Torsional stress promotes the DNAase I sensitivity of active genes

Transcriptionally Active Chromatin-Lessons Learned from the Chicken Erythrocyte Chromatin Fractionation

The chicken erythrocyte model system has been valuable to the study of chromatin structure and function, specifically for genes involved in oxygen transport and the innate immune response. Several seminal features of transcriptionally active chromatin were discovered in this system. Davie and colleagues capitalized on the unique features of the chicken erythrocyte to separate and isolate transcriptionally active chromatin and silenced chromatin, using a powerful native fractionation procedure. Histone modifications, histone variants, atypical nucleosomes (U-shaped nucleosomes) and other chromatin structural features (open chromatin) were identified in these studies. More recently, the transcriptionally active chromosomal domains in the chicken erythrocyte genome were mapped by combining this chromatin fractionation method with next-generation DNA and RNA sequencing. The landscape of histone modifications relative to chromatin structural features in the chicken erythrocyte genome was reported in detail, including the first ever mapping of histone H4 asymmetrically dimethylated at Arg 3 (H4R3me2a) and histone H3 symmetrically dimethylated at Arg 2 (H3R2me2s), which are products of protein arginine methyltransferases (PRMTs) 1 and 5, respectively. PRMT1 is important in the establishment and maintenance of chicken erythrocyte transcriptionally active chromatin.

DNA Supercoiling, Topoisomerases, and Cohesin: Partners in Regulating Chromatin Architecture?

Although our knowledge of chromatin organization has advanced significantly in recent years, much about the relationships between different features of genome architecture is still unknown. Folding of mammalian genomes into spatial domains is thought to depend on architectural proteins, other DNA-binding proteins, and different forms of RNA. In addition, emerging evidence points towards the possibility that the three-dimensional organisation of the genome is controlled by DNA topology. In this scenario, cohesin, CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF), transcription, DNA supercoiling, and topoisomerases are integrated to dictate different layers of genome organization, and the contribution of all four to gene control is an important direction of future studies. In this perspective, we review recent studies that give new insight on how DNA supercoiling shape chromatin structure.

Effects of DNA supercoiling on chromatin architecture

Disruptions in chromatin structure are necessary for the regulation of eukaryotic genomes, from remodelling of nucleosomes at the base pair level through to large-scale chromatin domains that are hundreds of kilobases in size. RNA polymerase is a powerful motor which, prevented from turning with the tight helical pitch of the DNA, generates over-wound DNA ahead of itself and under-wound DNA behind. Mounting evidence supports a central role for transcription-dependent DNA supercoiling in disrupting chromatin structure at all scales. This supercoiling changes the properties of the DNA helix in a manner that substantially alters the binding specificity of DNA binding proteins and complexes, including nucleosomes, polymerases, topoisomerases and transcription factors. For example, transient over-wound DNA destabilises nucleosome core particles ahead of a transcribing polymerase, whereas under-wound DNA facilitates pre-initiation complex formation, transcription factor binding and nucleosome core particle association behind the transcribing polymerase. Importantly, DNA supercoiling can also dissipate through DNA, even in a chromatinised context, to influence both local elements and large chromatin domains. We propose a model in which changes in unconstrained DNA supercoiling influences higher levels of chromatin organisation through the additive effects of DNA supercoiling on both DNA-protein and DNA-nucleosome interactions. This model links small-scale changes in DNA and chromatin to the higher-order fibre and large-scale chromatin structures, providing a mechanism relating gene regulation to chromatin architecture in vivo.

Effects of DNA supercoiling on chromatin architecture

Disruptions in chromatin structure are necessary for the regulation of eukaryotic genomes, from remodelling of nucleosomes at the base pair level through to large-scale chromatin domains that are hundreds of kilobases in size. RNA polymerase is a powerful motor which, prevented from turning with the tight helical pitch of the DNA, generates over-wound DNA ahead of itself and under-wound DNA behind. Mounting evidence supports a central role for transcription-dependent DNA supercoiling in disrupting chromatin structure at all scales. This supercoiling changes the properties of the DNA helix in a manner that substantially alters the binding specificity of DNA binding proteins and complexes, including nucleosomes, polymerases, topoisomerases and transcription factors. For example, transient over-wound DNA destabilises nucleosome core particles ahead of a transcribing polymerase, whereas under-wound DNA facilitates pre-initiation complex formation, transcription factor binding and nucleosome core particle association behind the transcribing polymerase. Importantly, DNA supercoiling can also dissipate through DNA, even in a chromatinised context, to influence both local elements and large chromatin domains. We propose a model in which changes in unconstrained DNA supercoiling influences higher levels of chromatin organisation through the additive effects of DNA supercoiling on both DNA-protein and DNA-nucleosome interactions. This model links small-scale changes in DNA and chromatin to the higher-order fibre and large-scale chromatin structures, providing a mechanism relating gene regulation to chromatin architecture in vivo.

Transcription forms and remodels supercoiling domains unfolding large-scale chromatin structures

DNA supercoiling is an inherent consequence of twisting DNA and is critical for regulating gene expression and DNA replication. However, DNA supercoiling at a genomic scale in human cells is uncharacterized. To map supercoiling we used biotinylated-trimethylpsoralen as a DNA structure probe to show the genome is organized into supercoiling domains. Domains are formed and remodeled by RNA polymerase and topoisomerase activities and are flanked by GC-AT boundaries and CTCF binding sites. Under-wound domains are transcriptionally active, enriched in topoisomerase I, “open” chromatin fibers and DNaseI sites, but are depleted of topoisomerase II. Furthermore DNA supercoiling impacts on additional levels of chromatin compaction as under-wound domains are cytologically decondensed, topologically constrained, and decompacted by transcription of short RNAs. We suggest that supercoiling domains create a topological environment that facilitates gene activation providing an evolutionary purpose for clustering genes along chromosomes.

