Intramitotic variation in proliferative potential: stochastic events in cellular aging

Is Evidence Supporting the Subtelomere-Telomere Theory of Aging?

The telomere theory tries to explain cellular mechanisms of aging as mainly caused by telomere shortening at each duplication. The subtelomere-telomere theory overcomes various shortcomings of telomere theory by highlighting the essential role of subtelomeric DNA in aging mechanisms. The present work illustrates and deepens the correspondence between assumptions and implications of subtelomere-telomere theory and experimental results. In particular, it is investigated the evidence regarding the relationships between aging and (i) epigenetic modifications; (ii) oxidation and inflammation; (iii) telomere protection; (iv) telomeric heterochromatin hood; (v) gradual cell senescence; (vi) cell senescence; and (vii) organism decline with telomere shortening. The evidence appears broadly in accordance or at least compatible with the description and implications of the subtelomere-telomere theory. In short, phenomena of cellular aging, by which the senescence of the whole organism is determined in various ways, appear substantially dependent on epigenetic modifications regulated by the subtelomere-telomere-telomeric hood-telomerase system. These phenomena appear to be not random, inevitable, and irreversible but rather induced and regulated by genetically determined mechanisms, and modifiable and reversible by appropriate methods. All this supports the thesis that aging is a genetically programmed and regulated phenoptotic phenomenon and is against the opposite thesis of aging as caused by random and inevitable degenerative factors.

Simple Detection Methods for Senescent Cells: Opportunities and Challenges

Cellular senescence, the irreversible growth arrest of cells from conditional renewal populations combined with a radical shift in their phenotype, is a hallmark of ageing in some mammalian species. In the light of this, interest in the detection of senescent cells in different tissues and different species is increasing. However much of the prior work in this area is heavily slanted towards studies conducted in humans and rodents; and in these species most studies concern primary fibroblasts or cancer cell lines rendered senescent through exposure to a variety of stressors. Complex techniques are now available for the detailed analysis of senescence in these systems. But, rather than focussing on these methods this review instead examines techniques for the simple and reproducible detection of senescent cells. Intended primary for the non-specialist who wishes to quickly detect senescent cells in tissues or species which may lack a significant evidence base on the phenomenon it emphasises the power of the original techniques used to demonstrate the senescence of cells, their interrelationship with other markers and their potential to inform on the senescent state in new species and archival specimens.

Mathematical modelling of ageing acceleration of the human follicle due to oxidative stress and other factors

There is a gradual telomere shortening due to the inability of the replication machinery to copy the very ends of chromosomes. Additionally, other factors such as high levels of oxidation (free radicals or reactive oxygen species (ROS)), e.g. due to cumulated stress, inflammation or tobacco smoke, accelerate telomere shortening. In humans, the average telomere length is about 10-15 kb at birth and telomeres shorten at a pace of 70 bp per year. However, when cells are exposed to ROS, telomere attrition happens at a faster pace, generating a wide variety of telomere size distribution in different length percentiles, which are different to what is expected just by age. In this work, the generational age of a cell is associated with its telomere length (TL), from certain maximum to the minimal TL that allows replication. In order to study the accumulation of aged granulosa cells in human follicles, from preantral to preovulatory size, a mathematical model is proposed, regarding different degrees of accelerated telomere shortening, which reflect the action of ROS in addition to the telomere shortening that happens after cell division. In cases of cells with TL shorter than cells with average TL, with low telomerase activity and accelerated telomere shortening, the mathematical model predicts an aged outcome in preovulatory follicles. The model provides a plausible explanation for what has been observed in oocytes from older women, which have been exposed to ROS for a longer period of time and have bad outcomes after in vitro fertilization.

