Effects of rating parameters on assessment of neuroleptic-induced vacuous chewing movements

Parallels between behavioral and neurochemical variability in the rat vacuous chewing movement model of tardive dyskinesia

The widely accepted rat vacuous chewing movement model for tardive dyskinesia could be more fully mined through greater focus on individual variability in vulnerability to this neuroleptic-induced behavior. We have examined parallels between behavioral and neurobiological variability within a cohort in order to evaluate the role that neurobiological factors might play in determining susceptibility to tardive dyskinesia. Inter-observer reliability and individual consistency across time, in both spontaneous and neuroleptic-induced vacuous chewing movements, were empirically demonstrated. While this behavior increased across 8 months of observation in both vehicle controls and haloperidol-treated rats, pre-treatment baselines were predictive of final levels across individuals only in the vehicle control group, not the haloperidol-treated group. Haloperidol-induced elevations in neostriatal D2 and GAD(67) mRNA were not correlated with individual variability in haloperidol-induced vacuous chewing movements. Ambient noise during the observations was found to exacerbate chronic haloperidol-induced, but not spontaneous vacuous chewing movements. Significant correlations were found among the haloperidol-treated rats between nigral and tegmental GAD(67) and tegmental α7 mRNA levels, measured by in situ hybridization histochemistry, and vacuous chewing movements, specifically in the noisy conditions. Variability in these secondary responses to primary striatal dopamine and GABA perturbations may play a role in determining vulnerability to vacuous chewing movements, and by analogy, tardive dyskinesia. Both the differential predictive value of baseline vacuous chewing movements and the differential effect of noise, between controls and haloperidol-treated rats, add to evidence that haloperidol-induced vacuous chewing movements are regulated, in part, by different mechanisms than those mediating spontaneous vacuous chewing movements.

Deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic or entopeduncular nucleus attenuates vacuous chewing movements in a rodent model of tardive dyskinesia

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) has recently emerged as a potential intervention for treatment-resistant tardive dyskinesia (TD). Despite promising case reports, no consensus exists as yet regarding optimal stimulation parameters or neuroanatomical target for DBS in TD. Here we report the use of DBS in an animal model of TD. We applied DBS (100 μA) acutely to the entopeduncular nucleus (EPN) or subthalamic nucleus (STN) in rats with well established vacuous chewing movements (VCMs) induced by 12 weeks of haloperidol (HAL) treatment. Stimulation of the STN or EPN resulted in significant reductions in VCM counts at frequencies of 30, 60 or 130 Hz. In the STN DBS groups, effects were significantly more pronounced at 130 Hz than at lower frequencies, whereas at the EPN the three frequencies were equipotent. Unilateral stimulation at 130 Hz was also effective when applied to either nucleus. These results suggest that stimulation of either the EPN or STN significantly alleviates oral dyskinesias induced by chronic HAL. The chronic HAL VCM model preparation may be useful to explore mechanisms underlying DBS effects in drug-induced dyskinesias.

Validation of the tremulous jaw movement model for assessment of the motor effects of typical and atypical antipychotics: effects of pimozide (Orap) in rats

Drug-induced tremulous jaw movements (TJMs) in rats have been used as a model of parkinsonian tremor. Previous studies demonstrated that the typical antipsychotic haloperidol induced TJMs after acute or subchronic administration, while atypical antipsychotics did not. Moreover, it has been suggested that the relative potency for suppression of tacrine-induced TJMs relative to the suppression of lever pressing can be used to discriminate between typical and atypical antipsychotics. In order to validate this model with additional drugs, the present studies assessed the effects of the typical antipsychotic pimozide. In the first series of experiments, the effects of acute pimozide on tacrine-induced TJMs and lever pressing were examined. As with haloperidol, pimozide failed to suppress tacrine-induced TJMs, even at doses considerably higher than those that suppressed lever pressing. In the second group of experiments, rats were given single daily injections of pimozide (0.125-1.0 mg/kg) or tartaric acid vehicle for 13 days, and were observed for TJMs on days 1, 7, and 13. Pimozide induced TJMs in a dose-related manner on all days. The jaw movements occurred largely in the 3-7 Hz frequency range characteristic of parkinsonian tremor. These data support the hypothesis that typical antipsychotics can induce TJMs in rats, and demonstrate that chronic administration of typical antipsychotics is not necessary for induction of TJMs. TJMs induced by acute or subchronic pimozide may be related to early-onset motor syndromes such as drug-induced parkinsonism.

