Molecular dosimetry of chemical mutagens. Measurement of molecular dose and DNA repair in mammalian germ cells

Spermiogenic Germ Cell Phase-Specific DNA Damage Following Cyclophosphamide Exposure

The production of genetically competent spermatozoa is essential for normal embryo development. The chemotherapeutic drug cyclophosphamide creates cross-links and DNA strand breaks in many cell types, including germ cells. This study assessed the phase specificity of the susceptibility of spermiogenic germ cells to genetic damage induced by cyclophosphamide. Adult male rats were given cyclophosphamide using one of four schedules: 1) high dose/acute- day 1, 100 mg/kg; 2) low dose/subchronic, 4 days-days 1-4, 6.0 mg/kg/d; 3) high dose/subchronic, 4 days-day 1, 100 mg/kg, and days 2-4, 50 mg/kg/d; and 4) low dose/chronic-daily, 6.0 mg/kg/d for 14-28 days. To capture cauda epididymal spermatozoa exposed to cyclophosphamide during late, mid-, and early spermiogenesis, animals were sacrificed on days 14, 21, and 28, respectively. Spermatozoa were analyzed for DNA strand breaks using the comet assay. No dramatic increases in damage were seen after high-dose/acute exposure to cyclophosphamide. Subchronic exposure showed a dose-related increase in DNA damage; maximal damage, as demonstrated by comet tail parameters, was seen after 21 days, reflecting an increased susceptibility of step 9-14 spermatids. Low-dose chronic exposure to cyclophosphamide induced DNA damage, which reached a plateau by day 21. The magnitude of damage at all time points after low-dose chronic exposure was much greater than that following low-dose exposure for 4 days, indicating an accumulation of damage over time. Thus, the DNA damage induced by cyclophosphamide is germ cell phase-specific. The most damaging effects of cyclophosphamide occurred during a key point of sperm chromatin remodeling (histone hyperacetylation and transition protein deposition). We speculate that strand breaks disrupt chromatin remodeling, hence affecting chromatin structure and embryo development.

Unexpected identification of two interstitial deletions in a patient with a pericentric inversion of a chromosome 4 and an abnormal phenotype

Interstitial deletions and pericentric inversions of chromosome 4 appear to be unusual phenomena. Here, we report the case of a 14-year-old boy with severe psychomotor retardation with a de novo 46,XY,der(4)del(p15.2p15.31)inv(4)(p15.2q13.3)del(4)(q13.2q13.2) karyotype. We used FISH analysis with YAC and BAC clones to characterise the inversion's breakpoints. A complex event with six breakpoints was found, characterised by a pericentric inversion and two deletions, the first on the short arm of chromosome 4 (4p) and the second on the long arm of chromosome 4 (4q). The deletion events had removed two segments, one of approximately 5 Mb, from 4p, outside the inversion, and the other 2 Mb from 4q, inside the inversion. These rearrangements were not found in the parents. Microsatellite marker analysis showed that the inversion carrying chromosome 4 was derived from the father. Bioinformatic analysis of the human genome sequence allowed us to identify several hemizygotic genes in the patient, which might be involved in the pathogenesis of this clinical phenotype.

Evaluation of chromosome breakage and DNA integrity in sperm: an investigation of remote semen collection conditions

