Infant contrast detectors are selective for direction of motion

A discrete magno-parvo additive model in early vision for explaining brightness perception in varying contrastive contexts

A varying contrastive context filter (VCCF)-based model of brightness perception has been proposed. It is motivated first by a recently proposed difference of difference-of-Gaussian (DDOG) filter. Alongside, it is also inspired from the fact that the nature evolves various discrete systems and mechanisms to carry out many of its complex tasks. A weight factor, used for the linear combination of two filters representing the magnocellular and parvocellular channels in the central visual pathway, has been defined and termed as the factor of contrastive context (FOCC) in the present model. This is a binary variable that lends a property of discretization to the DDOG filter. By analyzing important brightness contrast as well as brightness assimilation illusions, we arrive at the minimal set of values (only two) for FOCC, using which one is able to successfully predict the direction of brightness shift in both situations of brightness contrast, claimed and categorized here as low contrastive context, and those of brightness assimilation, claimed and categorized here as high contrastive context perception, depending upon whether the initial M-channel-filtered stimulus is above or below a threshold of the contrastive context. As distinct from Michelson/Weber/RMS contrast, high or low, the contrastive context claimed is dependent on the edge information in the stimulus determined by the Laplacian operator, also used in the DDOG model. We compared the proposed model against the already well-established oriented difference-of-Gaussian (ODOG) model of brightness perception. Extensive simulations suggest that though for most illusions both ODOG and VCCF produce correct output, for certain intricate cases in which the ODOG filter fails to correctly predict the illusory effect, our proposed VCCF model continues to remain effective.

Development of contrast normalization mechanisms during childhood and adolescence

Contrast sensitivity is regulated by neural mechanisms that flexibly adjust responsiveness to optimize stimulus encoding across different environments. Here we studied the developmental status of gain control mechanisms in school-age children (5-17years) and adults using a visual masking paradigm. A variable contrast, spatially random 2-D noise test pattern was masked by the presence of a superimposed independent noise pattern presented at 0, 12 and 40% contrast. Frequency-tagged steady state visual evoked potentials were used to separately record responses to the test (5.14Hz) and the mask (7.2Hz). By incrementally increasing the test contrast we measured contrast response functions for each mask contrast. The unmasked contrast response functions were largely similar in shape across age, but peak amplitude was higher in the children. Masking shifted the contrast response function rightward on the contrast axis in both the adults and older children, elevating contrast thresholds by a similar factor across age. However, in younger children, masking resulted in a change in the slope of the contrast response function. These findings suggest that immaturity in the contrast normalization process persists until approximately 11years of age.

Multiple dimension processing by newborns

Newborn looking toward novel stimuli containing a single or two novel dimensions was assessed in two studies. In Study 1, newborns were habituated to a visual stimulus containing stimulus movement and line orientation information. Following habituation, stimuli containing two novel dimensions were attended to more than stimuli containing a single novel dimension. It was also demonstrated that newborns detect stimulus movement changes. In Study 2, stimuli containing novel colour and line orientation information, following habituation, were attended to across three test trials more than stimuli containing a novel colour only. Colour discrimination was also demonstrated. It was concluded that newborns appear to attend to stimuli containing two novel dimensions differently than those containing a single novel dimension. It was suggested that newborns employ an analytic mode of processing to detect novel dimensions. Further research is required to verify this conclusion and to determine what component is first attended to.

Motion perception: a review of developmental changes and the role of early visual experience

Significant controversies have arisen over the developmental trajectory for the perception of global motion. Studies diverge on the age at which it becomes adult-like, with estimates ranging from as young as 3 years to as old as 16. In this article, we review these apparently conflicting results and suggest a potentially unifying hypothesis that may also account for the contradictory literature in neurodevelopmental disorders, such as Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). We also discuss the extent to which patterned visual input during this period is necessary for the later development of motion perception. We conclude by addressing recent studies directly comparing different types of motion integration, both in typical and atypical development, and suggest areas ripe for future research.

Development of sampling efficiency and internal noise in motion detection and discrimination in school-aged children

The aim of this study was to use an equivalent noise paradigm to investigate the development and maturation of motion perception, and how the underlying limitations of sampling efficiency and internal noise effect motion detection and direction discrimination in school-aged children (5-14 years) and adults. Contrast energy thresholds of a 2c/deg sinusoidal grating drifting at 1.0 or 6.0 Hz were measured as a function of added dynamic noise in three tasks: detection of a drifting grating; detection of the sum of two oppositely drifting gratings and direction discrimination of oppositely drifting gratings. Compared to the ideal observer, in both children and adults, the performance for all tasks was limited by reduced sampling efficiency and internal noise. However, the thresholds for discrimination of motion direction and detection of moving gratings show very different developmental profiles. Motion direction discrimination continues to improve after the age of 14 years due to an increase in sampling efficiency that differs with speed. Motion detection and summation were already mature at the age of 5 years, and internal noise was the same for all tasks. These findings were confirmed in a 1-year follow-up study on a group of children from the initial study. The results support suggestions that the detection of a moving pattern and discriminating motion direction are processed by different systems that may develop at different rates.

