Clonidine treatment of schizophrenia: can we predict treatment response?

Activation of brainstem and midbrain nuclei during cognitive control in medicated patients with schizophrenia

Evidence suggests that cognitive control functions as well as the underlying brain network, anchored by the prefrontal cortex (PFC) and the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC), are dysfunctional in schizophrenia. Catecholamine producing midbrain and brainstem nuclei are densely connected with the PFC and dACC and exert profound contributions to cognitive control processes. Dysfunctions within the underlying neurotransmitter systems are considered to play a central role in the occurrence of various symptoms of schizophrenia. We sought to investigate the putatively abnormal activation pattern of the dopaminergic midbrain nuclei, that is, ventral tegmental area (VTA) and substantia nigra as well as that of the noradrenergic locus coeruleus (LC) in patients with schizophrenia during cognitive control. A total of 28 medicated patients and 27 healthy controls were investigated with the manual version of the Stroop task using event-related fMRI. The main finding was a reduced BOLD activation in the VTA during both Stroop task conditions in patients in comparison to controls, which correlated significantly with the degree of negative symptoms. We further detected a comparable LC activation in in patients and healthy controls. However, in controls LC activation was significantly correlated with the Stroop interference time, which was not observed in patients. The finding of reduced VTA activation in schizophrenia patients lends further support to the assumed dysfunction of the DA system in schizophrenia. In addition, despite comparable LC activation, the nonsignificant correlation with the Stroop interference time might indicate altered LC functioning in schizophrenia and, thus, needs further investigations.

Is elevated norepinephrine an etiological factor in some cases of schizophrenia?

A number of hypotheses have been put forth regarding the etiology of schizophrenia, including the dopamine hypothesis, NMDA receptor hypofunction hypothesis, and others. A lesser known theory is that elevated noradrenergic signaling plays a causative role in the disease. This paper briefly re-examines the merits of this hypothesis, including as it relates to some recently published studies. Several lines of evidence are investigated, including: endogenous level studies of norepinephrine (NE); modulation of the disease by noradrenergic drugs; association of the disease with bipolar disorder and hypertension, since these latter two conditions may involve elevated NE transmission; and effects of psychological stress on the disease, since stress can produce elevated release of NE. For many of these lines of evidence, their relationship with prepulse inhibition of startle is examined. A number of these studies support the hypothesis, and several suggest that elevated NE signaling plays a particularly prominent role in the paranoid subtype of schizophrenia. If the hypothesis is correct for some persons, conventional pharmaceutical treatment options, such as use of atypical antipsychotics (which may themselves modulate noradrenergic signaling), may be improved if selective NE transmission modulating agents are added to or even substituted for these conventional drugs.

Clonidine normalizes sensorimotor gating deficits in patients with schizophrenia on stable medication

BACKGROUND

Cognitive deficits form core features in schizophrenia. Several studies have shown improvements in prefrontal cognitive function by α 2 -agonists in schizophrenia. In the present study, it was investigated whether clonidine (an α 2 -adrenoceptor agonist) could normalize sensorimotor gating deficits in schizophrenia.

METHODS

In a double blind, placebo controlled, randomized, yet balanced, cross-over experiment, 20 male schizophrenia patients on stable medication were assessed in an auditory prepulse inhibition (PPI), sensitization, and habituation of the startle reflex paradigm on 5 occasions: once after oral administration of placebo and after a single dose of 25, 50, 75, and 150 µg of clonidine. Their results were compared with 20 age- and gender-matched healthy volunteers, who received no treatment.

RESULTS

In the placebo treatment, patients showed deficient PPI and sensitization, yet normal habituation compared with the controls. Except the highest dose, all dosages of clonidine significantly increased percentage PPI in the patients compared with placebo, to such levels that it no longer differed significantly from the healthy controls. However, none of the dosages increased sensitization or influenced habituation.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to show that even a single low dose of clonidine added to the medical treatment of patients with schizophrenia who are clinically stable on their antipsychotic medication not only significantly ameliorates their PPI deficits, but also normalizes them. The results have a potentially high clinical relevance for the medical treatment of schizophrenia.

