Bond strength of composites to etched and silica-coated porcelain fusing alloys

The Effect of Mechanical and Chemical Surface Preparation Methods on the Bond Strength in Repairing the Surface of Metal-Ceramic Crowns with Composite Resin: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

The aim of this study was to find the most effective surface preparation methods to enhance the bond strength between the composite resin and surface remaining from ceramic fracture. In this systematic review and meta-analysis, 39 studies were examined. The information related to the studies was extracted and categorized based on the type of the substrate material and applying or not applying thermal cycles (p<0.05). In the meta-analysis of substrate metal-ceramic samples without aging, application of air abrasion resulted in a significant increase of the bond strength to composite resin when using chemical compounds of the group without the mentioned functional monomers. Application of mechanical and chemical surface preparation methods can result in enhanced bond strength of the composite to the substrate material, which depends on the type of substrate material.

Effect of thione primers on adhesive bonding between an indirect composite material and Ag-Pd-Cu-Au alloy

The current study evaluated the effect of primers on the shear bond strength of an indirect composite material joined to a silverpalladium-copper-gold (Ag-Pd-Cu-Au) alloy (Castwell). Disk specimens were cast from the alloy and were air-abraded with alumina. Eight metal primers were applied to the alloy surface. A light-polymerized indirect composite material (Solidex) was bonded to the alloy. Shear bond strength was determined both before and after the application of thermocycling. Two groups primed with Metaltite (thione) and M. L. Primer (sulfide) showed the greatest post-thermocycling bond strength (8.8 and 6.5 MPa). The results of the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopic (XPS) analysis suggested that the thione monomer (MTU-6) in the Metaltite primer was strongly adsorbed onto the Ag-Pd-Cu-Au alloy surface even after repeated cleaning with acetone. The application of either the thione (MTU-6) or sulfide primer is effective for enhancing the bonding between a composite material and Ag-Pd-Cu-Au alloy.

Effect of silica coating on bond strength between a gold alloy and metal bracket bonded with chemically cured resin

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of three different surface conditioning methods on the shear bond strength (SBS) of metal brackets bonded directly to gold alloy with chemically cured resin.

METHODS

Two hundred ten type III gold alloy specimens were randomly divided into six groups according to the combination of three different surface conditioning methods (aluminum oxide sandblasting only, application of a metal primer after aluminum oxide sandblasting, silica coating and silanation) and thermocycling (with thermocycling, without thermocycling). After performing surface conditioning of specimens in accordance with each experimental condition, metal brackets were bonded to all specimens using a chemically cured resin. The SBS was measured at the moment of bracket debonding, and the resin remnants on the specimen surface were evaluated using the adhesive remnant index.

RESULTS

Application of metal primer after aluminum oxide sandblasting yielded a higher bond strength than that with aluminum oxide sandblasting alone (p < 0.001), and silica coating and silanation yielded a higher bond strength than that with metal primer after aluminum oxide sandblasting (p < 0.001). There was no significant change in SBS after thermocycling in all groups.

CONCLUSIONS

With silica coating and silanation, clinically satisfactory bond strength can be attained when metal brackets are directly bonded to gold alloys using a chemically cured resin.

Effects of silanation time on shear bond strength between a gold alloy surface and metal bracket

Objective

We aimed to investigate the effects of silanation time on the shear bond strength (SBS) of metal brackets on gold alloy in a silicoating procedure and compare the SBS of metal brackets on gold alloy and enamel.

Methods

Type III gold alloy plates were sandblasted with 30-µm silicon dioxide. Excess particles were removed with gentle air after silica coating, and silane was applied. Maxillary central-incisor metal brackets were bonded to each conditioned alloy surface with a light curing resin adhesive for 1 s, 30 s, 60 s, or 120 s after applying silane. The brackets were also bonded to 36 upper central incisors with the same adhesive. All samples were cured for 40 s with a light emitting diode curing light. The SBS was tested after 1 h and after 24 h. The adhesive remnant index (ARI) of the samples was also compared.

