HLA class II antigen expression and the autoimmune thyroid response in patients with benign and malignant thyroid tumors

Increased binding of IFN regulating factor 1 mediates the synergistic induction of CIITA by IFN-gamma and tumor necrosis factor-alpha in human thyroid carcinoma cells

Expression of MHC class II molecules is restricted to professional antigen-presenting immune cells, but it can be induced by IFN-gamma in other cell types. Thyroid cells have been shown to induce class II expression (mainly HLA-DR) following stimulation with IFN-gamma and addition of tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha synergistically enhanced this expression. Class II transactivator (CIITA) has been implicated as the master regulator of MHC class II molecules and its transcription has been shown to be regulated from four different promoters, one of which is responsible for its induction by IFN-gamma. The aim of this study was to find whether CIITA is synergistically induced by IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha in the human thyroid MRO-87-1 cell line, and to investigate the molecular mechanisms responsible for this synergism. We have demonstrated that IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha synergistically induce HLA-DRalpha and CIITA mRNAs, but prolonged incubation resulted in the inhibition of CIITA mRNA accumulation. Several potential mechanisms that could explain the synergistic effect were explored. NF-kappaB did not bind the CIITA inducible promoter and addition of SN50, which inhibits NF-kappaB translocation to the nucleus, did not change the synergistic effect. Furthermore, IFN-gamma did not induce IkappaBalpha degradation. Synergistic activation of signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT)-1 or IFN regulating factor (IRF)-1 was not observed, and STAT-1 did not bind the CIITA inducible promoter. IRF-1, although not synergistically induced or activated, bound synergistically to its specific cis element on the CIITA type IV promoter. Thus we propose that IRF-1 binding mediates the synergistic induction of HLA-DRalpha and CIITA in thyroid cells.

Regulation of HLA-DR and costimulatory B7 molecules in human thyroid carcinoma cells: differential binding of transcription factors to the HLA-DRalpha promoter

The consequence of autoantigen presentation by thyroid cells is dependent on the magnitude of expression of both HLA class II antigens (mainly HLA-DR) and costimulatory molecules, such as B7 (CD80 and CD86). Autoimmune thyrocytes are induced to express HLA-DR by interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). The costimulatory signal leading to autoantibody production or cytotoxic T-cell immune response could be provided by antigen presenting cells (APCs) attracted to the thyroid by the primary autoimmune stimulus. Malignant thyrocytes can express HLA-DR antigens either constitutively, as a result of a nonimmunologic stimulus, or on induction with IFN-gamma after triggering of an immune response. However, their ability to express B7 molecules, which may determine enhanced antitumoral immune response mainly in the absence of intrathyroidal macrophages, has not yet been studied. The regulation of HLA-DR gene expression in APCs, such as B cells, is mediated by a series of short DNA consensus sequences located in the promoter, termed the W, X, and Y boxes, which bind several known transcription factors. We have previously characterized the expression of HLA-DR in four human thyroid carcinoma cell lines and found differences between constitutive and high- or moderate-induced expression of the protein and mRNA. Evaluation of B7 expression on the surface of thyroid cancer cells and understanding the mechanisms of HLA-DR gene expression may help in designing efficient immune response to thyroid tumors. Using the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA), we have demonstrated differences between the four thyroid cell lines in the binding of transcription factors to each of the three boxes. The binding to the promoter in each of the cell lines resulted in a single band, probably representing a complex of proteins formed via protein-protein interactions. Using flow cytometry we have shown that the B7 molecule was absent in the four thyroid cell lines and could not be induced by IFN-gamma. The absence of surface B7 molecules from the malignant thyroid cells may lead to either suppression of antitumoral cytotoxic T cell response or demand the cooperation of infiltrating APCs to favor immune response. Differences previously found in HLA-DR expression in the four human malignant thyroid cell lines may be explained by the variation in the binding of transcription factors to the boxes in the HLA-DRalpha promoter. The binding patterns of nuclear proteins derived from the four thyroid cell lines or from the B lymphocyte cell line--Raji--to each of the boxes or to the whole promoter exhibit similarities, thus suggesting similar DNA-protein interactions.

