Potentiation of radiotherapy by cis-dichlorodiammine platinum (II) in advanced cervical carcinoma

Concurrent chemoradiotherapy vs. radiotherapy alone in locally advanced cervix cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The efficacy of concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CTRT) in locally advanced cervix cancer (LACC, stages IIB-IVA) is contentious. This is due to the variable extent of therapeutic benefit reported in different randomized clinical trials and meta-analyses that usually include all stages of cervix cancer. A systematic review and meta-analysis was therefore conducted to evaluate the efficacy of concurrent CTRT over radiotherapy (RT) alone, predominantly in LACC for the key endpoints; complete response (CR), long-term loco-regional control (LRC), overall survival (OS), grade III/IV acute and late toxicities. Six databases namely - PubMed, EMBASE, SCOPUS, Web of Science, Google Scholar and Cochrane library were explored and supplemented by hand-searching. Only prospective randomized trials conducted in LACC between concurrent CTRT and RT alone with no surgical interventions were included. Fourteen English language articles from 1788 citations were shortlisted for the final analysis. Of the 2445 patients evaluated (CTRT: n=1217; RT: n=1228), 95.7% had LACC and 96% had a squamous cell histology. Eight studies used cisplatin alone, 4 had cisplatin-based combination chemotherapy (CT) while 2 used mitomycin-C, either alone or in combination. CTRT improved the CR (+10.2%, p=0.027), LRC (+8.4%, p<0.001) and OS (+7.5%, p<0.001) over RT alone. However a 10.4% higher incidence of grade III/IV acute toxicities (p<0.001) was also evident with CTRT. Late toxicities in both groups were equivalent. Subgroup analysis and meta-regression did not reveal any significant advantage in outcomes between the 3 CTRT regimens. Thus, although concurrent CTRT provides conclusive therapeutic benefit over RT alone in LACC, the choice of CT agents should be based on their cost-effectiveness and the anticipated expenses for the management of any associated acute toxicities. This assumes importance particularly in resource-constrained low-middle-income countries with the highest burden of LACC, where majority of the patients meet the treatment costs as out-of-pocket expenses.

[Result of concurrent chemoradiotherapy for cervical cancer at Radiation Oncology Service of University Hospital Joseph Ravoahangy Andrianavalona from 2007 to 2009]

La radiochimiothérapie devient un standard pour le traitement du cancer du col utérin à partir de IB de mauvais pronostic. L'objectif de ce travail est de rapporter les résultats de cette modalité thérapeutique. Il s'agissait d'une étude rétrospective descriptive des dossiers des patientes atteintes d'un cancer du col utérin du Janvier 2007 au Décembre 2009 traitées par une radiochimiothérapie concomitante. Les patientes ayant reçu une dose inférieure à 45Gy étaient éliminées dans cette étude. Les critères de l'OMS ont été utilisés pour évaluer la réponse tumorale. Au total 46patientes étaient retenues avec un âge moyen de 47ans. Le carcinome épidermoide représentait 89,13%, diagnostiqués au stade localement avancé dans 82,60%. Seulement 26,08% de nos patients ont bénéficié d'une tomodensitométrie abdominale et pelvienne. La dose reçue variait de 45 à 75 Gy. Les résultats thérapeutiques à un mois de la fin du traitement montraient: 45,63% de rémission complète et 30,42% de rémission partielle supérieure à 50%. La toxicité précoce était dominée par la neutropénie chiffrée à 30,55%. A travers de cette étude, la radiochimiothérapie concomitante a amélioré les résultats thérapeutiques à court terme.

Primary surgery versus chemoradiation in the treatment of IB2 cervical carcinoma: A cost effectiveness analysis

OBJECTIVES

To estimate the relative cost-effectiveness of treatments for patients with FIGO stage IB2 cervical cancer and no evidence of metastasis as determined by combination of positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT).

METHODS

A Markov state transition model was constructed to compare two strategies: (1) radical hysterectomy and pelvic lymphadenectomy with tailored adjuvant therapy (RH+TA); (2) primary chemoradiation (CR). Five-year survival estimates for FIGO stage IB2 cervical cancer were obtained from literature. Medicare reimbursement rates and Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality database were used to obtain costs of treatment regimens and grades 3-5 adverse events. Strategies were compared using incremental cost per year of life saved (YLS). Extensive sensitivity analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Overall survival estimates were 78.9% for CR; 79.6% for RH+TA. Mean cost for CR at 5 years was $21,403 compared to $27,840 for RH+TA. RH+TA cost $63,689 per additional year of life saved (YLS) compared to CR. Results were most sensitive to survival estimates and the costs associated with high dose rate (HDR) versus low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy. If 90% of patients with intermediate pathologic risk factors at surgery were assumed to receive adjuvant CR, the ICER of RH+TA rose to $100,000 per YLS compared to CR.

CONCLUSIONS

RH+TA is potentially cost effective when compared to CR for patients with stage IB2 cervical cancer without metastatic disease by PET/CT imaging. Key factors in the cost-effectiveness of treatments include physician's expected recommendation of adjuvant therapy, brachytherapy modality employed for primary CR and quality of life related to both treatment and its complications.

Multimodality therapy for locally advanced cervical carcinoma: state of the art and future directions

Globally, cervical cancer is the second most common cause of cancer-related mortality among women causing approximately 234,000 deaths annually among developing countries and killing 40,000 in developed nations. Most of these deaths occur in women with bulky or locally advanced cervical cancer, International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) stages IIB through IVA, when lesions are not amenable to high cure rates with surgery or radiation (RT). The standard prescription for RT used to treat locally advanced cervical cancer has been dictated by common practice and patterns of care studies. In contrast, the addition of concomitant chemotherapy to RT has been studied in a number of randomized prospective trials, which are discussed in detail. When added to RT, cisplatin reduces the relative risk of death from cervical carcinoma by approximately 50% by decreasing local/pelvic failure and distant metastases. In 1999, weekly intravenous cisplatin at 40 mg/m2 for 6 weeks in combination with RT was established as a new standard for the treatment of locally advanced cervical carcinoma. More recently, this recommendation has been expanded to include women with FIGO stage IB2 lesions as well as those with bulky stage IIA cancers. This monograph reviews the state of the art in treating locally advanced cervical cancer with combined chemotherapy and RT and discusses clinical and pathologic prognostic factors that impact cure. Quality of life during and after multimodality therapy is considered as well as ongoing clinical trials and future directions.

