Effects of chemical and physical mutagens on the frequency of a large genetic duplication in Salmonella typhimurium. I. Induction of duplications

Gene amplification and adaptive evolution in bacteria

Gene duplication-amplification (GDA) processes are highly relevant biologically because they generate extensive and reversible genetic variation on which adaptive evolution can act. Whenever cellular growth is restricted, escape from these growth restrictions often occurs by GDA events that resolve the selective problem. In addition, GDA may facilitate subsequent genetic change by allowing a population to grow and increase in number, thereby increasing the probability for subsequent adaptive mutations to occur in the amplified genes or in unrelated genes. Mathematical modeling of the effect of GDA on the rate of adaptive evolution shows that GDA will facilitate adaptation, especially when the supply of mutations in the population is rate-limiting. GDA can form via several mechanisms, both RecA-dependent and RecA-independent, including rolling-circle amplification and nonequal crossing over between sister chromatids. Due to the high intrinsic instability and fitness costs associated with GDAs, they are generally transient in nature, and consequently their evolutionary and medical importance is often underestimated.

Tandem duplications of the lac region of the Escherichia coli chromosome

Tandem duplications are caused by unequal crossing over between homologous sequences. Duplications in the lac region of the Escherichia coli chromosome were isolated by two methods. Duplication frequency using a method involving P1 transduction increased from 0.4% with no UV to 2.0% following UV irradiation at 35 J/m2. Duplication frequency in lac using a second generalizable method that does not involve P1 transduction increased from 0.7 to 12% at 35 J/m2 UV. In both cases the duplication frequency began to plateau at UV doses of 12 J/m2 and 24 J/m2. According to segregation analysis of sixteen duplications there may be at least seven classes of duplications isolated by each method. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis was used to measure the duplications isolated without P1 transduction. The minimum size of the duplications ranged from 30 to 320 kb but could be much larger.

Induction of genetic duplications and frameshift mutations in Salmonella typhimurium by acridines and acridine mustards: dependence on covalent binding of the mutagen to DNA

The aroC321 allele permits positive selection for the detection of a large genetic duplication that arises in the Salmonella typhimurium chromosome by homologous recombination. Strains that contain both aroC321 and the hisC3076 allele were constructed so that the induction of genetic duplications and frameshift mutations in a run of GC base pairs could be studied simultaneously by selecting for tryptophan and histidine prototrophy, respectively. Using these strains, we examined the ability of 9-aminoacridine, quinacrine, four acridine mustards (ICR-170, ICR-191, ICR-372, and quinacrine mustard) and the nitroacridine Entozon to induce genetic duplications and frameshift mutations. Although all these compounds induce reversion of hisC3076, only the four mustards and Entozon are effective as inducers of genetic duplications under identical treatment conditions. The induction of genetic duplications by acridine mustards, like the toxic and mutagenic effects of these compounds, is enhanced by a deficiency for excision repair caused by a deletion through the uvr B gene. The ineffectiveness of 9-aminoacridine and quinacrine in the test for genetic duplications indicates that simple intercalation is sufficient for the mutagenic effect measured with the hisC3076 allele but that the induction of duplications by the acridine mustards and Entozon requires covalent binding of the chemical to DNA.