Aberrantly expressed cytokeratin 1, a tumor-associated autoantigen in papillary thyroid carcinoma

Papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) is a somewhat puzzling disease, combining a propensity to metastasize with an indolent clinical course. The often pronounced T cell-dominated inflammatory infiltrate seen in PTC tumors has prompted us to search for signs of a tumor-induced immune response. In previous studies, we have demonstrated large tumor-specific deposits of IgG and complement in PTC tissue and isolated a putative target antigen. This investigation examines the presence of autoantibodies to cytokeratin 1, a high m.w. cytokeratin normally expressed only in suprabasal keratinocytes, in the serum and tumor tissue of PTC patients. Using immunoprecipitation and Western blot, cytokeratin 1-reactive autoantibodies were demonstrated in 80% of the PTC sera tested, and tumor-derived antibodies were shown to precipitate cytokeratin 1. Using immunohistochemistry, cytokeratins 1 and 10 were found in a large proportion of PTC tumors (39/44) but were absent from normal thyrocytes of most PTC-bearing glands. Our results indicate that this protein is expressed aberrantly in neoplastic cells and is immunogenic in this context.

HLA-DR expression and lymphocytic infiltration in metastatic and non-metastatic papillary carcinoma of the thyroid

Thyrocyte HLA-DR expression in association with lymphocytic infiltration has been demonstrated in autoimmune diseases of the thyroid. HLA-DR expression has been noted both in association with lymphocytic infiltration and in its absence. However, no prognostic significance was attributed to these findings. The purpose of this study on papillary carcinoma of the thyroid was to examine how tumour behaviour relates independently to HLA-DR expression and lymphocytic infiltration. Fifty patients with papillary carcinoma with known metastatic status were examined for HLA-DR expression utilizing the immunoperoxidase conjugated indirect method. The patients were divided into three groups: no metastases (n = 16), regional lymph node metastases only (n = 25), and distant haematogenous metastases (n = 9). Overall HLA-DR expression was noted in 6, 36 and 55% of the respective groups. Tumour HLA-DR expression without lymphocytic infiltration was noted in 0, 4 and 33% of the respective groups. Tumour HLA-DR expression with lymphocytic infiltration occurred in 6, 32 and 22% of the respective groups. From these findings we conclude that HLA-DR expression with lymphocytic infiltration occurs more frequently than HLA-DR expression in the absence of infiltration. The concurrence of HLA-DR expression and lymphocytic infiltration is most commonly associated with regional lymph node metastasis. HLA-DR expression in the absence of lymphocytic infiltration occurs in tumours with distant haematogenous metastases and is an uncommon feature of tumours that have not metastasized or have metastasized only to lymph nodes. Tumour HLA-DR expression in the absence of lymphocytic infiltration may indicate the potential for more aggressive behaviour.

HLA-D Antigen Expression and Langerhans' Cell Infiltrates in Thyroid Tumors

Papillary carcinomas (PCs) of thyroid are among the most common but least aggressive human malignancies. The factors explaining the indolence of these tumors are unknown but host-tumor immune interactions may play a role. This study was designed to determine if there is morphologic evidence of these. Frozen tissues collected from 21 PCs, 4 follicular adenomas (FAs), 4 follicular carcinomas (FCs), and 11 nodular hyperplasias (NHs) were stained immunohistochemically for HlLA-D antigens, lymphocyte, and macrophage markers; results were graded numerically. Paraffin-embedded tumors (35 PCs, 10 FAs, and 10 FCs) were stained for 5-100 protein to detect Langerhans' cells (LCs). Diffuse staining for HLA-D antigens and heavy mononuclear infiltrates were found more commonly in PCs compared to follicular neoplasms (FNs) or NHs. No consistent relationship was found between lymphocyte/macrophage infiltrates and expression of HLA-D antigens. The largest number of LCs was in PCs (median 11.8 cells/standard microscopic field [c/smf]), fewer cells were found in FA (3.7 c/smf), and the least in FC (0.05 c/smf). Features of host-tumor interaction including HLA-D expression and infiltrates with lymphocyte macrophages and LC are more strongly expressed in PC than other tumors. This may play a role in explaining their biological behavior.