Results

The 60-s and 120-s silanation time groups showed a higher SBS than the other groups (p < 0.05). Samples tested after 24 h showed a significantly higher SBS than did the samples tested after 1 h (p < 0.05). The 1-s group showed higher ARI scores. The one-way analysis of variance and Student-Newman-Keuls test showed that the SBS values of the 60-s and 120-s silanation time groups were not significantly different from the SBS values of enamel.

Conclusions

Adequate silanation time is required to produce sufficient bond strength during silicoating.

Bond strength comparison of amalgam repair protocols using resin composite in situations with and without dentin exposure

The replacement of defective amalgam restorations leads to loss of tooth material and weakens the tooth, creating an increased risk of cusp fracture. The repair of such defects is a minimal intervention technique. The current study compared the repair bond strengths of a resin composite to amalgam and an amalgam-dentin complex after various surface conditioning methods. The specimens (N = 50) consisted of sound human canines with cylindrical preparations (diameter: 2.3 mm, depth: 3 mm) with amalgam-dentin complex (N = 30, n = 10/per group) and two groups with amalgam only (N = 20, n = 10/per group). The teeth were embedded in auto-polymerized polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA). The preparations were filled with non-Gamma 2 amalgam. The enamel was removed to expose dentin. The specimens with the amalgam-dentin complex were randomly assigned to one of the following conditioning methods: Group 1: Silicacoating amalgam, etching dentin, silane application on amalgam, primer/bonding on dentin, opaquer on amalgam, resin composite on both; Group 2: Etching dentin, silicacoating amalgam, silane application on amalgam, primer/bonding on dentin, opaquer on amalgam, resin composite on both and Group 3: Etching dentin, primer/bonding on dentin, opaquer, resin composite. The specimens with only amalgam were assigned to one of the following conditioning methods: Group 4: Silicacoating, silane application, opaquer, resin composite and Group 5: Opaquer, resin composite. For the two control groups, where no dentin was involved (Groups 4 and 5), bonding was achieved only on amalgam and Group 5 had no conditioning. The specimens were kept in water at 37 degrees C for five weeks before bond strength (MPa +/- SD) testing (Universal Testing Machine). After debonding, the failure types were analyzed. The results were significantly affected by the surface conditioning method (ANOVA). Only dentin conditioning (Group 3) showed the highest bond strength (39.9 +/- 14). The unconditioned control group (Group 5) showed the least favorable results (1.4 +/- 0.5). Multiple comparisons (Tukey-Kramer adjustment) showed that the mean values of Group 1 (34.1 +/- 11.4), 3 (39.9 +/- 14) and 4 (35.5 +/- 4) were not significantly different (p > 0.05), but between Groups 2 (22.8 +/- 6.6) and 3 (39.9 +/- 14), significant differences were observed (p = 0.0027). For reliable repair of amalgam restorations, including dentin fractures, the amalgam surface should first be silica coated, then the dentin/enamel should be etched, washed and rinsed thoroughly. Finally, the amalgam should be silanized and primer/bonding applied onto the dentin.

The effects of primer precuring on the shear bond strength between gold alloy surfaces and metal brackets

The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of precuring of primer coated on bracket bases on the strength of bonds between metal brackets and gold alloy. Square type III gold alloy plates were sandblasted with 30 μm silicon dioxide. After silica coating, excessive particles were removed gently with air. Silane was then applied, and maxillary central incisor metal brackets were bonded to each conditioned alloy surface with Transbond XT. Half of the specimens were precured at the bracket base after primer coating and the other half was not precured before bonding to the alloy surface. After bracket positioning, samples were cured using a light emitting diode (LED) for 40 seconds. Shear bond strengths were tested and adhesive remnant index (ARI) was evaluated after 1 hour and 24 hours. The primer precuring and 24 hours group exhibited highest bond strength (12.53 MPa) and the no precuring and 1 hour group showed lowest bond strength (5.58 MPa). Precured groups showed lower ARI scores. Due to the shallow curing depth of LED light and inhibition of transillumination at the metal surface, primer precuring at the bracket base is required for secure bracket bonding on gold alloy surfaces using LED curing units.

