The normal replication terminus of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, terC, is dispensable for vegetative growth and sporulation

Too Much of a Good Thing: How Ectopic DNA Replication Affects Bacterial Replication Dynamics

Each cell division requires the complete and accurate duplication of the entire genome. In bacteria, the duplication process of the often-circular chromosomes is initiated at a single origin per chromosome, resulting in two replication forks that traverse the chromosome in opposite directions. DNA synthesis is completed once the two forks fuse in a region diametrically opposite the origin. In some bacteria, such as Escherichia coli, the region where forks fuse forms a specialized termination area. Polar replication fork pause sites flanking this area can pause the progression of replication forks, thereby allowing forks to enter but not to leave. Transcription of all required genes has to take place simultaneously with genome duplication. As both of these genome trafficking processes share the same template, conflicts are unavoidable. In this review, we focus on recent attempts to add additional origins into various ectopic chromosomal locations of the E. coli chromosome. As ectopic origins disturb the native replichore arrangements, the problems resulting from such perturbations can give important insights into how genome trafficking processes are coordinated and the problems that arise if this coordination is disturbed. The data from these studies highlight that head-on replication–transcription conflicts are indeed highly problematic and multiple repair pathways are required to restart replication forks arrested at obstacles. In addition, the existing data also demonstrate that the replication fork trap in E. coli imposes significant constraints to genome duplication if ectopic origins are active. We describe the current models of how replication fork fusion events can cause serious problems for genome duplication, as well as models of how such problems might be alleviated both by a number of repair pathways as well as the replication fork trap system. Considering the problems associated both with head-on replication-transcription conflicts as well as head-on replication fork fusion events might provide clues of how these genome trafficking issues have contributed to shape the distinct architecture of bacterial chromosomes.

Replication Termination: Containing Fork Fusion-Mediated Pathologies in Escherichia coli

Duplication of bacterial chromosomes is initiated via the assembly of two replication forks at a single defined origin. Forks proceed bi-directionally until they fuse in a specialised termination area opposite the origin. This area is flanked by polar replication fork pause sites that allow forks to enter but not to leave. The precise function of this replication fork trap has remained enigmatic, as no obvious phenotypes have been associated with its inactivation. However, the fork trap becomes a serious problem to cells if the second fork is stalled at an impediment, as replication cannot be completed, suggesting that a significant evolutionary advantage for maintaining this chromosomal arrangement must exist. Recently, we demonstrated that head-on fusion of replication forks can trigger over-replication of the chromosome. This over-replication is normally prevented by a number of proteins including RecG helicase and 3’ exonucleases. However, even in the absence of these proteins it can be safely contained within the replication fork trap, highlighting that multiple systems might be involved in coordinating replication fork fusions. Here, we discuss whether considering the problems associated with head-on replication fork fusion events helps us to better understand the important role of the replication fork trap in cellular metabolism.

A comparative genomic analysis of the alkalitolerant soil bacterium Bacillus lehensis G1

Bacillus lehensis G1 is a Gram-positive, moderately alkalitolerant bacterium isolated from soil samples. B. lehensis produces cyclodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase), an enzyme that has enabled the extensive use of cyclodextrin in foodstuffs, chemicals, and pharmaceuticals. The genome sequence of B. lehensis G1 consists of a single circular 3.99 Mb chromosome containing 4017 protein-coding sequences (CDSs), of which 2818 (70.15%) have assigned biological roles, 936 (23.30%) have conserved domains with unknown functions, and 263 (6.55%) have no match with any protein database. Bacillus clausii KSM-K16 was established as the closest relative to B. lehensis G1 based on gene content similarity and 16S rRNA phylogenetic analysis. A total of 2820 proteins from B. lehensis G1 were found to have orthologues in B. clausii, including sodium-proton antiporters, transport proteins, and proteins involved in ATP synthesis. A comparative analysis of these proteins and those in B. clausii and other alkaliphilic Bacillus species was carried out to investigate their contributions towards the alkalitolerance of the microorganism. The similarities and differences in alkalitolerance-related genes among alkalitolerant/alkaliphilic Bacillus species highlight the complex mechanism of pH homeostasis. The B. lehensis G1 genome was also mined for proteins and enzymes with potential viability for industrial and commercial purposes.