Effects of different chemotherapy regimens on survival for advanced cervical cancer: Systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

A large number of trials have assessed various chemotherapy regimens for the treatment of advanced cervical cancer, but there is uncertainty about the magnitude of survival benefits.

METHODS

We searched (last update January 2006) for trials in women with locally advanced or disseminated cervical cancer that compared neo-adjuvant or concurrent chemotherapy plus radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone; or different chemotherapy regimens among themselves (with or without background radiotherapy in both arms). Sixty-five trials were identified with survival data on 11,180 women. Results for survival were combined with fixed and random effects models and between-study heterogeneity was estimated. Separate results were obtained for different regimens, cycle length, and type of chemotherapy (neo-adjuvant, concurrent, without radiotherapy).

RESULTS

Twenty two comparisons had survival data on 3837 women randomized to receive chemotherapy plus radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone; the summary relative hazard for mortality was 0.95, 95% CI, 0.83-1.08. Modest between-study heterogeneity (I2=38%) seemed to be due to contradictory results in early trials; trials published in the last decade had a summary relative hazard 0.89 (95% CI, 0.78-1.02) and no between-study heterogeneity (I2=0%). Results were similar for neo-adjuvant chemotherapy and for concurrent chemo-radiotherapy. Cisplatin or cisplatin-based combinations had no significant benefit overall, but a potential benefit was seen with short-length cycles (14 days) and a marginally significant harm with longer-length cycles (summary relative hazards 0.80, 95% CI, 0.66-0.99 and 1.18, 95% CI, 1.02-1.38, respectively). The summary relative hazard was 1.02, (95% CI, 0.84-1.24) for trials using neo-adjuvant chemotherapy and 0.85 (95% CI, 0.73-1.00) for trials using concurrent chemotherapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Evidence on chemotherapy in women with advanced cervical cancer is not encouraging for major survival benefits. However, small benefits have been observed in some trials, especially with short-length cycles of cisplatin-based regimens and concurrent chemotherapy and radiotherapy.

Concomitant chemotherapy and radiation therapy for cancer of the uterine cervix

BACKGROUND

The National Cancer Institute (USA) alert in February 1999 stated that concomitant chemoradiotherapy should be considered for all patients with cervical cancer, based on evidence from five randomised controlled trials (RCTs).

OBJECTIVES

To review all known RCTs comparing concomitant chemotherapy and radiation therapy with radiotherapy for locally advanced cervical cancer.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched electronic databases, trials registers and reference lists of published trial reports and review articles were also searched.

SELECTION CRITERIA

This review includes RCTs in cervical cancer comparing concomitant chemoradiation with radiotherapy in the experimental arm. Trials allowing further adjuvant chemotherapy or hydroxyurea were included. Trials using radiosensitisers or radioprotectors in the experimental arm were excluded.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two authors reviewed trials for inclusion and extracted data. For meta-analyses of time-to-event outcomes (survival, progression-free survival), a hazard ratio (HR) was extracted or estimated from trial reports, where possible. Only overall rates of local and distant recurrence were presented in many reports so only odds ratios (OR) of recurrence rates could be calculated, which takes no account of time to recurrence or censoring. Few trials reported acute toxicity adequately, but where possible ORs were calculated for the main types and severities of acute toxicity. The HRs and ORs for individual trials were combined across all trials, using the fixed effect model. Late toxicity was rarely described in sufficient detail so could only be reviewed qualitatively.

MAIN RESULTS

The original review was based on nineteen trials (17 published and two unpublished) including 4580 patients. This update includes twenty four trials (21 published, 3 unpublished) and 4921 patients, although due to patient exclusion and differential reporting 61% to 75% were available for the analyses. The review strongly suggests chemoradiation improves overall survival and progression free survival, whether or not platinum was used with absolute benefits of 10% and 13% respectively. There was, however, statistical heterogeneity for these outcomes. There was some evidence that the effect was greater in trials including a high proportion of stage I and II patients. Chemoradiation also showed significant benefit for local recurrence and a suggestion of a benefit for distant recurrence. Acute haematological and gastrointestinal toxicity was significantly greater in the concomitant chemoradiation group. Late effects of treatment were not well reported and so the impact of chemoradiation on these effects could not be determined adequately. Treatment-related deaths were rare.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

Concomitant chemoradiation appears to improve overall survival and progression-free survival in locally advanced cervical cancer. It also appears to reduce local and distant recurrence suggesting concomitant chemotherapy may afford radiosensitisation and systemic cytotoxic effects. Some acute toxicity is increased, but the long-term side effects are still not clear.

Concurrent weekly cisplatin and radiotherapy in routine management of cervical cancer: a report on patient compliance and acute toxicity

PURPOSE

To evaluate patient compliance and acute toxicity accompanying concurrent weekly cisplatin and radiotherapy (RT) in the routine management of cervical cancer.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Locally advanced or high-risk early-stage cervical cancer patients treated with RT and concurrent weekly cisplatin at a dose of 40 mg/m(2) i.v. (maximum dose, 70 mg) for five cycles. Definitive RT included whole pelvis external beam RT to the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements reference dose of 40 Gy plus a 10-Gy boost to the parametrium and two brachytherapy applications of 20 Gy to point A each. Postoperative RT consisted of pelvic external beam RT to the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements reference dose of 50 Gy and one brachytherapy application of 30 Gy at a depth of 0.5 cm from the applicator surface.

