Cruciform extrusion in plasmids bearing the replicative intermediate configuration of a poxvirus telomere

Mapping vaccinia virus DNA replication origins at nucleotide level by deep sequencing

Poxviruses reproduce in the host cytoplasm and encode most or all of the enzymes and factors needed for expression and synthesis of their double-stranded DNA genomes. Nevertheless, the mode of poxvirus DNA replication and the nature and location of the replication origins remain unknown. A current but unsubstantiated model posits only leading strand synthesis starting at a nick near one covalently closed end of the genome and continuing around the other end to generate a concatemer that is subsequently resolved into unit genomes. The existence of specific origins has been questioned because any plasmid can replicate in cells infected by vaccinia virus (VACV), the prototype poxvirus. We applied directional deep sequencing of short single-stranded DNA fragments enriched for RNA-primed nascent strands isolated from the cytoplasm of VACV-infected cells to pinpoint replication origins. The origins were identified as the switching points of the fragment directions, which correspond to the transition from continuous to discontinuous DNA synthesis. Origins containing a prominent initiation point mapped to a sequence within the hairpin loop at one end of the VACV genome and to the same sequence within the concatemeric junction of replication intermediates. These findings support a model for poxvirus genome replication that involves leading and lagging strand synthesis and is consistent with the requirements for primase and ligase activities as well as earlier electron microscopic and biochemical studies implicating a replication origin at the end of the VACV genome.

Poxvirus DNA replication

Poxviruses are large, enveloped viruses that replicate in the cytoplasm and encode proteins for DNA replication and gene expression. Hairpin ends link the two strands of the linear, double-stranded DNA genome. Viral proteins involved in DNA synthesis include a 117-kDa polymerase, a helicase-primase, a uracil DNA glycosylase, a processivity factor, a single-stranded DNA-binding protein, a protein kinase, and a DNA ligase. A viral FEN1 family protein participates in double-strand break repair. The DNA is replicated as long concatemers that are resolved by a viral Holliday junction endonuclease.

Metal cofactors in the structure and activity of the fowlpox resolvase

Poxvirus DNA replication generates linear concatemers containing many copies of the viral genome with inverted repeat sequences at the junctions between monomers. The inverted repeats refold to generate Holliday junctions, which are cleaved by the virus-encoded resolvase enzyme to form unit-length genomes. Here we report studies of the influence of metal cofactors on the activity and structure of the resolvase of fowlpox virus, which provides a tractable model for in vitro studies. Small-molecule inhibitors of related enzymes bind simultaneously to metal cofactors and nearby surface amino acid residues, so understanding enzyme-cofactor interactions is important for the design of antiviral agents. Analysis of inferred active-site residues (D7, E60, K102, D132, and D135) by mutagenesis and metal rescue experiments specified residues that contribute to binding metal ions and that multiple binding sites are probably involved. Differential electrophoretic analysis was used to map the conformation of the DNA junction when bound by resolvase. For the wild-type complex in the presence of EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid) or Ca(2+), migration was consistent with the DNA arms arranged in near-tetrahedral geometry. However, the D7N active-site mutant resolvase held the arms in a more planar arrangement in EDTA, Ca(2+), or Mg(2+) conditions, implicating metal-dependent contacts at the active site in the larger architecture of the complex. These data show how divalent metals dictate the conformation of FPV resolvase-DNA complexes and subsequent DNA cleavage.

DNA binding and cleavage by the fowlpox virus resolvase

The first steps of poxvirus DNA synthesis yield concatemeric arrays of covalently linked genomes. The virus-encoded Holliday junction resolvase is required to process concatemers into unit-length genomes for packaging. Previous studies of the vaccinia virus resolvase have been problematic due to poor protein solubility. We found that fowlpox virus resolvase was much more tractable. Fowlpox resolvase formed complexes with a variety of branched DNA substrates, but not linear DNA, and had the highest affinity for a Holliday junction substrate, illustrating a previously unappreciated affinity for Holliday junctions over other substrates. The cleavage activity was monitored in fixed time assays, showing that, as with vaccinia resolvase, the fowlpox enzyme could cleave a wide array of branched DNA substrates. Single turnover kinetic analysis revealed the Holliday junction substrate was cleaved 90-fold faster than a splayed duplex substrate containing a single to double strand transition. Multiple turnover kinetic analysis, however, showed that the cleavage step was not limiting for the full reaction cycle. Cleavage by resolvase was also tightly coupled at symmetrical positions across the junction, and coupling required the complete Holliday junction structure. Last, we found that cleavage of an extruded cruciform yielded a product, which after treatment with ligase, had the properties expected for covalently closed DNA hairpin ends, as is seen for poxvirus genome monomers. These findings provide a tractable poxvirus resolvase usable for the development of small molecule inhibitors.

