A transcriptional map of the bacteriophage SPO1 genome. III. A region of early and middle promoters (the gene 28 region)

Without a license, or accidents waiting to happen

This is a memoir of circumstances that have shaped my life as a scientist, some of the questions that have excited my interest, and some of the people with whom I have shared that pursuit. I was introduced to transcription soon after the discovery of RNA polymerase and have been fascinated by questions relating to gene regulation since that time. My account touches on early experiments dealing with the ability of RNA polymerase to selectively transcribe its DNA template. Temporal programs of transcription that control the multiplication cycles of viruses (phages) and the precise mechanisms generating this regulation have been a continuing source of fascination and new challenges. A longtime interest in eukaryotic RNA polymerase III has centered on yeast and on the enumeration and properties of its transcription initiation factors, the architecture of its promoter complexes, and the mechanism of transcriptional initiation. These areas of research are widely regarded as separate, but to my thinking they have posed similar questions, and I have been unwilling or unable to abandon either one for the other. An additional interest in archaeal transcription can be seen as stemming naturally from this point of view.

The genome of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1

We report the genome sequence of Bacillus subtilis phage SPO1. The unique genome sequence is 132,562 bp long, and DNA packaged in the virion (the chromosome) has a 13,185-bp terminal redundancy, giving a total of 145,747 bp. We predict 204 protein-coding genes and 5 tRNA genes, and we correlate these findings with the extensive body of investigations of SPO1, including studies of the functions of the 61 previously defined genes and studies of the virion structure. Sixty-nine percent of the encoded proteins show no similarity to any previously known protein. We identify 107 probable transcription promoters; most are members of the promoter classes identified in earlier studies, but we also see a new class that has the same sequence as the host sigma K promoters. We find three genes encoding potential new transcription factors, one of which is a distant homologue of the host sigma factor K. We also identify 75 probable transcription terminator structures. Promoters and terminators are generally located between genes and together with earlier data give what appears to be a rather complete picture of how phage transcription is regulated. There are complete genome sequences available for five additional phages of Gram-positive hosts that are similar to SPO1 in genome size and in composition and organization of genes. Comparative analysis of SPO1 in the context of these other phages yields insights about SPO1 and the other phages that would not be apparent from the analysis of any one phage alone. These include assigning identities as well as probable functions for several specific genes and inferring evolutionary events in the phages' histories. The comparative analysis also allows us to put SPO1 into a phylogenetic context. We see a pattern similar to what has been noted in phage T4 and its relatives, in which there is minimal successful horizontal exchange of genes among a "core" set of genes that includes most of the virion structural genes and some genes of DNA metabolism, but there is extensive horizontal transfer of genes over the remainder of the genome. There is a correlation between genes in rapid evolutionary flux through these genomes and genes that are small.

Roles of genes 44, 50, and 51 in regulating gene expression and host takeover during infection of Bacillus subtilis by bacteriophage SPO1

We show that the products of SPO1 genes 44, 50, and 51 are required for the normal transition from early to middle gene expression during infection of Bacillus subtilis by bacteriophage SPO1; that they are also required for control of the shutoff of host DNA, RNA, and protein synthesis; and that their effects on host shutoff could be accounted for by their effects on the regulation of gene expression. These three gene products had four distinguishable effects in regulating SPO1 gene expression: (i) gp44-50-51 acted to restrain expression of all SPO1 genes tested, (ii) gp44 and/or gp50-51 caused additional specific repression of immediate-early genes, (iii) gp44 and/or gp50-51 stimulated expression of middle genes, and (iv) gp44 and/or gp50-51 stimulated expression of some delayed-early genes. Shutoff of immediate-early gene expression also required the activity of gp28, the middle-gene-specific sigma factor. Shutoff of host RNA and protein synthesis was accelerated by either the 44- single mutant or the 50(-)51(-) double mutant and more so by the 44(-)50(-)51(-) triple mutant. Shutoff of host DNA synthesis was accelerated by the mutants early in infection but delayed by the 44(-)50(-)51(-) triple mutant at later times. Although gp50 is a very small protein, consisting almost entirely of an apparent membrane-spanning domain, it contributed significantly to each activity tested. We identify SPO1 genes 41 to 51 and 53 to 60 as immediate-early genes; genes 27, 28, and 37 to 40 as delayed-early genes; and gene 52 as a middle gene.