From simple bacterial and archaeal replicons to replication N/U-domains

The Replicon Theory proposed 50 years ago has proven to apply for replicons of the three domains of life. Here, we review our knowledge of genome organization into single and multiple replicons in bacteria, archaea and eukarya. Bacterial and archaeal replicator/initiator systems are quite specific and efficient, whereas eukaryotic replicons show degenerate specificity and efficiency, allowing for complex regulation of origin firing time. We expand on recent evidence that ~50% of the human genome is organized as ~1,500 megabase-sized replication domains with a characteristic parabolic (U-shaped) replication timing profile and linear (N-shaped) gradient of replication fork polarity. These N/U-domains correspond to self-interacting segments of the chromatin fiber bordered by open chromatin zones and replicate by cascades of origin firing initiating at their borders and propagating to their center, possibly by fork-stimulated initiation. The conserved occurrence of this replication pattern in the germline of mammals has resulted over evolutionary times in the formation of megabase-sized domains with an N-shaped nucleotide compositional skew profile due to replication-associated mutational asymmetries. Overall, these results reveal an evolutionarily conserved but developmentally plastic organization of replication that is driving mammalian genome evolution.

The replication fork trap and termination of chromosome replication

Bacteria that have a circular chromosome with a bidirectional DNA replication origin are thought to utilize a 'replication fork trap' to control termination of replication. The fork trap is an arrangement of replication pause sites that ensures that the two replication forks fuse within the terminus region of the chromosome, approximately opposite the origin on the circular map. However, the biological significance of the replication fork trap has been mysterious, as its inactivation has no obvious consequence. Here we review the research that led to the replication fork trap theory, and we aim to integrate several recent findings that contribute towards an understanding of the physiological roles of the replication fork trap. Likely roles include the prevention of over-replication, and the optimization of post-replicative mechanisms of chromosome segregation, such as that involving FtsK in Escherichia coli.

The replication-related organization of bacterial genomes

The replication of the chromosome is among the most essential functions of the bacterial cell and influences many other cellular mechanisms, from gene expression to cell division. Yet the way it impacts on the bacterial chromosome was not fully acknowledged until the availability of complete genomes allowed one to look upon genomes as more than bags of genes. Chromosomal replication includes a set of asymmetric mechanisms, among which are a division in a lagging and a leading strand and a gradient between early and late replicating regions. These differences are the causes of many of the organizational features observed in bacterial genomes, in terms of both gene distribution and sequence composition along the chromosome. When asymmetries or gradients increase in some genomes, e.g. due to a different composition of the DNA polymerase or to a higher growth rate, so do the corresponding biases. As some of the features of the chromosome structure seem to be under strong selection, understanding such biases is important for the understanding of chromosome organization and adaptation. Inversely, understanding chromosome organization may shed further light on questions relating to replication and cell division. Ultimately, the understanding of the interplay between these different elements will allow a better understanding of bacterial genetics and evolution.

Bacterial chromosome segregation

Recent years have witnessed a resurgence of interest in how the bacterial chromosome is organized and how newly replicated chromosomes are faithfully segregated into daughter cells on cell division. In the past, the problem with studying bacterial chromosomes was their lack of any obvious morphology, combined with the lack of ability to readily separate DNA replication and segregation functions into distinct stages like those observed in eukaryotic cells. This was due to the overlapping nature of these events in most bacterial systems used in the laboratory. The situation has now changed as new tools have become available that enable chromosomes and specific chromosomal sites to be labelled and monitored throughout the cell cycle, and this has led to rapid progress and the discovery of many unexpected results. Historically, chromosome segregation was thought to be achieved through passive processes where chromosomes were separated through some kind of membrane/cell wall attachment and were moved apart as the cell grew (Jacob et al., 1963). We now know that this is not the case and that there are specific mechanisms to actively partition chromosomes. This review will focus principally on the Gram-positive sporulating bacterium Bacillus subtilis, but will also cover work carried out on Escherichia coli, in which valuable information has been obtained, and will cover the events that occur on termination of chromosome replication, chromosome decatenation and chromosome separation.