DNA cleavage by the A22R resolvase of vaccinia virus

Vaccinia virus encodes an enzyme, A22R, required during DNA replication for cleaving viral DNA concatamers to yield unit-length viral genomes. The concatamer junctions contain inverted repeat sequences that can be extruded as cruciforms, yielding Holliday junctions. Previous work indicated that A22R can cleave Holliday junctions in vitro. To investigate the mechanism of action of A22R, we have optimized reaction conditions and characterized the sequence specificity of cleavage. We found that addition of 20% dimethylsulfoxide boosted product formation six-fold, resulting in improved sensitivity of cleavage assays. To analyze cleavage specificity, we took advantage of mobile Holliday junctions, in which branch migration allowed sampling of many DNA sequences. We found that A22R weakly favors cleavage at the sequence 5'-(G/C) downward arrow(A/T)-3', and so is much less sequence specific than its Escherichia coli relative, RuvC. Analysis of the reaction products revealed that A22R cleaves to leave a 3' hydroxyl at the cleaved phosphodiester bond.

Quaternary structure and cleavage specificity of a poxvirus holliday junction resolvase

Recently, poxviruses were found to encode a protein with signature motifs present in the RuvC family of Holliday junction (HJ) resolvases, which have a key role in homologous recombination in bacteria. The vaccinia virus homolog A22 specifically cleaved synthetic HJ DNA in vitro and was required for the in vivo resolution of viral DNA concatemers into unit-length genomes with hairpin telomeres. It was of interest to further characterize a poxvirus resolvase in view of the low sequence similarity with RuvC, the absence of virus-encoded RuvA and RuvB to interact with, and the different functions of the viral and bacterial resolvases. Because purified A22 aggregated severely, studies were carried out with maltose-binding protein fused to A22 as well as to RuvC. Using gel filtration, chemical cross-linking, analytical ultracentrifugation, and light scattering, we demonstrated that A22 and RuvC are homodimers in solution. Furthermore, the dimeric form of the resolvase associated with HJ DNA, presumably facilitating the symmetrical cleavage of such structures. Like RuvC, A22 symmetrically cleaved fixed HJ junctions as well as junctions allowing strand mobility. Unlike RuvC and other members of the family, however, the poxvirus enzyme exhibited little cleavage sequence specificity. Structural and enzymatic similarities of poxvirus, bacterial, and fungal mitochondrial HJ resolvases are consistent with their predicted evolutionary relationship based on sequence analysis. The absence of a homologous resolvase in mammalian cells makes these microbial enzymes excellent potential therapeutic targets.

Extrusion of an imperfect palindrome to a cruciform in superhelical DNA: complete determination of energetics using a statistical mechanical model

We present a detailed study of the extrusion of an imperfect palindrome, derived from the terminal regions of vaccinia virus DNA and contained in a superhelical plasmid, into a cruciform containing bulged bases. We monitor the course of extrusion by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis experiments as a function of temperature and linking number. We find that extrusion pauses at partially extruded states as negative superhelicity increases. To understand the course of extrusion with changes in linking number, DeltaLk, we present a rigorous semiempirical statistical mechanical analysis that includes complete coupling between DeltaLk, cruciform extrusion, formation of extrahelical bases, and temperature-dependent denaturation. The imperfections in the palindrome are sequentially incorporated into the cruciform arms as hairpin loops, single unpaired bases, and complex local regions containing several unpaired bases. We analyze the results to determine the free energies, enthalpies and entropies of formation of all local structures involved in extrusion. We find that, for each unpaired structure, the DeltaG, DeltaH and DeltaS of formation are all approximately proportional to the number of unpaired bases contained therein. This surprising result holds regardless of the arrangement or composition of unpaired bases within a particular structure. Imperfections have major effects on the overall energetics of cruciform extrusion and on the course of this transition. In particular, the extent of the DeltaLk change necessary to extrude an imperfect palindrome is considerably greater than that required for extrusion of the underlying perfect palindrome. Our analysis also suggests that, at higher temperatures, significant denaturation at the base of an imperfect cruciform can successfully compete with extension of the cruciform arms.