Enhanced alpha1 adrenergic sensitivity in sensorimotor gating deficits in neonatal ventral hippocampus-lesioned rats

Neonatal ventral hippocampus (nVH) lesion in rats is a widely used animal model of schizophrenia due to the predominantly post-pubertal emergence of many schizophrenia-like behaviours. Our previous studies have shown increased ligand binding of alpha1 adrenergic receptors (AR) in the frontal cortex of post-pubertal, but not pre-pubertal, nVH-lesioned rats, compared to sham-lesioned control rats. Moreover, pretreatment with the alpha1 adrenergic receptor antagonist prazosin reversed amphetamine-induced hyperlocomotion in controls, but failed to do so in lesioned animals. This led to our hypothesis that nVH lesions may lead to post-pubertal hyperactivity of alpha1 adrenergic receptors. In order to test the functional relevance of alpha1 adrenergic hyperactivity to schizophrenia-like behaviours of nVH-lesioned animals, we conducted prepulse inhibition (PPI) studies in post-pubertal (postnatal days 56-120) sham and lesioned animals in response to systemic injections of alpha1 adrenergic receptor antagonist and agonist, prazosin and cirazoline, respectively. Our results show that PPI deficits in nVH-lesioned animals were reversed with prazosin treatment, without a significant effect on PPI in sham animals. Further, at various doses, cirazoline had a significantly greater PPI disruptive effect in nVH-lesioned animals than in sham animals. Together, these results suggest that nVH-lesioned animals show a hyperactive alpha1 adrenergic receptor system that may mediate sensorimotor gating abnormalities reported in these animals.

Disruption of prepulse inhibition after stimulation of central but not peripheral alpha-1 adrenergic receptors

Prepulse inhibition (PPI) refers to the attenuation of startle when a weak prestimulus precedes the startling stimulus. PPI is deficient in several psychiatric illnesses involving poor sensorimotor gating. Previous studies indicate that alpha1 adrenergic receptors regulate PPI, yet the extent to which these effects are mediated by central vs peripheral receptors is unclear. The present studies compared the effects of intracerebroventricular (ICV) vs intraperitoneal (IP) delivery of several alpha1 receptor agonists on PPI. Male Sprague-Dawley rats received either cirazoline (0, 10, 25, 50 microg/5 microl), methoxamine (0, 30, 100 microg/5 microl), or phenylephrine (0, 3, 10, 30 microg/5 microl) ICV immediately before testing. Separate groups received either cirazoline (0, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75 mg/kg), methoxamine (0, 2, 5, 10 mg/kg), or phenylephrine (0, 0.1, 2.0 mg/kg) IP 5 min before testing. PPI, baseline startle responses, and piloerection, an index of autonomic arousal, were measured. Cirazoline disrupted PPI; effective ICV doses were approximately six times lower than effective IP doses. Methoxamine disrupted PPI after ICV infusion but failed to affect PPI with IP doses that were up to 30-fold higher than the effective ICV dose. Phenylephrine disrupted PPI with ICV administration, but did not alter PPI after IP injection of even a 20-fold higher dose. None of the ICV treatments altered baseline startle magnitude, but phenylephrine and methoxamine lowered startle after administration of high systemic doses. Piloerection was induced by cirazoline via either route of administration, and by IP methoxamine and phenylephrine, but not by ICV infusion of methoxamine or phenylephrine. These findings indicate that alpha1 receptor-mediated PPI disruption occurs exclusively through stimulation of central receptors and is dissociable from alterations in baseline startle or autonomic effects.

Potential noradrenergic targets for cognitive enhancement in schizophrenia

Substantial evidence suggests that alterations in noradrenergic function contribute to the cognitive impairments of schizophrenia. Activation of post-junctional alpha 2a-adrenergic receptors in the prefrontal cortex by the alpha 2a-selective agonist guanfacine has demonstrated some preliminary benefit in subjects with schizophrenia treated with atypical antipsychotics. alpha 1-adrenergic receptor activity may be less important in mediating the cognitive impairments of schizophrenia. beta-adrenergic receptors may serve as another potential target for cognitive remediation in schizophrenia. However, the potential increase in memory consolidation in schizophrenia patients produced by beta-adrenergic agonists may be outweighed by the impairment in cognitive flexibility and executive functioning produced by beta-adrenergic agonists. Finally, norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, such as atomoxetine, hold promise as potential cognitive enhancers in schizophrenia because of their ability to indirectly but selectively increase extracellular dopamine concentrations in the prefrontal cortex.

