Comparison of prosthetic graft materials as intracardiac right atrial patches

Tissue Engineered Materials in Cardiovascular Surgery: The Surgeon's Perspective

In cardiovascular surgery, reconstruction and replacement of cardiac and vascular structures are routinely performed. Prosthetic or biological materials traditionally used for this purpose cannot be considered ideal substitutes as they have limited durability and no growth or regeneration potential. Tissue engineering aims to create materials having normal tissue function including capacity for growth and self-repair. These advanced materials can potentially overcome the shortcomings of conventionally used materials, and, if successfully passing all phases of product development, they might provide a better option for both the pediatric and adult patient population requiring cardiovascular interventions. This short review article overviews the most important cardiovascular pathologies where tissue engineered materials could be used, briefly summarizes the main directions of development of these materials, and discusses the hurdles in their clinical translation. At its beginnings in the 1980s, tissue engineering (TE) was defined as “an interdisciplinary field that applies the principles of engineering and the life sciences toward the development of biological substitutes that restore, maintain, or improve tissue function” (1). Currently, the utility of TE products and materials are being investigated in several fields of human medicine, ranging from orthopedics to cardiovascular surgery (2–5). In cardiovascular surgery, reconstruction and replacement of cardiac and vascular structures are routinely performed. Considering the shortcomings of traditionally used materials, the need for advanced materials that can “restore, maintain or improve tissue function” are evident. Tissue engineered substitutes, having growth and regenerative capacity, could fundamentally change the specialty (6). This article overviews the most important cardiovascular pathologies where TE materials could be used, briefly summarizes the main directions of development of TE materials along with their advantages and shortcomings, and discusses the hurdles in their clinical translation.

Bioengineered tissue solutions for repair, correction and reconstruction in cardiovascular surgery

The treatment of cardiac alterations is still nowadays a dramatic issue in the cardiosurgical practice. Synthetic materials applied in this surgery have failed in their long-term therapeutic efficacy due to low biocompatibility and compliance, especially when used in contractile sites. In order to overcome these treatment pitfalls, novel solutions have been developed based on biological tissues. Patches in pericardium, small intestinal submucosa, as well as engineered tissues of myocardium, heart valves and blood vessels have undergone a large preclinical investigation in regenerative medicine studies. Clinical translation has been started or reached by several of these new bioengineered treatment alternatives. This review will describe the preclinical and clinical experiences realized so far with the application of biological tissues in cardiovascular surgery. It will depict the progressive steps realized in the evolution of this research, as well as it will point out the challenges yet to face in order to generate the ideal biomaterial for cardiovascular repair, corrective and reconstructive surgery.

Long-term outcome of direct neopulmonary artery reconstruction during the arterial switch procedure

BACKGROUND

Neopulmonary stenosis at anastomosis site is one of the most frequent complications after the arterial switch procedure for transposition of the great arteries. The surgical technique is a crucial factor associated with the frequency of stenotic complications. We present the outcomes of direct neopulmonary anastomosis during the arterial switch procedure in patients with simple transposition. This research was to assess the efficacy of this surgical technique based on the incidence of postprocedural supravalvular neopulmonary stenosis (SVPS).

METHODS

Among 545 patients operated on in our department between 1992 and 2009, the 346 consecutive survivors who had undergone simple transposition in the first month of life were included in this analysis. Switch procedures were performed with direct neopulmonary artery anastomosis in 318 patients (92%); in the remaining 28 (8%), the risk of coronary artery compression required the use of a pericardial patch for pulmonary reconstruction.

RESULTS

Neopulmonary stenosis occurred in 9 patients (2.6%): 5 had undergone direct neopulmonary reconstruction, and 4 had been treated with a patch. Balloon angioplasty of SVPS was performed twice in 1 patient. No patients required reoperation to treat neopulmonary stenosis. In multivariate analysis (logistic regression), patch reconstruction (odds ratio, 27.5; p=0.001) and nonfacing commissures (odds ratio, 11.1; p=0.004) were correlated significantly with the incidence of SVPS.

CONCLUSIONS

Direct neopulmonary artery anastomosis during arterial switch is an interesting alternative to patch reconstructions and ensures a good postoperative result with low rates of complications and SVPS.

Allergic reaction to a bovine dural substitute following spinal cord untethering. Case report

Bovine tissues are now routinely used for dural closure in cranial and spinal surgery. The authors report the case of an 18-year-old woman with a history of myelomeningocele who had symptoms of tethered cord syndrome and presented to a regional hospital. At that hospital she underwent a cord untethering procedure. The spinal dura was closed with Durepair, a dural substitute derived from fetal bovine skin. Her postoperative course was complicated by a cerebrospinal fluid leak that was surgically repaired. Following this, she developed erythroderma, intermittent fevers, eosinophilia, and marked elevation in serum immunoglobulin E. She was then transferred to the authors' institution. A skin antigen test to beef was administered, which revealed a positive reaction. A radioallergosorbent test to beef also yielded positive results. She was taken to the operating room for removal of the bovine graft due to concern for an allergic reaction to the graft. The graft material showed evidence of eosinophilic infiltration. Her clinical symptoms and laboratory values all improved after surgery. To the authors' knowledge this is the first reported case of an allergic reaction to bovine-based dural substitutes.

