Analysis of cellular DNA synthesis during polyoma virus infection of mice: acute infection fails to induce cellular DNA synthesis

A circadian model for viral persistence

Persistently infecting DNA viruses depend heavily on host cell DNA synthesis machinery. Replication of cellular and viral DNA is inhibited by mutagenic stress. It is hypothesized that diurnal regulation of viral DNA replication may occur at the level of cell cycle checkpoints and DNA repair, to protect DNA from exposure to UV light or other mutagens. This highly conserved mechanism is traced back to viruses that persist in prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Inhibition of viral DNA replication and the cell cycle in response to UV light may represent a functional building block in the evolution of circadian-gated DNA replication. Viral DNA replication appears to be closely linked to the circadian clock by interaction of viral promoters, early viral proteins and transcription factors. It is proposed here that under certain conditions viral oncogene expression is phase-shifted relative to that of tumor suppressor and DNA repair genes. The resulting desynchrony of checkpoint controls and DNA repair from diurnal genotoxic exposure produces cyclic periods of suboptimal response to DNA damage. This temporal vulnerability to genotoxic stress produces a "mutator phenotype" with inherent genome instability. The proposed model delineates areas of research with implications for viral pathogenesis and therapeutics.

Natural biology of polyomavirus middle T antigen

"It has been commented by someone that 'polyoma' is an adjective composed of a prefix and suffix, with no root between--a meatless linguistic sandwich" (C. J. Dawe). The very name "polyomavirus" is a vague mantel: a name given before our understanding of these viral agents was clear but implying a clear tumor life-style, as noted by the late C. J. Dawe. However, polyomavirus are not by nature tumor-inducing agents. Since it is the purpose of this review to consider the natural function of middle T antigen (MT), encoded by one of the seemingly crucial transforming genes of polyomavirus, we will reconsider and redefine the virus and its MT gene in the context of its natural biology and function. This review was motivated by our recent in vivo analysis of MT function. Using intranasal inoculation of adult SCID mice, we have shown that polyomavirus can replicate with an MT lacking all functions associated with transformation to similar levels to wild-type virus. These observations, along with an almost indistinguishable replication of all MT mutants with respect to wild-type viruses in adult competent mice, illustrate that MT can have a play subtle role in acute replication and persistence. The most notable effect of MT mutants was in infections of newborns, indicating that polyomavirus may be highly adapted to replication in newborn lungs. It is from this context that our current understanding of this well-studied virus and gene is presented.

The distribution and kinetics of polyomavirus in lungs of intranasally infected newborn mice

The primary cell types that sustain polyomavirus (Py) replication following intranasal infection as well as the nature of the host cellular response to Py were unknown. As this is an essential and specific site for virus entry, it seems likely that viral gene function must be adapted to these mucosal tissues. Using immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridization, we determined the cell types in the lung that support Py gene expression and replication following intranasal inoculation of newborn mice within 24 h of birth. Lungs were collected daily from days 1 to 10 postinfection for Py DNA and early T antigen analysis and for histological examination by H&E staining, using methods that preserve the delicate newborn lung architecture. Viral DNA was present in increasing quantities from 2 to 6 dpi in a subset of the Clara cells lining the inner lumen of the bronchi and bronchioles, while T antigen expression was present in a majority of the cells in the bronchi and bronchiole lumen. A distinct and transient pattern of hyperplasia was observed among the cells expressing T antigen and was present from 3 through 6 dpi. Py DNA-containing cells exfoliated into the bronchiole lumen and alveolar ducts, but Py T antigen was not detected in these cells. Py DNA was first detected at 2 dpi, increased through 6 dpi, and abruptly declined through 9 dpi at which time there was no sign of viral DNA in the lungs by in situ hybridization. An unusual infiltration of neutrophils began before the presence of exfoliated cells or Py replication and continued for 2-3 days and was followed by a lymphocytic infiltration at 8-10 dpi lasting 2-3 days. Neither the hyperplasia nor the neutrophil infiltration occurred following infection with the MOP1033 MT-Ag or RB1 LT-Ag mutants of Py. In addition, both the neutrophil infiltration and the transient hyperplasia are in stark contrast to the heavy macrophage infiltration that follows infection of lungs with mouse adenovirus. Thus it appears that Py elicits a distinct host response pattern not seen with other DNA viral infections.