Shear bond strength of three veneering resins to a Ni-Cr alloy using two bonding procedures

Composite veneering materials are used as alternatives to porcelain in fixed prosthodontics. Mechanical retention of the resin on the metal framework has been associated with the formation of gaps at the resin/alloy interface, and failure of the restoration. Several chemical bonding systems have been introduced to promote resin adhesion. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the shear bond strength of three photocured composites (Artglass, Solidex & Signum+) to a Ni-Cr alloy.72 wax disks covered with 150-mum diameter beads were cast and divided in two equal groups. In the first group, Metal Photo Primer was applied on the casting surface, while the Siloc system was used in the second. Each group was divided in three subgroups of 12 samples, in which the three composites were photocured. Half of the specimens of each subgroup were subjected to 1000 and 5000 thermal cycles (5 and 55 degrees C) respectively. All specimens were tested in shear in a universal testing machine. The Siloc-Solidex group showed the highest bond strength (17.3 +/- 3.7 MPa). No statistically significant difference was found between specimens treated with Metal Photo Primer or Siloc. Thermocycling did not significantly affect the bond strength values. Solidex showed an adhesive failure mode for both alloy surface treatments, while Artglass and Signum+ exhibited combination failures. Conclusively, the appropriate alloy surface treatment - resin combination can significantly improve the resin-alloy shear bond strength. Specifically, Solidex resin exhibited significantly higher bond values compared with Artglass and Signum+, for both surface treatments and thermocycling procedures.

Bond strength of resin composite to differently conditioned amalgam

Bulk fracture of teeth, where a part of the amalgam restoration and/or the cusp is fractured, is a common clinical problem. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of different surface conditioning methods on the shear bond strength of a hybrid resin composite to fresh amalgam. Amalgams (N=84) were condensed into acrylic and randomly assigned to one of the following treatments (N=6): (1) Alloy primer + opaquer, (2) Air-particle abrasion (50 micro m Al(2)O(3)) + alloy primer + opaquer, (3) Silica coating (30 micro m SiO(x)) + silanization + opaquer, (4) Opaquer + pre-impregnated continuous bidirectional E-glass fibre sheets, (5) Silica coating + silanization + fibre sheets, (6) Silica coating + silanization + opaquer + fibre sheet application. Non-conditioned amalgam surfaces were considered as control group (7). The mean surface roughness depth (R(Z)) was measured from the control group and air-abraded amalgam surfaces. The resin composite was bonded to the conditioned amalgam specimens using polyethylene molds. All specimens were tested under dry and thermocycled (6.000, 5-55 degrees C, 30 s) conditions. The shear bond strength of resin composite to amalgam substrates was measured in a universal testing machine (1 mm/min). Surface roughness values for the non-conditioned control group (R(Z) approximately 0.14 micro m) and for air-particle abraded surfaces with either Al(2)O(3) or SiO(x) (R(Z) approximately 0.19 micro m and R(Z) approximately 0.16 micro m, respectively) did not show significant differences (p=0.23) (One-way ANOVA). In dry conditions, silica coating and silanization followed by fibre sheet application exhibited significantly higher results (14.8+/-5.6 MPa) than those of the groups conditioned with alloy primer (2.2+/-0.7 MPa) (p<0.001), air-particle abrasion+alloy primer (4.4+/-2.0 MPa, p<0.001), silica coating+silanization alone (6.2+/-0.8 MPa, p=0.009) or non-conditioned group (1.4+/-0.6, p<0.001). Silica coating and silanization followed by additional fibre sheets with opaquer application (23.6+/-6.9 MPa) increased the bond strength significantly compared to those of other groups (group 5 vs group 6, p=0.007; other groups vs group 6, p<0.001). Thermocycling decreased the bond strengths significantly for all of the conditioning methods tested (for group 1, p<0.001; for group 2, p=0.013; for group 3, p=0.002; for group 4, p=0.026; for group 5, p=0.002; for group 6, p<0.001 and for group 7, p<0.001).