Effects of replication termination mutants on chromosome partitioning in Bacillus subtilis

Many circular genomes have replication termination systems, yet disruption of these systems does not cause an obvious defect in growth or viability. We have found that the replication termination system of Bacillus subtilis contributes to accurate chromosome partitioning. Partitioning of the terminus region requires that chromosome dimers, that have formed as a result of RecA-mediated homologous recombination, be resolved to monomers by the site-specific recombinase encoded by ripX. In addition, the chromosome must be cleared from the region of formation of the division septum. This process is facilitated by the spoIIIE gene product which is required for movement of a chromosome out of the way of the division septum during sporulation. We found that deletion of rtp, which encodes the replication termination protein, in combination with mutations in ripX or spoIIIE, led to an increase in production of anucleate cells. This increase in production of anucleate cells depended on recA, indicating that there is probably an increase in chromosome dimer formation in the absence of the replication termination system. Our results also indicate that SpoIIIE probably enhances the function of the RipX recombinase system. We also determined the subcellular location of the replication termination protein and found that it is a good marker for the position of the chromosome terminus.

Effects of replication termination mutants on chromosome partitioning in Bacillus subtilis

Many circular genomes have replication termination systems, yet disruption of these systems does not cause an obvious defect in growth or viability. We have found that the replication termination system of Bacillus subtilis contributes to accurate chromosome partitioning. Partitioning of the terminus region requires that chromosome dimers, that have formed as a result of RecA-mediated homologous recombination, be resolved to monomers by the site-specific recombinase encoded by ripX . In addition, the chromosome must be cleared from the region of formation of the division septum. This process is facilitated by the spoIIIE gene product which is required for movement of a chromosome out of the way of the division septum during sporulation. We found that deletion of rtp , which encodes the replication termination protein, in combination with mutations in ripX or spoIIIE , led to an increase in production of anucleate cells. This increase in production of anucleate cells depended on recA , indicating that there is probably an increase in chromosome dimer formation in the absence of the replication termination system. Our results also indicate that SpoIIIE probably enhances the function of the RipX recombinase system. We also determined the subcellular location of the replication termination protein and found that it is a good marker for the position of the chromosome terminus.

A tale of two genomes: resolution of dimeric chromosomes in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis

Dimeric chromosomes can be formed during replication of circular bacterial chromosomes by an odd number of homologous recombination events between sister chromosomes. In the absence of a compensating recombination reaction such dimers cannot be segregated from each other as the cell divides. This review highlights the shared and divergent mechanisms employed by Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis in their effort to resolve and partition dimeric chromosomes safely. In particular, we discuss the Xer-type recombinases, RecA, FtsK/SpoIIIE, and dif.

Replication terminator protein-based replication fork-arrest systems in various Bacillus species

The replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis interacts with its cognate DNA terminators to cause replication fork arrest, thereby ensuring that the forks approaching one another at the conclusion of a round of replication meet within a restricted terminus region. A similar situation exists in Escherichia coli, but it appears that the fork-arrest systems in these two organisms have evolved independently of one another. In the present work, RTP homologs in four species closely related to B. subtilis (B. atrophaeus, B. amyloliquefaciens, B. mojavensis, and B. vallismortis) have been identified and characterized. An RTP homolog could not be identified in another closely related species, B. licheniformis. The nucleotide and amino acid changes from B. subtilis among the four homologs are consistent with the recently established phylogenetic tree for these species. The GC contents of the rtp genes raise the possibility that these organisms arose within this branch of the tree by horizontal transfer into a common ancestor after their divergence from B. licheniformis. Only 5 amino acid residue positions were changed among the four homologs, despite an up to 17.2% change in the nucleotide sequence, a finding that highlights the importance of the precise folded structure to the functioning of RTP. The absence of any significant change in the proposed DNA-binding region of RTP emphasizes the importance of its high affinity for the DNA terminator in its functioning. By coincidence, the single change (E30K) found in the B. mojavensis RTP corresponds exactly to that purposefully introduced by others into B. subtilis RTP to implicate a crucial role for E30 in the fork-arrest mechanism. The natural occurrence of this variant is difficult to reconcile with such an implication, and it was shown directly that RTP.E30K functions normally in fork arrest in B. subtilis in vivo. Additional DNA terminators were identified in the new RTP homolog-containing strains, allowing the definition of a Bacillus terminator consensus and identification of two more terminators in the B. subtilis 168 genome sequence to bring the total to nine.

Replication fork arrest and termination of chromosome replication in Bacillus subtilis

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis provided the first evidence for the presence of sequence-specific replication fork arrest (Ter) sites in the terminus region of the bacterial chromosome. These sites, when complexed with the replication terminator protein (RTP), block movement of a replication fork in a polar manner. The Ter sites are organized into two opposed groups which force the approaching forks to meet and fuse within a restricted terminus region. While the precise advantage provided to the cell through the presence of the so-called replication fork trap is not patently obvious, the same situation appears to have evolved independently in Escherichia coli. The molecular mechanism by which the RTP-Ter complex of B. subtilis (or the analogous but apparently unrelated complex in E. coli) functions is currently unresolved and subject to intense investigation. Replication fork arrest in B. subtilis, requiring RTP, also occurs under conditions of the stringent response at so-called STer sites that lie close to and on both sides of oriC. These sites are yet to be identified and characterized. How they are induced to function under stringent conditions is of considerable interest, and could provide vital clues about the mechanism of fork arrest by RTP-terminator complexes in general.

Experimental surgery to create subgenomes of Bacillus subtilis 168

The 4,188-kb circular genome of Bacillus subtilis 168 was artificially dissected into two stable circular chromosomes in vivo, one being the 3,878-kb main genome and the other the 310-kb subgenome that was recovered as covalently closed circular DNA in CsCl-ethidium bromide ultracentrifugation. The minimal requirements to physically separate the 310-kb DNA segment out of the genome were two interrepeat homologous sequences and an origin of DNA replication between them. The subgenome originated from the 1,255-1, 551-kb region of the B. subtilis genome was essential for the cell to survive because the subgenome was not lost from the cell. The finding that the B. subtilis genome has a potential to be divided and the resulting two replicons stably maintained may shed light on origins and formation mechanisms of giant plasmids or second chromosomes present in many bacteria. Similar excision or its reversal process, i.e., integration of large sized covalently closed circular DNA pieces into the main genome, implies significant roles of subgenomes in the exchange of genetic information and size variation of bacterial genomes in bacterial evolution.

New insights into the genetic instability of streptomyces

The high level of genetic instability in Streptomyces ambofaciens is related to large scale DNA rearrangements (deletions and DNA amplifications) which occur within a 2 Mb chromosomal region. The genome of several Streptomyces species is linear and the unstable region is present at the chromosomal extremities. This has raised the questions of the role of the unstable region (which is dispensable under laboratory conditions), the functions of the genes present in this area, and the relationships between instability and chromosomal linearity. The unstable region of Streptomyces and the replication termini of several other microorganisms, including Escherichia coli, share numerous common traits. This suggests that the unstable region of Streptomyces includes the replication terminus, and that chromosomal instability is related to the termination process.

Physical distance between the site of type II DNA binding to the membrane and oriC on the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome

The precise physical locations of the oriC region and the region for type II DNA binding to the membrane on the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome were determined. The DNA regions were physically mapped by creating new restriction sites (NotI and SfiI) within these regions. The physical distance between oriC and the type II DNA-binding region was verified with the creation of a novel sequence cleaved by endonuclease I-SceI in each of the above regions. Complete removal of the defined type II membrane-binding region produced no noticeable phenotype.

