Studies on hemopoietic chimerism following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in the molecular biology era

Mobilization-based chemotherapy-free engraftment of gene-edited human hematopoietic stem cells

Hematopoietic stem/progenitor cell gene therapy (HSPC-GT) is proving successful to treat several genetic diseases. HSPCs are mobilized, harvested, genetically corrected ex vivo, and infused, after the administration of toxic myeloablative conditioning to deplete the bone marrow (BM) for the modified cells. We show that mobilizers create an opportunity for seamless engraftment of exogenous cells, which effectively outcompete those mobilized, to repopulate the depleted BM. The competitive advantage results from the rescue during ex vivo culture of a detrimental impact of mobilization on HSPCs and can be further enhanced by the transient overexpression of engraftment effectors exploiting optimized mRNA-based delivery. We show the therapeutic efficacy in a mouse model of hyper IgM syndrome and further developed it in human hematochimeric mice, showing its applicability and versatility when coupled with gene transfer and editing strategies. Overall, our findings provide a potentially valuable strategy paving the way to broader and safer use of HSPC-GT.

•

HSPC mobilizers create an opportunity to engraft exogenous cells in depleted niches

•

Ex vivo culture endows HSPCs with migration advantage by rescuing CXCR4 expression

•

Cultured HSPCs outcompete mobilized HSPCs for engraftment in depleted BM niches

•

Transient engraftment enhancers coupled with gene editing confer a competitive advantage

Overcoming bioethical, legal, and hereditary barriers to mitochondrial replacement therapy in the USA

The purpose of the paper is to explore novel means to overcome the controversial ban in the USA against mitochondrial replacement therapy, a form of IVF, with the added step of replacing a woman’s diseased mutated mitochondria with a donor’s healthy mitochondria to prevent debilitating and often fatal mitochondrial diseases. Long proven effective in non-human species, MRT recently performed in Mexico resulted in the birth of a healthy baby boy. We explore the ethics of the ban, the concerns over hereditability of mitochondrial disease and its mathematical basis, the overlooked role of Mitochondrial Eve, the financial burden of mitochondrial diseases for taxpayers, and a woman’s reproductive rights. We examine applicable court cases, particularly protection of autonomy within the reproductive rights assured by Roe v Wade. We examine the consequences of misinterpreting MRT as genetic engineering in the congressional funding prohibitions causing the MRT ban by the FDA. Allowing MRT to take place in the USA would ensure a high standard of reproductive medicine and safety for afflicted women wishing to have genetically related children, concurrently alleviating the significant financial burden of mitochondrial diseases on its taxpayers. Since MRT does not modify any genome, it falls outside the “heritable genetic modification” terminology of concern to Congress and the FDA. Correcting this terminology, the IOM’s conclusion that MRT is ethical, the continuing normalcy of the first MRT recipient, and increasing public awareness of the promising benefits might be all that is required to modify the FDA’s position on MRT.

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation for homozygous β-thalassemia and β-thalassemia/hemoglobin E patients from haploidentical donors

Thalassemia-free survival after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT) is about 80-90% with either matched-related or -unrelated donors. We explored the use of a mismatched-related ('haplo- ') donor. All patients received two courses of pretransplant immunosuppressive therapy (PTIS) with fludarabine (Flu) and dexamethasone (Dxm). After two courses of PTIS, a conditioning regimen of rabbit antithymocyte globulin, Flu and IV busulfan (Bu) was given followed by T-cell-replete peripheral blood progenitor cells. GvHD prophylaxis consisted of cyclophosphamide (Cy) on days SCT +3 and +4 (post-Cy), and on day SCT +5 tacrolimus or sirolimus was started together with a short course of mycophenolate mofetil. Thirty-one patients underwent haplo-SCT. Their median age was 10 years (range, 2-20 years). Twenty-nine patients engrafted with 100% donor chimerism. Two patients suffered primary graft failure. Median time to neutrophil engraftment was 14 days (range, 11-18 days). Five patients developed mild to moderate, reversible veno-occlusive disease, while nine patients developed acute GvHD grade II. Only five patients developed limited-chronic GvHD. Projected overall and event-free survival rates at 2 years are 95% and 94%, respectively. The median follow up time is 12 months (range, 7-33 months).

Immunotherapy by allogeneic stem cell transplantation

During the past three decades, allogeneic stem cell transplantation (ASCT) has developed from being an experimental therapy in patients with endstage leukemia into a well-established therapy in patients with a range of disorders of the immunohematopoietic system. Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), acute or chronic, attacking host tissue is a major threat. However, donor immunocompetent T cells have a potent graft-versus-leukemia effect. A combination of calcineurin inhibitors and methotrexate is the standard therapy to prevent GVHD. Modulation of the immunosuppressive regimen may induce mild acute and mild chronic GVHD, reduce the risk of relapse, and improve long-term survival. Natural killer cells also play a role in this context. Killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor incompatibility between recipient and donor may reduce the risk of relapse in patients with myeloid leukemia. Relapse of leukemia is a major cause of death after ASCT. Minimal residual disease and recipient leukemia lineage-specific chimerism are sensitive techniques for early detection of leukemic relapse. Donor lymphocyte infusions can enhance the antitumor effect, especially for patients with molecular relapse. The allogeneic graft-versus-cancer effect has been demonstrated in patients with metastatic breast, renal, colorectal, ovarian, prostatic, and pancreatic carcinoma. Mesenchymal stem cells have immunomodulatory properties and may be used for immunomodulation of GVHD and tissue repair. All things considered, the future looks promising for ASCT.