The heat shock response: A case study of chromatin dynamics in gene regulation

Recent studies in transcriptional regulation using the Drosophila heat shock response system have elucidated many of the dynamic regulatory processes that govern transcriptional activation and repression. The classic view that the control of gene expression occurs at the point of RNA polymerase II (Pol II) recruitment is now giving way to a more complex outlook of gene regulation. Promoter chromatin dynamics coordinate with transcription factor binding to maintain the promoters of active genes accessible. For a large number of genes, the rate-limiting step in Pol II progression occurs during its initial elongation, where Pol II transcribes 30–50 bp and pauses for further signals. These paused genes have unique genic chromatin architecture and dynamics compared with genes where Pol II recruitment is rate limiting for expression. Further elongation of Pol II along the gene causes nucleosome turnover, a continuous process of eviction and replacement, which suggests a potential mechanism for Pol II transit along a nucleosomal template. In this review, we highlight recent insights into transcription regulation of the heat shock response and discuss how the dynamic regulatory processes involved at each transcriptional stage help to generate faithful yet highly responsive gene expression.

The importance of being supercoiled: how DNA mechanics regulate dynamic processes

Through dynamic changes in structure resulting from DNA-protein interactions and constraints given by the structural features of the double helix, chromatin accommodates and regulates different DNA-dependent processes. All DNA transactions (such as transcription, DNA replication and chromosomal segregation) are necessarily linked to strong changes in the topological state of the double helix known as torsional stress or supercoiling. As virtually all DNA transactions are in turn affected by the torsional state of DNA, these changes have the potential to serve as regulatory signals detected by protein partners. This two-way relationship indicates that DNA dynamics may contribute to the regulation of many events occurring during cell life. In this review we will focus on the role of DNA supercoiling in the cellular processes, with particular emphasis on transcription. Besides giving an overview on the multiplicity of factors involved in the generation and dissipation of DNA torsional stress, we will discuss recent studies which give new insight into the way cells use DNA dynamics to perform functions otherwise not achievable. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Chromatin in time and space.

Analysis of active and inactive X chromosome architecture reveals the independent organization of 30 nm and large-scale chromatin structures

Using a genetic model, we present a high-resolution chromatin fiber analysis of transcriptionally active (Xa) and inactive (Xi) X chromosomes packaged into euchromatin and facultative heterochromatin. Our results show that gene promoters have an open chromatin structure that is enhanced upon transcriptional activation but the Xa and the Xi have similar overall 30 nm chromatin fiber structures. Therefore, the formation of facultative heterochromatin is dependent on factors that act at a level above the 30 nm fiber and transcription does not alter bulk chromatin fiber structures. However, large-scale chromatin structures on Xa are decondensed compared with the Xi and transcription inhibition is sufficient to promote large-scale chromatin compaction. We show a link between transcription and large-scale chromatin packaging independent of the bulk 30 nm chromatin fiber and propose that transcription, not the global compaction of 30 nm chromatin fibers, determines the cytological appearance of large-scale chromatin structures.

Forces and torques in the nucleus: chromatin under mechanical constraints

Genomic DNA in eukaryotic cells is organized in discrete chromosome territories, each consisting of a single huge hierarchically supercoiled nucleosomal fiber. Through dynamic changes in structure, resulting from chemical modifications and mechanical constraints imposed by numerous factors in vivo, chromatin plays a critical role in the regulation of DNA metabolism processes, including replication and transcription. Indeed, DNA-translocating enzymes, such as polymerases, produce physical constraints that chromatin has to overcome. Recent techniques, in particular single-molecule micromanipulation, have allowed precise quantization of forces and torques at work in the nucleus and have greatly improved our understanding of chromatin behavior under physiological mechanical constraints. These new biophysical approaches should enable us to build realistic mechanistic models and progressively specify the ad hoc and hazy "because of chromatin structure" argument often used to interpret experimental studies of biological function in the context of chromatin.

Transcription elongation through a chromatin template

DNA transaction events occurring during cell life (replication, transcription, recombination, repair, cell division) are always linked to severe changes in the topological state of the double helix. However, since naked DNA almost does not exist in eukaryote nucleus but rather interacts with various proteins, including ubiquitous histones, these topological changes happen in a chromatin context. This review focuses on the role of chromatin fiber structure and dynamics in the regulation of transcription, with an almost exclusive emphasis on the elongation step. Beside a brief overview of our knowledge about transcribed chromatin, we will see how recent mechanistic and biochemical studies give us new insights into the way cell could modulate DNA supercoiling and chromatin conformational dynamics. The participation of topoisomerases in this complex ballet is discussed, since recent data suggest that their role could be closely related to the precise chromatin structure. Lastly, some future prospects to carry on are proposed, hoping this review will help in stimulating discussions and further investigations in the field.

The human growth hormone locus control region mediates long-distance transcriptional activation independent of nuclear matrix attachment regions

Expression of the human growth hormone (hGH-N) transgene in the mouse pituitary is dependent on a multicomponent locus control region (LCR). The primary determinant of hGH LCR function maps to the pituitary-specific DNase I hypersensitive sites (HS) HSI,II, located 15 kb 5' to the hGH-N gene. The mechanism by which HSI,II mediates long-distance activation of the hGH locus remains undefined. Matrix attachment regions (MARs) comprise a set of AT-rich DNA elements postulated to interact with the nuclear scaffold and to mediate long-distance interactions between LCR elements and their target promoters. Consistent with this model, sequence analysis strongly predicted a MAR determinant in close proximity to HSI,II. Surprisingly, cell-based analysis of nuclear scaffolds failed to confirm a MAR at this site, and extensive mapping demonstrated that the entire 87 kb region encompassing the hGH LCR and contiguous hGH gene cluster was devoid of MAR activity. Homology searches revealed that the predicted MAR reflected the recent insertion of a LINE 3'-UTR segment adjacent to HSI,II. These data point out discordance between sequence-based MAR predictions and in vivo MAR function and predict a novel MAR-independent mechanism for long-distance activation of hGH-N gene expression.