Importance and Meaning of TERRA Sequences for Aging Mechanisms

Any theory suggesting an adaptive meaning for aging implicitly postulates the existence of specific mechanisms, genetically determined and modulated, causing progressive decline of an organism. According to the subtelomere-telomere theory, each telomere is covered by a hood formed in the first cell of an organism having a size preserved at each subsequent duplication. Telomere shortening, which is quantitatively different for each cell type according to the telomerase regulation, causes the hood to slide on the subtelomere repressing it by the telomeric position effect. At this point, the theory postulates existence of subtelomeric regulatory sequences, whose progressive transcriptional repression by the hood should cause cellular alterations that would be the likely determinant of aging manifestations. However, sequences with characteristics of these hypothetical sequences have already been described and documented. They are the [sub]TElomeric Repeat-containing RNA (TERRA) sequences. The repression of TERRA sequences causes progressively: (i) down- or up-regulation of many other regulatory sequences; (ii) increase in the probability of activation of cell senescence program (blockage of the ability to replicate and very significant alterations of the cellular functions). When cell senescence program has not been triggered and the repression is partial, there is a partial alteration of the cellular functions that is easily reversible by telomerase activation. Location of the extremely important sequences in chromosomal parts that are most vulnerable to repression by the telomeric hood is evolutionarily unjustifiable if aging is not considered adaptive: this location must be necessarily adaptive with the specific function of determining aging of the cell and consequently of the whole organism.

The many types of heterogeneity in replicative senescence

Replicative senescence, which is induced by telomere shortening, underlies the loss of regeneration capacity of organs and is ultimately detrimental to the organism. At the same time, it is required to protect organisms from unlimited cell proliferation that may arise from numerous stimuli or deregulations. One important feature of replicative senescence is its high level of heterogeneity and asynchrony, which promote genome instability and senescence escape. Characterizing this heterogeneity and investigating its sources are thus critical to understanding the robustness of replicative senescence. Here we review the different aspects of senescence driven by telomere attrition that are subject to variation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the current understanding of the molecular processes at play, and the consequences of heterogeneity in replicative senescence.

Mathematical model to study the aging of the human follicle according to the telomerase activity

The aim of this work is to study the aging rate at which human follicles reach the preovulatory state. To this end, both telomere length and telomerase activity effects on granulosa cells (GCs) aging has been studied. GCs are somatic cells which determine the development of the oocyte. A human preantral follicle takes approximately 85 days to achieve the preovulatory size, going through several stages (Gougeon, 1996). The telomere length of GCs of each class of follicles, during folliculogenesis, are modelled using a chemical master equation formalism similar to the one in Wesch et al. (2016). Seven differential ordinary systems of equations, corresponding to seven stages of the follicule maturation, concatenated in time, are considered. The mitotic and death rates are approximated by using the mean number of GCs in each class of follicles and the time they remain on each stage. The influence of different telomerase activity rates and the telomere shortening of the preovulatory follicle is studied. Some cases of infertility are associated with low levels of telomerase activity and short telomeres in GCs. The method aims at understanding how low levels of telomerase activity in preovulatory stages lead to the accumulation of aged GCs. In the case of higher telomerase activities, the mathematical model predicts a more juvenile outcome in preovulatory follicles. Juvenile GCs, could be critical for embryo development if the oocyte were fertilized, since GCs, transformed in corpus luteum, must divide and increase their size (Alila and Hansel, 1984) to sustain early pregnancy (Csapo et al., 1972).

Senescence in the aging process

The accumulation of 'senescent' cells has long been proposed to act as an ageing mechanism. These cells display a radically altered transcriptome and degenerative phenotype compared with their growing counterparts. Tremendous progress has been made in recent years both in understanding the molecular mechanisms controlling entry into the senescent state and in the direct demonstration that senescent cells act as causal agents of mammalian ageing. The challenges now are to gain a better understanding of how the senescent cell phenotype varies between different individuals and tissues, discover how senescence predisposes to organismal frailty, and develop mechanisms by which the deleterious effects of senescent cells can be ameliorated.