Chimerism in the immunohematology laboratory in the molecular biology era

Dual or multiple cell populations, induced by chimeras, have been the subject of many studies. This long-standing fascination with chimeras has revealed a good deal of knowledge about human inheritance. Although historically most chimeras were caused by natural events, certain current medical intervention therapies are increasing the number of situations that can lead to a mixed cell population, that is, the chimeric condition, in humans. Medical therapies such as transfusion, stem cell transplantation, kidney transplantation, and artificial insemination induce temporary and sometimes permanent chimeras. Such natural or therapeutically induced presentations of chimerism can present challenging issues to the clinical immunohematology laboratory with regard to interpretation of results and subsequent patient management. The purpose of this review was to highlight some of these chimeric states and hypothesize how testing DNA from various tissues can cause apparent discrepancies between phenotype and genotype results.

Quantitative analysis of chimerism using a short tandem repeat method on a fluorescent automated DNA sequencer

Stem cell transplantation (SCT) is the treatment of choice for a number of malignant and nonmalignant diseases. Monitoring of SC engraftment or microchimerism (MC) is important for diagnosis of relapse, rejection or graft vs. host disease (GVHD). The goal of this study was to develop a sensitive and relatively simple method for MC lineage analysis using the Visible Genetics fluorescence automated sequencer. Sensitivity of the method was studied by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of informative short tandem repeats (STR) using donor/recipient DNA mixtures as the templates and DNA extracted from donor and recipient CD3+, CD19+ and CD15+ cells mixed at various ratios. Semi-quantitative analysis was performed using the Visible Genetics software and percent of donor specific signal was calculated. The sensitivity of this method varied from 0.8% to 6.2% for both DNA and cellular MC in CD3+, CD19+ and CD15+ subsets. Regression analysis revealed linearity (r = 0.94) between the number of donor cells in the mixture and intensity of MC fluorescent signal. These data indicate that the Visible Genetics polyacrylamide gel sequencer can be successfully used for MC analysis in SC recipients providing a relatively high level of sensitivity.

Hematologic aspects of myeloablative therapy and bone marrow transplantation

The transplantation of bone marrow cells or isolated hematopoietic stem cells from the bone marrow or peripheral blood is a widely utilized form of therapy for patients with incurable diseases of the hematopoietic and immune systems. Successful engraftment of the transplanted stem cells in an adequately prepared recipient normally leads to bone marrow reconstitution over a period of several weeks, accompanied by more gradual reconstitution of the immune system. Since the recipient is profoundly ill during the initial treatment period, laboratory data is critical for monitoring engraftment, detecting residual/recurrent disease, and identifying problems that may delay bone marrow reconstitution or lead to other medical complications. Accurate blood cell counts are imperative, and most bone marrow transplantation patients undergo periodic monitoring with bone marrow aspirates and biopsies with cytogenetic, molecular, and multiparametric flow cytometric studies. The potential complications of bone marrow transplantation include engraftment failure and delayed engraftment, infection, residual bone marrow disease, acute and chronic graft versus host disease, myelofibrosis, therapy-related acute leukemia, post-transplant lympho-proliferative disorders, and toxic myelopathy.

How and when should we monitor chimerism after allogeneic stem cell transplantation?

SUMMARY

Chimerism analysis has become an important tool for the peri-transplant surveillance of engraftment. It offers the possibility to realize impending graft rejection and can serve as an indicator for the recurrence of the underlying malignant or nonmalignant disease. Most recently, these investigations have become the basis for treatment intervention, for example, to avoid graft rejection, to maintain engraftment and to treat imminent relapse by pre-emptive immunotherapy. This invited review focuses on the clinical implications of characterization of hematopoietic chimerism in stem cell transplantation.

Mixed chimerism is frequent after allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation with positive CD34 selection, and is not reverted by low doses of donor T-cells add-back

The incidence of full donor chimerism (full DC) after CD34+ -selected peripheral blood stem cell transplantation (CD34+ -PBSCT) is controversial. Whereas the initial reports suggested a high incidence of full DC (hypothetically because of the high number of CD34+ cells infused) more recent works describe a high incidence of mixed lymphoid chimerism. There are no data concerning the ability of low-dose donor T-lymphocyte add-back on conversion to full DC.

METHODS

We prospectively monitored the chimerism status of 25 patients undergoing CD34+ -PBSCT and the effect on chimerism of delayed low doses of donor T-cell add-back (TCAB). One, two or three doses of TCAB were administered on days +28 (2 x 10(5) CD3+/kg), +60 (2 x 10(5) CD3+/kg) and +90 (2 x 10(6) CD3+/kg), respectively, when on cyclosporine A prophylaxis.