Pure exogenous singlet oxygen: nonmutagenicity in bacteria

Singlet oxygen (1 delta gO2) is the lowest energy-excited state of molecular oxygen, and more reactive than the triplet ground-state molecule. Although singlet oxygen has been implicated in a variety of biological effects, including reactions with DNA or some of its components, evidence for mutagenesis by singlet oxygen has remained unclear. We have previously described a system for bacterial exposure to pure exogenous singlet oxygen that eliminates ambiguity regarding the identity of the reactive species responsible for observed results. Despite the potent toxicity of pure singlet oxygen for several different strains of bacteria, we have found no evidence for mutagenicity of singlet oxygen in 26 Salmonella typhimurium histidine-auxotrophic strains killed to 35% survival. These strains included a variety of base-pair substitution or frameshift target sequences for reversion, including targets responsive to oxidative damage and targets rich in GC base pairs. Some strains combined histidine mutations with one or more mutations affecting DNA-repair capacity. 4 strains possessing the hisG46 mutation also were not mutated when exposed to dose ranges killing less than 28% and up to 99% of the bacteria. The relative frequency of small inphase deletions was assayed in hisG428 bacteria exposed to single oxygen and found to be the same as the spontaneous level. In addition to lack of induction of mutation in these strains, the 8-azaguanine forward mutation assay yielded no evidence of mutagenesis by singlet oxygen in strains killed to 15% survival. No induction of genetic changes by singlet oxygen was seen in an assay for duplication of approximately 1/3 of the bacterial chromosome. Tests for the ability of singlet oxygen to induce lambda prophage in E. coli K12 also proved negative. These studies collectively indicate that pure singlet oxygen generated outside the bacterial cell does not react significantly with the bacterial chromosome in ways leading to base-pair substitutions, frameshift mutations, small or large deletions, large duplications, or damage that interferes with DNA replication and induces the SOS system.

Induction of genetic tandem duplications in Salmonella by polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon and amine carcinogens

6 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon or similar amine carcinogens were tested as inducers of genetic tandem duplications in a rough strain of Salmonella typhimurium. When metabolically activated by rat-liver microsomes, all 6 were active in inducing genetic tandem duplications, yielding from over 3 times to almost 14 times as many tandem duplicants per viable bacterium as did concurrent uninduced control cultures. These results extend the number and chemical diversity of carcinogens shown to induce genetic duplications in bacterial tester systems. We suggest that polycyclic hydrocarbon carcinogens may act in carcinogenesis by inducing genetic duplications or other genetic rearrangements. Duplication induction may be a useful genetic endpoint for screening potential carcinogens.

Lowered induction of genetic tandem duplications in Salmonella by the pKM101 plasmid

Selection for 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole (AT) resistance in certain strains of Salmonella typhimurium has been previously shown to select for genetic tandem duplications of the histidine operon. We show here that agents which induce tandem duplications are less effective in such induction in the presence of the pKM101 plasmid. The presence of the plasmid also produces an increase in AT-resistance due to mechanisms other than duplication, presumably because pKM101 produces high levels of error-prone repair. We suggest that high levels of error-prone repair may cause decreases in tandem duplication induction and propose that error-prone repair and tandem duplication may be alternative cellular responses to certain DNA lesions.

Carcinogens induce genetic tandem duplications in Salmonella

Extensive studies have shown that chemical carcinogenesis involves an initiation-promotion pattern. A gene amplification model of carcinogenesis predicts that initiation involves induction of a genetic tandem duplication. We use a system developed by Anderson and Roth to select for tandem duplication of the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium by selection for resistance to 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole. Evidence reported here shows that, consistent with prediction, 10 carcinogens are all active in inducing tandem duplications. Two toxic noncarcinogens show little or no activity under the conditions used in inducing tandem duplication but azide, a mutagenic noncarcinogen, did show some activity. 9 types of evidence now support the gene amplification initiation-promotion model of carcinogenesis.

Effects of DNA-repair processes on the induction of genetic duplications in bacteria by ultraviolet light

A straightforward positive selection for genetic duplication is possible in strains of Salmonella typhimurium that carry the aroC321 allele. Strains with a single copy of this allele require phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan for growth. Such strains give rise to tryptophan prototrophs, which still require phenylalanine and tyrosine, through the formation of a duplication that includes about 30% of the chromosome. We have constructed strains that permit the simultaneous study of duplications and mutations and have used these strains to explore the effects of DNA repair processes on the induction of duplications by ultraviolet light (UV). UV causes dose-dependent increases in the frequency of duplications in bacteria. The exposure required to induce duplications is much less in a delta uvrB strain than in repair-proficient strains, suggesting that duplications result from DNA lesions that are subject to excision repair. The photoreversibility of UV-induced preduplication lesions implicates pyrimidine dimers in the induction of duplications. Unlike its effect on the induction of mutations, the error-prone repair process associated with plasmid pKM101 does not enhance the induction of duplications. The prevention of duplication-formation by a recA mutation suggests that the formation of duplications involves recombinational events. Taken together, the data indicate that the same DNA lesions can be mutagenic and recombinagenic in bacteria, but that the two effects involve different pathways of processing DNA damage.

