In vitro development of bovine embryos in Buffalo rat liver- or bovine oviduct-conditioned medium

Bovine embryo production in vitro: evolution of culture media and commercial perspectives

In vitro produced embryos exhibit lower viability compared to their in vivo counterparts. Mammalian preimplantation embryos have the ability to reach the blastocyst stage in diverse culture media, showcasing considerable metabolic adaptability, which complicates the identification of optimal developmental conditions. Despite embryos successfully progressing to the blastocyst stage, adaptation to suboptimal culture environments may jeopardize blastocyst viability, cryotolerance, and implantation potential. Enhancing our capacity to support preimplantation embryonic development in vitro requires a deeper understanding of fundamental embryo physiology, including preferred metabolic substrates and pathways utilized by high-quality embryos. Armed with this knowledge, it becomes achievable to optimize culture conditions to support normal, in vivo-like embryo physiology, mitigate adaptive stress, and enhance viability. The objective of this review is to summarize the evolution of culture media for bovine embryos, highlighting significant milestones and remaining challenges.

Progesterone-stimulated endometrial cell conditioned media increases in vitro produced bovine embryo blastocyst formation

The early bovine embryo is supported by histotroph molecules secreted by endometrial epithelial (EPI) and stroma fibroblast (SF) cells in response to luteal progesterone (P4). We hypothesized that specific histotroph molecule transcript abundance depends on cell type and P4 concentration and that endometrial cell conditioned media (CM) could improve in vitro produced (IVP) embryo development in culture. Primary bovine EPI and SF cells from seven uteri were incubated for 12 h with RPMI medium containing 0 (Control), 1, 15, or 50 ng of P4. RPMI was also incubated without cells (N-CM) and CM from EPI or SF cultures (EPI- or SF-CM) or a combination of the two (1:1; EPI/SF-CM) was used to culture IVP embryos from days 4-8 of development (n = 117). There was an effect of cell type (SLC1A1, SLC5A6, SLC7A1, FGF-2, FGF-7, CTGF, PRSS23 and NID2) and/or P4 concentration (FGF-7 and NID2) on endometrial cell histotroph molecule mRNA (P < 0.05). Compared to N-CM, blastocyst development on day 7 was greater in the EPI or SF-CM (P ≤ 0.05) and tended to be greater in the EPI/SF-CM (P = 0.07). On day 8, blastocyst development was greater only in the EPI-CM (P < 0.05). Further, culturing embryos with endometrial cell CM reduced day 8 blastocyst transcript abundance of cell adhesion molecule LGALS1 (P < 0.01). In conclusion, endometrial cell CM or histotroph molecules may be used to improve IVP embryo development in cattle.

Recent progress in bovine in vitro-derived embryo cryotolerance: Impact of in vitro culture systems, advances in cryopreservation and future considerations

Cryopreservation of in vitro-derived bovine embryos is a crucial step for the widespread reproduction and conservation of valuable high-merit animals. Given the current popularity of bovine in vitro embryo production (IVP), there is a demand for a highly efficient ultra-low temperature storage method in order to maximize donor ovum pickup (OPU) turn-over, recipient availability/utilization and domestic/overseas commercial trading opportunities. However, IVP bovine embryos are still very sensitive to chilling and cryopreservation, and despite recent progress, a convenient (simple and robust) protocol has not yet been developed. At the moment, there are two methods for bovine IVP embryo cryopreservation: slow programmable freezing and vitrification. Both of the aforementioned techniques have pros and cons. While controlled-rate slow cooling can easily be adapted for direct transfer (DT), ice crystal formation remains an issue. On the other hand, vitrification solved this problem but the possibility of successful DT commercial incorporation remains to be determined. Moreover, simplification of the vitrification protocol (including warming) through the use of an in-straw dilution without the use of a microscope is a prerequisite for its use under farm conditions. This review summarizes the bovine IVP embryo cryopreservation achievements, strengths and limitations of both freezing systems and prospective improvements to enhance cryosurvival, as well as perspectives on future directions of this assisted reproductive technology.