RESULTS

Incidence of full DC on day +20 was 56%. However, all but two patients progressed to MC. Fifteen patients were scheduled to TCAB. Six patients with initial MC did not convert to full DC after TCAB. Moreover, seven patients with full DC status progressed to mixed chimerism.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that low doses of TCAB administered under cyclosporine A prophylaxis have no effect on the eradication of the recipient cells. We believe that a high dose of CD34+ cells in the grafts of CD34+ -PBSCT is not enough to achieve stable full DC unless a minimum number of CD3+ cells are infused, or more intensified transplant conditioning regimens are employed.

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism at day 90 following allogenic myeloablative stem cell transplantation is a predictor of relapse and survival

We retrospectively analyzed the prognostic significance of mixed chimerism and associated clinical parameters in 80 patients following unmanipulated allogenic stem cell transplantation. Chimerism studies were performed on marrow aspirates using fluorescent in situ hybridization and variable number tandem repeats techniques at day +30, day +90 and +12 months. The median overall survival (OS) was 24 months (range, 1-56 months). Mixed chimerism was found in 23, 28 and 14% of patients at day +30 (1 month), +90 (3 months), and +12 months, respectively. Day +30 chimerism studies failed to provide any prognostic information. Day +90 mixed chimeras (MC) had significantly higher relapse rates compared to day +90 complete chimeras (CC) at 6 months (P=0.03) and 18 months when compared to MC (P=0.03) following transplant. The median OS in day +90 MC and day+90 CC were, respectively (95% CI, 2-35 months), compared to 47 months (95% CI, 20-74 months) (P=0.02). In conclusion, chimerism studies on day +30 could be reserved for patients who fail to demonstrate engraftment. Day +90 MC had higher relapse rates and lower OS, and therefore may be considered for novel therapies and future studies.

Use of ApoB3′ hyper variable region in studying mixed chimerism and maternal contamination in North Indian populations

ApoB3' hyper variable region is one of the highly polymorphic genetic marker and reveals a high degree of allelic variation in different populations therefore; it can be a useful marker for different clinical tests in which individual differences at DNA level form the basis of detection. In the present study we compared Apo B3 HVR with other 28 STR markers at allele frequency level, heterozygosity, polymorphism information content (PIC) and power of exclusion. Our results indicated a high degree of heterozygosity, PIC and power of exclusion for Apo B3 HVR. These criteria lead us to investigate this marker for different purposes like detection of maternal contamination in chorionic villus samples and chimerism studies after the engraftment of bone marrow in bone marrow transplantation patients. The utility of this marker has been discussed in comparison of other markers.

Significance of chimerism in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation: new variations on an old theme

The main goal of post-transplantation monitoring in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is to predict negative events, such as disease relapse, graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease, in order to intervene with appropriate therapy. In this context, chimerism analysis is an important method in monitoring post HSCT outcome. Mixed chimerism (MC) is mainly evaluated to define engraftment and relapse. Detection of MC is a prerequisite in both myeloablative and nonmyeloablative HSCT, in order to assess the graft status and decide later therapeutic strategies such as donor lymphocyte infusion. In this review, we discuss various techniques including erythrocyte phenotyping, cytogenetic analysis, fluorescent in situ hybridization, restriction fragment length polymorphism, STR/VNTR analysis and real-time quantitative PCR, along with the various methods used to detect minimal residual disease (MRD) in different diseases such as chronic myeloid leukemia, acute myelomonocytic leukemia or acute lymphoblastic leukemia. The review mainly highlights the optimal methodological approach, which needs to be informative, sensitive and quantitatively accurate for MC detection. Future of post HSCT graft monitoring lies in the selection of the most accurate and sensitive technique to determine both MC and MRD. Such an approach would be helpful in not only determining relapse or rejection, but also in ascertaining various responses to different treatment modalities.

Fractionated TBI correlates with less T cell mixed chimerism but increased risk of relapse compared to busulphan in patients with haematological malignancies after allogeneic stem cell transplantation

We prospectively evaluated mixed chimerism (MC) in the T cell and myeloid lineages and its correlation to busulphan, single-dose total body irradiation (TBI) and fractionated TBI (fTBI) conditioning in 180 patients with haematological malignancies after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT). In all patients receiving busulphan, the area under curve (AUC) was calculated. The incidence of MC in the T cell lineage was significantly lower in patients receiving fTBI (22%) compared to those given TBI (53%, P=0.02) or busulphan (47%, P<0.01). The incidence of myeloid MC did not differ between the three groups. The overall probability of acute graft-versus-host disease grades II-IV was significantly higher in patients with complete T cell donor chimerism (49%) compared to patients with T cell MC (23%, P<0.001). The incidence of T cell and myeloid MC after SCT did not differ between low (55%), medium (42%) and high (43%) AUC levels of busulphan during conditioning. Patients receiving fTBI had a significantly higher probability of relapse compared to busulphan-treated patients (44 vs l6%, P=0.01). In multivariate analysis adjusted for diagnosis, busulphan-treated patients showed both a better survival (P=0.04) and less probability of relapse (0.03) compared to TBI-treated patients.

