Properties of murine anti-morphine antibodies

From outer to inner space: traveling along a scientific career from astrochemistry to drug research

This professional history describes my journey as a research scientist after my early training and experiences in the pre- and early post-World War II United States. My graduate training concentrated on a problem in astrochemistry: phenomena on comets. As my career developed, I felt confident enough in myself as an experimentalist to enter, and make contributions to, several different fields: structural biochemistry (via nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy), molecular immunology, pharmacology, neurochemistry, and cell biology. One emphasis is on the nature and quality of my scientific training that permitted me to do cross-disciplinary work. A second emphasis is on the technical and intellectual developments in late twentieth-century science and how, along with the changes in American society as it passed through three major wars, they influenced my life and thought.

Preparation and characterization of specific and high-affinity monoclonal antibodies against morphine

A C6-hemisuccinate derivative of morphine was prepared and conjugated to bovine serum albumin. High titer antibody producing spleen cells were removed and fused with myeloma cells of Sp2/0 origin. A C3-hemisuccinate derivative of morphine was prepared and conjugated to enzyme penicillinase used as a tracer molecule. A novel enzyme-linked immunoadsorbent assay was developed using this conjugate to screen and characterize the monoclonal antibody produced in these experiments. After two successive limiting dilutions, antibodies produced by 5 clones with good affinities ranging from 10(8) to 10(12) M(-1) and less cross-reaction (least for codeine and other structurally related molecules) were selected. These clones were found to be of IgG class with kappa light chain. Subclass determination showed that two of the clones produced IgG2b and three of them produced IgG1 type of antibody. Affinity purifications were performed for the selected clone (MOR-I). Purified antibody was coated onto the wells of microtiter plate. The standard curve was constructed with a sensitivity of 100 pg/mL covering up to 10 ng/mL in buffer and urine. The slope of the standard curve for selected clone in buffer and urine was calculated to be -0.7 and -0.64, respectively.

Monoclonal antibodies as surrogate receptors in a high throughput screen for compounds that enhance insulin sensitivity

Monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) were made to a known insulin sensitivity enhancer (ISE) compound, CS-045. The MoAbs were characterized with respect to binding other known thiazolidinedione ISE compounds using a CS-045 labeled with b-phycoerythrin in a competitive particle concentration fluorescence immunoassay (PCFIA). By comparing the rank order of IC50 values for each compound to its respective potency as an ISE, one MoAb (13E3) was selected for further characterization. This MoAb was also used as a surrogate receptor in a high throughput screen to identify novel compounds that compete for binding to CS-045. Some of the hits were found to have efficacy in reducing blood glucose. Subsequently, another group reported that several compounds with the core thiazolidinedione structure of the ISE compounds bound with high affinity to peroxisome proliferator-activating receptors (PPAR). Therefore, we used the MoAb assay to test these and other compounds that are known to bind to PPARgamma and noted crossreactivity with some of the compounds.

Recognition of superpotent sweetener ligands by a library of monoclonal antibodies

Monoclonal antibodies (mAb) made to the superpotent guanidino sweet tasting ligand, N-(p-cyanophenyl)-N'-(diphenylmethyl)-guanidineacetic acid were examined for their molecular recognition specificities using 14 different sweetener analogues in a competitive radioimmunoassay. The effects of variations in pH on ligand binding was also examined by radioimmunoassay. Photoaffinity labelling of the binding site was accomplished using a radiolabelled azido-derivative of the parent ligand, and L-chain or H-chain labelling was easily identified in several different mAb. For two of the mAb examined in this study (NC6.8 and NC10.14), the analogue binding studies are in agreement with the known Fab-ligand crystal structures. Monoclonal antibodies to this family of sweet tasting compounds may be useful probes for the study of sweet taste chemistry and identification of novel sweet taste ligands from combinatorial chemical libraries.