RESULTS

Included in this analysis were 112 consecutive cervical cancer patients treated at one institution with concurrent cisplatin and RT between May 1999 and September 2002. The median age was 48 years (range, 28-79 years). Definitive RT was administered to 57 International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics "bulky" Stage IB or IIB-IVA patients, and 53 patients underwent postoperative RT; 2 patients underwent RT for stump carcinoma. All but 2 patients (both administered definitive RT) completed RT. A total of 454 cisplatin cycles were administered (median 4 cycles/patient, range 1-6). Overall, 74% of patients received at least four cycles of cisplatin. The planned five cisplatin cycles were administered to 50 patients (45%); 42% were irradiated definitively and 47% postoperatively. The full and timely planned cisplatin dose was administered to 29 patients (26%). For 29% of patients, the interval between cycles was prolonged because of toxicity (n = 11; 10%) or for reasons not related to toxicity (n = 10; 9%). Of the 112 patients, 62 (55%) did not undergo the planned five cycles of cisplatin because of treatment toxicity (n = 35; 31%) or noncompliance with the treatment schedule because of delayed administration of the first cycle or omission of a cycle for reasons other than toxicity (n = 23; 21%). The most common side effects resulting in chemotherapy discontinuation included GI complications (n = 7) and impaired renal function (n = 5). Of the 112 patients, 49 (44%) experienced Grade 1 or 2 leukopenia and 6 (5%) Grade 3 or 4 leukopenia.

CONCLUSION

Our results show that pelvic RT combined with weekly cisplatin in cervical cancer patients is accompanied by considerable acute toxicity. Furthermore, a number of patients were unable to comply with the treatment schedule owing to reasons unrelated to treatment toxicity. Thus, administration of the full chemotherapy dose may be difficult, although the delivery of planned RT was generally not compromised. Additional follow-up is needed to assess the late toxicity of combined modality treatment.

Concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy plus radiotherapy for cervical cancer--a meta-analysis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the role of concurrent cisplatin plus radiotherapy in the treatment of cervical cancer.

METHODS

A systematic review of randomized trials of cisplatin administered concurrently with external beam radiotherapy versus radiotherapy without cisplatin for cervical cancer was combined with a meta-analysis of results abstracted from published reports of the trials.

RESULTS

Pooled survival rates from eight randomized trials that evaluated the role of cisplatin, alone or in combination with other chemotherapy agents, administered concurrently with external beam radiotherapy to patients with cervical cancer demonstrated a statistically significant effect in favour of cisplatin-based chemotherapy plus radiotherapy compared with radiotherapy without cisplatin (relative risk [RR] of death, 0.74; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.64 to 0.86). The pooled RR of death among the six trials that enrolled only women with locally advanced cervical cancer was 0.78 (95% CI, 0.67 to 0.90). The pooled relative risk for the two trials in high-risk early-stage disease also demonstrated a statistically significant benefit for the addition of cisplatin-based chemotherapy to radiotherapy (RR=0.56; 95% CI, 0.41 to 0.77).

CONCLUSION

This meta-analysis confirms that treatment with concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy plus radiotherapy improves overall survival over various controls in women with locally advanced cervical cancer, large stage IB tumours (prior to surgery) and high-risk early-stage disease (following surgery). The variation in control treatments and the quality of their delivery among the randomized trials makes interpretation difficult. Nonetheless, the meta-analysis supports the use of concurrent cisplatin with radical radiotherapy in the treatment of cervical cancer.

Concomitant chemotherapy and radiation therapy for cancer of the uterine cervix

BACKGROUND

The National Cancer Institute (USA) alert in February 1999 stated that concomitant chemoradiotherapy should be considered for all patients with cervical cancer, based on evidence from five randomised controlled trials.

OBJECTIVES

To review all known randomised clinical controlled trials (RCTs) comparing concomitant chemotherapy and radiation therapy with radiotherapy for locally advanced cervical cancer.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched electronic databases, trials registers and reference lists of published trial reports and review articles were also searched.

SELECTION CRITERIA

This review includes RCTs in cervical cancer comparing concomitant chemotherapy and radiotherapy with radiotherapy. In the experimental arm, further adjuvant chemotherapy was allowable. Hydroxyurea was considered inactive and allowable. Trials using radiosensitisers or radioprotectors in the experimental arm were excluded.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two authors reviewed trials for inclusion and extracted data. For meta-analyses of time-to-event outcomes (survival, progression-free survival), a hazard ratio (HR) was extracted or estimated from trial reports, where possible. Only overall rates of local and distant recurrence were presented in many reports so only an odds ratios (OR) of recurrence rates could be calculated, which takes no account of time to recurrence or censoring. The HRs and ORs for individual trials were combined across all trials, using the fixed effect model. Few trials reported acute toxicity adequately. Data were therefore grouped and the number of toxic events was used to calculate a single OR for each site and grade. Late toxicity was rarely described so could only be reviewed qualitatively.

MAIN RESULTS

Nineteen trials (17 published, two unpublished) were identified including 4580 patients, although due to patient exclusion and differential reporting 62-78% were available for the various analyses. The review strongly suggests chemoradiation improves overall survival and progression free survival, whether platinum was used or not with absolute benefits of 12% and 16% respectively. There was, however, statistical heterogeneity for these outcomes There was some evidence that the effect was greater in trials including a high proportion of stage I and II patients. Chemoradiation also showed significant benefit for both local and distant recurrence. Haematological and gastrointestinal toxicity was significantly greater in the concomitant chemoradiation group. Details of late morbidity were sparse.

REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS

Concomitant chemotherapy and radiotherapy appears to improve overall survival and progression-free survival in locally advanced cervical cancer. It also reduces local and distant recurrence suggesting concomitant chemotherapy may afford cytotoxic and sensitisation effects. Some acute toxicity is increased, but data on long term side effects were sparse.

[Concomitant radiochemotherapy for cancer of the cervix: critical analysis based on the Standards, Options and Recommendations methodology]

INTRODUCTION

The "Standards, Options and Recommendations" (SOR) project, started in 1993, is a collaboration between the National Federation of the French Cancer Centres (FNCLCC), the 20 French Cancer Centres (CRLCC) and specialists from French public universities, general hospitals and private clinics. The main objective is the development of clinical practice guidelines to improve the quality of health care and outcome for cancer patients. The methodology is based on literature review and critical appraisal by a multidisciplinary group of experts, with feedback from specialists in cancer care delivery.

