Is there a correlation between continuous neurogenesis and directed axon regeneration in the vertebrate nervous system?

Why Has the Ability to Regenerate Following CNS Injury Been Repeatedly Lost Over the Course of Evolution?

While many vertebrates can regenerate both damaged neurons and severed axons in the central nervous system (CNS) following injury, others, including all birds and mammals, have lost this ability for reasons that are still unclear. The repeated evolutionary loss of regenerative competence seems counterintuitive, and any explanation must account for the fact that regenerative competence is lost in both cold-blooded and all warm-blooded clades, that both injury-induced neurogenesis and axonal regeneration tend to be lost in tandem, and that mammals have evolved dedicated gene regulatory networks to inhibit injury-induced glia-to-neuron reprogramming. Here, different hypotheses that have been proposed to account for evolutionary loss of regenerative competence are discussed in the light of new insights obtained into molecular mechanisms that control regeneration in the central nervous system. These include pleiotropic effects of continuous growth, enhanced thyroid hormone signaling, prevention of neoplasia, and improved memory consolidation. Recent evidence suggests that the most compelling hypothesis, however, may be selection for greater resistance to the spread of intra-CNS infections, which has led to both enhanced reactive gliosis and a loss of injury-induced neurogenesis and axonal regeneration. Means of testing these hypotheses, and additional data that are urgently needed to better understand the evolutionary pressures and mechanisms driving loss of regenerative competence, are also discussed.

Regeneration in anamniotes was replaced by regengrow and scarring in amniotes after land colonization and the evolution of terrestrial biological cycles

An evolutionary hypothesis explaining failure of regeneration among vertebrates is presented. Regeneration derives from postembryonic processes present during the life cycles of fish and amphibians that include larval and metamorphic phases with broad organ reorganizations. Developmental programs imprinted in their genomes are re-utilized with variations also in adults for regeneration. When vertebrates colonized land adopting the amniotic egg, some genes driving larval changes, and metamorphosis were lost and new genes evolved, further limiting regeneration. These included neural inhibitors for maintaining complex nervous systems, behavior and various levels of intelligence, and adaptive immune cells. The latter, that in anamniotes are executioners of metamorphic reorganization, became intolerant to embryonic-oncofetal-antigens impeding organ regeneration, a process that requires de-differentiation of adult cells and/or expansion of stem cells where these early antigens are formed. The evolution of terrestrial lifecycles produced vertebrates with complex bodies but no longer capable to regenerate their organs, mainly repaired by regengrow. Efforts of regenerative medicine to improve healing in humans should determine the diverse developmental pathways evolved between anamniotes and amniotes before attempting genetic manipulations such as the introduction of "anamniote regenerative genes" in amniotes. This operation may determine alteration in amniote developmental programs leading to teratomes, cancer, or death.

Molecular complexity of visual mapping: a challenge for regenerating therapy

Investigating the cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in the development of topographically ordered connections in the central nervous system constitutes an important issue in neurobiology because these connections are the base of the central nervous system normal function. The dominant model to study the development of topographic maps is the projection from the retinal ganglion cells to the optic tectum/colliculus. The expression pattern of Eph/ephrin system in opposing gradients both in the retina and the tectum, labels the local addresses on the target and gives specific sensitivities to growth cones according to their topographic origin in the retina. The rigid precision of normal retinotopic mapping has prompted the chemoaffinity hypothesis, positing axonal targeting to be based on fixed biochemical affinities between fibers and targets. However, several lines of evidence have shown that the mapping can adjust to experimentally modified targets with flexibility, demonstrating the robustness of the guidance process. Here we discuss the complex ways the Ephs and ephrins interact allowing to understand how the retinotectal mapping is a precise but also a flexible process.

Salamander spinal cord regeneration: The ultimate positive control in vertebrate spinal cord regeneration

Repairing injured tissues / organs is one of the major challenges for the maintenance of proper organ function in adulthood. In mammals, the central nervous system including the spinal cord, once established during embryonic development, has very limited capacity to regenerate. In contrast, salamanders such as axolotls can fully regenerate the injured spinal cord, making this a very powerful vertebrate model system for studying this process. Here we discuss the cellular and molecular requirements for spinal cord regeneration in the axolotl. The recent development of tools to test molecular function, including CRISPR-mediated gene editing, has lead to the identification of key players involved in the cell response to injury that ultimately leads to outgrowth of neural stem cells that are competent to replay the process of spinal cord development to replace the damaged/missing tissue.

Does repair of spinal cord injury follow the evolutionary theory?

Lower vertebrates, such as fish and amphibians, and higher vertebrates in embryonic development can acquire complete regeneration of complex body structures, including the spinal cord, an important part of the central nervous system. However, with species evolution and development, this regenerative capacity gradually weakens and even disappears, but the cellular and molecular mechanisms remain poorly understood. We explored the differences in mechanisms of spinal cord regeneration capability between lower and higher vertebrates, investigated differences in their cellular and molecular mechanisms and between the spinal cord structures of lower vertebrates and mammals, such as rat and monkey, to search for theoretical evidence and therapeutic targets for nerve regeneration in human spinal cord.

