Functional distinctions between the ribonucleic acids from citrus exocortis viroid and plant viruses: cell-free translation and aminoacylation reactions

Viroids, Satellite RNAs and Prions: Folding of Nucleic Acids and Misfolding of Proteins

Theodor ("Ted") Otto Diener (* 28 February 1921 in Zürich, Switzerland; † 28 March 2023 in Beltsville, MD, USA) pioneered research on viroids while working at the Plant Virology Laboratory, Agricultural Research Service, USDA, in Beltsville. He coined the name viroid and defined viroids' important features like the infectivity of naked single-stranded RNA without protein-coding capacity. During scientific meetings in the 1970s and 1980s, viroids were often discussed at conferences together with other "subviral pathogens". This term includes what are now called satellite RNAs and prions. Satellite RNAs depend on a helper virus and have linear or, in the case of virusoids, circular RNA genomes. Prions, proteinaceous infectious particles, are the agents of scrapie, kuru and some other diseases. Many satellite RNAs, like viroids, are non-coding and exert their function by thermodynamically or kinetically controlled folding, while prions are solely host-encoded proteins that cause disease by misfolding, aggregation and transmission of their conformations into infectious prion isoforms. In this memorial, we will recall the work of Ted Diener on subviral pathogens.

Revisiting the Non-Coding Nature of Pospiviroids

Viroids are small, circular, highly structured pathogens that infect a broad range of plants, causing economic losses. Since their discovery in the 1970s, they have been considered as non-coding pathogens. In the last few years, the discovery of other RNA entities, similar in terms of size and structure, that were shown to be translated (e.g., cirRNAs, precursors of miRNA, RNA satellites) as well as studies showing that some viroids are located in ribosomes, have reignited the idea that viroids may be translated. In this study, we used advanced bioinformatic analysis, in vitro experiments and LC-MS/MS to search for small viroid peptides of the PSTVd. Our results suggest that in our experimental conditions, even though the circular form of PSTVd is found in ribosomes, no produced peptides were identified. This indicates that the presence of PSTVd in ribosomes is most probably not related to peptide production but rather to another unknown function that requires further study.

Viroids, the simplest RNA replicons: How they manipulate their hosts for being propagated and how their hosts react for containing the infection

The discovery of viroids about 45 years ago heralded a revolution in Biology: small RNAs comprising around 350 nt were found to be able to replicate autonomously-and to incite diseases in certain plants-without encoding proteins, fundamental properties discriminating these infectious agents from viruses. The initial focus on the pathological effects usually accompanying infection by viroids soon shifted to their molecular features-they are circular molecules that fold upon themselves adopting compact secondary conformations-and then to how they manipulate their hosts to be propagated. Replication of viroids-in the nucleus or chloroplasts through a rolling-circle mechanism involving polymerization, cleavage and circularization of RNA strands-dealt three surprises: (i) certain RNA polymerases are redirected to accept RNA instead of their DNA templates, (ii) cleavage in chloroplastic viroids is not mediated by host enzymes but by hammerhead ribozymes, and (iii) circularization in nuclear viroids is catalyzed by a DNA ligase redirected to act upon RNA substrates. These enzymes (and ribozymes) are most probably assisted by host proteins, including transcription factors and RNA chaperones. Movement of viroids, first intracellularly and then to adjacent cells and distal plant parts, has turned out to be a tightly regulated process in which specific RNA structural motifs play a crucial role. More recently, the advent of RNA silencing has brought new views on how viroids may cause disease and on how their hosts react to contain the infection; additionally, viroid infection may be restricted by other mechanisms. Representing the lowest step on the biological size scale, viroids have also attracted considerable interest to get a tentative picture of the essential characteristics of the primitive replicons that populated the postulated RNA world.