OBJECTIVES

To update, according to the methodology of SOR, the Standards, Options and Recommendations for the management of patients with cancer of the cervix, and in particular, the place of concomitant radiochemotherapy.

METHODS

Data have been identified by a literature search using Medline (to April 1999) and the personal reference lists of experts. Once the guidelines were defined, the document was submitted for review to independent national and international reviewers and to the medical committees of the CRCC.

RESULTS

The principle recommendations concerning the place of radiochemotherapy in the treatment of cancer of the cervix are 1/ the available data shows a significant increase in local control (level of evidence A) and of overall survival (level of evidence B1) following concomitant radiochemotherapy as compared to radiotherapy alone or the combination of radiotherapy-hydroxyurea. For stages IB, IIA, proximal IIB with bad prognostic factors (tumour size greater than 4 cm and/or invasion of pelvic nodes and/or microscopic invasion of the parametrium) and without lumbo-aortic nodal invasion, concomitant radiochemotherapy can be considered as standard treatment. This benefit is less clear for stages distal IIB, III and IVA without para-aortic nodal invasion (level of evidence C) and must be confirmed (expert agreement). 2/ the toxicity of radiochemotherapy is essentially haematologic and gastrointestinal (level of evidence B1) and is greater than that of radiotherapy alone (level of evidence B1). 3/ these results have been obtained by the combination of chemotherapy based oncisplatin alone, or in combination with 5-FU. Although of equal benefit, the toxicity of the cisplatin/5-FU/ hydroxyurea combination was greater than that of cisplatin alone in a trial comparing the two protocols. A significantly longer survival have also been obtained by the combination of chemoradiation and adjuvant chemotherapy with epirubicin (level of evidence C). These results must be confirmed. 4/ the exact means of delivering the chemotherapy has not been clearly established. In fact, in these trials, some protocols use cisplatin weekly at a dose of 40 mg/m2 and others every three or four weeks at doses ranging from 50 to 75 mg/m2. Subsequent randomised studies are likely to establish optimal schema for the delivery of chemotherapy when combined with external radiotherapy and brachytherapy.

Chemoradiation and adjuvant chemotherapy in cervical cancer

PURPOSE

Radiotherapy is the standard treatment for locally advanced cervical cancer, but treatment results remain disappointing, particularly for women with bulky central disease. We investigated the role of concurrent chemoradiation and adjuvant chemotherapy in a randomized trial.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Two hundred twenty patients with bulky stage I, II, and III cervical cancer were randomized to receive either standard pelvic radiotherapy or chemoradiation (epirubicin 60 mg/m(2)) followed by adjuvant chemotherapy with epirubicin 90 mg/m(2) administered at 4-week intervals for five additional cycles.

RESULTS

Fifty-nine patients have relapsed, with a median follow-up duration of 77 months. Patients who received epirubicin radiation therapy showed a significantly longer disease-free (P =.03) and cumulative survival (P =.04). Patients who received radiation alone had significantly more distant metastasis than those who received chemoradiation (P =.012). There was no difference in long-term local tumor control (P =.99).

CONCLUSION

Survival benefit has been demonstrated in patients treated with chemoradiation followed by adjuvant chemotherapy with epirubicin as compared with patients treated with standard pelvic radiotherapy alone.

Randomized comparison of fluorouracil plus cisplatin versus hydroxyurea as an adjunct to radiation therapy in stage IIB-IVA carcinoma of the cervix with negative para-aortic lymph nodes: a Gynecologic Oncology Group and Southwest Oncology Group study

PURPOSE

In 1986, a protocol comparing primary radiation therapy (RT) plus hydroxyurea (HU) to irradiation plus fluorouracil (5-FU) and cisplatin (CF) was activated by the Gynecologic Oncology Group (GOG) for the treatment of patients with locally advanced cervical carcinoma. The goals were to determine the superior chemoradiation regimen and to quantitate the relative toxicities.

METHODS

All patients had biopsy-proven invasive squamous cell carcinoma, adenocarcinoma, or adenosquamous carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Patients underwent standard clinical staging studies and their tumors were found to be International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics stages IIB, III, or IVA. Negative cytologic washings and para-aortic lymph nodes were required for entry. Patients were randomized to receive either standard whole pelvic RT with concurrent 5-FU infusion and bolus CF or the same RT plus oral HU.

RESULTS

Of 388 randomized patients, 368 were eligible; 177 were randomized to CF and 191 to HU. Adverse effects were predominantly hematologic or gastrointestinal in both regimens. Severe or life-threatening leukopenia was more common in the HU group (24%) than in the CF group (4%). The difference in progression-free survival (PFS) was statistically significant in favor of the CF group (P = .033). The sites of progression in the two treatment groups were not substantially different. Survival was significantly better for the patients randomized to CF (P = .018).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that for patients with locally advanced carcinoma of the cervix, the combination of 5-FU and CF with RT offers patients better PFS and overall survival than HU, and with manageable toxicity.

Concurrent cisplatin-based radiotherapy and chemotherapy for locally advanced cervical cancer

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

On behalf of the Gynecologic Oncology Group, we performed a randomized trial of radiotherapy in combination with three concurrent chemotherapy regimens -- cisplatin alone; cisplatin, fluorouracil, and hydroxyurea; and hydroxyurea alone -- in patients with locally advanced cervical cancer. Women with primary untreated invasive squamous-cell carcinoma, adenosquamous carcinoma, or adenocarcinoma of the cervix of stage IIB, III, or IVA, without involvement of the para-aortic lymph nodes, were enrolled. The patients had to have a leukocyte count of at least 3000 per cubic millimeter, a platelet count of at least 100,000 per cubic millimeter, a serum creatinine level no higher than 2 mg per deciliter (177 micromol per liter), and adequate hepatic function. All patients received external-beam radiotherapy according to a strict protocol. Patients were randomly assigned to receive one of three chemotherapy regimens: 40 mg of cisplatin per square meter of body-surface area per week for six weeks (group 1); 50 mg of cisplatin per square meter on days 1 and 29, followed by 4 g of fluorouracil per square meter given as a 96-hour infusion on days 1 and 29, and 2 g of oral hydroxyurea per square meter twice weekly for six weeks (group 2); or 3 g of oral hydroxyurea per square meter twice weekly for six weeks (group 3).