Interference of the simian virus 40 origin of replication by the cytomegalovirus immediate early gene enhancer: evidence for competition of active regulatory chromatin conformation in a single domain

Replication origins are often found closely associated with transcription regulatory elements in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. To examine the relationship between these two elements, we studied the effect of a strong promoter-enhancer on simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication. The human cytomegalovirus (CMV) immediate early gene enhancer-promoter was found to exert a strong inhibitory effect on SV40 origin-based plasmid replication in Cos-1 cells in a position- and dose-dependent manner. Deletion analysis indicated that the effect was exerted by sequences located in the enhancer portion of the CMV sequence, thus excluding the mechanism of origin occlusion by transcription. Insertion of extra copies of the SV40 origin only partially alleviated the inhibition. Analysis of nuclease-sensitive cleavage sites of chromatin containing the transfected plasmids indicate that the chromatin was cleaved at one of the regulatory sites in the plasmids containing more than one regulatory site, suggesting that only one nuclease-hypersensitive site existed per chromatin. A positive correlation was found between the degree of inhibition of DNA replication and the decrease of P1 cleavage frequency at the SV40 origin. The CMV enhancer was also found to exhibit an inhibitory effect on the CMV enhancer-promoter driving chloramphenicol acetyltransferase expression in a dose-dependent manner. Together these results suggest that inhibition of SV40 origin-based DNA replication by the CMV enhancer is due to intramolecular competition for the formation of active chromatin structure.

Transport of torsional stress in DNA

It is well known that transcription can induce torsional stress in DNA, affecting the activity of nearby genes or even inducing structural transitions in the DNA duplex. It has long been assumed that the generation of significant torsional stress requires the DNA to be anchored, forming a limited topological domain, because otherwise it would spin almost freely about its axis. Previous estimates of the rotational drag have, however, neglected the role of small natural bends in the helix backbone. We show how these bends can increase the drag several thousandfold relative to prior estimates, allowing significant torsional stress even in linear unanchored DNA. The model helps explain several puzzling experimental results on structural transitions induced by transcription of DNA.

Influence of novobiocin on <FONT FACE=Symbol>g</font>-irradiation G0-lymphocytes as analyzed by cytogenetic endpoints

Experiments with novobiocin (NB) post-treatment were performed to verify its effect on the frequencies of micronuclei (MN) and chromosomal aberrations (CA) induced by <FONT FACE="Symbol">g</font>-irradiation (0.75, 1.5 and 3.0 Gy) in human lymphocytes at G0-phase. The frequencies of MN significantly decreased by 44 and 50%, for the treatment with NB 50 µg/ml (30-min pulse) after radiation doses of 1.5 and 3.0 Gy, respectively. However, CA frequencies were not significantly affected. No significant effect on CA was observed when lymphocyte cultures were exposed to a single dose of 2.0 Gy at the G0-phase and posttreated with 25 µg/ml NB for three hours either immediately after irradiation (G0-phase) or after 24 h (S-phase). The significant suppressive effect of NB on MN frequencies supports the hypothesis that NB interaction with chromatin increases access to DNA repair enzymes.

Effect of differential gene expression on the chromatin structure of the DHFR gene domain in vivo

Photoactivated psoralen was used to probe region-specific chromatin structure in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Specifically, the chromatin structure of six regions within the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene was probed with photoactivated psoralen in cells cultured in such ways as to differentially express the DHFR gene. Cells were irradiated with X-rays prior to the psoralen photocross-linking reaction in order to eliminate the influence of any DNA torsional tension on the psoralen binding and the sequence-specificity of psoralen binding was adjusted for. It was found that a region encompassing the promoter of the serum-regulated DHFR gene was about 50% more accessible to psoralen photocross-linking in serum-stimulated cells and about 90% more accessible in serum-starved cells than the other five regions of the DHFR gene analyzed and the genome overall. Treating serum-stimulated cells with the RNA polymerase II transcriptional inhibitor 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofuranosyl-benzimidazole (DRB) or the topoisomerase I inhibitor camptothecin reversed the elevated accessibility of the DHFR promoter region. These results suggest that the accessible chromatin structure of the DHFR promoter is not dependent on serum-stimulated poising of the gene for transcription, but may reflect the ability of the RNA polymerase to clear the promoter.

Induction of DNA double-strand breaks by ionizing radiation at the c-myc locus compared with the whole genome: a study using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and gene probing

Ionizing radiation-induced double-strand breaks (dsb) in a human colon carcinoma-derived cell line COLO320HSR were determined from the fragment size distribution of non-specifically labelled DNA and Sfi I restriction enzyme-digested DNA uniformly labelled with a c-myc probe. The dose-effect relation for the induction of DNA dsb was linear with no significant difference between slopes for the curves in the whole genome (7.2 +/- 0.3 x 10(-9) dsb/bp/Gy) and in the 130 kbp restriction fragments containing c-myc (6.5 +/- 0.5 x 10(-9) dsb/bp/Gy). The size distribution of the c-myc fragments showed deviations from the random-breakage model, indicating heterogeneity of dsb induction at this locus.

The nuclear matrix and the regulation of chromatin organization and function

Nuclear DNA is organized into loop domains, with the base of the loop being bound to the nuclear matrix. Loops with transcriptionally active and/or potentially active genes have a DNase I-sensitive chromatin structure, while repressed chromatin loops have a condensed configuration that is essentially invisible to the transcription machinery. Core histone acetylation and torsional stress appear to be responsible for the generation and/or maintenance of the open potentially active chromatin loops. The transcriptionally active region of the loop makes several dynamic attachments with the nuclear matrix and is associated with core histones that are dynamically acetylated. Histone acetyltransferase and deacetylase, which catalyze this rapid acetylation and deacetylation, are bound to the nuclear matrix. Several transcription factors are components of the nuclear matrix. Histone acetyltransferase, deacetylase, and transcription factors may contribute to the dynamic attachment of the active chromatin domains with the nuclear matrix at sites of ongoing transcription.