Neurogenesis and growth factors expression after complete spinal cord transection in Pleurodeles waltlii

Following spinal lesion, connections between the supra-spinal centers and spinal neuronal networks can be disturbed, which causes the deterioration or even the complete absence of sublesional locomotor activity. In mammals, possibilities of locomotion restoration are much reduced since descending tracts either have very poor regenerative ability or do not regenerate at all. However, in lower vertebrates, there is spontaneous locomotion recuperation after complete spinal cord transection at the mid-trunk level. This phenomenon depends on a translesional descending axon re-growth originating from the brainstem. On the other hand, cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying spinal cord regeneration and in parallel, locomotion restoration of the animal, are not well known. Fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) plays an important role in different processes such as neural induction, neuronal progenitor proliferation and their differentiation. Studies had shown an over expression of this growth factor after tail amputation. Nestin, a protein specific for intermediate filaments, is considered an early marker for neuronal precursors. It has been recently shown that its expression increases after tail transection in urodeles. Using this marker and western blots, our results show that the number of FGF-2 and FGFR2 mRNAs increases and is correlated with an increase in neurogenesis especially in the central canal lining cells immediately after lesion. This study also confirms that spinal cord re-growth through the lesion site initially follows a rostrocaudal direction. In addition to its role known in neuronal differentiation, FGF-2 could be implicated in the differentiation of ependymal cells into neuronal progenitors.

Sciatic nerve injury model in the axolotl: functional, electrophysiological, and radiographic outcomes

OBJECT

The 2 aims of this study were as follows: 1) to establish outcome measures of nerve regeneration in an axolotl model of peripheral nerve injury; and 2) to define the timing and completeness of reinnervation in the axolotl following different types of sciatic nerve injury.

METHODS

The sciatic nerves in 36 axolotls were exposed bilaterally in 3 groups containing 12 animals each: Group 1, left side sham, right side crush; Group 2, left side sham, right side nerve resected and proximal stump buried; and Group 3 left side cut and sutured, right side cut and sutured with tibial and peroneal divisions reversed. Outcome measures included the following: 1) an axolotl sciatic functional index (ASFI) derived from video swim analysis; 2) motor latencies; and 3) MR imaging evaluation of nerve and muscle edema.

RESULTS

For crush injuries, the ASFI returned to baseline by 2 weeks, as did MR imaging parameters and motor latencies. For buried nerves, the ASFI returned to 20% below baseline by 8 weeks, with motor evoked potentials present. On MR imaging, nerve edema peaked at 3 days postintervention and gradually normalized over 12 weeks, whereas muscle denervation was present until a gradual decrease was seen between 4 and 12 weeks. For cut nerves, the ASFI returned to 20% below baseline by Week 4, where it plateaued. Motor evoked potentials were observed at 2-4 weeks, but with an increased latency until Week 6, and MR imaging analysis revealed muscle denervation for 4 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple outcome measures in which an axolotl model of peripheral nerve injury is used have been established. Based on historical controls, recovery after nerve injury appears to occur earlier and is more complete than in rodents. Further investigation using this model as a successful "blueprint" for nerve regeneration in humans is warranted.

Considering the evolution of regeneration in the central nervous system

For many years the mammalian CNS has been seen as an organ that is unable to regenerate. However, it was also long known that lower vertebrate species are capable of impressive regeneration of CNS structures. How did this situation arise through evolution? Increasing cellular and molecular understanding of regeneration in different animal species coupled with studies of adult neurogenesis in mammals is providing a basis for addressing this question. Here we compare CNS regeneration among vertebrates and speculate on how this ability may have emerged or been restricted.

Origin of spinal cord axons in the lizard regenerated tail: supernormal projections from local spinal neurons

During tail regeneration most lizards also regenerate the tail spinal cord. The regenerated spinal cord primarily contains neuroepithelium (i.e., the ependymal tube which forms the central canal) and descending axons. The present experiments identify the source of the axons in the regenerated spinal cord. Application of HRP to normal tail spinal cord resulted in labeled cells in the nucleus paraventricularis, the interstitial nucleus of the fasciculus longitudinalis medialis, the nucleus ruber, the medullary reticular formation (including raphe nuclei), as well as in vestibular nuclei. HRP applied to the regenerated spinal cord labeled only 4% of the cells seen in normal animals, and these were confined to rhombencephalic nuclei. The lack of labeling of more rostral nuclei was not due to the death of descending neurons. Application of HRP immediately rostral to the regenerated spinal cord resulted in the labeling of a normal, and in some cases, greater than normal, number of neurons. To quantify the origin of axons in the regenerated spinal cord, electron microscopic montages of the regenerated spinal cord were made and the number of axons counted, before and after various spinal lesions. Only lesions within one spinal segment of the regenerated spinal cord had a significant effect on the number of axons in the regenerated tail spinal cord. This indicated that most of the regenerated axons were of local spinal origin. A significant increase in the number of labeled local spinal neurons was revealed following application of HRP to a regenerated tail spinal cord. These results suggest that while various portions of the lizard central nervous system can grow axons into the regenerating tail spinal cord, the great majority of axons in the regenerate are of local origin and that some of these arise from neurons that do not normally possess descending projections. Finally, to test whether new neurons were participating in the regeneration process, 3H-thymidine was injected during the regrowth of the tail. No labeled spinal cord cells were conclusively identified as neurons. Thus, the regenerating lizard tail spinal cord exhibits robust axonal sprouting from neurons near the site of a spinal transection in a manner reminiscent of sprouting in the mammalian CNS. This sprouting can develop into descending spinal projections that extend for significant distances into the regenerated tail spinal cord and provides a unique model for exploring the requirements for successful axon growth in an adult vertebrate CNS.