The post-mitotic state in neurons correlates with a stable nuclear higher-order structure

Neurons become terminally differentiated (TD) post-mitotic cells very early during development yet they may remain alive and functional for decades. TD neurons preserve the molecular machinery necessary for DNA synthesis that may be reactivated by different stimuli but they never complete a successful mitosis. The non-reversible nature of the post-mitotic state in neurons suggests a non-genetic basis for it since no set of mutations has been able to revert it. Comparative studies of the nuclear higher-order structure in neurons and cells with proliferating potential suggest that the non-reversible nature of the post-mitotic state in neurons has a structural basis in the stability of the nuclear higher-order structure.

Aged and post-mitotic cells share a very stable higher-order structure in the cell nucleus in vivo

In the mammalian liver the quiescent primary hepatocytes preserve a proliferating potential in vivo, yet natural aging correlates with loss of proliferating potential and progression towards terminal differentiation of the hepatocytes. Thus aged, terminally-differentiated hepatocytes may survive in a de facto post-mitotic state, similarly to early post-mitotic cells, like neurons, suggesting that there might be a common factor linking both cellular states. In the interphase of metazoan cells the nuclear DNA is organized in supercoiled loops anchored to a proteinaceous substructure known as the nuclear matrix (NM). The DNA-NM interactions define a higher-order structure in the cell nucleus (NHOS). Natural aging of the rat liver correlates with a progressive strengthening of the NM framework and the stabilization of the DNA-NM interactions in the hepatocytes indicating that the NHOS becomes highly stable with age. We compared the NHOS of post-mitotic rat neurons with that of aged rat hepatocytes. Our results indicate that a very stable NHOS is a common feature of both aged and post-mitotic cells in vivo.

Bridging the gap: ageing, pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics

Changes in pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics in elderly patients generally result in an increase in the incidence of drug toxicity and adverse drug reactions. Molecular alterations associated with ageing could bring about biological changes, a consequence of which is an altered response to pharmacological agents. Unfortunately, research in this area has yet to progress beyond the cataloguing of the pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic changes observed in the elderly. Therefore, real progress in our understanding of pharmacogerontology could be achieved if it were possible to merge pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic studies with recent advances in our understanding of the causal processes bringing about ageing changes at the cellular level. Therefore, this review will focus on the mechanisms of ageing in the hope that the information will be of value to those planning independent studies.

A structural basis for cellular senescence

Replicative senescence (RS) that limits the proliferating potential of normal eukaryotic cells occurs either by a cell-division counting mechanism linked to telomere erosion or prematurely through induction by cell stressors such as oncogene hyper-activation. However, there is evidence that RS also occurs by a stochastic process that is independent of number of cell divisions or cellular stress and yet it leads to a highly-stable, non-reversible post-mitotic state that may be long-lasting and that such a process is widely represented among higher eukaryotes. Here I present and discuss evidence that the interactions between DNA and the nuclear substructure, commonly known as the nuclear matrix, define a higher-order structure within the cell nucleus that following thermodynamic constraints, stochastically evolves towards maximum stability, thus becoming limiting for mitosis to occur. It is suggested that this process is responsible for ultimate replicative senescence and yet it is compatible with long-term cell survival.

From old organisms to new molecules: integrative biology and therapeutic targets in accelerated human ageing

Understanding the basic biology of human ageing is a key milestone in attempting to ameliorate the deleterious consequences of old age. This is an urgent research priority given the global demographic shift towards an ageing population. Although some molecular pathways that have been proposed to contribute to ageing have been discovered using classical biochemistry and genetics, the complex, polygenic and stochastic nature of ageing is such that the process as a whole is not immediately amenable to biochemical analysis. Thus, attempts have been made to elucidate the causes of monogenic progeroid disorders that recapitulate some, if not all, features of normal ageing in the hope that this may contribute to our understanding of normal human ageing. Two canonical progeroid disorders are Werner's syndrome and Hutchinson-Gilford progeroid syndrome (also known as progeria). Because such disorders are essentially phenocopies of ageing, rather than ageing itself, advances made in understanding their pathogenesis must always be contextualised within theories proposed to help explain how the normal process operates. One such possible ageing mechanism is described by the cell senescence hypothesis of ageing. Here, we discuss this hypothesis and demonstrate that it provides a plausible explanation for many of the ageing phenotypes seen in Werner's syndrome and Hutchinson-Gilford progeriod syndrome. The recent exciting advances made in potential therapies for these two syndromes are also reviewed.