Mimics of the binding sites of opioid receptors obtained by molecular imprinting of enkephalin and morphine

Molecular imprinting of morphine and the endogenous neuropeptide [Leu5]enkephalin (Leu-enkephalin) in methacrylic acid-ethylene glycol dimethacrylate copolymers is described. Such molecular imprints possess the capacity to mimic the binding activity of opioid receptors. The recognition properties of the resultant imprints were analyzed by radioactive ligand binding analysis. We demonstrate that imprinted polymers also show high binding affinity and selectivity in aqueous buffers. This is a major breakthrough for molecular imprinting technology, since the binding reaction occurs under conditions relevant to biological systems. The antimorphine imprints showed high binding affinity for morphine, with Kd values as low as 10(-7) M, and levels of selectivity similar to those of antibodies. Preparation of imprints against Leu-enkephalin was greatly facilitated by the use of the anilide derivative rather than the free peptide as the print molecule, due to improved solubility in the polymerization mixture. Free Leu-enkephalin was efficiently recognized by this polymer (Kd values as low as 10(-7) M were observed). Four tetra- and pentapeptides, with unrelated amino acid sequences, were not bound. The imprints showed only weak affinity for two D-amino acid-containing analogues of Leu-enkephalin. Enantioselective recognition of the L-enantiomer of phenylalanylglycine anilide, a truncated analogue of the N-terminal end of enkephalin, was observed.

Association constants of monoclonal antibodies for hapten: heterogeneity of frequency distribution and possible relationship with hapten molecular weight

Using published data, we have investigated the relationship of the association constant (Ka) of 265 MAbs for haptens with molecular weights ranging from 111 to 1202 Da. The study indicates that: (1) differences of a factor 10(3)-10(5) are frequently found between the lowest and the highest value of Ka for the same hapten; (2) the relationship between log Ka and the hapten molecular weight of either the native drug or the molecular entity used for the Ka determination is described by a hyperbolic function; (3) beyond a critical molecular weight of approximately 300-325 Da, the log Ka reaches a plateau at a maximal value near 10(-12) M-1.

Elicitation of a predominantly lambda light chain-bearing antibody response in BALB/c mice to a novel bifunctional aminocarboxylate chelating agent

A panel of murine monoclonal antibodies has been raised against the aminocarboxylate bifunctional chelating agent PA-DOTA complexed with Samarium. Ninety percent of the antibodies (43 of 48) used a lambda light chain. The binding specificity of 11 of the antibodies was examined by competition assays using several structurally related aminocarboxylate chelating agents containing different metals. Most of the antibodies are directed against the macrocycle ring of PA-DOTA and require the presence of a metal within the structure for binding.

Characterization of morphine-specific monoclonal antibodies showing minimal cross-reactivity with codeine

Six murine monoclonal antibodies against morphine were produced using N-(4-aminobutyl)normorphine as a hapten. Most of the antibodies obtained distinguished the substituents at the 3 and 6 positions of morphine. This property of the antibodies led to a reduction in cross-reactivity with codeine, morphine-3-glucuronide (M-3-G) and morphine-6-glucuronide (M-6-G) to negligible levels. However, one of the antibodies distinguished the substituent only at the 3 position of morphine, which cross-reacted with M-6-G, naloxone and naltrexone. In the competitive inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, morphine was detected at concentrations as low as circa 100 pg/ml.

Molecular and biochemical analyses of combining sites of monoclonal anti-morphine antibodies

