Clonal deletion: a mechanism of tolerance in mixed bone marrow chimeras

Induction of Chimerism in Mice Using Human MHC Class I-Mismatched Hoechst 33342 Side Population Donor Stem Cells

A population of Hoechst 33342-stained cells, termed side population (SP) cells, can reconstitute the hematopoietic system of syngeneic mice. This study examined whether limiting numbers of SP cells can repopulate mice across a xenogeneic MHC class I barrier. SP cells were isolated from HLA.B7 and HLA.A2.1 transgenic mice by FACS and placed in colony assays or transplanted into irradiated C57BL/6 (B/6) recipients. SP cells contained few colony-forming cells when placed directly in culture. The number of GM-CFC and HPP-CFC increased up to 3000- and 300-fold, respectively, after 7 days in IL-3- and SCF-stimulated liquid culture. BMC-derived GM-CFC increased up to only 12-fold and HPP-CFC decreased after 7 days in culture. HLA-B7 SP cells (2500–5000) were transplanted into lethal-irradiated B/6 mice. Two-color flow analysis, 4–6 weeks after transplantation, showed that HLA-B7 expression in granulocyte-, macrophage-, and lymphocyte-specific lineages from reconstituted mice was similar to that in B7 transgenic mice. Secondary transplanted B/6 mice also showed a pattern of HLA-B7 expression similar to that in transgenic mice and were followed for longer than 16 weeks with stable chimerism. When HLA-A2.1 SP cells were transplanted into sublethally irradiated mice, 50% of the mice expressed HLA-A2 by PCR analysis in short-term repopulation studies. These data confirm that limiting numbers of SP cells can repopulate the major hematopoietic lineages in lethal and sublethally irradiated mice across a human MHC class I barrier. Therefore, SP cells may be useful for establishing mixed chimerism, which may induce immunologic nonresponsiveness to donor antigens in solid organ transplantation.

Competitive equality of donor cells expressing a disparate MHC antigen following stem cell-enriched bone marrow transplantation

INTRODUCTION

Bone marrow cells expressing foreign MHC antigens survive poorly after transplantation. Stable mixed hematopoietic chimerism requires reconstitution with a relatively large number of foreign bone marrow cells and intensive depletion of host cells. In addition, when foreign MHC-transduced autologous bone marrow cells are transplanted, prolonged hematopoietic transgene expression requires extensive host conditioning. The competitive disadvantage associated with engraftment of donor cells expressing foreign MHC antigens is thought to result from a defect in engraftment secondary to donor-host incompatibility or immunologic resistance by the host.

METHODS

We used a limiting-dilution competitive repopulation assay with cells from HLA-A2.1 transgenic mice to determine whether and to what extent foreign MHC antigen expression impairs engraftment in C57BL/6 hosts. Transplants were performed with Hoechst 33342 fluorescence-sorted side population (SP) cells, a subset of bone marrow enriched for stem cells. RESULTS.: Transplantation with 250 stem cell-enriched HLA-A2.1-transgenic side population cells successfully competed with nearly 5000 host C57BL/6 side population cells to produce stable long-term mixed chimerism. There was a direct relationship between the number of transplanted donor HLA-A2-expressing cells and the percentage of HLA-A2-expressing cells in the peripheral blood of reconstituted C57BL/6 mice (r2=0.1799, P=0.031). This correlation was maintained in secondary transplant recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

HLA-A2-expressing hematopoietic cells do not have an engraftment defect when transplanted into C57BL/6 hosts and immunologic resistance did not limit chimerism following lethal irradiation. These results may have relevance to understanding long-term gene expression after hematopoietic stem cell based gene therapy.

Long-term (>1 year) analyses of chimerism and tolerance in mixed allogeneic chimeric mice using normal mouse combinations

We examined the induction of tolerance using pancreas allografts over the long term (>1 year) in mice for the human application of mixed allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). T cell-depleted BM cells (BMCs) of C57BL/6 (B6) and C3H/He (C3H) mice were transplanted at various ratios into lethally irradiated B6 mice. The percentages of C3H cells in the chimeric mice gradually decreased, finally declining to only a small percentage, except when the ratio of donor to recipient BMCs was 100:1. However, despite the marked decreases in C3H-type cells, all the pancreas allografts of C3H mice were accepted when more than 1% C3H cells were detected in the peripheral blood. To examine the relationships between percentages of transplanted donor cells and acceptance of pancreas allografts, various percentages of donor and recipient BMCs (5% to 30%) were transplanted. It was found that more than 10% donor cells were necessary for the pancreas allografts to be accepted. In vitro assays for mixed lymphocyte reaction and generation of cytotoxic T-lymphocytes revealed that spleen cells in chimeric mice accepting pancreas allografts are tolerant to both host-type and donor-type major histocompatibility complex (MHC) determinants, but show a vigorous responsiveness to third-party MHC determinants. Since donor-type hemopoietic stem cells (HSCs) were detected in the BM and the liver of the chimeric mice, donor-derived HSCs and donor-derived hematolymphoid cells are responsible for the induction of tolerance. It should be noted that the percentage of donor-type HSCs is higher in the liver (6.2%) than in the BM (0.9%).

