An ELISA assay efficiently detects clonal antibody formation by single, hapten-specific B lymphocytes

Influence of the antibody-peroxidase coupling methods on the conjugate stability and on the methodologies for the preservation of the activity in time

We studied the influence of conjugation methods and storage conditions on the stability of immunoconjugates with peroxidase. We demonstrate here that conjugates formed by the maleimide-sulfhydryl method and by the periodate oxidation method lose activity when maintained in diluted solutions. However, while the loss of activity of MSM conjugates is due exclusively to hydrolysis of the thioether bond, the loss of activity of periodate complexes is caused by a reduction of both the enzymatic and antibody immunochemical activities. Based on these observations, we developed a buffer that stabilizes the thioether bond, thus permitting long time storage of these immunoconjugates at low concentration and at above freezing temperatures.

Interferon-gamma downregulates the proliferative response of hapten-specific B cells stimulated by antigen and cytokines

IFN-gamma plays a role in many aspects of cellular interactions, both positive and negative. Among its functions during the immune response, the antagonistic effects of IFN-gamma and IL-4 are well documented. Observations in our laboratory suggested that IFN-gamma could also interfere with the activation of single, antigen-specific B cells by antigen and other cytokines. Closer examination revealed that IFN-gamma reduced the number of proliferating cell clones in response to antigen and a variety of cytokines, alone or in combination. Cell viability remained at the initial level and the cells were still able to produce Ig, albeit to a lesser extent than in the absence of IFN-gamma. On the other hand, the frequency of IgM secreting clones was not affected, whereas the total amount of secreted IgM was lower in the presence of IFN-gamma, probably due to the reduced cell number and a decrease in Ig production. In addition, proliferation was prevented when B cells were pre-incubated with IFN-gamma and then stimulated by other cytokines. Kinetic studies revealed that INF-gamma had to be present from the onset of culture because delayed addition did not inhibit the proliferation of the B cells. After its initial action, IFN-gamma could be removed without abolishing the negative signal for proliferation. From these results it can be concluded that IFN-gamma transmits a signal that causes B cells to stop proliferating and prevents them from forming large clones.

Rabbit single domain antibodies specific to protein C expressed in prokaryotes

VDJ genes were amplified by the polymerase chain reaction from mRNA isolated from peripheral blood B cells of rabbits immunized with protein C. The amplified genes were cloned into a lambda phage expression vector and packaged. A library of 6 x 10(5) recombinant phages was screened with labelled protein C and 30 positive clones were found. Three of them were plaque purified and the affinity of the single domain antibodies to the antigen determined to be 10(6)-10(7) l M-1. The data indicate the feasibility of generating single domain antibody, specific to protein antigen, from rabbit.

Spontaneous and cytokine-inducible 'natural' immunoglobulin secreting cells in organized lymphoid tissues of mice

The number and frequency of spontaneous and cytokine-inducible 'natural' immunoglobulin-secreting cells (ISC) were determined in bone marrow (BM), spleen and Peyer's patch (PP), in vitro. Cells were cultured at limiting dilution in the presence or absence of exogenous recombinant cytokines and supernatants then assayed for total immunoglobulin (Ig) and Ig isotype using an ELISA. Most spontaneous ISC were found in the spleen and BM, with fewer in PP. The addition of recombinant interleukin 5 (rIL-5) promoted a marked increase in both the ISC frequency and the amount of Ig secreted/ISC whereas recombinant IL-6 (rIL-6) promoted only a marginal increase. Recombinant IL-4 (rIL-4) promoted a marginal increase in ISC frequency only. The isotype profile of ISC was in the order IgM greater than IgG2 greater than IgA greater than IgG3 greater than IgG1. The exposure of cells to 1200 rad of gamma-radiation resulted in decreased numbers of spontaneous ISC in all tissues, but the addition of rIL-5 or rIL-6 to the irradiated cells increased both the ISC frequency and Ig secreted. The Ig isotype profile was similar to that of non-irradiated ISC with a few minor exceptions. This large population of potential cytokine-inducible ISC could contribute to 'natural' Ig secretion in vivo.