Crosslinking characteristics and mechanical properties of a bovine pericardium fixed with a naturally occurring crosslinking agent

Currently available crosslinking agents used in fixing bioprostheses are all highly (or relatively highly) cytotoxic, which may induce an adverse inflammatory reaction in vivo. It is therefore desirable to provide a crosslinking agent that is of low cytotoxicty and may form stable and biocompatible crosslinked products. To achieve this goal, a naturally occurring crosslinking agent-genipin-was used by our group to fix biological tissues. Genipin may be obtained from its parent compound, geniposide, which may be isolated from the fruits of Gardenia jasminoides Ellis. In our previous studies, it was found that the cytotoxicity of genipin is significantly lower than both glutaraldehyde and an epoxy compound. Also, it was shown that genipin can form stable and biocompatible crosslinked products. The present study further investigates the crosslinking characteristics and mechanical properties of a genipin-fixed bovine pericardium. Fresh and glutaraldehyde- and epoxy-fixed counterparts were used as controls. It was found that the denaturation temperatures of the glutaraldehyde- and genipin-fixed tissues were significantly greater than the epoxy-fixed tissue, although their fixation indices were comparable. The mechanical properties of fresh bovine pericardium are anisotropic. However, fixation tended to eliminate tissue anisotropy. The tendency in the elimination of tissue anisotropy for the genipin-fixed tissue was more remarkable than for the glutaraldehyde- and epoxy-fixed tissues. In addition, the genipin-fixed tissue had the greatest ultimate tensile strength and toughness among all the fixed tissues. Distinct patterns in rupture were observed in the study: The torn collagen fibers of the genipin- and glutaraldehyde-fixed tissues appeared to be bound together, while those of fresh and the epoxy-fixed tissues stayed loose. The results obtained in the study suggests that tissue fixation in glutaraldehyde, epoxy compound, and genipin may produce distinct crosslinking structures. The differences in crosslinking structure may affect the crosslinking characteristics and mechanical properties of the fixed tissues.

Bovine pericardium for dural grafts: clinical results in 35 patients

OBJECTIVE

The United States Food and Drug Administration has recently approved the marketing of bovine pericardium as a dural graft material, but literature reports of this use are limited. Bovine pericardium has been widely used for grafts in cardiac surgery and seems to have suitable properties for use as a dural graft. We report the use of glutaraldehyde-processed bovine pericardium for dural grafts in 35 patients undergoing cranial and craniospinal operations with the objective of providing a clinical assessment of this material and technique.

METHODS

This report is a retrospective analysis of 35 patients. All available records were reviewed and information regarding the indication for grafting, graft size, complications, and outcome were collected and analyzed for all patients.

RESULTS

Indications for grafting included meningioma resection, posterior fossa craniotomy, Chiari decompression, dural-based metastases, and trauma. Outcomes were good or excellent in 32 patients; the three fair or poor outcomes were not related to surgical closure. In no patient was the dural graft a significant factor in outcome. Bovine pericardium was found to be easily sutured to be watertight using standard suture material. The material is relatively inexpensive and requires no additional incision. It has low antigenicity and toxicity, good strength, and minimal elasticity.

CONCLUSION

In this clinical assessment, bovine pericardium was found to be an excellent dural graft material.

Spontaneous closure of fenestrations in an interatrial Gore-Tex patch: application to the Fontan procedure

The concept of the partial Fontan procedure, first described with the adjustable atrial septal defect (ASD) and more recently with the fenestrated technique, has become an accepted approach for the management of high-risk patients undergoing the Fontan procedure. Experience with both techniques has shown that a patent ASD placed in a prosthetic interatrial baffle may close spontaneously over a period of weeks to months. The mechanism and timing of spontaneous closure, as well as the effect of antiplatelet therapy on this process, are poorly understood. To better define this process, the interatrial septum of 15 mongrel dogs was excised and replaced with a fenestrated Gore-Tex (W.L. Gore, Flagstaff, AZ) patch. Postoperative echocardiography confirmed the patency of the ASD and left-to-right shunting. Animals were sacrificed 4 to 6 weeks postoperatively, or sooner if infection or other postoperative complications developed. Eight animals underwent no antiplatelet or anticoagulation therapy postoperatively, and 7 received antiplatelet therapy with aspirin. Patches were removed at the end of the study period and analyzed. By 6 weeks, all 2.7-mm and 4-mm holes had closed spontaneously in all animals that had not received antiplatelet therapy. The earliest closure occurred at 1 week. With antiplatelet therapy, hole closure was found to be delayed but not prevented, and was complete by 6 weeks in all but 1 animal. Histologic examination of the explanted patches revealed that closure was accomplished primarily through the ingrowth of fibrous tissue, accompanied by an inflammatory cell infiltrate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Mapping of glutaraldehyde-treated bovine pericardium and tissue selection for bioprosthetic heart valves