Effects of co-culture and embryo number on the in vitro development of bovine embryos

It is generally accepted that culturing embryos in groups or with somatic cells improves both the yield and quality of the blastocysts obtained. The aims of this study were 1) to compare the yield and quality of the embryos obtained after culture in several number conditions and in several culture systems and 2) to assess the effect of co-culture started at various stages of embryo development. Under cell-free culture conditions (modified synthetic oviduct fluid [mSOF] supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum [FCS] 48 h post insemination, the rate of Day 10 blastocysts was lower when embryos were cultured in small groups (1 to 6 per drop) than in large groups (4 versus 23% ; P < 0.01). There was no group effect when embryos were co-cultured either with Buffalo rat liver (BRL) cells in TCM 199, or in a culture system allowing the progressive development of cumulus cells in mSOF, even if co-culture started at 66 or 114 h post insemination. However, embryos cultured singly had lower cell numbers than embryos cultured in large groups when co-culture started at 114 h post insemination. This suggests that 1) somatic cells improve the development of singly cultured bovine embryos up to the blastocyst stage after the 9-16 cell stage; 2) co-culture affects blastocyst cell number of singly cultured embryos by acting roughly between the 5-8 and the 9-16 cell stage; and 3) cooperation between embryos could replace the effect of co-culture either on the yield of blastocysts or on blastocyst cell number. Blastocysts appeared significantly earlier in co-culture with cumulus cells in mSOF than in co-culture with BRL cells in TCM 199 (detection of the blastocysts: 7.3 +/- 0.1 d post insemination with cumulus cells versus 8.1 +/- 0.1 d with BRL cells; P < 0.001) and had a significant higher number of cells (143 +/- 9 versus 85 +/- 11; P < 0.001). This system thus seems suitable for the culture of small numbers of embryos resulting from in vitro maturation and fertilization of oocytes from individual donor cows.

Mammalian embryo co-culture: Trials and tribulations of a misunderstood method

Embryo-somatic cell co-culture was devised over 40 years ago in an attempt to improve the development and viability of mammalian preimplantation embryos generated and cultured in vitro. While initial endeavours were successful in this respect, other studies soon highlighted a number of significant long-term detrimental impacts of this approach. Surprisingly little is known about the mechanisms underlying the beneficial effects of co-culture, although the production of embryotrophic compounds, modulation of nutrient profile, protection against culture-induced stress and/or toxin clearance are all contenders. The extent to which the inadvertent exposure of embryos to serum accounts for many of these effects remains open to question. Although the popularity of somatic cell co-culture has recently declined in favour of the use of sequential media due to concerns associated with its risk of disease transmission and long-term sequelae, we argue that complete dismissal of this technique is ill advised, given that our limited understanding of basic somatic cell interactions has prevented us from fully exploiting its potential. In this respect, there is some merit in focussing future research strategies based on reconstructed maternal tract tissue. Although the use of co-culture in clinical practice is unacceptable and its implementation in domestic species for commercial purposes should be viewed with diffidence, this technique can still provide a wealth of information on the development of novel, more physiological embryo in vitro culture systems. The proviso for acquiring such information is to gain a fuller understanding of the culture requirements/biochemistry of somatic cells and their interaction with the early conceptus.

Embryo production by ovum pick up from live donors

Embryo production by in vitro techniques has increased steadily over the years. For cattle where this technology is more advanced and is applied more, the number of in vitro produced embryos transferred to final recipients was over 30,000 in 1998. An increasing proportion of in vitro produced embryos are coming from oocytes collected from live donors by ultrasound-guided follicular aspiration (ovum pick up, OPU). This procedure allows the repeated production of embryos from live donors of particular value and is a serious alternative to superovulation. Ovum pick up is a very flexible technique. It can be performed twice a week for many weeks without side effects on the donor's reproductive career. The donor can be in almost any physiological status and still be suitable for oocyte recovery. A scanner with a sectorial or convex probe and a vacuum pump are required. Collection is performed with minimal stress to the donor. An average of 8 to 10 oocytes are collected per OPU with an average production of 2 transferable embryos. The laboratory production of embryos from such oocytes does not differ from that of oocytes harvested at slaughter as the results after transfer to final recipients. For other species such as buffalo and horses OPU has been attempted similarly to cattle and data will be presented and reviewed. For small ruminants, laparotomy or laparoscopy seems the only reliable route so far to collect oocytes from live donors.