Mutational analysis of potato spindle tuber viroid reveals complex relationships between structure and infectivity

Viroids are single-stranded, covalently closed circular RNA pathogens that can be isolated from certain higher plants afflicted with specific diseases. Their small size (246-375 nucleotides; M(r) 0.8-1.3 x 10(5)) and ability to replicate autonomously make viroids a unique model system in which to study the relationships between the structure of an RNA and its biological function. The demonstrated infectivity of certain cloned viroid cDNAs allows the use of site-specific mutagenesis techniques to probe structure-function relationships suggested by comparative sequence analysis. Several site-specific mutations that disrupt base pairing in either the native structure or secondary hairpin I destroyed the ability of potato spindle tuber viroid cDNA to initiate infection. Alterations in the terminal loops of the native structure also abolished cDNA infectivity. One pseudorevertant, a mutant cDNA containing compensating changes that restore base pairing in the native structure, was marginally infectious; a second pseudorevertant in which base pairing was restored within the stem of secondary hairpin I was not infectious. The behavior of these mutants dramatically demonstrates the effect of remarkably small structural changes on viroid infectivity and emphasizes the importance of the conserved rod-like native structure for viroid function.

RNA sequences complementary to citrus exocortis viroid in nucleic acid preparations from infected Gynura aurantiaca

Molecular hybridization with (125)I-labeled citrus exocortis viroid RNA has been used to survey nucleic acid preparations from Gynura aurantiaca for viroid complementary molecules. A differential hybridization effect was detected between nucleic acid extracts from healthy and infected tissue in which significant RNase-resistant (125)I-labeled citrus exocortis viroid resulted in hybridization studies with the infected tissue extracts. Subsequent characterization indicated that RNA from infected tissue was involved in the formation of a duplex molecule with citrus exocortis viroid RNA and had properties of an RNA.RNA hybrid. Subcellular fractionation of infected tissue indicates that the complementary RNA is present in nuclear and soluble RNA fractions. This RNA may represent an intermediate molecule in the replication of the viroid or a pathogenic expression and may have a regulatory role in the host cell.

Potato spindle tuber and citrus exocortis viroids undergo no major sequence changes during replication in two different hosts

Potato spindle tuber viroid and citrus exocortis viroid, each purified from tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) and from Gynura aurantiaca, were iodinated in vitro with (125)I, digested with ribonuclease T1, and subjected to two-dimensional RNA fingerprinting analysis. With the exception of minor variations, each viroid retained its distinctive fingerprint pattern irrespective of the host species from which it was isolated. We conclude that the nucleotide sequences of these viroids are principally determined by the infecting viroid and not by the host.

Potato spindle tuber viroid: the simplicity paradox resolved?

TAXONOMY

Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) is the type species of the genus Posipiviroid, family Pospiviroidae. An absence of hammerhead ribozymes and the presence of a 'central conserved region' distinguish PSTVd and related viroids from members of a second viroid family, the Avsunviroidae.

PHYSICAL PROPERTIES

Viroids are small, unencapsidated, circular, single-stranded RNA molecules which replicate autonomously when inoculated into host plants. Because viroids are non-protein-coding RNAs, designation of the more abundant, highly infectious polarity strand as the positive strand is arbitrary. PSTVd assumes a rod-like, highly structured conformation that is resistant to nuclease degradation in vitro. Naturally occurring sequence variants of PSTVd range in size from 356 to 361 nt. HOSTS AND SYMPTOMS: The natural host range of PSTVd-cultivated potato, certain other Solanum spp., and avocado-appears to be quite limited. Foliar symptoms in potato are often obscure, and the severity of tuber symptoms (elongation with the appearance of prominent bud scales/eyebrows and growth cracks) depends on both temperature and length of infection. PSTVd has a broad experimental host range, especially among solanaceous species, and strains are classified as mild, intermediate or severe based upon the symptoms observed in sensitive tomato cultivars. These symptoms include shortening of internodes, petioles and mid-ribs, severe epinasty and wrinkling of the leaves, and necrosis of mid-ribs, petioles and stems.

Discovering viroids--a personal perspective

During 1970 and 1971, I discovered that a devastating disease of potato plants is not caused by a virus, as had been assumed, but by a new type of subviral pathogen, the viroid. Viroids are so small--one fiftieth of the size of the smallest viruses--that many scientists initially doubted their existence. We now know that viroids cause many damaging diseases of crop plants. Fortunately, new methods that are based on the unique properties of viroids now promise effective control.

Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid RNA: dissection of the pathogenicity determinant and comparative fitness of symptomatic and non-symptomatic variants

Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd) is a small RNA (398-401nt) with hammerhead ribozymes in both polarity strands that mediate self-cleavage of the oligomeric RNA intermediates generated in a rolling-circle mechanism of replication. Within the in vivo branched RNA conformation of CChMVd, a tetraloop has been identified as a major determinant of pathogenicity. Here we present a detailed study of this tetraloop by site-directed mutagenesis, bioassay of the CChMV-cDNA clones and analysis of the resulting progenies. None of the changes introduced in the tetraloop, including its substitution by a triloop or a pentaloop, abolished infectivity. In contrast to observations for other RNAs, the thermodynamically stable GAAA tetraloop characteristic of non-symptomatic CChMVd-NS strains was not functionally interchangeable for other stable tetraloops of the UNCG family, suggesting that the sequence, rather than the structure, is the major factor governing conservation of this motif. In most cases, the changes introduced initially led to symptomless infections, which eventually evolved to be symptomatic concurrently with the prevalence in the progeny of the UUUC tetraloop characteristic of symptomatic CChMVd-S strains. Only in one case did the GAAA tetraloop emerge and eventually dominate the progeny in infected plants that were non-symptomatic. These results revealed two major fitness peaks in the tetraloop (UUUC and GAAA), whose adjacent stem was also under strong selection pressure. Co-inoculations with CChMVd-S and -NS variants showed that only when the latter was in a 100- or 1000-fold excess did the infected plants remain symptomless, confirming the higher biological fitness of the S variant and explaining the lack of symptom expression previously observed in cross-protection experiments.

A naked plant-specific RNA ten-fold smaller than the smallest known viral RNA: the viroid

Viroids are subviral plant pathogens at the frontier of life. They are solely composed by a single-stranded circular RNA of 246-401 nt with a compact secondary structure. Viroids replicate autonomously when inoculated into their host plants and incite, in most of them, economically important diseases. In contrast to viruses, viroids do not code for any protein and depend on host enzymes for their replication, which in some viroids occurs in the nucleus and in others in the chloroplast, through a rolling-circle mechanism with three catalytic steps. Quite remarkably, however, one of the steps, cleavage of the oligomeric head-to-tail replicative intermediates to unit-length strands, is mediated in certain viroids by hammerhead ribozymes that can be formed by their strands of both polarities. Viroids induce disease by direct interaction with host factors, the nature of which is presently unknown. Some properties of viroids, particularly the presence of ribozymes, suggest that they might have appeared very early in evolution and could represent 'living fossils' of the precellular RNA world that presumably preceded our current world based on DNA and proteins.

An extra nucleotide in the consensus catalytic core of a viroid hammerhead ribozyme: implications for the design of more efficient ribozymes

Hammerhead ribozymes catalyze self-cleavage of oligomeric RNAs generated in replication of certain viroid and viroid-like RNAs. Previous studies have defined a catalytic core conserved in most natural hammerheads, but it is still unknown why some present deviations from the consensus. We have addressed this issue in chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd), whose (+) hammerhead has an extra A (A10) between the conserved A9 and the quasi-conserved G10.1. Effects of insertions at this position on hammerhead kinetics have not hitherto been examined. A10 caused a moderate decrease of the trans-cleaving rate constant with respect to the CChMVd (+) hammerhead without this residue, whereas A10-->C and A10-->G substitutions had major detrimental effects, likely because they favor catalytically inactive foldings. By contrast, A10-->U substitution induced a 3-4-fold increase of the rate constant, providing an explanation for the extra U10 present in two natural hammerheads. Because A10 also occupies a singular and indispensable position in the global CChMVd conformation, as revealed by bioassays, these results show that some hammerheads deviate from the consensus due to the involvement of certain residues in critical function(s) other than self-cleavage. Incorporation of the extra U10 into a model hammerhead also caused a similar increase in the rate constant, providing data for a deeper understanding of the hammerhead structural requirements and for designing more efficient ribozymes.