Reboxetine add on therapy to haloperidol in the treatment of schizophrenia: a preliminary double-blind randomized placebo-controlled study

The negative symptoms of schizophrenia remain a major clinical challenge. Reboxetine is an antidepressant whose major mechanism of action is as a noradrenergic reuptake inhibitor. This study was a 6-week randomized placebo-controlled trial of reboxetine or placebo add on to haloperidol 5 mg in the treatment of 30 patients with DSM-IV schizophrenia. The trial failed to demonstrate any significant difference between the placebo and reboxetine groups on any of the outcome measures. This trial does not suggest that increased noradreneregic drive mediated by reuptake inhibition in patients taking dopamine antagonists is of therapeutic value in schizophrenia.

The role of norepinephrine in the pathophysiology of cognitive disorders: potential applications to the treatment of cognitive dysfunction in schizophrenia and Alzheimer's disease

The role of noradrenergic neurotransmission in normal cognitive functions has been extensively investigated, however, the involvement of noradrenergic functions in the cognitive impairment associated with schizophrenia and Alzheimer's disease has not been as intensively considered. The limited ability of atypical antipsychotics to treat the cognitive impairment of schizophrenia, and cholinomimetics to treat the cognitive impairment of Alzheimer's disease, may be related to the influence of a multiplicity of neurotransmitter abnormalities including noradrenergic dysfunction, which these treatments do not address. The evidence of noradrenergic dysfunction occurring concomitantly with dopamine dysfunction in schizophrenia and acetylcholine dysfunction in Alzheimer's disease supports therapeutic approaches using noradrenergic drugs in combination with neuroleptics and cholinesterase inhibitors, respectively, to enhance the treatment of cognitive impairment. Given the results of animal and human studies, it appears that alpha-2A agonists may be the optimal choice for this purpose.

Pharmacologic strategies for augmenting cognitive performance in schizophrenia

There is recognition that the cognitive symptoms of schizophrenia have the most substantial impact on illness outcome. Domains of cognition reported to be significantly affected include serial learning, executive function, vigilance, and distractibility, to name a few. Dopamine activity at D1 receptors mediates many cognitive processes subserved by the prefrontal cortex (PFC), particularly working memory. The number of D1 receptors in the PFC is decreased in schizophrenics and is unaffected by chronic administration of typical neuroleptics. Therefore, medications that increase dopamine in the PFC, such as atypical neuroleptics, or that directly activate the D1 receptor may prove useful in the remediation of prefrontal-dependent cognitive deficits in schizophrenia. Decreased levels of cortical norepinephrine (NE) are associated with impaired learning and working memory in animal models, and can be reversed by drugs that restore NE activity. More specifically, alpha-2 adrenergic receptor agonists have been particularly effective in improving delayed response performance in young monkeys with localized 6-hydroxydopamine lesions in the PFC. Furthermore, human postmortem studies have demonstrated decreased NE in the frontal cortex of demented schizophrenic patients. Therefore, alpha-2 receptor agonists hold promise as drugs to improve cognitive performance on tasks dependent upon PFC function in schizophrenics. Finally, the finding that cortical choline acetyl transferase activity correlates with Clinical Dementia Rating scores in schizophrenic patients and that cholinomimetic drugs enhance cognition in healthy subjects suggests that cholinergic drugs may also treat cognitive symptoms in schizophrenia. Two potential types of cholinomimetics for use in schizophrenics are the acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and M1/M4 muscarinic agonists, both of which increase cortical cholinergic activity.

