Problems of neuroblastoma screening for 6 month olds and results of second screening for 18 month olds

Results of mass screening for neuroblastoma in 18-month-old infants in Osaka area, Japan

PURPOSE

In 2004, the Japanese government halted nationwide mass screening for neuroblastoma in 6-month-old infants as it led to overdiagnosis of localized tumors with favorable prognoses and failed to reduce neuroblastoma-related mortality. However, a new mass screening program for neuroblastoma in 18-month-old infants (18MS) was conducted in the Osaka prefecture. We assessed the efficacy of the 18MS in screening unfavorable cases.

METHODS

Public health centers in Osaka prefecture, excluding the Osaka city area, provided test kits to the guardians of infants who received a check-up at 18 months of age between 2004 and 2017. For patients whose standardized urinary levels of vanillylmandelic acid or homovanillic acid exceeded the threshold, they were further examined and treated in two specific hospitals Osaka University Hospital and Osaka Women's and Children's Hospital. Screening-positive patients with and without neuroblastoma were retrospectively reviewed.

RESULTS

Among 142,423 children screened during the 18MS, 85 tested positive, and 14 were diagnosed with neuroblastoma. Twelve patients were classified as very low risk, while 2 were classified as high risk, based on the International Neuroblastoma Risk Group risk classification.

CONCLUSION

The 18MS did not screen unfavorable cases with neuroblastoma efficiently, although few participants benefited from it.

Thoracoscopic Removal of Neurogenic Mediastinal Tumors in Children

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the feasibility and advantages of thoracoscopic removal of neurogenic mediastinal tumors (NMTs) in children.

METHODS

From January 1998 to December 2001, 6 patients, ages 1.1 to 6.8 years (mean, 3.5 years), underwent thoracoscopic removal of NMT. A retrospective study was done to assess the type of anesthesia, conversions to standard thoracotomy, operative time, complications, and the current status of each patient.

RESULTS

General anesthesia using a Fogarty catheter as an ipsilateral bronchial blocker was utilized. Four 5-mm ports were placed in all patients. All NMTs were successfully removed without a need to convert to standard thoracotomy. The tumor was captured in an extraction bag, fragmented, and then removed through the trocar site, which had been enlarged up to 2.0-2.5 cm in each case. Pathologic diagnosis was neuroblastoma in 1 patient, ganglioneuroblastoma in 2, and ganglioneuroma in 3 patients. The mean operative time was 230 minutes. There was no need for transfusion and no serious complication related to this approach. All patients are alive at the time of writing, without any evidence of tumor recurrence.

CONCLUSION

All tumors were successfully removed. Thoracoscopic surgery is a feasible, safe, and effective technique in the treatment for children with NMT.

Children may not benefit from neuroblastoma screening at 1 year of age. Updated results of the population based controlled trial in Germany

Neuroblastoma is the second most frequent malignancy in childhood. We investigated whether screening for neuroblastoma at 1 year of age reduces the incidence of metastatic disease or mortality. Screening was offered in 6 of the 16 German states from 1995 to 2000 with the remaining states serving as controls. We studied 2,581,188 children in the screening area born between 1994 and 1999 and 2,117,600 in the control area. We compared mortality from neuroblastoma and the incidence of disseminated disease in the two groups. The screened group and the control group had similar rates of stage 4 neuroblastoma and mortality due to neuroblastoma. Comparison of the screened group and the control area revealed substantial over diagnosis in the screened participants. The present findings provide no support for mass screening for neuroblastoma at 1 year of age.

Improved survival of children with advanced neuroblastoma treated by intensified therapy including myeloablative chemotherapy with stem cell transplantation: a retrospective analysis from the Tohoku Neuroblastoma Study Group

In the hospitals of the Tohoku Neuroblastoma Study Group (TNBSG), treatment for children with advanced neuroblastoma (NB) was intensified in the mid-1990's with the introduction of myeloablative therapy (MT) with stem cell transplantation (SCT) including the use of autologous peripheral blood stem cells (PBSC) and bone marrow transplantation (BMT). In this report, we examined whether the intensified therapy improved the outcome of children with advanced NB (age> 12 months) who were diagnosed between 1991 and 1997. Patients were 36 children (23 boys and 13 girls) with an average age of 3.4 years (range; 1 to 14 years). Six of them had stage III disease, and the other 30 had stage IV. They were treated initially with induction chemotherapy, surgery, and post-operative chemoradiotherapy, after which 17 of them continued further chemotherapy and the other 19 received MT/SCT (18 with PBSCT and 1 with BMT). Progression-free survival (PFS) rate at seven years from diagnosis was 43.5% for all patients, 66.7% for stage III patients and 38.2% for stage IV patients. The difference between stage III and IV patients was not significant. Among the 30 patients with stage IV disease, PFS at seven years was significantly higher in the 19 patients who received MT/SCT (55.6%) than in the 11 patients who did not receive it (12.5%). There was no difference in clinical and biological risk factors between these two groups, except for the proportion of patients with favorable response to initial therapy (36% and 80% for patients without and with MT/SCT, respectively). Furthermore, the proportion of patients with N-myc amplification was significantly higher in patients with progressive disease (PD) after MT/SCT than in those in CR after MT/SCT. The results of this retrospective study of children with advanced NB suggest that therapy intensification involving MT/SCT might result in lengthened survival time for patients with stage IV disease, and that post-transplant PD remains a risk for patients with high levels of N-myc amplification.