Combined immunocytochemistry and FISH: an improved method to study engraftment of accessory bone marrow stromal cells

In aplastic anaemia (AA), correction of bone marrow (BM) stromal function may contribute to the outcome of bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Engraftment of BM stromal cells is rarely observed, but engraftment of accessory cells (macrophages and T cells) may be important. We have improved a method of combined immunocytochemistry and FISH described by van Tol et al. (1998) to define the cellular origin and time course of engraftment of BM stromal accessory cells after sex-mismatched BMT. Long-term bone marrow cultures were trypsinized and cytospin preparations stained by immunocytochemistry using monoclonal antibodies against specific cell lineages followed by FISH for X and Y chromosomes. Low level phase contrast microscopy was used to study staining of individual cells simultaneously with fluorescence microscopy to define chromosomal pattern. In controls, the combined procedure did not affect the intensity of APAAP staining or the accuracy of sex chromosome determination. In cultures from AA patients after sex-mismatched BMT, cell lineages could be identified and donor or recipient origin determined unequivocally. This procedure enabled us to examine the origin (host/donor) of different cell lineages with high confidence, in addition to producing images of the combined staining.

Quantitative assessment of hematopoietic chimerism after bone marrow transplantation by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction

We have developed a real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay using TaqMan technology (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) for monitoring donor cell engraftment in allogenic hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients. For this purpose, we selected 19 specific sequence polymorphisms belonging to 11 human biallelic loci located on 9 different chromosomes. Using a set of specially designed primers and fluorogenic probes, we evaluated the 19 markers' informativity on a panel of 126 DNA samples from 63 recipient/donor pairs. In more than 90% of these pairs, discrimination between recipient and donor genetic profile was possible. By using serial dilutions of mixed DNAs, we evaluated the linearity and sensitivity of the method. A linear correlation with r higher than 0.98 and a sensitivity of 0.1% proved reproducible. Fluorescent-based PCR of short tandem repeats (STR-PCR) and real-time PCR chimerism assay were compared with a panel of artificial cell mixtures. The main advantage of the real-time PCR method over STR-PCR chimerism assays is the absence of PCR competition and plateau biases, and results evidenced greater sensitivity and linearity with the real-time PCR method. Furthermore, different samples can be tested in the same PCR run with a final result in fewer than 48 hours. Finally, we prospectively analyzed patients who received allografts and present 4 different clinical situations that illustrate the informativity level of our method. In conclusion, this new assay provides an accurate quantitative assessment of mixed chimerism that can be useful in guiding early implementation of additional treatments in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation.

Leukaemic transformation of donor cells in a patient receiving a second allogeneic bone marrow transplant for severe aplastic anaemia

Allogeneic blood or bone marrow transplantation is a successful treatment for leukaemia and severe aplastic anaemia (SAA). Graft rejection following transplantation for leukaemia is a rare event but leukaemic relapse may occur at varying rates, depending upon the stage of leukaemia at which the transplant was undertaken and the type of leukaemia. Relapse is generally assumed to occur in residual host cells, which are refractory to, or escape from the myeloablative conditioning therapy. Rare cases have been described, however, in which the leukaemia recurs in cells of donor origin. Lack of a successful outcome of blood or bone marrow transplantation for severe aplastic anaemia (SAA), however, is due to late graft rejection or graft-versus-host disease. Leukaemia in cells of donor origin has rarely been reported in patients following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for SAA. This report describes leukaemic transformation in donor cells following a second allogeneic BMT for severe aplastic anaemia. PCR of short tandem repeats in bone marrow aspirates and in colonies derived from BFUE and CFU-GM indicated the donor origin of leukaemia. Donor leukaemia is a rare event following transplantation for severe aplastic anaemia but may represent the persistence or perturbation of a stromal defect in these patients inducing leukaemic change in donor haemopoietic stem cells.

Long-term follow-up of persisting mixed chimerism after partially T cell-depleted allogeneic stem cell transplantation

Using red cell phenotyping (RCP) and/or cytogenetics (CYT) we identified 19 patients with persisting mixed chimerism (MC) among 231 patients transplanted with partially T cell-depleted stem cell grafts from HLA-identical siblings. Persisting MC is defined as MC for more than 2 years in patients without any evidence of relapse. Median leukemia-free survival in these patients was 150 (range, 50-218) months. Diagnoses were ALL (n= 10); AML (n = 2); CML (n = 2); NHL (n = 2); MDS (n= 1); MM (n = 1) and SAA (n = 1). Purpose of this study was the long-term follow-up of MC and definition of patterns of chimerism in the various subsets of PBMCs and granulocytes. Using a PCR-STR technique CD3(+)/CD4(+) (T4 lymphocytes), CD3(+)/CD8(+) (T8 lymphocytes), CD45(+)/CD19(+) (B lymphocytes), CD45(+)/CD14(+) (monocytes), CD45(+)/CD15(+) (granulocytes) and CD3(-)/CD56(+) (NK-cells) were analyzed. The majority of patients with persisting MC were conditioned with a less intensive conditioning regimen and had little GVHD. Sequential monitoring of the chimerism resulted in a group of patients (n = 7) with very slow transient mixed chimerism that resulted in complete DC after median 7 years. Another nine patients had a relatively high percentage of persisting autologous cells for a median of 12 years and in three patients we observed a stable low percentage of autologous cells. Only two out of 19 patients (AML-CR1, CML-CP1) relapsed during follow-up. Both patients had a relatively high percentage of autologous cells. Chimerism in granulocytes and PBMC subsets was analyzed at a median of 8 years after SCT in nine patients. In five patients mixed chimerism simultaneously detected by RCP and CYT was associated with MC in all subsets. Within each individual patient the percentages of donor and recipient cells were very different between the different subsets. Two CML-CP1 patients were mixed chimera in only two subsets and in one patient these subsets represented pending relapse. In another two patients mixed chimerism with a very low number of autologous red cells was not found in the PBMCs because of the different sensitivity level of the RCP and the PCR-STR technique. We conclude that in patients with persisting mixed chimerism after partially T cell-depleted SCT a remarkable number of patients had lymphoid malignancies, the majority of the patients were conditioned with less intensive conditioning regimens and the mixed chimerism was not correlated with relapse. Chimerism in granulocytes and PBMC subsets did show great intra-individual differences in the subsets and these data correlated well with RCP and CYT data with the exception of the NK cells.

