Idiotypic network interactions

Antibody catalysis based on functional mimicry

Approaches aiming at eliciting antibodies (Abs) that catalyze specific chemical transformations are numerous. Most of the developed methods are based on the chemical steps of the reaction catalyzed rather than on the structure of known enzyme active sites. The authors have developed an approach that rests on the mimicry properties of the idiotypic network of immune regulation. Recent results, together with the existence of natural catalytic Abs in autoimmune diseases, indicate the need to better understand the regulation properties of immune response, in order to improve the efficiency of tailor-made catalytic Abs.

A study of autologous anti-idiotypic antibody-forming cells in mice of different ages and genetic backgrounds

Antibody response to phosphorylcholine, an immunodominant epitope of Streptococcus pneumoniae R36a (Pn), is characterized by a public idiotype, T15, that is expressed on a large proportion of antibody molecules produced by all mouse inbred strains. The ability of the immune system to produce an autologous antibody to T15 upon immunization with Pn vaccine was investigated using a modified ELISA plaque assay for detection of single antibody-forming cells (AFC). The limit of ELISA assay for detection of specific anti-T15 AFC is approximately 300 cells/spleen. However, our studies failed to detect any autologous anti-T15 AFC in the course of the primary antibody response to Pn vaccine in young/adult (2-4 months) BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice. Aged mice (20-22 months) also failed to develop any specific auto-anti-T15 AFC upon the primary Pn immunization, despite the fact that the anti-Pn response in these animals changes both quantitatively and qualitatively. In order to generate specific anti-T15 AFC, BALB/c mice had to be immunized repeatedly with Pn vaccine (four weekly injections) or immunized directly with T15 protein in CFA. Different results were obtained with D1.LP mice that are low responders to Pn and express lower levels of T15 Id as compared to BALB/c. Young D1.LP mice produced high numbers of auto-anti-T15 AFC of both IgM and IgG isotypes following a single immunization with Pn vaccine. The kinetics of auto-anti-T15 response in D1.LP mice was similar to that of the antigen-specific response. These results demonstrate that the ability of the immune network to produce autologous antibody to a shared Id depends on the genetic makeup of the host, and that this response may be regulated by the level of Id expression.

Isolation of anti-idiotypic antibodies by immunoaffinity chromatography on Affinichrom beads

Anti-idiotypic antibodies are important regulators of the immune system but they are difficult to isolate and monitor. We have developed a technique for isolating specific auto-anti-idiotypic antibodies by high-performance immunoaffinity chromatography using immobilized autologous anti-tumor antibodies as the affinity ligand. The isolated anti-idiotypes demonstrated the ability to react with the original antitumor antibodies and inhibit their reactivity against autologous tumor cells. This technique can be used to monitor regulatory antibodies in cancer patients receiving immune modulation therapy.

Association of elevated anti-sarcolemma, anti-idiotype antibody levels with the clinical and pathologic expression of chronic Chagas myocarditis

Antibody F(ab')2 fragments derived from the sera of four patients with histology-proven chronic Chagas myocarditis [cF(ab')2]-complexed antibody F(ab')2 fragments of children with acute Trypanosoma cruzi infection [aF(ab')2] in significantly higher molar ratios than those measured with F(ab')2 antibody fragments of normal subjects [nF(ab')2] from nonendemic areas (p less than 0.05). Anti-idiotype [cF(ab')2 X aF(ab')2] immune-complex formation was significantly blunted by preabsorption of cF(ab')2 with porcine heart atria sarcolemma (PAMs) immobilized on sepharose beads (inhibition, mean, 78.1 +/- 2.4%, n = 4). cF(ab')2 X nF(ab')2] immune-complex formation was also inhibited by pretreatment of cF(ab')2 with PAMs (inhibition, mean, 48.7 +/- 7.5%, n = 4). The sera of three groups of subjects from a geographic zone endemic for T. cruzi infection in the northeast of Brazil were assayed for free and immune-complexed IgG anti-acute T. cruzi infection F(ab')2. The indexed levels of free IgG anti-idiotype antibody activity and levels of IgG anti-idiotype immune complexes (IC') were markedly elevated in hospitalized patients with severe, decompensated chronic Chagas myocarditis (n = 23), and their IC' indexes were significantly higher than those measured in asymptomatic seropositive subjects from a nearby endemic village of the northeast of Brazil (Moniz Ferreira, n = 92, p less than 0.001) and in healthy seronegative villagers (n = 84, p less than 0.001). There exists a strong correlation between elevated IgG anti-sarcolemma, anti-idiotype activity levels and the clinical and pathologic expression of chronic Chagas myocarditis.

Influence of a minor recurrent idiotype on the regulation of immune response: route dependence

Sp6, a BALB/c hybridoma, produces anti-TNP IgM antibodies (AB), which carry a minor recurrent idiotype (ID). Despite the fact that only about 20% of BALB/c anti-TNP AB carry the Sp6 ID, injection of Sp6-coated spleen cells (Sp6-SC) significantly influenced the anti-TNP B cell response. Repeated intratrail (i.t.) or intravenous (i.v.) injections of Sp6-SC resulted only in a minor increase of the anti-TNP background response. When mice consecutively were challenged with TNP-horse red blood cells (HRBC), i.t. injections of Sp6-SC resulted in a 2-3-fold increase in the number of anti-TNP plaque-forming cells (PFC), while i.v. injection of Sp6-SC displayed no effect on a primary anti-TNP response. But, after i.v. as well as i.t. application of Sp6-SC, it was not possible to obtain hapten-specific suppression by i.v. injection of TNP-haptenized lymphocytes. In vitro characterization of the underlying mechanism revealed that the helper effect, which only was observed after i.t. injection, was due to a Lyt-1+ population, not adhering to Sp6-coated plates, while counterregulation of hapten-specific suppression was found in a Lyt-2+ population, adhering to Sp6-coated plates. Hence, depending on the route of priming, injection of AB with a recurrent ID can augment the response towards the nominal antigen either directly via activation of helper cells or indirectly via activation of counterregulatory cells.