Relationship of orofacial movements to behavioural repertoire as assessed topographically over the course of 6-month haloperidol treatment followed by 4-month withdrawal

RATIONALE

Late-onset vacuous chewing movements (VCMs) arise in a significant proportion of rats treated chronically with conventional antipsychotic drugs. Given their common action to block dopamine D2-like receptors, VCMs may be related to changes in dopaminergic function; if so, other typical dopamine-mediated behaviours might be altered also.

OBJECTIVE

To examine this hypothesis, behavioural repertoire was studied topographically over the course of chronic treatment and withdrawal.

METHODS

Animals were injected with haloperidol decanoate 28 mg/kg IM, or vehicle, every 3 weeks for 27 weeks, and then maintained without treatment for a further 18 weeks. Immediately before each injection and during withdrawal, VCMs and other topographies of behaviour were assessed.

RESULTS

In both control and haloperidol-treated rats, exploratory behaviours declined over the study, indicating habituation effects. Conversely, VCMs emerged after 6 weeks of treatment with haloperidol and persisted after withdrawal; VCM and locomotion were not related, indicating that in treated rats, increased VCMs are not an artifact of reduced locomotion. Treated animals with VCMs evidenced increases in buccal tremor and grooming behaviour relative to those without VCMs, although no clear relationship to the emergence of VCMs was established; there were no material differences in any other topographies of behaviour.

CONCLUSION

The effect of long-term treatment with haloperidol to induce VCMs is not reflected in fundamental changes in dopamine-mediated behavioural topography but, rather, appears to affect neural mechanisms involved in orofacial movement preferentially.

The vacuous chewing movement (VCM) model of tardive dyskinesia revisited: is there a relationship to dopamine D(2) receptor occupancy?

Tardive dyskinesia (TD) is a late side effect of long-term antipsychotic use in humans, and the vacuous chewing movement (VCM) model has been used routinely to study this movement disorder in rats. Recent receptor occupancy studies in humans and rats have found that antipsychotics given in doses which lead to moderate levels of D(2) receptor blockade can achieve optimal clinical response while minimizing the emergence of acute motor side effects. This suggests that clinicians may have been using inappropriately high doses of antipsychotics. A review of the existing VCM literature indicates that most animal studies have similarly employed antipsychotic doses that are high, i.e. doses that lead to near complete D(2) receptor saturation. To verify whether the incidence or severity of VCMs would decrease with lower antipsychotic doses, we conducted initial experiments with different doses of haloperidol (HAL) given either as repeated daily injections or as depot injections over the course of several weeks. Our results demonstrate that (1) the incidence of VCMs is significantly related to HAL dose, and (2) significant levels of VCMs only emerge when haloperidol is continually present. These findings are consistent with the possibility that total D(2) occupancy, as well as 'transience' of receptor occupation, may be important in the development of late-onset antipsychotic-induced dyskinetic syndromes.

No change in dopamine D1 receptor in vivo binding in rats after sub-chronic haloperidol treatment

A frequent side effect in the long-term treatment of schizophrenia with the dopamine D2 antagonist haloperidol (HAL) is the appearance of tardive dyskinesia or, in animals, of repetitive involuntary vacuous chewing movements (VCMs). In rats, chronic HAL-induced or D1 receptor-stimulated VCMs are suppressed by D1 antagonists, suggesting that this behavioral supersensitivity is mediated by D1 receptors. The goal of this study was to investigate in vivo the possible relationship between D1 receptor binding and D1-mediated behavioral supersensitivity, after subchronic HAL treatments. D1 agonist R-SKF 82957 and antagonist SCH 23390, both labeled with carbon-11, were used to assess in vivo D1 receptor binding. Rats were treated with HAL (1.5 mg/kg, i.p.) or vehicle for 21 days, followed by a 4 day washout period. No significant difference was found in the regional brain binding of either radioligand. D1 receptor-mediated behaviors including VCMs, grooming, and rearing were measured in control or HAL-treated rats. VCMs were significantly increased in HAL-treated rats, suggesting D1 receptor stimulation and possibly receptor supersensitivity. This study failed to link the purported D1 receptor-mediated behaviors with in vivo receptor binding measures of R-[11C]SKF 82957 or [11C]SCH 23390 in rat brain regions.