Growth and pathfinding of regenerating axons in the optic projection of adult fish

In contrast to mammals, teleost fish are able to regrow severed long-range projection axons in the central nervous system (CNS), leading to recovery of function. The optic projection in teleost fish is used to study neuron-intrinsic and environmental molecular factors that determine successful axon regrowth and navigation through a complex CNS pathway back to original targets. Here we review evidence for regeneration-specific regulation and robust expression of growth- and pathfinding-associated genes in regenerating retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons of adult fish. The environment of the CNS in fish appears to contain few inhibitory molecules and at the same time a number of promoting molecules for axon regrowth. Finally, some environmental cues that are used as guidance cues for developing RGC axons are also present in continuously growing adult animals. These molecules may serve as guidance cues for the precise navigation of axons from newly generated RGCs in adult animals as well as of regenerating RGC axons after a lesion. The application of new molecular techniques especially to adult zebrafish, is likely to produce new insights into successful axonal regeneration in the CNS of fish and the absence thereof in mammals.

The Developing Human Spinal Cord Contains Distinct Populations of Neural Precursors

It is becoming apparent that neural stem cells display some differences in their behaviour depending on the region of the CNS they originate from and on whether they are derived from embryonic or adult tissue. Whereas much work has focused on brain neural stem cells, less attention has been paid to spinal cord neural precursors, particularly in the developing human embryo. We briefly review here some of our work which points at some similarities between neural precursors in developing human spinal cords and in animals which can regenerate their spinal cord (e.g. tailed amphibians), and at differences in the properties of human neural precursors with spinal cord development. Altogether these studies suggest the existence of dynamic neural stem cell populations within the developing spinal cord. They also support the notion that thorough characterization of neural stem cells under different culture conditions and analysis of how these may affect their differentiation in vivo after grafting into different injury models is imperative if we are to develop effective cell therapy strategies for spinal cord injury and diseases.

Functional recovery and axonal growth following spinal cord transection is accelerated by sustained l-DOPA administration

The eel, Anguilla anguilla, as with other fish species, recovers well from spinal cord injury. We assessed the quality of locomotion of spinally transected eels from measurements made from video recordings of individuals swimming at different speeds in a water tunnel. Following transection of the spinal cord just caudal to the anus, the animals displayed higher tail beat frequencies and lower tail beat amplitudes than before surgery, owing to the loss of power in this region. Swimming performance then progressively recovered, appearing normal within 1 month of surgery. Eels with similar transections, but given regular, repeated intraperitoneal injections (50 mg/kg) of l-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (L-DOPA) showed an equivalent pattern of decline and recovery that was 10-20 days shorter than that seen in non-treated fish. Axonal growth into the denervated cord, as determined from anterograde labelling experiments, was also more rapid in the drug-treated fish. L-DOPA treatment increased the activity of all fish for up to 18 h, and accelerated the spontaneous movements ('spinal swimming') made by the denervated, caudal portion of the animal that appeared following transection. We suggest that this enhancement of locomotion underlies the accelerated axonal growth and, hence, functional recovery.

Radial glial cells, proliferating periventricular cells, and microglia might contribute to successful structural repair in the cerebral cortex of the lizard Gallotia galloti

Reptiles are the only amniotic vertebrates known to be capable of spontaneous regeneration of the central nervous system (CNS). In this study, we analyzed the reactive changes of glial cells in response to a unilateral physical lesion in the cerebral cortex of the lizard Gallotia galloti, at 1, 3, 15, 30, 120, and 240 days postlesion. The glial cell markers glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), glutamine synthetase (GS), S100 protein, and tomato lectin, as well as proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) were used to evaluate glial changes occurring because of cortical lesions. A transitory and unilateral upregulation of GFAP and GS in reactive radial glial cells were observed from 15 to 120 days postlesion. In addition, reactive lectin-positive macrophage/microglia were observed from 1 to 120 days postlesion, whereas the expression of S100 protein remained unchanged throughout the examined postlesion period. The matricial zones closest to the lesion site, the sulcus lateralis (SL) and the sulcus septomedialis (SSM), showed significantly increased numbers of dividing cells at 30 days postlesion. At 240 days postlesion, the staining pattern for PCNA, GFAP, GS, and tomato lectin in the lesion site became similar to that observed in unlesioned controls. In addition, ultrastructural data of the lesioned cortex at 240 days postlesion indicated a structural repair process. We conclude that restoration of the glial framework and generation of new neurons and glial cells in the ventricular wall play a key role in the successful structural repair of the cerebral cortex of the adult lizard.

Morphology of brachial segments in mudpuppy (Necturus maculosus) spinal cord studied with confocal and electron microscopy

The isolated brachial spinal cord of Necturus maculosus is useful for studies of neural networks underlying forelimb locomotion, but information about its cellular morphology is scarce. We addressed this issue by using confocal and electron microscopy. Remarkably, the central region of gray matter was aneural and consisted exclusively of a tenuous meshwork of glial fibers and large extracellular spaces. Somata of motoneurons (MNs) and interneurons (INs), labeled by retrograde transport of fluorescent tracers from ventral roots and axons in the ventrolateral funiculus, respectively, were confined within a gray neuropil layer abutting the white matter borders, whereas their dendrites projected widely throughout the white matter. About one-third of labeled INs were found contralaterally, with axons crossing ventral to a thick layer of ependyma surrounding the central canal. Lateral MN dendrites proliferated under the pial surface to form a dense, thin (1-2 microm) plexus immediately beneath a thin layer of glial fibrillary acidic protein-positive glia limitans. The latter contained arrays of unusual tubular structures (diameter 200-400 nm, length 3 microm) that resembled mitochondria but lacked double membranes or cristae. Dorsal roots (DRs) produced dense presynaptic arbors within a wedge-shaped afferent termination zone medial to the dorsal root entry, within which dendrites of MNs and INs mingled with dense collections of synaptic boutons. Our data suggest that a major fraction of synaptic interactions takes place within the white matter. This study provides a detailed foundation for designing electrophysiological experiments to study the neural circuits involved in locomotor pattern generation.