Clonal repertoire analysis of murine B cells specific for repeat sequence antigens of Plasmodium falciparum

Clonal analysis of the murine B-cell repertoire has been used to investigate the possible role of tandem repeat sequence epitopes of Plasmodium falciparum in immune evasion. A limiting dilution culture system was used whereby murine spleen cells were stimulated with the B-cell mitogen lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in the presence of 3T3 fibroblast filler cells. One in three B cells were shown to produce clones secreting immunoglobulin measurable by an ELISA. The frequency of antibody forming cell precursors (AFCp) specific for the 3' repeat epitopes of the ring injected erythrocyte surface antigen (RESA) was estimated in non-primed mice and found to be low. However, an accurate frequency determination was not possible using this method since the detection of the few positive cultures was found to depend on the presence of more than one AFCp or its products. Limiting dilution analysis was used to assess the frequency and repertoire of splenic AFCp at various times after immunization with a synthetic peptide of the RESA 3' repeat epitope (8 x 4-mer), presented in various ways. There was no marked increase in LPS-responsive AFCp specific for this antigen at the level of either IgM or IgG secretion. This was in marked contrast to the antibody response in vivo, where moderate IgG antibody titres, normally indicative of a secondary response, were seen in the serum of the same mice used for AFCp assay. This discrepancy between serum titre and AFCp frequency following immunization was not apparent with a non-malarial antigen, keyhole limpet haemocyanin (KLH). It was concluded that the LPS-stimulated limiting dilution culture system was not registering RESA-specific memory AFCp. These results raise the possibility that the malarial antigens are deficient in memory B-cell generation, or that secondary responses to these determinants may arise from a distinct B-cell progenitor which is non-responsive to LPS in vitro.

Inhibition of antibody production at high cell density following mitogen stimulation and isotype switching in vitro

We have investigated antibody production in 3T3 filler cell-containing murine B lymphocyte cultures, stimulated with LPS and an IL-4-containing lymphokine mixture. At low cell density cultures produced 1.8 +/- 0.6 ng of IgM and 4.2 +/- 1.7 ng of IgG1 per input B cell. It was found that 21.7 +/- 3.5% of spleen cells, or approximately 43% of B cells, produce IgM under these conditions, and 11.9 +/- 5.5% spleen cells, approximately 24% of B cells, produced IgG1. Therefore, the mean IgM production per IgM-positive clone was 4.2 ng, and the mean IgG1 production per IgG1-positive clone was 17.6 ng. A cell density of about 10,000 B cells/ml was found to produce maximal antibody per input cell. A 32-fold increase above the maximum cell density resulted in a 600-fold decrease in IgG1 production per B cell. IgM production was also found to be inhibited above this concentration of cells, but to a six-fold lesser extent. Cell proliferation in dense cultures was also found to be diminished in a cell concentration-dependent manner, partially accounting for the observed inhibition phenomenon. The replenishment of media, LPS and growth factors was able to lessen the inhibition of dense cultures, but not to maximal levels. Overall, this work identified the upper limit of cell density for in vitro cloning of B lymphocytes for isotype switch and repertoire analysis. The most important conclusion is that antibody production is grossly suboptimal at the cell densities frequently used in the literature.

The immunochemistry of sandwich ELISAs--III. The stoichiometry and efficacy of the protein-avidin-biotin capture (PABC) system