Presence of negative torsional tension in the promoter region of the transcriptionally poised dihydrofolate reductase gene in vivo

DNA topology has been suggested to play an important role in the process of transcription. Negative torsional tension has been shown to stimulate both pre-initiation complex formation and promoter clearance on plasmid DNA in vitro. We recently showed that genomic DNA in human cells contains localized torsional tension. In the present study we have further characterized and mapped torsional tension in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and investigated the effects of differential rates of transcription on the magnitude and location of this tension. Using psoralen photo-cross-linking in conjunction with X-irradiation, we found that relaxable psoralen hypersensitivity was specifically localized to the promoter region of the serum-regulated DHFR gene in serum-stimulated, but not in serum-starved, cells. Moreover, this hypersensitivity did not appear to be caused by transcription elongation, since it persisted in cells in which transcription of the DHFR gene had been reduced by the transcription inhibitor 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofurano-sylbenzimidazole (DRB). We suggest that the generation of negative torsional tension in DNA may play an important role in gene regulation by poising genes for transcription.

DNA stainability with base-specific fluorochromes: dependence on the DNA topology in situ

The influence of DNA topology on stainability with the externally binding fluorochromes Hoechst 33258 (HO) and mithramycin (MI) was investigated in HeLa nuclei in comparison with the intercalating dye propidium iodide (PI). Changes in DNA topology were induced with a mild DNAse I treatment. Stainability properties of untreated and nuclease-treated nuclei were compared with those of the supercoiled-circular and the relaxed-linear forms of the plasmid pBR322. DNAse-treated nuclei stained with HO showed a higher fluorescence intensity than control samples, independently of the dye concentration, in contrast with the findings obtained with PI. Similar behaviour was observed with the relaxed-linear form of pBR322, compared with the supercoiled-circular molecule. With MI, the stainability of HeLa nuclei did not depend on the DNA topology, whereas the stainability of the plasmid was similar to that of HO. In order to assess whether this discrepancy depended on differences in the availability of DNAse-sensitive sites to the fluorochromes, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies were performed in nuclei stained with HO+PI, or with HO+MI dye pairs. After DNAse I digestion, the relative FRET efficiency between donor (HO) and acceptor molecules (PI or MI) was reduced significantly only when MI was the acceptor. This result may be due to greater stainability of DNAse-sensitive sites with HO than with MI. These findings indicate that DNA stainability with base-specific fluorochromes may be affected by the topology of chromatin regions.

Influence of amsacrine (m-AMSA) on bulk and gene-specific DNA damage and c-myc expression in MCF-7 breast tumor cells

In the MCF-7 human breast tumor cell line, the aminoacridine, m-AMSA, induces protein-associated DNA strand breaks consistent with inhibition of topoisomerase II. However, neither single-strand nor double-strand breaks in DNA, determined using conventional assays, show a consistent relationship with m-AMSA-induced inhibition of growth. In contrast, when DNA strand breaks are determined by alkaline unwinding under the high salt conditions of the alkaline unwinding/Southern blotting (AU/SB) assay, developed by our laboratories, damage to DNA corresponds closely with growth inhibition. The AU/SB assay, which is capable of assessing breaks within large-scale domains (upwards of 1 megabase) surrounding genes of interest, was further utilized to explore the capacity of m-AMSA to induce damage within specific genomic regions that may regulate cell growth. Regions encompassing the transcriptionally active oncogenes, c-myc and c-fos, were found to be more susceptible to m-AMSA-induced strand breaks than the region encompassing the non-transcribed alpha-satellite DNA or the genome as a whole (bulk DNA). These findings demonstrate that m-AMSA may produce more pronounced damage within specific genomic regions than in bulk DNA, m-AMSA also preferentially altered expression of the c-myc oncogene; at an m-AMSA concentration where growth was inhibited by between 70 and 80%, steady-state c-myc mRNA levels declined to approximately 10-15% of control levels within 2-3 hr; furthermore, concentration-dependent reductions in c-myc expression appeared to coincide with growth inhibition. In addition, inhibition of [3H]thymidine incorporation after 2 hr directly paralleled inhibition of growth, suggesting an early effect at the level of DNA biosynthesis, possibly related to the down-regulation of c-myc expression. It is proposed that specific lesions, e.g., in regions surrounding the c-myc gene, as well as generalized lesions in DNA may lead to growth inhibition mediated by down-regulation of the expression of select growth regulatory genes, such as c-myc.

Reverse transformation, genome exposure, and cancer

The reverse transformation reaction whereby malignant cells are restored to a more normal phenotype has been reviewed. The primary causative action is ascribed to the genome exposure reaction in which a peripheral nuclear DNA region is restored to high sensitivity to DNase I, like that in normal cells. Various aspects of genome exposure around the nucleoli and the nuclear periphery are considered. The special role of the cytoskeleton in regulating exposure resulting in normal differentiation on the one hand and malignant transformation on the other is discussed. The action of the two-level system for regulation of the mammalian genome previously proposed is reviewed in relation to normal differentiation and malignancy with brief indication of roles played by various metabolites, transcription factors, protooncogenes, cell organelles, and processes like specific phosphorylation and dephosphorylation. Possible implications for cancer therapy and prevention and for the fields of genetic disease and toxicology are indicated.

In vivo stage- and tissue-specific DNA-protein interactions at the D. melanogaster alcohol dehydrogenase distal promoter and adult enhancer

We performed a high resolution analysis of the chromatin structure within the regions required for distal transcription of the Drosophila melanogaster alcohol dehydrogenase gene (Adh). Using dimethyl sulfate, DNase I, and micrococcal nuclease as structural probes, and comparing chromatin structure in tissues isolated from several developmental stages, we have identified several sites of stage- and tissue-specific DNA-protein interactions that correlate with distal transcription initiation. Most were within previously identified cis-acting elements and/or in vitro protein binding sites of the adult enhancer (AAE) and distal promoter, including the TATA box. We also detected a novel stage-specific DNA-protein interaction at the Adf-2a binding site where a non-histone protein was bound to the DNA on the surface of a positioned nucleosome previously identified between the distal promoter and adult enhancer. In addition to footprints, we have also revealed stage- and tissue-specific DNA helix deformations between many of the non-histone protein binding sites. These helix distortions suggest there are interactions among the adjacently bound proteins that result in bending or kinking of the intervening DNA. The distal promoter and AAE have an accessible chromatin conformation in fat body prior to the third larval instar and many of the regulatory proteins that bind in these regions are also available before distal transcription begins. Nevertheless, the timing of DNA-protein interactions in the distal promoter and AAE suggest these proteins do not bind individually or assemble progressively as they and their binding sites become available. Instead, there appears to be a coordinated assembly of a large cooperative complex of proteins interacting with the distal promoter, the positioned nucleosome, the enhancer of the distal promoter (the AAE), and each other.