Urodele spinal cord regeneration and related processes

Urodele amphibians, newts and salamanders, can regenerate lesioned spinal cord at any stage of the life cycle and are the only tetrapod vertebrates that regenerate spinal cord completely as adults. The ependymal cells play a key role in this process in both gap replacement and caudal regeneration. The ependymal response helps to produce a different response to neural injury compared with mammalian neural injury. The regenerating urodele cord produces new neurons as well as supporting axonal regrowth. It is not yet clear to what extent urodele spinal cord regeneration recapitulates embryonic anteroposterior and dorsoventral patterning gene expression to achieve functional reconstruction. The source of axial patterning signals in regeneration would be substantially different from those in developing tissue, perhaps with signals propagated from the stump tissue. Examination of the effects of fibroblast growth factor and epidermal growth factor on ependymal cells in vivo and in vitro suggest a connection with neural stem cell behavior as described in developing and mature mammalian central nervous system. This review coordinates the urodele regeneration literature with axial patterning, stem cell, and neural injury literature from other systems to describe our current understanding and assess the gaps in our knowledge about urodele spinal cord regeneration.

Recruitment of postmitotic neurons into the regenerating spinal cord of urodeles

By using fluorescent tracers, we have investigated the origin of the cells that form the regenerating spinal cord after tail amputation in urodele amphibians. We show that spinal cord cells immediately adjacent to the amputation plane die and are removed by phagocytic cells. Spinal cells just anterior to these dying cells are destined to make the majority of the regenerating cord. The largest contribution is likely to come from the radial ependymal cells, but we also demonstrate that postmitotic neurons in this location can translocate into the regenerating cord. These neurons integrate into the regenerate structure and survive for at least 4 weeks. We find no evidence that these translocated neurons dedifferentiate and divide during this regeneration process. We discuss the possibility that these neurons survive long term in the regenerate cord and become part of the functional neuronal circuitry.

Changes in spinal cord regenerative ability through phylogenesis and development: lessons to be learnt

Lower vertebrates, such as fish and amphibians, and developing higher vertebrates can regenerate complex body structures, including significant portions of their central nervous system. It is still poorly understood why this potential is lost with evolution and development and becomes very limited in adult mammals. In this review, we will discuss the current knowledge on the cellular and molecular changes after spinal cord injury in adult tailed amphibians, where regeneration does take place, and in developing chick and mammalian embryos at different developmental stages. We will focus on the recruitment of progenitor cells to repair the damage and discuss possible roles of changes in early response to injury, such as cell death by apoptosis, and of myelin-associated proteins, such as Nogo, in the transition between regeneration-competent and regeneration-incompetent stages of development. A better understanding of the mechanisms underlying spontaneous regeneration of the spinal cord in vivo in amphibians and in the chick embryo will help to devise strategies for restoring function to damaged or diseased nervous tissues in mammals.

Ectoderm to mesoderm lineage switching during axolotl tail regeneration

Foreign environments may induce adult stem cells to switch lineages and populate multiple tissue types, but whether this mechanism is used for tissue repair remains uncertain. Urodele amphibians can regenerate fully functional, multitissue structures including the limb and tail. To determine whether lineage switching is an integral feature of this regeneration, we followed individual spinal cord cells live during tail regeneration in the axolotl. Spinal cord cells frequently migrate into surrounding tissue to form regenerating muscle and cartilage. Thus, in axolotls, cells switch lineage during a real example of regeneration.

Is the capacity for optic nerve regeneration related to continued retinal ganglion cell production in the frog?

In the central nervous system of fish and frogs, some, but not all, axons can regenerate. Retinal ganglion cells are among those that can. The retinae of fish and frogs produce new retinal neurons, including ganglion cells, for months or years after hatching. We have evaluated the hypothesis that retinal axonal regeneration is obligatorily linked to continued production of new ganglion cells. We used bromodeoxyuridine immunocytochemistry to assess retinal neurogenesis in juvenile, yearling, and 10 year old Xenopus laevis. Retinal ganglion cell genesis was vigorous in the marginal retina of the juveniles, but in the yearlings and the 10 year olds, no new ganglion cells were produced there. Cellular proliferation in the central retina was evident at all three ages, but none of the cells produced centrally were in the ganglion cell layer. Regeneration was examined in vivo by cutting one optic nerve and then, weeks later, injecting the eye with tritiated proline. Autoradiographs of brain sections showed that the optic nerves of all three ages regenerated. Regeneration in vitro was assessed using retinal explants from frogs of all three ages. In all cases, the cultures produced neurites, with some age-specific differences in the patterns of outgrowth. We conclude that retinal axonal regeneration is not linked obligatorily to maintained neurogenesis.