Collection of ejaculated semen at a remote site (outside of the laboratory) would facilitate participation rates and geographic diversity in reproductive epidemiology studies. Our study addressed concerns that remote collection and overnight mail return might induce chromosome/DNA damage. We collected semen from 10 healthy men. Part of each sample was snap frozen in liquid nitrogen and the rest held at 22 +/- 1 degrees C for 24 hours in a transport container (simulating ambient temperature during overnight return) then snap frozen. DNA breakage and fragmentation were measured using tandem-label sperm-fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end-labeling (TUNEL), and neutral comet assay. Tandem-label sperm-FISH and TUNEL detected no statistically significant difference between sperm fresh frozen (FF) and those frozen after 24 hours (F24). The mean frequency of chromosome breakage per 10 000 cells scored in sperm-FISH for FF and F24 was 10.5 +/- 1.3 breaks and 11.2 +/- 1.1 breaks, respectively (P =.69, Student's t test). The mean frequency of TUNEL-positive cells per 2000 cells scored in FF and F24 was 136 +/- 29 and 213 +/- 28 cells, respectively, which approached but did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.07, Student's t test). The neutral comet assay detected a statistically significant difference in DNA strand breakage between the 2 groups (percentage of DNA in the tail P = 0.037; tail moment P = 0.006; and tail length P = 0.033, all Student's t test). The mean frequency of damage denoted by tail length in micro m per 100 cells scored in FF and F24 was 175.0 +/- 15.5 and 152.2 +/- 17.6 micro m, respectively. Tandem-label sperm-FISH, TUNEL, and neutral comet assay are useful analytical techniques for laboratory-based studies of human sperm genomic integrity; however, for field studies incorporating the nonrefrigerated return of semen after 24 hours, only chromosome breakage at a level that can be detected using tandem-label sperm-FISH was unaffected. TUNEL and neutral comet assay need further study before they are used in specimens collected at remote sites and transported to a central laboratory.

Multicolor FISH analysis of chromosomal breaks, duplications, deletions, and numerical abnormalities in the sperm of healthy men

Transmitted de novo structural chromosomal abnormalities, the majority of which are paternally derived, can lead to abnormal reproductive outcomes as well as genetic diseases in offspring. We developed and validated a new multicolor FISH procedure (sperm ACM, which utilizes DNA probes specific for the alpha [1cen], classical, [1q12], and midi [1p36.3] satellites of chromosome 1) which utilizes DNA probes specific for three regions of chromosome 1 to detect human sperm that carry numerical abnormalities plus two categories of structural aberrations: (1) duplications and deletions of 1pter and 1cen, and (2) chromosomal breaks within the 1cen-1q12 region. In healthy men, the average frequencies of sperm with duplications and deletions were (a) 4.5 +/- 0.5 and 4.1 +/- 1.3 per 10(4) involving 1pter and (b) 0.9 +/- 0.4 and 0.8 +/- 0.3 per 10(4) involving 1cen, respectively. The frequency of sperm exhibiting breaks within the 1cen-1q12 region was 14.1 +/- 1.2 per 10(4). Structural aberrations accounted for 71% of the abnormalities detected by sperm ACM, which was significantly higher than numerical abnormalities (P=2x10-8). Our findings also suggest that, for healthy men, (a) sperm carrying postmeiotic chromosomal breaks appear to be more prevalent than those carrying products of premeiotic or meiotic breakage or rearrangements, (b) the high frequency of chromosome breaks measured after "fertilization" by the hamster-egg cytogenetic method already appear to be present and detectable within human sperm by FISH, and (c) there are nonrandom and donor-specific distributions of breakpoint locations within 1q12 in sperm. FISH facilitates the analysis of much larger numbers of sperm than was possible when the hamster-egg method was used. Therefore, FISH-based procedures for simultaneously detecting chromosomal breaks, rearrangements, and numerical abnormalities in sperm may have widespread applications in human genetics, genetic toxicology, and reproductive medicine.

Influence of p53 zygosity on select sperm parameters of the mouse

The influence of p53 gene zygosity on select parameters of mouse sperm was investigated by employing knock-out animal models. The background incidence of sperm shape abnormalities, total sperm count, and DNA double strand breaks were determined in p53 nullizygous (-/-) and heterozygous (+/-) mice and these estimates were compared to the corresponding measures in p53 wild-type (+/+) and the inbred C57Bl6 mouse strains. There were no qualitative differences in the incidence of sperm shape abnormalities and sperm counts regardless of p53 zygosity. However, the number of DNA double strand breaks, as measured by the comet assay, were significantly lower in the p53 knock-out mice. This apparent decrease was interpreted to be the result of a possible change in DNA-protein and/or DNA-DNA cross-linking in the germ cells of the knock-out mice. These data show that there is no evidence of increased incidence of gross alterations in spermatogenesis (no significant loss in sperm production nor any increase in the proportion of abnormal sperm produced) in knock-out mice deficient or absent in p53 protein; however, there appear to be changes at the genomic level where the degree of cross-linking was apparently elevated in DNA from p53 nullizygous and heterozygous mice.