Recognition of self and regulation of specificity at the level of cell populations

It is suggested that immunologic specificity and selective responsiveness, assayed by effector and memory cells, are, in part, determined by the existing repertoire of lymphocytes and, in part, by the dynamic nature of cellular growth. Clones within horizontal networks resemble competing species in a Darwinian world. Upon stimulation, the development of a clone is greatly affected, in a dynamic way, by factors that determine the balance between self-renewal and differentiation. Antigen is a major factor. The amount of antigen and the nature of encounter with the immune system (sudden, graded or continuous), through the selection of a particular subset of clones, can be correlated with a weak or a strong expression of effector function and with the generation of effective memory or of tolerance. The encounter with self antigens obeys the same rules. Thus, the distinction between self and non-self is a quantitative one, both at the single-cell level and at the systemic level. The encounter of developing lymphocytes with self antigens, and in particular with idiotypes and MHC-antigens, restricts the repertoire and imposes major constraints both on the mode of interaction with foreign antigens and on potential self-recognition networks. The proposed "dynamic scheme", differing from "structural schemes" in a number of fundamental aspects, calls for reevaluation of present concepts of immunoregulation and for reinterpretation of data.

T-cell helper circuits

T helper cells specific for trinitrophenylated PC-binding myeloma and hybridoma antibodies are induced by priming with PC antigen, idiotype or anti-idiotypic antibody. These T helper cells are specific for a shared idiotope present on T15 and M167. Priming with the isolated heavy chains of T15 or M167, or the light chain of anti-T15 hybridoma antibody is equally effective in generating T helper cells. Evidently, the idiotope that is recognized by T cells is not dependent upon the conformation of the 7s Ig molecule. Collectively, these and other findings indicate the existence of a TH1-TH2-B cellular circuit which is based on the recognition of idiotopic determinants on T cell receptors. The implications of these findings in terms of network theory are explored.

HLA and disease

This review describes the greater portion of a large number of new studies on HLA and disease association which has appeared in the literature since 1979. The majority of these are concerned with the association of certain diseases with class II major histocompatibility complex antigens. The possible biologic significance of these associations in terms of their probable etiology appears to be the prevailing theme. Current thinking regarding certain heritable diseases is described. It seems that although much has been done to resolve the genetics of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, other diseases such a multiple sclerosis still remain a mystery. Doubtlessly, much will be gained from DNA cloning and sequencing studies proposed for the future. A great deal of new information has been obtained relative to HLA itself. New loci have been postulated in the HLA-D/DR region through the use of powerful immunochemical procedures made possibly by the advent of modern technological advances. The impact of these developments on our understanding of the function of the MHC in man and its possible relationship to disease are discussed.

The occurrence of defined idiotypes on autoantibodies to mouse thyroglobulin

Anti-idiotypic antibodies were raised in rabbits to three monoclonal mouse autoanti-thyroglobulins. Of the idiotypes recognized, one was unique to that monoclonal, while the other two showed evidence of sharing idiotopes with other monoclonal anti-thyroglobulin (TG) idiotypes, the IgM idiotype in particular being found on nearly half of the hybridomas studied. Two of the idiotypes could be detected in the sera of mice with experimental allergic thyroiditis (EAT), but they constituted only a very small percentage of the total anti-TG present. In spite of its low levels in EAT mice the D8 idiotype could be induced by injection of anti-idiotype and TG and in this case it constituted up to 20% of the anti-TG activity in individual mice, showing a strain-related association between the idiotype and autoanti-TG.

A bi-directional immune network mechanism: simultaneous induction of idiotype and anti-anti-idiotype in rabbits immunized with antibody to a common idiotypic specificity of anti-VHa2-allotype antibodies

Recently, we identified a common idiotypic specificity (IdC) present on all of the allo and auto anti-VHa2-allotype antibodies tested. In this report, we immunized allotype-matched rabbits with anti-IdC Ab. When an a1a1 homozygote was immunized with anti-IdC Ab (also from an a1a1 rabbit), two distinct Ab populations were induced which were isolated through the use of immunoadsorbent column chromatography. One of these Ab populations, adsorbed to and eluted from an insolubilized a2 IgG column, was anti-VHa2-allotype Ab (Ab 1), which reacted with a2 Ig and inhibited the reaction between the a2 allotype and anti-VHa2-allotype Ab. The other Ab population, adsorbed to and eluted from an insolubilized immunogen anti-IdC column, was anti-anti-IdC Ab (Ab 3), which was specific for the immunogen anti-IdC Ab. In another experiment, when an a1a2 heterozygous rabbit was immunized with anti-IdC Ab, only the Ab 3 was induced, which appeared to be identical to the Ab 3 induced in the a1a1 rabbit. However, when the expression of the a2 allotype in an a1a2 heterozygous rabbit was suppressed and then this rabbit was immunized with anti-IdC Ab, both Ab 1 and Ab 3 were induced. These data indicate the occurrence of a bi-directional immune response within our immune network system. According to Jerne's network theory, Ab 3 appeared to be induced through a stimulation by the idiotope of the immunogen Ab 2, whereas Ab 1 appeared to be induced through a reverse stimulation by the paratope of the immunogen Ab 2. Furthermore, the production of Ab 1 in these rabbits exhibiting the bi-directional immune response was at least 3-5 times greater than that of Ab 3 production indicating that the response through the reverse stimulation appeared to be dominant. The importance of this bi-directional immune response is discussed in this paper.