Graves' disease thyroid tissue transplants in scid mice: persistent selectivity in hTcR Va gene family use

We have analyzed the human T-cell receptor (hTcR) V alpha gene repertoire in thyroid tissue transplants of a patient with hyperthyroid Graves' disease. Blocks of thyroid tissue were transplanted subcutaneously into 10 mice with severe immunodeficiency (scid) and 4 weeks later 5 of the mice were injected intraperitoneally with autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) (10(7) cells per mouse). After a further 3 weeks, mice were sacrificed and total cellular RNA and cDNA prepared from each of the explants. We used specific olingonucleotides in polymerase chain reactions (PCR) to amplify 18 different human hTcR V alpha gene families and the identity of the PCR fragments was confirmed by Southern blot analysis. Different samples of the donor thyroid tissue consistently expressed 9-10 of the 18 hTcR V alpha gene families screened (V alpha 1-7, 11, 12 & 15). A more marked bias in hTcR V gene family use was seen in each of the explants with a mean of only 2.8 V alpha gene families detected. After 7 weeks of transplantation, the thyroid explants largely reflected some of the same genes seen in the hTcR V gene repertoire of the donor tissue with particularly pronounced expression of V alpha 2 and V alpha 3 gene families. The transplantation of PBMC into the scid mice showed evidence for their accumulation within the transplanted thyroid tissues as judged by the appearance of additional hTcR V gene families expressed in these samples although the specificity of such accumulation remains unclear.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Divergent effects of cytokines on human leukocyte antigen-DR antigen expression of neoplastic and non-neoplastic human thyroid cells

Apparently complex modulatory effects of alpha-interferon (alpha-IFN), tumor necrosis factor (TNF), and epidermal growth factor (EGF) have been found in neoplastic human thyroid cells, which could possibly affect the final outcome in neoplastic disease. This was achieved by examining the influence of alpha-IFN, TNF, and EGF alone and in combination, on human leukocyte antigen-DR (DR) antigen expression and viability of neoplastic and non-neoplastic human thyroid cells in culture. alpha-IFN-induced DR antigen expression on non-neoplastic human thyroid cells, whereas TNF-alpha or EGF alone were ineffective. The addition of the same TNF-alpha concentrations (10 to 100 ng/ml) to alpha-IFN enhanced the expression of DR antigens compared with the effect of alpha-IFN alone. However, EGF inhibited alpha-IFN-induced DR on the same cells and at the same concentrations (10 to 500 ng/ml) at which the growth factor alone was ineffective. In contrast to the common pattern of cytokine effects on DR expression of all nonmalignant thyroid cell lines, neoplastic thyroid cell lines showed divergent responses to alpha-IFN, TNF-alpha, and EGF. In three malignant thyroid cell lines that were DR negative (follicular carcinoma WRO 82-1 and NRO 87-1 cell lines, and anaplastic carcinoma ARO 81-1), DR antigen could be induced by alpha-IFN and enhanced by TNF-alpha, whereas EGF was ineffective. In a fourth cell line (an anaplastic carcinoma SW1736) alpha-IFN, TNF-alpha, and EGF alone were capable of inducing DR, and a combination of either TNF-alpha and EGF with alpha-IFN potentiated DR induction. In a fifth neoplastic cell line (papillary carcinoma, NPA) that constitutively expressed surface DR, its expression was inhibited by both alpha-IFN and TNF-alpha and was not affected by EGF.

T cells and human autoimmune thyroid disease: emerging data show lack of need to invoke suppressor T cell problems

Human T cells recognize self and foreign antigens when such antigens are processed into small peptides and bound to molecules coded for by genes of the HLA region on chromosome 6. The part of the T-cell surface which is responsible for such recognition is a set of molecules coded for by a variety of genes and known as the T-cell-receptor complex. In animal models, T cells are able to transfer autoimmune thyroiditis and T cells have, therefore, long been implicated in the etiology of human autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD). Information gained from the study of intrathyroidal T cells and thyroid antigen-specific T-cell clones has shown that in patients with Graves' disease, mainly helper T-cell clones have been obtained, whereas in autoimmune (Hashimoto's) thyroiditis cytolytic T-cell clones may be predominant. Such thyroid antigen-specific T cells have now been shown to recognize one or other of the three major thyroid-specific antigens; thyroglobulin, thyroid peroxidase, or the TSH receptor and efforts are currently in progress to characterize the T-cell epitopes of these major thyroid autoantigens. Recent findings of restricted T-cell receptor V gene use amongst intrathyroidal T cells confirm the primary role of T cells in human thyroid autoimmune processes leading to AITD. However, the mechanisms whereby such autoreactive T cells escape deletion and anergy, and how they become activated, remain uncertain. There is compelling evidence that the thyroid cell itself, by expressing HLA molecules, and presenting antigen directly to the T cells, may initiate disease, perhaps after an external insult.