Repression of vaccinia virus Holliday junction resolvase inhibits processing of viral DNA into unit-length genomes

The vaccinia virus A22R gene encodes a protein that is homologous to the bacterial enzyme RuvC and specifically cleaves and resolves four-way DNA Holliday junctions into linear duplex products. To investigate the role of the vaccinia virus Holliday junction resolvase during an infection, we constructed two recombinant viruses: vA22-HA, which has a short C-terminal epitope tag appended to the A22R open reading frame, and vA22i, in which the original A22R gene is deleted and replaced by an inducible copy. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blot analysis of extracts and purified virions from cells infected with vA22-HA revealed that the resolvase was expressed after the onset of DNA replication and incorporated into virion cores. vA22i exhibited a conditional replication defect. In the absence of an inducer, (i) viral protein synthesis was unaffected, (ii) late-stage viral DNA replication was reduced, (iii) most of the newly synthesized viral DNA remained in a branched or concatemeric form that caused it to be trapped at the application site during pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, (iv) cleavage of concatemer junctions was inhibited, and (v) virion morphogenesis was arrested at an immature stage. These data indicated multiple roles for the vaccinia virus Holliday junction resolvase in the replication and processing of viral DNA into unit-length genomes.

The junction-resolving enzymes

Junction-resolving enzymes are ubiquitous nucleases that are important for DNA repair and recombination and act on DNA molecules containing branch points, especially four-way junctions. They show a pronounced selectivity for the structure of the DNA substrate but, despite its importance, the structural selectivity is not well understood. This poses an intriguing challenge in molecular recognition on a relatively large scale.

The X philes: structure-specific endonucleases that resolve Holliday junctions

Genetic recombination is a critical cellular process that promotes evolutionary diversity, facilitates DNA repair and underpins genome duplication. It entails the reciprocal exchange of single strands between homologous DNA duplexes to form a four-way branched intermediate commonly referred to as the Holliday junction. DNA molecules interlinked in this way have to be separated in order to allow normal chromosome transmission at cell division. This resolution reaction is mediated by structure-specific endonucleases that catalyse dual-strand incision across the point of strand cross-over. Holliday junctions can also arise at stalled replication forks by reversing the direction of fork progression and annealing of nascent strands. Resolution of junctions in this instance generates a DNA break and thus serves to initiate rather than terminate recombination. Junction resolvases are generally small, homodimeric endonucleases with a high specificity for branched DNA. They use a metal-binding pocket to co-ordinate an activated water molecule for phosphodiester bond hydrolysis. In addition, most junction endonucleases modulate the structure of the junction upon binding, and some display a preference for cleavage at specific nucleotide target sequences. Holliday junction resolvases with distinct properties have been characterized from bacteriophages (T4 endo VII, T7 endo I, RusA and Rap), Bacteria (RuvC), Archaea (Hjc and Hje), yeast (CCE1) and poxviruses (A22R). Recent studies have brought about a reappraisal of the origins of junction-specific endonucleases with the discovery that RuvC, CCE1 and A22R share a common catalytic core.