DNA damage in human and mouse spermatozoa after in vitro-irradiation assessed by the comet assay

The comet assay is widely employed as a method to measure DNA damage in a wide variety of cell types following genotoxic insult. We have used this method in order to characterise DNA damage in spermatozoa following in vitro irradiation with 137Cs gamma rays. In contrast to somatic cells, the DNA of mammalian spermatozoa is bound by protamine molecules allowing a sixfold more highly compact structure and thus rendering conventional cell lysis protocols ineffective. Therefore, this new method uses an extensive lysis step to ensure effective removal of DNA-associated proteins allowing DNA damage to be scored reproducibly in both murine and human spermatozoa. Mouse spermatozoa collected from the vas deferens at post-mortem or human spermatozoa provided by donors were irradiated with doses of gamma-rays from 0-100 Gy using a 137Cs source and then processed for both alkaline and neutral comet assays. Under neutral electrophoresis conditions, which permits the measurement of double-stranded DNA breaks, a linear increase in the amount of DNA damage measured was observed with increasing radiation dose for both murine and human spermatozoa. Similarly, using alkaline electrophoresis conditions to examine DNA single-strand breaks and alkali-labile sites, a linear relationship was also observed for murine sperm but in contrast no such relationship was apparent for human spermatozoa subjected to the same radiation treatments. Interestingly, unirradiated sperm (both human and mouse) showed extensive DNA migration from the nucleus after alkaline assay. Since it is unlikely that the DNA of normal spermatozoa contains high numbers of single-strand breaks and damage was not detected for unirradiated sperm in the neutral assay, it is more likely that this DNA migration is due to the presence of high numbers of alkali labile sites within sperm DNA and that these may be related to the highly condensed structure of spermatozoal DNA. The large radiation doses used in these experiments to produce measurable amounts of DNA damage reflects the high radioresistance of spermatozoa compared to somatic cells and this may also be related to the differences in DNA packaging and conformation. In conclusion, this work shows that the comet assay represents a new method for examining DNA damage in spermatozoa and should be evaluated for use in reproductive toxicity testing.

Flavonoids modulate comet assay responses to food mutagens in human lymphocytes and sperm

The flavonoids, silymarin, myricetin, quercitin, kaempferol, rutin and kaempferol-3-rutinoside have been examined in combination with the food mutagens, 3-amino-1-methyl-5H-pyrido (4,3-b)indole (Trp-P-2) and 2-amino-3-methylimidazo-(4,5-f) quinoline (IQ), in the Comet assay in human lymphocytes from donor A and human sperm from donor B. These compounds alone have been shown to produce positive responses in the Comet assay, as have the food mutagens. However, in combination with the food mutagens, the flavonoids produced antigenotoxic effects since DNA damage was reduced in the Comet assay in lymphocytes and sperm. The assays were performed in the absence of metabolic activation, since when quercetin and kaempferol were examined in blood with metabolic activation, there was little or no difference in response to that obtained in its absence. In the blood, there was an exacerbation or synergy of response at the lowest doses of the flavonoids. In the sperm, with silymarin, myricetin and quercitin, antigenotoxic effects only were observed, but with kaempferol, in general, there were no protective effects. The food mutagen, 2-amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimadazo (4,5-b)pyridine (PhIP), was also examined in addition to Trp-P-2 and IQ in combination with silymarin and myricetin in donors A and C in human lymphocytes only. Similar exacerbation of effects were found at low doses of these flavonoids with antigenotoxic effects at high doses. This was confirmed in the Ames test. There were slightly different profiles in lymphocytes and sperm, but antigenotoxic effects were observed over a similar dose range. This would suggest that effects occur in somatic and germ cells on a one-to-one ratio. These results have implications for man in terms of risk assessment and in the modulation of isolated food constituents.

