The use of monoclonal antibodies in an enzyme immunospot assay to detect isotype-specific antibody-secreting cells in pigs and chickens

Exploring the antigenic response to multiplexed immunizations in a chicken model of antibody production

Hens have a tremendous capacity for producing polyclonal antibodies that can subsequently be isolated in high concentrations from their eggs. An approach for further maximizing their potential is to produce multiple antisera in the same individual through multiplexed (multiple simultaneous) immunizations. An unknown with this approach is how many immunogens a single bird is capable of mounting a sizeable antigenic response toward. At what point does it become counter-productive to add more immunogens to the same immunization regimen?

In the present study we were able to demonstrate that the competing effects of co-administering multiple immunogens effectively limit the antibody specificities that can be raised in a single individual to a fairly low number. Two potent model immunogens, KLH and CRM₁₉₇, were administered together with competing antigens in various concentrations and complexities. With an upper limit of 1 mg protein material recommended for chicken immunizations, we found that the maximum number of immunogens that can be reliably used is most likely in the low double digits.

The limiting factor for a response to an immunogen could not be related to the number of splenic plasma cells producing antibodies against it. When administering KLH alone, up to 70% of the IgY-producing splenic plasma cells were occupied with producing anti-KLH antibodies; but when simultaneously being exposed to a plethora of other antigens, a response of a comparable magnitude could be mounted with a splenic plasma cell involvement of less than 5%.

Two breeds of egg-layers were compared with respect to antibody production in an initial experiment, but differences in antibody productivity were negligible.

Although our findings support the use of multiplexed immunizations in the hen, we find that the number of immunogens cannot be stretched much higher than the handful that has been used in mammalian models to date.

Porcine IgG: structure, genetics, and evolution

Eleven genomic porcine Cgamma gene sequences are described that represent six putative subclasses that appear to have originated by gene duplication and exon shuffle. The genes previously described as encoding porcine IgG1 and IgG3 were shown to be the IgG1(a) and IgG1(b) allelic variants of the IGHG1 gene, IgG2a and IgG2b are allelic variants of the IGHG2 gene, while "new" IgG3 is monomorphic, has an extended hinge, is structurally unique, and appears to encode the most evolutionarily conserved porcine IgG. IgG5(b) differs most from its putative allele, and its C(H)1 domain shares sequence homology with the C(H)1 of IgG3. Four animals were identified that lacked either IgG4 or IgG6. Alternative splice variants were also recovered, some lacking the C(H)1 domain and potentially encoding heavy chain only antibodies. Potentially, swine can transcribe >20 different Cgamma chains. A comparison of mammalian Cgamma gene sequences revealed that IgG diversified into subclasses after speciation. Thus, the effector functions for the IgG subclasses of each species should not be extrapolated from "same name subclasses" in other species. Sequence analysis identified motifs likely to interact with Fcgamma receptors, FcRn, protein A, protein G, and C1q. These revealed IgG3 to be most likely to activate complement and bind FcgammaRs. All except IgG5(a) and IgG6(a) should bind to FcgammaRs, while all except IgG6(a) and the putative IgG5 subclass proteins should bind well to porcine FcRn, protein A, and protein G.

Development and validation of a new in vitro assay for selection of probiotic bacteria that express immune-stimulating properties in chickens in vivo

Oral administration of immunoprobiotic bacteria may support animal health. Species specificity of such microorganisms requires appropriate selection. An in vitro assay for the selection of immunoprobiotic lactic acid bacteria was developed in chicken. The assay allowed testing of large numbers of individual strains. Immune stimulation in vitro correlated well with the in vivo situation in two experiments and no false negative results occurred. Therefore this assay is an appropriate selection tool for immunomodulating properties of lactic acid bacteria in chicken.