Observation of untreated patients with neuroblastoma detected by mass screening: a "wait and see" pilot study

BACKGROUND

Recent studies have indicated that mass screening for neuroblastoma detects tumors that otherwise would have regressed spontaneously without recognition. Therefore, we started an observation program for these patients to determine how frequently spontaneous regression occurs.

PROCEDURE

Eighteen patients were detected by mass screening between June 1994 and December 1996. Eight of these cases matched the following criteria and entered the observation program: Stage I or II, less than 5 cm in diameter; no involvement of large vessels or organs; not difficult to resect; informed consent. If there were an increase in tumor size, an elevation of tumor markers, or evidence of metastasis, the tumor would be immediately resected.

RESULTS

Five of the eight cases showed spontaneous regression. Although the remaining three tumors were resected 6-10 months after diagnosis, all patients survived without evidence of recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

At least 60% of neuroblastoma cases who entered our observation program regressed spontaneously.

Biological aspects of neuroblastomas identified by mass screening in Quebec

BACKGROUND

Neuroblastoma has several characteristics that suggest that preclinical diagnosis might improve outcome. Therefore, the Quebec Neuroblastoma Screening Project was undertaken from 1989 to 1994 to examine infants at 3 weeks and 6 months by measuring urinary catecholamine metabolites.

PROCEDURE

Over the 5-yr period, 45 tumors were detected by screening, 20 were identified clinically prior to the third week, and 64 were identified clinically at a later time. We analyzed available tumors for Shimada histopathology, tumor ploidy, MYCN copy number and serum ferritin.

RESULTS

Of the tumors detected by screening, only 2 of 45 tested had unfavorable histology, 2 of 45 had diploid or tetraploid DNA content, 0 of 43 had MYCN amplification, and 4 of 44 had elevated serum ferritin. All of these patients are alive and well. The 20 patients detected prior to the 3-week screen had similar biological characteristics. In contrast, of the patients detected clinically after 3 weeks of age, 19 of 51 testedhad unfavorable histology, 25 of 66 had diploid or tetraploid tumors, 12 of 56 had MYCN amplification, and 14 of 54 had elevated ferritin.

CONCLUSIONS

The difference between the screened and clinically detected cases was highly significant for each biological variable. Preliminary data on other biological variables, such as neurotrophin expression and allelic loss on 1 p in these patients are consistent with the above findings. These data suggest that mass screening for neuroblastoma at or before 6 months of age detects almost exclusively tumors that have favorable biological characteristics, many of which might have regressed spontaneously. Thus, continued mass screening for neuroblastoma at 6 months is unlikely to accomplish its intended goal, and should probably be discontinued.

Mass screening for neuroblastoma at 6 months of age: difficult to justify

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

A statistical analysis of the mass screening for neuroblastoma in Japan based on a population study rarely has been reported. This study aims to evaluate retrospectively the effectiveness of mass screening at 6 months of age using the available population data.

METHODS

The data on the neuroblastoma cases registered by the Committee for Pediatric Solid Malignant Tumors in the Kyushu area were analyzed based on both screened and unscreened populations in the Kyushu area.

RESULTS

From 1988 to 1992, the cumulative incidence of neuroblastoma in children less than 5 years of age was 82 in 484,599 for screened children, and 11 in 92,966 for unscreened children, respectively. Fourteen of the 82 screened patients had negative findings at 6 months of age (MS-negative cases). No significant difference was observed in the cumulative mortality rates from neuroblastoma in children younger than 5 years of age between the screened children and the unscreened children. Six of seven patients who died among the screened children were MS-negative cases with stage III or IV disease. In addition, no significant difference was found in the cumulative mortality rates from the neuroblastoma cases in patients less than 5 years of age between the children screened from 1988 to 1992 (7 of 484,599) and all children from 1980 to 1984 (14 of 668,084).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggests that the majority of the patients detected by mass screening had a favorable prognosis, and, mass screening in Japan for children less than 6 months of age was not observed to reduce the incidence and mortality from neuroblastoma. Therefore, mass screening at 6 months of age was not found to improve substantially the prognosis of patients with unfavorable neuroblastoma identified over 1 year of age, which is the primary purpose of such mass screening for neuroblastoma.