Improvement of in vitro co-culture systems for bovine embryos using a low concentration of carbon dioxide and medium supplemented with beta-mercaptoethanol

Two experiments were conducted to investigate the effect of carbon dioxide (CO2) gas atmosphere and beta-mercaptoethanol on the development of bovine embryos in an in vitro co-culture system. In Experiment 1, in vitro-matured bovine oocytes were inseminated and then co-cultured with cumulus cells in culture medium (CM; 25 mM HEPES buffered TCM-199 supplemented with 5% superovulated cow serum and 0.5 mM sodium pyruvate). Oocytes matured and fertilized in 2 or 5% CO2 in air exhibited similar cleavage rates, but the proportion of embryos that developed to the blastocyst stage was higher for embryos co-cultured in 2 versus 5% CO2 in air. In Experiment two, 4- to 8-cell embryos produced under the condition of 2% CO2 in air were co-cultured with cumulus cells in CM supplemented with various levels of beta-mercaptoethanol (0, 5, 10, 50 microM). The percentage of embryos that developed to the blastocyst stage in CM with 10 microM beta-mercaptoethanol was higher (P<0.05) than that of embryos co-cultured with 0 or 50 microM beta-mercaptoethanol. These results indicate that cumulus cell co-culture in an atmosphere of 2% CO2 in air has a marked stimulatory effect on in vitro development of bovine embryos and that addition of beta-mercaptoethanol to the co-culture medium 2 d after insemination improved the in vitro development of bovine 4- to 8-cell embryos to the blastocyst stage.

Comparison of sex ratio and cell number of IVM-IVF bovine blastocysts co-cultured with bovine oviduct epithelial cells or with Vero cells

The influence of 2 co-culture systems (BOEC and Vero cells) on the development rates, quality grades and sex ratios of IVM-IVF bovine embryos were studied. Zygotes obtained after IVF were co-cultured in each co-culture system for 7 and 8 d (Day 0 = day of insemination) in B2 medium. No effect of the co-culture system was observed on development rates measured on Days 7 and 8. However, Vero cell co-culture had a positive influence on embryo quality. Irrespective of their sex, embryos produced on Vero cells showed higher cells number than those co-cultured on BOEC (103.4 +/- 3.8 and 97 +/- 8.12 for BOEC vs 113.7 +/- 3.5 and 114 +/- 5.9 for Vero cells at Days 7 and 8, respectively; P < 0.05). The percentage of male embryos was increased in the two co-culture systems (60.7% males for BOEC; P < 0.05 vs 63% males for Vero cells; P < 0.01) on Day 7. In both co-culture systems the increase in the percentage of males was more obvious for embryos reaching the most advanced stage (expanded blastocysts). The results show that Vero cells improved the quality grade of bovine embryos produced in vitro, and thus are recommended for use as a safe co-culture system that does not contain pathogens.

A comparison of Menezo's B2 and tissue culture Medium-199 for in vitro production of bovine blastocysts

The objectives of this study were, first, to evaluate the effectiveness of 2 culture media, Menezo's B2 (B2) and Tissue Culture Medium-199 (M-199), for the production of bovine blastocysts in a commercial embryo transfer program; and, second, to characterize the stage of development, quality grade and cell number of blastocysts produced in each medium. One-cell bovine embryos were produced using in vitro maturation and fertilization procedures. After fertilization, the embryos were co-cultured on Buffalo rat liver (BRL) cell monolayers in either B2 or M-199+1% BSA (M-199) medium. Both media were supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum (FCS) and penicillin/streptomycin. Embryo cultures were continued undisturbed to either Day 7 or Day 8 post-insemination. In the Day 7 cultures, all blastocysts were removed for evaluation on Day 7, and the remaining embryos were cultured for a further 24 h. Any additional blastocysts that formed were removed for evaluation and designated as Day 8 disturbed embryos. All blastocysts were classified for stage and quality grade. Embryos were fixed and stained for determination of cell number. Overall, the proportion of blastocysts was greater (P = 0.0003) with B2 medium (46%) than with M-199 (33%). This was due to a larger (P = 0.0001) proportion of blastocysts produced in B2 medium when cultures were left undisturbed for 8 d (50 vs 28% for B2 vs M-199). The proportion of blastocysts on Day 7 of culture tended to differ (P = 0.073) between media (33 vs 24% for B2 vs M-199). In addition, there were more (P = 0.007) blastocysts at advanced stages of development in B2 medium on Day 7. There was no effect of type of medium on the distribution of embryo quality grades on any day examined. The number of cells per blastocyst did not differ between media but did vary significantly (P < .05) with both stage and grade. In conclusion, B2 medium was superior to M-199 medium when used in a co-culture system with BRL cells for the production of bovine blastocysts.