RESULTS

The analysis included 526 women. The median duration of follow-up was 35 months. Both groups that received cisplatin had a higher rate of progression-free survival than the group that received hydroxyurea alone (P<0.001 for both comparisons). The relative risks of progression of disease or death were 0.57 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.42 to 0.78) in group 1 and 0.55 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.40 to 0.75) in group 2, as compared with group 3. The overall survival rate was significantly higher in groups 1 and 2 than in group 3, with relative risks of death of 0.61 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.44 to 0.85) and 0.58 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.41 to 0.81), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Regimens of radiotherapy and chemotherapy that contain cisplatin improve the rates of survival and progression-free survival among women with locally advanced cervical cancer.

Cervical carcinoma metastatic to para-aortic nodes: extended field radiation therapy with concomitant 5-fluorouracil and cisplatin chemotherapy: a Gynecologic Oncology Group study

PURPOSE

A multicenter trial of chemoradiation therapy to evaluate the feasibility of extended field radiation therapy (ERT) with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and cisplatin, and to determine the progression-free interval (PFI), overall survival (OS), and recurrence sites in patients with biopsy-confirmed para-aortic node metastases (PAN) from cervical carcinoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-five patients with cervical carcinoma and PAN metastases were entered and 86 were evaluable: Stage I--14, Stage II--40, Stage III--27, Stage IVA--5. Seventy-nine percent of the patients were followed for 5 or more years or died. ERT doses were 4500 cGy (PAN), 3960 cGy to the pelvis (Stages IB/IIB), and 4860 cGy to the pelvis (Stages IIIB/IVA). Point A intracavitary (IC) doses were 4000 cGy (Stages IB/IIB), and 3000 cGy (Stages IIIB/IVA). Point B doses were raised to 6000 cGy (ERT + IC) with parametrial boost. Concomitant chemotherapy consisted of 5-FU 1000 mg/m2/day for 96 hours and cisplatin 50 mg/m2 in weeks 1 and 5.

RESULTS

Eighty-five of 86 patients completed radiation therapy and 90% of patients completed both courses of chemotherapy. Gynecologic Oncology Group (GOG) grade 3-4 acute toxicity were gastrointestinal (18.6%) and hematologic (15.1%). Late morbidity actuarial risk of 14% at 4 years primarily involved the rectum. Initial sites of recurrence were pelvis alone, 20.9%; distant metastases only, 31.4%; and pelvic plus distant metastases, 10.5%. The 3-year OS and PFI rate were 39% and 34%, respectively, for the entire group. OS was Stage I--50%, Stage II--39%, and Stage III/IVA--38%.

CONCLUSIONS

Extended field radiation therapy with 5-FU and cisplatin chemotherapy was feasible in a multicenter clinical trial. PFI of 33% at 3 years suggests that a proportion of patients achieve control of advanced pelvic disease and that not all patients with PAN metastases have systemic disease. This points to the importance of assessment and treatment of PAN metastases.

Paclitaxel is preferentially cytotoxic to human cervical tumor cells with low Raf-1 kinase activity: implications for paclitaxel-based chemoradiation regimens

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Low Raf- kinase activity has been reported to be associated with radioresistance in epithelial tumor cell lines and with paclitaxel sensitivity in cervical tumor cells. Paclitaxel might thus be effective in eliminating radioresistant clones from cervical tumors, even in the absence of synergistic interaction between these therapeutic modalities. We thus established the relationship between Raf-1 kinase activity and radiosensitivity in human cervical tumor cells and determined if paclitaxel is preferentially cytotoxic to radio-resistant tumor clones.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We established and contrasted the radiation and paclitaxel sensitivity of 12 human cervical tumor clones that exhibited a wide range of Raf-1 kinase activity.

RESULTS

Raf-1 kinase activity was inversely correlated (P = 0.001) with SF2 values in the 12 cervical tumor clones studied. Paclitaxel was preferentially cytotoxic to radioresistant tumor clones, with the level of paclitaxel-induced cytotoxicity being significantly (P = 0.0016) influenced by Raf-1 kinase activity levels.

CONCLUSIONS

Our in vitro data indicate that there are marked, but completely opposite, Raf-1 kinase dependencies of radiation and paclitaxel cytotoxicity in cervical tumor cells. The use of combined paclitaxel and radiotherapy treatment may thus lead to higher local control rates for squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix. Circumstantially, our data suggest that the greatest therapeutic gains might accrue if paclitaxel was administered when there is the greatest proportion of tumor clones with low Raf-1 kinase activity. It may thus be desirable to use paclitaxel towards the end of radiotherapy treatment or post-radiotherapy as consolidation therapy.

Treatment of carcinoma of the uterine cervix with concomitant cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil and split course hyperfractionated radiotherapy

To improve local and systemic control of bulky (>4 cm) and/or advanced primary cancer of the uterine cervix, 35 patients were treated with concomitant cisplatin (CDDP), 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and split course hyperfractionated radiotherapy. Radiation was administered to the pelvis in five-day courses at a dose of 1.5 Gy twice daily every 21 days until a median dose of 45 Gy was reached. 15 Gy more were administered to involved parametrium or central tumor by external radiotherapy or brachytherapy. The irradiated zone was extended to include paraaortic lymph nodes if necessary. CDDP was administered at a dose of 20 mg m(-2) and 5 FU at a dose of 500 mg m(-2) from day one to day five of each course. The median number of combined treatment courses per patient was four (1-6). Local responses were obtained in 19 out of 24 patients in whom evaluation was feasible (i.e. who did not undergo surgery prior to combined therapy). Median survival was not attained with a median follow up of 33 months, three year overall survival was 62% and 52% in patients with local control and in the whole population respectively. Several patients with stage III and IV tumors achieved a very long survival. Acute toxicity was manageable but three patients required surgical repair of late radiation complications. This combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy resulted in good local control and did not rule out surgery.

