Water and protein movement in the sheep lung after septic shock: Effect of colloid versus crystalloid resuscitation

Fluid administration and monitoring in ARDS: which management?

Modalities of fluid management in patients sustaining the acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) are challenging and controversial. Optimal fluid management should provide adequate oxygen delivery to the body, while avoiding inadvertent increase in lung edema which further impairs gas exchange. In ARDS patients, positive fluid balance has been associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation, longer ICU and hospital stay, and higher mortality. Accordingly, a restrictive strategy has been compared to a more liberal approach in randomized controlled trials conducted in various clinical settings. Restrictive strategies included fluid restriction guided by the monitoring of extravascular lung water, pulmonary capillary wedge or central venous pressure, and furosemide targeted to diuresis and/or albumin replacement in hypoproteinemic patients. Overall, restrictive strategies improved oxygenation significantly and reduced duration of mechanical ventilation, but had no significant effect on mortality. Fluid management may require different approaches depending on the time course of ARDS (i.e., early vs. late period). The effects of fluid strategy management according to ARDS phenotypes remain to be evaluated. Since ARDS is frequently associated with sepsis-induced acute circulatory failure, the prediction of fluid responsiveness is crucial in these patients to avoid hemodynamically inefficient—hence respiratory detrimental—fluid administration. Specific hemodynamic indices of fluid responsiveness or mini-fluid challenges should be preferably used. Since the positive airway pressure contributes to positive fluid balance in ventilated ARDS patients, it should be kept as low as possible. As soon as the hemodynamic status is stabilized, correction of cumulated fluid retention may rely on diuretics administration or renal replacement therapy.

Reproducibility of double indicator dilution measurements of intrathoracic blood volume compartments, extravascular lung water, and liver function

STUDY OBJECTIVE

Arterial thermal dye dilution (TDDart) with the COLD system (Munich, Germany) allows measurement of cardiac index (CI), partial blood volumes, lung water, and liver function. The aim of the study was to determine agreement of TDDart measurements with pulmonary artery thermal dilution measurements (TDpa) and to assess the reproducibility of TDDart parameters.

DESIGN

Prospective study.

SETTING

ICU of a university hospital department of cardiac surgery.

PATIENTS

Thirty consecutive patients after coronary artery bypass grafting.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

Triplicate measurements of TDDart parameters were performed 1, 3, 6, 12, and 24 h postoperatively and coefficients of variation (CVs) were computed. At the 3-h point, additional fivefold TDDart measurements were done and compared with TDpa measurements. The coefficient of correlation for CI from TDDart vs TDpa was 0.96 (p<0.001), and the mean difference was 0.16 L/min/m2 (2.4%). The CVs of the TDDart and TDpa CI measurement were 7.2% and 5.9%; the CVs of other TDDart parameters were 4.6% (cardiac function index), 8.3% (global end-diastolic volume), 7.0% (intrathoracic blood volume), 7.6% (total blood volume), 7.4% (right ventricular end-diastolic volume), 7.4% (right heart end-diastolic volume), 11.3% (left heart end-diastolic volume [LHEDV]), 12.0% (right to left heart volume proportion [R/LHV]), 8.8% (pulmonary blood volume), 10.8% (extravascular lung water), 16.4% (plasma disappearance rate of dye), and 19.8% (dye clearance). The CV did not depend on Glasgow coma scale or on body temperature.

CONCLUSION

The CVs of LHEDV and R/LHV are influenced by asynchronous TDDart and TDpa variation. The CVs of plasma disappearance and dye clearance are increased as the half-life of the dye is longer than the measurement sequence. All other parameters derived from TDDart and TDpa show a clinically sufficient reproducibility.

Effect of large volume replacement with balanced electrolyte solutions on extravascular lung water in surgical patients with sepsis syndrome

We investigated the effect of large volume replacement with balanced electrolyte solutions on extravascular lung water (EVLW) in 16 adult surgical patients with sepsis syndrome. Patients entered the study within the 24 h period following surgical interventions for acute necrotizing pancreatitis, intra-abdominal abscesses, and/or peritonitis. Sequential measurements (n = 108) were made at intervals of 6-12 h over a 48 h period. There were no significant differences between initial and final values of thermal-dye EVLW (5.0 +/- 1.1 vs. 5.7 +/- 1.1 ml/kg), plasma colloid osmotic pressure (COP, 13.3 +/- 2.5 vs. 13.2 +/- 2.9 mmHg), pulmonary artery wedge pressure (PAWP, 9.2 +/- 3.0 vs. 10.8 +/- 3.0 mmHg), and COP-PAWP gradient (4.0 +/- 3.5 vs. 2.4 +/- 3.9 mmHg). All results expressed as (mean +/- SD). The EVLW did not correlate with plasma COP, PAWP, or COP-PAWP gradient. We conclude that large volume replacement with balanced electrolyte solutions with the secondary decrease in plasma COP and COP-PAWP gradient do not necessarily contribute to a substantial increase in EVLW. This study fails to show any causal relationship between decrease in plasma COP or COP-PAWP gradient and oedema formation in the lung.

