Detecting cooperative protein-DNA interactions and DNA loop formation by footprinting

The thermodynamics of DNA loop formation, from J to Z

The formation of DNA loops is a ubiquitous theme in biological processes, including DNA replication, recombination and repair, and gene regulation. These loops are mediated by proteins bound at specific sites along the contour of a single DNA molecule, in some cases many thousands of base pairs apart. Loop formation incurs a thermodynamic cost that is a sensitive function of the length of looped DNA as well as the geometry and elastic properties of the DNA-bound protein. The free energy of DNA looping is logarithmically related to a generalization of the Jacobson-Stockmayer factor for DNA cyclization, termed the J factor. In the present article, we review the thermodynamic origins of this quantity, discuss how it is measured experimentally and connect the macroscopic interpretation of the J factor with a statistical-mechanical description of DNA looping and cyclization.

The structural basis of cooperative regulation at an alternate genetic switch

Bacteriophage lambda is a paradigm for understanding the role of cooperativity in gene regulation. Comparison of the regulatory regions of lambda and the unrelated temperate bacteriophage 186 provides insight into alternate ways to assemble functional genetic switches. The structure of the C-terminal domain of the 186 repressor, determined at 2.7 A resolution, reveals an unusual heptamer of dimers, consistent with presented genetic studies. In addition, the structure of a cooperativity mutant of the full-length 186 repressor, identified by genetic screens, was solved to 1.95 A resolution. These structures provide a molecular basis for understanding lysogenic regulation in 186. Whereas the overall fold of the 186 and lambda repressor monomers is remarkably similar, the way the two repressors cooperatively assemble is quite different and explains in part the differences in their regulatory activity.

Statistical-mechanical theory of DNA looping

The lack of a rigorous analytical theory for DNA looping has caused many DNA-loop-mediated phenomena to be interpreted using theories describing the related process of DNA cyclization. However, distinctions in the mechanics of DNA looping versus cyclization can have profound quantitative effects on the thermodynamics of loop closure. We have extended a statistical mechanical theory recently developed for DNA cyclization to model DNA looping, taking into account protein flexibility. Notwithstanding the underlying theoretical similarity, we find that the topological constraint of loop closure leads to the coexistence of multiple classes of loops mediated by the same protein structure. These loop topologies are characterized by dramatic differences in twist and writhe; because of the strong coupling of twist and writhe within a loop, DNA looping can exhibit a complex overall helical dependence in terms of amplitude, phase, and deviations from uniform helical periodicity. Moreover, the DNA-length dependence of optimal looping efficiency depends on protein elasticity, protein geometry, and the presence of intrinsic DNA bends. We derive a rigorous theory of loop formation that connects global mechanical and geometric properties of both DNA and protein and demonstrates the importance of protein flexibility in loop-mediated protein-DNA interactions.

A chimeric activator of transcription that uses two DNA-binding domains to make simultaneous contact with pairs of recognition sites

Many well-known transcriptional regulatory proteins are composed of at least two independently folding domains and, typically, only one of these is a DNA-binding domain. However, some transcriptional regulators have been described that have more than one DNA-binding domain. Regulators with a single DNA-binding domain often bind co-operatively to the DNA in homotypic or heterotypic combinations, and two or more DNA-binding domains of a single regulatory protein can also bind co-operatively to suitably positioned recognition sequences. Here, we examine the behaviour of a chimeric activator of transcription with two different DNA-binding domains, that of the bacteriophage lambda cI protein and that of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein. We show that these two DNA-binding moieties, when present in the same molecule, can bind co-operatively to a pair of cognate recognition sites located upstream of a test promoter, thereby permitting the chimera to function as a particularly strong activator of transcription from this promoter. Our results show how such a bivalent DNA-binding protein can be used to regulate transcription differentially from promoters that bear either one or both recognition sites.

The Neurospora circadian clock regulates a transcription factor that controls rhythmic expression of the output eas(ccg-2) gene

The circadian clock provides a link between an organism's environment and its behaviour, temporally phasing the expression of genes in anticipation of daily environmental changes. Input pathways sense environmental information and interact with the clock to synchronize it to external cycles, and output pathways read out from the clock to impart temporal control on downstream targets. Very little is known about the regulation of outputs from the clock. In Neurospora crassa, the circadian clock transcriptionally regulates expression of the clock-controlled genes, including the well-characterized eas(ccg-2) gene. Dissection of the eas(ccg-2) gene promoter previously localized a 68 bp sequence containing an activating clock element (ACE) that is both necessary and sufficient for rhythmic activation of transcription by the circadian clock. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs), we have identified light-regulated nuclear protein factors that bind specifically to the ACE in a time-of-day-dependent fashion, consistent with their role in circadian regulation of expression of eas(ccg-2). Nucleotides in the ACE that interact with the protein factors were determined using interference binding assays, and deletion of the core interacting sequences affected, but did not completely eliminate, rhythmic accumulation of eas(ccg-2) mRNA in vivo, whereas deletion of the entire ACE abolished the rhythm. These data indicate that redundant binding sites for the protein factors that promote eas(ccg-2) rhythms exist within the 68 bp ACE. The ACE binding complexes formed using protein extracts from cells with lesions in central components of the Neurospora circadian clock were identical to those formed with extracts from wild-type cells, indicating that other proteins directly control eas(ccg-2) rhythmic expression. These data suggest that the Neurospora crassa circadian clock regulates an unknown transcription factor, which in turn activates the expression of eas(ccg-2) at specific times of the day.