Traditional and new antipsychotic drugs differentially alter neurotransmission markers in basal ganglia-thalamocortical neural pathways

The effects of three chronically administered antipsychotic drugs on selected neurochemical markers of dopaminergic and GABAergic transmission were compared within the cerebral regions making up the basal ganglia-thalamocortical parallel processing neuronal pathways. All three drugs reduce psychosis in humans, whereas only haloperidol, but not olanzapine or sertindole, induce purposeless oral chewing movements (CMs) in rats or cause high rates of parkinsonism or tardive dyskinesia in humans. Male Sprague Dawley rats were treated with haloperidol, sertindole, or olanzapine delivered in drinking water for 6 months at doses which produce drug plasma levels in rat in the human therapeutic range. Results show the expected dopamine D2 receptor upregulation in striatum predominantly with haloperidol, although mild D2 upregulation was apparent in striatum after olanzapine. GAD67 mRNA was increased in striatum and decreased in globus pallidus by haloperidol and sertindole, but not by olanzapine. In the substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNR), both olanzapine and sertindole failed to induce GABA(A) receptor upregulation or D1 receptor downregulation, but haloperidol did both, confirming a previous report. In thalamus, all three drugs increased GAD expression in the reticular nucleus, whereas only haloperidol decreased GABA(A) binding in the mediodorsal nucleus, actions consistent with a reduction in nigrothalamic, GABA-mediated neural transmission. These results are consistent with the idea that the two new antipsychotics tested have mild and regionally restricted actions within the basal ganglia nuclei and a common action on increasing GAD expression in the reticular nucleus of the thalamus (RtN). Haloperidol, in contrast, has a broad and potent action in basal ganglia, causing changes in SNR and in the mediodorsal nucleus, while also altering GAD mRNA in RtN, potentially reflective of its dyskinetic and antipsychotic actions.

Neurotoxicity associated with neuroleptic-induced oral dyskinesias in rats. Implications for tardive dyskinesia?

Tardive dyskinesia is a serious motor side effect of long-term treatment with neuroleptics, with an unknown pathophysiologic basis. Brain damage and aging are prominent risk-factors, and together with the persistent character of the disorder, it is likely that long-lasting neuronal changes are involved in the pathogenesis. It has been hypothesized that striatal neurodegeneration caused by excitotoxic mechanisms and oxidative stress may play an important role in the development of the disorder, and the scope of the present work is to review the evidence supporting this hypothesis. The rat model of tardive dyskinesia has been used extensively in the field, and the usefulness of this model will be discussed. Neuroleptics are able to induce oxidative stress in vitro and increase striatal glutamatergic activity in rats, which may lead to toxic effects in the striatum. Drugs that block excitotoxicity inhibit the development of persistent oral dyskinesia in the rat model, and impaired energy metabolism leads to increased frequency of oral dyskinesia. There are also signs of altered striatal histology in rats with high frequency of oral dyskinesia. Furthermore, markers of increased oxidative stress and glutamatergic neurotransmission have been found in the cerebrospinal fluid of patients with tardive dyskinesia. In conclusion, several lines of evidence implicate neurotoxic events in the development of neuroleptic induced tardive dyskinesia.

The preventative role of antioxidants (selegiline and vitamin E) in a rat model of tardive dyskinesia

BACKGROUND

We examined the potential protective effects of two potent antioxidants, selegiline and vitamin E, in a rodent model of tardive dyskinesia (TD), viz. neuroleptic-induced spontaneous orofacial movements.

METHODS

Rats were treated with fortnightly injections of fluphenazine decanoate for 12 weeks, and examined at baseline and at fortnightly intervals for vacuous chewing movements, mouth tremors and tongue protrusions.

RESULTS

The administration of fluphenazine led to a progressive increase of all three types of orofacial movements. In the first study, the impact of the concomitant administration of selegiline on orofacial movements was examined. Selegiline led to a reduction in orofacial movements in neuroleptic-treated rats to the level of control rats not being administered a neuroleptic drug. In the second study, rats were fed diets either high or low in their vitamin E content. High and low vitamin E diets did not significantly affect neuroleptic-induced orofacial movements.

CONCLUSIONS

Our studies provide some support for the hypothesis that oxidative injury may play a role in the genesis of neuroleptic-induced movement disorder, and prompt further examination of this hypothesis in both animals and humans.