V region nucleotide sequences were determined by mRNA sequencing for 11 monoclonal anti-morphine antibodies with slightly different specificities for morphine-related opiates. The VH region nucleotide sequences of the antibodies MOR8, MOR33, MOR35, MOR44, MOR83, and MOR76 were classified into the VH-5 (7183) family, while the antibodies MOR39, MOR115, MOR131, MOR158 and MOR180 used VH-1 (J558) family genes. MOR39, MOR115 and MOR131 used the V lambda-1 gene for their L chain V region. MOR158 and MOR180 used the Vk-10 gene. MOR8, MOR33, OR35, MOR44, MOR76 and MOR83 used VK-21D. The antibody sets MOR158 and MOR180; MOR39 and MOR131; and MOR8, MOR33, MOR35, MOR44, MOR76 and MOR83 appeared to be somatic mutants derived from the same clones since they showed the same VH/VL usage and V(D)J recombination pattern. The pH-reactivity profiles for these antibodies revealed that the binding of morphine to the antibodies is highly dependent on the pH value of the assay solution, suggesting the importance of the electrostatic interaction between the positive charge of morphine and the negative charges at or near the combining sites. Direct UV-photoaffinity labeling with 3H-morphine was carried out in order to estimate the orientation of morphine in the combining sites. The H chains were preferentially labeled in MOR8, MOR33, MOR35, MOR76, and MOR83, whereas most of the crosslinked hapten was found in the L chains in MOR39, MOR115, MOR131, MOR158 and MOR180. Thus, these 11 antibodies were classified into two types in terms of reactivity in the photoaffinity labeling.

Two- and three-dimensional distributions of opioid receptors on NG108-15 cells visualized with the aid of fluorescence confocal microscopy and anti-idiotypic antibodies

Polyclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies previously shown to be specific for mu- and delta-opioid receptor subclasses on rat brain membrane preparations using radioreceptor assays have been labeled with fluorescent conjugates of avidin. The resulting complexes have been used to study the distribution and properties of opioid receptors on living and fixed NG108-15 cells using normal fluorescence, and confocal fluorescence, microscopy. From the confocal data three-dimensional views of immunofluorescent distributions have been obtained using a computer transformation of the data. From experiments involving co-incubation with media containing naloxone, selective opioid peptides and stereoisomeric synthetic opioid analogs as blocking agents, the specificity and stereospecificity of immunofluorescent binding is reported. The effects on immunofluorescent binding by co-incubation with media containing a sulfhydryl reagent, 100 mM-NaCl and sodium azide are also reported. The results have implications concerning the use of immunoprecipitation in the biochemical isolation of the receptors. Finally, the confocal two-dimensional sections and two-dimensional reconstructions obtained from fixed cells show internal immunofluorescence in the form of cytoplasmic clusters. The reagents and methods should be applicable to visualizing native opioid receptor distributions on neurons.

Kinetics of haloperidol binding to monoclonal antibodies as measured by direct fluorescence quenching

Monoclonal antibodies which bind small neurogenic ligands may mimic certain aspects of the stereospecific binding present in the natural biological receptor, and may prove useful in designing engineered protein receptors, provided their interactions are correctly understood. We report here the kinetic and equilibrium characteristics of ligand-antibody complexes of haloperidol, a dopaminergic antagonist, with three of its monoclonal antibodies as studied by fluorescence quenching techniques. These antibodies possessed moderate to high affinity constants, ranging from 10(5) to 10(9) M-1, and caused fluorescence quenching of a fluorescein-labeled haloperidol as well as quenching (40-60%) of the internal tryptophan fluorescence. The dissociation rates of the ligand from the complexes were measured at different conditions of temperature, pH and ionic strength. The results provide important information regarding the kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of the binding pockets of these antibodies.

Direct production of Fv-fragments from a family of monoclonal IgGs papain digestion