The development of global motion discrimination in school aged children

Global motion perception matures during childhood and involves the detection of local directional signals that are integrated across space. We examine the maturation of local directional selectivity and global motion integration with an equivalent noise paradigm applied to direction discrimination. One hundred and three observers (6-17 years) identified the global direction of motion in a 2AFC task. The 8° central stimuli consisted of 100 dots of 10% Michelson contrast moving 2.8°/s or 9.8°/s. Local directional selectivity and global sampling efficiency were estimated from direction discrimination thresholds as a function of external directional noise, speed, and age. Direction discrimination thresholds improved gradually until the age of 14 years (linear regression, p < 0.05) for both speeds. This improvement was associated with a gradual increase in sampling efficiency (linear regression, p < 0.05), with no significant change in internal noise. Direction sensitivity was lower for dots moving at 2.8°/s than at 9.8°/s for all ages (paired t test, p < 0.05) and is mainly due to lower sampling efficiency. Global motion perception improves gradually during development and matures by age 14. There was no change in internal noise after the age of 6, suggesting that local direction selectivity is mature by that age. The improvement in global motion perception is underpinned by a steady increase in the efficiency with which direction signals are pooled, suggesting that global motion pooling processes mature for longer and later than local motion processing.

The face inversion effect in infants is driven by high, and not low, spatial frequencies

To investigate the mechanisms underlying development of upright face preferences in infants, the current study measured inversion effects for faces that were spatial frequency (SF) filtered, into low SF and high SF, with the notion that different SFs are analyzed by different visual mechanisms. For comparison to faces, we used object stimuli that consisted of pictures of strollers. In 4 month olds, 8 month olds, and adults, we measured the strength of the selective face inversion effect (sFIE), operationally defined as an upright over inverted looking preference that is greater for faces than objects. In Study 1, we employed unfiltered stimuli, and found a clear sFIE in both infants and adults. To determine what drove this sFIE, in Study 2, the sFIE was measured for low-SF and high-SF stimuli, with all stimuli being equated for visibility. For adults, the sFIE was equally strong for low-SF and high-SF stimuli. A different pattern was seen for infants. Infants exhibited a significantly greater sFIE for high-SF, than for low-SF, stimuli (and only for high SF was the sFIE significant). In fact, the strength of infants' upright face preference for high-SF stimuli was indistinguishable from that observed for unfiltered faces, indicating that in natural (unfiltered) stimuli, high SFs are sufficient to account for infants' upright face preferences.

Fast development of global motion processing in human infants

Although global motion processing is thought to emerge early in infancy, there is debate regarding the age at which it matures to an adult-like level. In the current study, we address the possibility that the apparent age-related improvement in global motion processing might be secondary to age-related increases in the sensitivity of mechanisms (i.e., local motion detectors) that provide input to global motion mechanisms. To address this, we measured global motion processing by obtaining motion coherence thresholds using stimuli that were equally detectable in terms of contrast across all individuals and ages (3-, 4-, 5-, 6-, and 7-month-olds and adults). For infants, we employed a directional eye movement (DEM) technique. For adults, we employed both DEM and a self-report method. First, contrast sensitivity was obtained for a local task, using a stochastic motion display in which all the dots moved coherently. Contrast sensitivity increased significantly between 3 and 7 months, and between infancy and adulthood. Each subject was then tested on the global motion task with the contrast of the dots set to 2.5 × each individual's contrast threshold. Coherence thresholds were obtained by varying the percentage of coherently moving "signal" versus "noise" dots in the stochastic motion display. Results revealed remarkably stable global motion sensitivity between 3 and 7 months of age, as well as between infancy and adulthood. These results suggest that the mechanisms underlying global motion processing develop to an adult-like state very quickly.

Development of face discrimination abilities, and relationship to magnocellular pathway development, between childhood and adulthood

The current study tested the development of face and object processing in young children (mean age = 5.24 years), adolescents (mean age = 15.8 years), and adults (mean age = 21.1 years) using stimuli that were equated for low-level visual characteristics (luminance, contrast, and spatial frequency make-up) and methods that equate for difficulty across ages. We also tested sensitivity to luminance and chromatic contrast (i.e., thought to be mediated primarily by the subcortical Magnocellular (M) and Parvocellular (P) pathways, respectively) to determine whether age-related improvements in face or object discrimination were driven by age-related changes in the M and/or P pathways. Results showed a selective age-related improvement in face sensitivity and a relationship between age-related increases in face sensitivity and luminance contrast sensitivity. These results add to the mounting evidence that the M pathway may influence face processing.

Delayed luminance and chromatic contrast sensitivity in infants with spontaneously regressed retinopathy of prematurity

BACKGROUND

The current study assessed whether contrast sensitivity is affected in preterm infants with a history of spontaneously regressed retinopathy of prematurity (ROP, Stages 1-3). Specifically, we employed luminance (light/dark) and chromatic (red/green) stimuli, which are mediated by the magnocellular (M) and parvocellular (P) subcortical pathways, respectively.

METHODS

Contrast sensitivity (CS) was measured using forced-choice preferential looking testing in 21 infants with a history of ROP and 41 control preterm infants who were born prematurely but did not develop ROP, tested between 8 and 47 weeks (2-11 months) postterm age. Infants were presented with chromatic and luminance drifting sinusoidal gratings, which appeared randomly on the left or right side of the monitor in each trial. The contrast of the stimuli varied across trials and was defined in terms of root mean squared cone contrast for long- and medium-wavelength cones.

RESULTS

Between 8 and 25 weeks postterm, ROP infants had significantly worse CS, and there was a trend for greater impairment for luminance than chromatic CS. This delay was not seen at older ages between 26 and 47 weeks postterm.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings are consistent with the concept that early maturation of the M pathway is vulnerable to biological insult, as in the case of ROP, to a greater extent than in the P pathway.