Immunological differences between layer- and broiler-type chickens

In commercial poultry husbandry, alternatives for the use of antibiotics and vaccines are under investigation, which preferably have to be applicable for both layer- and broiler-type chickens. There are indications that the defense mechanisms vary between layer- and broiler-type chickens. Therefore, the difference in immune response between layer- and broiler-type chickens of the same age was investigated, using TNP-KLH (trinitrophenyl-conjugated keyhole limpet hemocyanin) as antigen without adjuvant. First different routes of immunization (intravenously, intramuscular, subcutaneous and ocular) were examined to find out which immunization route gives the highest antibody titers. The intravenous immunization route resulted in higher TNP-specific antibody responses than the other immunization routes tested and therefore this immunization route was used in both following experiments. In order to investigate the optimal dose of antigen needed for immunization, a dose-response curve in broiler- and layer-type chickens was completed. The humoral immune response was measured in serum by a TNP-specific ELISA and the in vitro cellular immune response by an antigen-specific lymphocyte proliferation assay. The antibody response of layer- and broiler-type chickens appeared to differ, not only in optimal dose and response, but also in kinetics of the response itself. Broiler chickens generated higher IgM anti-TNP titers whereas layer-type chickens generated higher IgG anti-TNP titers. This specific antibody response in broiler-type chickens did not last as long as in layer-type chickens. The TNP-specific cellular immune response was detectable in layer-type chickens, but not in broilers. Both types generate a non-specific cellular immune response, although this response in broilers is lower than in layer-type chickens. From these results, we conclude that broilers primarily respond to TNP-KLH with a high IgM antibody response whereas layer-type chickens respond with a high IgG response. In addition, the cellular response of layer-type chickens is much higher than the response of broilers. The results suggest that broilers are specialized in the production of a strong short-term humoral response and layer-type chickens in a long-term humoral response in combination with a strong cellular response, which is in conformity with their life expectancy.

Development of the natural response of immunoglobulin secreting cells in the pig as a function of organ, age and housing

We analysed the development of the natural immunoglobulin-secreting cell (Ig-SC) response in systemic- and mucosal-lymphoid tissues of specified pathogen free pigs between 1 and 40 weeks of age. As antigen exposure may influence the development of the Ig-SC repertoire we also compared the frequencies of Ig-SC in various lymphoid tissues of 40 weeks old specified pathogen free pigs and conventional pigs. A procedure to isolate lamina propria cells from porcine intestine was adapted for this study. The frequencies of IgM-, IgG-, and IgA-secreting (spot forming) cells were determined with a reversed enzyme linked immunospot assay, which was also adapted for detection of Ig-SC in pigs. The Ig-SC frequencies were calculated as percentage of the mononuclear leukocytes isolated from the various organs. The observations till 40 weeks of age were as follows: Splenic IgM-SC predominated at all ages and reached a plateau of 0.1-0.2% of the mononuclear leukocytes already at 4 weeks of age. The IgM-SC of mesenteric lymph node (MLN) predominated up till 12 weeks of age and reached an optimum of 0.15% reached at 4 weeks of age. The frequencies of IgG-SC of spleen and MLN had dips around 4 weeks of age and increased thereafter till 40 weeks of age (spleen 0.025%, MLN 0.05% at 40 weeks of age). The frequencies of IgA-SC were low in the spleen (< or =0.003%) and moderate in the MLN (0.01-0.02%) at all ages tested. In peripheral lymph node (PLN) and bone marrow (BM), the frequencies of IgM-SC (0.03-0.05%) were much lower than in the spleen. The IgG-SC frequencies of BM and MLN also had dips around 4 weeks of age and increased thereafter. The IgG-SC frequency of BM reached a plateau at 12 weeks of age (0.15%) and for PLN the highest frequency was observed at 40 weeks of age (0.05%). The frequencies of IgA-SC were low in BM and PLN (<0.003%). High frequencies of IgA-SC were observed in mucosa associated tissue like Peyer's patches (PP) and intestinal lamina propria (till 20% of the mononuclear leukocytes in intestinal lamina propria of 12-40 weeks of age). IgM and IgA are both important isotypes in mucosal lymphoid organs in the pig. The shift from IgM to IgAas predominant, mucosal isotype was first observed in duodenum and jejunum (12 weeks) and later in ileum (40 weeks). The influence of ageing on the frequency of Ig-SC in PP was only observed in jejunal PP. whereas in ileal PP the frequencies of Ig-SC did not vary over time. We combined our data about the frequencies of IgM-, IgG-, and IgA-SC in various organs with data obtained by others about the distribution of lymphocytes over porcine lymphoid organs at about 12 weeks of age. Based on these calculations we concluded that the small intestine, with more than 80% of all Ig-SC, is fair most the major site of Ig production in the pig. We also concluded that the small intestine is the major site of IgA and IgM production cells in the pig. Although IgA becomes predominant along the intestine, the results demonstrated that in the pig IgM is more a mucosal isotype compared with other species. With 40% of all IgG-SC the porcine BM appeared to be the major site of IgG production. Unexpected results were obtained for IgG-SC in the systemic lymphoid organs. In these organs the frequencies of IgG-SC dropped firstly from 1 to 4 weeks of age and steadily increased thereafter till 40 weeks of age. This observation is discussed in relation to the possibility that systemic IgG-SC at one week of age were passively acquired from maternal colostrum. The influence of housing/antigenic load at 40 weeks of age was mainly expressed by an increase (2-8x) of the frequency of IgG-SC in spleen, PLN, BM, and intestinal lamina propria, whereas the typical mucosal IgA-SC frequencies in the lamina propria were hardly affected.

