Hamster-to-rat cardiac xenografts. A useful model for transplantation studies

Intragraft cytokine mRNA expression in rejecting and non-rejecting vascularized xenografts

BACKGROUND

The aim of the present study was to further investigate the characteristics of both graft-infiltrating cells and splenocytes during acute vascular rejection (AVR), cell-mediated rejection and non-rejection of vascularized concordant xenografts, by analysing both proinflammatory [interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta) and tumour necrosis factor (TNF-alpha)] and more specific [(IL-2, IL-4, IL-10, IL-12p40 and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma)] cytokines. A parallel investigation was made of the antibody response of IgM and IgG to the xenografts.

METHODS

Mouse hearts were heterotopically transplanted to the neck vessels of recipient rats. Grafts, spleens and sera were collected from untreated (AVR) and cyclosporin A (CyA) treated animals on day 2 after transplantation. Organs from rats treated with 15-deoxyspergualin (DSG) or CyA and DSG in combination were harvested on both day 2 and day 8. Grafts from DSG-treated rats undergo cell-mediated rejection and stop beating on day 9 and forth, while CyA + DSG treatment results in long-term graft survival. Real-time quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) was applied for analysis of intragraft and splenic cytokine messenger RNA (mRNA) expression. The phenotypes of the graft infiltrating cells were characterized by immunohistochemistry. The antibody response was investigated by means of immunofluorescence, haemagglutination and flow cytometry.

RESULTS

All the studied cytokines (IL-1beta, IL-2, IL-4, IL-10, IL-12p40, IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha) were up-regulated in the grafts from rejecting untreated (day 2) and DSG-treated animals (day 8) in comparison with grafts from CyA + DSG treated animals (day 8). On day 2 under immunosuppression with CyA, DSG or CyA + DSG no or low cytokine mRNA levels were found. The mRNA levels of IL-2, IL-4 and IFN-gamma in the spleens were suppressed under both DSG- and CyA + DSG treatment on day 8. Immunofluorescence showed deposits of both IgM and IgG in grafts from untreated, CyA-treated (day 2) and DSG-treated (day 8) animals, while CyA + DSG treatment diminished these deposits on both day 2 and day 8. No circulating antibodies were identified in either group.

CONCLUSION

We hereby conclude that both AVR on day 2 and cell-mediated rejection on day 8 (under DSG treatment) in a concordant cardiac mouse-to-rat xenotransplantation model are associated with an increase of proinflammatory cytokines, T helper 1 (Th1)-associated cytokines as well as IL-10, while immunosuppression with CyA + DSG diminishes the levels of all examined cytokines. Grafts undergoing AVR or cellular rejection are subjected to deposits of both IgM and IgG, although circulating donor specific antibodies are undetectable in serum.

Induction of T-independent xenotolerance in a semi-discordant hamster-to-presensitized, nude rat model

BACKGROUND

We have previously demonstrated that in a concordant hamster-to-nude rat cardiac transplant model, T-independent specific B-lymphocyte and natural killer (NK)-cell tolerance could be induced, leading to long-term xenograft (Xg) survival. Here, we investigated whether the same could be achieved in a clinically more relevant semi-discordant model involving hamster hearts transplanted into pre-sensitized, nude rats.

METHODS

Sensitized, nude rats with high titers of anti-hamster immunoglobulin (Ig)M xenoantibodies (XAbs) were prepared by transplanting a first hamster heart without treatment. One week after rejection, a complete tolerizing regimen was given, including the following: a) an i.v. injection of hamster heart antigens; b) a 4-week administration of malononitriloamide; and c) a single injection of an anti-NK antiserum. Two weeks later, a second hamster heart was grafted. The isotype and level of XAb were examined by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. NK cytotoxicity was evaluated by a standard 4-hr 51Cr release assay. Hamster heart Xgs were examined by conventional histologic and immunohistochemical analysis.

RESULTS

Untreated, presensitized, nude rats developing high titers of IgM XAb underwent hyperacute rejection within 4 hr (n=4) after transplantation of the second hamster heart. Immunohistochemical analysis showed intensive staining for IgM and C3 along the vascular endothelia in the rejected Xgs. In contrast, presensitized, nude rats receiving the complete tolerizing regimen had a rapid decrease in anti-hamster IgM XAb. The second hamster hearts were not rejected and showed long-term survival even after withdrawal of malononitriloamide (n=6). Moreover, tolerant rats showed specific B-lymphocyte tolerance and a specific continuous absence of anti-hamster NK-cell reactivity.