Localized torsional tension in the DNA of human cells

Torsional tension in DNA may be both a prerequisite for the efficient initiation of transcription and a consequence of the transcription process itself with the generation of positive torsional tension in front of the RNA polymerase and negative torsional tension behind it. To examine torsional tension in specific regions of genomic DNA in vivo, we developed an assay using photoactivated psoralen as a probe for unconstrained DNA superhelicity and x-rays as a means to relax DNA. Psoralen intercalates more readily into DNA underwound by negative torsional tension than into relaxed. DNA, and it can form interstrand DNA cross-links upon UVA irradiation. By comparing the amount of psoralen-induced DNA cross-links in cells irradiated with x-rays either before or after the psoralen treatment, we examined the topological state of the DNA in specific regions of the genome in cultured human 6A3 cells. We found that although no net torsional tension was detected in the bulk of the genome, localized tension was prominent in the DNA of two active genes. Negative torsional tension was found in the 5' end of the amplified dihydrofolate reductase gene and in a region near the 5' end of the 45S rRNA transcription unit, whereas a low level of positive torsional tension was found in a region near the 3' end of the dihydrofolate reductase gene. These results document an intragenomic heterogeneity of DNA torsional tension and lend support to the twin supercoiled domain model for transcription in the genome of intact human cells.

Nucleosome spacing is compressed in active chromatin domains of chick erythroid cells

We have cleaved the chromatin of embryonic and adult chicken erythroid cells using a novel nuclease that is capable of resolving clearly the nucleosomes of active chromatin. We found that in active chromatin, nucleosomes are spaced up to 40 base pairs closer together than in inactive chromatin. This was true for both "housekeeping" and "luxury" genes and was observed whether the digestion was carried out on isolated nuclei in vitro or by activating the endogenous nuclease in vivo. The close spacing extended several kilobases into flanking chromatin, indicating that this is a domain property of active chromatin, not just a characteristic of regions disrupted by transcription. A simple interpretation of our results is that the nucleosomes of active chromatin are mobile in vivo and, not being constrained by linker histones, freely move closer together.

Image analysis-based measurement of DNA supercoiling changes in transformed and nontransformed human cell lines

An image analysis system was used to visualize and measure the changes in nucleoid diameter (nuclear matrix core plus extruded DNA loops) which occur when increasing concentrations of propidium iodide are used to titrate the DNA supercoiling response. Parallel core size measurements allow estimates of the changes in apparent DNA loop size. Unlike sedimentation assays, DNA loop size estimates are not influenced by particle mass, require no prior cell labeling, and can be performed on a per cell basis. This technique was used to examine changes in DNA loop characteristics which may occur when cells are transformed or undergo changes in their proliferative state. SV40-transformation of human diploid fibroblast lines resulted in a significant increase in both the nucleoid core and average DNA loop size. Lymphoblast cell lines also had larger nucleoid dimensions than normal lymphocytes. The response of several established human tumor cell lines indicated slightly increased loop but not core sizes as compared to normal human diploid fibroblasts. Changes in proliferative state also resulted in changes in DNA loop characteristics as measured in this assay. Both quiescent fibroblasts and unstimulated lymphocytes appeared to have smaller or more condensed DNA loop structures than their proliferating counterparts. These results demonstrate the utility of this assay in detecting changes in DNA loop structure which occur in association with changes in the proliferative activity of cells in culture.

Positive DNA supercoiling generates a chromatin conformation characteristic of highly active genes

During transcription, positive DNA supercoils generated ahead of RNA polymerase could theoretically uncoil the negative DNA supercoils associated with nucleosomes and thereby decondense the chromatin fiber in preparation for RNA polymerase passage. Here we examine the effect of positive DNA supercoiling on the structure of yeast 2-microns minichromosomes. We utilized a conditional topoisomerase mutant expressing Escherichia coli topoisomerase I to convert the DNA supercoiling state from negative to positive in vivo. Minichromosomes containing positively supercoiled DNA exhibited a striking increase in DNase I sensitivity. They also displayed additional micrococcal nuclease cleavage sites but yielded nearly typical nucleosomal ladders after extensive digestion. Upon in vitro relaxation with eukaryotic topoisomerase I, the minichromosomes remained DNase I sensitive but were converted to negative DNA supercoiling with a slightly increased linking number compared to typical minichromosomes, thus indicating the presence of bound histones. Therefore, positive DNA supercoiling provides a mechanism for generating, but is not required for maintaining, a conformation in chromatin characteristic of highly transcribed genes.

The DNA intercalator, ethidium bromide, alters the pattern of DNAse I hypersensitive sites of the beta A-globin gene in chicken erythrocytes

We have analysed the effects of a DNA intercalator, ethidium bromide (EB), on chromatin structure in nuclei from both chicken mature erythrocytes (RBC) and reticulocytes (Ret). A differential release of nuclear proteins was obtained from both types of nuclei exposed to EB. Among these proteins, a species of 45 kDa is the major component. Furthermore, in the 10 mM EB-treated nuclei, the pattern of DNAse I hypersensitive sites (DHS) around the chicken beta A-globin gene were significantly altered, i.e., the original set was replaced by a new set of DHS. We have discussed the implications of our observations, in the light of current concepts of functional aspects of the conformational heterogeneity of DNA in both protein-DNA interactions and chromatin structure, as well as the effects of DNA intercalators on DNA conformation.