Effects of prematurity on the development of contrast sensitivity: testing the visual experience hypothesis

In order to investigate the effects of visual experience on early visual development, the current study compared contrast sensitivity across infants born with different degrees of moderate-to-late prematurity. Here the logic is that at any given postterm age, the most premature infants will have the oldest postnatal age. Given that postnatal age is a proxy for visual experience, the visual experience hypothesis predicts that infants who are more premature, yet healthy, should have higher sensitivity. Luminance (light/dark) and chromatic (red/green) contrast sensitivities (CS) were measured in 236 healthy infants (born -10 to +2 weeks relative to due date) between 5 and 32 weeks postterm age from due date and 8-38 weeks postnatal from birth date. For chromatic CS, we found clear evidence that infants who were most premature within our sample had the highest sensitivity. Specifically, 4-10 additional weeks of visual experience, by virtue of being born early, enhanced chromatic CS. For luminance CS, similar but weaker results were seen. Here, only infants with an additional 6-10 weeks of visual experience, and only at later age points in development, showed enhanced sensitivity. However, CS in preterm infants was still below that of fullterm infants with equivalent postnatal age. In sum, these results suggest that chromatic CS is influenced more by prematurity (and possibly visual experience) than luminance CS, which has implications for differential development of parvocellular and magnocellular pathways.

Time crawls: the temporal resolution of infants' visual attention

Conscious visual perception of the constantly changing environment is one of the brain's most critical functions. In virtually every moment of every daily activity, the visual system is confronted with the task of accurately representing and interpreting scenes that change rapidly over time. Adults can judge the identity and order of changing images presented at a rate of up to 10 Hz (~50 ms per image); this limit reflects a finite temporal resolution of attention. In the research reported here, although 6- to 15-month-old infants could detect the presence of rapid flicker without difficulty, their ability to segment individual alternating states within the flicker was severely limited: Fifteen-month-old infants had a temporal resolution of attention approximately one order of magnitude lower than that of adults (~1 Hz). Coarse temporal resolution constrains how infants perceive and utilize dynamic visual information and may play a role in the visual processing deficits found in individuals with neurodevelopmental disorders.

Chromatic and luminance contrast sensitivity in fullterm and preterm infants

In order to investigate the contributions of visual experience vs. preprogrammed mechanisms on visual development, the current study compared contrast sensitivity in preterm vs. fullterm infants. If development is tied to time since conception, preterm infants should match the developmental trajectories of fullterm infants when plotted in postterm age. By contrast, if development is influenced by visual experience, preterm and fullterm infants should match when plotted in postnatal age. Luminance (light/dark) and chromatic (red/green) contrast sensitivities (CS) were measured in 25 preterm (born, on average, 6.6 weeks early) and 77 fullterm infants, between 1 and 6 months postterm. In the first few months, luminance CS was found to be predicted by postterm age, suggesting that preprogrammed development is sufficient to account for luminance CS. By contrast, chromatic CS exceeded that predicted by postterm age, which suggests that time since birth confers a benefit on chromatic CS. The preterms' 6.6 weeks of additional time since birth is roughly equivalent to 3.7 weeks of development in chromatic CS. In sum, these results suggest that chromatic CS is more influenced by early postnatal visual experience than luminance CS, which may have implications for development of parvocellular and magnocellular pathways.

Effects of gestational length, gender, postnatal age, and birth order on visual contrast sensitivity in infants

To investigate effects of visual experience versus preprogrammed mechanisms on visual development, we used multiple regression analysis to determine the extent to which a variety of variables (that differ in the extent to which they are tied to visual experience) predict luminance and chromatic (red/green) contrast sensitivity (CS), which are mediated by the magnocellular (M) and parvocellular (P) subcortical pathways, respectively. Our variables included gestational length (GL), birth weight (BW), gender, postnatal age (PNA), and birth order (BO). Two-month-olds (n = 60) and 6-month-olds (n = 122) were tested. Results revealed that (1) at 2 months, infants with longer GL have higher luminance CS; (2) at both ages, CS significantly increases over a approximately 21-day range of PNA, but this effect is stronger in 2- than 6-month-olds and stronger for chromatic than luminance CS; (3) at 2 months, boys have higher luminance CS than girls; and (4) at 2 months, firstborn infants have higher CS, while at 6 months, non-firstborn infants have higher CS. The results for PNA/GL are consistent with the possibility that P pathway development is more influenced by variables tied to visual experience (PNA), while M pathway development is more influenced by variables unrelated to visual experience (GL). Other variables, including prenatal environment, are also discussed.

Behavioral measurement of temporal contrast sensitivity development in macaque monkeys (Macaca nemestrina)

We measured the developmental time course for temporal contrast sensitivity in macaque monkeys. The animals, aged 5 weeks to 4 years, detected an unpatterned field of light sinusoidally modulated over time at frequencies ranging from 1 to 40 Hz. Young infants showed reduced sensitivity for all frequencies, and a reduced range of detectable frequencies. Sensitivity to high and low frequencies developed at different rates, but the shape of the temporal contrast sensitivity function did not change significantly with age. Temporal contrast sensitivity matures earlier than spatial contrast sensitivity. The development of high, but not low, frequency sensitivity may be limited by maturation of the magnocellular pathway.

Abnormal magnocellular pathway visual processing in infants at risk for autism

BACKGROUND

A wealth of data has documented impairments in face processing in individuals with autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Recently, the suggestion has been made that these impairments may arise from abnormal development of a subcortical system involved in face processing that originates in the magnocellular pathway of the primate visual system.