The protein-avidin-biotin capture (PABC) system was developed to decrease the adsorption-induced loss of antigen capture capacity (AgCC) of capture antibodies (CAb) used in sandwich ELISAs. This system involves immobilization of biotinylated CAbs through linkage by streptavidin (SA) to biotinylated carrier proteins adsorbed on polystyrene. Studies reported here describe the stoichiometry of the system and the influence of biotinylation of different carrier proteins and CAbs on the reaction stoichiometry and the AgCC of CAbs. Because of the widespread use of sandwich ELISAs to measure the concn of multivalent protein antigens, the AgCCs of monoclonal and polyclonal CAbs to pig IgG in the PABC system were compared with the AgCCs of these Abs immobilized on the plastic by direct adsorption. Optimal assay conditions for the carrier were obtained when 1 microgram/ml of the biotinylated protein was added to the polystyrene solid phase. An increasing degree of biotin substitution in three carrier proteins was paralleled by an increasing AgCC until a constant maximum was reached. Under conditions of maximal AgCC, 120 ng of the carrier rabbit gamma globulin (RGG; i.e. RGG25biot) was bound to polystyrene, which in turn yielded the maximum amount (i.e. 100 ng) of bound streptavidin (SA; Bdngmax) when 20 micrograms/ml of SA was added. Under conditions giving the Bdngmax for SA, CAb12biot yielded a higher Bdngmax than did CAb25biot or CAb2biot. When the AgCC of equal amounts of differentially biotinylated CAbs were compared, the following order of AgCC was observed: CAb12biot greater than CAb12biot greater than CAb25biot. Hence, while the maximal amount of CAb is immobilized on SA when CAb12biot is used, optimal AgCC is achieved with CAb2biot. The carrier:SA:CAb2biot ratio was 1:2:1 while that for carrier:SA:CAb12biot was 1:2:2. The same ratio was obtained using IgG2biot from four different species. Monoclonal antibodies to swine IgG showed a 5-6-fold increase in Bd%max when immobilized as CAbs using the PABC system versus when adsorbed on polystyrene. Plots of these data suggest that the differences result from a loss of functional affinity. On the contrary, no significant differences in Bd%max and hence functional affinity were observed when a polyclonal antibody to pig IgG was compared using the two assay configurations. Furthermore, when the globulin fraction of the anti-pig polyclonal was adsorbed on plastic, it behaved nearly as well as its affinity-purified counterpart immobilized by the PABC system. The PABC system appears to offer significant advantages for sandwich ELISAs utilizing monoclonal antibodies as the CAb, and may offer some advantages in other s

Isolation and characterization of highly purified streptavidin obtained in a two-step purification procedure from Streptomyces avidinii grown in a synthetic medium

A method is described for isolation of streptavidin from cultures of Streptomyces avidinii grown in a synthetic culture medium for 6-10 days. Streptavidin is precipitated directly from culture supernatant fluid using 80% ammonium sulfate, and the precipitate is dialyzed against water and centrifuged at 40,000 X g for 60 min. The absorbency coefficient at 280 nm of purified streptavidin was estimated to be 31.7142 +/- 0.1806 for a 1% solution. The protein appeared to be greater than 90% homogeneous by gel permeation chromatography and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. No biotin-binding molecules less than 70 kDa in size were detected at any step during the purification of streptavidin. Streptavidin was able to maintain a stable crosslink between two biotinylated molecules in a solid-phase assay. Streptavidin purified by this method was stable in 50% glycerol/water at -20 degrees C for more than 1 year. Lyophilization or iodination did not produce apparent damage to the protein.

A significant proportion of normal resting B cells are induced to secrete immunoglobulin through contact with anti-receptor antibody-activated helper T cells in clonal cultures

This report describes single-cell techniques to address the nature of a cellular interaction in which activated T lymphocytes stimulate small resting B cells to develop into antibody-forming cell clones in the absence of any surface immunoglobulin ligand or an antigen bridge. The cloned T helper cell line E9.D4 was stimulated with the anti-V beta 8 antibody F23.1 bound to the plastic of Terasaki 10-ul culture wells. When an excess of T helper lymphocytes was used (1,000 X-irradiated or 600 unirradiated, stimulated E9.D4 cells), 10-25% of B cells responded by antibody formation as judged by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay performed after 5 days of culture. When one of a very small number of B cells were present, the rate-limiting step to antibody-forming cell formation was the number of T cells present. Far fewer T cells sufficed for stimulation when culture trays were tilted to force T and B cells into proximity at the sulcus formed at the bottom edge of the culture wells. When T cell numbers were limiting, unirradiated T cells out-performed irradiated T cells. Some cell clones held for 7 days switched to IgG antibody production. E9.D4 supernatants were virtually ineffective in causing B cell stimulation, even when 3T3 filler cells were added to support cultures. The results suggest that cell contact, and perhaps conjugate formation, with a strongly activated T cell can cause changes in the adjacent resting B cells akin to those of Ig receptor cross-linking, following which a lymphokine flux (even one not involving IL 4 and 5) promotes antibody-forming cell development.