Permeability studies in a hypovolemic traumatic shock model: comparison of Ringer's lactate and albumin as volume replacement fluids

In order to shed light on the controversy surrounding the choice of resuscitative fluids in shock, we used a canine model which we feel to be a superior mimic of human traumatic shock, combining hemorrhage (to a mean arterial pressure of 50 mmHg), fracture of both femora, and soft tissue crush. After 90 min, animals were resuscitated by reinfusion of shed blood, supplemented by 5% albumin (n = 8) or lactated Ringer's solution (n = 8). Plasma colloid osmotic pressure (COP), transcapillary escape rate for albumin (TER), total lung water and extravascular lung water (EVLW) were measured. COP fell in both groups, but remained above 9 mmHg in the albumin recipients, while falling below 7 in those receiving crystalloid (P less than 0.05). Overall, the increase in EVLW averaged 20%; albumin recipients fared better (9.7%) than Ringer's recipients (31.1%), but wide inter-animal variation precluded statistical significance (P = 0.095). TER rose 30% per hour, without difference between groups. Quality of resuscitation (achieved blood pressure and cardiac output) was somewhat better in the albumin group. We conclude that this model allows study of the early microvascular leakage seen in shock; within the time-frame studied (maximum 4.5 h following shock), colloid and crystalloid resuscitation were approximately equivalent.

Increased plasma oncotic pressure inhibits pulmonary fluid transport when pulmonary pressures are elevated

Hydrostatic and oncotic pressures are the primary determinants of fluid movement across the pulmonary vascular membrane. The precise role of oncotic pressure in regulating transvascular fluid exchange especially when hydrostatic pressure is high is not known. Awake, adult sheep were instrumented for pressure monitoring and the collection of pulmonary lymph. A left atrial (LA) balloon catheter was utilized to control LA pressure. Statistically significant increases in lymph protein flux were seen with infusion of saline and elevated pulmonary microvascular pressure (Pmv) over elevated Pmv alone (15.3 +/- 1.23 versus 11.2 +/- 1.09 mg/min) concomitant with a decrease in plasma colloid oncotic pressure (COP) (14.9 +/- 0.5 versus 16.9 +/- 0.5 mm/Hg). The protein flux seen with elevated Pmv and saline infusion was blunted when plasma was infused (13.8 +/- 1.58 mg/min) and the plasma COP augmented (18.1 +/- 0.05 mg Hg) but was not statistically different. We conclude that under conditions of stable membrane permeability and elevated Pmv, the plasma COP appears to be an important mechanism for protection against pulmonary edema.

A retrospective survey of treatment and mortality in aspiration pneumonia

A retrospective survey was conducted of all patients with severe aspiration pneumonitis requiring artificial ventilation in our Intensive Care Unit from 1982-1986 inclusive. Of 38 patients, 8 (21%) died. Five of these deaths were due to severe primary intracranial pathology, and occurred after complete or almost complete resolution of the pneumonitis. One death (2.5%) due to myocardial infarction was possibly related to aspiration, and 2 deaths (5%) were definitely related to aspiration. The 7.5% mortality related to aspiration is considerably lower than in previous clinical studies of severe aspiration pneumonia. There was only one death due to aspiration in patients under the age of 70. The mean arterial to alveolar oxygen tension ratio was 0.221, and the mean predicted mortality by apache II was 43%. Patients were managed with rapid intravascular volume restoration using crystalloid fluids, early ventilation, no steroids, and no immediate antibiotics. We conclude that with such management it is possible to achieve a low hospital mortality in severe aspiration pneumonia, particularly in young patients.