Familial neuroblastoma: report of a kindred with later age at diagnosis

PURPOSE

To describe the clinical and biologic features of neuroblastoma (NB) in two siblings and their maternal second cousin.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

NB was diagnosed in the siblings at 2 1/2 (patient 2) and 5 (patient 3) years of age. NB was diagnosed in their maternal second cousin (patient 1) when she was 7 years old. Standard clinical and biological data, tumor karyotype, and tumor allelotype at select loci were obtained.

RESULTS

Patient 1 had International Neuroblastoma Staging System (INSS) stage 4 NB and unfavorable histology but no evidence of MYCN amplification; she died from complications of autologous bone marrow transplantation in second remission. Patient 2 had INSS stage 4 NB with unfavorable histology but no MYCN amplification; her disease recurred 39 months after completing therapy. Patient 3 had INSS stage 1 NB with favorable biologic features; he was treated with surgical excision and remains free of disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Familial NB may occur at a later age than predicted by the tumor suppressor gene model of inherited cancer. This report further emphasizes the clinical and biological heterogeneity of familial NB.

10 years' neuroblastoma screening in Europe: preliminary results of a clinical and biological review from the Study Group for Evaluation of Neuroblastoma Screening in Europe (SENSE)

Between January 1986 and May 1996, 870,313 children were tested in European neuroblastoma (NB) screening programmes. Among these children, 82 cases of NB (age range 4-24 months, median 11 months) were detected by screening. 83% of the patients had localised NB and 17% were diagnosed with generalised NB (stage 4, 10%; stage 4s, 7%). Unfavourable biological markers (MYCN amplification, loss of heterozygosity (LOH) 1p36, DNA di/tetraploidy) were observed in 14% of 76 biologically examined cases. The median follow-up time of all the patients was 21.5 months (range 1-101 months). To date, 69 patients are in complete remission (CR) and 2 patients have died due to therapy (stage 4, 1 patient; stage 3, 1 patient with unfavourable markers). Apart from screened patients, 16 other patients with NB were found who had previously had a normal screening test, i.e. 'false negative' patients (age range 10-41 months, median 31.5 months). The median interval between screening and diagnosis was 24.5 months (range 6-35 months). 11 of the 'false negative' patients suffered from generalised NB (stage 4) and 5 had localised NB at diagnosis. Unfavourable biological markers were observed in 7/12 patients. 5 patients have died, 2 achieved partial remission and 9 CR. 9 of the 11 patients with unfavourable biological markers diagnosed due to NB screening are currently in CR. It is very likely that, among the patients without unfavourable biological markers, we detected tumours which may have regressed spontaneously. These children may have undergone 'unnecessary,' but unavoidable, diagnostic procedures and therapy. To reduce the number of 'false negative' patients, a later screening could be helpful and should be evaluated.

Pathology review of screening negative neuroblastomas: a report from the Quebec Neuroblastoma Screening Project

BACKGROUND

The Quebec Neuroblastoma Screening (QNS) Project completed a 5-year program for measuring urinary vanillylmandelic acid (VMA)/homovanillic acid (HVA) levels at age 3 weeks and/or 6 months in 89% of 476,603 Quebec-born infants from 1989-1994; 45 screening positive preclinical cases (S-positive cases) and 20 congenital/neonatal (C/N) cases were identified. As of April 1997, an additional 59 cases in the same birth cohort were diagnosed clinically; these neuroblastomas developed after screening verified normal VMA/HVA levels (S-negative cases).

METHODS

Pathology specimens from 45 of 59 S-negative cases were reviewed centrally and classified according to the Shimada system. Results were compared with clinical data and also with S-positive and C/N cases.

RESULTS

Of 45 S-negative cases, 27 tumors had favorable histology (FH) and 18 had unfavorable histology (UH). Approximately 52% of FH tumors were diagnosed before age 1 year, whereas UH tumors were nearly exclusively (94%) diagnosed after age 1 year (P < 0.01). Approximately 89% of FH tumors were Stage I, II, or IV-S, whereas 72% UH tumors were Stage III or IV (P < 0.001). All children with FH tumors were alive at last follow-up (range of follow-up period: 9-79 months; median, 35 months), whereas 8 children with UH tumors died of disease even after limited follow-up (range of follow-up period: 0-60 months; median, 20 months). By contrast, S-positive and C/N cases were predominantly (97%) FH tumors, often (76%) Stage I, II, or IV-S, with excellent clinical outcome (survival rate of 98%).