Phase I-II study of combined 5-fluorouracil and cisplatin chemotherapy and altered fractionation radiotherapy for advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix

Forty patients with advanced carcinoma of the cervix were prospectively treated by an intermodality approach using chemotherapy combination concomitant with split-course hyperfractionated radiation therapy (RT). Cisplatin (CDDP) (60 mg/m2) was administered before radiotherapy initiation followed by 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) (750 mg/m2) for 5 days during the first week of irradiation. The same schedule was repeated in the last week of the RT, with 5-FU administration (1,000 mg/m2) for only 3 days. RT consisted of 5,020 cGy to the pelvis, followed by two intracavitary applications for a total of 5,000-5,500 mg/h radium equivalent when possible: 140 cGy/fraction was administered in the morning and evening, with a 6-h interval. The remainder of the external beam radiation was delivered at a standard daily fractionation of 180 cGy/fraction to a total dose of 5,020 cGy. This regimen of RT with concomitant chemotherapy had minimal toxicity and did not cause significant prolongation of the treatment program. However, a high rate of late complications was noted in patients who had extended-field RT due to paraaortic lymph node involvement. Thirty-two patients had complete response (CR) (80%). 24 (75%) of whom have no evidence disease (NED), with a median follow-up of 24 months. Our study suggests that this regimen of combined chemotherapy and RT in this group of patients with poor prognosis is effective and well tolerated, with acceptable acute toxicity and late morbidity.

A randomized trial of concurrent chemoradiotherapy versus radiotherapy in advanced carcinoma of the uterine cervix

The purpose of our study was to determine whether the chemoradiation is better than radiotherapy alone with respect to survival and treatment toxicity in patients with advanced carcinoma of the cervix. From October 1990 to April 1995, a total of 122 patients with advanced cervical carcinoma were included in this study and randomly assigned to either radiotherapy or concurrent chemotherapy and radiotherapy. The patients in the concurrent group received cisplatin, vincristine, and bleomycin every 3 weeks for a total of four courses, in combination with radiotherapy concurrently. Sixty patients were randomized to the concurrent chemoradiotherapy, and 62 were randomized to the radiotherapy alone. A tumor response was observed in 88.3% of the patients in concurrent group and in 74.2% of the patients in radiotherapy group (P = 0.04). After a median follow-up of 46.8 months, the overall disease-free survival and actuarial survival rate at 3 years were 51.7 and 61.7% in the concurrent group, and 53.2 and 64.5% in the radiotherapy group, respectively. Treatment-related toxicity appears to be higher with the combination of radiotherapy and chemotherapy compared with radiotherapy alone (36.7% versus 17.7%, P = 0.02). However, analysis by Kaplan-Meier method showed that the actuarial survival was not statistically different between the chemoradiotherapy and radiotherapy groups (mean survival time: 38.1 months versus 41.5 months, P = 0.27). In conclusion, this study showed that concurrent multiagent chemoradiotherapy did not prove to be a superior definitive therapy over radiotherapy alone for patients with advanced cervical carcinoma.

In vitro concurrent paclitaxel and radiation of four vulvar squamous cell carcinoma cell lines

BACKGROUND

The antitubule agent paclitaxel causes a cell cycle blockage in the most radiosensitive part of the cell cycle, the G2/M phase. The possible radiosensitizing effect of paclitaxel was tested in four vulvar (UM-SCV-1A, UM-SCV-1B, UM-SCV-2, and UM-SCV-4) squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) cell lines.

METHODS

A 96-well plate clonogenic assay was performed with paclitaxel and radiation, both separately and concomitantly. Survival data were fitted to the linear quadratic model. The area under the curve, equivalent to the mean inactivation dose (D), was obtained by numerical integration. The effect of paclitaxel on radiosensitivity was measured as the AUC ratio (paclitaxel plus radiation: radiation alone). This ratio was compared with the surviving fraction (SFP) after paclitaxel alone.

RESULTS

Paclitaxel concentrations of 0.4 to 2.0 nanomolar (nM) caused 1 to 70% inhibition of clonogenic survival. The AUC values of the cell lines were 1.9 to 2.9 gray. A full additive effect was observed when paclitaxel and radiation were administered concurrently; however, a supra-additive effect never occurred. The type of paclitaxel radiation interaction was not affected by the concentration of the drug nor did the type of interaction vary between cell lines studied.

CONCLUSIONS

Paclitaxel and radiation used concomitantly produced a clear additive effect at all concentrations and in all vulvar carcinoma cell lines tested. Although no supra-additive effect was observed, the additive effect already in nM concentrations could be beneficial in clinical use and, therefore, requires further investigation.

Effect of cisplatin on the clinically relevant radiosensitivity of human cervical carcinoma cell lines

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effect of clinically relevant levels of cisplatin on the radiosensitivity of human cervical tumor cells, and to estimate what changes in local control rates might be expected to accrue from the concomitant use of cisplatin during fractionated radiotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The effects of concomitant cisplatin (1 microgram/ml, a typical intratumor concentration) on the clinically relevant radiosensitivity, i.e., surviving fraction after 2 G (SF2) values, was determined in 19 cloned human cervical tumor cell lines. These early passage cell lines had SF2 values ranging from 0.26 to 0.87.

