The selection of the α,β heterodimeric T-cell receptor for antigen

The role of ThPOK in control of CD4/CD8 lineage commitment

During alphabeta T cell development, cells diverge into alternate CD4 helper and CD8(+) cytotoxic T cell lineages. The precise correlation between a T cell's CD8 and CD4 choice and its TCR specificity to class I or class II MHC was noted more than 20 years ago, and establishing the underlying mechanism has remained a focus of intense study since then. This review deals with three formerly discrete topics that are gradually becoming interconnected: the role of TCR signaling in lineage commitment, the regulation of expression of the CD4 and CD8 genes, and transcriptional regulation of lineage commitment. It is widely accepted that TCR signaling exerts a decisive influence on lineage choice, although the underlying mechanism remains intensely debated. Current evidence suggests that both duration and intensity of TCR signaling may control lineage choice, as proposed by the kinetic signaling and quantitative instructive models, respectively. Alternate expression of the CD4 and CD8 genes is the most visible manifestation of lineage choice, and much progress has been made in defining the responsible cis elements and transcription factors. Finally, important clues to the molecular basis of lineage commitment have been provided by the recent identification of the transcription factor ThPOK as a key regulator of lineage choice. ThPOK is selectively expressed in class II-restricted cells at the CD4(+)8(lo) stage and is necessary and sufficient for development to the CD4 lineage. Given the central role of ThPOK in lineage commitment, understanding its upstream regulation and downstream gene targets is expected to reveal further important aspects of the molecular machinery underlying lineage commitment.

Rescue of cytotoxic function in the CD8alpha knockout mouse by removal of MHC class II

CD8 plays an important role in the activity of cytolytic T cells (CTL). However, whether or not CD8 is required for the development of CTL has not been clearly determined. Cytotoxic activity in the CD8alpha knockout mouse is difficult to induce, and has only been demonstrated against allogenic MHC targets. The lack of cytotoxicity may result from impaired lineage commitment of CTL in the absence of CD8, or diminished competitiveness during selection against (unimpaired) development of CD4(+) T cells on MHC class II (MHC II). To differentiate between these possibilities, we have generated a double-knockout mouse (MHC II(-/-)CD8alpha(-/-)). In MHC II(-/-)CD8alpha(-/-) mice, developing MHC class I (MHC I)-reactive thymocytes cannot rely upon CD8 for selection, but they also cannot be overwhelmed by efficient selection of MHC II-reactive thymocytes. In this mouse, a large, heterogeneous population of peripheral coreceptor double-negative (DN) and CD4(+) T cells develops. Peripheral DN T cells are fully functional CTL. They display cytolytic activity against allogeneic MHC, and against syngeneic MHC following lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) infection. Cells from LCMV-infected mice bind more MHC I tetramer at lower concentrations than their wild-type CTL counterparts. These results demonstrate unequivocally that CD8 is not required for commitment of thymocytes to the CTL lineage.

Deletion of the CD4 silencer element supports a stochastic mechanism of thymocyte lineage commitment

The mechanism of T cell lineage commitment remains controversial; to examine it we deleted the CD4-silencer element in the germ line of a mouse using a combination of gene targeting and Cre/LoxP-mediated recombination. We found that these mice were unable to extinguish CD4 expression either in immature thymocytes or mature CD8+ cytotoxic T cells (CTLs), which resulted in the development of major histocompatibility complex class II-restricted double-positive CTLs in the periphery. This finding strongly supports a stochastic over an instructive mechanism of coreceptor down-regulation.

T-cell lineage fate: instructed by receptor signals?

Mechanisms of lineage choice represent a challenging problem in developmental biology. Recent studies have shown that different T-cell receptor signals can affect CD4 or CD8 lineage choice. Thus, all the ingredients for instructive mechanisms of lineage fate are in place but other mechanisms cannot be completely ruled out.