Cloning and characterization of transcriptional promoters from Bacillus subtilis phage 2C

Phage 2C is a Bacillus subtilis lytic phage, whose genome contains hydroxymethyluracil in place of thymine. To isolate promoters of early phage genes involved in the take-over of cellular metabolism, 2C DNA libraries were constructed in promoter-probe plasmids replicating in Escherichia coli and B. subtilis. Four different 2C DNA fragments strongly expressed reporter genes in E. coli but not in B. subtilis. All fragments originated from unique sequences of the genome and not from its terminal redundancies. One fragment was sequenced. Despite the presence of an sigma-A-RNA polymerase binding site upstream of the transcriptional initiation site of a 2C early gene, this fragment did not promote transcription in B. subtilis.

A cytotoxic early gene of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1

Some of the early genes of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1 were hypothesized to function in the shutoff of host biosyntheses. Two of these genes, e3 and e22, were cloned and sequenced. E22 showed no similarity to any known protein, while E3, a highly acidic protein, showed significant similarity only to other similarly acidic proteins. Each gene was immediately downstream of a very active early promoter. Each was expressed actively during the first few minutes of infection and was then rapidly shut off and its RNA rapidly degraded. An e3 nonsense mutation severely retarded the degradation of e3 RNA. Expression of a plasmid-borne e3 gene, in either B. subtilis or Escherichia coli, resulted in the inhibition of host DNA, RNA, and protein syntheses and prevented colony formation. However, the e3 nonsense mutation caused no measurable decrease in either burst size or host shutoff during infection and, in fact, caused an increased burst size at high multiplicities of infection. We suggest that e3 is one of several genes involved in host shutoff, that its function is dispensable both for host shutoff and for phage multiplication, and that its shutoff function is not entirely specific to host activities.

Deoxyuridylate-hydroxymethylase of bacteriophage SPO1

Phage SPO1 of Bacillus subtilis carries hydroxymethyl-deoxyuridylate in place of thymidylate in its DNA. The enzyme, responsible for the conversion of dUMP to HmdUMP, is a dUMP hydroxymethylase, encoded by the SPO1 gene 29. Here we describe the cloning and sequencing of the gene and the overexpression of the gene product. DNA hybridization using the DNA of bacteriophage T4 dCMP-hydroxymethylase gene as a probe, allowed us to identify and map g29 on a 3.9-kb restriction fragment, EcoRI*11. We determined the nucleotide sequence. One of the open reading frames detected, coding for a putative 44.6-kDa protein, showed significant amino acid homologies with all known thymidylate synthases. Gp29 was overexpressed in the pT7 system. Extracts prepared from induced cells show hydroxymethylase activity in a tritium release assay.

Bacteriophage SPO1 middle transcripts

Phage SPO1 middle transcripts are known to fall into two classes, m and m1l. Class m1l transcripts continue to be made late in the viral infection, while the synthesis of class m transcripts ceases soon after the onset of replication and late transcription. The experiments that are reported here deal with the regulatory nature of this diversity. The accumulation of transcripts associated with eight middle promoters was analyzed by S1 nuclease mapping. DNA sequence surrounding these middle promoters was determined or redetermined, and the stability of RNA associated with most of these promoters was also analyzed. Class m1l transcription was shown to be associated with SPO1 middle promoters that remain active at late stages of viral development, when middle promoters of class m are repressed. The consensus sequences of class m and m1l middle promoters were found to be indistinguishable and the search for sequences consensual with late promoters yielded only divergent candidates. No other consensus sequence that is specific and exclusive to either class of middle promoters was detected within a hundred base pairs upstream or downstream of these promoters. Considerable variations in the stabilities of SPO1 middle transcripts were found. Two promoters that are only 71 base pairs apart yielded transcripts that had substantially different stabilities. The 5'-flanking segment of the transcript associated with the upstream promoter apparently conferred a high degree of stability on this RNA.

