Behavioral tolerance to repeated apomorphine administration in parkinsonian monkeys

Development and characterization of a non-human primate model of disseminated synucleinopathy

Introduction

The presence of a widespread cortical synucleinopathy is the main neuropathological hallmark underlying clinical entities such as Parkinson's disease with dementia (PDD) and dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB). There currently is a pressing need for the development of non-human primate (NHPs) models of PDD and DLB to further overcome existing limitations in drug discovery.

Methods

Here we took advantage of a retrogradely-spreading adeno-associated viral vector serotype 9 coding for the alpha-synuclein A53T mutated gene (AAV9-SynA53T) to induce a widespread synucleinopathy of cortical and subcortical territories innervating the putamen. Four weeks post-AAV deliveries animals were sacrificed and a comprehensive biodistribution study was conducted, comprising the quantification of neurons expressing alpha-synuclein, rostrocaudal distribution and their specific location.

Results

Intraputaminal deliveries of AAV9-SynA53T lead to a disseminated synucleinopathy throughout ipsi- and contralateral cerebral cortices, together with transduced neurons located in the ipsilateral caudal intralaminar nuclei and in the substantia nigra pars compacta (leading to thalamostriatal and nigrostriatal projections, respectively). Cortical afferent systems were found to be the main contributors to putaminal afferents (superior frontal and precentral gyri in particular).

Discussion

Obtained data extends current models of synucleinopathies in NHPs, providing a reproducible platform enabling the adequate implementation of end-stage preclinical screening of new drugs targeting alpha-synuclein.

Visualizing advances in the future of primate neuroscience research

Future neuroscience and biomedical projects involving non-human primates (NHPs) remain essential in our endeavors to understand the complexities and functioning of the mammalian central nervous system. In so doing, the NHP neuroscience researcher must be allowed to incorporate state-of-the-art technologies, including the use of novel viral vectors, gene therapy and transgenic approaches to answer continuing and emerging research questions that can only be addressed in NHP research models. This perspective piece captures these emerging technologies and some specific research questions they can address. At the same time, we highlight some current caveats to global NHP research and collaborations including the lack of common ethical and regulatory frameworks for NHP research, the limitations involving animal transportation and exports, and the ongoing influence of activist groups opposed to NHP research.

The spectrum of "off" in Parkinson's disease: What have we learned over 40 years?

The terms "on" and "off" were used by Marsden and his contemporaries over 40 years ago to describe times when Parkinson's disease patients experienced good motor function ("on") and immobility ("off"). Yet there remains no published consensus definition of "off", leading clinicians and patients to develop individualized impressions of "off" determinations. In this paper, we first discuss the evolution of the terminology and understanding of "off" states since Marsden's time, which now include non-motor as well as motor symptoms. We then review pathophysiology and risk factors for the development of "off" states as well as tools to detect the "off" state, before proposing a practical definition of "off" for consideration. A common, practical definition of the "off" state could improve clinical recognition of "off" symptoms and lead to significant benefit for patients.

Levodopa in the treatment of Parkinson's disease: an old drug still going strong

After more than 40 years of clinical use, levodopa (LD) remains the gold standard of symptomatic efficacy in the drug treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD). Compared with other available dopaminergic therapies, dopamine replacement with LD is associated with the greatest improvement in motor function. Long-term treatment with LD is, however, often complicated by the development of various types of motor response oscillations over the day, as well as drug-induced dyskinesias. Motor fluctuations can be improved by the addition of drugs such as entacapone or monoamine oxidase inhibitors, which extend the half-life of levodopa or dopamine, respectively. However, dyskinesia control still represents a major challenge. As a result, many neurologists have become cautious when prescribing therapy with LD. This review summarizes the available evidence regarding the use of LD to treat PD and will also address the issue of LD delivery as a critical factor for the drug's propensity to induce motor complications.