Predicting haloperidol treatment response in chronic schizophrenia

The study attempted to identify pretreatment characteristics of chronic schizophrenic patients that would predict remission in psychosis and amount of clinical improvement after treatment with haloperidol. Thirty-five acutely relapsed schizophrenic patients were entered into a blind 6-week treatment protocol. Pretreatment measures were assessed for prediction of both remission status (dichotomous) and for correlations with change in psychopathology (continuous). Later age of onset and higher plasma homovanillic acid values were significant predictors of remission status (model 1). However, higher cerebrospinal fluid levels of 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol, as well as indices of normal neurodevelopment, predicted larger changes in psychopathology. The results indicate that the definition of drug response determines the predictive variables. Dopaminergic activity seems to relate to the ability to reach remission, while noradrenergic activity relates to symptom intensity and reduction. In addition to catecholamine activity, neurodevelopmental changes determine response to haloperidol.

A study of enzymes involved in catecholamine metabolism in parents of patients with schizophrenia

The concentrations of serum homovanillic acid (HVA), norepinephrine (NE), tyrosine (Tyr), phenylalanine (Phe) and tryptophan (Trp), and the activities of serum dopamine-beta-hydroxylase (DBH), platelet monoamine oxidase (MAO), and erythrocyte catechol-O-methyl transferase (COMT) were measured in 68 healthy parents who had schizophrenic offspring. The results show a significant correlation between the parents of schizophrenic patients in serum HVA (r=0.38, n=34, p<0.05), NE (r=0.40, n=33, p<0.02), Phe (r=0.44, n=34, p<0.0l), Tyr (r=0.43, n = 34, p <0.02) and DBH activity (r=0.51, n = 30, p <0.005), but do not show a significant correlation in erythrocyte COMT (r=0.01, n=27), platelet MAO (r=0.04, n=23) or serum Trp (r=0.10, n=34). There were no significant correlations in these measurements between randomly matched parents. The present study suggests that both parental sides of schizophrenic patients are likely to have similar alleles associated with the catecholamine pathway, and their ill offspring may possess a double dose of the schizophrenogenic alleles.

Clonidine plus haloperidol in the treatment of schizophrenia/psychosis

Because of the evidence for increased norepinephrine (NE) production in psychotic patients, we studied the effects of combining the alpha 2-adrenergic agonist clonidine with haloperidol for the treatment of schizophrenic psychosis. Twelve hospitalized schizophrenic patients were taken off their antipsychotic medication for 2 to 4 weeks before double-blind treatment with haloperidol (20 mg/day) combined with either clonidine or placebo. The group receiving clonidine was significantly more improved on the thought disorder subscale of the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (p = 0.02). The groups differed initially in the level of negative symptoms, but not controlling for this difference statistically by analysis of covariance did not change the finding with regard to the superiority of combining clonidine with haloperidol. We conclude that larger treatment trials of combining haloperidol with clonidine are warranted.

A Neural Network Simulation of Hallucinated “Voices” and Associated Speech Perception Impairments in Schizophrenic Patients

The mechanism of hallucinated speech, a symptom commonly reported by schizophrenic patients, is unknown. The hypothesis that these hallucinations arise from pathologically altered working memory underlying speech perception was explored. A neural network computer simulation of contextually guided sequential word detection based on Elman (1990a,b) was studied. Pruning anatomic connections or reducing neuronal activation in working memory caused word “percepts” to emerge spontaneously (i.e., in the absence of external “speech inputs”), thereby providing a model of hallucinated speech. These simulations also demonstrated distinct patterns of word detection impairments when inputs were accompanied by varying levels of noise. In a parallel human study, the ability to shadow noisecontaminated, connected speech was assessed. Schizophrenic patients reporting hallucinated speech demonstrated a pattern of speech perception impairments similar to a simulated neural network with reduced anatomic connectivity and enhanced neuronal activation. Schizophrenic patients not reporting this symptom did not demonstrate these speech perception impairments. Neural network simulations and human empirical data, when considered together, suggested that the primary cause of hallucinated “voices” in schizophrenia is reduced neuroanatomic connectivity in verbal working memory.