Genetic duplications in bacteria and their relevance for genetic toxicology

Tandem genetic duplications of various lengths occur at high frequency and at many chromosomal locations in bacteria. Most duplications are formed and lost by recombinational mechanisms. Since they readily give rise to haploid segregants, duplications are characteristically unstable. Various selection procedures permit measurements of duplication frequencies, and several mutagens have been shown to induce the formation of duplications in haploid bacteria and the loss of duplications from merodiploid bacteria. Although the data base is not extensive, it includes agents that interact with DNA by a variety of molecular mechanisms. Grounds on which the induction of genetic duplications in bacteria can be relevant for genetic toxicology are discussed.

Genetic instability associated with the aroC321 allele in Salmonella typhimurium involves genetic duplication

Strains of Salmonella typhimurium that contain the aroC321 allele require phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan for growth but revert to tryptophan-prototrophy at high frequencies (about 10(-4) per cell plated). The Trp+ derivatives remain auxotrophic for phenylalanine and tyrosine and are genetically unstable, in that they readily give rise to cells that require all three aromatic amino acids. On the basis of growth characteristics and genetic instability, it has been proposed that reversion to tryptophan-prototrophy in aroC321 strains occurs by genetic duplication. This paper provides genetic evidence in support of that hypothesis. The data indicate, moreover, that the tryptophan prototrophs contain a duplication that extends at least from glpT to xyl, a region of greater than 30% of the Salmonella chromosome. The aroC locus is found within the duplicated region, and aroC321/aroC321 merodiploids apparently grow as tryptophan prototrophs because of a gene-dosage effect.

Genetic effects of dimethyl sulfate, diethyl sulfate, and related compounds

DMS and DES are monofunctional alkylating agents that have been shown to induce mutations, chromosomal aberrations, and other genetic alterations in a diversity of organisms. They have also been shown to be carcinogenic in animals. As an alkylating agent, DMS is a typical SN2 agent, attacking predominantly nitrogen sites in nucleic acids. DES is capable of SN1 alkylations as well as SN2 and thereby causes some alkylation on oxygen sites including the O6-position of guanine which is thought to be significant in mutagenesis by direct mispairing. The mutagenicity of DMS is better explained in terms of indirect, repair-dependent processes. With respect to both alkylating activity and genetic effects, striking similarities are found between DMS and MMS and between DES and EMS. In most systems where they have been tested, both DMS and DES are mutagenic. Results of many of the mutagenesis studies involving these compounds and other alkylating sulfuric acid esters are summarized in Tables 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 of this review. Most data are consistent with these agents acting primarily as base-pair substitution mutagens. In the case of DES, strong specificity for G.C to A.T transitions has been reported in some systems but has not been clearly supported in some others. Low levels of frameshift mutations of the deletion type are also likely. In addition to the induction of mutations, recombinogenic and clastogenic effects have been described.

Effects of chemical and physical mutagens on the frequency of a large genetic duplication in Salmonella typhimurium. II. Stimulation of duplication-loss from merodiploids

Strains of Salmonella typhimurium which contain a duplication of approximately 30% of the genome may be obtained by a simple selective procedure. These strains are highly unstable, losing the duplication when grown on non-selective medium. In this paper we report that treatment of merodiploid bacteria with mutagenic agents stimulates the rate at which haploid segregants are obtained from merodiploid strains. The mutagens which have been tested for this effect are X-rays, ultraviolet light (UV), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), and the azaacridine half-mustard ICR-372.