A matrix/scaffold attachment region binding protein: identification, purification, and mode of binding

Matrix/scaffold attachment regions (MARs/SARs) partition chromatin into functional loop domains. Here we have identified a chicken protein that selectively binds to MARs from the chicken lysozyme locus and to MARs from Drosophila, mouse, and human genes. This protein, named ARBP (for attachment region binding protein), was purified to homogeneity and shown to bind to MARs in a cooperative fashion. ARBP is an abundant nuclear protein and a component of the internal nuclear network. Deletion mutants indicate that multiple AT-rich sequences, if contained in a minimal approximately 350 bp MAR fragment, can lead to efficient binding of ARBP. Furthermore, dimerization mutants show that, to bind ARBP efficiently, MAR sequences can act synergistically over large distances, apparently with the intervening DNA looping out. The binding characteristics of ARBP to MARs reproduce those of unfractionated matrix preparations, suggesting that ARBP is an important nuclear element for the generation of functional chromatin loops.

Nuclease-induced DNA structural changes assessed by flow cytometry with the intercalating dye propidium iodide

A flow cytometric analysis of DNA structural changes induced by cleavage with nucleases was performed on isolated HeLa nuclei by assessing changes in stainability with the DNA-specific fluorochrome propidium iodide (PI). After mild digestion with DNAse I, micrococcal nuclease, or with the single-strand-specific S1 and Neurospora crassa nucleases, fluorescence intensity of nuclei stained with PI increased by about 15-30% above the value of undigested control samples. No significant modifications were observed with the restriction enzymes Eco RI, Alu I, and Not I. The DNAse I-induced increase in fluorescence intensity was also observed with the non-intercalating dye Hoechst 33258, but not with mithramycin. Nuclease-induced fluorescence intensity changes as determined with PI were found to be dependent on the dye concentration. A constant increase (about 20%) was measured at dye/DNA-P ratios greater than 0.11. Below this value (2 micrograms/ml PI), the fluorescence intensity of digested samples was 15-30% lower than that of undigested controls. This behaviour towards intercalating dyes is similar to that of the relaxed (nicked) vs. the supercoiled (intact) form of circular DNA. These results suggest that conformation- but not sequence-specific nucleases induce a relaxation of DNA supercoils.

Topological properties of bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV-1) DNA in episomal nucleoprotein complexes: a model system for chromatin organization in higher eukaryotes

Sedimentation analysis of isolated episomal bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV-1) nucleoprotein complexes in sucrose gradients and subsequent separation of the purified DNA in chloroquine gels revealed different classes of molecules, varying in their degree of superhelicity. Since torsionally stressed DNA favors the adoption of secondary structures, we employed the single-strand-specific S1 nuclease to detect such structural alterations in both naked DNA and native chromatin. Direct examination of nuclease digestion products in chloroquine gels showed that neither the naked DNA nor the BPV-1 nucleoprotein complexes in isolated nuclei were cleaved randomly by the enzyme. Instead, there was a strict dependence on nuclease susceptibility and the degree of supercoiling, strongly suggesting that the structural features detected by S1 nuclease are due to the occurrence of torsionally stressed viral chromatin. Mapping analysis using the indirect end-labeling method demonstrated an S1-nuclease cleavage site adjacent to 20 homopurine residues known to be hypersensitive to S1 attack. Furthermore, direct methylation experiments with viral chromatin in isolated nuclei indicated that only circular, covalently closed nucleoprotein complexes served as substrate, whereas linearized BPV-1 chromatin was not susceptible to exogenously added Hhal methylase. This observation raises the possibility that the modulation of topology in nucleosomally organized DNA might also play a role in eukaryotic DNA methylation.

P1 nuclease defines a subpopulation of active SV40 chromatin--a new nuclease hypersensitivity assay

Under exhaustive digestion conditions P1 nuclease was found to cleave a subpopulation of intracellular SV40 chromatin only once. The major P1 cleavage site in SV40 DNA was mapped at the origin of DNA replication, and the two minor sites at the SV40 enhancers. The P1-sensitive SV40 chromatin subpopulation was found to have higher superhelical density than the bulk of the intracellular SV40 chromatin. Furthermore, pulse labeled SV40 DNA which had higher superhelical density than that of the steady state viral DNA (S.S. Chen and M.T.Hsu, J. Virol 51:14-19, 1984) was also found to be preferentially cleaved by P1 nuclease. These results are consistent with a supercoil-dependent alteration of chromatin conformation near the regulatory region of the viral genome that can be recognized by P1 nuclease. Since P1 nuclease cleaves the subpopulation of SV40 chromatin only once without further degradation, this nuclease can be used as a general tool to define viral or cellular chromatin fraction with altered chromatin conformation and to map nuclease hypersensitive sites. Preliminary studies indicate that P1 makes limited double stranded cleavages in cellular chromatin to generate large DNA fragments.

Serum stimulation of the c-fos enhancer induces reversible changes in c-fos chromatin structure

Transcription of the proto-oncogene c-fos is known to be activated by growth factors in serum and subsequently repressed by the Fos protein. We show that generalized DNase I sensitivity of c-fos chromatin correlates closely with enhancer activity during induction, repression, and superinduction of the c-fos gene. Within 90 s of serum stimulation, proximal DNA sequences on both sides of the enhancer exhibit increased DNase I sensitivity. Within 5 min, elevated DNase I sensitivity spreads to chromatin at the distal 3' end of the c-fos gene. These results suggest that an open state of chromatin is propagated in both directions from the enhancer. The induced alterations in chromatin structure precede the increased transcriptional activity of the c-fos gene, suggesting that these changes in chromatin structure potentiate transcription.

Serum stimulation of the c-fos enhancer induces reversible changes in c-fos chromatin structure

Transcription of the proto-oncogene c-fos is known to be activated by growth factors in serum and subsequently repressed by the Fos protein. We show that generalized DNase I sensitivity of c-fos chromatin correlates closely with enhancer activity during induction, repression, and superinduction of the c-fos gene. Within 90 s of serum stimulation, proximal DNA sequences on both sides of the enhancer exhibit increased DNase I sensitivity. Within 5 min, elevated DNase I sensitivity spreads to chromatin at the distal 3' end of the c-fos gene. These results suggest that an open state of chromatin is propagated in both directions from the enhancer. The induced alterations in chromatin structure precede the increased transcriptional activity of the c-fos gene, suggesting that these changes in chromatin structure potentiate transcription.