CONCLUSION

T-independent B-lymphocyte and NK-cell xenotolerance can also be achieved in recipients with pre-existing IgM XAb.

Suppression of T-independent IgM xenoantibody formation by leflunomide during xenografting of hamster hearts in rats

BACKGROUND

It was recently shown that leflunomide (LF) delayed xenoantibody (XAb) formation and xenograft (Xg) rejection in a hamster-to-rat heart transplantation model. Our aim in this study was further investigation of the mechanism of LF-mediated suppression of XAb formation.

METHODS

Hamster hearts were heterotopically transplanted to euthymic or nude rats receiving LF and/or cyclosporine (CsA). Second hamster hearts were transplanted at the time of first Xg rejection. Serum from rejecting rats was transferred to naive rats receiving a hamster heart Xg. The isotype of XAbs was examined by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Tissue deposition of XAbs and complement was determined by immunofluorescence. XAb formation and its response to LF were also investigated in severe combined immunodeficient mice reconstituted with purified CD5+ or CD5- rat B cells.

RESULTS

After xenografting, untreated PVG rats developed high titers of anti-hamster IgM XAbs that appeared T-independent (T-I) as they could not be suppressed by CsA and also occurred in athymic nude rats. A second Xg transplanted in control or CsA-treated rats rejecting a first Xg was subject to hyperacute rejection. Hyperacute rejection also occurred in naive rats after adoptive transfer of serum from rejecting rats. Monotherapy with LF resulted in a suppression of early IgM XAb formation and in a delay of Xg rejection, which was associated with predominantly IgG anti-hamster XAbs. These XAbs were T-dependent, as they did not occur in nude rats and were suppressed by CsA. CD5+ B lymphocytes appeared to contribute to T-I IgM XAb formation, as LF reduced the percentage of peripheral blood CD5+ B lymphocytes and severe combined immunodeficient mice reconstituted with purified CD5+ B cells, but not with CD5- B cells, produced anti-hamster IgM which were suppressed by LF but not CsA.

CONCLUSIONS

In rats, T-I XAb formation is a first step leading to hamster Xg rejection and is suppressed by LF leading to prolonged Xg survival.

Induction of specific transplantation tolerance across xenogeneic barriers in the T-independent immune compartment

After transplantation of primarily vascularized xenografts (Xgs), T-independent mechanisms may lead to Xg rejection before T-cell activation even takes place. The possibility of achieving T-independent xenotolerance was evaluated in nude rats that normally reject hamster cardiac Xgs within 4 days by non-T cell-mediated mechanisms. After donor antigen infusion, temporary NK-cell depletion and a 4-week administration of Leflunomide, hamster heart grafts survived even after withdrawal of immunosuppression. Tolerant rats accepted second hamster hearts, but promptly rejected mouse heart Xgs. In vivo immunization and in vitro cytotoxicity assays indicated that this species-specific tolerance was based on B-lymphocyte and NK-cell tolerance respectively.

Factors involved in rejection of concordant xenografts in complement-deficient rats

BACKGROUND

Factors that contribute to xenograft (Xg) rejection were investigated in complement C6-deficient (C-) PVG rats.

METHODS

First and second hamster hearts were transplanted in C6-deficient and C6-sufficient PVG rats. Xenoantibody (XAb) formation, hemolytic C (CH50) activity and immunohistochemistry were studied.

RESULTS

PVG C6-deficient rats rejected Xgs 3 days later than PVG C6-sufficient rats. Surprisingly, C activation participated in the rejection in PVG C- rats, as shown by partially recovered serum CH50 levels and deposition of C factors in the Xgs. As we found that cultured endothelial cells produced C6 in vitro, we hypothesized that Xg endothelial cells corrected the C6 defect in PVG C- rats. This was probably induced by IgM XAbs as: (1) it did not occur in immunosuppressed PVG C- rats in which XAb formation was prevented, and (2) transfer of IgM XAbs to naive, xenotransplanted PVG C- rats accelerated the recovery of CH50 and concomitantly Xg rejection. Thirty days after rejection of a first Xg, when no IgM XAbs or CH50 activity but high levels of IgG XAbs were detected in PVG C- rats, second Xgs underwent a hyperacute rejection. This time, complement was not involved, as no serum CH50 nor C deposition was found in the Xg. Instead, IgG antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity was involved as: (1) IgG XAbs were deposited in the Xg and (2) hyperacute rejection was induced in naive PVG C- rats by transfer of IgG XAbs, and (3) this rejection was delayed to 5+/-3 days if the adoptive hosts were first irradiated.

