Division septation in the absence of chromosome termination in Bacillus subtilis

Cell size control in bacteria

Like eukaryotes, bacteria must coordinate division with growth to ensure cells are the appropriate size for a given environmental condition or developmental fate. As single-celled organisms, nutrient availability is one of the strongest influences on bacterial cell size. Classic physiological experiments conducted over four decades ago first demonstrated that cell size is directly correlated with nutrient source and growth rate in the Gram-negative bacterium Salmonella typhimurium. This observation subsequently served as the basis for studies revealing a role for cell size in cell cycle progression in a closely related organism, Escherichia coli. More recently, the development of powerful genetic, molecular, and imaging tools has allowed us to identify and characterize the nutrient-dependent pathway responsible for coordinating cell division and cell size with growth rate in the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis. Here, we discuss the role of cell size in bacterial growth and development and propose a broadly applicable model for cell size control in this important and highly divergent domain of life.

The Bacillus subtilis SftA (YtpS) and SpoIIIE DNA translocases play distinct roles in growing cells to ensure faithful chromosome partitioning

In several bacterial species, the faithful completion of chromosome partitioning is known to be promoted by a conserved family of DNA translocases that includes Escherichia coli FtsK and Bacillus subtilis SpoIIIE. FtsK localizes at nascent division sites during every cell cycle and stimulates chromosome decatenation and the resolution of chromosome dimers formed by recA-dependent homologous recombination. In contrast, SpoIIIE localizes at sites where cells have divided and trapped chromosomal DNA in the membrane, which happens during spore development and under some conditions when DNA replication is perturbed. SpoIIIE completes chromosome segregation post-septationally by translocating trapped DNA across the membrane. Unlike E. coli, B. subtilis contains a second uncharacterized FtsK/SpoIIIE-like protein, SftA (formerly YtpS). We report that SftA plays a role similar to FtsK during each cell cycle but cannot substitute for SpoIIIE in rescuing trapped chromosomes. SftA colocalizes with FtsZ at nascent division sites but not with SpoIIIE at sites of chromosome trapping. SftA mutants divide over unsegregated chromosomes more frequently than wild-type unless recA is inactivated, suggesting that SftA, like FtsK, stimulates chromosome dimer resolution. Having two FtsK/SpoIIIE paralogues is not conserved among endospore-forming bacteria, but is highly conserved within several groups of soil- and plant-associated bacteria.

Noc protein binds to specific DNA sequences to coordinate cell division with chromosome segregation

Coordination of chromosome segregation and cytokinesis is crucial for efficient cell proliferation. In Bacillus subtilis, the nucleoid occlusion protein Noc protects the chromosomes by associating with the chromosome and preventing cell division in its vicinity. Using protein localization, ChAP-on-Chip and bioinformatics, we have identified a consensus Noc-binding DNA sequence (NBS), and have shown that Noc is targeted to about 70 discrete regions scattered around the chromosome, though absent from a large region around the replication terminus. Purified Noc bound specifically to an NBS in vitro. NBSs inserted near the replication terminus bound Noc-YFP and caused a delay in cell division. An autonomous plasmid carrying an NBS array recruited Noc-YFP and conferred a severe Noc-dependent inhibition of cell division. This shows that Noc is a potent inhibitor of division, but that its activity is strictly localized by the interaction with NBS sites in vivo. We propose that Noc serves not only as a spatial regulator of cell division to protect the nucleoid, but also as a timing device with an important role in the coordination of chromosome segregation and cell division.

The great divide: coordinating cell cycle events during bacterial growth and division

The relationship between events during the bacterial cell cycle has been the subject of frequent debate. While early models proposed a relatively rigid view in which DNA replication was inextricably coupled to attainment of a specific cell mass, and cell division was triggered by the completion of chromosome replication, more recent data suggest these models were oversimplified. Instead, an intricate set of intersecting, and at times opposing, forces coordinate DNA replication, cell division, and cell growth with one another, thereby ensuring the precise spatial and temporal control of cell cycle events.

