Directed mutation: paradigm postponed

Mathematical issues arising from the directed mutation controversy

During the past 14 years or so a large body of new evidence that supposedly supports the directed mutation hypothesis has accumulated. Interpretation of some of the evidence depends on mathematical reasoning, which can be subtler than it appears at first sight. This article attempts to clarify some of the mathematical issues arising from the directed mutation controversy, thereby offering alternative interpretations of some of the evidence.

Induction of the SOS response in starved Escherichia coli

The SOS system in Escherichia coli is induced in response to DNA damage and the arrest of DNA synthesis. Here we show that in AB1157 bacteria starved for arginine, conditions for induction of adaptive mutations, the LexA-dependent SOS system is induced, but that this occurs only when the bacteria resume growth and when the source of carbon is glycerol rather than glucose (glycerol, but not glucose, enables synthesis of cAMP). Therefore, we conclude that starved cells accumulate some lesions in DNA, which in growth conditions may trigger SOS induction by a process that is cAMP-dependent.

Glucose and related catabolite repressors are powerful inhibitors of pKM101-enhanced UV mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

When stationary phase Escherichia coli K12 trp (amber) cells were exposed to UV doses ranging from 180-540 J m(-2), we found that we could not recover any induced Trp+ revertants unless the irradiated cultures were first supplied with the Muc+ mutation-enhancing IncP plasmid pKM101 (by conjugation). We also found that the numbers of UV-induced Trp+ revertants recovered from pKM101+ cultures varied quite dramatically depending upon which of several commonly-used carbon sources were present in the post-irradiation plating medium, e.g., there were always significantly fewer revertants on minimal glucose plates than on minimal glycerol plates. More importantly, there were also fewer UV-induced revertants on glycerol + glucose plates than on 'glycerol-only' plates. We then tested two glucose-related compounds which are known to depress intracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) levels even more effectively than glucose (glucose-6-phosphate and the non-utilisable methyl-alpha-D-glucopyranoside) and found that they too were able to exert powerfully antimutagenic effects in UV-treated pKM101-containing bacteria. Taken together, these results provide strong additional support for our working hypothesis that at least one component of the mutational pathway which operates in UV-irradiated pKM101-containing cells is extremely sensitive to classical cAMP-mediated catabolite repression.

Mechanism and control of interspecies recombination in Escherichia coli. I. Mismatch repair, methylation, recombination and replication functions

A genetic analysis of interspecies recombination in Escherichia coli between the linear Hfr DNA from Salmonella typhimurium and the circular recipient chromosome reveals some fundamental aspects of recombination between related DNA sequences. The MutS and MutL mismatch binding proteins edit (prevent) homeologous recombination between these 16% diverged genomes by at least two distinct mechanisms. One is MutH independent and presumably acts by aborting the initiated recombination through the UvrD helicase activity. The RecBCD nuclease might contribute to this editing step, presumably by preventing reiterated initiations of recombination at a given locus. The other editing mechanism is MutH dependent, requires unmethylated GATC sequences, and probably corresponds to an incomplete long-patch mismatch repair process that does not depend on UvrD helicase activity. Insignificant effects of the Dam methylation of parental DNAs suggest that unmethylated GATC sequences involved in the MutH-dependent editing are newly synthesized in the course of recombination. This hypothetical, recombination-associated DNA synthesis involves PriA and RecF functions, which, therefore, determine the extent of MutH effect on interspecies recombination. Sequence divergence of recombining DNAs appears to limit the frequency, length, and stability of early heteroduplex intermediates, which can be stabilized, and the recombinants mature via the initiation of DNA replication.

Catabolite repressors are potent antimutagens in Escherichia coli plate incorporation assays: experiments with glucose, glucose-6-phosphate and methyl-alpha-D-glucopyranoside

Having previously found that the yields of spontaneous valine-resistant (Val(r)) Escherichia coli mutants which appeared on plates containing 40 microg/ml of valine were always much lower when glucose was present in the glycerol-containing defined medium normally used to select them, we now sought to determine whether or not the global regulatory mechanism known as catabolite repression (formerly also called glucose repression) might be involved. We therefore tested glucose (the archetypal catabolite repressor), glycerol (a non catabolite-repressing substrate), glucose-6-phosphate (G6P, an exceptionally powerful catabolite repressor) and methyl-alpha-D-glucopyranoside (alphaMG, a strongly catabolite-repressing but non-utilisable glucose analogue), as potential inhibitors of spontaneous mutagenesis in plate incorporation assays, using three distinct mutation detection systems. We found that the numbers of spontaneous Val(r) and Lac+ mutations appearing on the selective plates tended to be highest when the medium contained only a non-repressing primary carbon source (glycerol in the Val(s) --> Val(r) system, lactose in the Lac- --> Lac+ system) and lowest when it had been supplemented with a strongly catabolite-repressing compound such as alphaMG, G6P or glucose. These results would seem to establish that catabolite repression is an important factor in determining the outcome of the spontaneous mutation generation process in E. coli and hence that the numbers of spontaneous mutations which can be expected to arise in any given set of mutation assay conditions may often be dependent upon the levels of catabolite repression which prevail during the course of the assay. The implications of these results for conventional plate-incorporation mutation assays are discussed.