Normal terC-region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome acts in a polar manner to arrest the clockwise replication fork

A procedure is described for relocating a functional terC-region to various sites on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, and in alternative orientations. The relocated terC-region comprised the IRR-rtp portion of the chromosome contained within a 1.75 x 10(3) base-pair segment of DNA. This segment was first cloned into the Tn 917 vector pTV20 in both orientations, and the two new plasmids used for inserting the terC-region into chromosomal copies of Tn 917. When relocated to the pyr and metD loci (139 degrees and 100 degrees positions on the 360 degrees map) it was found that clockwise replication fork arrest occurred only when the IRR-rtp (or terC-) region was oriented, in relation to the direction of approach of the fork, in the same way as in the wild-type strain. Thus, the complete IRR when located in the chromosome, and apparently made up of opposing terminators which might enable it to function in both orientations, is polar in its action. Of the two inverted repeats present in the IRR, it appears that IRI is functional in the chromosome, but not IRII.

Variations and coding features of the sequence spanning the replication terminus of Bacillus subtilis 168 and W23 chromosomes

In a comparative study of the sequences of the 3-kb regions of DNA spanning the replication terminus, terC, of Bacillus subtilis strains 168 and W23, it was found that the latter contained an insertion of a large open reading frame (ORF405) whose translated protein product is a member of the cytochrome P-450 family. The insertion was about 34 nucleotides upstream from a putative promoter for the rtp gene. The sequenced regions contained a number of other ORFs. The translation product of one (ORF238) is a member of a previously identified oxidoreductase superfamily. The translation product of another (ORF257) is significantly similar to the proC product of Escherichia coli, but this ORF does not code for a functional proC product of B. subtilis.

Expression of the rtp gene of Bacillus subtilis is required for replication fork arrest at the chromosome terminus

It was earlier proposed that clockwise replication fork arrest at the chromosome terminus in Bacillus subtilis is dependent upon expression of the rtp gene adjacent to the site of arrest, terC [Smith and Wake, J. Bacteriol. 170 (1988) 4083-4090]. A merodiploid strain of B. subtilis, in which rtp was placed under the control of the IPTG-inducible spac-1 promoter, was constructed. Replication fork arrest at terC, as monitored by the level of a forked DNA molecule of predicted dimensions, was shown to be dependent upon IPTG-induced expression of rtp in this strain. The very low concentration of IPTG needed to induce a substantial level of fork arrest suggests that relatively little RTP, the protein product of rtp, is needed for fork arrest at terC.

Genetic characterization of Bacillus subtilis odhA and odhB, encoding 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase and dihydrolipoamide transsuccinylase, respectively

The 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase complex consists of three different subenzymes, the E1o (2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase) component, the E2o (dihydrolipoyl transsuccinylase) component, and the E3 (dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase) component. In Bacillus subtilis, the E1o and E2o subenzymes are encoded by odhA and odhB, respectively. A plasmid with a 6.8-kilobase-pair DNA fragment containing odhA and odhB was isolated. Functional E1o and E2o are expressed from this plasmid in Escherichia coli. Antisera generated against B. subtilis E1o and E2o expressed in E. coli reacted with antigens of the same size from B. subtilis. The nucleotide sequence of odhB and the terminal part of odhA was determined. The deduced primary sequence of B. subtilis E2o shows striking similarity to the corresponding E. coli protein, which made it possible to identify the lipoyl-binding lysine residue as well as catalytic histidine and aspartic acid residues. An mRNA of 4.5 kilobases hybridizing to both odhA and odhB probes was detected, indicating that odhA and odhB form an operon.