Pharmacological manipulations of the alpha 2-noradrenergic system. Effects on cognition

Electrophysiological and neurosurgical lesion studies with experimental animals have implicated the ascending dorsal noradrenergic bundle of the locus coeruleus system in cognitive process such as memory, learning and selective attention. However, it has also been suggested that noradrenaline (norepinephrine) is crucial in certain cognitive functions associated with the frontal lobes, particularly the prevention of distractibility by irrelevant stimuli. The alpha 2-receptors of the prefrontal cortex appear to be of particular importance in this respect. Studies with humans and experimental primates provide substantial support for this view. The aged primate brain is prone to degeneration of the locus coeruleus, as well as profound catecholamine depletion in the prefrontal cortex, and so is ideal for psychopharmacological investigation of the role of noradrenaline in frontal lobe function. Elderly monkeys show deficits in performance of the delayed response task, which can be reversed directly by both the mixed alpha 1/alpha 2-agonist clonidine, the more specific alpha 2-agonist guanfacine and also, indirectly, by the alpha 2-antagonist yohimbine. It is suggested that these results can be explained by an attenuation of the distracting properties of irrelevant stimuli following stimulation of noradrenergic activity. Conversely, distractibility is magnified whenever noradrenergic activity is reduced. This is supported by similar findings in psychopharmacological studies of healthy humans. The exception to this is when the locus coeruleus is likely to be firing, e.g. in times of stress or when novel stimuli are encountered. Clonidine attenuates locus coeruleus firing on such occasions, and so counteracts any beneficial (or deleterious) effects of stress on task performance. alpha 2-Adrenoceptor agents have little therapeutic value in patients with dementia of the Alzheimer's type. However, they may have some clinical use in patients who have a cognitive symptomatology similar to that of patients who have received neurosurgical excisions to the frontal lobes, e.g. deficits in working memory, executive function or focused attention, with relative sparing of episodic short term memory. Patients with Korsakoff's disease, attention deficit disorder or schizophrenia may benefit from treatment with alpha 2-agents. In particular, idazoxan has putative therapeutic effects in patients with a neurodegenerative disorder, namely dementia of frontal type.

Psychopharmacologic treatment of negative schizophrenic symptoms

Diverse pharmacologic agents have been reported to be effective in treating negative schizophrenic symptoms (NSS). In light of this large and growing literature, as well as of reconceptualizations of the underlying pathophysiology of NSS, the time may have come to reject models that assume "irreversibility" of NSS. However, flaws in existing studies prevent closure regarding the reversibility of, and by inference the treatability of, NSS. Guidelines for future studies are articulated, e.g., the need to distinguish primary from secondary NSS, to include drug-free subjects with a predominance of NSS in clinical trials, and to use well-validated and psychometrically sound instruments for assessing NSS.

Blunted growth hormone response to clonidine in Gilles de la Tourette syndrome

Noradrenergic mechanisms have been involved in the pathogenesis of Gilles de la Tourette Syndrome (GTS). Since the central alpha 2 adrenergic agonist clonidine is widely used as a therapeutic agent in GTS, the present study aimed at assessing whether GH release after clonidine, representing central alpha 2-adrenergic receptor sensitivity, was altered in GTS. After administration of 2 micrograms/kg body weight clonidine, the GH response was examined in nine drug-free, alcohol-abstinent GTS patients (eight men, one woman) and in nine age- and sex-matched abstinent healthy controls. A blunted response of GH release (< 5 ng/ml) was observed in seven patients and the area under the curve (AUC) of the GH-release was significantly reduced (p < .01) compared to controls. This finding indicates an involvement of the noradrenergic system in GTS.

Possible noradrenergic dysfunction in schizophrenia

In spite of extensive studies over the last 2 decades to find direct evidence in support of the dopamine hypothesis of schizophrenia, no undisputed experimental data has been obtained. In contrast, estimation of noradrenalin (another major catecholamine) and its metabolites in postmortem brain and in the cerebrospinal fluid appears to be producing consistent results. To understand the meaning of this change for the pathogenesis of the illness, we have carried out animal experiments in which reproducibility of schizophrenic signs and symptoms by noradrenergic dysfunction, and treatability of the disorder by modulation of noradrenergic activity were studied. First, psychophysiological signs in skin conductance responsiveness (nonhabituating or nonresponding change) and smooth pursuit eye movement (spiky or stepwise pursuit) could be reproduced by enhancing or suppressing central noradrenergic activity. Behavioral abnormalities resembling schizophrenic symptoms are known to be reproducible by over- or underactivity of the system (overarousal or underarousal syndrome). Secondly, the action of various drugs capable of modulating schizophrenic symptoms was analyzed in relation to noradrenergic activity. Haloperidol, in particular, had a potent suppressing effect on skin conductance activity (spontaneous fluctuation rate and habituation rate) when administered chronically, suggesting its inhibitory action on noradrenergic activity.