METHODS

To test this developmental hypothesis, we obtained visual perceptual data from 6-month-old infants who were at risk for ASD because they had an older sibling diagnosed with the disorder ("high-risk infants"). To measure sensitivity of the magnocellular (M) pathway and, for comparison, of the parvocellular (P) visual pathway, we employed visual stimuli designed to selectively stimulate the two. Sensitivity data from high-risk infants (n = 13) were compared with data from matched control infants (i.e., "low-risk" infants with no family history of ASD, n = 26).

RESULTS

On the P pathway stimulus, high-risk infants exhibited sensitivities that were identical to those of control infants. By contrast, on the M pathway stimulus, high-risk infants exhibited sensitivities nearly twofold greater than those of control infants.

CONCLUSIONS

Given that ASD and its symptoms are known to run in families, these preliminary results suggest that ASD may be associated with abnormal M pathway function early in infancy, which may aid in early diagnosis of the disorder.

Infants' perception of subjective contours from apparent motion

We examined infants' perception of subjective contours in Subjective-Contour-from-Apparent-Motion (SCAM) stimuli [e.g., Cicerone, C. M., Hoffman, D. D., Gowdy, P. D., & Kim, J. S. (1995). The perception of color from motion. Perception & Psychophysics, 57, 761-777] using the preferential looking technique. The SCAM stimulus is composed of random dots which are assigned two different colors. Circular region assigned one color moved apparently, keeping all dots' location unchanged. In the SCAM stimulus, adults can perceive subjective color spreading and subjective contours in apparent motion (http://c-faculty.chuo-u.ac.jp/ approximately ymasa/okamura/ibd_demo.html). In the present study, we conducted two experiments by using this type of SCAM stimulus. A total of thirty-six 3-8-month-olds participated. In experiment 1, we presented two stimuli to the infants side by side: a SCAM stimulus consisting of different luminance, and a non-SCAM stimulus consisting of isoluminance dots. The results indicated that the 5-8-month-olds showed preference for the SCAM stimuli. In experiments 2 and 3, we confirmed that the infants' preference for the SCAM stimulus was not generated by the local difference and local change made by luminance of dots but by the subjective contours. These results suggest that 5-8-month-olds were able to perceive subjective contours in the SCAM stimuli.

Integration of one- and two-dimensional motion signals in infants: evidence from the barber-pole illusion

Several previous studies in adults have investigated how one- and two-dimensional moving features are integrated into a coherent global motion percept by studying the "barber-pole illusion"; when a one-dimensional moving grating is presented within a rectangular aperture, the two-dimensional line terminators at the edges of the aperture bias the perceived direction of motion toward the longer axis of the aperture. In the current study, we used barber-pole stimuli to investigate the development of motion mechanisms that integrate one- and two-dimensional motion signals. Using a directional eye movement technique, we measured responses to obliquely moving gratings presented within horizontally vs. vertically oriented apertures, in infants (ages 2-5 months) and adults. For all ages, we found that horizontal eye movements were significantly stronger when gratings were presented within horizontal than within vertical apertures, as predicted by the barber-pole illusion. Additionally, we devised a way to infer the "effective shift" in eye movement direction produced by the barber-pole illusion. Using a simple motion integration model, effective shift values were then used to calculate the relative weightings of one- and two-dimensional motion signals to direction coding. The results show that by 2 months of age, infants integrate one- and two-dimensional motion signals, and that the relative weighting of one- and two-dimensional signals remains roughly constant from 2 months of age into adulthood.

Motion detection in normal infants and young patients with infantile esotropia

The purpose of this study was to investigate asymmetries in detection of horizontal motion in normal infants and children and in patients with infantile esotropia. Motion detection thresholds (% motion signal) were measured in 75 normal infants and in 36 eyes of 27 infants with infantile esotropia (ET), using a forced-choice preferential looking paradigm with random-dot patterns. Absolute motion detection sensitivity and asymmetries in sensitivity for nasalward (N) vs. temporalward (T) directions of motion were compared in normal and patient populations, ranging in age from 1 month to 5 years. In normal infants, N and T thresholds were equivalent under 2.5 months of age, whereas a superiority for monocular detection of N motion was observed between 3.5 and 6.5 months of age. The nasalward advantage gradually diminished to symmetrical T:N performance by 8 months of age, matching that of adults. No asymmetry was observed in 15 normal infants who performed the task binocularly, hence, the asymmetry was not a leftward/rightward bias. In the youngest infantile ET patients tested, at 5 months of age, a nasalward superiority in motion detection was observed and was equivalent to that of same-age normal infants. However, unlike normals, this asymmetry persists in older patients. This greater asymmetry in infantile ET represents worse detection of T than N motion. This is the first report of an asymmetry in motion detection in normal infants across a wide age range. Initially, motion detection is normal in infants with infantile esotropia. Cumulative abnormal binocular experience in these patients may disrupt motion mechanisms.

Putting order into the development of sensitivity to global motion

We studied differences in the development of sensitivity to first-versus second-order global motion by comparing the motion coherence thresholds of 5-year-olds and adults tested at three speeds (1.5, 6, and 9 degrees s(-1)). We used Random Gabor Kinematograms (RGKs) formed with luminance-modulated (first-order) or contrast-modulated (second-order) concentric Gabor patterns with a sinusoidal spatial frequency of 3c deg(-1). To achieve equal visibility, modulation depth was set at 30% for first-order Gabors and at 100%, for second-order Gabors. Subjects were 24 adults and 24 5-year-olds. For both first- and second-order global motion, the motion coherence threshold of 5-year-olds was less mature for the slowest speed (1.5 degrees s(-1)) than for the two faster speeds (6 and 9 degrees s(-1)). In addition, at the slowest speed, the immaturity was greater for second-order than for first-order global motion. The findings suggest that the extrastriate mechanisms underlying the perception of global motion are different, at least in part, for first- versus second-order signals and for slower versus faster speeds. They also suggest that those separate mechanisms mature at different rates during middle childhood.