A chloroplastic RNA polymerase resistant to tagetitoxin is involved in replication of avocado sunblotch viroid

Avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd), the type species of the family Avsunviroidae, replicates and accumulates in the chloroplast. Two main chloroplastic RNA polymerases have been described: the plastid-encoded polymerase (PEP) with a multisubunit structure similar to the Escherichia coli enzyme and a single-unit nuclear-encoded polymerase (NEP) resembling phage RNA polymerases. On a different basis, sensitivity to tagetitoxin, two major RNA polymerase activities, tagetitoxin sensitive (TS) and resistant (TR), have been found in plastids. The most plausible candidates for the TS and TR RNA polymerases are PEP and NEP, respectively. To gain an insight into the enzymology of the polymerization of ASBVd strands, purified chloroplast preparations from ASBVd-infected leaves were assayed for their in vitro ability to transcribe ASBVd RNAs together with some representative genes (psbA, 16SrDNA, accD, and rpoB) of the three classes of chloroplastic genes according to their promoter structure. High concentrations of alpha-amanitin had no effect on gene or on viroid transcription, but tagetitoxin (5-10 microM) prevented transcription of all these genes without affecting synthesis of ASBVd strands; only at higher tagetitoxin concentrations (50-100 microM) was a 25% inhibition observed. These results suggest that NEP is the RNA polymerase required in ASBVd replication, although the participation of another TR RNA polymerase from the chloroplast cannot be excluded.

Avsunviroidae family: viroids containing hammerhead ribozymes

This chapter focuses on the second viroid family, whose members are also referred to as hammerhead viroids, taking into account their most outstanding feature. If the word “small” is the first to come to mind when considering viroids, perhaps the second word is “hammerhead,” because this class of ribozymes, which because of its structural simplicity has an enormous biotechnological potential, is described in avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd) as well as in a viroid-like satellite RNA. The most outstanding feature of the Avsunviroidae members is their potential to adopt hammerhead structures in both polarity strands and to self-cleave in vitro accordingly. Viroids differ from viruses not only in their genome size but also in other fundamental aspects, prominent among which is the lack of messenger activity of both viroid RNAs and their complementary strands.

Viroids and the nature of viroid diseases

In its methodology, the unexpected discovery of the viroid in 1971 resembles that of the virus by Beijerinck some 70 years earlier. In either case, a novel type of plant pathogen was recognized by its ability to penetrate through a medium with pores small enough to exclude even the smallest previously known pathogen: bacteria as compared with the tobacco mosaic agent; viruses as compared with the potato spindle tuber agent. Interestingly, one of the two methods used by Beijerinck, diffusion of the tobacco mosaic agent into agar gels, is conceptually similar to one method used to establish the size of the potato spindle tuber agent, namely polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Further work demonstrated that neither agent is an unusually small conventional pathogen (a microbe in the case of the tobacco mosaic agent; a virus in the case of the potato spindle tuber agent), but that either agent represents the prototype of a fundamentally distinct class of pathogen, the viruses and the viroids, respectively. With the viroids, this distinction became evident once their unique molecular structure, lack of mRNA activity, and autonomous replication had become elucidated. Functionally, viroids rely to a far greater extent than viruses on their host's biosynthetic systems: Whereas translation of viral genetic information is essential for virus replication, viroids are totally dependent on their hosts' transcriptional system and, in contrast to viruses, no viroid-coded proteins are involved. Because of the viroids' simplicity and extremely small size they approach more closely even than viruses Beijerinck's concept of a contagium vivum fluidum.

Characterization of RNAs specific to avocado sunblotch viroid synthesized in vitro by a cell-free system from infected avocado leaves

Analysis by molecular hybridization of the RNAs transcribed by a cell-free fraction from avocado infected with avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBV) demonstrated the presence of newly synthesized viroid-specific sequences, most of which were of the same polarity as the mature infectious viroid RNA. Treatment of the cell-free fraction with DNase reduced the total synthesis of RNA considerably, but it did not influence that of the ASBV-specific RNAs, indicating that the latter were transcribed on an RNA template. Inhibition studies with alpha-amanitin showed that the synthesis of ASBV-specific RNAs was not affected by concentrations of 1 and 200 micrograms/ml of the drug, which typically inhibit RNA polymerase II and III, respectively, from most animal and plant systems. These results suggest that either RNA polymerase I or an unidentified RNA polymerase activity resistant to alpha-amanitin, acting on an RNA template, plays a role in the replication of ASBV, whereas for the rest of the viroids studied so far it appears that RNA polymerase II is involved. Analysis by polycrylamide gel electrophoresis under partially and fully denaturing conditions of the ASBV-specific RNAs synthesized in vitro showed that they contain unit and longer than unit length viroid strands, probably associated in complexes with single- and double-stranded regions. The structural properties of these complexes are similar to those of the RNAs accumulating in vivo in viroid-infected tissues, which are the postulated replicative intermediates of the rolling-circle mechanism proposed for viroid synthesis.