Function and regulation of memory CD4 T cells

The development of peripheral naive CD4 T cells is dependent on the success of positive selection of immature T cells in the thymus. Only thymocytes that express a T cell receptor (TCR) capable of recognizing self-MHC with low affinity are selected for survival and differentiation into mature naive T cells. Although the TCR of naive T cells has to maintain self-tolerance, it also propagates naive CD4 T cell proliferation on recognition of appropriate foreign peptide associated with MHC class II on antigen-presenting cells (APCs). Naive CD4 T cells that successfully engage foreign peptide undergo further differentiation that leads to the maturation of a select few into the memory T cell pool. Although the requirements that lead to memory T cell development are currently not known, functional changes have been described that are thought to be associated with the greater efficiency with which memory T cells respond to antigen. This article will discuss differences associated with signaling through the TCR of naive and memory CD4 T cells and describe unique control mechanisms imposed on memory CD4 T cells that are likely to have ari sen to counterbalance the altered TCR signaling.

Visualization of CD4/CD8 T cell commitment

A system to innocuously visualize T cell lineage commitment is described. Using a "knock-in" approach, we have generated mice expressing a beta-galactosidase reporter in place of CD4; expression of beta-galactosidase in these animals appears to be an accurate and early indicator of CD4 gene transcription. We have exploited this knock-in line to trace CD4/CD8 lineage commitment in the thymus, avoiding important pitfalls of past experimental approaches. Our results argue in favor of a selective model of thymocyte commitment, demonstrating a fundamentally symmetrical process: engagement of either class of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule by a differentiating CD4(+)CD8(+) cell can give rise to T cell antigen receptor (TCR)hi thymocytes of either lineage. Key findings include (a) direct demonstration of a substantial number of CD4-committed, receptor/coreceptor-mismatched cells in MHC class II- deficient mice, a critical prediction of the selective model; (b) highly efficient rescue of such "mismatched" intermediates by forced expression of CD8 in a TCR transgenic line, and an explanation of why previous experiments of this nature were less successful-a major past criticism of the selective model; (c) direct demonstration of an analogous, though smaller, population of CD8-committed mismatched intermediates in class I-deficient animals. Finally, we found no evidence of a CD4 default pathway.

CD4/CD8 lineage commitment: matching fate with competence

The outcome of positive selection of T lymphocytes is that there is a close match between the lineage adopted by a particular cell (CD4+ or CD8+) and the specificity of the T-cell receptor for the class of Major Histocompatibility Complex molecule recognized. How this match is obtained has been a matter of debate. We review the evidence, from recent and older experiments, that indicates that the process follows a selective logic, rather than an instructive one.

Two Signaling Pathways Can Increase Fas Expression in Human Thymocytes

Fas, a cell surface receptor, can induce apoptosis after cross-linking with its ligand. Fewer than 3% of human thymocytes strongly express Fas. We report that Fas antigen expression can be upregulated by two signaling pathways in vitro, one mediated by anti-CD3 and the other by interleukin-7 + interferon-γ. The two signaling pathways differed in several respects. (1) Fas expression increased in all thymic subsets after cytokine activation, but only in the CD4 lineage after anti-CD3 activation. (2) Fas upregulation was inhibited by cyclosporin A (a calcineurin inhibitor) in anti-CD3–activated but not in cytokine-activated thymocytes. (3) Cycloheximide (a metabolic inhibitor) inhibited Fas upregulation in cytokine-activated thymocytes but not in anti-CD3–activated thymocytes. (4) Cytokine-activated thymocytes were more susceptible than anti-CD3–activated thymocytes to Fas-induced apoptosis, a difference mainly accounted for by CD4+ cells. The nature of the stimulus might thus influence the susceptibility of human thymocytes to Fas-induced apoptosis.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Two Signaling Pathways Can Increase Fas Expression in Human Thymocytes