Evaluation of alternative intra-oral repair techniques for fractured ceramic-fused-to-metal restorations

Ceramic fractures are serious and costly problems in dentistry. Moreover, they pose an aesthetic and functional dilemma both for the patient and the dentist. This problem has created demand for the development of practical repair options which do not necessitate the removal and remake of the entire restoration. Published literature on repair techniques for fractured fixed partial dentures, concentrating on the data obtained both from in vitro and in vivo studies, reveals that the repair techniques based on sandblasting and silanization are the most durable in terms of adhesive and cohesive failures compared with those using different etching agents.

Tensile bond strengths of composites to a gold-palladium alloy after thermal cycling

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Many different materials and methods have been used to fabricate or repair veneer facings with composites, but only a few of these have been studied.

PURPOSE

This study compared the tensile bond strengths of composites to a gold-palladium alloy with the use of several surface treatment methods.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Forty alloy specimens were cast in Eclipse (52% gold and 37.5% palladium) in the form of truncated cones. These specimens were divided equally into 4 groups. In group I, the bonding surfaces of the metal cones were treated with Silicoater MD. Truncated cones of Dentacolor composite were bonded to the metal surfaces and light-polymerized. In group II, the bonding surfaces of the metal cones were air-particle abraded with 50 microm aluminum oxide and coated with C&B Metabond. Truncated cones of Epic-TMPT composite were bonded to the metal surfaces and light-polymerized. In group III, the bonding surfaces of the metal cones were air-particle abraded with CoJet-Sand. Truncated cones of Pertac-Hybrid composite were bonded to the metal surfaces and light-polymerized. In group IV, the bonding surfaces of the metal cones were air-particle abraded with CoJet-Sand. Truncated cones of Visio-Gem were bonded to the metal surfaces and light-polymerized. After 24 hours of water immersion at 37 degrees C and 1000 thermal cycles in water at 5 degrees C and 55 degrees C, tensile forces were applied to all specimens with a universal testing machine. Analysis of variance was applied to the data (P<.05), and differences among means were determined with a Tukey-Kramer interval of 5.4 MPa.

RESULTS

Tensile bond strengths in MPa were as follows: Dentacolor, 14 +/- 5; Epic-TMPT, 12 +/- 4; Pertac-Hybrid, 13 +/- 5; and Visio-Gem, 18 +/- 4. The tensile bond strength of Visio-Gem was significantly higher than that of Epic-TMPT, but no differences were found among Dentacolor, Pertac-Hybrid, and Epic-TMPT (P<.05).

CONCLUSION

Within the limitations of this study, all 4 bonding systems tested produced high bond strengths between composites and a gold-palladium alloy after thermal cycling.

Shear bond strength of resin composite veneering material to gold alloy with varying metal surface preparations

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Although adequate surface preparation is indispensable to achieve a consistent and durable bond between resin composite materials and the metal substructures of veneered restorations, information on the bonding performance of current metal adhesive systems is limited.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the surface preparation effects of 4 metal conditioners and 1 adhesive system on bonding between a prosthetic resin composite veneering material and a gold casting alloy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Four primers containing sulfur derivative monomer and designed for conditioning noble metal alloys (Alloy Primer, Infis Opaque Primer, Metal Primer II, and Metaltite) and a surface modification technique (Siloc) were assessed. Cast disk specimens made of gold alloy (Pontor LFC) were either primed with 1 of the 4 primers or treated with the Siloc system and bonded with a light-activated prosthetic resin composite material (New Metacolor Infis). Control specimens were also prepared without the use of a bonding agent. Shear bond strengths were determined before and after thermocycling (20,000 cycles) for evaluation of bond durability.