The concept of telomeric non-reciprocal recombination (TENOR) applied to human fibroblasts grown in serial cultures: concordance with genealogical data

Since the discovery of the limited life span of human fibroblasts some 50 years ago, many genealogical studies have been undertaken to describe growth kinetics of fibroblasts in serial cultures by their individual division behavior. It is now accepted that proliferation capacities of human fibroblasts strongly depend on their telomere lengths and integrity. Telomeres shorten with each replication round, and there is a direct correlation between cell division capacity and telomere lengths; that is, the consumption of disposable telomeric DNA repeats during cell divisions progresses until critically short telomeres determining the replicative senescence of the cells are present. Recently, we have suggested that telomeres in fibroblasts can also become elongated during DNA replication by telomeric non-reciprocal recombination (TENOR). Here we discuss genealogical data collected over the last decades as well as more recent findings on the telomere-driven replicative senescence process, and we summarize both to give an integrated picture.

Cellular and molecular mechanisms of stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS) of human diploid fibroblasts and melanocytes

Replicative senescence of human diploid fibroblasts (HDFs) or melanocytes is caused by the exhaustion of their proliferative potential. Stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS) occurs after many different sublethal stresses including H(2)O(2), hyperoxia, or tert-butylhydroperoxide. Cells in replicative senescence share common features with cells in SIPS: morphology, senescence-associated beta-galactosidase activity, cell cycle regulation, gene expression and telomere shortening. Telomere shortening is attributed to the accumulation of DNA single-strand breaks induced by oxidative damage. SIPS could be a mechanism of accumulation of senescent-like cells in vivo. Melanocytes exposed to sublethal doses of UVB undergo SIPS. Melanocytes from dark- and light- skinned populations display differences in their cell cycle regulation. Delayed SIPS occurs in melanocytes from light-skinned populations since a reduced association of p16(Ink-4a) with CDK4 and reduced phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein are observed. The role of reactive oxygen species in melanocyte SIPS is unclear. Both replicative senescence and SIPS are dependent on two major pathways. One is triggered by DNA damage, telomere damage and/or shortening and involves the activation of the p53 and p21(waf-1) proteins. The second pathway results in the accumulation of p16(Ink-4a) with the MAP kinase signalling pathway as possible intermediate. These data corroborate the thermodynamical theory of ageing, according to which the exposure of cells to sublethal stresses of various natures can trigger SIPS, with possible modulations of this process by bioenergetics.

Accumulation of short telomeres in human fibroblasts prior to replicative senescence

The loss of telomere repeats has been causally linked to in vitro replicative senescence of human diploid fibroblasts (HDFs). In order to study the mechanism(s) by which telomere shortening signals cell senescence, we analyzed the telomere length at specific chromosome ends at cumulative population doublings in polyclonal and clonal HDFs by quantitative fluorescence in situ hybridization. The rate of telomere shortening at individual telomeres varied between 50 and 150 bp per population doubling and short telomeres with an estimated 1-2 kb of telomere repeats accumulated prior to senescence. The average telomere length in specific chromosome ends was remarkably similar between clones. However, some exceptions with individual telomeres measuring 0.5-1 kb were observed. In the fibroblast clones, the onset of replicative senescence was significantly correlated with the mean telomere fluorescence but, strikingly, not with chromosomes with the shortest telomere length. The accumulation of short telomeres in late passages of cultured HDFs is compatible with selection of cells on the basis of telomere length and limited recombination between telomeres prior to senescence.