Fas, a cell surface receptor, can induce apoptosis after cross-linking with its ligand. Fewer than 3% of human thymocytes strongly express Fas. We report that Fas antigen expression can be upregulated by two signaling pathways in vitro, one mediated by anti-CD3 and the other by interleukin-7 + interferon-γ. The two signaling pathways differed in several respects. (1) Fas expression increased in all thymic subsets after cytokine activation, but only in the CD4 lineage after anti-CD3 activation. (2) Fas upregulation was inhibited by cyclosporin A (a calcineurin inhibitor) in anti-CD3–activated but not in cytokine-activated thymocytes. (3) Cycloheximide (a metabolic inhibitor) inhibited Fas upregulation in cytokine-activated thymocytes but not in anti-CD3–activated thymocytes. (4) Cytokine-activated thymocytes were more susceptible than anti-CD3–activated thymocytes to Fas-induced apoptosis, a difference mainly accounted for by CD4+ cells. The nature of the stimulus might thus influence the susceptibility of human thymocytes to Fas-induced apoptosis.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Opposite CD4/CD8 Lineage Decisions of CD4+8+ Mouse and Rat Thymocytes to Equivalent Triggering Signals: Correlation with Thymic Expression of a Truncated CD8α Chain in Mice But Not Rats

Unselected CD4+8+ rat thymocytes, generated in vitro from their direct precursors, are readily converted to functional TCRhigh T cells by stimulation with immobilized TCR-specific mAb plus IL-2. Lineage decision invariably occurs toward CD4−8+, regardless of the timing of TCR stimulation after entry into the CD4+8+ compartment or the concentration of TCR-specific mAb used for stimulation. CD4-specific mAb synergizes with suboptimal TCR-specific mAb in inducing T cell maturation, but lineage decision remains exclusively CD4−8+. These results contrast with those obtained in mice, in which Abs to the TCR complex were shown to promote CD4+8− T cell maturation from CD4+8+ thymocytes. Surprisingly, when rat and mouse CD4+8+ thymocytes were stimulated with PMA/ionomycin under identical conditions, the opposite lineage commitment was observed, i.e., mouse thymocytes responded with the generation of CD4+8− and rat thymocytes with the generation of CD4−8+ cells. It thus seems that CD4+8+ thymocytes of the two species respond with opposite lineage decisions to strong activating signals such as given by TCR-specific mAb or PMA/ionomycin. A possible key to this difference lies in the availability of p56lck for coreceptor-supported signaling. We show that in contrast to mouse CD4+8+ thymocytes, which express both a complete and a truncated CD8α-chain (CD8α′) unable to bind p56lck, rat thymocytes only express full-length CD8α molecules. Mice, but not rats, therefore may use CD8α′ as a “dominant negative” coreceptor chain to attenuate the CD8 signal, thereby facilitating MHC class II recognition through the higher amount of p56lck delivered, and rats may use a different mechanism for MHC class distinction during positive selection.

Signals through CD8 or CD4 can induce commitment to the CD4 lineage in the thymus

Differentiation of thymocytes into mature single-positive T cells is an ordered process involving sequential interactions between T cell receptor (TCR), co-receptors (CD4 or CD8) and their appropriate major histocompatibility complex-encoded ligands. Precisely how these receptor/co-receptor engagements determine lineage commitment is still controversial, but recently it has been suggested that quantitative differences in the signal transmitted by co-ligation of CD4 versus CD8 with TCR might provide the discriminating signal. We examine this hypothesis, using bispecific F(ab')2 antibodies to mimic TCR/ co-receptor engagement during thymocyte differentiation. These bispecific antibodies lack Fc and can engage surface molecules without extensive cross-linking or targeting to Fc receptor-bearing cells. We show that TCR/CD3 co-ligation with CD4 induces efficient differentiation of mature CD4 lineage cells, irrespective of their TCR specificity. Interestingly, TCR/CD3 co-ligation with CD8 also induces maturation of CD4 T cells, although less efficiently, but not of CD8 T cells. Thus, although the signals delivered by co-ligation of TCR and CD8 appear weaker than from co-ligation of TCR and CD4, the outcome from either engagement is the same. These data suggest that differences in signal intensity alone do not determine lineage commitment in the thymus, but that distinct signals are required for CD4 and CD8 single-positive cell differentiation.