A comparative study of germinal center: fowls and mammals

The mammalian germinal center is organized into a dark zone containing proliferating centroblasts and a light zone filled with nondividing B cells (called centrocytes), follicular dendritic cells and a few scattered T cells. We clarified these two zones in the chicken germinal center with immunohistology. Proliferating cells and immunoglobulin negative cells were detected in the circumference ring of the chicken germinal center. The central part of the chicken germinal center contained B cells expressing immunoglobulin, follicular dendritic cells and a few T cells. Most of the B cells in the central part of the chicken germinal center did not enter into the S phase. These results suggest that the chicken germinal center is also organized into the dark zone (the circumference ring of germinal center) and the light zone (the central part of germinal center).

Inadequate anti-polysaccharide antibody responses in the chicken

Chickens are notorious for the fact that they carry bacteria such as Salmonellae and Campylobacter, which can cause zoonoses by contamination of the end product, without hampering growth and development of the chicken itself. This carrier status can only been explained by the inability of the chickens immune system to eliminate the pathogen, this in turn being due to insufficient humoral responses towards the polysaccharides of the bacterial capsule. In a previous study, we demonstrated that in chickens a model thymus-independent type 2 (TI-2) polysaccharide antigen, trinitrophenylated Ficoll (TNP-Ficoll), hardly evokes a humoral immune response. Furthermore this TI-2 antigen was shown to exhibit a very specific initial localization pattern after intravenous injection, i.e. in the periellipsoidal lymphocyte sheaths (PELS) and the surrounding ring of macrophages. The functional equivalent of these macrophages in mammals, the marginal zone macrophages, were shown to suppress the humoral responses against TI-2 antigens. Therefore we investigated whether other standard TI-2 antigen models also induce low antibody responses, whether this low response is dose-dependent, and whether macrophages are responsible for this low response. It was found that other TI-2 antigens, such as hydroxyethyl starch and detoxified lipopolysaccharides, also induced very low IgM and IgG responses, indicating a general phenomenon that could not be overcome by using a higher dose of antigen. In addition, selective depletion of splenic macrophages with liposomes containing dichloromethylene diphosphonate prior to immunization increased the specific humoral response to TD and TI-1 antigens, but failed to do so for TI-2 antigen. This result indicates that the low humoral responses are not (only) due to a macrophage suppressive activity but also to other yet unknown mechanisms, for example the lack of responsive B cells in the splenic PELS.

ELISPOT for detecting antibody-secreting cells in response to infections and vaccination

Based on immunoassay principles, methods have been developed for the analysis of secreted products at the cellular level. This approach offers substantial methodological advantages compared to traditional immunoassays. In a number of applications cell-based methods have proved able to overcome many of the problems inherent to immunoassays of biological fluids. This review focuses on applications of ELISPOT in natural infections and vaccinations of human individuals. The studies reviewed here have contributed to our understanding of the B-cell responses in infections and the independence of mucosal and systemic immune responses. Whilst diagnostic applications are rare, enzyme immunospot assays have been extensively used in testing the immunogenicity of vaccines. In particular, B-cell responses to mucosal vaccines are better covered with this cellular assay.

The B cell compartment of two chicken lines divergently selected for antibody production: differences in structure and function