Increase in descending brain-spinal cord projections with age in larval lamprey: implications for spinal cord injury

The purpose of this study was to determine whether new descending brain-spinal cord projections are added with age in larval lamprey and might contribute substantially to restoration of these projections following spinal cord injury. Retrograde horseradish peroxidase (HRP) labeling of descending brain neurons was performed in "young" and "old" larval lamprey that differed in age by at least one year. In old larval lamprey, significantly more descending brain neurons projected to specific rostral levels of the spinal cord than in young animals. Furthermore, in young and old lamprey, the main morphological change in Müller and Mauthner cells was an increase in soma size. The major conclusion from the present study is that in larval lamprey, some new brain-spinal cord projections are added with age that could be due to axonal elongation by preexisting brain neurons and/or descending projections from new neurons (i.e., neurogenesis or maturation of incompletely differentiated neurons). Following spinal cord transections, the numbers of descending projections were not significantly different than those in normal, unlesioned animals. Thus, some new descending projections are added with age, but at a relatively slow rate, and the rate does not appear to be affected significantly by spinal cord transections. Together, the present results and those from our recent double-labeling study suggest that following spinal cord transection in larval lamprey, axonal regeneration by descending brain neurons, rather than the relatively slow addition of new brain-spinal cord projections with age, probably accounts for the majority of restored projections and recovery of locomotor function

The lizard cerebral cortex as a model to study neuronal regeneration

The medial cerebral cortex of lizards, an area homologous to the hippocampal fascia dentata, shows delayed postnatal neurogenesis, i.e., cells in the medial cortex ependyma proliferate and give rise to immature neurons, which migrate to the cell layer. There, recruited neurons differentiate and give rise to zinc containing axons directed to the rest of cortical areas, thus resulting in a continuous growth of the medial cortex and its zinc-enriched axonal projection. This happens along the lizard life span, even in adult lizards, thus allowing one of their most important characteristics: neuronal regeneration. Experiments in our laboratory have shown that chemical lesion of the medial cortex (affecting up to 95% of its neurons) results in a cascade of events: first, massive neuronal death and axonal-dendritic retraction and, secondly, triggered ependymal-neuroblast proliferation and subsequent neo-histogenesis and regeneration of an almost new medial cortex, indistinguishable from a normal undamaged one. This is the only case to our knowledge of the regeneration of an amniote central nervous centre by new neuron production and neo-histogenesis. Thus the lizard cerebral cortex is a good model to study neuronal regeneration and the complex factors that regulate its neurogenetic, migratory and neo-synaptogenetic events.

Continued neurogenesis is not a pre-requisite for regeneration of a topographic retino-tectal projection

Electrophysiological recording demonstrated that visuo-tectal projections are topographically organised after optic nerve regeneration in aged Xenopus laevis. 3H-thymidine autoradiography confirmed previous reports [Taylor, Lack, & Easter, Eur. Journal of Neuroscience 1 (1989) 626-638] that cell division had already ceased at the retinal ciliary margin. The results demonstrate that, contrary to a previous suggestion [Holder & Clarke, Trends in Neuroscience 11 (1988) 94-99], continued neurogenesis is not a pre-requisite for the re-establishment of appropriate connections with target cells.

Axonal regeneration of descending brain neurons in larval lamprey demonstrated by retrograde double labeling

In larval lamprey, the large, identified descending brain neurons (Müller and Mauthner cells) are capable of axonal regeneration. However, smaller, unidentified descending brain neurons, such as many of the reticulospinal (RS) neurons, probably initiate locomotion, and it is not known whether the majority of these neurons regenerate their axons after spinal cord transection. In the present study, this issue was addressed by using double labeling of descending brain neurons. In double-label control animals, in which Fluoro-Gold (FG) was applied to the spinal cord at 40% body length (BL; measured from anterior to posterior from tip of head) and Texas red dextran amine (TRDA) was applied later to the spinal cord at 20% BL, an average of 98% of descending brain neurons were double labeled. In double-label experimental animals, FG was applied to the spinal cord at 40% BL; two weeks later the spinal cord was transected at 10% BL; and, eight weeks or 16 weeks after spinal cord transection, TRDA was applied to the spinal cord at 20% BL. At eight weeks and 16 weeks after spinal cord transection, an average of 49% and 68%, respectively, of descending brain neurons, including many unidentified RS neurons, were double labeled. These results in larval lamprey are the first to demonstrate that the majority of descending brain neurons, including small, unidentified RS neurons, regenerate their axons after spinal cord transection. Therefore, in spinal cord-transected lamprey, axonal regeneration of descending brain neurons probably contributes significantly to the recovery of locomotor function.

Spinal Cord Injury: Lessons from Locomotor Recovery and Axonal Regeneration in Lower Vertebrates

After severe spinal cord injury in adult higher vertebrates (birds and mammals), there normally is little or no axonal regeneration and virtually no recovery of voluntary locomotor function below the lesion. In contrast, certain lower vertebrates, including lamprey, fish, and some amphibians, exhibit robust axonal regeneration and substantial recovery of locomotor function after spinal cord injury. The remarkable behavioral recovery of lower vertebrates with spinal cord injuries is due to at least three factors: 1) minimal hemorrhagic necrosis at the injury site and the lack of a neurite growth–inhibiting astrocytic scar, 2) an environment in the spinal cord that is permissive for axonal regeneration, and 3) mechanisms for directed axonal elongation and selection of appropriate postsynaptic targets. The latter two features probably represent developmental mechanisms for axonal guidance and synaptogenesis that persist in the nervous systems of these animals well beyond the main phase of neural development. In the injured spinal cords of higher vertebrates, the full complement of manipulations necessary to promote functional regeneration and behavioral recovery is unknown. An understanding of the mechanisms that result in repair of spinal cord injuries in lower vertebrates may provide guidelines for identifying the requirements for functional spinal cord regeneration in higher vertebrates, including humans.

The primary visual system of adult lizards demonstrates that neurogenesis is not obligatorily linked to central nerve regeneration but may be a prerequisite for the restoration of maps in the brain

Following optic nerve crush in the adult lizard Ctenophorus ornatus, most retinal ganglion cells regrow their axons into visual brain centres: however, the regenerated projections lack retinotopic order and the animals are blind via the experimental eye. Here we have used 3H-thymidine autoradiography to demonstrate that cell division is no longer taking place in the retina of normal adult lizards. We conclude that the optic nerve can regenerate in lizard even though cells are no longer being added to the retina. However, continued retinal neurogenesis may be linked to the ability to restore topographic maps.