Thymocyte Fas Expression Is Dysregulated in Myasthenia Gravis Patients With Anti-Acetylcholine Receptor Antibody

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is a human autoimmune disease mediated by anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies. The thymus is probably the site where the autoimmune response is triggered and maintained. Recent reports have linked various autoimmune disease with defective Fas expression. We thus analyzed Fas expression in thymocytes and peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from MG patients. The proportion of a thymocyte subpopulation with strong Fas expression (Fashi) was markedly enhanced in MG patients with anti-AChR antibodies (P < .0003, compared with controls). In this group of patients, the proportion of CD4+Fashi and CD4+CD8+Fashi thymocytes were significantly increased (P < .002 for both subsets). Fashi thymocytes were enriched in activated cells and showed intermediate CD3 expression. They were preferentially Vβ5.1-expressing cells, previously shown to be enriched in potentially autoreactive cells. The proliferative response of thymocytes from MG patients to peptides from the AChR was abolished after depletion of Fashi cells. Fashi thymocytes were sensitive to an agonistic anti-Fas antibody. In peripheral blood, Fashi lymphocytes proportion was not significantly modified in MG patients whatever their anti-AChR antibody titer, compared with controls. Altogether, these results indicate that Fashi thymocytes, which accumulate in MG patients with anti-AChR antibodies, could be involved in the autoimmune response that targets the AChR.

Unexpectedly complex regulation of CD4/CD8 coreceptor expression supports a revised model for CD4+CD8+ thymocyte differentiation

CD4+ CD8+ TCRlo thymocytes are the precursors of CD4+ and CD8+ mature T cells, whose receptors show specific recognition of peptide-MHC class II and MHC class I complexes, respectively. How T cells emerge from the intrathymic differentiation process with selective expression of either CD8 molecule or CD4 molecule coordinated with the MHC class specificity of the TCR has been the subject of intense examination. Many previous studies of this question have been based on the assumption that extinction of CD4 or CD8 expression by the precursor thymocytes was a steady, uninterrupted process. Here we show that this is an incorrect assumption, with CD4 and CD8 expression undergoing an unexpectedly complex series of expression changes involving down-modulation, kinetically asymmetric up-regulation, and then selective loss. Based on these data, we propose a model for the differentiation pathway of alphabeta TCR thymocytes that explains previous, apparently contradictory findings and establishes useful parameters for future studies at the cellular and gene level.

Differential induction of helper and killer T cells from isolated CD4+CD8+ thymocytes in suspension culture

Thymocytes of T cell receptor transgenic mice with nonselecting and RAG-2 -/- backgrounds were developmentally arrested at the CD4+CD8+ stage before positive selection. These thymocytes underwent lineage commitment upon transient stimulation with a combination of ionomycin, a calcium ionophore, and phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), a protein kinase C activator, in suspension culture. The effective drug doses were limited within narrow ranges and much lower than those which induce proliferation of mature T cells. The doses corresponded to those which inhibit glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis in these thymocytes. CD4 lineage commitment required longer duration, higher intensity of the stimulation, or both, than CD8 lineage commitment. Functional helper T cells (Th1 and Th2) were induced from the CD4 lineage-committed cells upon secondary stimulation with a combination of ionomycin and PMA followed by lymphokine treatment. Cytotoxic T cells were induced from the CD8 lineage-committed cells upon incubation with concanavalin A and irradiated splenic dendritic cells, but not with the combination of ionomycin and PMA. These results indicate that positive selection is mimicked by the pharmacological stimulation in the absence of other cell types, but that final maturation of CD8 T cells may require a different signal.