Cell division in Bacillus subtilis: FtsZ and FtsA association is Z-ring independent, and FtsA is required for efficient midcell Z-Ring assembly

The earliest stage in cell division in bacteria is the assembly of a Z ring at the division site at midcell. Other division proteins are also recruited to this site to orchestrate the septation process. FtsA is a cytosolic division protein that interacts directly with FtsZ. Its function remains unknown. It is generally believed that FtsA localization to the division site occurs immediately after Z-ring formation or concomitantly with it and that FtsA is responsible for recruiting the later-assembling membrane-bound division proteins to the division site. Here, we report the development of an in vivo chemical cross-linking assay to examine the association between FtsZ and FtsA in Bacillus subtilis cells. We subsequently use this assay in a synchronous cell cycle to show that these two proteins can interact prior to Z-ring formation. We further show that in a B. subtilis strain containing an ftsA deletion, FtsZ localized at regular intervals along the filament but the majority of Z rings were abnormal. FtsA in this organism is therefore critical for the efficient formation of functional Z rings. This is the first report of abnormal Z-ring formation resulting from the loss of a single septation protein. These results suggest that in this organism, and perhaps others, FtsA ensures recruitment of the membrane-bound division proteins by ensuring correct formation of the Z ring.

The midcell replication factory in Bacillus subtilis is highly mobile: implications for coordinating chromosome replication with other cell cycle events

During vegetative growth, rod-shaped bacterial cells such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis divide precisely at midcell. It is the Z ring that defines the position of the division site. We previously demonstrated that the early stages of chromosome replication are linked to midcell Z ring assembly in B. subtilis and proposed a direct role for the centrally located replication factory in masking and subsequently unmasking the midcell site for Z ring assembly. We now show that the replication factory is significantly more scattered about the cell centre than the Z ring in both vegetative cells and outgrown spores of B. subtilis. This finding is inconsistent with the midcell replication factory acting as a direct physical block to Z ring assembly. Time-lapse experiments demonstrated that the lower precision of replication factory positioning results from its high mobility around the cell centre. Various aspects of this mobility are presented and the results are discussed in the light of current views on the determinants of positional information required for accurate chromosome segregation and cell division.

The Min system is not required for precise placement of the midcell Z ring in Bacillus subtilis

In bacteria, the Min system plays a role in positioning the midcell division site by inhibiting the formation of the earliest precursor of cell division, the Z ring, at the cell poles. However, whether the Min system also contributes to establishing the precise placement of the midcell Z ring is unresolved. We show that the Z ring is positioned at midcell with a high degree of precision in Bacillus subtilis, and this is completely maintained in the absence of the Min system. Min is therefore not required for correct midcell Z ring placement in B. subtilis. Our results strongly support the idea that the primary role of the Min system is to block Z ring formation at the cell poles and that a separate mechanism must exist to ensure cell division occurs precisely at midcell.

Transcription of essential cell division genes is linked to chromosome replication in Escherichia coli

Cell division normally follows the completion of each round of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli. Transcription of the essential cell division genes clustered at the mra region is shown here to depend on continuing chromosomal DNA replication. After chromosome replication was blocked by either nalidixic acid treatment or thymine starvation, the transcription of these cell division genes was repressed significantly. This suggests a way in which cell division is controlled by chromosome replication.

Mid-cell Z ring assembly in the absence of entry into the elongation phase of the round of replication in bacteria: co-ordinating chromosome replication with cell division

We have shown previously that, when spores of a thymine-requiring strain of Bacillus subtilis were grown out in the absence of thymine, mid-cell Z rings formed over the nucleoid and much earlier than might be expected with respect to progression into the round of replication. It is now shown that such conditions allow no replication of oriC. Rather than replication, partial degradation of the oriC region occurs, suggesting that the status of this region is connected with the 'premature' mid-cell Z ring assembly. A correlation was observed between entry into the replication elongation phase and a block to mid-cell Z rings. The conformation of the nucleoid under various conditions of DNA replication inhibition or limitation suggests that relief of nucleoid occlusion is not primarily responsible for mid-cell Z ring formation in the absence of thymine. We propose the existence of a specific structure at mid-cell that defines the Z ring nucleation site (NS). It is suggested that this NS is normally masked by the replisome upon initiation of replication or soon after entry into the elongation phase, and subsequently unmasked relatively late in the round. During spore outgrowth in the absence of thymine, this checkpoint control over mid-cell Z ring assembly breaks down prematurely.