Subviral pathogens of plants: the viroids

Research during the last 15 years has conclusively shown that viroids are not only fundamentally different from viruses at the molecular level, but that they are most likely not directly related to viruses in an evolutionary sense. Today, viroids are among the most thoroughly studied biological macromolecules. Their molecular structures have been elucidated to a large extent, but much needs to be learned regarding the correlation between molecular structure and biological function. The availability of the tools of recombinant DNA technology in viroid research promises rapid progress in these areas of inquiry.

Interference between coinoculated viroids

Experiments were carried out to seek evidence of an interaction between two viroid RNAs introduced to tomato plants in the same inoculum. At the level of symptom expression, the severe isolate of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTV) dominated the mild isolate. Seventy-five percent of the plants inoculated with a 100-fold excess of the mild isolate developed unattenuated symptoms of severe disease. Other experiments revealed that infectious RNA molecules transcribed from cloned DNA templates containing PSTV sequences reduced the level of hop stunt viroid (HSV) RNA present in nucleic acid extracts of plants which had been inoculated with a mixture of dimeric plus-strand transcripts of these two viroids. Plants inoculated with dual transcripts--containing two copies of PSTV linked to two copies of HSV--developed characteristic symptoms of severe PSTV. Dot hybridization demonstrated that only PSTV replicated to detectable levels in these plants. A likely interpretation of these results is that the HSV portion of the dual transcripts failed to replicate because of interference from PSTV. These results raise questions about how the process of viroid replication is related to symptom expression, and lead to suggested models for the effect of viroid-like RNAs in cells under both normal and pathogenic circumstances.

Sequence homology between potato spindle tuber viroid and U3B snRNA

Sequence homology was found by computer analysis between potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTV) RNA and U3B snRNA of Novikoff hepatoma cells. This homology is colinear in arrangement, extends in length to 81% of the entire U3B snRNA molecule and is involved in the PSTV molecule unique sites which, if depicted in terms of the secondary structure of the circular PSTV molecule, reveal a conspicuous regularity in their location. A strong relation in primary structure between PSTV and U3B snRNA is demonstrated by statistical analysis.

Gelelectrophoretic analysis of phenol-extractable leaf proteins from different viroid/host combinations

The phenol-soluble proteins from leaves of healthy and viroid-infected plants were compared after separation on SDS-polyacrylamide gels. After staining with Coomassie blue, alterations in the protein patterns of infected plants were found which resulted from an increase or decrease of certain protein bands. After infection with the same viroid, different hosts show characteristic changes in the protein pattern which suggest that these alterations are host-specific rather than pathogenspecific. After infection of tomato plants with different viroid "species" a protein with the apparent MW of 14,000 (p14 tom) was found to accumulate dramatically. This protein also accumulates in tomato plants after viral and fungus infections and the rate of its accumulation is directly related to the severity of symptoms developed by the diseased plants. It is assumed, therefore, that it is a response of tomato plants to infection in general.

Analysis of acid-extractable tomato leaf proteins after infection with a viroid, two viruses and a fungus and partial purification of the "pathogenesis-related" protein p 14