Fv fragments of four monoclonal antibodies specific for morphine binding have been produced from their divalent IgG forms by papain digestion using the classic procedure for Fab formation. The binding characteristics of one of the Fv fragments have been determined relative to the intact antibody by equilibrium dialysis. Its dissociation constant is a factor of five lower than the IgG. Previous work had resulted in the sequences of each the chains for the four Fv fragments. The light chains are all from the highly homologous lambda subclass while the gamma heavy chains are closely related except for their CDR regions. In this work optical molar extinction coefficients are predicted from amino acid sequences for each of the fragments. It is found that they differ significantly from each other and from the commonly used value for intact IgG. Detailed comparisons between our results and those reported previously on the molecular masses of Fv-derived light and heavy chains and hapten-Fv dissociation constants are given based on analytical gel electrophoresis and electroblotting experiments using dye and immunovisualization techniques. Isoelectric focusing experiments have been performed and the pIs obtained are compared to those predicted theoretically from the chain sequences. Gel filtration column chromatography, acrylamide gel electrophoresis and equilibrium dialysis experiments are consistent with significant aggregation of the Fv fragments in neutral solution with accompanying inactivation of the binding site. Comparison of sequences for the Fv light and heavy chains are made with those which have been proposed to be important for chain dimer association and for canonical hypervariable regions. This methods of Fv production is not regarded as a general one. However, it may be an approach which is general to lambda chain containing antibodies.

Binding of the neuroleptic drug haloperidol to a monoclonal antibody: refinement of the binding site molecular model using canonical structures

The ligand binding site of a monoclonal antibody (185), which binds the neuroleptic drug haloperidol, has been modelled using canonical structures and energy minimization techniques. This refined modelling protocol has allowed us to predict the variable region loop conformations. Three key residues, H:50(W), H:100a(D) and L:96(Y) appear to create the basis of the electrostatic, pi-pi stacking interactions and hydrogen bonding required for the high affinity binding site characteristics present in this antibody. The use of computer-aided graphics techniques and appropriate three-dimensional modelling permits inspection of the predicted molecular recognition features of the ligand binding site.

A glass-fiber filtration assay for solution phase hapten-antibody binding. Effect of surface treatment with a polycation

Radioligands bound to murine monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies in solution are rapidly and effectively separated from free ligand by filtration through either untreated or polyethylenimine (PEI)-pretreated glass-fiber filters. Ligand binding to selected anti-morphine monoclonal antibodies, determined by filtration through untreated filters, was significantly greater (1.5-3.0-fold) than the binding activities obtained by gel filtration. However, radioactivity retained by filters that were pretreated with PEI (pH 4) was essentially the same as that obtained using the Sephadex G-25 short-column assay. The pH dependence of the retention on the coated fibers suggests that the mechanism of binding of antibodies to glass is different from that to the PEI-treated surfaces. The quantitative aspects of the assay are reported. The method should prove useful where quantitative, rapid and inexpensive binding radioassays need to be performed.

Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of flexible opiate conformations at monoclonal antibody binding sites. Quantitative interproton distances obtained from comparing theoretical and experimental transferred nuclear Overhauser enhancement: correlation with antibody sequence

A previous publication described the use of qualitative intramolecular 1H-transferred nuclear Overhauser effect measurements to determine the conformations of flexible ligands at monoclonal anti-opiate antibody binding sites. This paper concentrates on the quantitative interpretation of experiments of this type using the ligand nalorphine (N-allyl morphine) and a single anti-opiate monoclonal antibody. I compare the experimental unidimensional driven nuclear Overhauser effect buildup curves to theoretical curves derived with a knowledge of the fixed interproton distances in the ligand. The discussion covers the potential accuracies of derived distances and concentrates on two problem areas associated with determining structures from this type of experiment. The most serious one is the case where, because of particular multiproton spatial distributions, spin diffusion is so rapid that it cannot be determined experimentally and where numerical fits of theoretical calculations are misleading. The results show that, while intraligand spin diffusion complicates the interpretation for some proton pairs, with many others accuracies within about 0.3 A for interproton distances from 2 to 4 A are attainable. The results confirm the earlier report that the conformation of nalorphine in this antibody binding site differs from the major one present in solution or in the crystal. An important aspect of the work is that theoretical prediction of nuclear Overhauser effect time-dependence is an important practical tool for recognizing cases where interpretation of experiments will be difficult. Initial data on protein-to-ligand transferred nuclear Overhauser effect are presented, which show that at least one aromatic amino acid residue is closely involved in the binding of the ligand. The companion paper presents the primary sequences of the variable regions of the antibodies being used in our studies. In this paper, these and associated immunochemical studies are correlated with the nuclear magnetic resonance results. The combination of data presented in the two papers provides a basis for future work on protein-ligand interproton distances in the range 1 to 5 A using both transferred nuclear Overhauser effect (for rapidly exchanging ligands) and isotope-edited, indirectly detected nuclear Overhauser effect (for tightly bound ligands).