The duration of the motor response to apomorphine boluses is conditioned by the length of a prior infusion in Parkinson's disease

"Pulsatile" administration of levodopa has been invocated a relevant factor for motor fluctuations in Parkinson's disease (PD). We studied dopaminergic sensitivity to apomorphine in 10 parkinsonian patients with motor fluctuations. Patients were tested as follows: the minimal effective dose of apomorphine (MED-1) was administered in the morning to induce an on response. Fifteen minutes after this motor response had disappeared, an apomorphine infusion was initiated and maintained to ensure on periods of three different durations on different days. Infusion lasted for approximately 30, 60 and 90 minutes. Subsequently, the infusion was stopped, and after 15 minutes in the off state, a second bolus of apomorphine (MED-2) was given. The mean infusion doses were 49.2 +/- 5.4, 108.4 +/- 10.3, and 150 +/- 8.2 mg. These elicited on periods of 48.2 +/- 4.1, 110 +/- 4.5, and 195 +/- 3.8 minutes. The MED-2 elicited on responses with a duration of 30 +/- 4.5, 18.4 +/- 3.2, and 11.2 +/- 4.1 minutes. The duration of the on response induced by the apomorphine infusions correlated inversely (P < 0.01) with the on induced by the MED-2 of apomorphine. Our findings indicate that a continuous dopaminergic stimulus may induce pharmacodynamic changes associated with tolerance in PD patients.

The number of dopaminergic cells is increased in the olfactory bulb of monkeys chronically exposed to MPTP

We investigated the impact of the nigrostriatal lesion on the olfactory tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactive (TH-ir) cells in monkeys. The majority of these TH-ir cells appeared in the glomerular layer of the olfactory bulb and many were immature but functional dopaminergic neurons. In parkinsonian monkeys the number of olfactory dopaminergic neurons increased up to 100% as compared to controls, but their phenotype did not change. This increased TH-ir cell population might be a direct consequence of the nigral cell loss and contribute to the hyposmia reported by Parkinson's disease patients.

New striatal dopamine neurons in MPTP-treated macaques result from a phenotypic shift and not neurogenesis

We investigated whether there is neurogenesis in the striatum of aged monkeys, and whether dopamine (DA) depletion induces the genesis of new DA neurons in this structure. Six aged macaques received repeated intraperitoneal injections of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) over a 3 week period to label dividing cells. Three macaques were injected in parallel with the neurotoxin 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) to decrease dopaminergic innervation of the striatum. The brains were analysed 3 weeks after the last BrdU injection. In MPTP-treated aged macaques, the number of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) immunoreactive (ir) striatal neurons increased 2.3-fold compared with controls. These TH-ir striatal cells did not express dopamine beta hydroxylase (DBH) but the dopamine transporter (DAT), suggesting that they are functional DA neurons. They were also negative for calbindin (CB), neuropeptide Y (NPY) and parvalbumin (PV), and a small proportion expressed calretinin (CR). This suggests that these cells stained for TH are interneurons. All these cells also co-expressed glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD). They thus resemble the small, aspiny, GABAergic interneurons. None of the BrdU-labelled cells in the striatum expressed the neuronal markers neuronal nuclei (NeuN), or GAD or TH, and none of TH-ir cells incorporated BrdU. These data indicate that neurogenesis did not occur in the striatum of aged macaques. The new striatal TH-ir neurons observed after DA depletion was therefore derived from pre-existing GABAergic interneurons. Understanding of the molecular signals mediating this phenotypic shift might help in developing novel and elegant strategies for a cell-based therapy for Parkinson's disease that would avoid many of the drawbacks of cell transplantation.

Changes in vascularization in substantia nigra pars compacta of monkeys rendered parkinsonian

The degeneration of nigral dopaminergic neurons in Parkinson's disease is believed to be associated with a glial reaction and inflammatory changes. In turn, local factors may induce changes in vascularization and contribute to neuronal vulnerability. Among these factors, Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) is released in adults under pathological conditions and is thought to induce angiogenesis. In order to determine whether changes in brain vasculature are observed in the affected brain regions in parkinsonism, we quantitatively analysed the VEGF-expressing cells and blood vessels in the substantia nigra of monkeys rendered parkinsonian by MPTP injection and compared the results with those obtained in control monkeys. Using stereological methods, we observed an increase in the number of VEGF-expressing neurons and an increase of the number of blood vessels and their volume occupying the substantia nigra pars compacta of monkeys rendered parkinsonian by chronic MPTP intoxication. These changes in vascularization may therefore modify the neuronal availability of blood nutrients, blood cells or toxic substances and neuronal susceptibility to parkinsonism.