Approaches to study interactions between small DNA viruses and differentiated tissue

Polyomavirus (Py) derives its name from the early observation of multiple tumors that develop in newborn mice following inoculation with this family of viruses. In nature, however, tumor development is rare in the virus life cycle, rather a two-phase infection occurs, acute and persistent, resulting in a final latent infection in the kidneys. The acute phase induces an antiviral immune response, although no recognizable inflammation, which can last the lifetime of the mouse, even passing on antibodies to its offspring. The structure, replication, and expression of the Py viral genome in permissive and nonpermissive infections has been studied extensively in various cell culture systems. However, the nature of Py expression, replication, and immunopathogenesis in mice has not been thoroughly researched.

Potential role of DNA polymerase beta in gene therapy against cancer: a case for colorectal cancer

Genetic instability characterized by the accumulation of mutations of tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes appears to be associated with carcinogenesis in colorectal and other cancers. Mutations of DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) and related chromosomal alterations appear to be consistent with the causal role of a "mutator phenotype' in carcinogenesis. However, homozygous knockout pol beta mutations appear to interfere with embryogenesis. Increased pol beta activity (i.e. relative to pol alpha activity) has been associated with cell cycle arrest. The related aphidicolin-resistant DNA replication has been observed primarily in differentiating cells, including the mammalian blastocyst, adrenal cortex, thyroid, anterior pituitary, and the mechanism of endoreduplication (amitotic over-replication of DNA) can be traced to lower eukaryotes. This increased activity in relation to terminal commitment is inconsistent with a simple "DNA repair' view of pol beta. It is therefore proposed that pol beta may play a more fundamental role in cellular differentiation through involvement in a putative subgenomic DNA replication-based model of terminal gene expression. Thus genetic instability, loss of differentiation, and carcinogenesis may result from aberration(s) or "derailment' of such replication-based mechanism of terminal gene expression. It is suggested to examine the relationship of DNA pol beta to genomic instability and carcinogenesis using genetic analyses and antisense technology with possible applications for gene therapy against colorectal cancer.

The evolution of small DNA viruses of eukaryotes: past and present considerations

Historically, viral evolution has often been considered from the perspective of the ability of the virus to maintain viral pathogenic fitness by causing disease. A predator-prey model has been successfully applied to explain genetically variable quasi-species of viruses, such as influenza virus and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which evolve much faster rates than the host. In contrast, small DNA viruses (polyomaviruses, papillomaviruses, and parvoviruses) are species specific but are stable genetically, and appear to have co-evolved with their host species. Genetic stability is attributable primarily to the ability to establish and maintain a benign persistent state in vivo and not to the host DNA proofreading mechanisms. The persistent state often involves a cell cycle-regulated episomal state and a tight linkage of DNA amplification mechanisms to cellular differentiation. This linkage requires conserved features among viral regulatory proteins, with characteristic host-interactive domains needed to recruit and utilize host machinery, thus imposing mechanistic constrains on possible evolutionary options. Sequence similarities within these domains are seen amongst all small mammalian DNA viruses and most of the parvo-like viruses, including those that span the entire spectrum of evolution of organisms from E. coli to humans that replicate via a rolling circle-like mechanism among the entire spectrum of organisms throughout evolution from E. coli to humans. To achieve benign inapparent viral persistence, small DNA viruses are proposed to circumvent the host acute phase reaction (characterized by minimal inflammation) by mechanisms that are evolutionarily adapted to the immune system and the related cytokine communication networks. A striking example of this is the relationship of hymenoptera to polydnaviruses, in which the crucial to the recognition of self, development, and maintenance of genetic identity of both the host and virus. These observations in aggregate suggest that viral replicons are not recent "escapies" of host replication, but rather provide relentless pressure in driving the evolution of the host through cospeciation.