RESULTS

All of the primed and Siloc-treated groups showed improved 24-hour shear bond strengths compared with the control group. After thermocycling, the groups either primed with the Metaltite conditioner or treated with the Siloc system exhibited the highest mean shear bond strengths.

CONCLUSION

The Metaltite conditioner and Siloc system each represent a useful method for improving the bond between the gold alloy and resin composite material tested.

Shear bond strength of techniques for bonding esthetic veneers to metal

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

New composites with improved qualities have been introduced to the dental profession as alternatives to porcelain. There is concern about the strength and reliability of new metal-resin bonding systems when these composites are used as esthetic veneers over metal frameworks.

PURPOSE

This in vitro study compared the shear bond strength of 2 metal-resin bonding techniques with the bond strength of conventional porcelain fused-to-metal (PFM). Effects of water storage and thermocycling were also evaluated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Ninety disks, cast in a medium gold, high noble PFM alloy, were divided equally into 6 groups, and received 3 treatments for veneering: conventional feldspathic porcelain on 1 group, and a composite (Artglass) bonded to the metal, using 2 metal-resin bonding techniques. Specimens were tested in shear, half of them after a 24-hour dry storage at room temperature and the rest after 10-day storage in normal saline solution at 37 degrees C and thermocycling. Fractured specimens were evaluated under x10 magnification to determine the nature of failure. Statistical analysis was performed with 2-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA).

RESULTS

Mean shear bond strength values before and after wet storage and thermocycling were 29.66 and 22.91 MPa for the PFM group; 21.43 and 17.92 MPa for the Siloc group; and 19.34 and 15.64 for the etched group, respectively. The PFM group exhibited significantly higher bond strength values compared with the other 2 groups (P<.001). All groups showed a significant decrease in bond strength values after wet storage and thermocycling (P<.001).

CONCLUSION

Wet storage and thermocycling caused a significant decrease in shear bond strength of all specimens. Shear bond strength of conventional feldspathic PFM was significantly higher than that of the 2 metal-resin bonding techniques tested. The 2 latter techniques did not reveal any statistically significant differences.

Effect of sandblasting and silicoating on bond strength of polymer-glass composite to cast titanium

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

There is little information regarding the mechanical and chemical retention of polymer-glass composite to cast titanium.

PURPOSE

This study examined whether sandblasting in conjunction with silicoating improves the bond strength of the polymer-glass composite to cast titanium.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Disk patterns (10 mm in diameter, 2.5 mm thick) were cast with commercially pure titanium (CP Ti) and Type IV gold alloy. Three pretreatments were applied: 50 microm Al(2)O(3) sandblasting (50 SB), 250 microm Al(2)O(3) sandblasting (250 SB), and 600-grit SiC paper polishing (600 SiC). After surface preparation, the Siloc system (silicoating) was applied on the disks. The 50 SB specimens without Siloc system were also prepared as controls. Then sticky tape with a circular hole (4.76 mm diameter) was placed onto the disk to define the bonding area. Artglass (polymer-glass) opaque, dentin, and enamel composites were applied using Teflon matrices and then light-polymerized. Shear bond strength (n = 8) was determined at a crosshead speed of 5 mm/min. Results were analyzed statistically with 2-way ANOVA and the Tukey-Kramer test (alpha=.05).

RESULTS

The Siloc system significantly (P <.05) improved the mean shear bond strength of Artglass to both metals in the 50 SB specimens. Statistical differences (P <.05) in shear bond strength were found among surface treatments for the silicoated CP Ti specimens, in which 250 SB specimens yielded the greatest bond strength. The Type IV specimens treated with Siloc system showed no significant differences in shear bond strength between the 50 SB and the 250 SB specimens.

