associated with AcP aggregation as well as folding processes. Despite the extensive mutation experiments, the molecular origin and the structural motifs for aggregation and folding kinetics as well as thermodynamics of AcP have not been rationalized at the atomic resolution. To this end, we have investigated the mutation effects on the structures and thermodynamics for the aggregation and folding of AcP by using the combination of fully atomistic, explicit-water molecular dynamics simulations, and three-dimensional reference interaction site model theory. The results indicate that the A30G mutant with the fastest experimental aggregation rate displays considerably decreased α1-helical contents as well as disrupted hydrophobic core compared to the wild-type AcP. Increased solvation free energy as well as hydrophobicity upon A30G mutation is achieved due to the dehydration of hydrophilic side chains in the disrupted α1-helix region of A30G. In contrast, the Y91Q mutant with the slowest aggregation rate shows a non-native H-bonding network spanning the mutation site to hydrophobic core and α1-helix region, which rigidifies the native state protein conformation with the enhanced α1-helicity. Furthermore, Y91Q exhibits decreased solvation free energy and hydrophobicity compared to wild type due to more exposed and solvated hydrophilic side chains in the α1-region. On the other hand, the experimentally observed slower folding rates in both mutants are accompanied by decreased helicity in α2-helix upon mutation. We here provide the atomic-level structures and thermodynamic quantities of AcP mutants and rationalize the structural origin for the changes that occur upon introduction of those mutations along the AcP aggregation and folding processes.

The degree of structural protection at the edge beta-strands determines the pathway of amyloid formation in globular proteins

The assembly of proteins into highly organized fibrillar aggregates is a key process in biology, biotechnology, and human disease. It has been shown that proteins retain a small, yet significant propensity to aggregate when they are folded into compact globular structures, and this may be physiologically relevant, particularly when considering that proteins spend most of their lifespan into such compact states. Proteins from the acylphosphatase-like structural family have been shown to aggregate via different mechanisms, with some members forming native-like aggregates as a first step of their aggregation process and others requiring unfolding as a first necessary step. Here we use the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus to show that assembly of folded protein molecules into native-like aggregates is prevented by single-point mutations that introduce structural protections within one of the most flexible region of the protein, the peripheral edge beta-strand 4. The resulting mutants do not form native-like aggregates, but can still form thioflavin T-binding and beta-structured oligomers, albeit more slowly than the wild-type protein. The kinetic data show that formation of the latter species proceeds via an alternative mechanism that is independent of the transient formation of native-like aggregates.

Crystal structure and anion binding in the prokaryotic hydrogenase maturation factor HypF acylphosphatase-like domain

[NiFe]-hydrogenases require a set of complementary and regulatory proteins for correct folding and maturation processes. One of the essential regulatory proteins, HypF (82kDa) contains a N-terminal acylphosphatase (ACT)-like domain, a sequence motif shared with enzymes catalyzing O-carbamoylation, and two zinc finger motifs similar to those found in the DnaJ chaperone. The HypF acylphosphatase domain is thought to support the conversion of carbamoylphosphate into CO and CN(-), promoting coordination of these ligands to the hydrogenase metal cluster. It has been shown recently that the HypF N-terminal domain can aggregate in vitro to yield fibrils matching those formed by proteins linked to amyloid diseases. The 1.27A resolution HypF acylphosphatase domain crystal structure (residues 1-91; R-factor 13.1%) shows a domain fold of betaalphabetabetaalphabeta topology, as observed in mammalian acylphosphatases specifically catalyzing the hydrolysis of the carboxyl-phosphate bonds in acylphosphates. The HypF N-terminal domain can be assigned to the ferredoxin structural superfamily, to which RNA-binding domains of small nuclear ribonucleoproteins and some metallochaperone proteins belong. Additionally, the HypF N-terminal domain displays an intriguing structural relationship to the recently discovered ACT domains. The structures of different HypF acylphosphatase domain complexes show a phosphate binding cradle comparable to the P-loop observed in unrelated phosphatase families. On the basis of the catalytic mechanism proposed for acylphosphatases, whereby residues Arg23 and Asn41 would support substrate orientation and the nucleophilic attack of a water molecule on the phosphate group, fine structural features of the HypF N-terminal domain putative active site region may account for the lack of acylphosphatase activity observed for the expressed domain. The crystallographic analyses here reported were undertaken to shed light on the molecular bases of inactivity, folding, misfolding and aggregation of the HypF N-terminal acylphosphatase domain.