Leukemia lineage-specific chimerism analysis is a sensitive predictor of relapse in patients with acute myeloid leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome after allogeneic stem cell transplantation

One of the major complications after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT) in patients with malignant disease is a high frequency of relapse. We have prospectively analyzed the clinical impact of recipient-derived chimeric cells in 30 patients with acute myeloid leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome after SCT. In order to improve sensitivity and specificity, all samples were cell-separated by using immunomagnetic beads according to the patient's leukemia phenotype, expressed at diagnosis or relapse before SCT. Twelve out of 30 patients experienced a clinical relapse after SCT. Median follow-up time for patients alive and without relapse (n = 15) was 30 (16-47) months. Mixed chimerism in peripheral blood (PB) and bone marrow (BM) > or =1 month post SCT, in the leukemia-affected cell lineage, was detected in 14/30 patients. Ten of these 14 patients relapsed as compared to 2/16 with donor chimerism (DC) (P <0.01). All eight patients with MC in peripheral blood > or =1 month after SCT relapsed vs 4/22 DC patients (P < 0.001). MC was detected a median of 66 (23-332) days before hematological relapse. No correlation was found between T cell MC and relapse. In this study, chimerism analysis showed a higher sensitivity and specificity vs morphological examination. In conclusion, this study may provide a rational basis for treatment with adoptive immunotherapy at an earlier time after SCT than at present, in patients with AML and MDS, in order to treat recurrences of malignant disease.

Analysis of chimaerism in thalassaemic children undergoing stem cell transplantation

We have prospectively assessed the relative contribution of host and donor to haemopoiesis following stem cell transplantation (SCT) in children with beta-thalassaemia major (n = 35), using karyotype analysis or Southern blot/polymerase chain reaction analysis of variable number tandem repeats on genomic DNA from peripheral blood. Early haemopoiesis was fully donor in origin in 24 out of 35 cases and remained so throughout the post-transplant course in all but one patient, who evolved to stable mixed chimaerism. The remaining 11 cases (31%) initially showed mixed chimaerism: four of these rejected, one eventually eradicated host haemopoiesis to become fully donor haemopoietic, and the remaining six had persistent mixed chimaerism, with 5--38% host haemopoiesis. The risk of graft rejection was high when > 15% host haemopoiesis was present at 3 months post transplant: four out of six such patients rejected their grafts; conversely, zero out of 29 patients with < 15% host haemopoiesis at 3 months rejected (P < 0.0001). There was a higher incidence of significant acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease in patients with full donor chimaerism. These studies confirm that the mixed chimaeric state is common following SCT for thalassaemia, often persists (with up to 4 years follow-up) and is compatible with long-term cure. Analysis of chimaerism in patients undergoing SCT for beta-thalassaemia enables monitoring of engraftment in the early post-transplant period, provides insight into the biology of engraftment and may be useful in identifying patients at high risk of rejection.

Chimerism analysis by lineage-specific fluorescent polymerase chain reaction in secondary graft failure after allogeneic stem cell transplantation

BACKGROUND

Chimerism analysis is essential in understanding the etiology of graft failure occurring after allogeneic stem cell transplantation. The detection of marrow and/or blood host cells suggests graft rejection, relapse of the underlying disease, or a state of stable mixed chimerism. However, complete donor chimerism may be observed in some cases. Our objective was to characterize, by a sensitive process of chimerism analysis, six cases of graft failure occurring after transplant.

METHODS

Six cases of secondary graft failure, in which previous analysis had shown complete donor chimerism by standard polymerase chain reaction amplification of variable number of tandem repeats, were studied. In order to detect a minority population of recipient cells, we increased the sensitivity of the process by using fluorescent polymerase chain reaction and analyzing the origin of T, B, and natural killer lymphocytes at the time of graft failure.

RESULTS

The complete donor origin of mononuclear cells and lymphocytic populations was confirmed with this method in five of six patients. In the remaining patient, diagnosis of graft failure was clarified by the detection of a previously undetected mixed chimerism, compatible with graft rejection. In the other five patients, graft rejection was thereby excluded and graft failure could be related to viral infection or to graft-versus-host disease.

CONCLUSION

Our sensitive process of fluorescent lineage-specific chimerism analysis may help in distinguishing between graft rejection and other mechanisms of graft failure, which is essential for deciding appropriate therapy.