CONCLUSIONS

In the face of a defect of host C factors, IgM XAb may induce cells of the Xg to secrete C factors which may correct the C defect of the host. Even if activation of lytic C can be prevented, IgG XAb may still provoke an acute Xg rejection by antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity.

Anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody treatment in combination with total lymphoid irradiation and cyclosporin A in hamster-to-rat cardiac transplantation. Morphological features of heart grafts, recipient spleens and lymph nodes

Significantly prolonged graft survival (GS) of hamster hearts transplanted heterotopically into rats can be achieved by different immunosuppressive treatment strategies. The exact mechanism of graft rejection is unclear, but it seems to be a primarily humoral, antibody-mediated type of rejection. The histopathology of long-term surviving grafts is controversial and the morphology of lymphoid tissue in spleens and lymph nodes as the possible site of anti-donor antibody formation has not previously been investigated. This report demonstrates a significantly prolonged GS in hamster-to-rat cardiac transplantation after combined treatment with total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), cyclosporin A (CyA) and anti-CD4 monoclonal antibodies (MAb), where long-term GS (> 100 days) could be achieved in a few animals. The histopathology of heart grafts showed predominantly chronic vascular changes with endothelial proliferation, intimal thickening and vessel obliteration. No substantial cellular reactivity in terms of mononuclear/lymphoid cell infiltration could be demonstrated in rejected grafts. Spleens and lymph nodes were characterized by a profound global reduction in lymphoid tissue after preoperative TLI. Although subsequent lymphoid regeneration was depressed due to postoperative immunosuppression, a significant increase in IgM-positive plasma cells was observed, supporting evidence of an antibody-mediated mechanism of graft rejection. The role of CD4+ cells is unclear, but anti-donor antibody formation might involve T-cell help.

The biological basis of and strategies for clinical xenotransplantation

Recent discoveries have suggested that the exchange of multiple leukocyte lineages between grafts and host and subsequent long-term chimerism in both is the seminal mechanism of the acceptance of organs transplanted from the same (allografts) or different species (xenografts). This insight suggests new strategies which may allow xenotransplantation, the principal obstacle to which has been humoral rejection. We have defined humoral rejection as a family of complement activation syndromes afflicting allografts and xenografts in which there is a strong (but not invariable) association with performed antigraft antibodies, invariable evidence of complement activation, histopathologic stigmas of vascular endothelial damage, and a concomitant local or systemic coagulopathy. The generic descriptive term hyperacute rejection is a misnomer because a slow-motion version of the same "humoral" process can occur with some allografts and is the rule with the so-called concordant species xenotransplantations. The pathway of experience and discovery leading to this conclusion shows clearly that the distinction frequently made between allograft versus xenograft humoral rejection does not actually exist in principle, but only in details and intensity. Breaking down this barrier to xenotransplantation, whether or not it is associated with antibodies, is unrealistic. However, the possibility of avoiding the barrier has been exposed by showing that animal organs can be humanized, with a mixed donor and recipient cell population similar to the chimerism seen in long surviving allografts or even with complete leukocyte replacement. Pilot experiments in rodents suggest that organs from fully xenogeneic chimeras can be made into xenogeneic targets that are no more provocative of complement activation than allografts when they are transplanted into the donor bone marrow species. Although the validity of this concept of organ xenograft preparation is only at the pilot stage of verification, there is reason to suspect that the complement trigger of humoral rejection can be thereby disarmed. If this can be accomplished, independent evidence suggests that cellular rejection can be controlled with conventional T-cell directed immunosuppression, perhaps even with surprising ease. The potential subtle liability of synthetic products of xenogeneic parenchymal cells is not yet known.

Organ xenografting between rodents: an evolutionary perspective

Rejection times of heart xenografts in several donor-recipient combinations including the guinea pig, rat, hamster, and mouse are examined in light of the paleontological history of rodents and the resulting phylogenetic distances between taxa. This multidisciplinary review at the molecular, chromosomal and morphological levels suggests that xenograft rejection time is inversely proportional to the time divergence or phylogenetic distance, and that the binomial terminology concordant/discordant does not reflect the amplitude of phylogenetic distances.