MHC class II-specific T cells can develop in the CD8 lineage when CD4 is absent

The generation of mature CD4 T cells from CD4+CD8+ precursor thymocytes usually requires corecognition of class II MHC by a TCR and CD4, while the production of mature CD8 T cells requires corecognition of class I MHC by a TCR and CD8. To assess the role of the CD4 coreceptor in development and lineage commitment, we generated CD4-deficient mice expressing a transgenic class II-specific TCR. Surprisingly, in the absence of CD4 a large number of T cells mature, but these cells appear in the CD8 lineage. Thus, when CD4 is present, the majority of immature T cells with this class II-specific TCR choose the CD4 lineage but develop in the CD8 pathway when CD4 is absent. The results indicate that even for TCRs that are not dependent on coreceptor for MHC recognition, the coreceptor can influence the lineage choice. These findings are considered in terms of a quantitative signaling model for CD4/CD8 lineage commitment.

Expression of cell interaction molecules by immature rat thymocytes during passage through the CD4+8+ compartment: developmental regulation and induction by T cell receptor engagement of CD2, CD5, CD28, CD11a, CD44 and CD53

Rat thymocytes of the T cell receptorlow (TcRlow) CD4+8+ subset which is the target of repertoire selection are heterogeneous with respect to expression of the cell interaction (CI) molecules CD2, CD5, CD11a/CD18 (LFA-1), CD28 and CD44. We show that this heterogeneity is due to the developmental regulation of these CI molecules during passage through the CD4+8+ compartment, and to up-regulation by TcR engagement. Thus, cohorts of CD4+8+ cells differentiating synchronously in vitro from their direct precursors, the immature CD4-8+ cells, were homogeneous with regard to CI molecule expression. Upon entry into the CD4+8+ compartment, they expressed relatively high levels of CD2 and CD44, and moderate levels of CD5, CD28 and CD11a. CD2, CD28 and CD44 were slightly down-regulated during the following 2 days, whereas CD5 slightly increased and CD11a remained constant. TcR stimulation using immobilized monoclonal antibodies resulted in rapid and dramatic up-regulation of CD2, CD5 and CD28 and, to a lesser extent, of CD11a and CD44. Finally CD53, a triggering structure absent from unstimulated CD4+8+ thymocytes was also rapidly induced by TcR stimulation. Inclusion of interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, or IL-7 in this in vitro differentiation system did not affect the levels of CI molecules studied. Since the high levels of CI molecules induced by TcR-stimulation correspond to those found in vivo on TcRintermediate thymocytes known to be undergoing repertoire selection, these results suggest that upregulation of CI molecules by TcR engagement provides a mechanism by which thymocytes that have entered the selection process gain preferential access to further interactions with stromal and lymphoid cells in the thymus.

A human CD4 transgene rescues CD4-CD8+ cells in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice

The specificity of the alpha beta T cell receptor for class I or class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules determines whether a mature T cell will be of the CD4-CD8+ or CD4+CD8- phenotype, respectively. We show here that a human CD4 transgene can rescue a significant fraction of CD4-CD8+ T cells in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice. Cells with this phenotype could be induced to become potent killers of targets expressing allogeneic MHC antigens, indicating that lineage commitment can precede the rescue of developing cells by the T cell receptor for antigen and the CD4 coreceptor.

Functional commitment to helper T cell lineage precedes positive selection and is independent of T cell receptor MHC specificity

Thymocyte differentiation proceeds from double positive CD4+CD8+ to single positive T cells. It has been proposed that this process occurs by an instructive or a stochastic mechanism. In this report, we show that in recombination-deficient mice (RAG-1-I-) constitutive expression of a CD8 transgene allows maturation of CD4+(CD8tg+) cells, which express mature levels of a transgenic class I-restricted T cell receptor, F5. Rescued F5+CD4+(CD8tg+) cells have equivalent levels of T cell receptor expression as CD8end+ cells, respond to cognate antigen and, upon stimulation, they exhibit a phenotype characteristic of CD4+ helper T cells. These data are consistent with a model of differentiation that predicts that thymocytes become functionally committed to a helper or cytotoxic lineage before the final step of positive selection and independently of MHC specificity of their T cell receptor.