T cell mixed chimerism is significantly correlated to a decreased risk of acute graft-versus-host disease after allogeneic stem cell transplantation

BACKGROUND

It has been debated whether mixed chimerism (MC) is correlated to a decreased incidence of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT).

METHODS

Between September 1996 and April 1999 we analyzed 102 patients for MC in the T-cell fraction post allogeneic SCT, using PCR amplification of variable numbers of tandem repeat (VNTR) loci. All samples, taken regularly post SCT, were cell separated using anti-CD3 immunomagnetic beads.

RESULTS

T-cell mixed chimerism was detected in 58 out of 102 patients (57%). Patient characteristics were comparable in the T-cell MC- and donor chimeric-group (DC). The median follow-up time for the MC group was 714 days (range 58 - 1248) as compared to 427 days (range 45 - 1042) for the DC group. Overall probability of acute GVHD grades II-IV was significantly higher in the DC group as compared to the MC group (52% vs. 5%, P<0.001). In multivariate analysis T-cell DC proved to be the most significant risk factor for acute GVHD grades II-IV. The cumulative incidence of relapse, among patients with malignant disease, did not show any statistical difference between the T-cell MC patients and the DC-group. There was a tendency for better overall survival in the T-cell MC group compared to the DC group (2 yrs; 73% vs. 54%, P=0.06). Among DC patients, 14/20 (70%) deaths were due to GVHD versus none in the MC-group(P<0.001).

CONCLUSION

T-cell mixed chimerism was significantly correlated to a decreased risk of moderate to severe acute GVHD and death by GVHD.

Sequential monitoring of chimerism and detection of minimal residual disease after allogeneic blood stem cell transplantation (BSCT) using multiplex PCR amplification of short tandem repeat-markers

Sequential analysis of chimerism after allogeneic blood stem cell transplantation (BSCT) has been shown to be predictive for graft failure and relapse. We have explored the impact of a novel approach for the quantitative determination of chimerism using a commercial PCR assay with multiplex amplification of nine STR-loci and fluorescence detection. The feasibility was studied in 121 patients transplanted from related or unrelated donors. Follow-up investigation was performed in 88 patients. Twenty-eight of these patients had received a transplantation after dose-reduced conditioning therapy. Results were compared to data obtained by FISH analysis in a subgroup of patients receiving grafts from sex-mismatched donors. The analysis was possible in all patients, the median number of informative alleles was 4 (range 1-8) compared to 7 (range 1-9) in the related and unrelated situation, respectively. A good correlation was seen in 84 samples from 14 patients analyzed in parallel with STR-PCR and FISH. Decreasing values of donor chimerism were detected prior to or concomitantly with the occurrence of graft failure and relapse of disease in all patients investigated prospectively. Using FACS-sorted material, eg peripheral blood CD34+ cells, the assay permitted the detection of residual recipient cells with high sensitivity (down to one CD34+ Kasumi cell in 40,000 normal WBC). Evaluation of the inter-laboratory reproducibility revealed that in 20 samples analyzed in three different centers, the median coefficient of variation was 2.1% (range 0.7-9.6%). Taken together, the results support the use of the test as a valuable tool in the follow-up of patients undergoing allogeneic BSCT. In cases lacking PCR-detectable disease-specific gene products, this assay may represent an alternative to recently established real-time PCR methods.

Prediction and reversion of post-transplant relapse in patients with chronic myeloid leukemia using mixed chimerism and residual disease detection and adoptive immunotherapy

In the prospective study, we examined hematopoietic mixed chimerism (using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of variable number of tandem repeat-VNTR sequences) and minimal residual disease (MRD) status (using qualitative and in the case of positivity quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for the BCR/ABL fusion mRNA) in serial peripheral blood samples taken from 25 patients after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). Increasing mixed chimerism in correlation with increasing signal of MRD was detected in 10 patients. In two patients mixed chimera status and BCR/ABL rearrangement led to hematologic relapse, in five patients molecular relapse was followed by reappearance of Ph chromosome and three patients developed molecular relapse only. Adoptive immunotherapy-donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI), interferon (INF) and discontinuation of post-transplant immunosupression-separately or in different combinations was used in nine patients with molecular, cytogenetic or hematologic relapse of CML. The results demonstrate that significant response at the molecular level can be achieved for a majority of CML patients and that using of all forms of adoptive immunotherapy controlled by MC and MRD is more efficient in patients treated in early molecular relapse-with minimal disease burdens.

Characterization of lineage-specific chimaerism in patients with acute leukaemia and myelodysplastic syndrome after allogeneic stem cell transplantation before and after relapse