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of the UH neuroblastomas that developed in the birth cohort of the QNS Project were included in the group of S-negative cases and could not be detected by the screening at age 3 weeks and/or 6 months.

Neuroblastoma screening in the United States: results of the Texas Outreach Program for neuroblastoma screening

BACKGROUND

Mass screening of infants for neuroblastoma began in Japan after studies suggested that survival rates could be improved by early detection. This study was initiated in 1991 to test the methodology and feasibility of screening for neuroblastoma within the U. S. health care system.

METHODS

Infants ages 5-10 months (mean age, 9 months, 25 days) who were born in Texas were screened for neuroblastoma. An enzyme-linked immunoadsorbent assay (ELISA) for homovanillic acid (HVA) and vanillylmandelic acid (VMA) used to quantify the HVA and VMA was performed on urine extracted from specimens dried on filter paper. Infants were recruited to participate in the study by several methods, and the effectiveness of each method was determined by calculating compliance rates.

RESULTS

Between February 1991 and June 1994 a total of 14,046 infants were recruited to participate in neuroblastoma screening. Neuroblastoma was detected in 2 children for an incidence rate of 1 in 7023. A total of 291,158 screening kits were distributed to the parents of these infants, resulting in an overall compliance rate of only 4.8%. Compliance rates varied by method of distribution of the test kits: Houston Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) clinic (53%), volunteers (31%), Rio Grande Valley WIC clinics (14.5%), the patient's private physician (9.9%), and by mail (4.7%).

CONCLUSIONS

Early detection of neuroblastoma in infants ages 5-10 months was achieved using ELISA. Compliance rates were poor, but clinics with a preventive health focus, such as the WIC clinics, achieved higher compliance rates than did private physicians.

Determination of vanillylmandelic, 5-hydroxyindoleacetic and homovanillic acid in urine by isocratic liquid chromatography

A new isocratic HPLC method, employing electrochemical detection, is described for the determination of urinary vanillylmandelic acid, 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid and homovanillic acid. The main advantages of this technique are: simplicity, simultaneous determination of all analytes, the absence of an extraction procedure, isocratic elution and low cost. The diluted urine is injected onto a C18 reversed phase column. The mobile phase is potassium dihydrogenphosphate buffer containing 1-heptanesulphonic acid, methanol and acetonitrile. The calibration curves are linear from 0.1 to 50 mg/l; the precision data show CV less than 2.36% for within-day assay and less than 2.72% for day-to-day assays. The mean recoveries for supplemented samples are 98.2 to 102.0% for vanillylmandelic acid, 99.6 to 103.9% for 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid and 98.7 to 102.0% for homovanillic acid. In comparisons of the present method with Radjaipur's extraction method (Radjaipur M. et al., Eur J Clin Chem Clin Biochem 1994; 32:609-13) the slopes for the three analytes were nearly 1, and the confidence region of the intercepts was close to 0. In conclusion the technique seems to be suitable for routine determination of the three analytes, especially for mass screening purposes.

Mass screening for neuroblastoma: quo vadis? A 9-year experience from the Pediatric Oncology Study Group of the Kyushu area in Japan

Since 1985, a nationwide program of mass screening for neuroblastoma has been available for 6-month-old infants throughout Japan. From 1985 to 1993, the authors studied 285 patients with neuroblastoma among their regional population of 15 million. There was an increase in the total number of patients per year in comparison to the previous 6-year period (1979 to 1984). However, no significant difference was noted in the number of patients older than 1 year or in the incidence of advanced-stage (stages III and IV) unscreened cases. The majority of neuroblastomas in the screened group showed favorable biological factors, even in the advanced stages. However, there was a small group with histologically and/or biologically unfavorable factors; five of 115 had amplified N-myc oncogene, four of 74 showed unfavorable Shimada histological findings, and three of 33 had an unfavorable DNA ploidy pattern. One case from this group with unfavorable factors died of the tumor. 3) Thirty-eight cases were negative at the time of mass screening, but later presented with neuroblastoma. Most of them were diagnosed between 1 and 3 years of age, and 30 of the 38 cases (78.9%) were advanced stage with unfavorable prognostic factors. Thus, the authors conclude that mass screening at 6 months can detect a selected population of infants with neuroblastoma; some of the tumors may represent subclinical masses destined for spontaneous regression. However, some tumors with unfavorable factors have been detected by mass screening before progression and/or dissemination. Infants in this group are considered to benefit most from early diagnosis and treatment.