Development of mature CD8+ thymocytes: selection rather than instruction?

The role of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in T cell differentiation was investigated by comparison of thymocyte subpopulations in wild-type mice and beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2M) mutant mice deficient in MHC class I expression and mature CD8+ cells. On the basis of surface markers, glucocorticoid resistance, in vitro differentiation capacity, and absence in beta 2 M-l- mice, CD4intermediateCD8hi cells with high expression of alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR alpha beta) were identified as having been positively selected by MHC class I for development into mature CD8+ T cells. Activated CD4intCD8hi cells bearing intermediate rather than high amounts of TCR were present in both wild-type and beta 2M-l- animals. These data suggest that recognition of MHC class I molecules is required for full maturation to CD8+ T cells, but not for receptor-initiated commitment to the CD8+ lineage, consistent with a stochastic (selection) model of thymocyte development.

Another view of the selective model of thymocyte selection

Thymocyte commitment to the CD4 helper versus CD8 cytotoxic lineage has not been satisfactorily established. Two models have been elaborated: one based on instruction, the other on selection. Most previous results support the instructive model, but our comparison of thymocyte differentiation in MHC class II-, class I- and double-deficient mice provides data challenging it. There exists a significant population of CD4 single positive cells in class II-deficient animals that is intermediate in maturity between CD4+CD8+ and end-stage CD4+CD8- thymocytes and is selected on class I molecules; an equivalent CD8+CD4- population occurs in class I-deficient animals. We propose a selective model entailing two TCR-MHC molecule engagements: the first provokes random down-modulation of either CD4 or CD8 and a degree of differentiation; the second, requiring participation of the appropriate coreceptor, permits end-stage differentiation.

Thymic selection: a matter of life and death

Mice transgenic for the T-cell receptor (TCR) were instrumental to the understanding that developing alpha beta T cells undergo programmed cell death unless the TCR beta gene properly rearranges and produces receptors of appropriate specificity. The delineation of developmental pathways for 'conventional' alpha beta T cells has resulted in the recognition of a different lineage of alpha beta T cells that develop in the thymus, the function of which remains to be elucidated.

Phenotypic changes accompanying positive selection of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes

We know little about the way mature CD4 (helper) and CD8 (killer) T cells develop from thymic CD4+CD8+ precursors. Here we show that small but not large CD4+CD8+ cells with high levels of the alpha beta T cell receptor (TcRhigh) result from positive selection. Neither CD4+CD8+ cells with low TcR levels nor large CD4+CD8+ thymocytes with high TcR levels differentiate in vitro. However, small CD4+CD8+ cells with high TcR levels develop in vitro into mature cells by gradually decreasing the surface levels of one or the other co-receptor and acquiring the potential to respond with proliferation to ligation of the TcR. Small CD4+CD8+ cells with high levels of a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted transgenic TcR develop in vitro exclusively into CD4-CD8+ cells while small CD4+CD8+ TcRhigh cells with heterogeneous TcR from various mice yield both CD4 and CD8 T cells. While these experiments are consistent with an instructive model of CD4/CD8 lineage commitment they do not rule out other mechanisms which require multiple TcR-MHC ligand interactions in the generation of mature alpha beta T cells.

Detection of calbindin-D immunoreactivity in human follicular dendritic cells

The calcium-binding protein calbindin-D (28 kD) has been analysed immunohistochemically in different human lymphoid tissues. Combined immunohistochemical staining showed that calbindin-D (28 kD) is expressed by only a proportion of dendritic cells within the light zone of germinal centres, where antigens in the form of immune complexes are trapped and presented to B lymphocytes. All other cell types including macrophages, interdigitating cells, and various lymphocyte populations were negative. The expression of calbindin-D in this functionally relevant subset of follicular dendritic cells could have a role in the regulation of proliferation and selection of memory B-cells by modulating the concentration of calcium ions. Calbindin-D may be a useful marker for analysing in situ the phases of follicular development in different physiological and pathological conditions.