Sudden senescence syndrome plays a major role in cell culture proliferation

Normal human cells of various types have a finite and predictable proliferative potential in vitro. This limited life span is due to a gradually increasing fraction of senescent cells that appear in the culture in a sudden and stochastic fashion due to a phenomenon referred to as sudden senescence syndrome (SSS). Because nondividing cells increasingly accumulate in the culture, dividing cells have to compensate for nondividers in order to accomplish additional population doubling (PD). Thus, individual dividing cells undergo more divisions, called cell generations (CG), than the number of PDs. Based on integrated experimental data, we calculated maximum CG for normal human diploid fibroblasts (HDF). It appears that for a HDF culture that undergoes 65 PD, the calculated final CG is at least 126. Based on the obtained value for CG we calculated the total size of the culture, both with and without effect of SSS. If no SSS takes place and cells divide by geometrical progression, the culture will grow up to 2(126) or 10(38) cells. By constantly eliminating cells from further divisions, causing cell loss (CL), SSS reduces the total size of the culture at every point during its proliferation. The calculated value for CL is enormous, so that the culture of 10(38) cells is reduced to only 10(19) cells, thus as little as 10(-17)% of its size! Accordingly, by preventing virtually every cell in the culture from reaching its original maximum doubling capacity, SSS appears to be the most important mechanism that influences cell culture proliferation.

Telomere shortening and the population size-dependency of life span of human cell culture: further implication for two proliferation-restricting telomeres

Cultures of normal human cell can only undergo a finite number of population doublings. The proliferative life span of a culture is affected by population size, i.e., the number of cells a culture maintains. A 1000-fold transient reduction in population size can reduce the life span by as many as eight population doublings. The limited proliferative potential of human cells has been speculated to be a result of telomere shortening that occurs during DNA synthesis at each round of cell division. In this paper, I use computer simulation to test the telomere theory of cell aging against the population size-dependency of life span of human cell culture. It is found that telomere shortening well explains the above phenomenon. In addition, the results suggest that the proliferative potential of human cells might be limited by the shortening of only a few, most likely two, specific telomeres, providing further support to the same conclusion put forward in my previous paper (Tan, 1999).

Replicative senescence: considerations relating to the stability of heterochromatin domains

Replicative senescence of human diploid fibroblasts (HDF) cultured in vitro is characterized by a progressive and irreversible loss of responsiveness to mitogenic stimulation by serum. While some constraints have been placed on the nature of HDF senescence, its underlying molecular mechanism(s) remain obscure. Here, the possibility is considered that defects in cell cycle-coupled reassembly of repressive chromatin domains may contribute to HDF senescence. Features of this model are discussed in relation to established models of HDF senescence based on telomere shortening and loss of DNA methylation.

DNA damage and the proliferation and aging of cells in culture: a mathematical model with time lag

This paper is an extension of an earlier one by the same author in which a mathematical model was presented to describe the proliferation and aging of cells in culture. The model consists of a group of ordinary differential equations with a time lag. In the previous paper, the time lag was omitted for simplicity and the resulting differential equations were resolved analytically. It was shown that the model explains the behavior of a cell culture reasonably well. In this paper, the analytical solution of the original differential equations is presented without omitting the time lag. An analytical description of the variations in doubling capability between sister cells that was only simulated numerically in the earlier paper is given.