Glutaraldehyde-crosslinked bovine pericardium is widely used in bioprosthetic heart valve fabrication. In an attempt to set a scientific basis for more reproducible tissue selection, we produced and analyzed topographical maps of glutaraldehyde-treated bovine pericardium. Whole pericardia were divided into specific anatomical areas and their thickness was measured and mapped on templates. In each area, the suture holding power was determined in both parallel and perpendicular (to the base-apex line) directions; analyses of the tearing patterns in each fragment were used to evaluate predominant fiber orientation, and observations were confirmed by polarized light microscopy. Complete maps were superimposed graphically to aid in the selection of certain areas that would have known fiber orientation, high suture holding power, and suitable thickness. Our results describe regional heterogeneity of bovine pericardial structure and mechanical properties, specifically demonstrating variations in thickness, suture holding power, and collagen fiber orientation. Two areas of choice (representing about 35% of the total) were described as suitable for use in bioprosthetic heart valve fabrication.

Lysine-enhanced glutaraldehyde crosslinking of collagenous biomaterials

Crosslinking of collagenous biomaterials currently employs the use of glutaraldehyde. The putative enhancement of glutaraldehyde crosslinking by lysine was investigated in three model systems: bovine pericardium, collagen membranes, and bovine serum albumin. Repetitive sequential treatment of bovine pericardium with glutaraldehyde and lysine and finally with formaldehyde produced a matrix which, by the two criteria used (shrinkage temperature and urea/SDS soluble collagen), was shown to be more highly crosslinked than pericardium fixed in glutaraldehyde alone. Essentially the same results were obtained when membranes prepared from pepsin-soluble pericardial collagen were subjected to sequential glutaraldehyde and lysine treatments, reaching shrinkage temperatures of more than 90 degrees C. Heart valves prepared from lysine-enhanced glutaraldehyde crosslinked bovine pericardium were tested in vitro in an accelerated fatigue tester and have been shown to behave satisfactorily after 300 million cycles. These additional crosslinks proved to be stable in saline at 37 degrees C. Studies on bovine serum albumin attempted to get an insight into the mechanisms of lysine enhancement of glutaraldehyde crosslinking by treating sequentially albumin with glutaraldehyde and lysine and analysis of the products by gel filtration and SDS-PAGE. These studies suggest that free amino groups exposed by proteins are initially reacted with glutaraldehyde and then bridged by the diamino compound (lysine) producing more extensive intermolecular crosslinking than glutaraldehyde alone.

Partial characterization of a low molecular weight proteoglycan isolated from bovine parietal pericardium

Knowledge of the nature of pericardial connective tissue components is incomplete. To gain a better understanding of the composition of this tissue, bovine parietal pericardium was extracted with 4 M guanidine hydrochloride yielding a proteoglycan-containing protein mixture. This was fractionated by a three-step chromatographic procedure with the resultant purification of a 75-110 Kd proteoglycan. The purified proteoglycan was susceptible to chondroitinase ABC digestion but resistant to chondroitinase AC and nitrous acid degradation suggesting the presence of dermatan sulfate glycosaminoglycan(s). This is the first reported isolation of a proteoglycan from parietal pericardium.

Comparative studies of prosthetic materials in the left atrium of the dog

To assess the healing process of various intracardiac prosthetic graft materials, we inserted autologous left atrium (control), autologous pericardium (AP), bovine pericardium (BP), polytetrafluoroethylene (PTEE) and woven Dacron (WD) patches into excised defects in the left atrial wall of 15 dogs. Two patches were implanted into each heart utilizing six patches for each material. Three months after graft placement, histological examination revealed chronic inflammation and fibrosis for all materials. Dense connective tissue surrounded the grafts in which fibrosis was most prominent. Cartilage formation occurred in 11 grafts: 5 BP, 4 PTFE, 1 control and 1 AP site. This change was not evident with WD. The extent of cartilage formation was greatest in BP. Bone formation occurred in 3 BP sites. 2 PTFE and 1 control site. Quantitative calcium concentrations were similar for all of the grafts without bone formation. Calcium concentrations at sites with bone formation averaged 15.13 mg/g +/- 6.39 mg/g compared to 0.939 +/- 0.419 for sites without bone formation (p less than 0.0001). We conclude that while inflammation, fibrosis and connective tissue thickening occur with healing of all graft materials, cartilage and bone formation differ with respect to the material employed.