Taking the thymus to pieces

Complex in vitro and in vivo techniques are being combined to unlock the remaining secrets of the thymus. In this report from a recent thymus workshop*, Bruno Kyewski and Thomas Hünig describe the genetic manipulations aimed at clarifying the mechanisms of T-cell selection and lineage commitment, and the use of organ culture and immunohistology to identify the thymic microenvironments in which these events take place.

Kinetics and efficacy of positive selection in the thymus of normal and T cell receptor transgenic mice

DNA-labeling studies in alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mice show that the lifespan of immature CD4+8+ thymocytes is 3.5 days irrespective of whether they are selected for maturation or not. While nonselected cells die, the binding of the TCR to thymic major histocompatibility complex molecules rescues CD4+8+ cells from programmed cell death and induces first upregulation of the TCR level and then differentiation into CD4+8- or CD4-8+ cells in the absence of any cell division. When most CD4+8+ thymocytes express a selectable transgenic TCR the formation of mature cells with high TCR levels is 10-20 times as efficient as observed in normal mice, yet still only 20% of the CD4+8+ cells become mature. This is due to the limited availability of selecting 'niches': most CD4+8+ thymocytes with a selectable transgenic TCR will undergo maturation when they represent only 5% or less of all CD4+8+ cells.

Towards an integrated view of thymopoiesis

One prediction from the complex series of steps in intrathymic T-cell differentiation is that to regulate it the stroma controlling the process must be equally complex: the attraction of precursors, commitment to the T-cell lineage, induction of T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangement, accessory molecule expression, repertoire expansion, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule-based selection (positive and negative), acquisition of functional maturity and migratory capacity must all be controlled. In this review, Richard Boyd and Patrice Hugo combine knowledge of T-cell differentiation with thymic stromal cell heterogeneity to offer an integrated view of thymopoiesis within the thymic microenvironment.

Thymic selection in CD8 transgenic mice supports an instructive model for commitment to a CD4 or CD8 lineage

Immature thymocytes, which coexpress CD4 and CD8, give rise to mature CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ T cells. Only those T cells that recognize self-MHC are selected to mature, a process known as positive selection. The specificity of the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) for class I or class II MHC influences the commitment to a CD4 or CD8 lineage. This may occur by a directed mechanism or by stochastic commitment followed by a selection step that allows only CD8+, class I-specific and CD4+, class II-specific cells to survive. We have generated a mouse line expressing a CD8 transgene under the control of the T cell-specific CD2 regulatory sequences. Although constitutive CD8 expression does not affect thymic selection of CD4+ cells, selection of a class I-specific TCR in the CD8 subset is substantially improved. This outcome is consistent with a model for positive selection in which selection occurs at a developmental stage in which both CD4 and CD8 are expressed, and positive selection by class I MHC generates an instructive signal that directs differentiation to a CD8 lineage.

Self recognition by the immune system

In each organism, the immune system must acquire the ability to distinguish self from nonself. Experiments in T cell receptor transgenic mice indicate that this process involves the selection of lymphocytes in the thymus.

Self-nonself discrimination by T cells

The alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR) recognizes antigens that are presented by major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded cell surface molecules by binding to both the antigen and the MHC molecules. Discrimination of self from nonself antigens and MHC molecules is achieved by negative and positive selection of T cells in the thymus: potentially harmful T cells with receptors that bind to self antigens plus self MHC molecules are deleted before they can mount immune responses. In contrast, the maturation of useful T cells with receptors that bind foreign antigens plus self MHC molecules requires the binding of their receptor to MHC molecules on thymic epithelium in the absence of foreign antigen. The binding of the TCR to either class I or class II MHC molecules directs differentiation of the selected cells into either CD4-8+ (killer) or CD4+8- (helper) T cells, respectively.