Induction and repair of DNA single-strand breaks and DNA base damage at different cellular stages of spermatogenesis of the hamster upon in vitro exposure to ionizing radiation

Alkaline elution has been used for quantitative detection of DNA damage caused by ionizing radiation in unlabeled somatic and germ cells. Both the induction and subsequent repair have been studied for two classes of DNA damage, viz. single-strand breaks (SSB), and base damage (BD) recognized by the gamma-endonuclease activity in a cell-free extract of Micrococcus luteus bacteria. The high sensitivity of the assay permitted the measurement of induction and repair of SSB and BD after in vitro exposure of hamster germ cells in different cellular stages of spermatogenesis (spermatocytes, round and elongated spermatids), and of bone-marrow cells, to biologically relevant doses (0-8 Gy) of 60Co gamma-rays. A dose-dependent increase was observed for both types of lesions, which was similar for most cell types. The elongated spermatids, however, showed a lower induction frequency of SSB (and perhaps BD). Spermatocytes, round spermatids and bone-marrow cells had normal, fast repair of the SSB when compared with the repair reported for cultured rodent cells and human lymphocytes. In contrast, the elongated spermatids showed hardly any SSB repair. The initial rate of repair of BD in spermatocytes and bone-marrow cells was in the same range as that for SSB, but only 60-70% of the initial BD was repaired within 1 h, whereas after that period no SSB were detectable. The round spermatids hardly repaired any BD within the first hour after irradiation, but after 7 h only a few BD could be detected. In elongated spermatids repair of BD could not be measured due to a high background level of this type of damage.

Immunochemical detection of DNA damage induction and repair at different cellular stages of spermatogenesis of the hamster after in vitro or in vivo exposure to ionizing radiation

An immunochemical method has been used to detect quantitatively DNA damage caused by ionizing radiation in germ cells. With this method, DNA strand breaks as well as lesions converted into breaks in alkaline medium are measured as a function of controlled partial unwinding of the DNA, a time-dependent process starting at each breakage site, followed by the determination of the relative amount of single-stranded regions by use of a single-strand specific monoclonal antibody. With this method the induction and repair of DNA damage in different cellular stages of spermatogenesis (spermatocytes, round and elongated spermatids) of the hamster were investigated. Germ cells were irradiated in vitro with 60Co-gamma-rays, at doses between 0 and 5 Gy. A linear dose-response relationship was observed. Spermatocytes and round spermatids had normal, fast repair of the lesions when compared with the repair of these sites in cultured V79 or CHO cells and human lymphocytes. The elongated spermatids, however, showed hardly any repair. Similar results were obtained after the in vivo gamma-irradiation of hamsters with doses of 0. 4, and 8 Gy and subsequent isolation of germ cells. The damage was still detectable in the elongated spermatids at 24 h after exposure. The results of the experiments show substantial differences in repair capacity between different stages of germ cell development. Because DNA is the major target for mutation induction, this assay may be useful for assessment of the genetic risk of exposure of male germ cells to ionizing radiation, in relation to the stage of development.

Significance of structural chromosome aberrations in human sperm: analysis of induced aberrations

A significant increase in the incidence of structural chromosome anomalies has been observed in the sperm of patients treated with radio and/or chemotherapy for different types of cancer when analyzed by the interspecific fertilization of hamster eggs. The analysis of these aberrations shows that while in controls only 9.4% of structural abnormalities are of the stable type, in treated patients this figure increases to 39.3%, thus indicating that the anomalies have not been produced during the fertilization of the hamster egg. However, it is possible that part, or even most, of the breaks appear as a result of a reduced repair capacity of sperm chromosomes in the cytoplasm of the hamster egg.