Normal and anomalous development of visual motion processing: motion coherence and 'dorsal-stream vulnerability'

Directional motion processing is a pervasive and functionally important feature of the visual system. Behavioural and VEP studies indicate that it appears as a cortical function after about 7 weeks of age, with global processing, motion based segmentation, and the use of motion in complex perceptual tasks emerging shortly afterwards. A distinct, subcortical motion system controls optokinetic nystagmus (OKN) from birth, showing characteristic monocular asymmetries which disappear as binocular cortical function takes over in normal development. Asymmetries in cortical responses are linked to this interaction in a way that is not yet fully understood. Beyond infancy, a range of developmental disorders show a deficit of global motion compared to global form processing which we argue reflects a general 'dorsal-stream vulnerability'.

Sampling efficiency and internal noise for motion detection, discrimination, and summation

By comparing real observers to an ideal observer, previous studies have found that the detection of static patterns is limited by internal noise and by imperfect sampling efficiency. We developed and applied ideal observer models for the detection, discrimination, and summation of oppositely drifting gratings in Gaussian white noise. The three tasks share a common source of internal noise. The sampling efficiencies were on the order of 1-2% except for much lower efficiency in direction discrimination for faster moving gratings. The efficiency of direction discrimination relative to detection systematically declines as the speed is increased from 1 to 6 Hz. These results suggest that observers use mismatched filters tuned to slow speeds regardless of the signal speed. Human visual motion sensing appears to use distorted representations of the incoming signals, and this distortion is a major limitation to visual performance.

Development of psychophysically-derived detection contours in L- and M-cone contrast space

In order to investigate the development of color mechanisms in infants we fitted elliptical detection contours to psychophysically-derived contrast thresholds plotted in L- and M-cone contrast space. Detection ellipses were obtained for 47 infants (ages 2-5 months of age), and were compared to those of six adults tested under nearly identical conditions. The parameters of the fitted ellipses allowed us to address several aspects of color development. First, the lengths and widths were used to assess the relative development of chromatic, with respect to luminance, sensitivity. The results of these analyses revealed a sharp increase in chromatic sensitivity between 3 and 4 months of age, suggesting an accelerated development of chromatic mechanisms around this time. Second, the angles of the ellipses provided estimates of individual red/green isoluminance points. In line with previous reports, we found that isoluminance points do not vary significantly with age. Finally, our ellipse-fitting procedures were used to assess whether color sensitivity is best described by a model that assumes independence between post-receptoral chromatic and luminance mechanisms. Similar to previous results of Kelly and Chang [Kelly, J. P. & Chang, S. (2000). Vision Research 40, 1887-1906] obtained using steady-state visually evoked potentials, only a proportion (approximately half) of our infants exhibited detection contours that were consistent with independent mechanisms, a finding that most likely results from statistical noise in the infant data sets.

The effect of contrast on vertical motion processing asymmetries in 11-week-old infants

Recent forced-choice preferential looking (FPL) experiments with random-dot patterns [Wattam-Bell, 1998 Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 39(4) S885] found evidence for a perceptual asymmetry of vertical-motion processing in young infants: a preference for patterns that move downwards. This asymmetry was in the opposite direction to the asymmetry of vertical optokinetic nystagmus, which was biased towards upwards motion. However, the FPL bias was weak, and the object of present experiments was to explore the possibility that it could be enhanced by reducing stimulus contrast. In experiment 1, contrast thresholds for gratings moving upwards and downwards were compared, and no directional asymmetry at threshold was found. In experiment 2, the effect of contrast on infants' preference between simultaneously displayed upwards-drifting and downwards-drifting gratings was examined. Infants showed no preference at 5% contrast, a marked preference for downwards motion at intermediate contrasts (10% and 20%), and a similar but smaller preference at 40% contrast. These results suggest that the vertical-motion asymmetry is a result of differences in the gains of directionally selective mechanisms for upwards and downwards motion.

Infant direction discrimination thresholds

Although adults can detect direction differences as small as 1 arc degree, the ability of infants to discriminate direction of motion is less clear. This study measures the precision with which 6-, 12-, and 18-week-old infants discriminate direction of motion. Infants viewed random dot kinematograms in which a direction difference between the target and background dots defined a circular target. The target was then placed into continuous motion. An FPL paradigm was used to assess infants' preference for the target as a function of the direction difference between the target and background dots. Direction discrimination thresholds with a moving target were indeterminate at 6 weeks of age, 22 degrees at 12 weeks of age and 17 degrees at 18 weeks of age. This precision was maintained across different testing conditions. However, performance dropped markedly when dot motion was presented within a flickering stationary target. It was concluded that infants can make relatively fine discriminations of motion direction if given an engaging stimulus.

Infant light adaptation shows Weber's law at photopic illuminances

In the present study we investigate the dependence of photopic contrast thresholds on retinal illuminance in infants and adults. Contrast thresholds were measured at five retinal illuminances between about 6 and about 20,000 Td in subjects in both age groups. The forced-choice preferential looking technique was used in 3-month-old infants, and standard forced-choice techniques were used in adults. The stimulus was a 0.25 cy/deg squarewave grating phase alternated at 6 Hz. Infants' contrast thresholds were more than two log units higher than those of adults at all retinal illuminances. Contrast thresholds had a similar dependence on retinal illuminance in both infants and adults. For both age groups, contrast thresholds initially decreased with increasing retinal illuminance. However, at both ages, above a critical illuminance of about 200 Td, contrast thresholds remained constant, following Weber's law. Thus a vertical shift was sufficient to bring the two data sets into correspondence. In the context of a two-site model of light adaptation, our results imply that infants' elevated contrast thresholds cannot be explained solely on the basis of photoreceptoral immaturities. Later physiological immaturities must also limit infants' photopic contrast thresholds.