Active beta-globin gene transcription occurs in methylated, DNase I-resistant chromatin of nonerythroid chicken cells

We report active, inappropriate transcription of the chicken beta A-globin gene in normal fibroblasts, cultured MSB cells, and brain. We were unable to detect ovalbumin gene transcription in these same tissues. Most of the globin gene transcripts were found to be truncated near the beginning of the gene, suggesting the existence of a premature termination process that is preferentially active under conditions of inappropriate transcription. The inappropriately transcribed beta A-globin gene chromatin remained DNase I resistant and highly methylated. Thus, the DNase I-sensitive conformation of erythrocyte beta A chromatin was correlated not with beta A transcription per se but with beta A expression. Although both transcribed and nontranscribed genes within the globin domain exhibited the same DNase I sensitivity in erythrocyte nuclei, a housekeeping gene active in erythrocytes exhibited a different level of DNase I sensitivity. However, this gene exhibited the same level of DNase I sensitivity in both erythrocytes and a cultured cell line. These observations are consistent with the proposal (G. Blobel, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82:8527-8529, 1985) that the DNase I sensitivity of a gene may reflect properties of chromatin related to cotranscriptional and posttranscriptional aspects of mRNA production rather than to transcription per se.

Active beta-globin gene transcription occurs in methylated, DNase I-resistant chromatin of nonerythroid chicken cells

We report active, inappropriate transcription of the chicken beta A-globin gene in normal fibroblasts, cultured MSB cells, and brain. We were unable to detect ovalbumin gene transcription in these same tissues. Most of the globin gene transcripts were found to be truncated near the beginning of the gene, suggesting the existence of a premature termination process that is preferentially active under conditions of inappropriate transcription. The inappropriately transcribed beta A-globin gene chromatin remained DNase I resistant and highly methylated. Thus, the DNase I-sensitive conformation of erythrocyte beta A chromatin was correlated not with beta A transcription per se but with beta A expression. Although both transcribed and nontranscribed genes within the globin domain exhibited the same DNase I sensitivity in erythrocyte nuclei, a housekeeping gene active in erythrocytes exhibited a different level of DNase I sensitivity. However, this gene exhibited the same level of DNase I sensitivity in both erythrocytes and a cultured cell line. These observations are consistent with the proposal (G. Blobel, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82:8527-8529, 1985) that the DNase I sensitivity of a gene may reflect properties of chromatin related to cotranscriptional and posttranscriptional aspects of mRNA production rather than to transcription per se.

The effect of novobiocin on yeast topoisomerase type II

Low concentrations of novobiocin are toxic to permeable yeast cells, but do not inhibit type II topoisomerase activity. Furthermore, the enzyme does not bind specifically to novobiocin-Sepharose. These observations are in agreement with genetical analyses. Mutations at a single locus that confer novobiocin resistance and temperature sensitivity exhibit a similar phenotype to cells treated with novobiocin, but are not topoisomerase II mutants.

The nucleoskeleton and the topology of transcription

Transcription is conventionally believed to occur by passage of a mobile polymerase along a fixed template. Evidence for this model is derived almost entirely from material prepared using hypotonic salt concentrations. Studies on subnuclear structures isolated using hypertonic conditions, and more recently using conditions closer to the physiological, suggest an alternative. Transcription occurs as the template moves past a polymerase attached to a nucleoskeleton; this skeleton is the active site of transcription. Evidence for the two models is summarised. Much of it is consistent with the polymerase being attached and not freely diffusible. Some consequences of such a model are discussed.

The terminal regions of adenovirus and minute virus of mice DNAs are preferentially associated with the nuclear matrix in infected cells

The interaction of viral genomes with the cellular nuclear matrix was studied by using adenovirus-infected HeLa cells and minute virus of mice (MVM)-infected A-9 cells. Adenovirus DNA was associated with the nuclear matrix both early and late in infection, the tightest interaction being with DNA fragments that contain the covalently bound 5'-terminal protein. Replicative forms of MVM DNA were also found to be exclusively matrix associated during the first 16 to 20 h of infection; at later times viral DNA species accumulated in the soluble nuclear fraction at different rates, suggesting a saturation of nuclear matrix-binding sites. MVM DNA fragments enriched in the matrix fraction were also derived from the terminal regions of the viral genome. However, only the subset of fragments which possess a covalently bound 5'-terminal protein (i.e., DNA fragments in which the 5' palindromic DNA sequences are in the extended duplex rather than the hairpin conformation) were matrix associated. These observations suggest that the DNA-matrix interactions are, at least in part, mediated by the viral terminal proteins. Since these proteins have previously been shown to be intimately involved in viral DNA replication, our results further indicate that an association with the nuclear matrix may be important for viral genome replication and possibly also for efficient gene transcription.

Characterization of a topoisomerase-like activity at specific hypersensitive sites in the Drosophila histone gene cluster

It is well known that treatment of DNA-topoisomerase complexes with SDS induces cleavage of the DNA by trapping a reactive intermediate in which the topoisomerase is covalently linked to the terminal phosphates of the cut DNA. I have used this technique to examine potential topoisomerase binding sites in the histone gene chromatin of Drosophila Kc cells. Treatment of Kc nuclei with SDS induces Mg++-dependent DNA cleavage near the borders of two nuclease-hypersensitive sites located 5' and 3' of histone H4. It is likely that the SDS-induced cleavage at these hypersensitive sites is due to a topoisomerase because protein becomes tightly bound to the ends of the cleaved DNA fragments. Preliminary experiments suggest that a type II topoisomerase may be responsible for the cleavage.