An Lrp-like transcriptional regulator from the archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus is negatively autoregulated

The archaeal transcriptional initiation machinery closely resembles core elements of the eukaryal polymerase II system. However, apart from the established basal archaeal transcription system, little is known about the modulation of gene expression in archaea. At present, no obvious eukaryal-like transcriptional regulators have been identified in archaea. Instead, we have previously isolated an archaeal gene, the Pyrococcus furiosus lrpA, that potentially encodes a bacterial-like transcriptional regulator. In the present study, we have for the first time addressed the actual involvement of an archaeal Lrp homologue in transcription modulation. For that purpose, we have produced LrpA in Escherichia coli. In a cell-free P. furiosus transcription system we used wild-type and mutated lrpA promoter fragments to demonstrate that the purified LrpA negatively regulates its own transcription. In addition, gel retardation analyses revealed a single protein-DNA complex, in which LrpA appeared to be present in (at least) a tetrameric conformation. The location of the LrpA binding site was further identified by DNaseI and hydroxyl radical footprinting, indicating that LrpA binds to a 46-base pair sequence that overlaps the transcriptional start site of its own promoter. The molecular basis of the transcription inhibition by LrpA is discussed.

Methyl-specific DNA binding by McrBC, a modification-dependent restriction enzyme

McrBC, a GTP-requiring, modification-dependent endonuclease of Escherichia coli K-12, specifically recognizes DNA sites of the form 5' R(m)C 3'. DNA cleavage normally requires translocation-mediated coordination between two such recognition elements at distinct sites. We have investigated assembly of the cleavage-competent complex with gel-shift and DNase I footprint analysis. In the gel-shift system, McrB(L) binding resulted in a fast-migrating specific shifted band, in a manner requiring both GTP and Mg(2+). The binding was specific for methylated DNA and responded to local sequence changes in the same way that cleavage does. Single-stranded DNA competed for McrB(L)-binding in a modification and sequence-specific fashion. A supershifted species was formed in the presence of McrC and GTPgammaS. DNase I footprint analysis showed modest cooperativity in binding to two sites, and a two-site substrate displayed protection in non-specific spacer DNA in addition to the recognition elements. The addition of McrC did not affect the footprint obtained. We propose that McrC effects a conformational change in the complex rather than a reorganization of the DNA:protein interface.

A cyclic AMP receptor protein mutant that constitutively activates an Escherichia coli promoter disrupted by an IS5 insertion

Previously an Escherichia coli mutant that had acquired the ability to grow on propanediol as the sole carbon and energy source was isolated. This phenotype is the result of the constitutive expression of the fucO gene (in the fucAO operon), which encodes one of the enzymes in the fucose metabolic pathway. The mutant was found to bear an IS5 insertion in the intergenic regulatory region between the divergently oriented fucAO and fucPIK operons. Though expression of the fucAO operon was constitutive, the fucPIK operon became noninducible such that the mutant could no longer grow on fucose. A fucose-positive revertant which was found to contain a suppressor mutation in the crp gene was selected. Here we identify this crp mutation, which results in a single amino acid substitution (K52N) that has been proposed previously to uncover a cryptic activating region in the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP). We show that the mutant CRP constitutively activates transcription from both the IS5-disrupted and the wild-type fucPIK promoters, and we identify the CRP-binding site that is required for this activity. Our results show that the fucPIK promoter, a complex promoter which ordinarily depends on both CRP and the fucose-specific regulator FucR for its activation, can be activated in the absence of FucR by a mutant CRP that uses three, rather than two, activating regions to contact RNA polymerase. For the IS5-disrupted promoter, which retains a single CRP-binding site, the additional activating region of the mutant CRP evidently compensates for the lack of upstream regulatory sequences.