Chiasmatic specificity in the regenerating mammalian optic nerve

The mammalian central nervous system is capable of regenerating; however, there is no evidence that the regenerating axons can navigate along their normal pathways and reestablish topographically organized projections: essential for functional return of vision. Here retinal ganglion cells in the opossum Monodelphis were birthdated with tritiated thymidine on the sixth postnatal day (P6), before being lesioned in the temporal retina at P8. Retrograde tracing with horseradish peroxidase injected into the ipsilateral optic tract at P24 showed that the temporal crescent had reformed behind the retinal lesion. By comparisons of cell and thymidine counts from lesioned and control regions of retina, it was estimated that about 40% of the normal number of ganglion cells are able to regenerate into the ipsilateral optic tract following a lesion in the temporal retina at P8. A clear line of decussation (separation of ipsilateral and contralateral projections) reformed in the lesioned temporal retina and regenerating ganglion cells labeled with DiI were turned at appropriate points on passing through the optic chiasm. This is evidence of chiasmatic specificity with regard to lesioned retinal ganglion cells regenerating into the ipsilateral optic tract.

Possible roles for Wnt genes in growth and axial patterning during regeneration of the tail in urodele amphibians

Urodele amphibians are nearly the only adult vertebrates able to regenerate their missing or amputated tail. An interesting aspect of this biological model lies in the ability of regenerates to differentiate the spinal cord (SC), the vertebral cartilage, and muscles. The main questions addressed in this study concern the possible roles of Wnt genes in these regenerative processes. We have previously reported the expression pattern of a Pleurodeles Waltl wnt-10a gene (Pwnt-10a) in tail blastema (Caubit et al. [1997] Dev. Dyn. 208:139-148). We report here the cloning and tissue distribution of three additional Wnt genes (Pwnt-5a, Pwnt-5b, and Pwnt-7a) in adult and regenerating tail tissues and in the central nervous system (CNS) of adult newt. In adult and regenerating tails, Pwnt-5a and Pwnt-5b transcripts exhibit a graded distribution along the antero-posterior (A-P) axis, the maximal accumulation of these transcripts being detected in the mesenchyme within the subectodermal apical region of the normal tail and blastema. In contrast to Pwnt-5a and Pwnt-5b, Pwnt-7a is expressed in adult normal tail skin and in the epidermis of the regenerating tail. In the adult CNS, Pwnt-5a, Pwnt-5b, Pwnt-7a, and Pwnt-10a genes are expressed in sharp overlapping but not identical domains along the A-P axis. The sustained expression of Wnt genes in the adult newt and the spatial distribution of transcripts in adult and regenerating tail tissues suggest roles of these genes in continuous growth capacities in the urodeles and may explain the ability for CNS and tail regeneration.

Optic nerve regenerates but does not restore topographic projections in the lizard Ctenophorus ornatus

In adult fish and amphibians, the severed optic nerve regenerates and visual behaviour is restored. By contrast, optic axons do not regenerate in the more recently evolved birds and mammals. Here we have investigated optic nerve regeneration in a member of the class Reptilia, phylogenetically intermediate between the fish and amphibians and the birds and mammals. We assessed visual recovery anatomically and behaviourally one year after unilateral optic nerve crush in the adult ornate dragon lizard. Ctenophorus ornatus. Ganglion cell densities and numbers of axons in the optic nerve on either side of the crush site indicated that two-thirds of ganglion cells survived axotomy and regrew their axons. However, myelination fell from a mean of 21% in normals to 5.5% and 3%, proximal and distal to the crush, respectively. Anterograde labelling of the entire optic nerve showed that axons regenerated along essentially normal pathways and that the major projection, as in normals, was to the superficial one-third of the contralateral optic tectum. However, localised retinal injections indicated that regenerated projections lacked retinotopic order. Any one retinal region projected to the entire tectum. This feature presumably explains why the experimental lizards consistently appeared blind to stimuli via the regenerated nerve. Our findings indicate that although axons regenerate along essentially normal pathways in adult lizards, conditions within the visual centres do not allow regenerating optic axons to select appropriate central connections. In a wider context, the result suggests that the ability for regenerating central axons to form topographic maps may also have been lost in the more recently evolved vertebrate classes.

Development and role of retinal glia in regeneration of ganglion cells following retinal injury

AIMS/BACKGROUND

Recent observations have shown that the glial scar resulting from a surgical lesion of the immature retina differs from elsewhere in the central nervous system, in that it permits the through growth and reconnection of regenerating axons. This study in the opossum examines in detail the development and reaction to injury of retinal glia at different developmental stages, and specifically examines the distribution of the gliosis related inhibitory molecule, chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan (CSPG), making comparisons with a control site of gliosis in the cerebral cortex.

METHODS

A linear slit was cut into the retina or cortex with a fine tungsten probe. After a variable time delay, immunocytochemistry of the resulting gliosis was employed to detect astrocytes with glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), Müller cells with vimentin, and CSPG with CS-56 antibodies. GFAP was also used at different ages to examine the normal development of astrocytes in the retina of this species.

RESULTS

Astrocytes entered the retina 12 days after birth (P12), closely associated with blood vessels in the nerve fibre layer. In experiments at all ages studied, cellular continuity was re-established across the lesioned retina, which did not result in a significant astrocyte proliferation or CSPG expression. In contrast, cortical injury led to the development of a cystic cavity surrounded by astrocytes and CSPG. Müller cells expressed GFAP but not CSPG in the lesioned retina.