Distribution of Langerhans cells and HLA class II molecules in prostatic carcinomas of different histopathological grade

We have investigated Langerhans cell (LC) distribution in 38 prostatic carcinomas, of various degrees of differentiation, by immunohistochemistry with a polyclonal anti-S-100 serum, furthermore evaluating the expression of HLA class II-DR by neoplastic cells using a monoclonal antibody (MoAb) that reacts with a monomorphic determinant in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue. Antiserum to S-100 protein identified LCs mostly in carcinomas ranging from grade 1 to grade 2, while LCs were inconspicuous in grade 4 and virtually absent in grade 5 cancers. Moreover, sections stained with the anti -HLA-DR MoAb displayed an immunoreactivity, both cytoplasmic and apical, especially confined to neoplastic glands of low grade (1-2) carcinomas. Although we did not find a direct correlation between the two parameters under investigation and lymphoid infiltrate, we were able to document an increased number of HLA class II-positive interstitial cells in low-grade carcinomas, corresponding mostly to macrophages. Our results indicate that LC number is inversely correlated to the histopathological grade and directly to the expression of HLA class II-DR molecules by tumor cells; we believe that this might be important in understanding the more favorable biological behavior of low-grade prostate carcinomas as opposed to the higher grades, since LCs and HLA class II molecules may provide a means of eliciting the immune response, both LCs and epithelial cells expressing HLA class II molecules being capable of direct antigen presentation to immune cells. In this context macrophages might play a primary role in controlling tumor progression. To the best of our knowledge this is the first time that an attempt is made to correlate LCs and HLA class II expression to histopathological grading of prostatic carcinomas. We would also suggest that the presence of LCs and HLA class II molecules, either singly or in combination, in carcinoma of the prostate represents a good prognostic indicator, being constantly associated with the clinically less aggressive low-grade tumors. The evaluation of these two parameters might prove useful in the assessment of intermediate grades where no valid histologic criteria have been found to predict the clinical course of the disease.

Immunohistochemical evidence for IgE involvement in Graves' orbitopathy

Orbital muscle and adipose tissues from seven Graves' orbitopathy patients were studied with in situ assays for IgE. The cases varied in disease severity and site biopsied. Two monoclonal and one polyclonal anti-IgE reagents produced similar results. Identically prepared monoclonal anti-IgM and anti-IgG antibodies and tissues obtained from five patients treated for unrelated orbital disorders were used as controls. Graves' tissues exhibited extravasated leukocytes and leukocyte-rich vessels. These leukocytes were mostly lymphoid. Some basophils and mast cells were identified and polymorphonuclear cells were abundant within vessels of adipose tissue. IgE-positive material was found in association with the majority of leukocytes and with muscle fibers. Parallel sections reacted with anti-IgM antibody were negative, whereas anti-IgG produced diffuse staining with no specific structures highlighted. Control, non-Graves' tissues had no evidence of immune cell activity and were either negative or displayed reactions with anti-IgE reagents that were in most cases different from those of Graves' tissue. Serum IgE was measured in six of the seven patients and was elevated in the two patients with fulminating disease.

Human autoimmune thyroid disease A mechanistic update

Autoimmune thyroid disease refers to a group of common, often familial, disorders of thyroid function, which are associated with disturbances in both cellular and humoral immunity. Current research into autoimmune thyroid disease is characterizing specific target antigens and the cellular and molecular events that lead to tissue-specific immune dysfunction. The thyroid gland is an accessible and useful model for the study of human autoimmune disease. This review highlights some of the more active research areas.