NAD-dependent DNA-binding activity of the bifunctional NadR regulator of Salmonella typhimurium

NadR is a 45-kDa bifunctional regulator protein. In vivo genetic studies indicate that NadR represses three genes involved in the biosynthesis of NAD. It also participates with an integral membrane protein (PnuC) in the import of nicotinamide mononucleotide, an NAD precursor. NadR was overexpressed and purified as a His-tagged fusion in order to study its DNA-binding properties. The protein bound to DNA fragments containing NAD box consensus sequences. NAD proved to be the relevant in vivo corepressor, but full NAD dependence of repressor activity required nucleotide triphosphates. DNA footprint analysis and gel shift assays suggest that NadR binds as a multimer to adjacent NAD boxes. The DNA-repressor complex would sequester a potential RNA polymerase binding site and thereby decrease expression of the nad regulon.

Adjacent cooperation of proteins on DNA are not representative of long-distance interactions

The cI repressor of bacteriophage lambda is better-fitted to the proximal interactions in which it naturally takes part than to the long-distance cooperative interactions on DNA for which it has become representative. The first observation in support of this statement is the ambiguity of an untypical DNAase I footprint which has become a diagnostic for DNA circularisation (and thus for the capacity of the protein to control expression at a distance). However, it was also observed without effective DNA looping when lac repressor binds to nearly contiguous sites. Additionally, the surface of interaction between the two dimers seems to be more important than the one commonly admitted (via some contacts between the flexible arms), the biological function of the repressor is lost when the sites are separated and loops have not been observed for large separation of the sites. In fact, naturally distant interactions can conform to shorter distances, as an intrinsic property of DNA looping. On the contrary, interactions which are naturally optimised for contiguity are generally constrained to proximity. Alternative protein-protein contacts are generally responsible for this situation (cf. CRP versus NRI in Escherichia coli).

Autoregulation of the plasmid addiction operon of bacteriophage P1

The P1 plasmid addiction operon increases the apparent stability of a plasmid that carries it by killing plasmid-free (cured) segregants. The operon consists of a gene encoding an endotoxin responsible for death on curing (doc), preceded by a gene encoding a relatively unstable antidote that can prevent host death (phd). When the copy number of the operon was increased, expression of a lacZ reporter fused to the promoter of the operon decreased, indicating that expression of the operon was stabilized by an autoregulatory circuit. Transcription of the lacZ reporter was repressed about 10-fold when phd, without doc, was expressed from an exogenous promoter. DNase I footprinting showed that Phd binds a perfect 10-base pair palindromic DNA sequence and, at higher concentrations, an adjacent, imperfect palindrome. The palindromic sites are located between the -10 region of the putative promoter and the start codon of phd. Electrophoretic mobility of DNA containing the promoter region was retarded in the presence of Phd and further retarded in the presence of Phd and Doc. When doc was co-expressed with phd, repression of the lacZ fusion was enhanced more than 100-fold. Thus, both products of the addiction operon participate in its autoregulation.

Active contribution of two domains to cooperative DNA binding of the enhancer-binding protein nitrogen regulator I (NtrC) of Escherichia coli: stimulation by phosphorylation and the binding of ATP

Activation by the prokaryotic activator nitrogen regulator I (NRI, or NtrC) of Escherichia coli requires an interaction between two NRI dimers. ATP-dependent phosphorylation stimulates this tetramerization, which can be detected as cooperative binding to DNA. A polypeptide containing only the DNA-binding carboxyl-terminal domain has been previously shown to bind noncooperatively to DNA. Our primary purpose was to determine whether the highly conserved N-terminal domain or the ATP-binding central domain is required for cooperative DNA binding. Because ATP was present in the experiments that showed that phosphorylation enhances cooperative bindings, it is possible that ATP and not phosphorylation stimulated cooperative binding. Our secondary purpose was to separately assess the effects of ATP and phosphorylation on cooperative binding. We showed that a variant with a deletion of the central domain, NRI-(delta 143-398), binds cooperatively as well as unphosphorylated wild-type NRI, implying that the N-terminal domain mediates phosphorylation-independent cooperative binding. Phosphorylation of NRI-(delta 143-398) did not further stimulate this binding, suggesting that the ATP-binding central domain may be required for the phosphorylation-dependent enhancement. Cooperative binding was enhanced by either acetyl-phosphate-dependent (i.e., ATP-independent) phosphorylation of NRI or the specific binding of ATP to the central domain. Their effects were not additive, a finding which is consistent with the interpretation that each promotes a similar dimer-dimer interaction. We discuss these results within the context of the hypothesis that the highly conserved N-terminal domain mediates phosphorylation-independent cooperativity and the central domain is required for cooperativity stimulated by ATP binding or phosphorylation.