Gel electrophoretic analysis revealed marked alterations in the pattern of acid-extractable proteins from tomato leaves after infection with a viroid (PSTV), two viruses [tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) and cucumber mosaic virus (CMV)], and a fungus (Cladosporium fulvum) when compared to the pattern from healthy leaves. A pathogen-specific appearance of new protein bands was only found after infection with TMV (MW 17,400 and 65,000), CMV (MW 9000 and 8000) and Cladosporium fulvum (MW 28,000). With the exception of the TMV coat protein (MW 17,400) it could not be established whether the other four proteins are coded for by the corresponding pathogen or by the host. Nine proteins with the apparent NW of 10,000, 11,000, 12,000, 13,000, 14,000, 25,000, 31,000, 33,000 and 38,000 showed an increase in their relative concentration which is most dramatic in the case of the protein with the MW of 14,000 called p14. A decrease was observed in four proteins with molecular weights of 14,500, 23,000, 30,000 and 105,000. Since all these alterations could be correlated with the severity of the disease symptoms but not with the nature of the pathogen they must be considered as a general pathophysiological response of the tomato plant to infection and symptom development. A partial purification of the most prominent "pathogenesis-related" protein p14 from tomato plants is described.

Avocado sunblotch viroid: primary sequence and proposed secondary structure

The sequence of the 247 nucleotide residues of the single strand circular RNA of avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBV) was determined using partial enzymic cleavage methods on overlapping viroid fragments obtained by partial ribonuclease digestion followed by 32p-labelling in vitro at their 5'-ends. ASBV is much smaller than potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTV; 359 residues) and chrysanthemum stunt viroid (CSV; 356 residues). A secondary structure model for ASBV is proposed and contains 67% of its residues base paired. In contrast to the extensive (69%) sequence homology of CSV with PSTV, only 18% of the ASBV sequence is homologous to PSTV and CSV. There are eight potential polypeptide translation products with chain lengths from 4 to 63 amino acid residues coded for by the plus (infectious) strand and four potential translation products (2 to 60 residues) coded for by the minus strand. An improved method is described for the synthesis of gamma-32p-ATP of high specific activity.

A severe and a mild potato spindle tuber viroid isolate differ in three nucleotide exchanges only

Fingerprint analyses of two potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTV) isolates causing severe and mild symptoms, respectively, in tomato exhibited defined differences in the RNase T1 and RNase A fingerprints. The complete sequencing of the mild isolate and the comparison of its primary structure with the previously established one of the pathogenic type strain revealed that oligonucleotides CAAAAAAG, CUUUUUCUCUAUCUUACUUG, and AAAAAAGGAC in the 'severe' strain are replaced by CAAUAAG, CUUUUUCUCUAUCUUUCUUUG, AAU, and AAGGAC in the 'mild' strain. Thus, three nucleotide exchanges at different sites of the molecule may change a pathogenic viroid to a practically non-pathogenic isolate. The possible correlation between the secondary structure in a defined region of the PSTV molecule and its pathogenicity for tomato is discussed.

Viroids: structure and function

Viroids are nucleic acid species of relatively low molecular weight and unique structure that cause several important diseases of cultivated plants. Similar nucleic acid species may be responsible for certain diseases of animals and humans. Viroids are the smallest known agents of infectious disease. Unlike viral nucleic acids, viroids are not encapsidated. Despite their small size, viroids replicate autonomously in cells of susceptible plant species. Known viroids are single-stranded, covalently closed circular, as well as linear, RNA molecules with extensive regions of intramolecular complementarity; they exist in their native state as highly base-paired rods.

Nucleotide sequence and secondary structure of potato spindle tuber viroid

The viroid of the potato spindle tuber disease (PSTV) is a covalently closed ring of 359 ribonucleotides. As a result of intramolecular base pairing, a serial arrangement of double-helical sections and internal loops form a unique rod-like secondary structure. PSTV is the first pathogen of a eukaryotic organism for which the complete molecular structure has been established.

Viroids are single-stranded covalently closed circular RNA molecules existing as highly base-paired rod-like structures

Viroids are uncoated infectious RNA molecules pathogenic to certain higher plants. Four different highly purified viroids were studied. By ultracentrifugation, thermal denaturation, electron microscopy, and end group analysis the following features were established: (i) the molecular weight of cucumber pale fruit viroid from tomato is 110,000, of citrus exocortis viroid from Gynura 119,000, of citrus exocortis viroid from tomato 119,000 and of potato spindle tuber viroid from tomato 127,000. (ii) Viroids are single-stranded molecules. (iii) Virods exhibit high thermal stability, cooperativity, and self-complementarity resulting in a rod-like native structure. (iv) Viroids are covalently closed circular RNA molecules.