Construction and properties of a temperature-sensitive mutation in the gene for the bacteriophage SPO1 DNA-binding protein TF1

The Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1 encodes the DNA-binding protein TF1, a homolog of the ubiquitous type II DNA-binding proteins that are components of bacterial chromatin. The known three-dimensional structure of a related protein was used in devising a scheme of site-directed mutagenesis that led to the creation of a temperature-sensitive mutation in the TF1 gene. At the nonpermissive temperature, this mutation disrupted the temporal regulation of viral protein synthesis and processing, altered the kinetics of accumulation of at least one viral transcript, and prohibited the production of infective progeny phage. We suggest that TF1 function is required to shut off the expression of several early-middle and middle viral genes and that TF1 plays a role in phage head morphogenesis. Spontaneous second-site mutations of the temperature-sensitive mutant TF1 allele that suppressed its associated phenotypes were analyzed. These suppressor mutations conferred greater amino acid sequence homology with the type II DNA-binding protein from the thermophile Bacillus stearothermophilus.

Activity of a phage-modified RNA polymerase at hybrid promoters. Effects of substituting thymine for hydroxymethyluracil in a phage SP01 middle promoter

Transcription of bacteriophage SP01 middle promoters is specifically initiated by a complex of the Bacillus subtilis host's RNA polymerase core (E) with the SP01 gene 28 transcription-regulating protein, gp28. Normal SP01 DNA contains hydroxymethyluracil (hmUra) in place of thymine and E . gp28 preferentially transcribes hmUra-containing DNA. Hybrid DNA molecules containing an SP01 middle promoter, PM25 . 1, have been constructed in which one DNA strand contains T and the other hmUra. The major feature of these reciprocal hybrid promoters is that one has, predominantly, T substituted for hmUra in the central -35 recognition sequence in the transcribed strand, while the other has, predominantly, T substituted for hmUra in the -10 recognition sequence in the non-transcribed strand. Binding by the E . gp28 RNA polymerase and transcription of these hybrid promoters and of the normal, all-hmUra, promoter have been compared. Both hybrid promoters are weaker than the normal PM25 . 1 promoter, but the hybrid promoter with T substituted in the -10 sequence is the weakest of the set. The DNase I footprint of the normal PM25 . 1 promoter shows temperature-dependent protection of a relatively long stretch of DNA downstream from the transcriptional start site, correlating with a thermal transition of transcriptional activity of promoter complexes. The stronger of the hybrid promoters also undergoes this transition, but the weaker does not. We discuss these findings in terms of protein-DNA interactions determining specificity for a modified nucleotide at this promoter.

The phage SPO1-specific RNA polymerase, E.gp28, recognizes its cognate promoters in thymine-containing DNA

The bacteriophage SPO1 gene 28-encoded protein, gp28, directs specific recognition of viral middle promoters in hydroxymethyluracil-containing DNA by the Bacillus subtilis host's RNA polymerase core. Using appropriately sensitive methods of detection, we have shown that discrimination against thymine-containing DNA is not absolute and that the gp28-containing RNA polymerase precisely initiates transcription at two thymine-containing SPO1 middle promoters.

Electron-microscopic examination of the binding of a large RNA polymerase III transcription factor to a tRNA gene

A Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNA polymerase III transcription factor was previously shown to bind stably to tRNA genes. This transcription factor has been further purified on the basis of its large size and its binding to a S. cerevisiae tRNALeu3 gene has been examined by electron microscopy. Site-specific binding of the factor to the tRNALeu3 gene sharply bends the DNA.