Recently, we have shown that patients with acute leukaemias and myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS), who showed increasing mixed chimaerism (MC) upon serial PCR analysis after transplant, have a significantly increased risk of relapse. To determine whether the increasing MC in these patients is caused by the reappearance of normal recipient haematopoiesis or by the reoccurrence of malignant cells, we purified different leucocyte subpopulations and analysed these subfractions with regard to their donor-recipient ratio by a PCR-based method for the analysis of minisatellite DNA regions. In 14 patients [eight acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL), three acute myelogenous leukaemia (AML) and three MDS] subfractions were analysed when increasing MC was first noted upon serial analysis of the peripheral blood. In seven of these 14 patients (four ALL, two AML and one MDS), subfractions were characterized at the time of frank haematological relapse. In all 14 patients investigated with increasing MC, recipient cells were detected in different mononuclear cell subpopulations. In patients characterized during frank relapse, two distinct distribution patterns were found. Patients who relapsed before day +300 (one ALL, two AML and one MDS) showed recipient-derived (normal) cells in addition to blast populations in different mononuclear subsets as well as granulocytes. In patients with acute leukaemias who relapsed after day +300 (two ALL and one AML), only leukaemic cells were found that were of recipient origin, whereas all other haematopoietic cell lines were donor derived. These data show that persistent MC in the early post-transplant period is caused predominantly by normal recipient haematopoietic cells. This finding further supports the hypothesis that a state of mixed haematopoietic chimaerism may reduce the clinical graft-versus-leukaemia (GVL) effect of alloreactive donor-derived effector cells in patients with acute leukaemias and MDS, and thus facilitate the proliferation of residual malignant cells that may have survived the preparative regimen.

Minimal residual disease is common after allogeneic stem cell transplantation in patients with B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia and may be controlled by graft-versus-host disease

Following allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT), we studied the presence of donor and recipient derived cells within the CD19+ B cell fraction, in patients with B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). The chimeric status of the six patients studied was further investigated with minimal residual disease (MRD) detection, by sequencing and using patient-specific primers derived from junctional regions of clonally rearranged immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) receptor genes. To date, five of six patients are alive with a median follow-up time of 24 months (range 15-60) post-SCT. All patients experienced acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease and responded clinically to SCT. All patients were MRD positive after SCT, which correlated to mixed chimerism within the CD19+ cell fraction in all samples except one (25/26). High levels of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and soluble interleukin-2 receptor (sIL-2R) indicated advanced disease, and patients with increased levels pre- and post-SCT were also those with the most long-lasting PCR-detectable MRD post-SCT. Hence, a high tumor burden pre-SCT may reflect the long duration of detectable MRD in patients with B-CLL after SCT. A durable anti-leukemic effect was probably important in these patients.

Evaluation of an automated technique for assessment of marrow engraftment after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation using a commercially available kit

Several methods have been used to evaluate engraftment after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). We assessed the usefulness of a multiple short tandem repeat (STR) amplification kit combined with a capillary electrophoresis unit for DNA identity analysis in the evaluation of engraftment after BMT. For 17 of 18 patients, at least 1 locus showed unique alleles for the donor and the recipient. In all cases, at least 1 locus was informative for the presence of small amounts of recipient DNA. The results from STR analysis were the same as Southern blot analysis in 14 of 17 cases. Differences included mixed chimerism detected only with STR analysis, informative loci present only with STR analysis, and informative loci present only with Southern blot analysis (1 case each). By using mock mixed chimeras, minor populations of 5% were detected routinely in all loci using the kit manufacturer's default protocol. By increasing the amount of amplified DNA, minor populations of 1% were detected in all cases but not in all loci. This single reaction technique provides for faster results, reduced workforce needs, and greater sensitivity than traditional Southern blot.

Kinetics of the Graft-Versus-Leukemia Response After Donor Leukocyte Infusions for Relapsed Chronic Myeloid Leukemia After Allogeneic Bone Marrow Transplantation

Little is known about the mechanisms and the kinetics of the so-called graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) response induced by donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI) in patients with leukemic relapse after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). We sought to elucidate this problem by sequentially studying three patients with relapsed chronic myeloid leukemia after sex-mismatched BMT from time before donor leukocyte infusion until achievement of complete molecular remission. Lineage-specific chimerism was assessed longitudinally by a combined fluorescent immunophenotyping and sex chromosome-specific in situ hybridization approach. Results were related to quantitative detection of bcr-abl transcripts by competitive differential reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), qualitative bcr-abl RT-PCR, and multiplex PCR-based DNA donor/recipient chimerism. All patients had predominant donor lymphopoiesis at the time of DLI, suggesting a state of tolerance to recipient leukemic and/or normal cells. In contrast, granulopoiesis and erythropoiesis were mainly recipient derived in both patients with hematologic relapse and partly recipient derived in the patient with molecular relapse. Eighty percent, 90%, and 8% of CD34+cells, respectively, were found to be of recipient origin at relapse, and few donor stem cells predicted for cytopenia post-DLI. Responses were seen after a time lag of 5 to 13 weeks after DLI and resulted in reversal to full donor chimerism within a critical switch period of 4 to 5 weeks. A sudden decrease in recipient cells was paralleled by a sharp decrease in bcr-abl transcript numbers detectable several weeks before achievement of molecular remission and onset of clinical graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). This response pattern was confirmed by retrospective RT-PCR analysis in an additional five patients. Prospective monitoring of stem cell chimerism and response may enable us to individually tailor adoptive immunotherapy in the future.