CONCLUSION

Successful regrowth of ganglion cells through a retinal lesion may be partly the result of the scarcity of astrocytes in the retina, which results in minimal gliosis, or of their apparent inability to express inhibitory molecules.

Clonal cell cultures from adult spinal cord of the amphibian urodele Pleurodeles waltl to study the identity and potentialities of cells during tail regeneration

The urodele amphibians are nearly the only adult vertebrates able to regenerate their missing or amputated tail. The most striking feature of this model lies in the ability of the spinal cord (SC) to differentiate, within the regenerating tail, a new ependymal tube from which the SC and the peripheral nervous system originate. A fundamental question is whether, in response to tail excision, the ependymoglia of the old SC stump behaves as an embryonic neuroepithelium. To evaluate this possibility, cell lines from primary cell cultures of adult SC were established for the first time in newts, and two cell clones, immunochemically characterized as ependymoglial cell populations, could be obtained. To analyze the potentialities of these clonal cells, after transplantation in tail regenerates, cell-marking experiments, using either in vitro transfection with lacZ gene or the lineage tracer lysinated rhodamine dextran (LRD), were performed. One to 2 weeks postimplantation, most of labeled derivatives were identified as melanocytes. Interestingly, labeled cells were also seen integrated in the ependymoglia of the regenerating SC. Two to 6 weeks after implantation in young regenerates, we also observed LRD-labeled elongated cells close to nerves or myofibers which were unambiguously identified as Schwann cells by galactocerebroside staining. Taken together, these findings showed that clonal cells derived from adult newt SC cultures could largely find, in regenerate mesenchyme, suitable environmental conditions to differentiate into melanocytes or Schwann cells. Because these two cells types arise from neural crest cells during embryo-genesis, this supports the interesting view that multipotent cells are still present in the SC of adult urodeles.

A critical period for axon regrowth through a lesion in the developing mammalian retina

Although the central nervous system of mature mammals is incapable of regeneration, certain elements present in the developing system must permit and promote the growth of new axons to their initial targets. We investigate whether the environment of a developing visual system is capable of supporting regeneration in the Brazilian opossum Monodelphis domestica, in which the retinofugal system develops postnatally. Retinae were lesioned up to the 16th postnatal day and analysed for regeneration after a further 7-10 days. Anterograde tracing with Dil showed axons to have regrown from the axotomized area of retina directly through the lesion. Retrograde tracing with horseradish peroxidase injected into the superior colliculus confirmed that axons from the lesioned area of retina had grown to an appropriate position in the midbrain. The proportion of retinae in which axonal continuity was restored across the lesion decreased as the visual system matured, falling to zero after the 12th postnatal day. Thus a critical period exists in the postnatal opossum in which a retinal lesion permits axon passage. Correlating these results to the known pattern of retinofugal pathway development provides an insight into factors that may restrict this critical period to the 12th postnatal day, and suggests that at least some of the axotomized neurons are regenerating.

Reactive neurogenesis during regeneration of the lesioned medial cerebral cortex of lizards

This study reports that lesion of the adult lizard medial cortex (lizard hippocampal fascia dentata) induces a short period of intensive neurogenesis which we have termed reactive neurogenesis; a cell proliferation event that occurs in the subjacent ependyma. Specific lesion of the medial cortex was achieved by intraperitoneal injection of the neurotoxin 3-acetylpyridine and proliferating cells were detected using tritiated thymidine or 5-bromodeoxiuridine pulse labelling. After lesion, granule neurons in the lizard medial cortex cell layer appeared pyknotic and died; they were then removed and progressively replaced by a set of new neurons. These neurons were mostly generated from the second to the seventh day post-lesion. A dramatic temporal increment of labelled ependymal cells was detected when either tritiated thymidine or 5-bromodeoxiuridine pulses were delivered in that period. The maximum of about five thousand labelled cells per hemisphere was reached by the fourth day after the lesion. Beyond the seventh day post-lesion, the numbers of labelled cells returned to a level of about four hundred per hemisphere, similar to that of the control specimens. Electron microscopy revealed that the recently generated cells were neuroblasts or immature neurons with a characteristic pattern of chromatin condensation and a high number of ribonucleic granules.

Relations between development and regeneration of tadpole spinal cord

1. The developing spinal cords of bullfrogs and transected cords of stage IV tadpoles were subjected to two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and histological analysis. During development, the level of actin, alpha-tubulin or beta-tubulin in the 7-10th spinal segments increased with time and reached a maximum around stage XIII followed by a decrease, as shown from quantitative assay on protein spots of 2-dimensional gels of cord homogenates. In contrast, the level of 68 kD neurofilament subunit (NF68) was low in tadpoles but high in frog. 2. Following a complete transection made at the level of the 8th spinal segment, the cord tissue of the lesion zone degenerated; regeneration from each cut end then occurred, which lengthened for approximate 0.35 mm by 28 days after transection. The content of actin, alpha-tubulin and beta-tubulin in the cord within 1-2 mm of the transection site was elevated to 124-192% of control values 7-28 days post-transection, whereas NF68 declined to near non-detectable extent. 3. The regeneration of each cord stump included outgrowth of neuroepithelial cells and nerve fibers, reconstituting a newly regenerated cord segment. Ultrastructural examination revealed that features of the regrowth of fibers and guidance of neuroepithelial cells to the axonal growth resembled that seen in the developing cord. Thus the biochemical and morphological data support that the regeneration of the nervous system recaptulates its developmental events, providing evidence for molecular mechanism underlying central axonal regeneration.