CONCLUSION

Sandblasting with coarser alumina particles in conjunction with silicoating significantly enhanced bond strength of polymer-glass composite to cast titanium.

Resin-bonded fixed partial dentures: a review of three decades of progress

The resin-bonded fixed partial denture has undergone significant changes in design, materials and tooth preparation since its development in 1973. The selection of resin cement and micromechanical retention have closely paralleled alloy-resin-bonding research. Despite impressive in vitro research results, only 74 percent of the prostheses are still functional at the end of four years. Understanding the limitations, indications and design of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures will result in improved longevity and patient satisfaction.

Shear bond strength of four commercial bonding systems to cp Ti

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the bond strength of veneering composite to commercially pure titanium (cp Ti) using several different bonding systems and a post-cure heat treatment.

METHODS

Four commercial bonding systems (Cesead, Kuraray; New Metacolor, Sun Medical; Silicaoater MD, Kulzer; Termoresin LC II, GC) were evaluated. Bonding was attempted with the opaque resin provided by each bonding system as well as with the New Metacolor opaque resin. New Metacolor resin composite was used for the veneering composite. Half of the specimens were subjected to a post-cure heat treatment at 100 degrees C for 30 min. The shear bond strengths were tested after aging the specimens in water at 37 degrees C for 1 d and also after thermocycling for 16.5 d (20,000 cycles).

RESULTS

Strong bonds, exceeding 20 MPa, were achieved with all of the bonding systems with the exception of Thermoresin LC II, which is designed for noble metals. Bond strengths were only increased by the post-cure heat treatment for the New Metacolor system. Thermocycling caused a significant reduction in bond strength for the New Metacolor adn the Thermoresin LC II systems. The use of the New Metacolor opaque resin produced increased bonding for the Silicoater MD and the opaque resin produced increased bonding for the Silicoater MD and the Cesead systems, but the effect was eliminated after thermocycling.

SIGNIFICANCE

Strong, durable bonds can be achieved between composite and sandblasted cp Ti, thus enhancing the usefulness of this metal for esthetic resin-veneered crowns and other fixed prosthetics.

Bonding to glass infiltrated alumina ceramic: adhesive methods and their durability

Resin bonding to a glass-infiltrated aluminum oxide ceramic (In-Ceram) cannot be achieved by the methods commonly used for conventional silica-based dental ceramics. This study evaluated the durability of alternative methods of adhesive bonding to In-Ceram ceramic. The tensile bond strength of six bonding systems to In-Ceram ceramic was tested after up to 150 days of storage in isotonic artificial saliva solution and thermal cycling. Sandblasting alone or additional use of a silane did not result in a durable bond of a conventional BIS-GMA composite resin to In-Ceram ceramic. A durable bond to In-Ceram ceramic was achieved with a combination of tribochemical silica coating and conventional BIS-GMA composite resin or with the combination of sandblasting and a composite resin modified with a phosphate monomer. These two chemomechanical bonding methods appeared suitable for clinical bonding of In-Ceram ceramic restorations. A delayed degradation in bond strength was recorded for the combination of thermal silica coating and a conventional BIS-GMA composite resin; no reduction was found after 30 days, but there was a pronounced decrease after 150 days. This degradation indicated that extended storage in a wet environment was needed in laboratory tests to evaluate the durability of chemical bonds.