5-Azacytidine-induced demethylation of DNA to senescent level does not block proliferation of human fibroblasts

IMR-90 human diploid fibroblasts (HDF) lose from 30-50% of their genomic 5-methyldeoxycytidine (5mdC) during the cellular aging process. In contrast, immortal SV40-transformed IMR-90 maintain a constant level of 5mdC in culture. Precrisis SV40-transformed HDF (AG3204) represent a stage in between normal cell aging and immortalization because these cells still have a finite proliferative lifespan, but it is longer than that of normal HDF and ends in cell death rather than in G1-arrest. We find that AG3204 cells continue to lose from 12-33% of their 5mdC after a population has become 99% positive for SV40 T-antigen. Both IMR-90 cells and AG3204 cells have similar levels of 5mdC (average of 2.25%) at the end of lifespan. We investigated whether this level of 5mdC is an absolute block to further proliferation by treating IMR-90 and AG3204 cells with 5-azacytidine (5azaC) to reduce their 5mdC levels below the terminal level normally achieved at end of lifespan. We find that both IMR-90 and AG3204 cells undergo extensive proliferation with subterminal levels of 5mdC and that the lifespans of both cell types are shortened by 5azaC treatment. These studies indicate that random genomic DNA demethylation to a specific level of 5mdC is not a direct cause of finite proliferative lifespan. However, the correlation between accelerated DNA demethylation and accelerated aging still suggests that these two phenomena are related. Two ways to explain this relationship are: (1) DNA demethylation during aging is not random, and/or (2) both DNA demethylation and other independent aging processes cooperate to produce finite lifespan. In both cases, accelerated random DNA demethylation could accelerate aging, but not necessarily in direct relationship to the final genomic level of 5mdC achieved during the normal aging process.

A model for phenotypic switching in adrenocortical cells senescing in culture

We have developed a cell model for loss of differentiated gene expression in cellular aging. Over long periods in culture, bovine adrenocortical cells lose expression of a specialized gene, steroid 17 alpha-hydroxylase. The decline in expression of 17 alpha-hydroxylase in mass cultures and clones of bovine adrenocortical cells is the result of a phenotypic switching process which yields a mixture of cells that can express 17 alpha-hydroxylase after induction with cyclic AMP and cells that are incapable of expression of 17 alpha-hydroxylase. In the experimental portion of the work, bovine adrenocortical cells were grown in culture in colonies, stimulated with cyclic AMP to induce 17 alpha-hydroxylase, then fixed and hybridized in situ with labeled 17 alpha-hydroxylase cDNA. Separate images of Giemsa-stained cell colonies and of their hybridization patterns were digitized and combined as stylized representations of the colonies for comparison with those produced by a computer simulation. A program for the simulation of growth of colonies of bovine adrenocortical cells in senescence with phenotypic switching of 17 alpha-hydroxylase is presented. Comparison between simulated colonies and real colonies shows that the model accurately simulates colony growth and phenotypic switching. It suggests that the probability of phenotypic switching per cell generation is in the range of 0.03 to 0.06. The major variable among colonies is division probability, consistent with observations in this and other cell culture systems that clones differ widely in replicative potential. Thus, phenotypic switching of 17 alpha-hydroxylase in adrenocortical cells may be modelled using simple assumptions.

DNA methylation and cellular ageing

Methylated cytosine (m5C) in DNA appears to be an important modulator of the expression of some genes. There are several lines of evidence that gradual loss of m5C is relevant to in vitro cellular ageing: m5C loss occurs during cell culture; m5C loss is detectable at an early stage of culture; m5C loss appears to be related to cell division not just duration in culture; the rate of m5C loss appears to be related to in vitro lifespan of the cell strain in question; and the total loss of m5C during an in vitro lifespan is significant by comparison with induced-changes in m5C levels which effect cell growth, or cause cell-death in culture. Progressive loss of m5C in dividing cells may thus produce the multi-step cell division "clock" which underlies the Hayflick phenomenon.