Spatial frequency tuned covariance channels for red-green and luminance-modulated gratings: psychophysical data from human infants

This study concerns the spatial-frequency-tuned channels underlying infants' contrast sensitivity functions (CSFs) for red-green chromatic stimuli, and their relationship to the channels underlying infants' CSFs for luminance-modulated stimuli. Behavioral (forced-choice preferential-looking) techniques and stationary stimuli were used. In experiment 1. contrast thresholds were measured in 4- and 6-month-olds, using isoluminant red-green gratings with spatial frequencies ranging from 0.27 to 1.53 c deg. In experiment 2. contrast thresholds were measured in 4-month-olds. using both red-green and luminance-modulated gratings in the same low spatial frequency range. Covariance analyses of individual differences were performed. Experiment 1 revealed one dominant covariance channel for the detection of red-green gratings, with a second channel contributing to detection of the highest spatial frequencies used. Experiment 2 revealed two to three channels serving color and luminance: but surprisingly these channels were not statistically separable for luminance versus chromatic stimuli. Thus, covariance channels for color and luminance that are independent for adults [Peterzell & Teller (2000). Spatial frequency tuned covariance channels for red-green and luminance-modulated gratings: psychophysical data from human adults. Vision Research, 40, 417-430] are apparently interdependent in infants. These data suggest that for infants, detection thresholds for chromatic and luminance-modulated stimuli may be limited by common mechanisms.

Spatial frequency tuned covariance channels for red-green and luminance-modulated gratings: psychophysical data from human adults

Both chromatic and luminance-modulated stimuli are served by multiple spatial-frequency-tuned channels. This experiment investigated the independence versus interdependence of spatial frequency channels that serve the detection of red-green chromatic versus yellow-black luminance-modulated stimuli at low spatial frequencies. Contrast thresholds for both chromatic and luminance-modulated gratings were measured within 12 individual subjects using a repeated-measures design. Spatial frequencies ranged from 0.27 to 2.16 c/deg. A covariance structure analysis of individual differences was applied to the data. We computed statistical sources of individual variability, used them to define covariance channels, and determined the number and frequency tuning of these channels. For luminance-modulated gratings, two covariance channels were found, including one above and one below 1 c/deg [cf. Peterzell, & Teller (1996). Individual differences in contrast sensitivity functions: the coarsest spatial pattern analyzer. Vision Research, 36, 3077-3085]. For chromatic gratings, correlations between thresholds for most spatial frequencies were uniformly high, yielding a single covariance channel covering all but the highest spatial frequency tested. A combined analysis of both data sets recovered the same three covariance channels, and showed that detection thresholds for low-frequency red-green chromatic and luminance-modulated stimuli are served by separate, statistically independent processes.

Neural correlates of contrast detection at threshold

Human psychophysical studies have demonstrated that, for stimuli near the threshold of visibility, detection of motion in one direction is unaffected by the superimposition of motion in the opposite direction. To investigate the neural basis for this perceptual phenomenon, we recorded from directionally selective neurons in macaque visual area MT (middle temporal visual area). Contrast thresholds obtained for single gratings moving in a neuron's preferred direction were compared with those obtained for motion presented simultaneously in the neuron's preferred and antipreferred directions. A simple model based on probability summation between neurons tuned to opposite directions could sufficiently account for contrast thresholds revealed psychophysically, suggesting that area MT is likely to provide the neural basis for contrast detection of stimuli modulated in time.

Mechanisms of visual motion detection

Visual motion is processed by neurons in primary visual cortex that are sensitive to spatial orientation and speed. Many models of local velocity computation are based on a second stage that pools the outputs of first-stage neurons selective for different orientations, but the nature of this pooling remains controversial. In a human psychophysical detection experiment, we found near-perfect summation of image energy when it was distributed uniformly across all orientations, but poor summation when it was concentrated in specific orientation bands. The data are consistent with a model that integrates uniformly over all orientations, even when this strategy is sub-optimal.

Infant temporal contrast sensitivity functions (tCSFs) mature earlier for luminance than for chromatic stimuli: evidence for precocious magnocellular development?