DNA and protein sequence conservation at the replication terminus in Bacillus subtilis 168 and W23

Cloned DNA from the replication terminus region of Bacillus subtilis 168 was used to identify and construct a restriction map of the homologous region in B. subtilis W23. With this information, DNA from the terminus region of W23 was cloned and the sequence was determined for a 1,499-base-pair segment spanning the expected terC site. The position of the site was then located more precisely. Use of the cloned DNA from strain W23 as a probe for digests of DNA from exponentially growing cells of the same strain established the presence of the slowly migrating replication termination intermediate (forked DNA). The orientation and dimensions of the forked molecule were consistent with arrest of the clockwise fork at the terC site in W23, as has been shown to occur in strain 168. Thus, despite significant differences between the two strains, the same termination mechanism appears to be used. The DNA sequences spanning the terC site in strains 168 and W23 showed a high level of homology (90.2%) close to the site but very little at a distance of approximately 250 base pairs from the site in one particular direction. The overall sequence comparison emphasised the importance of the open reading frame for a 122-amino-acid protein adjacent to terC. Although there were 22 base differences in the open reading frames between the strains, the amino acid sequence of the encoded protein was completely conserved. It is suggested that the amino acid sequence conservation reflects a role for the protein in the clockwise fork arrest mechanism as proposed earlier (M.T. Smith and R.G. Wake, J. Bacteriol. 170:4083-4090, 1988).

DNA sequence requirements for replication fork arrest at terC in Bacillus subtilis

The replication terminus, terC, of Bacillus subtilis is the chromosomal site at which movement of the clockwise replication fork is blocked. The effect of deletion or modification of DNA sequences on either side of terC (defined by the sequence location of the arrested clockwise fork junction) has been investigated. Deletion of sequences ahead of terC to within 250 base pairs (bp) had no effect on fork arrest, whereas removal of a further 130 bp abolished it. The 250-bp segment immediately ahead of terC encompassed the previously identified inverted repeat region as well as potential promoters for the transcription of an adjoining open reading frame (ORF). Deletion of DNA from the other side of terC up to 80 bp from it also abolished fork arrest. This deletion removed the bulk of the ORF. Disruption of this ORF by the insertion of 4 bp also abolished fork arrest. A model for clockwise fork arrest at terC, implicating both the inverted repeat region and the protein product of the ORF, is proposed.

Relocation of the replication terminus, terC, of Bacillus subtilis to a new chromosomal site

The terC-deletion strain of Bacillus subtilis 168, SU153 [Iismaa and Wake, J. Mol. Biol. 195 (1987) 299-310] was used for the re-insertion of a 1.75-kb segment of DNA containing terC at a site approx. 25 kb from its original position. The relocated terC in the new strain, SU160, was oriented normally with respect to the approaching clockwise replication fork, and was positioned such that this fork was the first to reach it. The relocated terC was effective in causing arrest of the clockwise fork, as evidenced by the appearance of a unique DNA species with a characteristic mobility in agarose gel electrophoresis and with a predicted single-strand composition. Thus, the previously cloned 1.75-kb terC-containing segment [Smith et al., Gene 38 (1985) 9-17] has not been altered with respect to TerC function and contains sufficient sequence for this function. The findings reported here provide the opportunity for establishing the minimal and essential sequence features of terC, and for examining its possible polarity of action in causing fork arrest.

Bacillus subtilis citM, the structural gene for dihydrolipoamide transsuccinylase: cloning and expression in Escherichia coli

The 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase multienzyme complex is composed of three different subenzymes: 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase (E1o), dihydrolipoamide transsuccinylase (E2o), and dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase (E3). Bacillus subtilis E1o and E2o are encoded by the citK and citM genes, respectively. A 3.4-kb BamHI DNA fragment containing citK and citM markers was isolated from a library of B. subtilis DNA in Escherichia coli. Functional E2o was expressed from the cloned DNA both in B. subtilis and E. coli. E2o had an apparent Mr of 60,000 when expressed in E. coli. The B. subtilis E2o component complemented an E. coli E2o-defective mutant in vivo and in vitro. It is concluded that functional B. subtilis E2o can be produced in E. coli and can interact with E. coli and E1o and E3 to form an active chimeric enzyme complex.