Both short- and long-acting D-1/D-2 dopamine agonists induce less dyskinesia than L-DOPA in the MPTP-lesioned common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus)

The current concept of dyskinesia is that pulsatile stimulation of D-1 or D-2 receptors by L-DOPA or short-acting dopamine agonists is more likely to induce dyskinesia compared to long-acting drugs producing more continuous receptor stimulation. We now investigate the ability of two mixed D-1/D-2 agonists, namely pergolide (long-acting) and apomorphine (short-acting), to induce dyskinesia in drug-nai;ve MPTP-lesioned primates, compared to L-DOPA. Adult common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) were lesioned with MPTP (2 mg/kg/day sc for 5 days) and subsequently treated with equieffective antiparkinsonian doses of L-DOPA, apomorphine, or pergolide for 28 days. L-DOPA, apomorphine, and pergolide reversed the MPTP-induced motor deficits to the same degree with no difference in peak response. L-DOPA and apomorphine had a rapid onset of action and short duration of effect producing a pulsatile motor response, while pergolide had a slow onset and long-lasting activity producing a continuous profile of motor stimulation. L-DOPA rapidly induced dyskinesia that increased markedly in severity and frequency over the course of the study, impairing normal motor activity by day 20. Dyskinesia in animals treated with pergolide or apomorphine increased steadily, reaching mild to moderate severity but remaining significantly less marked than that produced by L-DOPA. There was no difference in the intensity of dyskinesia produced by apomorphine and pergolide. These data suggest that factors other than duration of drug action may be important in the induction of dyskinesia but support the use of dopamine agonists in early Parkinson's disease, as a means of delaying L-DOPA therapy and reducing the risk of developing dyskinesia.

Diurnal motor variations to repeated doses of levodopa in Parkinson's disease

Patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) in long-term levodopa therapy often complain of worsening of motor symptoms in the afternoon and evening. The pathophysiology of this phenomenon is not known. We evaluated the motor response to repeated doses of levodopa during a 12-hour period in 52 parkinsonian patients (19 de novo, 20 stable, and 13 wearing-off). On the day of the study, all patients received standard doses of levodopa/carbidopa at 8:00 a.m., 12:00 noon, and 4:00 p.m. Motor measurements such as tapping test, walking time, and tremor score, and blood samples for levodopa and 3-O-methyldopa (3OMD) plasma analysis, were performed hourly. Mean motor scores and pharmacokinetic data, evaluated for a period of 3 hours after each levodopa dose, were compared. In de novo patients, we did not observe diurnal changes in motor score, whereas a progressive daytime worsening was visible in stable and wearing-off patients. No significant difference in levodopa pharmacokinetics after each levodopa dose was observed within each patient group, whereas 3OMD plasma levels significant increased with repeated levodopa administrations. However, no significant correlation between motor scores and 3OMD plasma levels was observed, suggesting that the diminishing motor response to afternoon and evening doses of levodopa in patients in long-term levodopa therapy does not relate to the pharmacokinetics of the drug. It is possible that this phenomenon may be an expression of the occurrence of tolerance to repeated doses of levodopa.