Hepatocyte transplantation in rats with decompensated cirrhosis

Hepatocyte transplantation improves the survival of laboratory animals with experimentally induced acute liver failure and the physiological abnormalities associated with liver-based metabolic deficiencies. The role of hepatocyte transplantation in treating decompensated liver cirrhosis, however, has not been studied in depth. To address this issue, cirrhosis was induced using phenobarbital and carbon tetrachloride (CCL(4)) and animals were studied only when evidence of liver failure did not improve when CCL(4) was held for 4 weeks. Animals received intrasplenic transplantation of syngeneic rat hepatocytes (G1); intraperitoneal transplantation of syngeneic rat hepatocytes (G2); intraperitoneal transplantation of a cellular homogenate of syngeneic rat hepatocytes (G3); intraperitoneal transplantation of syngeneic rat bone marrow cells (G4); or intrasplenic injection of Dulbecco's modified Eagle medium (DMEM) (G5). After transplantation, body weight and serum albumin levels deteriorated over time in all control (G2-G5) animals but did not deteriorate in animals receiving intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation (G1) (P <.01). Prothrombin time (PT), total bilirubin, serum ammonia, and hepatic encephalopathy score were also significantly improved toward normal in animals receiving intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation (P <. 01). More importantly, survival was prolonged after a single infusion of hepatocytes and a second infusion prolonged survival from 15 to 128 days (P <.01). Thus, hepatocyte transplantation can improve liver function and prolong the survival of rats with irreversible, decompensated cirrhosis and may be useful in the treatment of cirrhosis in humans.

Treatment of surgically induced acute liver failure by transplantation of conditionally immortalized hepatocytes

The shortage of human livers available for hepatocyte isolation limits its clinical application. The availability of cloned, conditionally immortalized hepatocytes that could be grown in culture but would lose their transformed phenotype and provide metabolic support upon transplantation would greatly facilitate the treatment of acute liver failure. Toward this goal, we transduced isolated Lewis rat hepatocytes using a replication-defective recombinant retrovirus capable of transferring a gene encoding a thermolabile mutant simian virus 40 T antigen (SV40ts). The cloned, immortalized hepatocytes proliferate at 33 degrees C. At the nonpermissive temperatures (37-39 degrees C), they stop growing and exhibit characteristics of differentiated hepatocytes. These cells did not produce tumors when transplanted in mice with severe combined immunodeficiency disease or in syngeneic rats. To induce acute liver failure, Lewis rats were subjected to 90% hepatectomy (Hpx) and given 5% oral dextrose. All rats that did not undergo hepatocyte transplantation died within 96 hr. Fifty percent of rats that received intrasplenic injection of 10 x 10(6) primary Lewis rat hepatocytes (G2, n=6) or 10 x 10(6) SV40ts-conditionally immortalized (SV40ts-ci) hepatocytes (G3, n=8) 1 day before 90% hepatectomy survived, whereas 80% of rats that received an intraperitoneal injection of 200 x 10(6) primary Lewis rat hepatocytes (G4, n=10) or 200 x 10(6) SV40ts-ci hepatocytes (G5, n=10) on the day of hepatectomy survived. Survival after intraperitoneal injection of a cellular homogenate of 200 x 10(6) primary Lewis rat (G7, n=9) or SV40ts-ci hepatocytes (G8, n=10) on the day of Hpx was 33% and 40%, respectively, whereas survival after intraperitoneal injection of 200 x 10(6) Lewis rat bone marrow cells (G6, n=7) was 29%. Thus, transplanted, conditionally immortalized hepatocytes can be as effective as primary hepatocytes in supporting life during acute liver insufficiency. This work represents the first step in developing an hepatocyte cell line that would partially alleviate the organ-donor shortage and could be of potential clinical value.

Use of gene therapy to suppress the antigen-specific immune responses in mice to an HLA antigen

Hematopoietic chimerism has been used in the laboratory to induce life-long immunologic tolerance to donor antigens. The present study demonstrates that mice transplanted with autologous bone marrow cells retrovirally transduced to express HLA-A2.1 develop a significantly depressed immune response to this antigen while retaining normal reactivity to HLA-B7. Retrovirus-mediated transduction was performed using whole bone marrow-producer cell coculture. This approach did not result in significant gene transfer into hematopoietic progenitor cells. Despite this, the antibody response to HLA-A2.1 in mice reconstituted with genetically modified BMC was completely suppressed three months following bone marrow transplantation. Cell-mediated immunity to HLA-A2.1 was partially suppressed in three-fourths of animals tested three months later, although one animal had a CTL profile similar to that an of HLA-A2.1 transgenic mouse. Complete suppression of the antibody-mediated immune response occurred when only one-third of mice had evidence of the introduced genes in their spleen and one-tenth had the introduced sequences in their circulating WBCs by PCR. In conclusion, engineering of BMC to express donor MHC genes may be an alternative to xenogeneic BMT to induce chimerism and tolerance. More efficient transduction of bone marrow progenitor cells may result in more persistent gene expression and long-lasting transplantation tolerance in recipients of genetically modified bone marrow. Successful application of this technology may also be useful in altering immune responses to other external and self antigens.