In order to investigate the development of luminance and chromatic temporal contrast sensitivity functions (tCSFs), we obtained chromatic and luminance contrast thresholds from individual 3- and 4-month old infants, and compared them to previously obtained functions in adults. Stimuli were moving sinusoidal gratings of 0.27 cyc/deg, presented at one of five temporal frequencies: 1.0, 2.1, 4.2, 9.4 or 19 Hz (corresponding speeds: 3.8, 7.7, 15, 34, 69 deg/s). Previous studies, including our own, have shown that adult tCSFs are bandpass for luminance stimuli (peaking at 5-10 Hz), yet lowpass for chromatic stimuli (sensitivity falling at > 2 Hz), and that the two functions cross one another near 4-5 Hz when plotted in terms of cone contrast. In the present study, we find that the shapes and peaks of the luminance tCSF in both 3- and 4-months-olds appear quite similar to those of adults. By contrast, chromatic tCSFs in infants are markedly different from those of adults. In agreement with our earlier report (Dobkins, K. R., Lia, B., & Teller, D. Y. (1997). Vision Research, 37(19), 2699-2716), the chromatic function in 3-month-olds is rather flat, lacking the sharp high temporal frequency fall-off characteristic of the adult function. In addition, the luminance tCSF in 3-month-olds is elevated above the chromatic tCSF, and the two functions do not exhibit an adult-like cross-over within the range of temporal frequencies tested. By 4 months of age, substantial development of chromatic contrast sensitivity takes place at the lowest temporal frequencies. Although still immature, the 4-month-old chromatic tCSF has begun to adopt a more adult-like shape. In addition, similar to adults, luminance and chromatic tCSFs in 4-month-olds cross one another near 5 Hz. In adults, magnocellular (M) and parvocellular (P) pathways are thought to underlie the bandpass luminance and lowpass chromatic tCSF, respectively (e.g. Lee, B. B., Pokorny, J., Smith, V. C., Martin, P. R., & Valberg, A. (1990). Journal of the Optical Society of America (a), 7(12), 2223-2236). Based on this correspondence between psychophysical and neural responses in adults, our results suggest that the relatively slow development of the chromatic tCSF in infants may reflect immature chromatic responses in the P pathway and/or reliance on chromatic responses originating in the M pathway.

Infants code the direction of chromatic quadrature motion

The present experiment uses a quadrature motion paradigm to investigate the motion correspondence cues used by young infants for coding the direction of motion of red/green isoluminant gratings. Three-month-old infants and adults were tested with 0.25 c/d luminance-modulated or red/green isoluminant gratings, either moving continuously or shifted in spatial quadrature. Both direction-of-motion and detection thresholds were measured, and motion:detection (M:D) threshold ratios were examined. Infants, like adults, could code the direction of motion of red/green quadrature-shifted gratings. In adults, M:D ratios were similar for continuous and quadrature motion. In infants, M:D ratios were higher for quadrature than for continuous motion, but elevations of similar magnitude were seen for both luminance-modulated and red/green gratings. The results suggest that frequency-doubled signals, such as those often seen in the magnocellular (M-cell) pathway, are not necessary for coding the direction of motion of isoluminant gratings in infant subjects. Two other theoretical options--mediation by the scatter of isoluminance points in the M-cell population, and parvocellular (P-cell) mediation--are discussed.

Spatial and temporal aspects of infant color vision

The present paper constitutes a review of the literature on young infants' chromatic discrimination capabilities. A series of early studies showed that infants as young as two months postnatal can make at least some chromatic discriminations between stationary, homogeneous fields of different wavelength compositions. Current studies of spatial and temporal contrast sensitivity functions (CSFs) for red/green isoluminant stimuli suggest that spatial chromatic CSFs show developmental changes in sensitivity and spatial scale, but not curve shape; while temporal chromatic CSFs (tCSFs) show developmental changes in sensitivity and curve shape, but not temporal scale. Infants can also code the direction of motion of moving isoluminant red/green gratings, for both continuous and quadrature motion. The possible mechanisms that underlie infants' chromatic discriminations are discussed.

Temporal modulation enhances the efficiency of spatial offset discriminations by 6-month-olds

Fourteen- and 24-week-old infants were tested for sensitivity to small position differences under two conditions: (a) the Vernier stimulus was flashed on and off at 1.2 or 4.8 Hz (flash condition); and (b) the Vernier breaks were presented in apparent motion at 1.2 or 4.8 Hz (motion condition). The latter stimulus also contained local flicker cues. Each infant was tested at one temporal frequency with both stimuli. No benefit was shown by 14-week-olds at either temporal frequency from the additional motion and flicker cues. However, 24-week-olds required spatial offsets only one third as large in the motion condition as they required in the flash condition at 4.8 Hz. Ideal observer methodology was used to ensure that the spatial information for both of these discriminations was held strictly equivalent. Increasing sensitivity to flicker and/or motion or uncertainty reduction may underlie the enhancement in discrimination shown by 24-week-olds at 4.8 Hz.

Infant color vision: temporal contrast sensitivity functions for chromatic (red/green) stimuli in 3-month-olds

In order to investigate the development of temporal contrast sensitivity functions (tCSFs) for chromatic (red/green) stimuli, we obtained chromatic contrast thresholds from 3-month-old infants and adults using behavioral techniques. Stimuli were moving or counterphase-reversing sinusoidal gratings of 0.25 c/deg. Five temporal frequencies were used: 0.7, 2.1, 5.6, 11 and 17 Hz (corresponding speeds = 2.8, 8.4, 22, 44 and 67 deg/sec). In order to compare chromatic results with those obtained under luminance-defined conditions, luminance tCSFs were also obtained from adults, and previously obtained infant luminance tCSFs were used (from Dobkins & Teller, 1996a). In accordance with previous studies, adults exhibited bandpass luminance tCSFs with peaks near 5 Hz and lowpass chromatic tCSFs that declined rapidly at temporal frequencies greater than 2 Hz, and the two curves crossed one another near 4 Hz. By contrast, infants exhibited bandpass rather than lowpass chromatic tCSFs with peaks near 5 Hz. These chromatic curves were quite similar in peak frequency and general shape to previously obtained infant tCSFs for luminance stimuli. Moreover, both chromatic and luminance tCSFs in infants were found to be quite similar in peak and shape to luminance tCSFs observed in adults. These findings point to the possibility that, for 3-month-old infants, both chromatic and luminance stimuli are detected by the same underlying mechanism under these conditions. We propose that such a mechanism is probably a physiological pathway dominated by magnocellular input. Earlier studies of infant color vision are discussed in this context.