Stability of DNA repeats in Escherichia coli dam mutant strains indicates a Dam methylation-dependent DNA deletion process

In this study we report on the stabilization of short direct repetitive DNA elements. We arranged a 20 bp SK-primer element in a direct repeat manner within the cloning vector pBluescript KS (+). This resulted in an array of 27 direct repeats consisting of 24 bp units. We show that this plasmid could only be propagated without deletion of repeats in dam mutant Escherichia coli hosts, whereas all efforts to use strains that were defective in the methylation-dependent restriction system and the recA- or the mismatch repair-dependent deletion system failed. The deletions always affected whole repeat units and not parts of them, leading to an unpredictable reduction of the unit number down to a range of between 12 and two during propagation. We conclude that a Dam methylation-dependent, but recA- and mismatch repair-independent, deletion mechanism caused the DNA rearrangements without an obvious involvement of the known methylated-DNA restriction systems.

Bacterial-type DNA holliday junction resolvases in eukaryotic viruses

Homologous DNA recombination promotes genetic diversity and the maintenance of genome integrity, yet no enzymes with specificity for the Holliday junction (HJ)-a key DNA recombination intermediate-have been purified and characterized from metazoa or their viruses. Here we identify critical structural elements of RuvC, a bacterial HJ resolvase, in uncharacterized open reading frames from poxviruses and an iridovirus. The putative vaccinia virus resolvase was expressed as a recombinant protein, affinity purified, and shown to specifically bind and cleave a synthetic HJ to yield nicked duplex molecules. Mutation of either of two conserved acidic amino acids abrogated the catalytic activity of the A22R protein without affecting HJ binding. The presence of bacterial-type enzymes in metazoan viruses raises evolutionary questions.

Shope fibroma virus DNA topoisomerase catalyses holliday junction resolution and hairpin formation in vitro

The telomeres of poxviral chromosomes comprise covalently closed hairpin structures bearing mismatched bases. These hairpins are formed as concatemeric replication intermediates and are processed into mature, unit-length genomes. The structural transitions and enzymes involved in telomere resolution are poorly understood. Here we show that the type I topoisomerase of Shope fibroma virus (SFV) can promote a recombination reaction which converts cloned SFV replication intermediates into hairpin-ended molecules resembling mature poxviral telomeres. Recombinant SFV topoisomerase linearised a palindromic plasmid bearing 1.5 kb of DNA encoding the SFV concatemer junction, at a site near the centre of inverted-repeat symmetry. Most of these linear reaction products bore hairpin tips as judged by denaturing gel electrophoresis. The resolution reaction required palindromic SFV DNA sequences and was inhibited by compounds which block branch migration (MgCl2) or poxviral topoisomerases. The resolution reaction was also slow, needed substantial quantities of topoisomerase, and required that the palindrome be extruded in a cruciform configuration. DNA cleavage experiments identified a pair of suitably oriented topoisomerase recognition sites, 90 bases from the centre of the cloned SFV terminal inverted repeat, which may mark the resolution site. These data suggest a resolution scheme in which branch migration of a Holliday junction through a site occupied by covalently bound topoisomerase molecules, could lead to telomere resolution.

In vitro resolution of poxvirus replicative intermediates into linear minichromosomes with hairpin termini by a virally induced Holliday junction endonuclease

Available evidence suggests that one or more late viral gene products are involved in processing poxvirus replicative intermediates into mature progeny hairpin-terminated genomes. Cloned versions of the Shope fibroma virus (SFV) replicated telomere in the inverted repeat configuration were used as substrates to assay lysates from poxvirus-infected cells for protein fractions that participate in the resolution of the circular substrate plasmid into a linear minichromosome with viral hairpin termini. An activity in a crude protein fraction obtained from vaccinia virus-infected cells at late times during the replicative cycle was capable of accurately resolving all poxviral inverted repeat replicative intermediates tested. The resolved linear products are identical to the products of in vivo resolution and possessed symmetrical nicks which mapped at the borders of the inverted repeat sequence. Strand-specific nicks were also identified, which mapped within the telomere resolution target sequence known to be required for telomere resolution in vivo. The resolving activity that we have identified is specific to virus-infected cells at late times during replication and cleaves cloned poxviral telomeric substrates in a fashion expected of a classic Holliday junction-resolving enzyme in addition to possessing a telomere resolution target-specific nicking activity. Although a Holliday junction-resolving activity would also be expected to play a role in the recombination induced by poxvirus infection, the appearance of the activity described here only after the commencement of viral late protein synthesis suggests that it functions strictly at late times. Other non-viral Holliday junction analogs can also be cleaved by this extract, suggesting that this component of the resolution activity may also play a role in other viral processes that require cleavage of a branched DNA structure. Thus, we have identified a poxviral activity that may be a part of a protein complex which resolves concatemeric replicative intermediates of viral DNA as well as participate in general recombination late during infection.