RESULTS

The concomitant administration of cisplatin reduced the clinically relevant radiosensitivity in the majority (11 out of 19) of the human tumor cell lines investigated. In only 4 out of 19 was any radiosensitization observed, and in 4 out of 19 cell lines there was no significant change in radiosensitivity. However, the sum of the independent cell killing by radiation and cisplatin, was approximately twofold higher than after radiation alone. There was no apparent dependence of the cisplatin-induced changes in SF2 values upon the level of cell killing by cisplatin. However, there is a suggestion that concomitant cisplatin administration may have a differential effect in inherently radiosensitive and resistant human tumor cell lines.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that concomitant cisplatin/radiotherapy regimens may result in a higher level of local tumor control, but primarily through additive toxicity and not through radiosensitization. Future improvements in local tumor control may, thus, be derived by increasing the total dose of cisplatin.

[Chemotherapy and systemic treatments of cervical cancer]

The prognosis of cervical cancer depends on nodal status and tumoral volume. Among patients with risk factors, chemotherapy seems promising, particularly with concomitant chemoradiation or neo adjuvant chemotherapy before surgery. The advent of treatments with combination of alpha interferon and 13 cis retinoid acid probably leads to a new therapeutic generation.

Simultaneous cisplatin and radiation in endometrial adenocarcinoma cell lines

The effects of concomitantly administered cisplatin and radiation were evaluated in four recently established endometrial adenocarcinoma cell lines. We used the 96-well clonogenic assay to obtain survival data which were fitted to the linear quadratic model. The area under the survival curve (AUC) was obtained by numerical integration. It turned out that there was only a systematic additive cytotoxic effect and no supra-additive, true radiosensitising effect could be found. The results were not affected by the cisplatin dose used, the intrinsic radiosensitivity of the cell lines or the sensitivity of the cells to cisplatin.

Preliminary results of concurrent radiotherapy and chemotherapy with cis-platinum, vincristine, and bleomycin in bulky, advanced cervical carcinoma: A pilot study

Twenty-four patients with bulky (greater than 4 cm), advanced (stages IIB-IVA) carcinoma of the uterine cervix were prospectively treated with a concurrent combination of radiotherapy (RT) and chemotherapy (CT). RT consisted of 4400 cGy (22 fractions) to the whole pelvis and a 1400-cGy boost to the parametrium. This was followed by two to three intracavitary brachytherapy courses. CT consisted of one to four course (median, three) of cisplatin (50 mg/m2) on Day 1, vincristine (1 mg/m2) on Day 2, and bleomycin (25 mg/m2) on Days 2-4. CT was started on the first day of external radiation and the scheduled course interval was 21 days. Among the 20 evaluable patients who completed at least one course of chemotherapy and a full course of radiation, 13 (65%) achieved complete response and 5 (25%) had partial response. Fatal complication occurred in 1 patient with stationary disease who died of septic shock due to ruptured pyometra. The other patient with primary stage IVA disease had progressive disease with ascites appearance after two courses of CT and later expired. Transient drug fever occurred in 19 (40.4%) of the 47 bleomycin-containing CT cycles. Grade 2 or 3 hematological toxicities occurred in 16 (30.2%) of a total of 53 CT cycles. Treatment delays of 1 to 7 days occurred in 15 (28.3%) CT cycles. Except for the case of septic shock, all of the other toxicities were generally tolerable and reversible. From this preliminary result we concluded that this particular combination of RT and CT in bulky, advanced cervical carcinoma is effective in enhancing local pelvic tumor control and well tolerated if strict selection of accrued patients is applied. Further investigation to assess its impact on long-term survival is in progress.

Role of induction chemotherapy in invasive cervical cancer

The 386 cases of invasive cervical carcinoma treated with radiotherapy alone were statistically analyzed to delineate the high risk factors (HRFs) associated with a significantly high treatment failure rate; they were (1) stages III-IV, (2) lesion greater than or equal to 4.0 cm, (3) small cell carcinoma or adenocarcinoma, (4) stages I-II with lesion greater than or equal to 4.0 cm, and (5) lymphographic evidence of nodal metastasis. Then, chemoradiotherapy (induction chemotherapy plus subsequent radiotherapy) was instituted to 113 invasive cervical carcinoma patients with at least one such HRF. Each patient received two to three cycles of induction chemotherapy at about 3-week intervals. For squamous cell carcinoma, cisplatin, 100 mg/m2 iv, was followed immediately by 5-fluorouracil, 1000 mg/m2, as a 24-hr iv infusion x 5 days. For adenocarcinoma, cisplatin, 70 mg/m2 iv, on Day 1 was followed by cytoxan, 250 mg/m2, on Day 2, and adriamycin, 45 mg/m2, on Day 3. Five-year survival of these patients according to each HRF, in the above order, was 69.1, 67.2, 68.1, 78.3, and 79.5% after chemoradiotherapy, all significantly higher than 57.4, 53.0, 54.5, 48.0, and 48.8% by radiotherapy alone. Drug toxicities such as leukopenia, hepatotoxicity, nephrotoxicity, and hypomagnesemia were seen in 46.5, 53.2, 47.1, and 55.4% of all cycles, respectively. The toxicities altered drug schedule in 191 (61.2%) ongoing induction chemotherapy cycles. Our cisplatin-based induction chemotherapy is considered an effective preradiotherapy adjunct that can reduce treatment failure in HRF-associated invasive cervical carcinoma.

Concomitant pelvic irradiation, 5-fluorouracil and mitomycin C in the treatment of advanced cervical carcinoma

This was a Phase II study of 24 late (FIGO) Stage IIb and 39 Stage III patients. External beam radiotherapy was given daily, five days a week, using 15 x 15 cm parallel opposed pelvic fields. The first 20 patients had 45.00 Gy mid-plane dose in 20 fractions, Days 1-28, the last 43 patients had 50.40 Gy in 28 fractions, Days 1-43. This was followed by an intracavitary boost of 17.00 Gy to Point A in two fractions over seven days. The first seven patients had concomitant 5-fluorouracil (5FU) 1 g/m2/day (maximum 1.5 g/day) Days 2-5, 30-33 and 57-60, with mitomycin C 10 mg/m2 (maximum 15 mg) Days 2 and 57. Two patients had WHO Grade 4 cytopenia, and only two were able to have full dose intensity. The 5FU dose was reduced to 0.8 g/m2/day, for Days 2-5 and 30-33; mitomycin C was given on Day 2 only. Treatment morbidity with the reduced chemotherapy intensity was comparable with that of radiotherapy alone. Median follow-up was 16 months (range 6-44). Median survival was 35 months. The results were compared with historical controls treated using the same radiation method alone. Two-year survival for late Stage IIb patients was 67% with the combination and 72% with radiotherapy alone; for Stage III, 67% and 49% respectively. Two-year pelvic control for late Stage IIb was 87% (combination) and 84% (radiotherapy alone) and for Stage III, 61% and 55% respectively. In contrast to reports from other centres, these results do not show an overall significant improvement on radiotherapy alone. A Phase III study may not be practicable.