n-Butyrate, a cell cycle blocker, inhibits the replication of polyomaviruses and papillomaviruses but not that of adenoviruses and herpesviruses

Small DNA viruses are dependent on the interaction of early proteins (such as large T antigen) with host p53 and Rb to bring about the G1-to-S cell cycle transition. The large DNA viruses are less dependent on host regulatory genes since additional early viral proteins (such as viral DNA polymerase, DNA metabolic enzymes, and other replication proteins) are involved in DNA synthesis. A highly conserved domain of large T antigen (similar to the p53-binding region) exclusively identifies papovavirus, parvovirus, and papillomaviruses from all other larger DNA viruses and implies a conserved interaction with host regulatory genes. In this report, we show that 3 to 6 mM butyrate, a general cell cycle blocker implicated in inhibition of the G1-to-S transition, inhibits DNA replication of polyomavirus and human papillomavirus type 11 but not the replication of larger DNA viruses such as adenovirus types 2 and 5, herpes simplex virus type 1, Epstein-Barr virus, and cytomegalovirus, which all bypass the butyrate-mediated cell cycle block. This butyrate effect on polyomavirus replication is not cell type specific, nor does it depend on the p53 or Rb gene, as inhibition was seen in fibroblasts with intact or homozygous deleted p53 or Rb, 3T6 cells, keratinocytes, C2C12 myoblasts, and 3T3-L1 adipocytes. In addition, butyrate did not inhibit expression of polyomavirus T antigen. The antiviral effect of butyrate involves a form of imprinted state, since pretreatment of cells with 3 mM butyrate inhibits human papillomavirus type 11 DNA replication for at least 96 h after its removal. Butyrate, therefore, serves as a molecular tool in dissecting the life cycle of smaller DNA viruses from that of the larger DNA viruses in relation to the cell cycle.

Aphidicolin-resistant polyomavirus and subgenomic cellular DNA synthesis occur early in the differentiation of cultured myoblasts to myotubes

Small DNA viruses have been historically used as probes of cellular control mechanisms of DNA replication, gene expression, and differentiation. Polyomavirus (Py) DNA replication is known to be linked to differentiation of may cells, including myoblasts. In this report, we use this linkage in myoblasts to simultaneously examine (i) cellular differentiation control of Py DNA replication and (ii) an unusual type of cellular and Py DNA synthesis during differentiation. Early proposals that DNA synthesis was involved in the induced differentiation of myoblasts to myotubes were apparently disproved by reliance on inhibitors of DNA synthesis (cytosine arabinoside and aphidicolin), which indicated that mitosis and DNA replication are not necessary for differentiation. Theoretical problems with the accessibility of inactive chromatin to trans-acting factors led us to reexamine possible involvement of DNA replication in myoblast differentiation. We show here that Py undergoes novel aphidicolin-resistant net DNA synthesis under specific conditions early in induced differentiation of myoblasts (following delayed aphidicolin addition). Under similar conditions, we also examined uninfected myoblast DNA synthesis, and we show that soon after differentiation induction, a period of aphidicolin-resistant cellular DNA synthesis can also be observed. This drug-resistant DNA synthesis appears to be subgenomic, not contributing to mitosis, and more representative of polyadenylated than of nonpolyadenylated RNA. These results renew the possibility that DNA synthesis plays a role in myoblast differentiation and suggest that the linkage of Py DNA synthesis to differentiation may involve a qualitative cellular alteration in Py DNA replication.