Efficient concerted integration of retrovirus-like DNA in vitro by avian myeloblastosis virus integrase

We report the efficient concerted integration of a linear virus-like DNA donor into a 2.8 kbp circular DNA target by integrase (IN) purified from avian myeloblastosis virus. The donor was 528 bp, contained recessed 3' OH ends, was 5' end labeled, and had a unique restriction site not found in the target. Analysis of concerted (full-site) and half-site integration events was accomplished by restriction enzyme analysis and agarose gel electrophoresis. The donor also contained the SupF gene that was used for genetic selection of individual full-site recombinants to determine the host duplication size. Two different pathways, involving either one donor or two donor molecules, were used to produce full-site recombinants. About 90% of the full-site recombinants were the result of using two donor molecules per target. These results imply that juxtapositioning an end from each of two donors by IN was more efficient than the juxtapositioning of two ends of a single donor for the full-site reaction. The formation of preintegration complexes containing integrase and donor on ice prior to the addition of target enhanced the full-site reaction. After a 30 min reaction at 37 degrees C, approximately 20-25% of all donor/target recombinants were the result of concerted integration events. The efficient production of full-site recombinants required Mg2+; Mn2+ was only efficient for the production of half-site recombinants. We suggest that these preintegration complexes can be used to investigate the relationships between the 3' OH trimming and strand transfer reactions.

Leucine-responsive regulatory protein and deoxyadenosine methylase control the phase variation and expression of the sfa and daa pili operons in Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli operons daa and sfa encode F1845 and S pili, respectively. In this paper we show that the expression of these operons is under phase variation control at a transcriptional level. The transcription of both operons is dependent on the global regulator leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp) and deoxyadenosine methylase (Dam). Lrp is required for methylation protection of two GATC sites located within conserved DNA sequences in the regulatory regions of these operons. These GATC sites are differentially methylated, establishing a methylation pattern which is characteristic of either the phase ON or phase OFF state. We also show that Lrp binds to the daa and sfa regulatory regions and that this binding is modulated by the methylation of the GATC sites. These results indicate that the phase variation of the daa and sfa operons is regulated by a mechanism involving differential binding of Lrp owing to methylation of GATC sites in the regulatory region, which is similar to the mechanism that controls phase variation of the pap operon.

A novel antivirulence element in the temperate bacteriophage HK022

Lysogens of the temperate lambdoid phage HK022 are immune to superinfection by HK022. Superinfection immunity is conferred in part by the action of the HK022 CI repressor at the O.R operators. In this work, we have identified an additional regulatory element involved in immunity. This site, termed OFR (operator far right), is located just downstream of the cro gene, more than 250 nucleotides distant from OR. The behavior of phage containing a mutation in OFR suggests that the wild-type site functions as an antivirulence element. HK022 OFR- mutants were able to form turbid plaques indistinguishable from those of the wild type. However, they gave rise to virulent derivatives at a far higher frequency than the wild type (approximately 10(-5) for OFR- versus about 10(-9) for the wild type). This frequency was so high that cultures of HK022 OFR- lysogens were rapidly overgrown by virulent derivatives. Whereas virulent mutants arising from a wild-type OFR+ background contained mutations in both OR1 and OR2, virulent derivatives of the OFR- mutant phage contained a single mutation in either OR1 or OR2. We conclude that the wild-type OFR site functions to prevent single mutations in OR from conferring virulence. The mechanism by which OFR acts is not yet clear. Both CI and Cro bound to OFR and repressed a very weak rightward promoter (PFR). It is unlikely that repression of PFR by CI or Cro binding to OFR can account in full for the antivirulence phenotype conferred by this element, since PFR is such a weak promoter. Other models for the possible action of OFR are discussed.

Regulation of pyelonephritis-associated pili phase-variation in Escherichia coli: binding of the PapI and the Lrp regulatory proteins is controlled by DNA methylation

Expression of pyelonephritis-associated pili (Pap) in Escherichia coli is under a phase-variation control mechanism in which individual cells alternate between pili+ (ON) and pili- (OFF) states through a process involving DNA methylation by deoxyadenosine methylase (Dam). Methylation of two GATC sites (GATC1028 and GATC1130) within the pap regulatory region is differentially inhibited in phase ON and phase OFF cells. The GATC1028 site of phase ON cells is non-methylated and the GATC1130 site is fully methylated. Conversely, in phase OFF cells the GATC1028 site is fully methylated whereas the GATC1130 site is non-methylated. Two transcriptional activators, PapI and Lrp (leucine-responsive regulatory protein), are required for this specific methylation inhibition. DNA footprint analysis using non-methylated pap DNAs indicates that Lrp binds to a region surrounding the GATC1130 site, whereas PapI does not appear to bind to pap regulatory DNA. However, addition of Lrp and PapI together results in an additional DNaseI footprint around the GATC1028 site. Moreover, Dam methylation inhibits binding of Lrp/PapI near the GATC1028 site and alters binding of Lrp at the GATC1130 site. Our results support a model in which Dam and Lrp/PapI compete for binding near the GATC1028 site, regulating the methylation state of this GATC site and, consequently, the pap transcription state.