Analysis of the B lymphocyte repertoire by polyclonal activation. Hindrance by clones yielding antibodies which bind promiscuously to plastic

We here describe a form of 'noise' in the ELISA as commonly performed on antigen-coated microtiter trays that represents a major hindrance to the accurate enumeration of infrequent antibody-forming cell (AFC) precursors (AFCp) specific for epitopes on monomeric proteins. Supernatants from cultures of lipopolysaccharide-stimulated murine splenocytes, when split into aliquots and separately assayed, scored as positive in parallel on ELISA trays coated with unrelated proteins and on uncoated trays. Some properties of such coincident false positives (CFP) noted were: (1) optical density (OD) ranges for CFP and non-CFP overlapped; (2) different members of CFP triplets on differently coated assay trays usually had similar OD values; (3) CFP-generating culture supernatants did not contain unusually high immunoglobulin concentrations; and (4) numbers of CFP-forming supernatants increased with increasing input cells/culture consistent with causation by single AFCp present at an approximate mean frequency of 1 in 6600 CBA splenocytes. It is proposed that CFP are due to AFC clones that secrete antibody reactive with some epitope(s) present in the assay tray itself. Repertoire elements with such 'anti-plastic' characteristics are rarer than anti-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) AFCp, but at least as frequent as anti-bovine serum albumin (BSA) or anti-transferrin (TFN) AFCp.

T-independent activation of single B cells: an orderly analysis of overlapping stages in the activation pathway

This review has three chief purposes. It describes a microculture system in which single, hapten-specific B lymphocytes can be microscopically observed, cultured and assayed for antibody production in isolation and thus are the unequivocal target of ligands present in the culture fluid. It defines the respective roles of antigens and cytokines acting singly or in combination in the four discernible phases of the immunoproliferative cascade, namely activation, clonal expansion, IgM antibody secretion and isotype switching. It then argues that this precise stepwise analysis can yield useful information concerning important immunological situations, such as experimentally induced immunological tolerance or the effects of constitutive expression of the c-myc oncogene. Evidence is presented that initial activation of the resting B cell in "T-independent" triggering can be achieved either by attachment of a molecule that has B-cell stimulatory properties, such as FLU-LPS or FLU-polymerized flagellin (FLU-POL) or by the lymphokine interleukin 4 (IL-4). IL-4 + FLU-POL is somewhat more effective than either agent alone. IL-4 alone or, better, FLU-POL + IL-4 can stimulate clonal proliferation of the B cell, but FLU-POL alone does not achieve this. Moreover, IL-4 or FLU-POL + IL-4 lead to very little antibody formation. None of IL-1, IL-2 or IL-5 acting alone causes either activation or proliferation. IgM antibody formation is stimulated most strongly by FLU-POL + IL-5, somewhat less strongly by FLU-POL + IL-1 + IL-2 and rather weakly with antigen plus only one of the latter cytokines. The cloning efficiency in the single cell system, and the median clone size can be markedly enhanced by the addition of small numbers of fibroblast or other filler cells to the cultures. While filler cell-free clones do not progress to the stage of isotype switching, filler cell-supported ones can do so in up to 30% of cases. The only cloned lymphokine which has so far been found to promote such switching is IL-4, and the fact that it is at least as powerful as a T-cell supernatant may mean that it is the only agent active in this particular system. However, the detailed pattern of secreted isotypes is different from that seen when MHC-restricted, carrier-specific T cells act on hapten-specific B cells. Hapten-specific B cells from animals rendered neonatally tolerant to FLU-HGG exhibit anergy in the single cell system.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Single lipopolysaccharide-reactive B cells in the non-immune mouse spleen cell population secrete natural multispecific autoantibodies

Starting from unimmunized BALB/c splenocytes, B-cell clones were obtained by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) stimulation, and the frequencies of their anti-TNP, anti-BALB/c actin, and anti-BALB/c tubulin secretion were determined. The culture conditions were then chosen so as to have one anti-TNP precursor per positive well. Out of the 41 wells containing one anti-TNP antibody-secreting cell, nine (22%) also reacted either with actin or with tubulin and five (12%) with both actin and tubulin. Using horse red blood cells to which trinitrophenyl (TNP) had been coupled, spleen cell rosettes were prepared, enriched, micromanipulated, and cultured individually. Of the 500 micromanipulated and cultured TNP antigen-binding cells, 28 were found to secrete antibodies directed against TNP. Eight of these 28 clones (28%) also reacted with either actin or tubulin, and five (17%) reacted with both actin and tubulin. The frequency of these multispecific clones is of the same order of magnitude as that obtained with the limiting dilution experiments. The results show that unimmunized BALB/c mouse spleen contains precursor cells that secrete natural multispecific autoantibodies.