Co-ordinating DNA replication with cell division in bacteria: a link between the early stages of a round of replication and mid-cell Z ring assembly

Spores of a thymine-requiring strain of Bacillus subtilis 168, which is also temperature sensitive for the initiation of chromosome replication, were germinated and allowed to grow out at the permissive temperature in a minimal medium containing no added thymine. Under these conditions, there was no or very limited progression into the elongation phase of the first round of replication. In a significant proportion of the outgrown cells, a Z ring formed precisely at mid-cell and over the centrally positioned nucleoid, leading eventually to the formation of a mature division septum. When initiation of the first round of replication was blocked through a temperature shift and with thymine present, the Z ring was positioned acentrally. The central Z ring that formed in the absence of thymine was blocked by the presence of a DNA polymerase III inhibitor. It is concluded that the very early stages of a round of replication (initiation plus possibly limited progression into the elongation phase) play a key role in the precise positioning of the Z ring at mid-cell and between replicating daughter chromosomes.

Polar localization of the MinD protein of Bacillus subtilis and its role in selection of the mid-cell division site

Cell division in rod-shaped bacteria is initiated by formation of a ring of the tubulin-like protein FtsZ at mid-cell. Division site selection is controlled by a conserved division inhibitor MinCD, which prevents aberrant division at the cell poles. The Bacillus subtilis DivIVA protein controls the topological specificity of MinCD action. Here we show that DivIVA is targeted to division sites late in their assembly, after some MinCD-sensitive step requiring FtsZ and other division proteins has been passed. DivIVA then recruits MinD to the division sites preventing another division from taking place near the newly formed cell poles. Sequestration of MinD to the poles also releases the next mid-cell sites for division. Remarkably, this mechanism of DivIVA action is completely different from that of the equivalent protein MinE of Escherichia coli, even though both systems operate via the same division inhibitor MinCD.

Bacillus subtilis cell cycle as studied by fluorescence microscopy: constancy of cell length at initiation of DNA replication and evidence for active nucleoid partitioning

Fluorescence microscopic methods have been used to characterize the cell cycle of Bacillus subtilis at four different growth rates. The data obtained have been used to derive models for cell cycle progression. Like that of Escherichia coli, the period required by B. subtilis for chromosome replication at 37 degrees C was found to be fairly constant (although a little longer, at about 55 min), as was the cell mass at initiation of DNA replication. The cell cycle of B. subtilis differed from that of E. coli in that changes in growth rate affected the average cell length but not the width and also in the relative variability of period between termination of DNA replication and septation. Overall movement of the nucleoid was found to occur smoothly, as in E. coli, but other aspects of nucleoid behavior were consistent with an underlying active partitioning machinery. The models for cell cycle progression in B. subtilis should facilitate the interpretation of data obtained from the recently introduced cytological methods for imaging the assembly and movement of proteins involved in cell cycle dynamics.

Dynamic, mitotic-like behavior of a bacterial protein required for accurate chromosome partitioning

The Bacillus subtilis spo0J gene is required for accurate chromosome partitioning during growth and sporulation. We have characterized the subcellular localization of Spo0J protein by immunofluorescence and, in living cells, by use of a spo0J-gfp fusion. We show that the Spo0J protein forms discrete stable foci usually located close to the cell poles. The foci replicate in concert with the initiation of new rounds of DNA replication, after which the daughter foci migrate apart inside the cell. This migration is independent of cell length extension, and presumably serves to direct the daughter chromosomes toward opposite poles of the cell, ready for division. During sporulation, the foci move to the extreme poles of the cell, where they function to position the oriC region of the chromosome ready for polar septation. These observations provide strong evidence for the existence of a dynamic, mitotic-like apparatus responsible for chromosome partitioning in bacteria.