Stabilisation of alpha-helices by site-directed mutagenesis reveals the importance of secondary structure in the transition state for acylphosphatase folding

The effects of stabilising mutations on the folding process of common-type acylphosphatase have been investigated. The mutations were designed to increase the helical propensity of the regions of the polypeptide chain corresponding to the two alpha-helices of the native protein. Various synthetic peptides incorporating the designed mutations were produced and their helical content estimated by circular dichroism. The most substantial increase in helical content is found for the peptide carrying five mutations in the second alpha-helix. Acylphosphatase variants containing the corresponding mutations display, to different extents, enhanced conformational stabilities as indicated by equilibrium urea denaturation experiments monitored by changes of intrinsic fluorescence. All the protein variants studied here refold with apparent two-state kinetics. Mutations in the first alpha-helix are responsible for a small increase in the refolding rate, accompanied by a marked decrease in the unfolding rate. On the other hand, multiple mutations in the second helix result in a considerable increase in the refolding rate without any significant effect on the unfolding rate. Addition of trifluoroethanol was found to accelerate the folding of the acylphosphatase variants, the extent of the acceleration being inversely proportional to the intrinsic rate of folding of the corresponding mutant. The trifluoroethanol-induced acceleration is far less marked for those variants whose alpha-helical structure is efficiently stabilised by amino acid replacements. This observation suggests that trifluoroethanol acts in a similar manner to the stabilising mutations in promoting native-like secondary structure. Analysis of the kinetic data indicates that the second helix is fully consolidated in the transition state for folding of acylphosphatase, whereas the first helix is only partially formed. These data suggest that the second helix is an important element in the folding process of the protein.

Development of enzymatic activity during protein folding. Detection of a spectroscopically silent native-like intermediate of muscle acylphosphatase

The recovery of enzymatic activity during the folding of muscle acylphosphatase and two single residue mutants (proline 54 to alanine and proline 71 to alanine) from 7 M urea has been monitored and compared with the development of intrinsic fluorescence emission. Fluorescence measurements reveal the presence in the wild-type protein of a major rapid refolding phase followed by a second low amplitude slow phase. The slow phase is absent in the fluorescence trace acquired with the proline 54 to alanine mutant, suggesting the involvement of this proline residue in the fluorescence-detected slow phase of the wild-type protein. The major kinetic phase is associated with a considerable recovery of enzymatic activity, indicating that a large fraction of molecules refolds with effective two-state behavior. The use of time-resolved enzymatic activity as a probe to follow the folding process reveals, however, the presence of another exponential slow phase arising from proline 71. This slow phase is not observable by utilizing optical probes, indicating that, unlike proline 54, the cis to trans isomerization of proline 71 can take place in an intermediate possessing a native-like fold. We suggest that, although spectroscopically silent and structurally insignificant, the cis-trans interconversion of proline residues in native-like intermediates may be crucial for the generation of enzymatic activity of functional enzymes.

Structural and kinetic investigations on the 15-21 and 42-45 loops of muscle acylphosphatase: evidence for their involvement in enzyme catalysis and conformational stabilization

The structural and catalytic importance of the 15-21 and 42-45 loop residues of the acylphosphatase muscular isoenzyme has been investigated by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Seven mutants involving conserved residues of the two loops have been prepared and characterized for structural, kinetic, and stability features by using different spectroscopic techniques and compared to the wild-type enzyme. The results are discussed in light of the crystal structure of the highly homologous common type acylphosphatase [Thunnissen et al. (1997) Structure 5, 69-79]. A differential role of the two loops has emerged: the 15-21 and the 42-45 loops appear mainly involved in active site formation and enzyme structural stabilization, respectively. These conclusions are supported by a strong impairment of the catalytic efficiency, in terms of enzymatic activity and substrate binding capability, for most of the 15-21 loop mutants. In particular, the Gly15Ala mutant is completely inactive and displays a native-like overall fold, indicating that the correct geometry of the 15-21 loop is an essential requisite for optimal enzymatic catalysis. Instead, the Gly45Ala mutant, though revealing unchanged catalytic properties, shows a considerably reduced conformational stability, as judged by circular dichroism and 1H NMR spectroscopy. This finding confirms previous results relative to Thr42 and Thr46 residues [Taddei et al. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 7077-7083] underlining the structural importance of the 42-45 loop as a linker for the two beta alpha beta units constituting the overall enzyme structure.

Crystal structure of common type acylphosphatase from bovine testis

BACKGROUND

Acylphosphatase (ACP) is a low molecular weight phosphomonohydrolase catalyzing with high specificity the hydrolysis of the carboxyl-phosphate bond present in acylphosphates. The enzyme is thought to regulate metabolic processes in which acylphosphates are involved, such as glycolysis and the production of ribonucleotides. Furthermore the enzyme is capable of hydrolyzing the phospho-aspartyl intermediate formed during the action of membrane pumps such as (Ca2++Mg2+) ATPase. Although the tertiary structure of a muscle ACP has been determined by NMR spectroscopy, little is known about the catalytic mechanism of ACP and further structures might provide an increased understanding.