The use of biotinylated monoclonal antibodies and streptavidin affinity chromatography to isolate herpesvirus hydrophobic proteins or glycoproteins

A streptavidin/biotin-based immunoaffinity system was optimized to isolate herpesvirus (human cytomegalovirus) immediate early proteins or late glycoproteins from crude infected cell lysates. Biotinylation of the primary antibody by biotin substitution of epsilon amino groups was superior to biotin substitution of sugar residues. Biotinylation of the primary antibody was superior to that of a secondary antibody. A biotin substitution of approximately 8 M biotin/M antibody allowed for maximal recovery of viral antigens. The streptavidin/biotin-based immunoaffinity system can allow for relatively pure preparations of viral antigens that may be used for functional, immunological, or structural studies.

Clonal analysis of the anti-DNA repertoire of murine B lymphocytes

The present studies characterize at the clonal level the repertoire of lipopolysaccharide-responsive murine B lymphocytes committed to the production of antibodies reactive with denatured DNA. This repertoire is vast in normal mice as 1-5% of total mitogen-induced antibody-forming cell clones secreted denatured DNA-reactive antibodies when the splenocyte donors were CBA (Ighj), BALB/c (Igha), C57BL/6 (Ighb), CBA nu/nu, and C57BL/6 nu/nu athymic mice. The autoimmune NZB (Ighe) strain did not display elevated proportions of anti-denatured DNA antibody-forming cell precursors. Cross-reactions shown by CBA anti-denatured DNA antibodies suggest that many antibodies might derive significant binding energy from interaction with the bases or similar hydrophobic moieties. Cross-reactions with other tested polynucleotides were frequent, but cross-reactions with phospholipids and phosphocholine were undetectable. Most anti-DNA antibodies bound preferentially or exclusively to single-stranded denatured DNA as compared to double-stranded native DNA. The frequency of anti-denatured DNA antibody-forming cell precursors among CBA peritoneal cells was not elevated. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter-selected Ly-1-positive NZB splenic B cells were not enriched, and Ly-1 negative B cells were not depleted of anti-DNA antibody-forming cell precursors. These results show that antibody-forming cell precursors specific for denatured DNA are not restricted to the Ly-1 positive B-cell subset.

Bone marrow pre-B cells and the clonal anergy theory of immunologic tolerance

This review begins with a summary of a decade's research from the author's own laboratory which documents the fact that B lymphocytes can receive and store negative, down-regulatory signals from an encounter with antigen, and that the sensitivity to such negative signalling depends critically on maturational status, the most immature B cells being the most susceptible. The review then examines the relationship between these experimentally-induced models of immunologic tolerance, with the pre-B to B cell transition as the critical stage for examination, and the real-life phenomenon of self-tolerance. It makes the point that no repertoire-purging mechanism to ensure self-tolerance can afford to be too effective, for fear of purging too many useful cells, given the number and variability of self-antigens. The review then examines certain dilemmas posed by recent findings in cellular and molecular immunology. These include: 1) the preferential use of particular VH gene families by B cells at different stages of the differentiation process; 2) the apparent frequency of B lymphocytes with the potential for antiself-reactivity in the B cell repertoire; and 3) the existence of a new type of B cell, the Ly-1-positive B cell, with peculiar characteristics. These findings are considered within the particular contexts of pre-B-to-B cell transition and tolerance induction through clonal anergy mechanisms.