Acute effects of neuroleptics on unmedicated schizophrenic patients and controls

Acute administration of haloperidol (0.2 mg/kg) produced many more side effects in normal controls than in unmedicated schizophrenic patients. Prior to the neuroleptic challenge, both groups were on the peripheral monoamine oxidase inhibitor, debrisoquin, for at least 1 week, in order to enhance the relative contribution of CNS catecholamine metabolites to those measured in both plasma and urine. The patient group had higher plasma levels of methoxyhydroxyphenylglycol (MHPG) and homovanillic acid (HVA) and higher urinary MHPG output than controls, but there were no effects of haloperidol challenge, compared to placebo challenge. In both groups there were significant declines in plasma HVA levels from 8:30 AM to 12 NOON. These declines were unaffected by the haloperidol challenge. Explanations for the marked differences in behavioral effects of haloperidol on patients and controls include the possibility that dopamine receptor numbers were increased in the brains of the schizophrenic patients.

Treatment of schizophrenia: a clinical and preclinical evaluation of neuroleptic drugs

Forty years after the first clinical report on the effectiveness of chlorpromazine in psychiatric patients, neuroleptic drugs are still the most widely used drugs in the treatment of schizophrenia. Indeed, there are no other drugs which have proven to be as effective in the treatment of this severe psychiatric disorder. Yet, there are still many unresolved problems relating to neuroleptic drugs. The present review gives a comprehensive overview of our knowledge (and our lack of knowledge) with respect to the clinical and preclinical effects of neuroleptic drugs and tries to integrate this knowledge in order to identify the neuronal mechanisms underlying the therapeutic and side effects of neuroleptic drugs.

The biochemical basis of relapse and drug response in schizophrenia: review and hypothesis

This review of the literature suggests that antipsychotic drug response is determined by dopamine (DA) turnover and norepinephrine (NE) activity prior to treatment. The data suggest that NE modulates the DA system. Drug-free psychotic patients with relatively increased DA and NE activity, including release, are more likely to be treatment responsive, while patients who show evidence of enhanced DA and NE activity during treatment with antipsychotic drugs are likely to relapse soon after neuroleptic withdrawal. Basal release of DA and NE is decreased and associated with residual positive and negative symptoms. Improvement during neuroleptic treatment is associated with decreases in DA and NE phasic or stimulus induced release. The variable response to antipsychotic drugs is most likely to be a result of dysregulated DA and NE release, i.e. under state-dependent control, rather than evidence of a heterogeneous aetiology. Because catecholamines regulate gain, signal-to-noise ratio and gating in the brain, this model allows for environmental factors to interact with biochemical state and drug treatment. The author proposes that impaired homeostasis of NE and DA in schizophrenia causes instability in NE and DA neuronal firing and release, presumably related to mechanisms down-stream from the receptors, such as G proteins. This instability of catecholamine release may explain the observed variability in clinical states and drug response in schizophrenia.

Dopamine and norepinephrine activity in schizophrenia. An integrative perspective

The dopamine (DA) hypothesis of schizophrenia stated that increased DA activity is the primary cause of schizophrenia. Recently, even though increased DA activity is in fact involved in psychotic symptoms and antipsychotic drug response, it has become clear that decreased DA activity is present in remitted and chronic states and may relate to deficit symptoms and cortical lesions. In addition, the norepinephrine (NE) system seems to be involved in symptomatology, antipsychotic drug response, course, and outcome in schizophrenia. This review supports the hypothesis that a disturbance in DA and NE activity regulates schizophrenic behavior. A plethora of DA- and NE-related findings in schizophrenic patients are reviewed in relationship to each other according to basic science data and to presently entertained hypotheses, with emphasis on a neural developmental disturbance interacting with a genetic predisposition shaped by environmental factors.