Measurement of DNA breakage in specific germ-cell stages of male mice exposed to acrylamide, using an alkaline-elution procedure

DNA breakage in spermiogenic stages of the mouse was studied after exposure to acrylamide (AA), using an alkaline-elution technique. At daily intervals over a 3-week period following i.p. injection of 100 mg AA/kg, mature spermatozoa were recovered from treated ([3H]dThd-labeled) and control ([14C]dThd-labeled) animals, and were lysed together on polycarbonate filters; the DNA was eluted with a high-pH (12.0) buffer. Elution of germ-cell DNA from AA-exposed animals increased (more DNA-strand breaks) in stages sensitive to the dominant-lethal effects of AA (late spermatids to early spermatozoa) (Shelby et al., 1986). The stage-related pattern of AA-induced DNA breakage also paralleled the pattern of sperm alkylation and protamine alkylation found to be produced by AA (Sega et al., 1989). While dominant-lethal damage from AA exposure is greatest in the spermatids and early spermatozoa, no such damage was observed in pachytene spermatocytes and early spermatids (Shelby et al., 1986). Therefore, AA-induced DNA breakage was also studied directly in pachytene spermatocytes and in early spermatids at short intervals (up to 4 days) after exposure. DNA breakage was clearly detected in these cell stages, with maximum breakage occurring at 1 day after treatment. At later times, the breakage gradually decreased, presumably as a result of DNA repair. By the time these cell stages gave rise to functional spermatozoa, DNA breaks that could have produced dominant-lethal events had apparently been reduced to a level where no genetic effect could be observed.

The importance of molecular dosimetry and analysis of mutations for estimation of genetic risk

A method of estimating risk to germ cells is developed by using both molecular dosimetry and analysis of mutations for points of commonality in comparison among test systems. Studies on adduct formation can be related to dose in germ cells of test systems suitable for genetic analysis of mutations through successive generations. To analyze mutations properly, both classical genetic analysis to describe large deletions and chromosomal aberrations along with molecular analysis to describe mutations at the nucleotide level must be used. A complete description of mutations permits comparison with the data that are recently becoming available on spontaneous mutations in humans where the observed change in DNA can be related to a health effect.

Measurement of DNA breakage in spermiogenic germ-cell stages of mice exposed to ethylene oxide, using an alkaline elution procedure

DNA breakage in spermiogenic stages of the mouse was studied after exposure to ethylene oxide (EtO), using an alkaline elution technique. At daily intervals over a 23-day period following i.p. injection of 100 mg EtO/kg, mature spermatozoa were recovered from treated ([3H]dThd-labeled) and control ([14C]dThd-labeled) animals, lysed together on polycarbonate filters, and the DNA was eluted with a high pH (12.2) buffer. Elution of germ-cell DNA from EtO-exposed animals increased (more DNA strand breaks) in stages sensitive to the genetic effects of EtO (late spermatids to early spermatozoa). The stage-related pattern of EtO-induced DNA breakage paralleled the pattern of sperm alkylation and protamine alkylation found to be produced by EtO in an earlier study (Sega and Owens, 1987). At 9 days posttreatment (sperm sampled were in late-spermatid stages at the time of EtO exposure) the amount of sperm DNA eluted did not change significantly over a pH range of 11.6-12.8, indicating that, at the time of assay, DNA breaks were already present in the sperm.