Comparative sequence and immunochemical analyses of murine monoclonal anti-morphine antibodies

A more complete characterization is given for four previously reported anti-morphine monoclonal antibodies that bind the hapten with high affinity and to which anti-idiotypic antibodies have been raised that mimic opiates at receptor binding sites. The variable (V) region nucleotide sequences of the heavy (H) and light (L) chains of these murine antibodies have been determined by direct sequencing of the poly(A)+ mRNAs using specific oligonucleotide primers and dideoxynucleotide chain-termination, and the deduced amino acid sequences are compared. The primary sequences predicted for the VH segments of 10C3 and 11C7 antibodies are closely associated with the VHIIIB subgroup of mouse H-chain (80 to 82% homology), while those for the V-regions of 3B9 and 12D4 H-chains correlate well with the VHIIC subgroup (64 to 67% homology). The 11C7, 10C3, 3B9 and 12D4 hybridoma cell lines use JH1, JH2, JH3 and JH4 DNA segments, respectively. Since considerable variations in length and primary sequence in the CDR3 (complementarity determining region) peptides of all the H-chains are evident, conservation of the D-region structure does not appear to be necessary for effective hapten binding. However, sequence homologies of the CDR2 regions of all the antibodies indicate that residues Glu H-50, Ile H-51, Pro H-52a and Tyr H-59 are conserved, and that these segments may be more critically involved in binding than the other H and L-chain hypervariable regions. The marked VL sequence homology, greater than 93%, among the L-chains and consensus lambda sequence, suggests derivation from a similar or identical VL germ-line gene. The L-chain J-region peptides for all the antibodies are classified JL1 and no VL-JL junctional diversity was apparent. The antimorphine antibody L-chains are apparently generated by the joining of a specific J-gene segment to a single germ-line V-gene segment, and minor sequence variations are the result of somatic mutations within the coding region. The leader sequence for one of the H-chains was determined. The inhibition of morphine binding by phenoxybenzylation or iodination of the affinity-purified immunoglobulins indicates the involvement of a single tyrosyl residue within or close to the antibody-combining site for the opiate. This conclusion is supported by the sequence data and nuclear magnetic resonance measurements reported in the accompanying paper, in which the results are used to interpret nuclear magnetic resonance measurements on one of the ligand-antibody systems. The possible importance of additional contact amino acids, tryptophan, aspartic and/or glutamic acids, is discussed.

Production and characterization of high-affinity monoclonal antibodies against morphine

Twelve hybridoma cell lines producing MAbs against morphine were established by using morphine hemisuccinate-conjugated bovine serum albumin as an immunogen. The MAbs belonged to the IgG1 subclass with kappa- or lambda-chains. The association constants of the antibodies ranged from 4.6 x 10(8) to 4.7 x 10(10) (M-1). These antibodies revealed slightly different cross-reactivities with various agonistic opiates and antagonists. In general, the antibodies were strongly cross-reactive with the opiate agonists, codeine, ethylmorphine, dihydromorphine and dihydrocodeine, while their cross-reactivities with norcodeine and the opiate antagonists, naloxone and naltrexone, were weak. The cross-reactivities with dihydromorphinone, dihydrocodeinone, naloxone, naltrexone, dextromethorphan and homatropine varied from clone to clone. Interestingly, certain MAbs displayed weak but significant cross-reactivities with the synthetic opiate, meperidine. However, none of the antibodies was cross-reactive with the opioid peptides, beta-endorphin, Met-enkephalin, and D-Ala2-D-Leu5-enkephalinamide. Radioimmunoassay for morphine using one of the antibodies (MOR 131.5.13) was shown to be sufficiently sensitive (IC50 = 0.1 nM) for the purposes of forensic analysis of morphine. This set of monoclonal anti-opiate antibodies is assumed to be suitable for analyzing the structure-function relationship in the hapten-antibody interaction, since the antibodies revealed similar but not identical cross-reactivities with various morphine related compounds.