RESULTS

The structure of 'common type' ACP from bovine testis has been determined by X-ray crystallography to a resolution of 1.8 A. The structure has been refined to an R factor of 17.0 % using all data between 15 and 1.8 A. The binding of a sulphate and a chloride ion in the active centre allows a detailed description of this site. The overall protein folds of common type and muscle ACP are similar but their loops have very different conformations. These differences, in part, are probably caused by the binding of the ions in the active site of the common type form. The phosphate-binding loop of ACP shows some remarkable similarities to that of low molecular weight protein tyrosine phosphatase.

CONCLUSIONS

The active site of ACP has been located, enabling a reaction mechanism to be suggested in which the phosphate moiety bound to Arg23 acts as a base, abstracting a proton from a nucleophilic water molecule liganded to Asn41. The transition-state intermediate is stabilized by the phosphate-binding loop. We suggest the catalysis to be substrate assisted, which probably explains why this enzyme can only hydrolyze acylphosphates.

Looking for residues involved in the muscle acylphosphatase catalytic mechanism and structural stabilization: role of Asn41, Thr42, and Thr46

Asn41, Thr42, and Thr46 are invariant residues in both muscle and erythrocyte acylphosphatases isolated so far. Horse muscle acylphosphatase solution structure suggests their close spatial relationship to Arg23, the main substrate binding site. The catalytic and structural role of such residues, as well as their influence on muscle acylphosphatase stability, was investigated by preparing several gene mutants (Thr42Ala, Thr46Ala, Asn41Ala, Asn41Ser, and Asn41Gln) by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. The mutated genes were cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and the mutant enzymes were purified by affinity chromatography and investigated as compared to the wild-type enzyme. The specific activity and substrate affinity of Thr42 and Thr46 mutants were not significantly affected. On the contrary, Asn41 mutants showed a residual negligible activity (about 0.05-0.15% as compared to wild-type enzyme), though maintaining an unchanged binding capability of both substrate and inorganic phosphate, an enzyme competitive inhibitor. According to the 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and circular dichroism results, all mutants elicited well-constrained native-like secondary and tertiary structures. Thermodynamic parameters, as calculated from circular dichroism data, demonstrated a significantly decreased stability of the Thr42 mutant under increasing temperatures and urea concentrations. The reported results strongly support a direct participation of Asn41 to the enzyme catalytic mechanism, indicating that Asn41 mutants may well represent a useful tool for the investigation of the enzyme physiological function by the negative dominant approach.

C-terminal region contributes to muscle acylphosphatase three-dimensional structure stabilisation

Ser-Ala and Ser-Ala-Ser-Ala C-terminus elongated (delta+2 and delta+4, respectively) and two C-terminus deleted (delta-2 and delta-3) muscle acylphosphatase mutants were investigated to assess the catalytic and structural roles of the C-terminal region. The kinetic analysis of these mutants shows that the removal of two or three C-terminal residues reduces the catalytic activity to 7% and 4% of the value measured for the wild-type enzyme, respectively; instead, the elongation of the C-terminus does not significantly change the enzyme behaviour. 1H Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy indicates that all mutants display a native-like fold though they appear less stable, particularly delta-2 and delta-3 mutants, as compared to the wild-type enzyme. Such destabilisation of the C-terminal modified mutants is further confirmed by urea inactivation experiments. The results here presented account for an involvement of the C-terminal region in the stabilisation of the three-dimensional structure of acylphosphatase, particularly at the active-site level. Moreover, a participation of the C-terminal carboxyl group to the catalytic mechanism can be excluded.

Properties of Cys21-mutated muscle acylphosphatases

Cys21 is an invariant residue in muscle acylphosphatases, but is absent in the erythrocyte isozymes. To assess the importance of this residue in the muscle isozymes for catalytic, structural, and stability properties, two gene mutants have been prepared by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis and expressed in Escherichia coli cells; in these mutants, the codon for Cys21 was replaced by those for Ser and Ala, respectively. The two mutant enzymes, purified by immunoaffinity chromatography, showed kinetic and structural properties similar to those of the wild-type recombinant enzyme; however, the specific activity of the two mutants, especially that of the C21A mutant, was lower. The urea and thermal stabilities of the mutant enzymes were reduced with respect to those of the wild-type form, contrary to the susceptibility to inactivation by mercuric ions. The reported data support the possibility that Cys21 is involved in the stabilization of the enzyme active-site conformation.