Origin and selection of peripheral CD4-CD8- T cells bearing alpha/beta T cell antigen receptors in autoimmune gld mice

We have analyzed the origin and development of unusual CD4-CD8- alpha/beta T cell receptor-positive peripheral T cells produced in large numbers by mice homozygous for the gld mutation (C3H-gld/gld). These mice may be an important model for investigating processes controlling T cell development. Bone marrow transfers demonstrated that the gld defect was intrinsic to bone marrow-derived cells. Clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive cells was observed in peripheral gld CD4-CD8-, CD4+CD8-, and CD4-CD8+ T cells, as well as mature thymocytes. This suggests that gld CD4-CD8- T cells have passed through the thymus in ontogeny and that gld autoimmunity does not result from a general defect in elimination of self-reactive thymocytes. These observations, combined with demethylation of the CD8 gene in the CD4-CD8- population, support prior expression of CD4 and/or CD8 in gld CD4-CD8- T cell ontogeny, perhaps at a CD4+CD8+ stage. Steroid sensitivity of gld thymocytes and CD4-CD8- T cells was normal. Therefore, we found no gross abnormalities in two major mechanisms of inducible cell death in the gld thymus, the clonal deletion process associated with tolerance and the steroid-inducible endogenous endonuclease thought to be involved in apoptosis of unselected thymocytes. The data suggest that if gld CD4-CD8- T cells arise via escape from normal elimination in the thymus, they must do so by a novel defect in thymic selection (perhaps related to aberrant positive signals) and/or are expanded by an extrathymic process which allows clonal deletion to occur.

Intrathymic T cell repertoire after prenatal trinitrobenzene-sulfonic acid-treatment

It is still a matter of debate, whether tolerance toward self-non-MHC antigens is due to intrathymic deletion or to regulatory processes in the periphery. To further pursue this question, responsiveness toward TNP and an anti-TNP monoclonal antibody (Sp6) carrying a recurrent idiotype was evaluated in prenatally trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS)-treated mice. In prenatally untreated as well as in TNBS-treated mice, thymocytes proliferating in the absence of nominal antigen were double negative (L3T4-/Lyt2-), but antigen-specific thymocytes were single positive (L3T4+/Lyt2- or L3T4-/Lyt2+). TNBS-treated mice differed from controls inasmuch as in their first week of life T cells proliferating in response to TNP were found in the thymus and detected at increased frequencies in the spleen. The frequency of TNP-specific thymocytes and spleen cells declined rapidly, finally reaching in the spleen a level of 20-30% of controls. Furthermore, after antigenic stimulation, the frequency of thymocytes and spleen cells proliferating in response to TNP was found to be increased in control mice, but TNP-specific T cell were no more recovered in the thymus or the spleen of tolerized mice. The same accounted for thymic and splenic T cells proliferating in response to Sp6. They were expanded in control mice after antigenic stimulation, but were undetectable in TNBS-treated mice. Thus, T cells with specificity for an internal (Sp6) and an external (TNP) antigen, provided the latter was present during ontogeny, were detected in the thymus of control and, transiently, in the thymus of tolerized mice. But, the fate of antigen-specific thymocytes was different in prenatally untreated and TNBS-treated mice. The data are interpreted in the sense that tolerance toward non-MHC antigens may be acquired subsequently to tolerance toward self-MHC antigens and possibly after imprinting of antigen specificity.

Positive selection of the T cell repertoire: where and when does it occur?

The T cell repertoire is shaped by both positive and negative influences. T lymphocytes that express the V beta 6 variable region are positively selected in the thymus by cells expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II E molecules. To identify these cells, we have quantitated V beta 6+ T lymphocytes in a set of transgenic mice showing variant patterns of E expression in the thymus. We demonstrate that class II molecules must be expressed on epithelial cells of the cortex for positive selection to occur. Using a direct assay of unmanipulated thymocytes, we show that positive selection is manifest only as a rather late event in thymocyte differentiation, after the maturation of cortical double-positives into single-positives.