Single cell studies on the role of B-cell stimulatory factor 1 in B-cell activation

The role of the T-cell-derived lymphokine B-cell stimulatory factor 1 (BSF-1) in the early activation, proliferation, and antibody-forming cell (AFC) clone formation of single fluorescein-specific B lymphocytes isolated from normal mouse spleens by hapten-gelatin adherence has been studied in vitro. BSF-1 acting alone induced early B-cell activation, as assessed by a significant increase in cell diameter of single B cells cultured for 24 hr. A small but significant number of these B cells formed proliferating clones, some of which secreted antibody. When acting with the specific antigen fluorescein-polymerized flagellin, BSF-1 augmented early cell enlargement and markedly enhanced proliferation, but it did not increase the frequency of AFC clones stimulated by fluorescein-polymerized flagellin alone. The further addition of recombinant murine interleukin 1 (IL-1) marginally enhanced proliferation caused by antigen plus BSF-1. No synergy was observed between BSF-1 and IL-1 for antibody formation. In the presence of fibroblast filler cells, BSF-1 substantially inhibited AFC clone development achieved by antigen plus IL-1. BSF-1 was also found to be inhibitory to AFC clone development stimulated by specific antigen acting with either recombinant human interleukin 2 (IL-2) or with IL-2 plus IL-1, both in the presence or absence of filler cells. The results suggest that BSF-1 plays a complex role in the regulation of the B-cell activation pathway by enhancing early activation and antigen-specific proliferation as well as inhibiting the effects of other B-cell factors on antibody formation. BSF-1 is the only cytokine so far tested in the single B-cell system that acts with antigen to promote proliferation without concomitant antibody production.

The immunochemistry of sandwich ELISAs. II. A novel system prevents the denaturation of capture antibodies

The studies reported here describe a model system by which the effect of surface adsorption on the antigen capture capacity (AgCC) of monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) can be quantitated. Three mouse anti-fluorescein (FLU) MoAbs were biotinylated and iodinated with [125I]Na. The AgCC/ng of these MoAbs was compared when they were adsorbed directly on plastic or immobilized via a Protein Avidin Biotin Capture (PABC) system. In this system, biotinylated MoAbs were allowed to adsorb on biotinylated carrier proteins through a "bridging" process using Streptavidin. This permits MoAbs to complex with antigen at some distance from the plastic surface. The AgCCs of the MoAbs immobilized using the PABC system were 5-400-fold higher than when they were directly adsorbed on plastic.

The immunochemistry of sandwich ELISAs--I. The binding characteristics of immunoglobulins to monoclonal and polyclonal capture antibodies adsorbed on plastic and their detection by symmetrical and asymmetrical antibody-enzyme conjugates

Radiolabelled bovine IgG1, IgG2, SIgA and IgM and heavy-chain specific polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies to these isotypes were employed as models to investigate immunochemical aspects of sandwich enzyme immunoassays (ELISAs). The titration plots obtained by measuring enzyme activity paralleled those obtained when the binding of radiolabelled immunoglobulins to solid-phase capture antibodies was quantitated. As predicted from the Mass Law, the percentage of labelled immunoglobulin which was bound remained constant over the range in which the sandwich ELISA titration was linear on a log-log plot. Also as predicted from the Mass Law, increasing the solid-phase concn of polyclonal antibodies by affinity purification increased the linear region of the log-log ELISA plot and the corresponding region over which a constant percentage of immunoglobulin binding was observed. When used as capture antibodies adsorbed on plastic at equal concns, the best monoclonal antibodies were 1/8- less than 1/16 as effective as their polyclonal counterparts in binding iodinated bovine immunoglobulins; these differences can be directly interpreted to result from an 8 and greater than 16-fold higher functional, relative affinity of the polyclonal reagents. Steric hindrance was shown to occur when symmetrical sandwich ELISAs, i.e. capture and detection antibody are both heavy-chain specific, are used to measure monomeric but not IgM immunoglobulins. The use of an asymmetrical configuration, i.e. anti-Fab antibody-enzyme conjugates, avoids this problem. Symmetrical conjugates based on the avidin-biotin system, horseradish peroxidase or alkaline phosphatase, were less effective than their asymmetrical (anti-Fab) counterparts. Evidence that the lower activity of symmetrical conjugates was due to steric hindrance was illustrated using horseradish peroxidase-antibody conjugates of different sizes. Sandwich assays using affinity-purified, polyclonal solid-phase antibodies and an asymmetrical conjugate were judged to be immunochemically and economically optimal. Using an asymmetrical configuration, the non-linear nature of sandwich ELISA titration plots is the predictable result of changing antibody to antigen ratios in an antibody-limiting system, and not the result of steric hindrance of the detection system.