Dopamine D1 receptor desensitization profile in MPTP-lesioned primates

The motor effects of dopamine D1 receptor activation and the optimal way to stimulate these receptors were studied in a primate model of parkinsonism induced by the neurotoxin 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP), using 2 selective full dopamine D1 receptor agonists: A-77636 ([1 R,3S] 3-(1'-adamantyl)-1-aminomethyl-3,4-dihydro-5,6-dihydroxy-1 H-2-benzopyran hydrochloride), and SKF 82958 (6-chloro-7,8-dihydroxy-3-allyl-1-phenyl-2,3,4,5-tetrahydro-1 H-3-benzazepine hydrobromide). A-77636 was administered to one group of primed monkeys (N = 4) previously treated with levodopa and other dopamine receptor agonists, while SKF 82958 was given to another group of drug-naive monkeys (N = 3). These drugs have different durations of efficacy, lasting > 20 h and approximately 1 h, respectively, and were administered once daily (A-77636) or thrice daily (SKF 82958) for 7 days. Both drugs demonstrated excellent antiparkinsonian efficacy and locomotor stimulation. However, a rapid, functionally important, homologous (selective for D1 receptor agonists) desensitization process took place as early as on the second day with the longer-acting drug and a dose escalation of A-77636 failed to restore the initial benefit. Thrice daily dosing at a 4-h interval with the short-acting agent SKF 82958 maintained the maximal antiparkinsonian response but some shortening in the duration of response was observed after several days. These behavioral results show that dopamine D1 receptors are susceptible to desensitization after prolonged occupancy and can be desensitized profoundly and independently of dopamine D2 receptors in vivo in this model. Potent dopamine D1 receptor agonists with an intermediate half-life may prove to be better adjuncts in the treatment of Parkinson's disease. Clinical entities with pathologically enhanced dopamine D1 receptor-linked neural transmission might eventually also benefit from such desensitization.

A study of tolerance to apomorphine

1. The present study was designed to investigate tolerance to several pharmacological effects of apomorphine. 2. Changes in blood pressure, heart rate, plasma noradrenaline levels, rectal temperature, respiratory rate and retching plus vomiting were compared after administration of apomorphine (200 micrograms kg-1, i.v. as a bolus) or saline at different time intervals (30, 120 and 720 min) in four groups of chloralose-anaesthetized dogs. 3. The first administration of apomorphine induced a significant decrease in blood pressure and rectal temperature, a marked rise in heart rate with no change in noradrenaline plasma levels or respiratory rate. Emesis occurred in 71% of the animals. 4. A second administration of apomorphine 30 min later failed to modify blood pressure or heart rate. In contrast, the magnitude of apomorphine-induced changes in blood pressure and heart rate was similar to that observed after the first administration when apomorphine was given 120 or 720 min later. 5. The apomorphine-induced decrease in rectal temperature evoked by a second dose of apomorphine was less marked when given 30 and 120 min after the first dose and unchanged when given 720 min later. 6. The number of animals exhibiting retching and vomiting was lower when apomorphine was reinjected after 30 min than when the time between two successive injections of apomorphine was 120 or 720 min. 7. These results show that tolerance to apomorphine involves its cardiovascular, hypothermic and emetic effects. The time course of tolerance to repeated injections of apomorphine is longer for its hypothermic than for its hypotensive or emetic effects. This suggests a tissue-specific regulation of D2 dopamine receptors to repeated injections of apomorphine.

The role of pulsatile versus continuous dopamine receptor stimulation for functional recovery in Parkinson's disease

More effective measures to control and replace the dopaminergic deficit of Parkinson's disease are being actively sought. One basic problem is how the striatal dopamine loss should be replaced in order to mimic most accurately the physiological state. Animal electrophysiology indicates that the dopaminergic nigrostriatal pathway has a dual tonic and phasic action. Intermittent dopaminergic stimulation is associated with behavioural hyposensitivity both in animal models and in patients with Parkinson's disease. Continuous dopaminergic stimulation provides a tonic background and improves some clinical problems but is also associated with tolerance. None of the available pharmacological approaches can restore the dopamine deficiency of Parkinson's disease to physiological levels. Continuous dopaminergic stimulation for < 24 h, associated with small doses of levodopa or a short-acting dopamine agonist, appears to be the best, albeit imperfect, therapeutic approach until other, more efficacious remedies are developed.