Replicative senescence and differentiated gene expression in cultured adrenocortical cells

We have used a differentiated endocrine cell type, the adrenocortical cell, to investigate the interrelationship of senescence and differentiation, the effects of the environment on differentiated gene expression, and the interrelationship of differentiated gene expression and proliferation. In bovine adrenocortical cells, expression of some differentiated functions is maintained to very late points in the replicative life span, whereas expression of others is lost at various times prior to senescence. There is clonal variation in the rate and extent of loss of functions. For steroid 17 alpha-hydroxylase, in situ hybridization shows that the observed decline in induction of 17 alpha-hydroxylase mRNA during senescence results from a decline in the fraction of cells expression the gene. Descendants of expressing cells in the primary cell population randomly become nonexpressing. Among clones there is a correlation between the fraction of cells expressing the gene and remaining replicative potential, although several experiments show no direct mechanism linking replicative senescence and 17 alpha-hydroxylase expression. Transfection with SV40 early region genes also dissociates the decline in growth and the change in 17 alpha-hydroxylase expression. SV40 T antigen selectively affects growth; expression of 17 alpha-hydroxylase is stabilized either in the on state, when cells are transfected early in the culture life span, or in the off state, when senescent cells are transfected. Thus, although the switching off of 17 alpha-hydroxylase expression and the loss of replicative potential are independent events, the switching process requires DNA replication. Because the switch is irreversible, changes in replicative potential occurring after the switch-off event do not affect the state of expression of the switched-off gene. Changes in differentiated cell properties and changes in replicative potential may be two facets of a general phenomenon of stochastic changes in gene expression in normal cells during senescence.

Cellular senescence involves stochastic processes causing loss of expression of differentiated function genes: transfection with SV40 as a means for dissociating effects of senescence on growth and on differentiated function gene expression

In the accompanying work we demonstrated that the decline in expression of steroid 17 alpha-hydroxylase in mass cultures and clones of adrenocortical cells is the result of a stochastic switching process which yields mixtures of expressing and nonexpressing cells. There is an apparent positive correlation between the replicative potential of adrenocortical cell cultures and the number of cells in the culture that can express 17 alpha-hydroxylase. We investigated this by extending the cells' replicative potential by transfecting them with cloned SV40 virus. Cells from a senescent subclone, with very limited remaining replicative potential, were transfected. The cell population showed a progressive increase in growth rate and gave rise to a line of cells that expressed T antigen and which was apparently immortalized. Induction of mRNA for 17 alpha-hydroxylase by cyclic AMP was absent in this line of cells, as it was in the senescent cells prior to transfection. The cells remained responsive to gene induction by cyclic AMP as evidenced by increases in mRNA and activity for cholesterol side-chain cleavage. The absence of 17 alpha-hydroxylase expression in this line was not the result of interference by SV40 T antigen. When early passage cells were transfected with pSV3neo, which contains the early region of SV40 and neo, and were selected with G418, SV40 T antigen-expressing lines were derived which showed high levels of expression of 17 alpha-hydroxylase after induction with cyclic AMP. These cells maintained high levels of expression of 17 alpha-hydroxylase through four successive recloning events, over a period of replication much longer than that achievable by nontransfected cells. Thus, transfection by SV40 can be used to dissociate effects of senescence on growth and differentiated gene expression. T antigen expression selectively affects growth, but preserves the state of expression of a differentiated function gene as it was prior to transfection.

Proliferative potential of human fibroblasts: an inverse dependence on cell size

Human foreskin fibroblast-like cells were separated on the basis of DNA content and cell size by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Subpopulations of "large" or "small" cells with the same (G1) DNA content were clonally expanded and found to contain predominantly nondividing or highly proliferative cells, respectively. From the rate of clonal growth, we deduce that small cells divide faster than large cells. Intermediate-sized cells were found to yield primarily smaller ("attenuated") clones. The clonal data can be incorporated into a previously reported kinetic model of clonal attenuation. This version of the model postulates that small "stem" cells yield larger daughters which have only a limited proliferative potential. We also postulate that a progressive increase in cell size can account for the decreasing concentration of DNA polymerase alpha, which has been reported in older cultures.