In the present study differences in the B cell compartment of two chicken lines selected for either high (H) or low (L) antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) are investigated. In non-immunized chicks, flow cytometry revealed generally more circulating Ig+ leukocytes in the H line, while in the L line slightly more CD4+ and in week 5, more CD8+ cells were found. In the L line spleen more CD8+ were found and in the H line spleen more CD4+ cells. In week 6, half of the chicks were immunized. Both lines were similarly affected by immunization. Immunization reduced the percentages of the circulating T cell subpopulations, while Ig+ cells were enhanced, compared with non-immunized chicks. Histological determinations with specific mAbs on spleens of young, non-immunized chicks, showed large dense T cell areas in the L line, while in the H line more and larger germinal centres were found. In the H line, also, more B cells were found in the peri-ellipsoid lymphoid sheaths (PELS). No line differences in mononuclear phagocytes were found other than associated with line differences in numbers of PELS and germinal centres. After immunization with TNP-BSA, both higher numbers of TNP-specific antibody producing cells and higher levels of circulating antibody were found in the H line. Moreover, more TNP-specific plasma cells were found in non TNP-immunized H line chicks, than in the L line chicks. The H line had also higher ELISA-titers to KLH 5 days after immunization with KLH. Therefore it was concluded that selection for antibody response has affected the B cell compartment. The H line has relatively more B cells and the splenic structure of the H line differs from the L line, in the H line probably resulting in a more optimal organization for antibody response to T cell dependent antigens.

Parenteral vaccination of mice and piglets with F4+ Escherichia coli suppresses the enteric anti-F4 response upon oral infection

We studied with a mouse model and in piglets the requirements to prime for a secondary, mucosal B-cell response against Escherichia coli F4 fimbriae, an important virulence factor of enterotoxigenic E. coli, the agent associated with postweaning diarrhoea in piglets. The major observation obtained with the mouse model was verified for piglets. Mice and piglets were primed orally or parenterally with purified F4ac antigen or whole bacterial cells carrying the F4ac antigen and were later orally infected with live F4ac+ E. coli bacteria. Cell suspensions of murine spleen or porcine serum were used to study the systemic B-cell response. Cell suspensions were also made of murine and porcine enteric lamina propria and were used to study the mucosal B-cell response. Enzyme-linked immunospot assays and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays specific to E. coli F4ac antigen were used to quantify either the antibody-secreting cells or antibody titres in serum. Results showed that in mice only primary oral immunization with live bacteria induced an enteric immune response against the E. coli F4ac+ fimbriae. Oral immunization with killed bacteria induced hardly any mucosal immune response. Parenteral immunization induced a state of suppression that was reflected by the lack of an enteric immune response upon a subsequent oral infection with live bacteria. A comparable induction of suppression was observed in piglets using the same protocol. We conclude that parenteral vaccination of piglets with the E. coli F4ac antigen is ineffective to induce protective immunity at the mucosal level against postweaning diarrhoea and is possibly detrimental.

Antigen presenting cells and B-cells in the pig

The central position of antigen presenting cells (APC) in the immune system and the heterogeneity of the APC family are discussed; both aspects are illustrated with data from species other than the pig. Thereafter the limited work on porcine APC is reviewed. The section on B-cells, the effector cells of the humoral immune system, exclusively focuses on 'porcine data'.

Mannan-binding protein-like activity in the sera of newborn piglets

The mechanism of the antibody-independent bactericidal activity of the sera of newborn piglets deprived of colostrum was studied using rough strains of E. coli and S. typhimurium. Although all strains were invariably killed by all newborn piglet sera tested, two different mechanisms of killing were encountered. Using specific anti-pig C1q antiserum, strains S. typhimurium LT2Ml and E. coli K-12, strain Gal 23 were found to be killed by a C1q-dependent mechanism, while the killing of E. coli S 16, E. coli K-12, strain W 3100 and E. coli B 41 could not be inhibited by anti-C1q antiserum. In order to test whether a mannan-binding protein is responsible for the bactericidal effect in the latter group of strains, we examined the inhibitory activity of two types of mannans isolated from S. cerevisiae and H. capsulata, respectively. The use of a purified rabbit mannan-binding protein showed that only strains killed by the C1q-independent mechanism were sensitive to the MBP-dependent mechanism of killing, the inhibitory activities of both mannans were found to be equal. As expected, the inhibitory effect of mannan on the bactericidal activity of newborn piglet sera was also detected only in strains killed by the C1q-independent mechanism. Surprisingly, only the phosphomannan isolated from H. capsulata was found to be an effective inhibitor of the bactericidial activity of piglet sera against E. coli S 16 and E. coli K-12, strain W 3100, while the mannan isolated from S. cerevisiae was inactive. Hence the factor present in newborn piglet sera is either MBP with slightly different binding properties, or a completely different protein.