Group B streptococcal sepsis in the piglet: effects of fluid therapy on venous return, organ edema, and organ blood flow

We investigated the physiologic effects of normal saline versus 5% albuminated saline fluid resuscitation on 10-12-day-old piglets infected with group B streptococci for four hours. After intravenously receiving 1 X 10(10) bacteria/kg over 45 minutes, one group was untreated while the two fluid-treated groups received enough intravenous fluid to maintain the baseline cardiac output. An increase in the resistance to venous blood return was the major limitation to cardiac output. The resistance nearly quadrupled in the untreated piglets as shown by a 50% decrease in cardiac output with a nearly doubling of the driving pressure for venous return (mean circulatory pressure was normal and atrial pressures decreased by 70%). In both fluid-treated groups, resistance doubled as shown by an unchanged cardiac output with a doubling of the driving pressure (mean circulatory pressure increased by 50%) and atrial pressures remained at baseline). Blood volume was 9% below control in the untreated group and 13% above control in both fluid-treated groups. Much more crystalloid (155 ml/kg) than colloid (58 ml/kg) was necessary to maintain baseline cardiac output; this resulted in a 36% decrease in the plasma protein oncotic pressure of the former group and a 15% increase in the oncotic pressure of the latter group. Organ edema formation (ileum, pancreas, kidney, adrenal gland, lung) occurred only in the saline-treated animals. We conclude that increased resistance to venous return was the primary cause of shock in our model and that this can be effectively treated by giving enough intravenous fluid to elevate the mean circulatory pressure. However, if the plasma protein oncotic pressure is also lowered (saline group), organ edema results.

[Indications for postoperative human albumin therapy in the intensive care unit--a prospective randomized study]

In a prospectively randomised study (n = 161) we examined whether postoperative human albumin administration is justified in intensive care patients whenever the colloid osmotic pressure (COP) decreases below 26 cm H2O. Postoperative complication rates did not increase in the control group, although only 22% of these patients received albumin as compared to 100% in the therapy group. A decline of the COP below extreme values (even under 20 cm H2O) was compatible with survival. This study established only one indication for postoperative human albumin therapy: acute volume substitution in patients on dialysis. Consequently, in the second half year of this study only 3 of 49 patients of the control group received human albumin therapy.

Extravascular lung water measurement in septic sheep

Sheep were prepared with a chronic lung lymph fistula and studied unanesthetized following septicemia by infusion of live Escherichia coli 10(9) ml/kg bw or injection of oleic acid 0.05 ml/kg bw. Extravascular lung water (EVTV) was measured with thermal-dye technique and compared to gravimetrically measured lung water (EVWV). Septic sheep had increased pulmonary artery pressure, reduced mean arterial blood pressure and reduced cardiac output. In control animals there was a correlation between EVTV-EVWV of r = 0.70. In animals given oleic acid lungs were macroscopically edematous and the correlation was r = 0.93. In septic sheep, however, no correlation could be found between EVTV and EVWV (r = -0.25). The thermal-dye technique was found to give erroneously high values. This finding could probably be due to erythrostasis and leukocyte plugging with uneven perfusion and prolonged transit times due to reduced cardiac output.

Crystalloid resuscitation of patients with pulmonary contusion

One hundred nine patients with the diagnosis of pulmonary contusion were studied retrospectively. Thirteen deaths were respiratory related (12 percent of patients). All of the patients were quickly resuscitated with crystalloid solutions as necessary to restore perfusion to normal. Twenty-eight of the most severely injured patients, all of whom were intubated and ventilated and in whom serial PaO2 and total protein determinations were available, were examined for the relationship between crystalloid induced hemodilution as measured by the plasma colloid oncotic pressure and oxygenation as measured by the PaO2/FiO2 ratio. When survivors and nonsurvivors were analyzed by group, both individually and collectively, no correlation was found between oxygenation and oncotic pressure. Survivors and nonsurvivors exhibited similar post-traumatic courses in the PaO2/FiO2 ratios with differences not becoming significant until the eleventh day after injury. We conclude that contusion is not a progressive lesion unless pneumonia supervenes and that pulmonary dysfunction after contusion is unrelated to hemodilution.

Endotoxaemia in the horse

Endotoxins are non-protein fragments of the cell wall of Gram-negative bacteria. They must be absorbed into the circulation to produce disease and systemic effects are similar, regardless of bacterial source. Absorption of endotoxins occurs in obstructive bowel disease and may play a significant part in determining the severity of the disease. Many of the responses to experimentally administered endotoxin are identical to those of bowel diseases or the horse and include circulatory, haematological and metabolic alterations. Therapeutic approaches are indirect and include many drugs currently employed in equine practice. The agents are directed toward mediators of the disease rather than the endotoxins themselves and include fluids, corticosteroids, anti-inflammatory drugs, energy sources and vasoactive drugs. The rationale for use and dosages are discussed.