Expression of HLA ABC and DR antigens in thyroid neoplasia and correlation with mononuclear leukocyte infiltration

The rejection of tumor cells by the immune system depends on the production of tumor-associated antigens and the expression of HLA antigens on these cells. We therefore studied the expression of HLA ABC and DR antigens in malignant and benign thyroid disorders and correlated it with the types and extent of mononuclear cell infiltration. In the normal thyroid, HLA ABC expression was weak and focal, while it was diffusely present in benign disorders and in most but not all malignancies. HLA DR antigens, while absent or infrequently expressed in normal thyroid, were strongly but often focally expressed in all cases of autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD), as well as in most cases of malignant tumors and benign epithelium surrounding these tumors, and colloid nodule disease. There was a T cell predominance in all disorders, and the CD4+/CD8+ ratio was greater than 1 in most benign and malignant specimens. There was a direct correlation between the high expression of HLA antigens and dense inflammatory infiltration in AITD but not in most tumor specimens. Lack of such correlation suggests that the expression of HLA antigens is an autonomous event in tumors, independent of cellular infiltrate.

Intrathyroidal accumulation of T cell phenotypes in autoimmune thyroid disease

In this study we have correlated peripheral T cell subset phenotypes with intrathyroidal lymphocyte accumulation in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease (Graves' and Hashimoto's disease). Our study utilized euthyroid family members for one of our control groups (n = 48) thus significantly limiting familial, but not disease-specific, influences on these T cell phenotypes. Our principal new observations were found only in patients with Graves' disease. As previously reported, there was a decrease in CD8+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) T cells in the peripheral blood of patients with untreated hyperthyroid Graves' disease (n = 27) (mean +/- SEM, 19 +/- 1.1% in patients compared with 25 +/- 1.2% in controls, p = 0.03), a finding not observed in treated, euthyroid Graves' disease patients or their relatives. However, the relative number of CD8+ T cells, assessed by CD4:CD8 ratios, was increased in the intrathyroidal T cell populations (n = 10), when compared to normal and patient peripheral blood. There were no consistent changes in total CD4+ (helper) T cells in the peripheral blood of patients with treated and untreated Graves' disease but a reduction in CD4+2H4+ (suppressor-inducer) T cells was seen in patients undergoing surgery for Graves' disease (13 +/- 6.9% compared with 39 +/- 3.4%). Again, however, this T cell subset was increased within the target organ of the same patients (41 +/- 5.9%). These data point to either a selective accumulation, or a specific "homing", of certain T cell subsets within the thyroid gland of patients with Graves' disease where T cell differentiation may be strongly influenced by antithyroid drug treatment and the local immune environment.

Human autoimmune thyroid disease: cellular and molecular aspects

We have reviewed the impact of cellular and molecular biology on our understanding of the immune system and thyroid autoimmune disease and presented the evidence that MHC, TCR and immunoglobulin genes are involved in susceptibility to such disease. At the level of the target thyroid epithelial cell, the identification of the genes for Tg and TPO (the microsomal antigen) using recombinant DNA techniques are evidence of dramatic progress. On the humoral side of the immune response, the investigation of restricted clonality is still hampered by the technical difficulties in obtaining immortal B cell lines producing thyroid antigen specific high affinity IgG antibodies, although the advent of tools to sequence the immunoglobulin V genes from small quantities of DNA will overcome this difficulty (e.g. by polymerase chain reactions). T cells have also begun to be characterized both phenotypically, thanks to the advent of ever better characterized monoclonal antibodies, and functionally at the clonal level, thanks to refinement of cell culture techniques. Future studies in this area will also need to focus on cell immortalization and maintenance of antigen-specific responses although, major strides in the direct sequencing of the TCR are taking place and investigation of T cell receptors in antigen-specific T cells should be feasible. MHC associations with thyroid autoimmune disease, as studied by analysis of RFLP patterns, have not significantly improved already established serological HLA associations and direct MHC gene sequencing will be required. Analysis of the organ-specific regulation of MHC class II gene expression has led to a better understanding of the functional role of MHC class II genes in thyroid autoimmune disease at the target cell level. Such studies have pointed out important local immune responses within the thyroid gland but have not yet provided the initiating factor or factors for human autoimmune thyroid disease in genetically susceptible individuals.