Humoral immune response to Salmonella abortusovis in sheep: in vitro induction of an antibody synthesis from either sensitized or unprimed lymph node cells

In vitro culture conditions were determined to induce an anti-Salmonella abortusovis antibody synthesis from lymph node leucocytes of three immunized sheep and two unprimed lambs maintained in culture in the presence of heat-inactivated bacteria for 2 weeks. Humoral immune responses were assessed by enumerating specific antibody-secreting cells using ELISASPOT and by titrating immunoglobulins secreted into culture supernatants using ELISA techniques. Optimal secondary antibody response was observed from cultures performed with fetal calf serum (compared with horse serum) and with an antigen concentration of one to ten bacteria per cell. This kind of antigenic stimulation allowed induction of numerous antibody-secreting cells without adsorption of the secreted antibodies. Maximal numbers of antibody-secreting cells could reach a rate of 1% of the sheep leucocytes initially put into culture. Kinetic profiles of antibody production from boosted lymph node cells were characterized by an ascending phase from the sixth to the twelfth day of culture and then showed a plateau phase until Day 14. Most of the responses were composed of IgM and IgG1 antibodies, traces of IgG2 being detected at the end of experiments. From the twelfth day of antigenic stimulation, the IgM isotype was preferentially expressed with high antigen concentration (100 bacteria per cell), whereas the highest amounts of IgG1 were detected at lower concentration (one to ten bacteria per cell). While anti-Salmonella IgM appeared to be mainly specific for the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) cell wall fraction, some IgG1 recognized other bacterial antigens. Kinetic profiles and magnitudes of primary antibody responses induced in vitro from lamb lymph node cells did not differ from those defined in cultures of sheep boosted leucocytes. But these immune reactions were mainly made up of anti-LPS IgM. Few anti-Salmonella IgG1 were detected from the tenth day of culture. So these in vitro assays allowed induction of antibody synthesis from either in vivo sensitized or unprimed sheep lymph node leucocytes. This methodology would permit achievement of more detailed studies on interactions between Salmonella and lymph node leucocytes, leading to a better understanding of the mechanisms controlling bacterial dissemination through the lymphoid tissue.

Detection of mucosal immune responses in chickens after immunization or infection

In order to measure mucosal antibody responses in the chicken intestine an ELISA-based assay was developed that was able to detect antigen-specific antibodies in an isotype-specific way. Locally produced antibodies could be detected after overnight culture at 37 degrees C. In particular the production of IgA, more than IgM and IgG, was significantly increased by immunization of the animals with K99 pilus antigen or by infection with Eimeria tenella parasites. Data presented here indicate that the assay can be used to estimate the magnitude of the mucosal antibody response in experimental conditions where antibody levels in bile or intestinal contents were not significantly changed.

Development of the B- and T-cell compartments in porcine lymphoid organs from birth to adult life: an immunohistological approach

Using immunohistological techniques, we studied the development over time of B- and T-cell compartments in the lymphoid organs of specific-pathogen-free pigs. Tissue samples were collected at various time-points, starting 2 days before the pigs were born until the pigs were 10 months old. The samples were collected from the spleen, thymus, peripheral lymph node, mesenteric lymph node, duodenum, jejunum, ileum, jejunal Peyer's patch and ileal Peyer's patch. Monoclonal antibodies specific to B- and T-cells were used to identify where the following cells were localized: IgM-B cells (cells positive to surface immunoglobulin), IgM-, IgG- and IgA-containing cells (cells positive to cytoplasmic immunoglobulin), and CD2-, CD4- and CD8-positive cells. The development of the B- and T-cell subpopulations in each organ was analysed. Two days before birth, most organs contained quantities of IgM-B cells. The spleen, lymph nodes, Peyer's patches and, notably, the thymus, contained some immunoglobulin-containing cells (Ig-CC); this finding indicates that pigs have cells that secrete immunoglobulins before birth. Just after birth, the incidence of Ig-CC increased in most organs; first IgM-CC increased, then either IgG- or IgA-CC increased, depending on the organ. T-cell development was observed clearly in spleen and in the lamina propria of the small intestine, in contrast to other organs, in which the T-cell compartments containing various T-cell subpopulations were well developed before birth. Comparison of the incidence of CD4+ and CD8+ cells showed that the CD4:CD8 ratio of these cells in the spleen, lymph nodes, Peyer's patches and small intestine is low, especially in adult pigs, compared with the CD4:CD8 ratio in other species. Weaning had little influence on the incidence of B- and T-cells in lymphoid organs. This study is the first immunohistological survey to describe the development of the major B- and T-cell subpopulations in various lymphoid organs of pigs, and it should be useful for future immunopathological and comparative immunological studies in pigs.