NMR studies of flexible opiate conformations at monoclonal antibody binding sites. I. Transferred nuclear Overhauser effects show bound conformations

500 MHz H, homonuclear, intra-molecular, transferred Nuclear Overhauser Effect measurements have been performed on the bound forms of a classical opiate antagonist, nalorphine and an agonist, levorphanol at their respective binding sites in two different specific anti-opiate monoclonal antibody fragments. Based upon previous studies of opiate conformations in solution the results clearly show without extensive interpretation that one of these flexible haptens has the opposite (from solution) isomeric conformation in its bound form. For nalorphine the axial isomer of the N-allyl substituent is the bound form whereas in solution the equatorial isomer dominates at a ratio of 5:1. For levorphanol the bound form is that of equatorial N-methyl in accord with the low energy conformation in solution. In this preliminary report we discuss the initial measurements and results and their implications with respect to the conformations of flexible ligands at macromolecular binding sites including opiate receptors.

Attempts to obtain anti(D2 dopamine receptor) antibodies via the anti-idiotypic route

Five stable hybridomas have been obtained that secrete monoclonal antibodies against the D2-dopamine receptor-selective drug spiperone. Each monoclonal antibody has been characterized in terms of its ability to bind a range of dopamine-receptor-selective ligands. One monoclonal antibody has been purified by Protein A affinity chromatography and used to immunize mice. Anti-idiotypic antisera and one hybridoma secreting an anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody were obtained and shown to inhibit [3H]spiperone binding to the anti-spiperone antibody used for immunization. Neither the antisera nor the anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody, however, inhibited binding of [3H]spiperone to D2-dopamine receptors.

Morphine-mimetic anti-paratypic antibodies: cross-reactive properties

Polyclonal, anti-idiotypic, rabbit antibodies have been raised against four murine monoclonal anti-morphine Fab fragments. The antibody preparations, after affinity purification, have been shown to contain an anti-paratypic fraction which reversibly inhibits morphine binding to the anti-morphine antibodies and to cellular opiate receptors. Using some of the unique properties of this system, for the first time cross-reactivities of anti-paratypic antibodies with the monoclonal anti-morphine IgGs have been examined including competition for the same binding sites by a classical opiate agonist/antagonist pair.

Morphine and other opiates from beef brain and adrenal

We describe nonpeptide opioids found in extracts of beef hypothalamus and adrenal, which are recognized by antisera raised against morphine. Four have been purified to homogeneity. One is morphine. The structures of the other three have not been determined yet. None of them are derived from morphine or normorphine after extraction from the tissues. It is not known whether the opiates described here are of endogenous or exogenous origin.

Rabbit anti-idiotypic antibodies raised against monoclonal anti-morphine IgG block mu & delta opiate receptor sites

Rabbit antibodies have been raised against murine monoclonal anti-morphine Fab fragments. Following affinity purification, these antibodies competitively inhibit morphine binding to anti-morphine monoclonal antibodies, yet do not recognize normal mouse IgGs, suggesting that the antibodies produced are anti-idiotypic with respect to the anti-morphine IgG. More importantly, the purified antibodies competitively inhibit binding of morphine, naloxone, and D-ala-2-D-leu-5-enkephalin to rat brain opiate receptors.