Treatment of 29 patients with bulky squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix with simultaneous cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil, and split-course hyperfractionated radiation therapy

Attempting to improve local disease control in bulky (greater than 8 cm) primary or recurrent pelvic tumors, 29 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix (stage II, 4; III, 10; IV, 6; recurrent, 9) were treated with concomitant chemotherapy and split-course hyperfractionated radiation therapy between April 1983 and August 1988. Cisplatin (CDDP) and 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) have been shown to be radiation enhancers; furthermore, CDDP, radiation therapy, and continuous-infusion 5-FU have elicited high local response rates in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. A pilot study of cyclical week on/week off CDDP, continuous-infusion 5-FU, and hyperfractionated radiation therapy was developed. Radiation was administered at 116 cGy twice daily, Days 1-5, every other week for a median dose of 4600 cGy to a pelvic field, with paraaortic extension if indicated. Concomitant chemotherapy included CDDP 60 mg/m2 IV Day 1 and 5-FU 600 mg/m2 IV continuous infusion for 96 hr following CDDP infusion. Patients received a median of four cycles of combined treatment, and intracavitary or interstitial brachytherapy followed in 21 patients. Local pelvic response was achieved in 29 of 29 (100%): complete response (CR) in 19 of 29 (66%), partial response (PR) in 10 of 29 (34%). Among CR patients 10 of 19 (53%) were without evidence of disease at a mean follow-up of 29 (range 12-76) months. Five-year actuarial disease-free survival among complete responders was 65%. Of the 10 CR patients 2 failed in the pelvis, for a local control rate of 17/19 (89%). Chemotherapy-related and acute radiation morbidity was minimal but 2 patients required surgical correction of radiation injury. Aggressive combination of split-course hyperfractionated radiation therapy with radiation enhancers resulted in promising local control of bulky pelvic tumor, with an acceptable complication rate, in this otherwise very poor prognostic group of patients.

Advances in diagnosis, staging, and management of cervical and endometrial cancer, stages I and II

The majority of patients with low stage cervical and endometrial cancer are cured. Results obtained in the past only in the categorical cancer centers are currently being achieved more broadly. This reflects the work of formally trained gynecologic oncologists often in collaboration with formally trained radiation therapists distributing themselves in a horizontal fashion to more and more university medical centers, teaching hospitals, and quality tertiary hospitals in the private sector. The formalization of training in gynecologic oncology has been pivotal in this development. This group of physicians, working with physicians in other disciplines, have impacted significantly on patient care and have provided many clinical and pathologic studies to better define favorable low stage cases and poor prognosis cases. The need to explore the use of currently available modalities in a variety of different combinations and to define and develop new techniques to apply to these poor prognosis subsets of disease represent areas of progress and challenge.

Long-term follow-up of potentiation of radiotherapy by cis-platinum in advanced cervical cancer

Between January 1982 and January 1983 all patients with advanced cervical cancer were randomized into three groups: radiotherapy only (group I), radiotherapy plus weekly cis-platinum (group II), and radiation plus twice-weekly cis-platinum (group III). Better initial central control was observed in group III patients. Long-term survival was similar in the three groups. Potentiation of radiotherapy with cis-platinum failed to show any significant improvement in long-term survival.

Concomitant cisplatin and radiotherapy in locally advanced cervical carcinoma

Patients with locally advanced cervical cancer have a poor prognosis. The efficacy of radiotherapy is limited by the presence of large tumor volume and nodal disease. As cisplatin is a documented radiosensitizer and has activity in squamous cell carcinomas, a prospective study was designed to evaluate the toxicity and potential synergism of concurrent cisplatin (20 mg/m2 x 5 d every 21 days) and radiotherapy in locally advanced cervical cancer. Forty-three patients were studied, of which 14 were stage IB/IIA (bulky disease) and 29 were stage IIB/IIIB/IVA. Of the 32 evaluable patients, there were 29 complete responders. Of these 29 patients, 27 remain without evidence of disease, with a median follow-up of 12 months. There were no treatment-related deaths. Cisplatin and radiotherapy appear to be a well-tolerated and highly effective regimen for locally advanced cervical cancer.

Feasibility study of an alternating schedule of radiotherapy and chemotherapy in advanced uterine cervical carcinoma

From July 1981 to April 1982, 36 patients with advanced cervical carcinoma stage III (24 patients) and stage IV (12 patients) entered a feasibility study of a radiotherapy and chemotherapy combination. The first three chemotherapy courses consisted of cis-platinum alone (50 mg/m2) and were interdigitated with radiotherapy. Six more courses composed of an association of cis-platinum (50 mg/m2) and cyclophosphamide (400 mg/m2) were given after the completion of radiotherapy. Radiotherapy was delivered in two courses of 25 Gy separated by a gap of 2 weeks. The overall 4-year survival rate was 35% (95% CI: 22%). The 4-year survival rate, cumulative loco-regional failure rate, and cumulative metastasis rate were respectively 44% (95% CI: 20%), 56% (95% CI: 21%), and 30% (95% CI: 21%) in stage III and 28% (95% CI: 27%), 83% (95% CI: 21%) and 74% (95% CI: 30%) in stage IV. The incidence of immediate and late complications was low: no patient had her radiotherapy stopped because of an intolerance and two patients had their chemotherapy stopped because of an haematological intolerance. Only one patient presented a severe late clinical complication (small bowel injury).