Kinetics of the Graft-Versus-Leukemia Response After Donor Leukocyte Infusions for Relapsed Chronic Myeloid Leukemia After Allogeneic Bone Marrow Transplantation

Little is known about the mechanisms and the kinetics of the so-called graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) response induced by donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI) in patients with leukemic relapse after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). We sought to elucidate this problem by sequentially studying three patients with relapsed chronic myeloid leukemia after sex-mismatched BMT from time before donor leukocyte infusion until achievement of complete molecular remission. Lineage-specific chimerism was assessed longitudinally by a combined fluorescent immunophenotyping and sex chromosome-specific in situ hybridization approach. Results were related to quantitative detection of bcr-abl transcripts by competitive differential reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), qualitative bcr-abl RT-PCR, and multiplex PCR-based DNA donor/recipient chimerism. All patients had predominant donor lymphopoiesis at the time of DLI, suggesting a state of tolerance to recipient leukemic and/or normal cells. In contrast, granulopoiesis and erythropoiesis were mainly recipient derived in both patients with hematologic relapse and partly recipient derived in the patient with molecular relapse. Eighty percent, 90%, and 8% of CD34+cells, respectively, were found to be of recipient origin at relapse, and few donor stem cells predicted for cytopenia post-DLI. Responses were seen after a time lag of 5 to 13 weeks after DLI and resulted in reversal to full donor chimerism within a critical switch period of 4 to 5 weeks. A sudden decrease in recipient cells was paralleled by a sharp decrease in bcr-abl transcript numbers detectable several weeks before achievement of molecular remission and onset of clinical graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). This response pattern was confirmed by retrospective RT-PCR analysis in an additional five patients. Prospective monitoring of stem cell chimerism and response may enable us to individually tailor adoptive immunotherapy in the future.

Comparative Study of FISH, PCR and Cytogenetics on 25 Patients Submitted to Bone Marrow Transplantation (BMT) for Chronic Myelogenous Leukemia (CML); Which Tests can we Use in Routine Analysis Post BMT?

Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia (CML) shows an excellent response to allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) with a 60-80% long term disease free survival in recipients of unmanipulate marrow. The most frequent cause of treatment failure is leukaemic relapse, due to the re-emergence of malignant recipient clones. Clinical and haematological relapse is usually preceded by molecular evidence of relapse. Early detection of molecular relapse may allow intervention with immunotherapy such as donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI). This study was undertaken to compare results from two centres who employ either Fluorescent In Situ Hybridisation (FISH) or polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of DNA polymorphisms as their routine method of detecting residual host cells following BMT for CML in order to establish (1) if these methods are equivalent for routine laboratory use in reporting of chimaerism results to the referring clinician, and (2) if these methods are beneficial for indicating new and early therapeutic strategies. FISH analyses for the X and Y chromosomes (in sex mismatched patients) and/or FISH for BCR and ABL loci were compared with short tandem repeat PCR (STR-PCR) and conventional karyotyping in serial analyses in 25 patients submitted to BMT for Philadelphia positive (Ph) CML. Comparison of all results on samples assessed between 1 and 13 years post BMT indicated that FISH and PCR, performed on the same bone marrow samples displayed similar results in more than 90% of patients in first 3 years after BMT which increased to a concordance rate of 100% in long term survivors. In contrast, comparison of FISH or PCR versus cytogenetic analysis indicated a low concordance rate, with less than 50% of samples showing similar results during all the follow-up period. Eighty percent of recipients (22 patients) had evidence of mixed chimaerism following BMT (initial level of positivity 1-6% recipient cells) during the follow-up period. This low percentage of recipient cells remained stable in 7 patients, while 9 patients reverted to a donor profile. All 16 patients are in haematological remission. In addition the 3 patients with complete donor chimaerism remain in remission. In the remaining 6 patients, a progressive increase in recipient cells occurred (progressive mixed chimaerism, PMC), and was followed by haematological relapse. We conclude that FISH and PCR can be used to monitor CML patients post BMT and transient or stable low level mixed chimaerism is not associated with leukaemia relapse, but PMC is predictive of imminent relapse and its detection may help to illucidate the timing of early intervention with donor lymphocyte infusion.

Early establishment of chimerism in the B and T lymphoid lineages after transplantation of allogeneic mobilized blood cells in leukemic patients

BACKGROUND

The use of allogeneic recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (rhG-CSF)-mobilized blood cells was recently evaluated in patients with malignancies.

METHODS

Ten patients with leukemia were transplanted with allogeneic blood cells from HLA-identical sex-mismatched siblings; blood cells were mobilized with recombinant rhG-CSF. Up to 6 months after transplantation, blood and bone marrow samples were obtained from the recipient and analyzed for the presence of donor cells, using fluorescence in situ hybridization with specific probes hybridizing to sex chromosomes.

RESULTS

Analysis of blood and bone marrow smears demonstrated a complete chimera, as early as day 15 after transplantation. Furthermore, marrow and blood CD4+, CD8+, CD19+, and CD34+ cells were sorted using direct immunofluorescence and flow cytometry: fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis on sorted cells demonstrated that most progenitors and most cells in the T- and B-cell lineages were of donor origin as early as day 15 after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Together with recently reported results, this study demonstrates that allogeneic rhG-CSF-mobilized blood cells contain primitive hematopoietic progenitors that can repopulate all lymphoid and myeloid lineages. Establishment of chimerism seems to be quick and stable, including the T- and B-cell lineages. Although establishment of chimerism in mitogen-responsive T cells is readily assayable with conventional cytogenetics, our study provides additional insight on the reconstitution of the B lineage and T-cell subsets after allogeneic transplantation in patients with leukemia.