Effects of sandblasting and silica-coating procedures on pure titanium

Silica coating titanium improves chemomechanical bonding. Sandblasting is recommended as a pretreatment to thermal silica coating (Silicoater MD) or as part of a tribochemical silica coating process (Rocatec). This study evaluated the effects of sandblasting and coating techniques on volume loss, surface morphology and composition changes in pure titanium. Volume loss of titanium was similar to values reported for base alloys and does not seem to be critical for the clinical fit of restorations. Embedded alumina particles were found in the titanium after sandblasting and the alumina content increased to a range of 27.5-39.3 wt% as measured by EDS. Following tribochemical silica coating, a layer of small silica particles remained on the surface, increasing the silica content to a range of 17.9-19.5 wt%. Ultrasonic cleaning removed loose alumina or silica particles from the surface, resulting in only slight decreases in alumina or silica contents, suggesting firm attachment of most of the alumina and silica to the titanium surface. Silica content following thermal silica coating treatment increased only slightly from the sandblasted specimen to 1.4 wt%. The silica layer employed by these silica coating methods differs widely in both morphology and thickness. These results provide a basis for explanation of adhesive failure modes in bond strength tests and for developing methods to optimize resin bonding. Clinically, ultrasonic cleaning of sandblasted and tribochemically silica coated titanium should improve resin bonding as loose surface particles are removed without relevant changes in composition.

Bond strength of adhesive composites to dental substrates

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the in vitro bond strength of adhesive and traditional composites to several materials that might be encountered in clinical practice.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An adhesive composite, an adhesive composite with a bonding agent, and a traditional composite with a bonding agent were bonded to enamel, dentin, amalgam, porcelain, and nickel-chromium-beryllium (Ni-Cr-Be) alloy. Tensile bond strengths were determined after 24 hours storage at 23 degrees C or thermocycling.

RESULTS

The use of an adhesive composite with a bonding agent resulted in increased bond strength to amalgam, porcelain, and dentin, but not to enamel or Ni-Cr-Be alloy at 23 degrees C, when compared with the adhesive composite alone. The adhesive composite with a bonding agent had higher bond strengths to amalgam, porcelain, and dentin than did the traditional composite with bonding agent, but not to enamel or Ni-Cr-Be alloy at 23 degrees C.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of a bonding agent with an adhesive composite produced higher bond strengths than the adhesive composite alone. The traditional composite bonded better to enamel and Ni-Cr-Be alloy than did the adhesive composite. Thermocycling generally had no effect on bond strengths or increased them slightly.

Sandblasting and silica coating of a glass-infiltrated alumina ceramic: volume loss, morphology, and changes in the surface composition

Silica coating can improve bonding of resin to glass-infiltrated aluminum oxide ceramic (In-Ceram), and sandblasting is a pretreatment to thermal silica coating (Silicoater MD system) or a tribochemical coating process (Rocatec system). This study evaluated the effects of sandblasting and coating techniques on volume loss, surface morphology, and surface composition of In-Ceram ceramic. Volume loss through sandblasting was 36 times less for In-Ceram ceramic compared with a feldspathic glass ceramic (IPS-Empress), and sandblasting of In-Ceram ceramic did not change its surface composition. After tribochemical coating with the Rocatec system, a layer of small silica particles remained that elevated the silica content to 19.7 weight percentage (energy-dispersive spectroscopy). Ultrasonic cleaning removed loose silica particles from the surface and decreased the silica content to 15.8 weight percentage, which suggested firm attachment of most of the silica layer to the surface. After treatment with the Silicoater MD system, the silica content increased only slightly from that of the sandblasted specimen. The silica layer created by these systems differs greatly in both morphology and thickness, which could result in different bond strengths. Sandblasting of all ceramic clinical restorations with feldspathic glass materials should be avoided, but for In-Ceram ceramic the volume loss was within an acceptable range and similar to that of noble metals.

Influence of prolonged thermal cycling and water storage on the tensile bond strength of composite to NiCr alloy

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the bond strength and bond durability of new adhesive systems (both micromechanical and chemo-mechanical) to a beryllium-free nickel-chromium alloy (NiCr).

METHODS

Plexiglass tubes filled with composite were bonded to NiCr alloy discs. Groups of 24 samples were bonded using six different bonding systems. Subgroups of eight bonded samples were stored in an isotonic artificial saliva solution (37 degrees C) either for 1 d, 30 d or 150 d. In addition, the 30 and 150 d samples were thermal cycled for 7,500 or 37,500 cycles, respectively.