Transcription of Bacillis subtilis plasmid pBD64 and expression of bacteriophage SPO1 genes cloned therein

Plasmid pBD64, a vector which is useful for cloning in Bacillis subtilis (T. J. Gryczan, A. G. Shivakumar, and D. Dubnau (1980), J. Bacteriol. 141, 246-253), has at least three substantial transcription units. Two of these include the single EcoRI, XbaI, and BamHI sites, while the other includes the single BglII site. Each of these transcripts was synthesized in the counterclockwise direction, relative to the pBD64 restriction map. No transcripts were detected in the opposite direction. Infection by bacteriophage SPO1 caused a substantial decrease in each of these transcripts. No new pBD64 transcripts were detected during SPO1 infection. Various SPO1 genes, cloned at several of these pBD64 sites, were tested for expression by observing their capacity to complement SPO1 mutants. Several middle and late genes were expressed substantially, regardless of the orientation in which the fragments were inserted. Since transcription from the vector could cause expression only in one orientation, this argues that the necessary transcription originated at SPO1 promoters, and, thus, that SPO1 middle and late promoters can be active in thymine-containing DNA.

Cloning and mapping of the SPO1 genome

Many of the XbaI, EcoRI, KpnI, and BglII fragments of bacteriophage SPO1, accounting for about 65% of the genomic sequences, were cloned in Bacillus subtilis. Four of the EcoRI fragments were specifically refractory to cloning in both Escherichia coli and B. subtilis, probably because of expression of deleterious genes carried on the SPO1 fragments. To permit complete identification of the regions cloned, the SPO1 restriction map has been extended to include the XbaI fragments and the previously unmapped KpnI fragments. Markers for 26 of the 39 known genes have been located on specific cloned fragments, permitting more precise determination of the positions of most of the genes. One cloned SPO1 fragment was inhibitory to SPO1 development.

Sequence of the bacteriophage SP01 gene coding for transcription factor 1, a viral homologue of the bacterial type II DNA-binding proteins

The Bacillus subtilis phage SP01, whose DNA contains 5-hydroxymethyluracil (hmUra) in place of thymine, codes for an abundant, small, basic protein called TF1. TF1 binds preferentially to hydroxymethyluracil-containing DNA and thereby selectively inhibits transcription of such DNA in vitro. The gene for TF1 has been sequenced. We find that this viral protein is a homologue of the ubiquitous bacterial type II DNA-binding proteins. The three-dimensional structure of one of these bacterial proteins has recently been determined. We are able to discern common as well as distinctive features in the amino acid sequence and the three-dimensional structure of the homologous viral protein.

Regions specifying transcriptional termination and pausing in the bacteriophage SP01 terminal repeat

We have determined the nucleotide sequences of four termination sites recognized by Bacillus subtilis RNA polymerase. These sites are located in the terminally repeated segment of the bacteriophage SP01 genome, where most early phage transcription occurs. The SP01 terminators have structures that are similar to those recognized by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, containing a region of dyad symmetry followed by a stretch of HMU residues in the noncoding DNA strand (HMU is substituted for T in SP01 DNA). We note that in a terminator that is only 60% efficient in vitro, there is a greater distance between these two conserved elements that exists in more efficient terminators. We also find that RNA polymerase molecules which elongate a transcript through a partial terminator often pause at this site.

Structure of a Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1 gene encoding RNA polymerase sigma factor

Gene 28 of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1 codes for a regulatory protein, a sigma factor known as sigma gp28, that binds to the bacterial core RNA polymerase to direct the recognition of phage middle gene promoters. middle promoters exhibit distinctive and conserved nucleotide sequences in two regions centered about 10 and 35 base pairs upstream from the start point of mRNA synthesis. Here we report the cloning of gene 28 and its complete nucleotide sequence. We infer that sigma gp28 is a 25,707-dalton protein of 220 amino acids. Neither the nucleotide sequence of gene 28 nor the inferred amino acid sequence of sigma gp28 exhibits extensive homology to the gene or protein sequence of Escherichia coli sigma factor.

Interchangeability of delta subunits of RNA polymerase from different species of the genus Bacillus

RNA polymerase was purified from five species of Bacillus, including Bacillus subtilis. Each polymerase had a subunit composition analogous to that reported for B. subtilis, i.e., beta beta '2 alpha sigma delta omega 1 omega 2. The delta subunits from the B. subtilis and Bacillus thuringiensis polymerases were interchangeable, as judged from their effects on promoter selection in the polymerase binding assay.