In vivo resolution of circular plasmids containing concatemer junction fragments from minute virus of mice DNA and their subsequent replication as linear molecules

During replication of their linear, single-stranded DNA genomes, parvoviruses generate a series of concatemeric duplex intermediates. We have cloned, into Escherichia coli plasmids, junction fragments from these palindromic concatemers of minute virus of mice DNA spanning both the right end-to-right end (viral 5' to 5') and left end-to-left end (viral 3' to 3') fusions. When mouse cells were transfected with these circular plasmids and superinfected with minute virus of mice, the viral junctions were resolved and the plasmids replicated as linear chromosomes with vector DNA in their centers and viral DNA at their termini. Resolution did not occur when the concatemer joint was replaced by a different palindromic sequence or when the transfected cells were not superinfected, indicating the presence of latent origins of replication which could only be activated by a viral trans-acting factor(s). Moreover, the products of resolution and replication from the two termini were characteristically different. Analysis of individual terminal fragments showed that viral 5' (right-end) sequences were resolved predominantly into "extended" structures with covalently associated copies of the virally encoded NS-1 polypeptide, while bridges derived from the 3' (left) end resolved into both NS-1-associated extended termini and lower-molecular-weight "turn-around" forms in which the two DNA strands were covalently continuous. This pattern of resolution exactly coincides with that seen at the two termini of replicative-form intermediates in normal virus infections. These results demonstrate that the bridge structures are authentic substrates for resolution and indicate that the frequency with which extended versus turn-around forms of each terminus are generated is an intrinsic property of the telomere.

Transcription of the terminal loop region of vaccinia virus DNA is initiated from the telomere sequences directing DNA resolution

The telomeres of vaccinia virus DNA are transcribed at late times after infection. Analysis of cDNAs of RNA transcripts of the terminal loop region of the viral DNA shows that both inverted and complementary forms of the terminal loop region are transcribed. These late RNAs, which contain 5' poly(A) sequences, do not appear to encode any proteins. The transcriptional start sites for most of these RNAs are within the sequences that direct the resolution of concatemeric DNA replication intermediates (M. Merchlinsky and B. Moss, 1989, J. Virol. 63, 4354-4361). This suggests that the process of DNA resolution may involve transcription initiated from the telomere sequences required for resolution.

T7 endonuclease I resolves Holliday junctions formed in vitro by RecA protein

T7 endonuclease I is known to bind and cleave four-way junctions in DNA. Since these junctions serve as analogues of Holliday junctions that arise during genetic recombination, we have investigated the action of T7 endonuclease I on recombination intermediates containing Holliday junctions. We find that addition of T7 endonuclease I to strand exchange reactions catalysed by RecA protein of Escherichia coli leads to the formation of duplex products that correspond to 'patch' and 'splice' type recombinants. Resolution of the recombination intermediates occurs by the introduction of nicks at the site of the Holliday junction. The recombinant molecules contain 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl termini which may be ligated to restore the integrity of the DNA.

Resolution of poxvirus telomeres: processing of vaccinia virus concatemer junctions by conservative strand exchange

The replication of vaccinia virus proceeds through concatemeric intermediates which are resolved into unit-length DNA. In vaccinia virus-infected cells, plasmids containing the vaccinia virus DNA junction fragment that connects concatemers are resolved into linear minichromosomes of vector DNA flanked by hairpin loops. Resolution requires two copies of a specific nucleotide sequence conserved among poxviruses and found proximal to the hairpin loop. This study demonstrates that orientation of each sequence with respect to the other as well as to the axis of symmetry is critical for resolution, the processing of plasmids containing heterologous pairs of resolution sites is influenced by mismatched nucleotides between the sites, and the vaccinia virus hairpin in the linear minichromosome is a heteroduplex composed of DNA from each strand of the concatemer junction. A model incorporating site-specific recombination and orientated branch migration is proposed to account for resolution of the vaccinia virus concatemer junction.