RESULTS

The bond strength of a conventional BisGMA composite to sandblasted NiCr was statistically significantly lower than that of chemo-mechanical bonding systems and decreased continuously during the storage time of 150 d. The additional use of a silane on the sandblasted alloy resulted only in a slight, statistically insignificant increase in bond strength. Statistically significantly higher and more durable bonds to NiCr alloy were achieved either with the combination of silica coating and use of a conventional BisGMA composite or with the combination of sandblasting and the use of a composite modified with a phosphate monomer. In these systems, the bond strengths were limited by the cohesive strength of the resin composites. However, a newly developed composite containing the same active phosphate monomer showed a statistically significant decrease in bond strength (cohesive strength) over storage time.

SIGNIFICANCE

Longer-term storage times in a wet environment are needed in laboratory tests to examine the durability of bonding systems.

Bond strength of composite to alloy treated with bonding systems

PURPOSE

The in-vitro bond strengths of a composite bonded to a nickel-chromium-beryllium alloy treated by eight bonding systems were measured after three storage conditions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nickel-chromium-beryllium alloy samples were treated by eight commercial bonding systems including adhesive composite cements, all-purpose bonding agents, and silica-coating systems. A composite was bonded to the alloy samples. Sample groups were stored in water for 24 hours at 23 degrees C, or thermocycled, or stored for 6 months at 23 degrees C and then debonded in tension.

RESULTS

Bond strengths after 24 hours storage were: adhesive composite cements, 14.2 to 22.1 MPa; all-purpose bonding agents, 11.4 to 14.6 MPa; and silica-coating systems, 18.6 to 20.2 MPa. Bond strengths after thermocycling were: adhesive composite cements, 12.6 to 20.6 MPa; all-purpose bonding agents, 9.9 to 17.7 MPa; and silica-coating systems, 11.1 to 19.2 MPa. Bond strengths after 6 months were: adhesive composite cements, 12.0 to 13.1 MPa; all-purpose bonding agents, 8.7 to 14.1 MPa; and silica-coating systems, 14.8 to 18.4 MPa.

CONCLUSIONS

Only two bonding systems showed decreased bond strength after thermocycling, as compared with 24 hours' storage; whereas four bond systems showed decreased bond strength after 6 months' storage. Bond strengths measured after thermocycling were not predictive of those measured after 6 months' storage.

Sandblasting and silica-coating of dental alloys: volume loss, morphology and changes in the surface composition

Silica-coating alloys improves chemo-mechanical bonding. Sandblasting is recommended as pretreatment to thermal silica-coating or as part of a tribochemical silica-coating process. This study evaluated the effects of sandblasting and coating techniques on volume loss, surface morphology and compositional changes in noble (AuAgCu) and base alloys (NiCr and CoCr). Volume loss was statistically significantly higher in the noble as compared to the base alloys but does not seem to be critical for the clinical fit of restorations. Embedded alumina particles were found in all alloys after sandblasting and the alumina content increased to a range of 14 to 37 wt% as measured by EDS. Following tribochemical silica-coating, a layer of small silica particles remained on the surface, increasing the silica content to between 12 and 20 wt%. Ultrasonic cleaning removed loose alumina or silica particles from the surface, resulting in only slight decreases in alumina or silica contents, thus suggesting firm attachment of the major part of alumina and silica to the alloy surface. Clinically, ultrasonic cleaning of sandblasted and tribochemically silica-coated alloys might improve resin bonding as loose surface particles are removed without relevant changes in composition. Silica content following thermal silica-coating treatment increased only slightly from the sandblasted specimen. The silica layer employed by these silica-coating methods differs widely in both morphology and thickness. These results provide a basis for explanation of adhesive failure modes in bond strength tests which will possibly optimize resin bonding. Further research is needed to characterize the outermost surface layers after these treatments and the exact location of adhesive failures.