Replication fork arrest at relocated replication terminators on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome

The replication terminus region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, comprising TerI and TerII plus the rtp gene (referred to as the terC region) was relocated to serC (257 degrees) and cym (10 degrees) on the anticlockwise- and clockwise-replicating segments of the chromosome, respectively. In both cases, it was found that only the orientation of the terC region that placed TerI in opposition to the approaching replication fork was functional in fork arrest. When TerII was opposed to the approaching fork, it was nonfunctional. These findings confirm and extend earlier work which involved relocations to only the clockwise-replicating segment, at metD (100 degrees) and pyr (139 degrees). In the present work, it was further shown that in the strain in which TerII was opposed to an approaching fork at metD, overproduction of the replication terminator protein (RTP) enabled TerII to function as an arrest site. Thus, chromosomal TerII is nonfunctional in arrest in vivo because of a limiting level of RTP. Marker frequency analysis showed that TerI at both cym and metD caused only transient arrest of a replication fork. Arrest appeared to be more severe in the latter situation and caused the two forks to meet at approximately 145 degrees (just outside or on the edge of the replication fork trap). The minimum pause time erected by TerI at metD was calculated to be approximately 40% of the time taken to complete a round of replication. This significant pause at metD caused the cells to become elongated, indicating that cell division was delayed. Further work is needed to establish the immediate cause of the delay in division.

Replication through the terminus region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome is not essential for the formation of a division septum that partitions the DNA

Germinated and outgrowing spores of a temperature-sensitive DNA initiation mutant of Bacillus subtilis were allowed to initiate a single round of replication by being shifted from 34 to 47 degrees C at the appropriate time. The DNA replication inhibitor 6-(parahydroxyphenylazo)-uracil was added to separate portions of the culture at various times during the round. Samples were collected from each around the time of the first division septation for measurements of the extent of the round completed, the level of division septation, the position of the septum within the outgrown cell, and the distribution of DNA (nucleoid) in relation to the septum. The extent of replication was measured directly through a hybridization approach. The results show clearly that a central division septum can close down onto a chromosome that is only partially replicated (to a minimum extent of about 60% of the round) such that DNA appears on both sides of the septum and frequently very close to it. It is concluded, as claimed previously on the basis of a less direct approach (T. McGinness and R.G. Wake, J. Mol. Biol. 134:251-264, 1979), that replication through the terminus region of the chromosome is not essential for the formation of a division septum that partitions the DNA.

Postseptational chromosome partitioning in bacteria

Mutations in the spoIIIE gene prevent proper partitioning of one chromosome into the developing prespore during sporulation but have no overt effect on partitioning in vegetatively dividing cells. However, the expression of spoIIIE in vegetative cells and the occurrence of genes closely related to spoIIIE in a range of nonsporulating eubacteria suggested a more general function for the protein. Here we show that SpoIIIE protein is needed for optimal chromosome partitioning in vegetative cells of Bacillus subtilis when the normal tight coordination between septation and nucleoid partitioning is perturbed or when septum positioning is altered. A functional SpoIIIE protein allows cells to recover from a state in which their chromosome has been trapped by a closing septum. By analogy to its function during sporulation, we suggest that SpoIIIE facilitates partitioning by actively translocating the chromosome out of the septum. In addition to enhancing the fidelity of nucleoid partitioning, SpoIIIE also seems to be required for maximal resistance to antibiotics that interfere with DNA metabolism. The results have important implications for our understanding of the functions of genes involved in the primary partitioning machinery in bacteria and of how septum placement is controlled.

Characterization of cell cycle events during the onset of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

To elucidate the process of asymmetric division during sporulation of Bacillus subtilis, we have measured changes in cell cycle parameters during the transition from vegetative growth to sporulation. Because the propensity of B. subtilis to grow in chains of cells precludes the use of automated cell-scanning devices, we have developed a fluorescence microscopic method for analyzing cell cycle parameters in individual cells. From the results obtained, and measurements of DNA replication fork elongation rates and the escape time of sporulation from the inhibition of DNA replication, we have derived a detailed time scale for the early morphological events of sporulation which is mainly consistent with the cell cycle changes expected following nutritional downshift. The previously postulated sensitive stage in the DNA replication cycle, beyond which the cell is unable to sporulate without a new cell cycle, could represent a point in the division cycle at which the starved cell cannot avoid attaining the initiation mass for DNA replication and thus embarking on another round of the cell cycle. The final cell cycle event, formation of the asymmetric spore septum, occurs at about the time in the cell cycle at which the uninduced cell would have divided centrally, in keeping with the view that spore septation is a modified version of vegetative division.