Development of temporal contrast sensitivity in human infants

The time course for the development of the temporal contrast sensitivity function in humans is uncertain. Some studies indicate that temporal contrast sensitivity is immature in infants. However, earlier work suggests that critical flicker fusion is adult-like by 2 months. We traced the development of temporal contrast sensitivity to uniform field flicker in 2-, 3- and 4-month-old infants using a modified preferential-looking technique that employed a rating scale. Two-month-old infants exhibited highest sensitivities at 1 and 2 Hz. Three- and 4-month infants exhibited peak sensitivity at 4 and 8 Hz, respectively. Overall temporal contrast sensitivity increased with age and the peak frequency shifted toward higher temporal frequencies. Using this paradigm, no infant subjects showed responses to 32 Hz, the highest temporal frequencies tested.

Development of the temporal properties of visual evoked potentials to luminance and colour contrast in infants

We have studied the development of the temporal characteristics of the pattern visual evoked potentials (P-VEPs) in response to contrast reversal of patterns of low spatial frequency (0.1 c/deg) of either pure luminance contrast (yellow-black plaid patterns) or pure colour contrast (equiluminant red-green plaid patterns) in 15 infants between 6 and 30 weeks of age. High contrast patterns were modulated temporally either sinusoidally at various temporal frequencies to elicit steady-state responses, or abruptly at a low temporal frequency to elicit transient responses. Analysis of both the transient and steady-state responses suggests the existence of three different mechanisms contributing to the infant and adult P-VEP responses at low, medium and high temporal frequencies. The responses at the three different temporal frequency ranges have different time constants, and develop at different rates. The low frequency response predominates at 8 weeks, where it spans the range 1-6 Hz with an apparent latency of about 230 msec, for both colour and luminance stimulation. This response increases in bandwidth and decreases in latency progressively with age, at a similar rate for luminance and colour contrast, up to 14 weeks. After 14 weeks, the luminance response undergoes major changes, with the emergence of a new response with a shorter latency (about 100 msec) and a peak activity near 10 Hz. This mid-frequency response matures further with age, until it dominates the whole response of the adult P-VEP to luminance contrast. It also makes a contribution to the chromatic response at frequencies above 10 Hz, generating the characteristic double-peaked amplitude response in adults. However, its contribution is very limited below 10 Hz, where the response latency is 140 msec in adults, as it was at 14 weeks of age. A third component is evident at very high temporal frequencies of the luminance response as early as 6 weeks, extending up to 15 Hz in 8-week-olds and up to 25 Hz for older infants. It remains apparent up to 18 weeks, thereafter being swamped by the major mid-frequency response. The apparent latency of response over this frequency range is about 70 msec at all ages. The development of transient P-VEPs paralleled that of the steady-state P-VEPs. At all ages there was an early negative component (N70) at about 70 msec, corresponding to the fast steady-state response at high frequencies for luminance contrast. Before 14 weeks, the luminance and chromatic transient response had the same morphology, with a single major peak of similar latency to the apparent latency of the low temporal frequency response. After this age, the morphology of the luminance response changed, particularly in the first 100 msec, consistent with the emergence of the mid-frequency response. We discuss whether the high-frequency component may represent pre- or early post-synaptic cortical activity, already mature by 8 weeks, and how the different maturation rates of the mid and high-frequency components may reflect different intra-cortical circuitry for colour and luminance.

Infant motion: detection (M:D) ratios for chromatically defined and luminance-defined moving stimuli

In order to assess the relative contributions of chromatic vs luminance information to motion processing in infants, we employed a motion:detection (M:D) paradigm. Stimuli consisted of 27 deg by 40 deg, 0.25 c/deg sinusoidal gratings moving at 22 deg/sec (5.6 Hz), and were either chromatically defined or luminance-defined. Contrast thresholds for direction-of-motion (M) were obtained using a directional eye movement technique. Contrast thresholds for detection (D) were obtained using forced-choice preferential looking. M:D threshold ratios were obtained for individual infant subjects, and results were compared to those of adults. As expected, adult M:D threshold ratios were near 1:1 for luminance-defined stimuli, but greater than 1:1 for chromatically defined stimuli. This suggests that, for adults, luminance-defined, but not chromatically defined, stimuli are detected by mechanisms labeled for direction of motion. By contrast, infant M:D ratios for chromatically and luminance-defined stimuli were approximately equal and close to 1:1, suggesting that, for infants, luminance- as well as chromatically defined stimuli are detected by mechanisms that are labeled for direction of motion.

Infant color vision: motion nulls for red/green vs luminance-modulated stimuli in infants and adults

Four-week-olds, 9-week-olds, and adult subjects were tested with low spatial frequency sinusoidal gratings moving at a speed of 25 deg/sec. Luminance-modulated and red/green gratings were presented either separately, or superimposed and moving in opposite directions in a chromatic motion nulling paradigm. An adult observer judged the direction of the slow phase of the subject's eye movements. Luminance-modulated gratings elicited directionally appropriate eye movements in all three age groups, with contrast thresholds decreasing markedly with age. For red/green gratings alone, 4-week-olds responded only marginally, but 9-week-olds and adults produced consistent directionally appropriate eye movements. In the motion nulling condition, 15% contrast luminance-modulated gratings were about equally effective in nulling the motion of the red/green gratings in all three age groups. A formal model of the motion nulling paradigm, separating threshold and equivalent luminance contrast parameters, was developed and applied to the data. Model fits showed that equivalent luminance contrast was constant or nearly constant across age groups. This outcome is consistent with the hypothesis that, with respect to adults, infants show a uniform rather than a differential loss of sensitivity to moving red/green vs luminance-modulated stimuli.