Correlations between chemical parameters, mitogenic activity and embryotrophic activity of bovine oviduct-conditioned medium

To establish parameters predicting the quality of bovine oviduct epithelial cell-conditioned media, we compared media conditioned by oviduct cells from cows at Day 2 (n = 3) and Day 15 (n = 3) of the estrous cycle. In addition, we tested the influence of time of conditioning. Media were evaluated for their embryotrophic activity using a cumulus cell co-culture system as a control. The same media were tested for their mitogenic activity on NIH 3T3 cells and for chemical parameters, including total protein, and de novo synthesized protein as well as for concentrations of glucose, lactate and ammonium. Analysis of variance did not reveal a significant effect by stage of the estrous cycle on the embryotrophic activity of conditioned media. However, there was a significant effect by time of conditioning on the proportion of 5- to 8-cell embryos (P < 0.01) and of blastocysts and hatched blastocysts (P < 0.05). None of the conditioned media (19 to 31% blastocysts) was superior to the cumulus cell co-culture system (32% blastocysts). In the conditioned media, the proportion of 5- to 8-cell embryos correlated positively with mitogenic activity on 3T3 cells (r = 0.64; P < 0.05), whereas the proportion of blastocysts was not significantly correlated with this parameter. In summary, our results provide evidence for an effect of time of conditioning on embryotrophic activity of oviduct epithelial cell-conditioned media. The fact that mitogens for NIH 3T3 cells affect the proportion of 5- to 8-cell embryos but not of blastocysts suggests different culture requirements for early and late preimplantation stage development of bovine embryos.

Effect of estrus-associated glycoprotein and tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-1 secreted by oviduct cells on in vitro bovine embryo development

The effect of two glycoproteins (estrus-associated glycoprotein [EGP] and tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase [TIMP-1]) secreted by bovine oviduct cells on in vitro bovine embryo development was assessed. A first set of experiments was conducted to determine whether the embryotrophic activity of the bovine oviduct-conditioned medium (BOCM) was correlated with the presence of EGP or TIMP-1. EGP and TIMP-1 were detected in BOCM, supporting the development of 22% zygotes to the blastocyst stage, as well as in BOCM yielding a low blastocyst rate (3-4% blastocysts). These glycoproteins do not seem to be necessary for bovine embryo development up to the blastocyst stage in our BOCM. In a second experiment, zygotes were cultured in modified synthetic oviduct fluid (mSOF) supplemented with different concentrations (0.5, 5, 50, and 500 micrograms/ml) of purified bovine EGP. In the third experiment, since purified bovine TIMP-1 was not available, zygotes were cultured in BOCM depleted of TIMP-1 by immunoprecipitation treatment. Adding EGP to mSOF, or removing TIMP-1 from BOCM, did not affect bovine embryo development up to the blastocyst stage, or mean number of cells per blastocyst after 8 days of culture. The results indicate that, under our culture conditions, EGP and TIMP-1 do not play an important role in sustaining bovine embryo development, and do not influence blastocyst quality, assessed in terms of total number of cells per embryo.