The use of alkaline elution procedures to measure DNA damage in spermiogenic stages of mice exposed to methyl methanesulfonate

The ability of methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) to induce DNA breakage in spermiogenic stages of the mouse was studied using an alkaline elution technique. At daily intervals over a 3-week period following i.p. injection of 50 mg MMS/kg, mature spermatozoa were recovered from treated (3H-labeled) and control (14C-labeled) animals, lysed together on polycarbonate filters, and eluted with a high pH (12.2) buffer. Elution of germ-cell DNA from MMS-treated animals was found to increase in stages in which genetic damage from MMS is greatest. In general, the pattern of DNA elution from treated, spermiogenic stages paralleled the pattern of sensitivity to dominant lethals, specific-locus mutations and heritable translocations found by other investigators. It also paralleled the pattern of sperm-head methylation and protamine methylation measured in an earlier study (Sega and Owens, 1983). At 9 days post treatment (sperm sampled were in mid-to late-spermatid stages at the time of MMS exposure) the elution of sperm DNA did not change significantly over a pH range of 11.6-12.8, suggesting that, at the time of assay, DNA breaks were already present in the sperm. Because of the parallelism found between increased sperm DNA elution and increased genetic damage after mutagen treatment, alkaline elution may prove useful in monitoring potential genetic damage in human sperm.

Increased cancer incidence in the progeny of male rats exposed to ethylnitrosourea before mating

Results from previous experiments have indicated tha persistence of an increased cancer risk in subsequent generations following prenatal exposure to a chemical carcinogen. In the present experiment, the possible role of prezygotic events in determined cancer risk was investigated in the progeny of male rats treated with ethylnitrosourea (ENU) before mating with untreated females. Eight BDVI male rats were given a single i.p. dose of 80 mg/kg bw ENU and each rat was then caged at weeks 1, 2, 3 and 4 after treatment with three untreated females. Fertility was lower and preweaning mortality higher in the experimental group, as compared to controls, particularly at the 4th-week mating. Survival rates after weaning were similar in the progeny of treated males and controls, as was the total incidence of tumours. However, analysis of tumour incidence at the various organ sites showed an increased incidence of neurogenic tumours in the progeny of ENU-treated males, as compared to that of controls.

Whole-mammal mutagenicity tests: evaluation of five methods

Transmitted genetic changes in mammals can be used to study all of the main endpoints of mutagenesis: point mutations, chromosome breakage, with or without rearrangement, and chromosome nondisjunction. Four methods most commonly employed in whole-mammal germ-line mutagenicity tests as well as an in vivo somatic prescreen, are summarized. Genetic basis, historical background, description of the test, limitations, and strengths are presented for each of the five systems. The specific-locus test using visible markers is the most reliable and practical method for detecting heritable point mutations, including small deficiencies, and does not require very large numbers of animals for risk extrapolations, if a relatively high dose can be administered without killing germ cells. For the detection of chromosome-breakage events, dominant lethals are useful to determine relative sensitivities of different germ-cell stages of the male, but the heritable-translocation test is more sensitive when the exposed cells are male meiotic and postmeiotic stages. Chromosome breakage events in the female are best revealed through a sex-chromosome loss test, which utilizes genetically marked X chromosomes. The same method can also be employed to detect nondisjunction in either sex. The in vivo somatic mutation test is useful as a prescreen for both point mutations and losses of chromosomal material. The reliability and efficiency of whole-mammal mutagenicity tests must be considered in two contexts: in the assessment of mutagenicity per se (as this applies to genetic changes transmitted to future generations), and in the use of mutagenicity as a possible indicator of carcinogenicity. In the former context, the whole-mammal tests are irreplaceable because they provide the closest practicable approach to the metabolic pathways existing in man, and because there is no array of lower-system tests that can predict the complexity of the response of the different mammalian germ-cell stages (which differ greatly with respect both to their absolute and their relative sensitivities to the induction of various genetic endpoints). In the second context, i.e., the use of mutagenicity as a screen for carcinogenicity in the exposed individual, most of the whole-mammal tests are of more limited utility, because they require several weeks or months for completion. Of the methods discussed, the spot test appears most suitable, because it provides a relatively rapid in vivo system capable of detecting both gene mutations and chromosomal changes of various kinds in somatic cells, including some that have been suggested to be involved in tumor promotion.