Hormonal regulation of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase gene expression is mediated through modulation of an already disrupted chromatin structure

We used indirect end labeling to identify a series of five hypersensitive (HS) sites in the phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK) gene in H4IIE rat hepatoma cells. These sites were found at -4800 base pairs (bp) (site A), at -1300 bp (site B), over a broad domain between -400 and -30 bp (site C), at +4650 bp (site D), and at +6200 bp (site E). Sites A to D were detected only in cells capable of expressing the PEPCK gene, whereas site E was present in all of the cells examined thus far. The HS sites were present in H4IIE cells even when transcriptional activity was reduced to a minimum by treatment with insulin. Stimulation of transcription by a cyclic AMP analog to a 40-fold increase over the insulin-repressed level did not affect the main features of the HS sites. Furthermore, increased transcription did not disrupt the nucleosomal arrangement of the coding region of the gene, nor did it affect the immediate 5' region (site C), which is always nucleosome-free. In HTC cells, a rat hepatoma line that is hormonally responsive but unable to synthesize PEPCK mRNA, the four expression-specific HS sites were totally absent. Our experimental results also showed that, although there is a general correlation between lack of DNA methylation and transcriptional competence of the PEPCK gene, the role, if any, of methylation in the regulation of PEPCK gene activity is likely to be exerted at very specific sites.

Plasticity of DNA conformation around the Drosophila melanogaster alcohol dehydrogenase gene under torsional stress

Genomic DNA of eukaryotes is thought to be organized into multiple topological domains whose conformation can be independently regulated by torsional stress. We have demonstrated the formation of altered DNA structures around the Drosophila melanogaster alcohol dehydrogenase (Adh) gene by sensitivity to endonucleases and by binding single-strand binding (SSB) protein. Several altered DNA structures were detected only on torsionally stressed DNA at specific sites. Some corresponded to the two initiation cap sites and the poly(A) addition sites and others were found in the 5'-flanking regions of both the adult and larval cap sites and in the 3'-flanking region of the Adh gene. In particular, the 5'-flanking regions both exhibited a plasticity of DNA conformation according to the strength of torsional stress and the concentration of Mg2+. SSB protein bound preferentially to the non-coding regions of the Adh gene only on torsionally stressed DNA and not on relaxed or linear DNA. The observed binding preference appeared to correspond to the thermodynamic stability of the base-pairs involved. These results suggest that DNA conformation is specifically organized around the Adh gene for gene function. The plasticity of DNA may play a role in the regulation of transcriptional activation.

Hormonal regulation of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase gene expression is mediated through modulation of an already disrupted chromatin structure

We used indirect end labeling to identify a series of five hypersensitive (HS) sites in the phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK) gene in H4IIE rat hepatoma cells. These sites were found at -4800 base pairs (bp) (site A), at -1300 bp (site B), over a broad domain between -400 and -30 bp (site C), at +4650 bp (site D), and at +6200 bp (site E). Sites A to D were detected only in cells capable of expressing the PEPCK gene, whereas site E was present in all of the cells examined thus far. The HS sites were present in H4IIE cells even when transcriptional activity was reduced to a minimum by treatment with insulin. Stimulation of transcription by a cyclic AMP analog to a 40-fold increase over the insulin-repressed level did not affect the main features of the HS sites. Furthermore, increased transcription did not disrupt the nucleosomal arrangement of the coding region of the gene, nor did it affect the immediate 5' region (site C), which is always nucleosome-free. In HTC cells, a rat hepatoma line that is hormonally responsive but unable to synthesize PEPCK mRNA, the four expression-specific HS sites were totally absent. Our experimental results also showed that, although there is a general correlation between lack of DNA methylation and transcriptional competence of the PEPCK gene, the role, if any, of methylation in the regulation of PEPCK gene activity is likely to be exerted at very specific sites.

Thyroid-specific and cAMP-dependent hypersensitive regions in thyroglobulin gene chromatin

Two regions hypersensitive to DNase I digestion were found in a 7-kb segment of thyroglobulin gene 5'-flanking sequences in the chromatin from bovine thyroid. The most upstream site (-2000 to -1600 bp relative to the transcriptional start) was found in thyroid chromatin only, but independently of actual expression of the gene. It therefore represents a tissue-specific characteristic which may be associated with the commitment of the thyroglobulin gene to transcriptional activity. The very 5' end of the gene and the proximal promoter sequences (-100 to +60 bp relative to transcriptional start), constitute the second site, the hypersensitive character of which could be directly correlated with transcriptional activity. The structural changes occurring in this region of the chromatin were dependent on cAMP stimulation of the thyroid cells.

Transcription-dependent DNA supercoiling in yeast DNA topoisomerase mutants

Studies with yeast DNA topoisomerase mutants indicate that neither topoisomerase I nor II appears to be essential for transcription by RNA polymerase II. However, plasmids carrying transcriptionally active genes are found to be extremely negatively supercoiled when isolated from mutants lacking topoisomerase I. Supercoiling occurs during transcriptional elongation rather than during transcriptional activation. It takes place in the absence of topoisomerase I and does not seem to be dependent on topoisomerase II since it can occur at the nonpermissive temperature in a top1-top2 ts mutant. Whether this change in linking number is due to an unusual form of topoisomerase II or whether it is due to a new enzyme has yet to be determined. The results suggest that topoisomerase I is normally required to relax transcriptionally induced supercoils. A model is discussed which considers the role of topoisomerases in the movement of RNA polymerase along the DNA template.

Novobiocin inhibits the SV40 enhancer activity

Using a transient expression assay, we have analysed the effect of novobiocin, DNA topoisomerase II inhibitor, on simian virus 40(SV40) enhancer activities. We used the recombinant clones containing type I or II collagen promoters placed upstream of the bacterial chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene with or without SV40 enhancer. We observed the expected increase in CAT activities due to the presence of the SV40 enhancer. Interestingly, CAT gene expression of the enhancer-containing constructs were inhibited more sensitively by novobiocin than that of the enhancer-less construct. This findings lead us propose that DNA superhelicity mediated by topoisomeraseII is one of the important factor for the manifestation of SV40 enhancer activity.