Spontaneous mutations in bacteria: chance or necessity?

Several investigators have recently reported that significant numbers of appropriately adapted mutants can be induced in bacterial and yeast strains by exposing stationary phase cells to specific environmental challenges. The resulting mutants are said to be both selection-induced and demonstrably non-random in origin; if this interpretation is correct, it is in direct conflict with the conventional neo-Darwinian view, which is that spontaneous mutants are truly random in origin and arise without the intervention of any overtly adaptive forces. We believe that there are alternative ways of accounting for the appearance of many (and probably all) of the additional mutants which proponents of the adaptive mutation theory claim are observed only after they applied the appropriate selective pressure. Having reviewed the available evidence, we consider that most (if not all) of the sorts of mutants which are said to have been induced following exposure of stationary-phase cells to intense selective pressure are equally likely to have been generated during the operation of certain well-known, conventional (and essentially random) cellular DNA repair processes. Evidence in support of our view can be found in the mainstream literature on the origins of spontaneous mutations. We also note that some of the molecular models which have recently been proposed to explain the production of selection-induced mutations preferentially (or even only) in genes of adaptive significance may turn out to be of considerable interest in their own right, even although the mutants whose origins they were intended to explain may turn out to have arisen in a manner which is totally independent of the conditions used for their selection.

cAMP-dependent SOS induction and mutagenesis in resting bacterial populations

The inducible SOS system increases the survival of bacteria exposed to DNA-damaging agents by increasing the capacity of error-free and error-prone DNA repair systems. The inducible mutator effect is expected to contribute to the adaptation of bacterial populations to these adverse life conditions by increasing their genetic variability. The evolutionary impact of the SOS system would be even greater if it was also induced under conditions common in nature, such as in resting bacterial populations. The results presented here show that SOS induction and mutagenesis do occur in bacteria in aging colonies on agar plates. The observed SOS induction and mutagenesis are controlled by the LexA repressor and are RecA- and cAMP-dependent.

Evidence that F plasmid transfer replication underlies apparent adaptive mutation

An Escherichia coli K12 strain, FC40, has been used extensively in the analysis of adaptive mutability. This strain carries a revertible mutant lac allele on an F plasmid and accumulates Lac+ (lactose utilizing) revertants, but not unselected mutants, when placed on selective medium. These adaptive mutations are a subset of spontaneous types and their formation depends on the RecABC functions. Data presented here suggest that this phenomenon depends on transfer functions of the F factor. Fertility inhibition eliminates RecA-dependent adaptive reversion. Thus, "adaptive" revertants may form during replication from the transfer origin, whereas loci in the nonreplicating chromosome show little mutation.

The use of shuttle vectors for mutation analysis in transgenic mice and rats

The establishment in recent years of transgenic shuttle vector-based mutagenicity assays has provided improved systems for analysis of mutagenic and carcinogenic processes. Results in the mouse have stimulated the development of an alternate species suitable for mutation analysis and have increased our understanding of the existing models. A previously described shuttle vector (lambda LIZ), based on a lacI target gene, was constructed in this laboratory for the study of mutagenesis in transgenic mice and in cultured cell lines. The shuttle vector allows for several options in its recovery from the host genome and in mutant identification. Of the 9 transgenic lineages that were generated with the lambda LIZ vector, one was chosen for use in a standardized mutagenicity assay (Big Blue, mouse lineage A1). Characterization of this lineage included copy-number determination, chromosomal localization of transgene integration and analysis of copy-number stability. As part of the validation process, the standardized color-screening assay has been tested in the mouse, both for spontaneous mutant frequencies and with a variety of model mutagenic compounds, and has been shown to identify most major classes of mutations as evidenced by mutant spectra data. A discussion of the relative sensitivity of the shuttle vector to each of these classes of mutations is included. These studies have now been extended to the generation of transgenic rats containing the same shuttle vector for cross-species analysis. Spontaneous mutant frequencies in two transgenic rat lineages were measured in liver and in germ cells. Preliminary data suggest that spontaneous mutant frequencies in somatic tissue are lower in rats than in mice, a result consistent with historical observations of DNA damage and repair in these two species. Also under evaluation are alternative selectable systems for mutant identification, and hybrid animals obtained from mating lambda LIZ transgenics with genetically engineered mice possessing an inactivated tumor suppressor gene. It is expected that each of these widely varying endeavors will contribute, not only in furthering our understanding of the role transgenic systems should play in human risk assessment, but in illuminating the mechanisms of mutation in general.