Nucleotide sequence required for resolution of the concatemer junction of vaccinia virus DNA

The mature form of the vaccinia virus genome consists of a linear, 185,000-base-pair (bp) DNA molecule with a 10,000-bp inverted terminal repetition and incompletely base-paired 104-nucleotide hairpin loops connecting the two strands at each end. In concatemeric forms of intracellular vaccinia virus DNA, the inverted terminal repetitions of adjacent genomes form an imperfect palindrome. The apex of this palindrome corresponds in sequence to the double-stranded form of the hairpin loop. Circular plasmids containing palindromic concatemer junction fragments of 250 bp or longer are converted into linear minichromosomes with hairpin ends when they are transfected into vaccinia virus-infected cells, providing a model system with which to study the resolution process. To distinguish between sequence-specific and structural requirements for resolution, plasmids with symmetrical insertions, deletions, and oligonucleotide-directed mutations within the concatemer junction were constructed. A sequence (ATTTAGTGTCTAGAAAAAAA) located on both sides of the apex segment was found to be critical for resolution. Resolution was more efficient when additional nucleotides, TGTG, followed the run of A residues. Both the location and sequence of the proposed resolution signal are highly conserved among poxviruses.

Specific binding of cruciform DNA structures by a protein from human extracts

A gel electrophoresis binding assay has been used to probe extracts from cultured human lymphoblasts for proteins that bind cruciform structures in duplex DNA. Proteins have been detected that form complexes with synthetic X- and Y-junctions. Several lines of evidence suggest that binding is specific for DNA structure rather than sequence: (1) X- and Y-structures were bound whereas linear duplexes containing identical DNA sequences were not, (2) Binding occurred with equal efficiency to two X-junctions that were constructed from DNA strands of different sequence, (3) One X-junction successfully competed with another for binding whereas linear duplex DNA did not; and (4) protein-DNA complexes were observed at probe:non-specific competitor DNA ratios of 1:10,000.

Conformational isomerization of the Holliday junction associated with a cruciform during branch migration in supercoiled plasmid DNA

The variable positions of a branch-migrating cruciform junction in supercoiled plasmid DNA were mapped following cleavage of the DNA with bacteriophage T7 endonuclease I. T7 endonuclease I specifically cleaved, and thereby resolved, the Holliday junction existing at the base of the cruciform in the circular bacterial plasmid pSA1B.56A. Cruciform extrusion of cloned sequences in pSA1B.56A (containing a 322 base-pair inverted repeat insert composed of poxvirus telomeric sequences) topologically relaxed the plasmid substrate in vitro. Thus, numerous crossover positions were identified within the region of cloned sequences, reflecting the range of superhelical densities in the native plasmid preparation. Endonuclease I-sensitive crossover positions, mapped to both strands of the viral insert following the T7 endonuclease I digestion of either plasmid preparations or individual topoisomers, were regularly separated by approximately ten nucleotides. The appearance of sensitive crossovers every ten nucleotides corresponds to a change in linking difference (delta Lk) of +/- 2 in the circular core domain of the plasmid during branch point migration. In contrast, individual topoisomers of a plasmid preparation differ in linking number in increments of +/- 1. Thus, the observed linearization of each individual topoisomer following enzyme treatment, as a result of resolution of the crossovers associated with each topoisomer, showed that branch point migration to sensitive crossover positions must have occurred facilely. T7 endonuclease I randomly resolved across either axis of the cruciform, though some discrimination (related to the sequence specificity of the enzyme) was observed. The ten-nucleotide spacing between sensitive crossover positions is accounted for by an isomerization of the cruciform junction on branch point migration. An hypothesis is that this isomerization was imposed upon the cruciform junction by the change in helix twist (delta Tw) in the two branches that compose the topologically closed, circular domain of the plasmid. T7 endonuclease I may discriminate between the various isomeric forms and cleave a sensitive conformation that appears with every turn of branch migration which leads to the extrusion, or absorption, of two turns of helix from the circular core.