Cellular senescence revisited: a review

The field of cellular senescence (cytogerontology) is reviewed. The historical precedence for investigation in this field is summarized, and placed in the context of more recent studies of the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation. The now-classical embryonic lung fibroblast model is compared to models utilizing other cell types as well as cells from donors of different ages and phenotypes. Modulation of cellular senescence by growth factors, hormones, and genetic manipulation is contrasted, but newer studies in oncogene involvement are omitted. A current consensus would include the view that the life span of normal diploid cells in culture is limited, is under genetic control, and is capable of being modified. Finally, embryonic cells aging in vitro share certain characteristics with early passage cells derived from donors of increasing age.

Cellular aging (the Hayflick limit) and species longevity: a unification model based on clonal succession

A model is presented which proposes a specific cause-and-effect relationship between a limited cell division potential and the maximum lifespan of humans and other mammals. It is based on the clonal succession hypothesis of Kay which states that continually replicating cell beds (e.g. bone marrow, intestinal crypts, epidermis) could be composed of cells with short, well-defined division potentials. In this model, the cells of these beds are proposed to exist in an ordered hierarchy which establishes a specific sequence for cell divisions throughout the organism's lifespan. The depletion of division potential at all hierarchical levels leads to a loss of bed function and sets an intrinsic limit to species longevity. A specific hierarchy for cell proliferation is defined which allows the calculation of time to bed depletion and, ultimately, to organism mortality. The model allows the existence of a small number (n) of critical cell beds within the organism and defines organism death as the inability of any one of these beds to produce cells. The model is consistent with all major observations related to cellular and organismic aging. In particular, it links the PDLs (population doubling limit) observed for various species to their mean lifespan; it explains the slow decline in PDL as a function of age of the donor; it establishes a thermodynamically stable maximum lifespan for a disease-free population; and it can explain why tissue transplants outlive donors or hosts.

Clonal variation in response to adrenocorticotropin in cultured bovine adrenocortical cells: relationship to senescence

During cellular senescence, non-clonal cultures of bovine adrenocortical cells show a continuous decline in the rate of production of cyclic AMP (cAMP) stimulated by adrenocorticotropin (ACTH), without changes in the rate of forskolin- or prostaglandin E1-stimulated cAMP production. We investigated the possible mechanisms for loss of response to ACTH by examining the properties of clones of bovine adrenocortical cells. ACTH-stimulated cAMP production rates were measured in clones immediately after isolation, during long-term growth following isolation, and after subcloning. ACTH-stimulated rates were compared with cAMP production in response to forskolin, which acts directly on the catalytic subunit of adenylate cyclase. The results show that cloning is not necessarily associated with a loss of response to ACTH, but that clones with high ACTH response can give rise to subclones with low response. Clones of adrenocortical cells, at the same approximate population doubling level (PDL), showed ACTH response levels that ranged from 12 to 135 pmol cAMP/10(6) cells/min, whereas mass cultures at this PDL showed approximately 50 pmol/10(6) cells/min. Forskolin-stimulated cAMP production rates in clones varied only over the range of 59-119 pmol/10(6) cells/min and showed no correlation with the ACTH-stimulated rates. All clones were adrenocortical cells, as shown by mitogenic response to angiotensin II and cAMP-inducible 17 alpha-hydroxylase activity. The replicative potential of clones varied widely, and there was no apparent correlation between ACTH response levels and growth potential. The level of ACTH response in each clone was stable during proliferation through at least 25 PD beyond the stage at which the clone was isolated. When clones were subcloned, a clone with a high ACTH response level produced sister subclones that had ACTH response levels ranging from 3% of that of the parent clone to a level slightly greater than that of the parent clone. The growth potential of sister subclones varied widely, as for the parent clones, and there was no obvious correlation between growth potential and ACTH response. Two subclones were cloned; in sub-subclones, levels of ACTH response were again different from each other and also from the parent subclone; in one case, the level of ACTH response was approximately eight-fold higher than that of the parent subclone. These experiments show that clonal variation in the extent of expression of a differentiated property may occur in a normal differentiated cell in culture. The loss of ACTH response and the loss of proliferative potential appear to be independent stochastic events.