Bacillus subtilis SpoIIIE protein required for DNA segregation during asymmetric cell division

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis begins with an asymmetric cell division, producing a smaller prespore and a larger mother cell, both of which contain intact copies of the chromosome. The spoIIIE gene is required for chromosome segregation into the prespore compartment. The effects of the spoIIIE36 mutation on sigma F-dependent transcription are an indirect consequence of the failure of certain genes to enter the cellular compartment in which their transcription factor has become active. SpoIIIE may also be required to prevent sigma F from becoming active in the mother cell.

Characterization of mutations in divIB of Bacillus subtilis and cellular localization of the DivIB protein

Four temperature-sensitive mutations in the divIB gene of Bacillus subtilis have been localized to the region corresponding to the C-terminal half of the 263-residue DivIB protein. Antiserum was raised to the 80% C-terminal portion lying on one side of a putative transmembrane (hydrophobic) segment, and used to examine aspects of the nature and localization of the DivIB protein in the cell. A single DivIB species of a size equal to the full-length protein encoded by the divIB gene was detected in wild-type cells. Cell fractionation studies established that DivIB is associated preferentially with the cell envelope (membrane plus cell wall), with approximately 50% being released into solution upon treatment of cells with lysozyme under conditions that yield protoplasts. Of the remaining 50%, approximately half remained firmly associated with the membrane fraction. On the basis of the 'positive-inside rule' of von Heijne (1986) it is suggested that the topology of membrane-bound DivIB is such that the long C-terminal portion is directed to the outside and the smaller N-terminal portion to the inside of the cell. DivIB in protoplasts was rapidly degraded by proteinase K under conditions where there was no general proteolysis of the cytoplasmic proteins. This is consistent with its absence from the cytoplasm, and with the predicted membrane topology. Septum positioning in a divIB null mutant, which grows as filaments at temperatures of 30 degrees C and below, was found to be normal. It appears that DivIB is needed for achieving the appropriate rate of initiation of septum formation at normal division sites. It is proposed that the C-terminal portion of DivIB, localized on the exterior surface of the membrane and in juxtaposition to the peptidoglycan, normally interacts with another protein (or proteins) to initiate septum formation.

Normal terC-region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome acts in a polar manner to arrest the clockwise replication fork

A procedure is described for relocating a functional terC-region to various sites on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, and in alternative orientations. The relocated terC-region comprised the IRR-rtp portion of the chromosome contained within a 1.75 x 10(3) base-pair segment of DNA. This segment was first cloned into the Tn 917 vector pTV20 in both orientations, and the two new plasmids used for inserting the terC-region into chromosomal copies of Tn 917. When relocated to the pyr and metD loci (139 degrees and 100 degrees positions on the 360 degrees map) it was found that clockwise replication fork arrest occurred only when the IRR-rtp (or terC-) region was oriented, in relation to the direction of approach of the fork, in the same way as in the wild-type strain. Thus, the complete IRR when located in the chromosome, and apparently made up of opposing terminators which might enable it to function in both orientations, is polar in its action. Of the two inverted repeats present in the IRR, it appears that IRI is functional in the chromosome, but not IRII.

A model for asymmetric septum formation during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Many differentiation processes in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes begin with an asymmetric division, producing 'daughter' cells that differ in size and developmental fate. This is particularly obvious in the well-studied prokaryotic life cycles of Caulobacter and Bacillus. In no system, however, is the mechanism of asymmetric division understood. Here I propose a model for the mechanism of asymmetric division during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. The model explains both the timing and asymmetric localization of spore-septum formation. It also explains the morphological phenotypes of various asporogenous (spo) mutants.