Changes in the microtubule proteins in the developing and transected spinal cords of the bullfrog tadpole: induction of microtubule-associated protein 2c and enhanced levels of Tau and tubulin in regenerating central axons

The distribution of tubulin, microtubule-associated protein 2 and Tau in the spinal cords of bullfrog tadpoles during development and after transection was studied. alpha-Tubulin or beta-tubulin immunoreactivity was present in the axons, neuronal perikarya and dendrites, as revealed by immunocytochemistry. The axonal staining intensity of the tubulins in the tadpoles was significantly stronger than that in the adult bullfrog. Microtubule-associated protein 2 immunoreactivity was localized largely to dendrites and expanded from distal to proximal dendrites with time; a high-molecular-weight microtubule-associated protein 2 was seen on the immunoblots of cord homogenates throughout development Tau1 stained mainly the axons. Two-dimensional gel immunoblotting disclosed that the tadpole contained a greater number of isoforms of Tau than the frog. Complete transection of the spinal cords of stage IV tadpoles was followed by regeneration of the damaged cord region. The levels of tubulin and Tau immunoreactivity in the regenerating axons of the ventral fasciculi were generally increased. Strikingly, microtubule-associated protein 2 immunoreactivity appeared in the regenerating axons and the chromatolytic cell bodies of axotomized motor neurons, paralleling the induction of microtubule-associated protein 2c in the regenerating cord segment shown by immunoblotting. The chromatolytic cell bodies were also markedly labeled by Tau1, whereas the high-molecular-weight microtubule-associated protein 2 diminished on the immunoblots, in accordance with the reduced level of staining for the dendrites. It is apparent that the changes in the cytoskeletal proteins in the regenerating axons mostly recapitulated their developmental patterns. Moreover, the data indicate a close relationship between tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins in axonal growth as well as providing evidence for similar molecular mechanisms underlying successful regeneration for central and peripheral axons.

H3-thymidine labeled cerebrospinal fluid contacting cells in the regenerating caudal spinal cord of the lizard Lampropholis

Australian scincid lizards (Lampropholis) were injected with a single dose of H3-thymidine during the early stages of tail regeneration in order to study later a possible differentiation of neurons and glial cells within the regenerating spinal cord. After 5 hours post-injection only electrondense or pale ependymal cells took up H3-thymidine. Light and electron microscopic analysis of later stages, 6, 12 and 20 days post-injection, revealed that labeled pale cells were occasionally recognizable 12-20 days post-injection. Many pale unlabeled and a few labeled cells contacted the central canal of the spinal cord and appeared as cerebrospinal fluid contacting cells. The electron microscope showed the presence of stereocilia in the apical cytoplasm of these pale cells, a typical characteristic of cerebrospinal fluid contacting neurons. After 12-20 days post-injection, among ependymal cells rare pale cells containing intermediate filaments were labeled. Other pale cells represented intermediate stages of differentiation between ependymal and neural or glial cells. Differentiated medium-high electrondense ependymal tanicytes were also labeled 6, 12 and 20 days post-injection. This analysis showed that a limited regeneration of cerebrospinal fluid contacting neurons occurs locally in the caudal spinal cord of the scincid lizard Lampropholis.

The conservation of neurotrophic factors during vertebrate evolution

Neurotrophic factors are a family of extracellular ligands that affect the differentiation, survival (by inhibition of apoptosis) and maintenance of function of neuronal cells in vertebrates. The family includes nerve growth factor (NGF), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) and neurotrophin-4/5 (NT-4/5). The survival specificities of NGF and BDNF for different classes of chick neurons are maintained from the fish to the mammalian proteins, implying a conserved interaction with neuronal cell surface receptors (of the Trk family). However, the quantitative effect of a fish neurotrophin can differ significantly from that of the mammalian orthologue.

Central nervous system lesion triggers inappropriate pathway choice in adult vertebrate system

Damaged neurons within the CNS of the goldfish are able to regrow to appropriate target areas with resultant recovery of swimming behavior. However, after a whole spino-medullary level crush, many adult goldfish do not recover all behavior. Brain neurons regenerating past a crush wound at this level have a choice between the spinal cord and the first ventral root. Many CNS neurons faced with this decision do not make the same pathway choice as they made during development but rather project axons into the first ventral root, away from their normal target areas in the spinal cord. In fact, more regenerating fibers, including those of reticulospinal and vestibulospinal neurons, choose the peripheral nervous system (PNS) over the CNS, which may limit behavioral recovery. The goldfish PNS may present a more permissive environment to regenerating fibers than the CNS, as is the case in mammals. We suggest that the goldfish is a better model for mammalian regeneration than previously thought.

Contact inhibition in the failure of mammalian CNS axonal regeneration

Anamniote animals, such as fish and amphibians, are able to regenerate damaged CNS nerves following injury, but regeneration in the mammalian CNS tracts, such as the optic nerve, does not occur. However, severed adult mammalian retinal axons can regenerate into peripheral nerve segments grafted into the brain and this finding has emphasized the importance of the environment in explaining regenerative failure in the adult mammalian CNS. Following lesions, regenerating axons encounter the glial cells, oligodendrocytes and astrocytes, and their derivatives, respectively myelin and the astrocytic scar. Experiments to investigate the influence of these components on axon growth in culture have revealed cell-surface and extracellular matrix molecules that inhibit axon extension and growth cone motility. Structural and functional characterization of these ligands and their receptors is underway, and may solve the interesting neurobiological conundrum posed by the failure of mammalian CNS regeneration. Simultaneously, this might allow new possibilities for treatment of the severe clinical disabilities resulting from injury to the brain and spinal cord.