Increasing the rate of blastocyst formation and hatching from in vitro-produced bovine zygotes

This study was designed to identify parameters that would facilitate early selection of superior embryos, as well as to define culture conditions that could increase the proportion of embryos proceeding to the blastocyst stage. In the first experiment, the developmental potential of bovine embryos that had reached different stages of development after 60 h of culture following insemination was assessed. No 2-cell embryos underwent further cleavage. Of the 4-cell embryos (n = 188) only 12.2% progressed to the blastocyst stage, while 62.5% of 8-cell embryos (n = 480) did so (P < 0.01). In a further experiment, the effects of conditioning the culture medium (TCM 199) either with Buffalo rat liver cells (BRLC) or bovine oviductal epithelial cells (BOEC) and the effects of co-culture with either of these 2 cell types were examined. The percentage of 8-cell embryos proceeding to the morula and blastocyst stages was independent of cell type and culture system. However, BOEC-conditioned medium supported significantly lower production of blastocysts than any of the other culture methods. Only 24.1% of the former proceeded to the blastocyst stage after the full 10 d of culture, and only 3% hatched, values that were significantly lower than in the other 3 groups (P < 0.01). Among the latter, 44% progressed to the blastocyst stage in BRLC-conditioned medium while 44 and 46% reached that endpoint after co-culture with BOEC or BRL cells, respectively. The percentages that hatched among these were 28.2, 31 and 28.5%, respectively.

Effect of high molecular weight factors present in bovine oviductconditioned medium on in vitro bovine embryo development

To investigate the presence of embryotrophic factors in bovine oviduct-conditioned medium (BOCM), the high molecular weight fraction (> 10 KDa) from BOCM was added to 3 chemically defined embryo culture media (TCM199, DMEM/F12 and modified synthetic oviduct fluid [mSOF]). Zygotes were obtained by in vitro maturation and fertilization of oocytes. Conditioning of TCM199 with oviduct cells increased both cleavage to the 5- to 8-cell stage (59 vs 37%) and further development to the blastocyst stage (19 vs 4%). The low molecular weight fraction (< 10 KDa) of BOCM maintained development to the 5- to 8-cell stage but did not allow development to the blastocyst stage. Adding the high molecular weight fraction to the inactive low molecular weight fraction restored bovine embryo development up to the blastocyst stage. This embryotrophic effect of the high molecular weight fraction was not observed when this fraction was added to TCM199 or DMEM/F12 medium. Whereas adding this fraction to mSOF medium significantly (P<0.05) increased embryo development up to the blastocyst stage (36%) in comparison with that of mSOF (15%) or BOCM (14%). These results show that BOCM contains high molecular weight factors promoting embryo development up to the blastocyst stage. Some chemically defined media mask the effect of these embryotrophic factors.

The sex ratio of bovine embryos produced in vitro in serum-free oviduct cell-conditioned medium is not altered

The sex ratio of bovine blastocysts produced in vitro in serum-free oviduct cell-conditioned medium was investigated. Bovine embryos reaching the blastocyst stage were removed from culture medium on Days 6, 7, 8 and 9 and were identified as small, mid-sized or expanded blastocysts. One third (29/91) of the blastocysts appeared on Day 6. Twelve from them were small blastocysts (5 males), 7 were mid-sized blastocysts (4 males) and 10 were expanded blastocysts (5 males). On Day 7, 33 blastocysts were obtained: 8 small (5 males), 9 mid-sized (3 males) and 16 expanded (13 males) blastocysts. Finally, on Days 8 and 9, 29 blastocysts were obtained: 12 small (9 males), 9 mid-sized (6 males) and 8 (3 males) expanded blastocysts. Sexing of the 91 blastocysts was performed by using an original polymerase chain reaction (PCR) protocol generating discreet internal control signals from both female and male samples and Y-specific smears from the male samples. Proportions of male embryos on Days 6, 7 and on Days 8+9 were 48, 64 and 62%, respectively. These values did not differ significantly among days and did not differ from 50%. Fifty-nine percent of small blastocysts, 52% of mid-sized blastocyst and 62% of expanded blastocysts were male. No difference between these values or with respect to 50% could be observed. These results show that bovine blastocysts produced in serum-free oviduct cell-conditioned medium do not have an altered sex ratio.