Relocation of the replication terminus, terC, of Bacillus subtilis to a new chromosomal site

The terC-deletion strain of Bacillus subtilis 168, SU153 [Iismaa and Wake, J. Mol. Biol. 195 (1987) 299-310] was used for the re-insertion of a 1.75-kb segment of DNA containing terC at a site approx. 25 kb from its original position. The relocated terC in the new strain, SU160, was oriented normally with respect to the approaching clockwise replication fork, and was positioned such that this fork was the first to reach it. The relocated terC was effective in causing arrest of the clockwise fork, as evidenced by the appearance of a unique DNA species with a characteristic mobility in agarose gel electrophoresis and with a predicted single-strand composition. Thus, the previously cloned 1.75-kb terC-containing segment [Smith et al., Gene 38 (1985) 9-17] has not been altered with respect to TerC function and contains sufficient sequence for this function. The findings reported here provide the opportunity for establishing the minimal and essential sequence features of terC, and for examining its possible polarity of action in causing fork arrest.

A unique DNA intermediate associated with termination of chromosome replication in Bacillus subtilis

A unique DNA structural intermediate associated with termination of replication in Bacillus subtilis has been identified. This was achieved by probing for the Bam HI DNA fragment within which the terminus of the chromosome (terC) resides. The intermediate migrates more slowly than the bulk of digested chromosomal DNA upon electrophoresis. It is more readily detected in DNA from a merodiploid strain in which the clockwise fork should be immobilized at terC for longer than usual, and it is destroyed by S1 nuclease. The intermediate may be a forked or related structure. These findings provide evidence for the existence of a specific, sequence-based termination site that blocks or severely impedes the movement of at least the clockwise fork, which is the first to encounter it.

Timing and other features of the action of the ts1 division initiation gene product of Bacillus subtilis

The ts1 division initiation mutation of Bacillus subtilis 160 was transferred into a thymine-requiring strain of B. subtilis 168. Aspects of the role and timing of the action of the ts1 gene product in relation to septum formation were studied by comparing the behavior of this new strain with that of the isogenic wild type after outgrowth of germinated spores. The ts1 gene product was shown to be required for the asymmetric division which occurs in the absence of chromosome replication, in addition to normal division septation. The time interval between completion of the action of the ts1 gene product and initiation of the first central division septum was estimated to be less than 4 min at 34 degrees C, and it is possible that an active ts1 gene product is required until the commencement of septal growth. Recovery of septa after transfer of outgrown spores (filaments) from the nonpermissive to the permissive temperature was also examined. During recovery, septa formed at sites which were discrete fractional lengths of the filaments, with the first septum located at the most polar of these sites. The data have been interpreted in terms of the formation of potential division sites at the nonpermissive temperature and the preferred utilization, upon recovery, of the most recently formed site. Recovery of septa at the permissive temperature occurred in the absence of DNA synthesis but was blocked completely by inhibitors of RNA and protein synthesis. It is possible that the only protein synthesis required for recovery of septa is that of the ts1 gene product itself.

Bacterial growth and division: genes, structures, forces, and clocks

Images

Conformation and segregation of nucleoids accompanying cell length extension after completion of a single round of DNA replication in germinated and outgrowing Bacillus subtilis spores

When germinating spores of the temperature-sensitive DNA initiation mutant of Bacillus subtilis TsB134 are shifted to the restrictive temperature at a time such that just one or two rounds of replication are accomplished, the completed, nonreplicating nucleoids that form eventually adopt a doublet conformation. This conformation has now been observed after fixation by glutaraldehyde or osmium tetroxide, as well as by Formalin as found previously. The doublet was observed in media of different degrees of richness and under both light and electron microscopes. Electron micrographs of serial sections through the doublet were consistent with its formation by the gradual pulling apart of a single mass of DNA into two lobes. A systematic study was made of the effect of the time of shifting from the permissive to the restrictive temperature and of the restrictive temperature used on the number of nucleoids segregating within the outgrowing rod. It was established that the doublet nucleoid behaved as a single unit in replication control and segregation in both rich and poor media. Measurement of the relative position of the two segregating nucleoids within the outgrowing rod after completion of just one round of replication yielded quantitative information on the segregation and cell length extension processes. Segregation was accompanied by cell length extension at approximately equal rates on both sides of each nucleoid. Furthermore, the data were consistent with an exponential increase in such an extension with time over the early and major portion of the period studied, but it was not possible to rule out other models of length extension.