Coevolution of persistently infecting small DNA viruses and their hosts linked to host-interactive regulatory domains

Although most RNA viral genomes (and related cellular retroposons) can evolve at rates a millionfold greater than that of their host genomes, some of the small DNA viruses (polyomaviruses and papillomaviruses) appear to evolve at much slower rates. These DNA viruses generally cause host species-specific inapparent primary infections followed by life-long, benign persistent infections. Using global progressive sequence alignments for kidney-specific Polyomaviridae (mouse, hamster, primate, human), we have constructed parsimonious evolutionary trees for the viral capsid proteins (VP1, VP2/VP3) and the large tumor (T) antigen. We show that these three coding sequences can yield phylogenetic trees similar to each other and to that of their host species. Such virus-host "co-speciation" appears incongruent with some prevailing views of viral evolution, and we suggest that inapparent persistent infections may link virus and most host evolution. Similarity analysis identified three specific regions of polyoma regulatory gene products (T antigens) as highly conserved, and two of these regions correspond to binding sites for host regulatory proteins (p53, the retinoblastoma gene product p105, and the related protein p107). The p53 site overlaps with a conserved ATPase domain and the retinoblastoma site corresponds to conserved region 1 of E1A protein of adenovirus type 5. We examined the local conservation of these binding sequences and show that the conserved retinoblastoma binding domain is characteristic and inclusive of the entire polyomavirus family, but the conserved p53-like binding domain is characteristic and inclusive of three entire families of small DNA viruses: polyomaviruses, papillomaviruses, and parvoviruses. The evolution of small-DNA-virus families may thus be tightly linked to host evolution and speciation by interaction with a subset of host regulatory proteins.

Adult mouse kidneys become permissive to acute polyomavirus infection and reactivate persistent infections in response to cellular damage and regeneration

Kidneys of newborn (but not adult) mice are normally high permissive for polyomavirus (Py) infection and readily establish persistent infections. We have proposed that ongoing cellular differentiation, which occurs in newborn mice, may be necessary for a high level of in vivo Py replication (R. Rochford, J. P. Moreno, M. L. Peake, and L. P. Villarreal, J. Virol. 66:3287-3297, 1992). This cellular differentiation requirement may also be necessary for the reactivation of a persistent Py kidney infection and could provide an alternative to the accepted view that reactivation results from immunosuppression. To examine this proposal, the ability of adult BALB/c mouse kidneys to support primary acute Py infection or to reactivate previously established persistent Py infections after kidney-specific damage was investigated. Kidney damage was induced by both chemical (glycerol, cisplatin, or methotrexate) and mechanical (through renal artery clamping to produce unilateral renal ischemia) treatments. We also examined the effects of epidermal growth factor (EGF), which enhances the rate of kidney regeneration, on Py replication. Using histopathologic techniques, in situ hybridization for Py DNA, and immunofluorescence for Py VP1 production, we established that both chemical damage and damage through renal artery clamping of adult kidneys promoted high levels of primary Py replication in these normally nonpermissive cells. This damage also promoted the efficient reactivation of Py replication from persistently infected kidneys, in the absence of immunosuppression. EGF treatment significantly increased acute Py replication and also reactivation in damaged kidneys. These results support the view that ongoing cellular division and differentiation may be needed both for high levels of acute Py replication and for reactivation of persistent infections in vivo.

Enhancer dependence of polyomavirus persistence in mouse kidneys

We previously showed that alterations in the enhancer sequence of polyomavirus DNA can alter both the level and the organ specificity of viral DNA replication during the acute phase of infection of newborn mice (R. Rochford, B. A. Campbell, and L. P. Villarreal, J. Virol. 64:476-485, 1990). In this study, we examined whether these enhancer sequence alterations can also affect polyomavirus replication during the persistent phase of infection in vivo. After infection of newborn mice with a mixture of three enhancer variants, the individual organs could select for enhancer-specific viral DNA replication during both the acute and the persistent phases of infection. Contrary to expectations, the ability of some variants to establish a high-level acute infection in some organs (e.g., the pancreas) did not necessarily lead to a persistent infection in those organs. Thus, enhancers can affect acute and persistent infections differently. In addition, some enhancer variants tended to establish a high-level persistent infection in the kidneys immediately following an acute infection; however, in all cases considerable histopathology was associated with these elevated long-term infections, and these mice were always runty. A persistent infection in the kidneys thus appears able to exist in two distinguishable states, a high-level pathological state and a low-level nonpathological state, which can be affected by the viral enhancer sequence.